r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jul 12 '21

If socialism works why is Cuba currently collapsing?

1 Upvotes

r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Mar 22 '22

I’m going to argue that Capitalism is already dead

0 Upvotes

Capitalism: an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state.

Point one: The money supply is completely controlled by the federal reserve, you cannot have a free market of any kind with fake money. Bailing out businesses is the opposite of capitalism. They socialize the losses and privatize the gains.

Point two: everyone is talking about banning Congress from trading stocks. Why? Is that because they have a large amount of central control over the economy?

Point 3: this whole thing is about the petrodollar system. This is where the government made a deal with Saudi Arabia that everyone has to buy oil in US currency, and we enforce all the trade routes with our military.

Point 4: the stock market is a form of socialization. Yes, it does not offer equal shares to all people. But those with stock have a form of political control of a PUBLIC company.

Point 5: people like Jeff Bezos live in DC and lobby for regulations that will help close the door to future competition. They also lobby for things that will cut our small businesses and shift that business to Amazon, such as the 15$ minimum wage. Anti competitive practices such as this are not a form of capitalism.

So are we socialism? No not really.

Conclusion: I don’t think we’ve been capitalism for a long time. We’re just a centrally controlled empire and barely any different from standard dictatorships. The president and the Fed have massive amounts of power, and they exert that power over businesses every day. If anything we are corporatist, not capitalist. The biggest corporation being Washington DC. Honestly Keynesian economics is the imperialism and “capitalism” that you’re looking for. Government intervention and central planning is the name of that game. Centrally controlled systems are the ones that invade and engage in anti competitive practices. This is the problem you are looking for no matter what side you’re on. It’s time to bury the ideas of John Maynard Keynes.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Oct 08 '20

This subreddit name is a misnomer

0 Upvotes

I've scrolled through it for a bit and it doesn't seem like it's actually meant for genuine debate, mostly seems like a place to harp on abut how capitalism is bad.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Sep 01 '22

Difference between rich people and normal people

0 Upvotes

What would happen if you have the average person 1B dollars?

I saw a post on a other subreddit claiming that a rich person would turn $600 into $6000 where as a regular person would essential be rid of the money by the next day. I want to engage in a similar thought experiment. What do you think a regular person would do if they got 1 billion dollars?

I don't think they would make any money from it. They would probably not be able to spend it all (because spending that much money in one lifetime is a challenge) but I don't believe they would increase their wealth after getting the money. A rich person (a rich businessman that is) i think would turn a huge profit.

The point of this being to demonstrate the fundamental difference between billionaires (or wealthy businessman) and normal people is not luck or theft but rather competence.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Oct 10 '20

Why isn't antifa/BLM more open and transparent regarding their desire for a socialist revolution?

0 Upvotes

Wouldn't they have a higher chance of success if they openly stated their goals and demands?

What do they have to gain by their chosen strategy of lies and deceit?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Dec 06 '20

Why is the execution and elimination of scholars a common hallmark of communism (and socialism?) ?

0 Upvotes

something that never quite made sense to me. Does owning the means of production also mean everyone (society) has to be at the same level of education? Is that why?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Dec 08 '21

Why does Socialism Exclude people?

0 Upvotes

For people who want change and equality, it seems (at least to me) that if you disagree with what a Socialist says or tell them a fact that's anti socialism. You get banned from posting on the Socialist sub lol, and typically called a racists and all the other things in the book.

Is this because my group of Socialist is too small? Or is it common?

Seriously Asking.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Apr 06 '20

What's my political ideology?

0 Upvotes

I've taken many political compass tests but I don't think I've found a label for myself yet. Can anyone help me with labeling my opinions (subsequently I'll be able to read more about the philosophy I'm inclined to and will become a more informed individual)?

You can ask questions if you want to.

Here are my general beliefs:

  • A private market should exist.

  • The market should be regulated.

  • Abortion is murder and hence should be illegal.

  • The state should spend money for healthcare, education and so on.

  • Education budget should always be more than defence budget. State has a duty to provide every citizen with education.

  • Private schools should be banned.

  • There should be standardized curriculum (but with minimum bias) designed such that free thought can exist in the institution.

  • Retributive Justice is better than rehabilitative justice. Rehabilitative Justice should be used for smaller crimes and retributive for repetition of crimes or larger crimes.

