r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Jan 19 '21

Discussion Why is NASA still building the SLS?

2 Upvotes

It is projected that SLS will cost a whopping $2 billion every single launch and makes use of a modified Space Shuttle design, which is rapidly being outdated with every Spacex launch. Falcon Heavy, though it has a slightly lower payload capacity than the SLS (141,000 lbs vs 154,000lbs) only costs roughly $150 million to launch. And its.. already built. The RS-25 engines on the SLS are the same exact engines to power the Space Shuttle, with some modifications made to accommodate stresses the two side boosters will impose. The RS-25 are nothing compared the Spacex Raptor engines. Since it utilizes a full-flow combustion engine design, its equally the most powerful engine and efficient rocket engine ever created. In addition, the propellent used is made of liquid oxygen and methane-based, something revolutionary as well. Liquid oxygen and methane propellant have a much higher performance is much cheaper to launch than the liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen propellent that the RS-25 use. When Starship is built is ready for commercial use, it’s projected to cost a mere 2 million dollars to launch and will have twice the payload capacity of a Falcon Heavy (220,000 lbs). Starship seems to be in faster production, and at this rate, will be ready for use much before the SLS. Why is NASA still building the SLS instead of contracting Spacex?


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • May 18 '25

Discussion Does SLS being job program actually valid critism or a red herring? Idk but I don’t think cancelling have consequences.

0 Upvotes

Sorry for my grammar I have Autism accompany with language impairment.

Please let have some intellectual, nuanced, and detailed with context discussion not oversimplified things.

My opinion: To me already spent the money on SLS their no way of getting money back so cancelling the SLS completely will not help cost criticism, likely make it worse.

Is likely cancelling put us back bit like on domestic exploration like we did with space shuttle and Apollo. We don’t have hindsight say cancelling it worth or not via versa.

Job creation did have legit boost economic impact that could justify the cost and allow kept knowledge for aerospace. Why not keep SLS but improve SLS launch cadence and cost efficiency to prove crew safety without risking crew mission. Money spent on cargo mission can help prove safety and reliability of SLS further the need but also cutting cost per crew mission.

Because majority SLS cost is R&D and most of it was inefficient and already spent why not change the future of program. We can use the money saved for NASA program which nasa does best research and development of unproven technology.

SLS can help cut cost scientific mission by help reducing engineering restraint of space mission saving from SLS improvement can help fund further science mission. Make subsided which make Incentive to launch more SLS especially for constellation and cost likely cover launch cost and further development on SLS.

We do partnership with other development countries too like what French did with ISRO.

SLS is junk performance wise compare Saturn V or SpaceX rocket but cancelling to me has more legit proven negative but continue also has unproven chances so in my what is really best option?


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Jul 31 '22

Discussion A rant about people’s understanding about the SLS

1 Upvotes

I recently noticed that a lot of younger people seem to give a lot of backlash at the Space Launch System for reasons like it not being reusable and expensive.
I think the main thing that people do not understand is that companies like SpaceX use reusable rockets because it saves them money because they are a private industry. Another major point people point out is the timeframe and costs which you have to understand that these projects take a long time in r&d. Yes SLS is expensive but compared to other nasa’s previous program it’s a lot cheaper and it’s timeframe is less than thing like the Saturn V and the shuttle.


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Apr 30 '19

Why I have no sympathy for SLS

0 Upvotes

I will get downvoted for this, but this is a harsh reality. I'll state the reasons why I have no sympathy for SLS being cancelled in future:-

  1. 'What about the jobs of people working on SLS?' There's been an explosion of Private Aerospace industry, and there's never been a more better period in history for job opportunities in this field than today.

  2. 'What if some of these people wont get a job?' I am sorry but that's just the harsh reality of life. When 78% of people are living paycheck to paycheck and 58% of people cant handle an unexpected $500 bill, you cannot justify at $20 billion jobs program for few hundred people at expense of taxpayer's money.

  3. This will be good for NASA in long term. The country is under imminent economic stress despite we being in Year 10 of Expansion, a recession is probably due in the coming years.

When recession hits us, the Democrats will come for gutting NASA's budget to rechannel those funds to welfare programs. And they will justify this action by pointing at SLS cost overruns.

4. The technology is obsolete. Even without factoring reusability, the upcoming Starship, New Glenn, Vulcan, Ariane 6 will be more than enough to cover NASA's needs and will certainly be cheaper.

Yes, I know it's not NASA but Congress who decided on this requirements because of lobbying from the contractor. All the more reason to discard this gravy train at the earliest.

5. 'But it is Boeing who is responsible for Cost Overruns not NASA'

All the more reason to gut this project to send a message that NASA will not tolerate and allow these 'Cost plus contracts' anymore.


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Sep 06 '22

Video SLS - Why so many scrubs?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • May 01 '18

Boeing's Misleading Anti-SpaceX Pro-SLS Facebook Ad Campaign

Thumbnail
nasawatch.com
0 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Nov 29 '21

Discussion Distributed Lift to maximize payload to the Moon

0 Upvotes

The SLS is the ideal rocket for enabling a colony on the moon. Multiple SLS rocket launches can be used in conjunction to land large surface elements directly onto the moon.

Here is how the plan works:

The first SLS launches a fuel depot, this fuel depot is partially fueled at launch and is made of a solar panel, plus a sunshield similar to the one used on the James Webb Space Telescope. The Fuel depot is placed near the Gateway, but far away where it poses no danger to the station itself.

Two more SLS launches send tanks full of water using a spiraling orbit with two solar electric space tugs. These tugs are relatively simple and based on the SEP technology already employed on the Gateway.

The water tankers bring the water to the fuel depot,w here the same solar arrays that power the electric thrusters now power the electrolysis machine which converts the water into fuel.

