r/Spartacus_TV • • Sep 17 '26 Bravo

HoA Discussion I feel like House of Ashur didn't work all that well as a show for me, and I wouldn't really be interested in seeing more of it anyway... (sorry)

9 Upvotes

Just finished watching this new season with my girlfriend. I've seen the original Spartacus series maybe 4 times I think? This was my first time seeing House of Ashur.

It was very nice at times to revisit this universe. But I had too many major problems with the show, and we were kind of glad to just be through all of the episodes so we can move on.

  • First and foremost... Ashur is a piece of shit. Always has been, always will be. I get that having morally gray characters, or very dynamic characters who change drastically can be very engaging and makes the characters all the more interesting. But the whole time I'm watching this show, after having seen the original series, and Ashur is exchanging loving stares with Viridia and I'm yelling at the TV, "HE IS AN EVIL FUCKING RAPIST THOUGH". Like we're supposed to feel heart warming feelings for this guy?

  • The overall plot was lacking. The original series is based on the rebellion and everything is building up to that. It's an incredible story. This one felt aimless though, and if anything important was building up, I'm not sure what it was. It was cool when Ashur killed Caesar at the end, but I don't know what the overall point is.

  • The female gladiators thing was kind of weak. Even my girlfriend who takes jiu jitsu was annoyed and yelling at the TV about how not believable it is that women could be physically overpowering men like that. We even had a little critique with the replacement Spartacus in the original show because he wasn't physically intimidating enough to be the top dog, so this was just that, but much more.

  • Caesar and Cornelia kind of annoyed me in every scene that they had. The actors did a good job being hateable, but Caesar did not look appropriate for the time period with that hair and fine grooming, and Cornelia also has too much work done to fit into the universe. They stuck out like a sore thumb to me on screen.

I don't regret watching it, but I can't say either I'm that upset that it was cancelled. The show seems like it was just dreamt up by an intern who was smoking some weed and though, "you know The Fall of the House of Usher? Duuuude, what if we did House of Ashur? Duuude."

Don't get me wrong, Nick Tarabay is an outstanding actor and he did a great job with everything he was given. There were also a lot of great performances all around, especially the guy who played Korris... and Satyrus was an awesome character too.

Anyway, I'm sure many will agree and many will be outraged that I didn't love it. I'm curious to see if you all agree with my review.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Jul 07 '26

HoA Discussion Idk about you guys but I liked House of Asher more than S3 and 4 of Spartacus

0 Upvotes

It’s such an absolute bummer that the show wasn’t renewed. I’m a huge fan of Nick Tarabay, from Spartacus, The Expanse, he was also in the video game House of Ash and was fantastic in that. The guy deserves to headline his own show. And that’s not even counting the rest of the cast! There was so much potential for this show, between ABYSMAL marketing, and OG fans not giving it a fair shake because “woke” is unfortunate.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Mar 25 '24

DISCUSSION What do y'all think of Spartacus: House of Ashur so far?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Spartacus_TV • • Feb 20 '26

HoA Discussion HoA feels like a shell of the original series. Spoiler

18 Upvotes

I am curious as to what the general viewpoint is from people on the new House of Ashur season. Just finished, and while it was nice to be back in the world (and I love the alternate future timeline now in play), the season feels hollow. We barely got to know any gladiators, and the ones we did, I don't care about. Doctore is the only one I enjoyed, I don't really even know the names of any other except Achillia, and she is a boring character.


r/Spartacus_TV • • May 09 '26

HoA Discussion Anyone else completely disappointed with House of Ashur?

0 Upvotes

I came into this expecting something great but I was very disappointed with this show. It feels like a parody compared to the original. It’s not even because of Achilia like a lot of people are complaining about. I don’t even care about that. It’s just inferior in quality in every aspect, the fighting, the acting, cinematography, writing. I expected more from the same show runner as the OG which is a masterpiece. Did they get a smaller budget or something? The only way to save this show is bring back the OG Agron, Nassir, and Leata actors and I’m not even sure that will do it.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Feb 24 '26

HoA Discussion House of Ashur, Solid 6/10 Spoiler

7 Upvotes

The thing I liked most about House of Ashur was the way they speak and the prose. It really did feel like poetry. I liked all the performances and watching the dialogues was really enjoyable in the moment. Even if they are not speaking about something interesting, the way they spoke was enjoyable.

Especially Claudia Black because she has a very pleasant sounding voice.

So word usage is basically my favorite part about this show, yet the most important part of any show in my opinion, which is the story, I found was below average.

In the original show, I was invested in Spartacus because there was an emotional connection between him and the viewer. There was a clear goal he was trying to reach. And the success of Batiatus and his schemes were tied to Spartacus being successful too. And they were interesting in themselves.

