r/SpacePolicy • u/Apprehensive_Eye6684 • 18d ago
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Nov 04 '20
Former astronaut Mark Kelly wins Senate race in Arizona
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Nov 09 '20
Biden administration expected to emphasize climate science over lunar exploration at NASA
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Jul 18 '20
Rep. John Lewis, Space Station Savior, Passes Away
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Jun 08 '26
Russia is jamming GPS from space
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Nov 02 '20
Top commander of U.S. space forces: Space should be peaceful, bad actors will be held accountable
r/SpacePolicy • u/DragonGod2718 • Oct 31 '20
Thoughts on Biden's Space Policy
Politico mentions Oklahoma Rep. Kendra Horn as a possible NASA administrator if Biden wins. I think a Horn!NASA would be disastrous.
Artemis Program
Trump!NASA plants to return to the Moon by 2024, and eventually build a permanent outpost on the Lunar surface.
Lunar habitation is an important step in gaining the experience required to settle other celestial bodies. The Moon's closeness to earth means we can quickly respond if anything goes wrong on the surface.
The far side of the moon is the perfect space to construct an observatory. We may need a permanent outpost to make ideal use of it.
The Artemis program includes plans for in situ resource utilisation (ISRU) which would grant experience for ISRU on other celestial bodies.
Horn intends any return to the Moon to be a repeat of the Apollo program (flags and footprints).
Reuters notes that plans to return to the Moon in a Biden adnministration would be delayed.
ISS
Trump!NASA intends to end support for the ISS in 2024 and instead support commercial space stations.
This would further encourage the commercialisation of space and bolster the nascent space economy.
Biden intends to prolong ISS support and isn't in favour of commercial space stations
Reuters notes that extending support for the ISS would be a "major boost" for Boeing due to their $225 million annual operations contract (currently set to expire in 2024).
Commercial efforts
Trump!NASA has been contracting some space capability development to New Space companies (e.g. Blue Origin and NASA).
This further supports the commercial space industry and is just ridiculously more efficient in monetary value. SpaceX for example developed Falcon 9 for < 10% the cost NASA estimates it would have cost them to get a similar capability rocket using their traditional cost plus program.
Supporting commercial space is the most effective way to raise national space capability. $4 billion auctioned out to commercial partners to develop a capability would likely go further than e.g. $10 billion contracted to Boeing to develop something (the cost savings can and have historically been up to an order of magnitude).
Trump!NASA also went with fixed price contracts over cost plus (the government foots the bill whatever it is, thus incentivising the contractors to overrun on cost).
Horn's bill requires the use of cost plus contracts for the development of the Human landing system.
Cost plus contracts are ridiculously bad due to incentivising cost overruns, and may end up costing 10x more than what could be delivered by competent private space contractors.
Horn's bill effectively ensures that only Boeing can be contracted for the Artemis mission.
Given evidence so far, Horn seems to support an era where Boeing would be fed fat cost plus contracts.
Mars
Horn's bill endorses a journey to Mars orbit in 2033, but doesn't lay out increased funding for human exploration or solving the technical challenges required for a trip to Mars.
It seems that under a Horn administration, NASA would have the official goal of a journey to Mars (as under the Obama administration) without actually taking any steps towards Mars settlement (again as under the Obama administration).
A Horn administration would likely see a stagnation in NASA human spaceflight capability.
Reactions from the Space Industry
The bill seems to have been widely condemned by the space community.
Horn seems like a very effective Boeing lobbyist whose main accomplishment at NASA would be lining Boeing's pocket, stagnating NASA human spaceflight capability, and hindering the nascent space economy.
There are however, reasons for optimism:
Reuters reports that Biden agenda broadly supports competition in space (a very good thing).
Reuters reports that the Biden staff are split on SLS (cancelling SLS would likely be positive if the private market can supply superior Super Heavy Launch Vehicles for cheaper launch costs). However, Reuters also reports that the decision on SLS is to be "heavily influenced" by his choice for NASA administrator (Horn would double down on SLS regardless).
