r/Somaliland • • Dec 26 '25

My view on Israeli recognition

4 Upvotes

I want to start by saying that I’m Eritrean, so I understand I’m coming at this from an outside perspective. People are free to disagree, critique, or ignore what I’m saying—but I hope this can be a respectful and thoughtful conversation.

In my view, Israeli recognition of Somaliland is unlikely to benefit Somaliland in the long term. The strongest argument in favor is that it might push Ethiopia to recognize Somaliland as well, since Ethiopia has often suggested it would not be the first country to do so, but might follow others. Even if that happens, I am not convinced the overall outcome would be positive or stabilizing.

I believe Somaliland would have been better served by focusing on negotiating the strongest possible terms for reintegration with Somalia, rather than pursuing independence primarily through external recognition. A useful comparison here is the Kurdish case in Syria. Despite decades of repression and conflict, Kurdish leaders are now negotiating reintegration arrangements that include meaningful autonomy, revenue-sharing, and security guarantees. These discussions involve direct financial mechanisms, protection of regional economic interests, and partial control over local military command structures.

I recognize that many Somalilanders argue reintegration is impossible because of the extreme crimes committed by the Somali state against the North. I do not deny those crimes. In fact, I believe Somalia must openly acknowledge them, apologize, and engage in genuine reconciliation. Denial only deepens mistrust. While all Somalis suffered under dictatorship, the North experienced disproportionate and targeted violence, and that reality must be confronted honestly.

That said, I do not believe past atrocities automatically make political reconciliation impossible. History shows that deeply divided societies have restructured political relationships when incentives, guarantees, and enforceable power-sharing arrangements are strong enough.

My concern with Israeli recognition is that it may increase regional tensions rather than stabilize Somaliland. Turkey already has a close military and political relationship with Somalia and has been competing with Israel across several regional theaters. Israeli involvement in Somaliland could push Turkey to deepen its military engagement in Somalia and encourage Somali rearmament. If Somaliland begins receiving advanced military or surveillance capabilities, Somalia may respond forcefully—despite its internal divisions. History shows that even fragmented states can temporarily unify to block secessionist movements when they perceive an existential threat.

I would also add that this development risks altering a long-standing status quo in Africa. Since independence, African states have largely upheld colonial borders as a stabilizing principle, despite their flaws. If Somaliland gains recognition through external geopolitical alignment rather than a negotiated regional settlement, this norm could weaken. That shift may encourage other breakaway regions across Africa to seek recognition through great-power patronage rather than internal political processes. Over time, this could fuel new separatist movements—not only in Somalia, but potentially even within Somaliland itself and elsewhere on the continent. The broader consequence may be increased fragmentation and instability in the Horn of Africa and beyond.

I also question what Somaliland realistically gains from Israel. Israel remains highly polarizing across much of Africa, the Middle East, and Asia. Being recognized primarily by Israel (and Taiwan) risks associating Somaliland with contested geopolitical blocs. We have already seen how Taiwan’s involvement prompted China to increase support for Adwal as a counterbalance. Similar dynamics could emerge elsewhere, potentially isolating Somaliland further rather than strengthening its position.

From a comparative perspective, I also think Eritrea’s case is fundamentally different from Somaliland’s. Eritrea was never given a choice during decolonization—it was forcibly federated with Ethiopia without a referendum and later annexed. Somaliland, by contrast, voluntarily joined Somalia. That decision was later betrayed through violence and repression, but the original political choice still matters when assessing international legitimacy.

Because of this, I believe Somaliland may have had greater leverage by collectively insisting on a future reintegration under strict conditions: meaningful autonomy, guaranteed revenue streams (such as Berbera port revenues), independent budgeting authority, and regional security control. Even a confederal or highly decentralized arrangement could have preserved dignity, security, and economic stability without the risks that come with geopolitical isolation.

I fully expect disagreement, and that is fine. My questions to Somalilanders are sincere: • Why do you believe reintegration is impossible, even with strong guarantees and autonomy? • Do you see Israeli recognition as a net strategic gain? • What concrete benefits do you expect Somaliland to gain from Israel that outweigh the regional risks?

I am not interested in hostile or racist exchanges. People in the North are fully capable of engaging in serious geopolitical discussion, and I hope this can be a productive conversation.


r/Somaliland • • Jan 23 '24

It's funny for girl like me in somalia to be in this subreddit

9 Upvotes

I think it't funny most of you think all somalis in somalia are muslim when in fact many of us are ex muslims but are too afriad to come out becouse of alshabab in my circle we make fun of muhammed and allah like it's funny too see you write those thing in this subreddit very funny islam destroyed our country Sorry for my english i learnt it in online


r/Somaliland • • Dec 28 '25

As an Israeli, Shalom to Somaliland!