  • A cabinet of Intellectual, social, religious and corporate leaders should vote among themselves (These people must have a clean criminal record and especially for corporate leaders should not be exploitative of public) to choose the leader of country.

  • Student Politics should be highly encouraged.

  • Sex outside marriage should not be allowed and rather the marriage should be made easy for people. State should encourage people to marry and to settle in stable families. Cohabitation is also considered a marriage under this definition.

  • There should be gun control.

  • Interest (which is exploitative) should be banned. Loans should be given adjusted for CPI.

  • The heads of government departments should be elected and they must have atleast a Major or a PhD in the given field.

I can't really think of anything else.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Aug 26 '20

What socialists and capitalists have in common.

3 Upvotes

They both see themselves as being the good guys and the other side as being the bad guys.

What if they are both right?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Aug 27 '21

Is socialism sustainable on long term?

1 Upvotes

Firat, excuse me if the question is misinformed or terms are used inaccurately. As I think of it, it seems like socialism is economically unsustainable on the long term. Basically, socialism virtually lowers the survival bar in terms of gene selection. At some point the productivity of the population may degrade to the point where individuals have to suffer working very hard in order to collectively survive.

Thus from a utilitarian point of view, there should be a limit to how much one should allow the survival bar to be lowered in order to maintain an optimal aggregated "happiness" with a certain level of population productivity.

Does socialism offer an answer to the claim of degrading productivity? Again, excuse me if I misused the terms. I hope the thought is clear though.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Mar 22 '20

I think some point of socialism makes sense but big goverment is asking for a tyranny

2 Upvotes

Goverment is one of the worst way to help the poor the power is in the people hands but having higher tax to attack problem that are easy to solve like for example homeless people Democrat in California just throw money at the problem but as we see that never solve the problem or put a dent in it but when a musician try to build a small home with electrics and everything for basics need and guess what the goverment of California torn down these homes with no reasons and healthcare the only reason the cost of them are at ridiculously cost is because goverment not let small clinic that are way cheaper exist and the one who do are under ridiculous regulations not making them viable to poor and the intense regulations cause by big health corporations not let other have competition in that market let them make what every price they want and never give a price list


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Dec 26 '20

Capitalism may be deeply biased against the working class, but the democratic ways of America allow for change for the better. Socialism has the opposite. Which is more useful?

0 Upvotes

r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Feb 10 '23

Why shouldnt owners get paid more than employees?

0 Upvotes

If you agree with the premise that workers should be paid more throughout their time of employment due to their increased value provided to the business, why is it wrong for the business owner to have a higher pay than workers (particularly at the start I’m referring to) since their financial investment provided a lot of value- ability to buy machines, training, uniforms, product, marketing, hire new employees, pay rent for the business premises… etc.

Why is that form of investment that provides value to the company not deserving of a higher reward, just as throughout more labour the workers should get higher rewards due to increased value provided the business?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jun 28 '24

I can debunk every anti-socialist argument I have ever heard in a single sentence.

5 Upvotes

The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was socialist in the same way that the Democratic Republic of Korea is democratic.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • May 22 '24

Right Wingers need to Stop forcing a False narrative on the Left

0 Upvotes

As a rational left winger from the UK, I cant stress how annoying it is to see radical Right wing/ One Nation Conservatives continually group wokie extremists in the same box as anyone who doesn't agree with them.

Just because I am left wing does not mean I support communism, just because I hate Candace Owens, does not mean I read Mao's Little Red book every night as a bedtime story, just because I think your views on immigration are a little harsh does not mean I want open boarders.

And most importantly, just because I am left wing does not mean I should be grouped with wokies. We despise them just as much!

Lets start with the recent surge in online content, of so called Right wing intellectuals roasting left wing college students, is this what we have come to? THIS is bar for where you base your opinions?

One of these intellectuals being Ben Shapiro, who called Andrew Neil, a long time conservative, a "Lefty". Now regardless of the event it took place, this perfectly encapsulates the Right Wing in America right now, and slowly in the rest of the world.

You guys are so hung up on trying to debunk other views of how society should be run that you never stop to think: "Huh...the world isnt just about me...maybe this is how politics...works?"

