r/Sourdough • • Feb 20 '24

Let's talk bulk fermentation Is this over proofed?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

25% freshly milled rye flour (rye berries in the Vitamix), 75% Robinhood bread flour, 80% hydration, 20% starter, 2.5% salt, 1.5% caraway seeds

Autolyse for 30m, added starter, knead for 8 minutes in a stand mixer.

Bulk fermentation in the oven with the light on for almost 8 hours, with 3 coil folds at 45m intervals. Shaped and placed in the banneton when it hit almost 70% expansion and was still rising very rapidly.

Cold proofed for 10 hours at the back of the bottom shelf of the fridge, baked in a Dutch oven at 450°F for 25m covered, 25m open.

I don't think this is the best oven sitting, and I feel like maybe I should have stopped bulk sooner, or maybe put it in the freezer for a few minutes to retard it more quickly.

Thoughts?


r/Sourdough • • Jun 10 '24

Things to try Asked my 3 year old to put flour in the starter

Post image
0 Upvotes

I turned to get water and he had put grass in it that he was carrying around in a bucket 🙃


r/Sourdough • • Mar 12 '26

Advanced/in depth discussion 95% hydration fail

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I decided to try something different and did a 95% hydration loaf. It was pretty much a failure (although tastes fine)

Conventual wisdom says higher hydration dough is harder to work with, but I would argue that in many ways it is much easier.

  1. Mixing the water and flour is faster and less effort, as is incorporating the starter and salt.

  2. I can use fast, low effort coil folds the whole way through.

  3. Cleanup is easier as the wetter dough sticks less.

In this case, I think my mistake was fermenting too long (to 50% volume)for two reasons. First, a really wet dough is more slack and may not dome as much, and second, since a higher hydration dough will ferment faster, it will continue to ferment more than a dryer dough while it cools to ambient temp in the fridge. So basically, I think I should have put the brakes on it a little sooner.

You can see where the crumb has started to compress horizontally at the bottom and how the crumb has also started to separate from the crust at the sides and top.

Anyway, a fun experiment and I'm open to any feedback on how to improve on this sad frisbee lol

460g bf 435g water 75g starter 10g salt

6 rounds coil folds Bulk to 50% Preshape and rest 30m Shape in cold retard for 16h

Bake in preheated DO @ 480f, 30m Uncovered @ 420, 25m


r/Sourdough • • Apr 13 '26

Crumb read please Tips for a better crumb?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I'm relatively new to sourdough. After a learning curve, I've made several decent loaves, but I wish they had a more open crumb and weren't quite as "gummy."

I use a starter that's half rye and half all-purpose flour. I usually keep it in the fridge between bakes, since they're not as frequent. I'll feed it once the night before and again the morning I make the dough.

Here are the notes I follow:

300g AP flour

200g Bread floor

300g Warm Water

100g Active Sourdough Starter (bubbly and fed)

10g Salt

Whisk starter and water

Add flour and salt, mix with paddle attachment until just combined

30-minute autolyse while covered with a damp towel

Knead with the dough hook on level 2 for 6-10 minutes, until it passes the window pane test

Follow with one set of 4 stretch and folds

Cover with the damp towel for 30-60 minutes then repeat the set of stretch and folds

Very lightly grease the proofing container with a neutral oil

Proof with the lid on in a turned-off oven, cycling the oven light on and off to maintain 80 degrees, for at least 5 hours or until doubled

Scrape down sides of container with a wet spatula and scoop out onto a lightly floured surface

Tuck edges into the center, flip with a dough scraper, and rotate seam side down to form a tight ball

Invert into a bowl lined with a heavily floured towel, seam side up

Cover bowl with a plastic and rest in the fridge for overnight or up to 18 hours

Preheat oven to 450 degrees (convection) with Dutch oven inside for at least one hour, testing temp with a laser thermometer

Add a baking sheet to the bottom rack to prevent the bottom of the bread from burning

Flip dough onto a parchment square (seam side down)