A Biden administration without Kendra Horn in charge of NASA would probably be much better than one with her at the helm. I think one of the better outcomes would be to keep the current NASA administrator, but Reuters reports that Biden intends to select a woman as NASA administrator.
Principal sources:
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Mar 26 '21
South Korean leader vows ‘landing on the moon by 2030’
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • May 26 '20
U.S. Army signs deal with SpaceX to assess Starlink broadband
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Jun 16 '16
Please Upvote Please upvote me! This account needs karma in order to work properly
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Jul 23 '20
U.S. Space Command again condemns Russia for anti-satellite weapon test
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Jan 25 '20
U.S. Space Force says its new seal is not a Starfleet knockoff
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Feb 03 '21
White House: Space Force “absolutely has the full support of the Biden administration”
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Dec 10 '20
NASA Picks 18 Astronauts for Its First Artemis Cadre
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Feb 07 '21
DARPA to survey private sector capabilities to build factories on the moon
r/SpacePolicy • u/weedenbc • Jul 07 '16
Hi, my name is Brian Weeden. I work on a lot of space policy issues, mostly dealing with space debris, national security, and commercial space. AMA!
I am Brian Weeden. I have a background in engineering and military space operations, and currently work on space policy issues for an NGO in Washington, DC. Areas I focus on include space debris, space situational awareness, space traffic management, and protecting national security space capabilities. I'm also finishing my PhD dissertation on how the U.S. government makes policy decisions on dual-use space technology. You can also check out my writings and pubs, my full bio on LinkedIn, or follow me on Twitter.
Feel free to ask my anything about those topics, and I'll be answering questions over the weekend.
r/SpacePolicy • u/imtherty • Jul 25 '15
/r/space policy is one of the trending subreddits for today. Huge thanks to all of our new subscribers!
r/SpacePolicy • u/mrfeeny24 • Jun 30 '23
Fuck it, /u/spacepolicy is turned off and we're NSFW now
Hey everyone. Today is the last day third-party Reddit apps will be functional. I think this is incredibly sad. Not just because I've been using /r/syncforreddit for 11 years, but mostly because it's become increasingly clear that Reddit no longer cares about their users, or the people who literally run their site for free.
I know this is a small sub that doesn't have tons of activity, but I've really enjoyed running it the last 7 years. While it may not seem like it, a decent amount of work goes into keeping the lights on. And while the below changes may not make a giant difference in the grand scheme of things, they are the least I can do to show my support and give my (albeit relativity very small) middle finger to /u/spez and co.
With that being said, as of today (1)/u/spacepolicy has been turned off, (2) the sub has been changed to NSFW, and (3) all rules are no longer in effect (outside of Reddit's Content Policy). Making the sub NSFW (which prevents Reddit from making any ad revue off of us) and no longer enforcing rules will likely have little to no effect on the sub (although I'd find it hilarious to be proven wrong). The most notable change will be the disabling of /u/spacepolicy, a bot who is responsible for the majority of the posts in this sub.
Will any of this make a difference...Will anyone even notice? The answer doesn't matter (the answer is definitely no to both lol) because we're doing it anyway. Fuck /u/spez and never stop caring about the policies of space.
=
-- /r/spacepolicy mod team
=
EDIT: Just to confirm, sub isn't going anywhere. Just turning off the rules and the bot that posts everything
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Mar 16 '21
U.S. Space Force would support commercial services to remove orbital debris
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Jul 14 '20
House bill restores funding for five NASA science missions
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Apr 09 '21
Biden administration proposes $24.5 billion budget for NASA in 2022
r/SpacePolicy • u/Captainmanic • Dec 07 '20
Op-ed | No, Mars is not a free planet, no matter what SpaceX says - SpaceNews
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Sep 07 '20
Chinese reusable experimental spacecraft releases object before returning to Earth
r/SpacePolicy • u/spacepolicy • Jun 09 '20