Political ideologies exist for a reason, so when supposed specalists like Jordan Peterson (Who I respect) talk about Socalism like its a sin that was chisled on the 10 commandements, I tend to roll my eyes.

I tend to roll my eyes even more audaciously when in debates about Socalism, you guys keep mentioning Karl Marx...at that point why am I wasting my time debating you? So if you see a trans protester spray painting a pride flag on your garage door, dont see her as "Left Wing", see her as an extremist. And btw, these Right Wing radicals are just as bad! Candace Owens saying "Fuck Ukraine and wearing a White Lives Matter shirt is not "commendable" or beneficial in any way to anything.

And thats my thesis: Wokies are not left wing, nor right wing. They are deluded extremists, so stop blaming us for them

Thank you


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Feb 28 '20

Why is Stalin so popular all of a sudden?

2 Upvotes

Is Stalin's popularity now 7 decades after his carnage a case of history though rose coloured glasses ? https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2019/04/16/stalins-approval-rating-among-russians-hits-record-high-poll-a65245


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jan 27 '23

Socialism and capitalism both have their good aspects. And so...

0 Upvotes

...we should not be debating socialism vs. capitalism, but rather should be working together to build a better system that incorporates both of their good aspects.

The name of that system doesn't matter right now. It may never matter.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Nov 21 '21

ECONOMIC THEORIES NEVER HAD ANY PRACTICAL UTILITY (Karl Popper) --LESS SO FOR HUMAN RIGHTS.

0 Upvotes

Human rights: Food for a thought of little worth ‘HR and economic theory’

Human Rights Reader 604

[TLDR (too long didn’t read): This Reader is about the rhetoric spread about a benign neoliberalism that, in reality, only pays lip service to human rights. For a quick overview, just read the bolded text].

-Science requires us to constantly think against and challenge our own brains, i.e., distrust the evidence, not adopting the first interpretation of a given phenomenon. This leads me to say that the so-called economic science is still in the caverns. (Louis Casado)

  1. As I often do, let me start with a few pertinent one-liner iron laws:

· Competition and profit are one of the core themes of economic theory studies: One is the war and the other is the bounty…

· The ideal of Capitalism is to make something as cheap as possible to sell it as expensive as possible.* (Albino Gomez)

· The economic measure packages that governments take ought to carry a warning that said: “It has not been proven this product is good for the health of the citizens”. (Jean-Francois Revel)

· Market economies have evolved into market societies where price determines the value of everything. (Mark Carney) --wither human rights (HR).

· Technology reflects the biases of those who make it. And when those who make it are corporations, it reflects corporate imperatives making this one of the world’s most significant threats to democracy and to HR. (Mother Jones)

· When corporations refer to the bankruptcy of one of their subsidiaries they frivolously call it “redeployment to other markets”.

· It is so good to benefit from a tax that one does not pay. (Vilfredo Pareto), and a real old one,

· To be wealthy and honored in an unjust society is a disgrace. (Confucius)

*: [The goal has always been simple: ‘capture as much wealth as possible while sharing as little as possible’. In large part that has, for instance, meant shifting responsibility for the environmental and social harm that corporations unleash onto society away from themselves and onto governments and thus taxpayers …and for the most part, it has worked for them].

The topic of the concentration of wealth and of the pauperization of billions of human beings is not a topic that sprang up yesterday

2. It would be good to remember that Marx already described this phenomenon in the XIX century as an unstoppable, evil process part of the capitalist mode of production. The false ‘consensus’ that perennially favors the privileged --those who inherit wealth-- has been sold to us as the must-have of ‘political stability’. But when the immense inequalities, unbearable inequities and social injustices that are behind HR violations are not resolved through methods that the prevailing ‘democracy’ allow, discontent and confusion will invariably seek all means to break that false consensus. (L. Casado) …a lesson/role for HR activists here.