A lander is launched, empty, but with it's full payload. It is brought to the Depot where it fills up its tanks and lands.

With such a architecture one could land 50-60 tons on the moon. With five sls water tanks there would be a continuous presence on the moon with the SLS. Soon a colony could be set up and mine the water on the moon itself creating a conveyor belt form the earth to the moon.


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Mar 11 '19

WHEENNN WILL FLY?!?

0 Upvotes

What the hell are they doing?!?? Testing shits?


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Jul 22 '19

SLS: A Jobs Program?

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Jul 03 '20

Discussion Lockheed Martin's Flawed Comparison Between Orion and Dragon

Thumbnail
nasawatch.com
5 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Apr 09 '19

NASA's $17-billion moon rocket may be doomed before it ever gets to the launch pad

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
2 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Mar 12 '19

EUS-exploration upper stage

0 Upvotes

So, was it CANCELED or SUSSPENDED in development!? As i heard now there will be at least 3 miasions on Block1? Are gateaway parts going to be launched on other vehicles?? U think other advanced blocks will even fly in the future!???


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Jul 17 '19

When will SLS launch?

2 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Sep 13 '22

Article Why NASA’s Artemis Has Fuel-Leak Problems That SpaceX Doesn’t

Thumbnail
youtube.com
32 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Aug 17 '23

Discussion SpaceX should withdraw Starship from consideration for an Artemis lander.

0 Upvotes

The comparison has been made of the Superheavy/Starship to the multiply failed Soviet N-1 rocket. Starship defenders argue the comparison is not valid because the N-1 rocket engines could not be tested individually, whereas the Raptor engines are. However, a key point in this has been missed: even when the Raptor engines are successfully tested there is still a quite high chance it will fail during an actual flight.

The upshot is for all practical purposes the SH/ST is like N-1 rocket in that it will be launching with engines with poor reliability.

This can have catastrophic results. Elon has been talking like he wants to relaunch, like, tomorrow. But nobody believes the Raptor is any more reliable that it was during the April launch. It is likely such a launch will fail again. The only question is when. This is just like the approach taken with the N-1 rocket.

Four engines having to shut down on the recent static fire after only 2.7 seconds does not inspire confidence; it does the opposite. Either the Raptor is just as bad as before or the SpaceX new water deluge system makes the Raptor even less reliable than before.

Since nobody knows when such a launch would fail, it is quite possible it could occur close to the ground. The public needs to know such a failure would likely be 5 times worse than the catastrophic Beirut explosion.

SpaceX should withdraw the SH/ST from Artemis III consideration because it is leading them to compress the normal testing process of getting engine reliability. The engineers on the Soviet N-1 Moon rocket were under the same time pressures in launching the N-1 before assuring engine reliability in order to keep up with the American's Moon program. The results were quite poor.

The difference was the N-1 launch pad was well away from populated areas on the Russian steppe. On that basis, you can make a legitimate argument the scenario SpaceX is engaging in is worse than for the N-1.

After SpaceX withdraws from Artemis III, if they want to spend 10 years perfecting the Raptors reliability before doing another full scale test launch that would be perfectly fine. 
(They could also launch 20 miles off shore as was originally planned.)

SpaceX should withdraw its application for the Starship as an Artemis lunar lander.
http://exoscientist.blogspot.com/2023/08/spacex-should-withdraw-its-application.html


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Jun 01 '19

Artemis, Gateway, Moon Direct, Dr. Zubrin & more on Ep. 4 of Mars Talk

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Dec 04 '24

News Truth Social

Thumbnail
truthsocial.com
39 Upvotes

Donald Trump has just nominated Jared Isaacman as NASA Administrator

Massively unexpected to me personally, and I really do wonder what potential consequences for SLS would look like. As far as I can tell he really doesn't like the program, but he also seems like a realist to me. So I definitely wouldn't expect cancellation immediately after him entering office or anything. What do you think could be plausible paths forward for SLS, and Artemis as a whole, assuming he's confirmed as Administrator?


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Jul 06 '25

Video Is the President's beautiful bill big enough to save Artemis, Gateway, and SLS Block 1B?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Dec 23 '19

Article Congress throws in the towel on the Artemis program?

Thumbnail
thehill.com
0 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Aug 29 '22

Discussion I don’t remember there being recurring problems of hydrogen leaks with the shuttle.

0 Upvotes

Yes, the shuttle had scrubs, but I don’t remember there being recurring problems of hydrogen leaks as there is with the SLS. Is there a flaw in the design?


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Aug 23 '22

Discussion Why have there not been exploding prototypes?

2 Upvotes

Assuming that the Artemis 1 launch is successful, there won't have been unplanned exploding prototypes. On the other hand, there have been many Starship prototypes which have exploded unplanned.

As far as I know, similar hiccups haven't been a part of the development of SLS. Why is that?


r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Oct 24 '19

unsourced rumor ⇒ locked Artemis Timeline Draft

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Mar 28 '19

Ariane 6 core for the Space Launch System(SLS) upper stage.

Thumbnail
self.arianespace
0 Upvotes

r/SpaceLaunchSystem • • Mar 17 '20

Discussion Comparison to BFR (i'll do my best not to be a fanboy, forgive me if i am)

8 Upvotes

If both STARSHIP and SLS accomplish exactly what they aim for at exactly the price they projected, then would there be any reason for the existence of SLS?

by this what im asking is, is SLS absolutely depending on the failure of STARSHIP or is there one use in which it would exceed even if STARSHIP succeded?

Like, with starship you have around 50-80 tons to LEO for around 10 million dollars

you have 100 tons to mars or moon for 10 million dollars

you have around 20 tons to the outer planets for 10 million dollars

In that situation is SLS still good or is it objectively and undeniably inferior?