Slice top with a razor

Remove Dutch oven and quickly transfer the dough on the parchment paper into the pan and cover

Return to the oven and bake covered for 20 minutes

Switch oven from convection to standard bake setting at 450 degrees and bake uncovered for 25 minutes more

Let rest for several hours before cutting

-----

EDIT: Thank you to those of you who took my request for advice seriously. The picture probably doesn't do it justice, but this version is so much more tender:

https://photos.app.goo.gl/NRRekuqTSEfXB2nQA

What I changed: 500g bread flour (no AP except for what's in the starter), 325g water, 60 minutes autolyse, waited to add salt after autolyse, baked for 20 minutes at 500, dropped the temp to 450 after removing the lid (except I forgot to do this for 5 minutes, so the crust got way darker than I wanted).


r/Sourdough • • Jul 26 '26

Let's talk technique Shaggy dough not recommended?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Came across this on TikTok and she’s purporting that mixing until shaggy is not the way to go. This is for sourdough, something I’ve never done but I’ve always yielded good results with shaggy dough > stretch and fold with my loaves.

I’m not a professional so could someone please elaborate further on what she means? She’s pretty aggressive/defensive in the comments too so it’s difficult to get context clues.


r/Sourdough • • Sep 30 '24

Let's talk technique Anyone else take a Laissez-faire attitude with their starter vessel?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Mine gets cleaned maybe once a year, usually when my wife complains about the crusty bits that are being shed on the fridge shelf. Occasionally, I will pull big chunks off the rim of the jar, which is strangely satisfying. I have never had an issue with a starter going bad in 15+ years of sourdough baking.


r/Sourdough • • 24d ago

AI discussion/recipe/content My Personal Sourdough App

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

I have spent the better part of the last 6 months trying to perfect my sourdough. I've been using Claude to document my process and progress. Making small changes here and there based on the outcome of the bake. Some were definitely better than others. As I perfected the 70% hydration I wanted to push to 75% hydration. The fruits of my labor, and with the help of Claude, I've been able to make my own personal Sourdough baking app that I can use on my iPad/iPhone while baking. No more digging for my recipe sheet.

Things that I input into my app:

  • Hydration

  • Single/Double batch

  • Dutch oven or 9x5 loaf pan

  • Aliquot sample size (to get amount for 2 oz cup)

  • Mixing day

  • Time I added the levain and salt to my autolyse

This gives me a rough fermenting timeline and helps me plan on what time I'll more than likely be baking in case I'm not available. The time it took to experiment and log my bakes turned into something I never thought of when I started.


r/Sourdough • • Jul 16 '25

Let's talk technique Well at Least it’s Edible :-/

Thumbnail
gallery
83 Upvotes

I definitely need some work. This was a 73% hydration dough. Shaping needs improvement, and trying to nail the scoring as well. Sometimes it works and other times it like this.

Process was… Rested after mixing. Autolyse for two hours. Transferred to bowl and let it rest for half hour. 4 Stretch & Folds half hour between. Bulk fermented for 1 1/2 hours to 50%. Divided, shaped and cold proof. I think this is where I messed up.

Cold proofed 14 hours. And baked.


r/Sourdough • • Oct 12 '26

Rate/critique my bread 50/50 Rye & Wheat 71% Hydration 13% Protein

0 Upvotes

479g Wheat flour 10% Protein
472g Rye flour 9% Protein
49g Wheat Gluten 80% Protein
250g rye Sourdough
20g Salt
670g Water

- Stretching once every 45 mins till 60-70% rise.
- shaping and proofed overnight 7-11 degrees
- 1 hour at room temp till 70% rise
- baked in dutch oven 250C and 482f 30 mins with lid and 30 mins off till inner temperature of 95C

we ate all of it immediately after baking 🥲 had to cut into it


r/Sourdough • • May 07 '26 Heartwarming

Crumb read please WHAT AM I DOING WRONG?!?!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

100g starter, 350 grams of room temp water, 500 grams of unbleached bread flour, 10 grams of salt.