143 Upvotes

I wanted to share a message of support and goodwill from Israel.

I’ve been reading more about Somaliland’s history and governance, and it’s genuinely impressive how you’ve maintained stability, institutions, and internal peace over such a long period of time. That kind of consistency is hard-earned anywhere, and it deserves recognition.

I truly hope Israel’s recognition proves to be the first of many, and that it helps open doors internationally in the years ahead.

Wishing Somaliland a peaceful, prosperous future, and hoping for respectful, mutually beneficial relations between our peoples over the coming decades. :)


r/Somaliland • • Jan 11 '26

Inside the forgotten past of Somaliland’s lost Jews | The Jerusalem Post

Thumbnail jpost.com
0 Upvotes

Judaism in the Somali Peninsula has for some time been treated as a historical footnote, if it was acknowledged at all. However, scholarship now confirms that Jews lived, traded, and practiced their faith in the region for centuries – sometimes openly, sometimes in secrecy – and often as indispensable intermediaries in the commercial and social life of the area.


r/Somaliland • • Jan 02 '24

The Habesha - Isaaq port deal will end Somaliland/Somalia as we know it

3 Upvotes

The Habeshas will set up a military base on the coast of Somalia with an army. After a few years of them being settled they can easily start a two front war from the north and east and easily crush SL troops in a matter of days. They have superior military equipment and we've already seen how SL was decisively beaten by a bunch of Hartis on Jeeps.

This deal is clearly a trojan horse and a long awaited plan by Ethiopia to divide our country further by annexing SL so we never have the opportunity to reclaim our stolen lands again. HSM will sit back and do nothing as he only cares for his own pockets. The only hope we have is Isaaq patriots standing up to their brutal dictator and removing him from his post.


r/Somaliland • • Dec 27 '25

Congratulations Somaliland from Israel with love

64 Upvotes

Hi Somalilanders! I just wanted to congratulate you for the recognition. We in Israel are very happy about our government's decision. Hopefully other Western countries will soon follow the same path! 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙌🏼🎉


r/Somaliland • • Dec 31 '25

Would Ethiopia annex our land?

1 Upvotes

Btw wallahi I'm a lander, and fully agree with Israel recognising us and Ethiopia & any other nation too!!

I just want to play devil's advocate here. What's stopping Ethiopia from annexing parts of Somaliland once we let them in?

Does Cirro have any contingencies like drones & anti drone weapons from UAE & Israel?

Then again, I don't think UAE would allow them to build their own commercial port because Berbera port would lose out!! So, is it just a naval base they wanted?? (On behalf of Israel) 🤔


r/Somaliland • • Dec 26 '25

Massage to other somalis

28 Upvotes

Please, we have been fighting 35 years, we are on the road to get international recognition. Please, build your country and stop the hate you are spreading.


r/Somaliland • • Jan 01 '26

Why are People Happy about Division?

0 Upvotes

Question from a middle eastern:

Why are you celebrating a decision that is only used to divide and weaken Somalia and Africa more broadly?

I won’t even comment on the fact that the recognition of somaliland was done by the genocidal Zionists, but what’s the point of celebrating further division of Africa and African countries?

I’m really not asking this question in bad faith, I would like to know why nationalism is put ahead of brotherhood? Somalis and somalilanders are literally the same people.


r/Somaliland • • Jun 13 '25

Don't skip just hear me out please

0 Upvotes

I absolutely understand for wanting to secede of course. But tell me this though do you think somaliland was the only state to suffer tremendously ? in 2010 200k+ people died from famine yet I Dont see jubaland wanting to secede. wallahi I do see it a bit greedy to segregate somalis saying your tribe is better and wanting to remove yourself from somalia. As a Isaaq myself our parents are grieving and until somalia can say and acknowledge discrimination that happened during civil war then of course you can be self autonomous but so segregate and give a part of somalia ocean to ethiopia who stole our land, your sick and inshallah those mindless somalis perish in the here after.


r/Somaliland • • Dec 26 '25

Hello from Israel

98 Upvotes

Hi! I just heard that israel officially recognizes your sovreignty. Nice to meet you and congratulations

I've heard about Somaliland before but I don't know much else to be honest. What language(s) do you speak? What are your favorite things to eat? Do you have any famous musicians I should check out? Is it safe for foreigners to travel as tourists?


r/Somaliland • • Aug 15 '25

Somaliland and somalia

3 Upvotes

Why does Somalia, a chaotic mess of a state, throw a tantrum and turn anti-West the moment Somaliland dangles deals for recognition in front of Western powers? Meanwhile, those same Western countries prop up Somalia’s shaky government and run their shady operations there without a peep


r/Somaliland • • Sep 14 '23

How is Somaliland dealing with the recent news about the Awdal region?