3. Activists embracing a revolutionary change in HR must thus remind themselves that there is nothing normal, natural, or unchangeable about the social and political institutions that society and the prevailing ‘democracy’ have erected all over the world. --wither economic theories. Ergo, in order to have a world-with**, activists must create a** world-without --a watchword for all of us attempting to act within and against the massive legal, institutional, material, and financial HR-averting apparatus of the current global economy. (Maywa Montenegro de Wit)

4. In the community of HR activists, we are well aware of the capacity of the proponents of the corporate global system to co-opt language and concepts so that corporate narratives get away with generalities and with empty slogans. The corporate discourse may seem a poor cousin to the muscle of economic theory, but it does perform the important functions of legitimizing the global neoliberal discourse, as well as stifling public awareness of the stakes involved. This is the ably fabulized vision that is spread by ‘corporate spin docs’ to present the discourse as a vision universally shared. (Nora McKeon)

5. The avoidance of accountability of such corporate actors is yet another legacy of colonialism. Manifestations of this can be seen in the lack of an internationally legally binding instrument to regulate business activities (its negotiation endlessly dragging at the UN HR Council) despite the clear historical and continuing role of conflicted corporations** and their negative impact on HR especially in the area of the extraction of natural resources. The transition to justice from colonialism must, therefore, first ensure an eradication of the colonialism of the past and clearly prohibit the practice of it in the future --as the UN itself has said/claimed. What must be addressed is the systemic and structural issues that have created the problems at hand. Addressing the contemporary manifestations of colonialism today requires a reconstruction in our understanding of the relationship between businesses and HR within the broader context of geopolitics and the international political economy --no matter what economic theory says. (Wesam Ahmad)

**: Accountability goes beyond conflicts of interest and into corporate interference (the latter referring to any corporation intentionally damaging someone else's contractual or business relationships with a third party thus causing economic harm. The result pursued is a higher concentrated corporate control). Furthermore, corporations and their allies embark in strategizing to oppose and get-rid-of government regulations and any democratic checks on corporate power. For this, corporations do use their outsized financial advantage to shape politics and policy thus robbing people of their ability to use local democratic channels to rein-in corporate-driven excesses and harm.

An active neo-mercantilism of the powerful countries lurks behind the rhetoric spread about a benign neoliberalism and globalization process (Chakravarthi Raghavan)

-“I would define globalization as the liberty of my group to invest wherever we want, at the time we choose, to produce whatever we want, sourcing and selling wherever we want and enduring the minimal possible obligations in relation to labor legislation and social conventions.” (Percy Barnevik, president of the transnational ABB, 1995)

6. If we can speak of the betrayal of the global political class, it is precisely in this sense: the absence of political will to reverse trends, i.e., abdicating their politics and playing a fundamental role in defending and promoting the general interest and the global common good.

7. As countries rendered poor struggle to cope with the pandemic, they are being set back further by restrictive fiscal policies. These are imposed by conditionalities demanded by countries rendered rich who no longer practice them themselves --if they ever did.

8. As if not already bad enough, some pandemic relief spending in many countries has been ‘captured’ by the politically well-connected as political elites and their cronies seize the lucrative new opportunities. [You have read that some corporations and individuals have benefited greatly during the pandemic, e.g., US billionaires have reportedly become over a trillion dollars richer over the last year and a half]. (Jomo Sundaram)

9. Moreover, in their secret free trade agreement negotiations, for instance, Northern trade representatives are deviously using the word ‘rights’ when what they are really all about is ‘privileges’. I am talking about intellectual property privileges, because these are ultimately, under duress, given to companies by States through forced policies and/or acts of law. Mind you that HR are too seldom enforced by law: Corporations 1: People’s Rights 0!

10. Among many, one of the structural reasons for the seldom acknowledged irresponsibility of the global dominant classes is their vision of life and of the world as essentially mercantile, productivity-oriented, techno-scientific, subservient to efficiency, conquering, elitist and ultimately violent. For them, knowledge cannot be openly shared and diffused; if it would, they would lose their profits and their power.*** Add to this how the commodification and privatization of knowledge, promoted by the public authorities, has destroyed the capacity of the State to act according to its prerogatives, its missions, and its obligations.

***: Take taxes: We have a global trade regime, but not a global tax regime. (Hans Dembowski) Tax evasion by the wealthy, it is universally agreed, must be deterred, but trickily continues (think Panama, think Pandora). To be equitable, taxation must be progressive (but, as you well know, it is not). More equitable tax systems are to get more revenue from those most able to pay while reducing the burden on the needy. Wealth taxes are the most progressive (but vigorously resisted) way to raise revenue while also reducing inequalities. (J. Sundaram)

11. So, with survival foresight, the dominant classes send their young to management and administration schools, where they learn the skills to conquer markets, eliminate competitors and maximize short-term returns on investment.**** No surprise, then, that it is rare to see that the priority objectives of grants-hungry higher education institutions are to foster the capacity of our societies to make universal HR, collective responsibility for general well-being, the security of humanity and fraternity a reality.