In House of Ashur, I didn't really feel invested in anyone. Achillia was obsessed with freedom and not being a slave, but once she was told that freedom can be won in the arena, she just forgot about her motivation of being free and just became an obedient slave.

There was also no real investment in the fights because they didn't hold any emotional weight behind them and didn't have any narrative payoffs.

All the gladiators are just invested in the "GLORY OF THIS FUCKING HOUSE" with no apparent reason.

This is a nitpick, but the show says that Ashur just killed the most skilled gladiator they had by a big margin out of spite at the start of the show. This fight was literally unbelievable, much more so than Ashur dispatching several armed guards in the second season. The choreography was unbelievable and narratively this was unbelievable too.

However, most of my disappointment from the narrative stems from Ashur himself. He was smart and cunning in the original show, yet here he seems to be outsmarted and surprised at every turn. This is out of character for him.

The biggest "scheme" he hatched was telling Claudia Black to send his rival's man to a trap. This isn't a multi-level scheme where he manipulated everyone to do what he wanted. It's just a straightforward ask, because Claudia Black wanted to avenge her friend.

In the original show Ashur brilliantly manipulated Batiatus to kill Barca, this was tense and impactful because Ashur carefully built a house of cards from his schemes and it was essential that all the lies will be maintained and none of the cards would fall for it to work.

In House Of Ashur, he just asked "Can you send them here" and she did. And that's it.

Not to mention all the times where Ashur naively believed what other characters told him. I felt like I was in The Invention Of Lying a movie about a world where people are incapable of telling a lie, and therefore everyone trusts, at face value, in what other people say.

When Caesar told Ashur "And if you just do that for us, we'll build your arena and put you in charge and everything will be dandy" I was like.... Doesn't it sound they give you too much? How do you actually know that Caesar is telling the truth and how do you know he intends to honor the deal?

Ashur arguably is the smartest character in the original Spartacus series, and there is no way, he would have taken this at face value. Especially knowing how Caesar treated him.

Oh, yes, Ashur's biggest scheme was probably what led to Pompeii killing Claudia Black's husband. But that too was largely contingent on luck and didn't really have a multi-layer plan. It really is just luck more than anything. Also, it doesn't seem like infidelity was such a big problem in Roman society, Claudia Black's husband didn't really have such a big issue with his wife stepping out on him on occasion just like Pompeii did prior to marrying his daughter.

Also, he had significant motivators to keep the marriage intact regardless of Pompeii's infidelity (again, though he wasn't actually married).

The other characters, the father and son, it was pretty obvious that one of them is going to die. And the tension of the last fight, again had no narrative stake at all, and therefore the victory was hollow. Seeking revenge on the woman who killed the father didn't really have any narrative weight because she didn't have any character she was just a prop that killed someone you were supposed to care about. But because the motivation and desires of all the characters are pretty basic, it's hard to care about any of them.

One could say the same about Spartacus + Crixus VS Theokoles. And one could be right, but in that fight, the payoff wasn't about killing Theokoles, who was prompted as a real badass for multiple episodes btw. But it was seeing Spartacus and Crixus finally cooperating and seeing Spartacus survive and triumph, and this has emotional weight, because in contrast to Achillia we care about him and relate to his motivation.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Aug 23 '15

What Spartacus TV Series wants you to believe

0 Upvotes
  1. Armours and shields are useless. If you wear one, you will be unable to fight against a man wearing pants only.

  2. When you go on a secret covered mission requiring the best of your men, your girlfriends are part of it.

  3. Ballistae, catapults, javelins, cavalry, formations are not to be used but in the final battle.

  4. Laws of physics do not matter if you are a beautiful warrior woman going in bikini to battle. You can still throw from side by side an armored opponent double your weight.

  5. In South Italy can be as cold as in Iceland.

  6. 4 against 100 is good odds if you are among Spartacus favourites. You cannot lose if you yell enough.

  7. The Spartacus gangs are good inspiring people, fighting for freedom. They have beautiful ideals. Every now and then they slaugher few hundreds of peasants to take their food or an entire city, but that does not matter.

  8. The best leaders are also the best fighters.

  9. Spartacus people only flee when the odds are 1 to 1000 and a trumpet sounds.

  10. The women slaves are all beautiful, horny, willing to make orgies. If you look at another woman, your girfriend will talk to her and convince her to have a threesome.

  11. Being on a horse is a disadvantage.

  12. The night before a battle, remember digging a 200x3x3 meters big hole as a trap. You will never be spotted as nobody expects it.

  13. Using two swords is cool. Forget about a shield, especially if you wear no armour.

  14. You attack a formed shield wall by jumping over it or kicking it with both legs. The opponents will be impressed by your impetus and will not stub you.

  15. A group of fugitives men, women and children can outrun the army following them coming from North, move around them, move north and attack Rome.