I knead this by hand till it stops sticking heavily to me. Rest for 1 hour and stretch and fold 3-4 times every 30 minutes. I mixed the dough around 6:00 a.m and baked around 3:00 p.m. My husband got me a proofing box and this was the first time I felt like I got the jiggle on the dough during bulk fermentation. I preheated my oven and Dutch oven for 45 minutes between 425 and 450°. Couple ice cubes for 40 minutes and 10 minutes with the lid off. I got absolutely no ear on the expansion, this is the first time my dough actually tastes sour(and idk if it's a good sour), the crumb looks pretty even but it is denser than a mother fucker. My dough stayed consistently 76-77° all day. Sat on the counter for 2 hours before cutting into it.

I have a gooooood starter too so I know it's bulk fermentation somewhere screwing me over


r/Sourdough • • Jul 30 '22

Unpopular opinion: Removing the first 30 seconds of your cutting-bread-in-half videos saves everyone valuable time.

5 Upvotes

I love watching crumb shot reveal videos as much as any bread enthusiast in this sub, but we could save valuable time by getting rid of the first 30 seconds of most of these kind of videos. Otherwise we all have to sit through:

  • 0-5 seconds: nothing really happens, as the person cutting the bread is double checking if they are actually recording. They then pick up a knife. Exciting stuff.

  • 5-15 seconds: We all watch a way too dull bread knife struggle to penetrate the crust of the bread. The viewer is left thinking they're in the wrong sub and will now have to witness someone cutting off one or two fingers.

  • 15-25 seconds: Bread cutting in progress. Unexperienced bakers have probably zoned out by now. Experienced bakers are tensing up just in case they see some steam coming out of the loaf, in which case they would get ready to end OP's life with a hefty comment.

  • 25-30 seconds: The person cutting the bread has noticed that the bottom crust is actually harder to cut through than expected. More force is applied until finally...

The crumb is revealed! (It took way too long though)


r/Sourdough • • Dec 06 '25

Beginner - wanting kind feedback I’m about to quit

Post image
25 Upvotes

I don’t understand what I’m doing wrong. I’ve made 6 doughs, a few of them have ended up in the trash. The ones I have baked have not turned out. I had three hockey pucks and one that had little oven spring and was very gummy. I tried sandwich bread which never rose after 10 hours. My latest dough had basically zero fermentation after an overnight bulk.

ChatGPT is saying it’s a starter issue, so someone please help before I lose my mind. My starter is about 2 months old. I started with AP flour, but have been switching to bread flour after some recommendations I’ve gotten elsewhere - it had 3 bread flour feedings before I made my last dough. I’ve been feeding about 1:2:1.5 every 12ish hours, I don’t measure exactly but she seems to do better when she’s thick. I keep her in my oven with the light on which is 77-79 degrees. This is her after about 11 hours.

Is this not a ready and active starter? I do plan on feeding some whole wheat flour, I just haven’t been able to go to the store to get some yet.


r/Sourdough • • Jun 24 '26

Starter help 🙏 Is my starter ruined?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve never made sourdough before so my friend gave me some sourdough starter back in December to help get me started. I kept in my fridge and completely forgot about it until recently. Can someone tell me if it’s gone bad or if it’s salvageable?! Thank you so much!!


r/Sourdough • • Aug 28 '25

Help 🙏 Over? Under? Weak starter? I'm lost.

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Hi! Fermentation during bulk looked kinda good, big and small bubbles at the top, glossy, a bit jiggly, but I didn't feel like it was truly "alive" yet and poke test seemed kinda tight, so I let it proofed a bit in banneton until it seemed a bit more poofy.