0 Upvotes

I was curious hearing that Gadabuursi has now announced it’s support for Somalia. Combined with the recent loss of Lascaanod by Dulbahante. It seems that Somaliland really only controls Hargeisa nowadays. How are you guys dealing with that news?


r/Somaliland • • Mar 11 '26

Well well well

0 Upvotes

We warned you guys that this deal for recognition posed only one purpose yet you were so naive into thinking that Israel was doing it for the good of their hearts now look, a military base is being built which WILL DRAW UNWANTED ATTENTION FROM SHIA MILITANTS like HOUTHIS and IRAN and best believe Israel won’t help you they only care about themselves


r/Somaliland • • Dec 25 '25

What is everyone's thoughts on Somaliland's recognition rumours?

0 Upvotes

Is there any proof Somaliland will be recognised tomorrow? (Israel being the first sickens me but I'd take that L)


r/Somaliland • • Jan 24 '26

Are you guys voting reform?

1 Upvotes

Genuine question. Noticed a lot of landers in support of Nigel Farage lately.


r/Somaliland • • Jan 16 '23

These folks in R/Ethiopia wanted to see somali women naked and become worthless as their xabashi and oromo women

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Somaliland • • Feb 04 '26

Handing Your Natural Resources to Another Nation is Never a Good Idea.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Somaliland • • Jan 16 '26

historic milestone

Thumbnail
gallery
76 Upvotes

The arrival of the President of the Federal Republic of Somalia in Laascaanood represents a historic milestone, underscoring national cohesion, political maturity, and the strengthening of unity among the Somali people.


r/Somaliland • • Dec 18 '25

The idea behind r/Somalia is centered on oppression and nastiness toward Somaliland.

13 Upvotes

They can’t tolerate comments that challenge their fake claims; it's weak garbage. Just look at their subreddit—they can't even handle a rebuttal.

0 IQ


r/Somaliland • • Oct 25 '25

Many Somalians that are claiming both Jigjiga and Hargeisa are delusional

10 Upvotes

When they say Hargeisa is part of Somalia it's because of so called international law (even though Somalia means only the former Italian Somalia colony and the illegal 1960 "union" never de jure took place).

However these same people say Jigjiga is part of Somalia even though the so called international law they use regarding Hargeisa clearly recognises Jigjiga, Godey etc as part of Ethiopia and in fact Ethiopia controls all its claimed territory whilst Somalia is a failed state that controls 0% of Somaliland and less than 50% of its own actual land barely thanks to AMISOM lol


r/Somaliland • • Dec 26 '25

I support you from Lithuania and i am very dissapointed about western hypocrisy towards independence movements. We have gained our own freedom 35 years ago and were recognised, but it seems like the west doesn't care about things that don't benefit them personally

49 Upvotes

r/Somaliland • • Jan 07 '26

Whar are the thoughts from real Somalilanders

18 Upvotes

This sub seems to be taken over by non Somalilanders, bots pretending to be landers and other nonsense. YouTube and TikTok videos all Zionist or far right AI gen progranda pieces or local shills paid $100 to wave a isreali flag and give a tour.

Moderation on this sub has always been poor..

Those in Somaliland - what's the real feelings about this?

Diaspora - how are you feeling about this ?

We haven't heard from real Somalilanders in all of this. I want to hear what you have to say.

Me personally, I'm heartbroken, double so as a berbera native, I feel morality has been compromised - while I believe in pragmatism some principles are worth keeping. Welcoming the architects of an active genocide is nauseating.


r/Somaliland • • Sep 28 '25

The interview about the president of Somalia is very telling of the situation within their country.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/Somaliland • • Jan 20 '26

Somaliland and Israel recognition hyprocisy

141 Upvotes

Salam, I am somalilander. With regard to the Israeli recognition of Somaliland. I fully support this 100%. Why? The reason being that Irro put his people FIRST, not the Palestinians, not the arabs. The reality is, I feel like Somalis have been indoctrinated into having an UMMAH first or being Muslim First, which would be good if we lived in a fairy world. However, every first-world muslim nation, when they do deals, they are acting for the interest of themselves and their people first. The reality is somalia is a failed state; Somalia has not accomplished anything. They are a laughing stock of the world. There is a reason you would rather live in the UAE than in Somalia. We need to have a Somali-first mentality. Prioritising our people first, not the Palestinians, not the arabs. Furthermore, the Arabs whom we advocate and support have not reciprocated that love back to us. Our attention, money, and focus should go back to our people FIRST. WE NEED TO HAVE A SOMALI-FIRST MENTALITY. If the Somalis really cared about Palestine, then maybe they should talk to the rich arab nations that aren't doing anything.