  16. The two opposite leaders always find each other in battle. A leader can only by killed by another leader.

  17. If the rebels are losing, it is because "There are too many!!!"

  18. Two short knives are the best weapon in battle if you are a beautiful blonde woman. Plate armor is just for show. It will be pierced as it were paper.


r/Spartacus_TV • • May 28 '25

DISCUSSION Why is that Lucretia isn't allowed to have sexual intercourse with a slave but Quintus is allowed to and even does it in front of his wife?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Is it just pure sexism of that age? A man just has more rights than his wife?

Quintus fucks slaves whenever he wants, however he wants without the need to hide like Lucretia does with Crixus.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Feb 14 '16

I used Caesers line in an arguement

1 Upvotes

My stepdad is a BIG passive-aggressive douche bag. We were at a family dinner and he starts bringing my name up in conversation, trying to get everyones focus on me. So I snapped on him and was storming off and he says I'm disrespectful then I said “Apologies, I slip from reason when presented with the faults of lesser men...”


r/Spartacus_TV • • Mar 14 '25

Meme Now I can never unsee this.

3 Upvotes

r/Spartacus_TV • • Aug 04 '25

Is a female gladiator really a problem?

16 Upvotes

I don’t remember the show ever striving for historical accuracy. Everything about the show is so over the top. It’s one of the big reasons I love it. Out of everything that’s happened in the show can you not suspend disbelief for a female gladiator?


r/Spartacus_TV • • Dec 27 '25

HoA Discussion The training in HOA is horrendous [Spoiler] Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I remember Oenomaus training Spartacus and Crixus to fight the Shadow of Death, he fought against them in Theokeles' style, he fought standing tall and wide, swings were mimicking, the best he could of a giant man.

Then we have this, no one even is preparing Achillia to fight against small men, no special prepation to deal with low to the ground attacks, protecting her legs and no strategy for their size. Nothing... its really sad to see how little thoughts these training sequences have in comparison.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Dec 17 '25

HoA Discussion Does HoA provide a good explanation to why Asher is still alive? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I am rewatching the entire series in preparation to watch HoA. I’ve watched season 1 probably 10 times, but only watched the last 3 season once when they first released. Anyways, I just finished the episode in season 3 where Ashur dies and honestly, I forgot this even happened. For some reason, I just kept thinking ashur got away like he always does.

Anyways, does HoA at least address this in some manner or am I supposed to go into this just not remembering that he died? I’m gonna watch the show either way, but just want to set my expectations prior lol


r/Spartacus_TV • • Dec 17 '24

Lucricia looks like she dun messed up her chair during the primus in Gods of the Arena 😭

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Spartacus_TV • • Feb 02 '26

HoA Discussion [SPOILER] Why is Ashur so fucking dumb and why is everyone horribly unlikable Spoiler

26 Upvotes

I want to air the biggest two greviances that just make me not want to see a second season of this. I know spinoffs often end up not being faithful to the amazing characters they originated from (had the same issue with Elsbeth recently), but House of Ashur is just so damning to Ashur's character.

Ashur treaded the line well and was a character you liked to hate in Spartacus. He was smart, calculated, measured and quite effective, establishing himself with subterfuge, keen awareness and political maneuvering. All of that faded entirely into the abyss in his own show. I would have entirely understood if he was trying to play himself as a 'bigger/better' man now that he's free and has property and wanted to distance himself from where he was. Trying to be a proper 'roman man' and caring about things like 'the republic' and how people perceive him. But that's entirely not what's happening, we see little of him lashing out and 'reverting' to simpler methods of solving solutions.

More damning is just how much he degraded in aptitude. Ashur in HoA more than once slipped his tongue about something or another, leading to personal disaster. Gloating about Opiter's holdings succeeding to him to Proculus right in the middle of a public street.. letting slip his part to Gabinius as he was clearly not dead yet then being forced to kill him. Secrets and keen political acument were CORE to his character, and it seems they just evaporated. Let alone him being the punching bag for almost everyone in the show where i end up feeling even Batiatus lashed out more and was more vengeful. Ashur in his own show is a pale shadow leading to him just being a slog to watch unfold. "Let's see how Ashur doesn't succeed in almost anything and self-causes most of his own issues". I had hoped the first few episodes of beating him down were just to have him come back in the later season, but minus a 'GOTCHA' reserved for the last episode, which doesn't feel earned... i cannot perceive the character at all as someone i'd want to watch.