Overall I thought my bread would be a bit underfermented but passable, so I baked it anyway. A reasonable oven spring but no "ear" per se, tunneling holes and irregular structure.. overfermented? Before baking, I thought it was a bit underfermented at the end of my bulk (6hrs+1hr proof in banneton at 24c/75f room temp. and no cold retard)

I'm lost. I did this simple recipe to "reset" my streak of truely awfuly flat loaves, and this one finally sprung, holding itself a bit better, but still no ear, nor fluffy interior. Starter grows quickly and seems kinda lively, but not as much as I would like...Been giving her a bit of rye to stimulate a bit more, but she always smells like wet socks days after, so I stopped (2 month old starter). Would appreciate pointers and guidance if possible! Thank you so much 🙏 Here's the recipe:


●263g water ●96g starter ●10g salt ●431g strong white bread flour

2-3mins thorough mix, 30mins after incorporating/mix ingredients (hands) -1hr after, big laminations -1 hr later, another big lamination -40mins later, coil folds -rest of bulk -preshape -20mins after, shape -proof banneton for 1hr -bake


r/Sourdough • • Sep 05 '25

Beginner - checking how I'm doing First loaf! 🌼 What went wrong? :(

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I got gifted a rye Sourdough Starter about two weeks ago! I slowly bred (? lol is that the right word) a part of it to be a wheat based Starter. I fed it often, it was always very active and definitely quickly doubled in size. It’s a Levito Madre so a more stiff Starter btw :)

I baked a bread with it today and I’m positively surprised because it was edible! Didn’t think It would turn out even okayish tbh. But what bothers me is that the bread doesn’t have holes! It sounds hollow when I tap it. It’s not really fluffy but also not insanely gooey in my opinion. But the crust could be crustier haha What could have went wrong?

Recipe:

  • Mixed 40g of active wheat starter with 40g 550er wheat and 40g of water

  • set aside for around 4h to rise almost to the peak

  • Roughly knead the sourdough with 100g wholemeal spelt flour, 485g 550er wheat flour and 395g of water and let it sit for an hour

  • add 12g of salt and knead for 5 minutes

  • let it rise for a few hours until doubled in size (first stretch and fold after 30mins and then repeat 2 more times also after 30mins each, then let it rise for the rest of the time without doing anything) Note: I fall asleep and mine was sitting on the counter for 2-3 more hours!

  • after doubled in size form the bread and put it in the fridge for 10-14h Note: I choose 10 hours

  • preheat the oven at 250°C, cut the bread, put it in the oven with a lot of steam Note: I used an dutch oven and added water on the inside, drop the heat immediately to 230°C, bake for 20min, remove the lid, drop the temperature to 210°C, bake for 30 more mins


r/Sourdough • • Oct 14 '25

Rate/critique my bread 3 day old starter

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

After I killed my starter I decided to start a new one. Wasn’t patient enough to wait a week and it had seemed to double after only 3 days, so I baked a test loaf. I did 450g flour 65% hydration 11g salt. 3 stretch and folds and a total bulk ferment time of 7h. Cold proof for 12 h. Bake at 230c with lid for 20 and at 210c without lid for another 25 min. Didn’t have time to let it cool down so the crumb looks a bit wet. Is it under fermented?


r/Sourdough • • Apr 17 '25

Let's talk technique Solved a problem - fix your cavernous crumb.

Post image
3 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of cavernous gummy crumbs lately. So I am here to share a solution!

I know the first assumption is always proofing issues, or starter issues. But, my starter has been perfect, my proofing immaculate. And yet for 4 loaves straight, I got these cavernous crumbs, a gummy crust...

Let's define something - a crumb with big holes is not an "airy crumb" because the bread around the holes is much denser. A good crumb will have an architecture of smaller holes, smaller than the tip of your finger, and will feel like a fluffy masterpiece when touched.

My usual loaves were airy, fluffy, divine - I'll post a pic in the comments. So I was determined to figure out: Why? Why did my crumb suddenly change? Why were so many people on this sub having the same problem?

It was the way I was folding.

I saw this stupid new york times video with a "bread expert" doing these long pulls, stretching the bread way out. It looks great on camera, like she's a bread wizard. And I had started doing these long, drawn out stretches.

But there was a hidden problem, those long stretches burst all the tiny bubbles needed for your airy crumb. It destroys the architecture of your fermentation.

I turned back to how I had originally learned how to make break - the "old European grandma with too much to do" way = quick, short folds, hardly stretching the bread at all. And my crumb? Went back to being perfect heaven.

Lesson learned - don't overstretch your folds.
I generally like the New York Times a lot - but their tips for making bread? fake news.

Recipe:
350 g water
100 g starter
12 g salt
500 g flour

Fold six times, every 30 minutes.
Shape and fridge cool for 10c hours.

The only difference between these two loaves (see comments)* was my fold method.

*I don't know why, but reddit wouldn't let me attach both photos today ☹️


r/Sourdough • • Jun 21 '25

Let's discuss/share knowledge What makes Sourdough..sourdough?

1 Upvotes

Context is definitely needed here: I mean this in the most respectful way possible- No shame or hate to your community of specific bread lovers, but I seriously do not like sourdough bread. I mean cannot stand. I baked a Brie and my boyfriend brought home sourdough and no joke it ruined my baked Brie experience and I love baked Brie so much I thought that was impossible. I’ve tried to love and accept sourdough many times in life with no success. So this raises the question- what makes sourdough.. sourdough? I ask because I love all other breads. Have no qualms with any of ‘em. Sourdough on the other hand is exactly that- sour dough man and I just ugh can’t. Can someone with the knowledge tell me what makes sourdough like this. Again, this is obviously a me thing and I in no way am trying to criticize sourdough. Thanks in advance 💓


r/Sourdough • • Jan 15 '23

Let's talk ingredients I had a brain fart and didn’t use any wheat flour. Instead it was 75% hydration with all AP flour. After realizing my mistake (at the start of bulk rise) I decided to go with it. I wouldn’t recommend it

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/Sourdough • • Aug 16 '25

Sourdough Am I the only one still making sourdough anymore? Such a therapy!

0 Upvotes

r/Sourdough • • Oct 31 '25

Crumb help 🙏 Can someone tell me what I'm doing wrong

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

I made this loaf today with a 1:2:3 ratio of starter:water:bread flour respectively.

Bake time was 475 for 25mins lid on 465 for 28mins lid off Cooled for 3 hours

There are some large holes but most of them are small. Idk if I didn't prove it enough or it over proofed.


r/Sourdough • • Jul 11 '25

Starter help 🙏 WORMS?! NSFW

0 Upvotes

WTF?! Has this ever happened to anyone? Started my starter from scratch at the beginning of the year. Never had any issues. Moved it to a new jar this past weekend and fed. Took a peek today and there are two dead bugs in there and multiple worms crawling around in the hooch. Is my flour contaminated or something with the jar?! Had been covered with the regular mason jar lid and ring seal but not screwed down tight. Will be throwing this away out of pure disgust and restarting but want to avoid this happening in the future.


r/Sourdough • • Aug 14 '26

Starter help 🙏 How do I use this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

A friend gave me this dehydrated starter and I have no idea how to make it not dehydrated, please help!


r/Sourdough • • Oct 04 '26

Inclusions Sourdough & chat Inclusions are ruining my loaves!

Post image
0 Upvotes

My dough becomes so gummy when I add cheese and jalapeno.

My recipe is 150g starter
300g water
500g bread flour
10g salt
Bulk fermented for 6 hours at about 78-80 degrees. I added inclusions during lamination. Then a 12 hour cold proof.

I’ve always been weary of adding cheese during the stretch and folds because warm cheese sitting out for 6+ hours just seems like a breeding ground for bacteria, no?

But it looks like adding the cheese during lamination isn’t successful either. This is my 3rd failed loaf.

Open to any and all advice!

ETA: I used a white cheddar, instead of a typical orange cheese, and fresh jalapeños.

Baked at 500 for 25 minutes (lid on), then at 450 for 20 minutes (lid off)