The second is related to overall most of all the characters. Most everyone seems cuntish and unlikeable and we see almost nothing to endear us to them or care about their struggles. Minus the slaves of the house and the recently killed off, it seems most of the front-roles, and there's a lot of them, are just entirely hate-bait, with Cesar and his wife getting top grades, but Tarchon absolutely being a bore to see ad naseum repeat the exact same 'i hate you' shtick for nine whole episodes. The gladiadator cast, what little is shown of them, act like a choir of school bullies, usually of one mind behind Tarchon. Claudia Black's character, Cossutia, manages to toe the line well, but it's probably the only instance i can think. Korris and Caledus with a mention to Hilara are probably the only truly likeable characters, Ashur avoiding getting marks purely because he seems pitiable more than likeable. And the less said about Achillia the better, not sure what to blame there more, the actress, the direction, the writing or just the sum of it all.

It so strange to have so much of the original artists behind the spinoff and somehow missing the mark entirely. I could do with the uninteresting offscreen politicking that we never actually see matter to anything in the show aside from the moments they decide to pop in, the weaker characterisation of a large part of the cast and few/nonexistent arcs the characters go through.

But seeing Ashur be incompentent while being bullied into submission by absolute assholes who you hate with a Jeoffery-level of passion... that's going to make me tune out of the show. I'm giving it the finale because i like to see things through but yeah, i'm out.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Dec 16 '25

HoA Discussion [Spoiler] Gladiators in House of Ashur are too pretty and well groomed Spoiler

10 Upvotes

One of the first thing I noticed, was how well groomed and well cute the gladiators' facial hair is in Spartacus the house of Ashur. It makes no sense, people have flawless dreads, machine cut beards, with perfect edges and there is a serious lack of dirt and ruggedness.

Anyone else feels this way ?


r/Spartacus_TV • • Nov 12 '25

DISCUSSION They should have just set the new show in a different time period Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The Roman Empire covers 1000 years of history with gladiators being around for most of it. The Colosseum wouldn’t even be built into more the 100 years after the first season takes place. So it’s annoying that Roman shows and movies always take place with in the same couple of decades.

It’s clear they are just doing this to have a familiar character return. Even if they wanted to go the female gladiator thing it would have made more sense in the empire stage


r/Spartacus_TV • • Oct 31 '25

The show is going to be awesome

11 Upvotes

and all these supposed Spartacus "fans" will look like clowns. Every minor flaw this show has - and inevitably will have, because every single media out there has flaws if you look for it - will be magnified a 100x times only because they dislike the show even before release and just want to talk shit instead of doing like a normal person and avoid interacting with the content that supposedly bothers them. As someone already pointed out, the Spartacus pilot is atrocious so they're having high standards even if to keep going with the original series you had to lower it too until it got better.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Jan 31 '13

In my eyes, the greatest scene in all of TV and possibly film. *Spoilers*

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/Spartacus_TV • • Dec 23 '25

Theory Do they really want us to believe this about Ashur? Spoiler

9 Upvotes

Yes in GOTA, Ashur is an alright Gladiator. I wouldn’t want to mess with him. He did prove himself. But he was by no means a great gladiator. I think everyone would agree with that. And now they want us to believe that he was able to kill the best the House of Ashur had to offer(according to Korris) without a hiccup and with no sword and armour and a jug of wine in his hand. Like come on.


r/Spartacus_TV • • Sep 18 '25

DISCUSSION Why I have no interest in the House of Asher Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Make no mistake. I love Spartacus. I think it’s a great show and I was sad to see it end.

So if I love the series, why do I have no interest in the House of Asher? It’s a very simple reason. I LOATHE Asher! Honestly, I can’t stand him! He’s like the Petyr Baelish/Littlefinger of the show. The Starscream. The instigator. The man who is only out for himself. His death is one of the most satisfying moments in the entire series for me.

So to see this opportunistic vermin be rewarded for killing Spartacus, just makes my blood boil. It would be like Littlefinger getting away with everything he’s done in Game of Thrones. Or like how Beth got everything she wanted at the end of Yellowstone. Seeing characters I despise not only surviving but getting everything they want is not a show I want to watch.

If you want to watch it, all the power to you. But I just can’t stand the idea of this vulture getting his own series. If I wanted to see a “What Ifs” Spartacus series, it would be what if Spartacus survived the final battle and made it to Rome?

But those are just my thoughts. What about you?


r/Spartacus_TV • • Dec 28 '25

HoA Discussion [Spoiler]The plot of house of asher Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Im 4-5 episodes in and its been good so far but is this entire story about training the women gladiator to beat 3 little people? Everything else doesnt seem to matter


r/Spartacus_TV • • Jul 13 '24

I hope House of Ashur isn’t as disappointing as this

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Jupiter himself rolled his eyes when the rap started


r/Spartacus_TV • • Jan 14 '26

Question Since they planned to do a "do-over"/alternate timeline, Why not make it about Batiatus?

6 Upvotes

John Hannah was phenomenal. They shouldve done a do-over with Batiatus, and Ashur that would've been amazing.