****: In recent years, these classes have also prioritized investment in artificial intelligence, especially in the field of robotics, primarily because their goal is to quickly achieve the manufacture of robot soldiers that do not unionize.

12. So, what can be done? First, it is up to the citizens to answer the question. It is not a question of asking the G2O member states --or, worse, the World Economic Forum-- what to do. [The Davos Forum is the Vatican of neoliberalism. (Vicente Navarro)] It is necessary to carry the revolt to the heart of the power and to the very foundations of the dominant system: e.g., the private property of knowledge (patents) on a world scale. It is not a question of working on how to force private companies and public authorities to practice greater and more transparent ‘social responsibility’ and ‘environmental responsibility’. The history of the last 80 years shows that, unfortunately, this objective is an illusion within the dominant system. (Riccardo Petrella) What is needed is a regime of corporate social accountability managed by public interest CSOs!

Claudio Schuftan, Ho Chi Minh City

Your comments are welcome at [email protected]

All Readers are available at www.claudioschuftan.com

Postscript/Marginalia

-I do not know anything about geopolitics or about macroeconomics or about any of that nonsense, so do not pay too much attention to me. (Anibal Malbar) …not my case!


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jul 13 '20

Questioning

0 Upvotes

https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/meet-the-youth-liberation-front-the-militant-group-promoting-a-marathon-of-angry-portland-protests/

  1. Where do high schoolers who have never really lived or worked in the real world, or cast a ballot, gain all of these beliefs and feel they have this right to somehow express them violently?

  2. does anyone else not see the hypocrisy? “We are anarchists, who in our effort to fight the state, are creating our own state (CHOP) of anarchists” so essentially they are making a state-less, State. Am I alone in seeing this as hypocrisy?

This is why I have this common belief that any person promoting complete socialism and/or communism 1) either does not really fully understand what they are advocating 2) they do understand, and our just willing to be hypocrites


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jun 28 '23

Capitalism is basically a very productive system it just needs to be properly regulated

0 Upvotes

Do you agree or disagree ? https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/04/did-karl-marx-secretly-love-capitalism/237283/ This is not to suggest for a moment that Marx considered capitalism as simply a Bad Thing, like admiring Sarah Palin or blowing tobacco smoke in your children's faces. On the contrary, he was extravagant in his praise for the class that created it, a fact that both his critics and his disciples have conveniently suppressed. No other social system in history, he wrote, had proved so revolutionary. In a mere handful of centuries, the capitalist middle classes had erased almost every trace of their feudal foes from the face of the earth. They had piled up cultural and material treasures, invented human rights, emancipated slaves, toppled autocrats, dismantled empires, fought and died for human freedom, and laid the basis for a truly global civilization. No document lavishes such florid compliments on this mighty historical achievement as The Communist Manifesto, not even The Wall Street Journal.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Apr 20 '22

A book entitled "The Fall of the US Dollar: A Second Coming of the Non-Aggression Pact" forsees strong communist momentum coming about from negligent monetary policy. According to this book, Germany replaces the US as Saudi Arabia's main ally and overthrows the petrodollar agreement

0 Upvotes

A book entitled "The Fall of the US Dollar: A Second Coming of the Non-Aggression Pact" forsees strong communist momentum coming about from negligent monetary policy. According to this book, Germany replaces the US as Saudi Arabia's main ally and overthrows the petrodollar agreement, while Russia corners the market on the mineral cobalt, putting US defense at the mercy of Russian and Chinese exports. US economic and military hegemony would come to an end. According to the book, Germany wil either leave the eurozone or annex the European Central Bank.

The rise of communism in America, as explained in the book, is attributed to something that Keynes mentioned in one of his books. It is right in line with what is transpiring in the US, and "The Fall of the US Dollar: A Second Coming of the Non-Aggression Pact" eloquently explains the connection. I forget what chapter of "The Fall of the US Dollar" that the connection is made between Keynes and what is happening in the US. It is certainly there and right on the money.

The non aggression pact is an agreement between Germany, Russia, the Democratic Republic of the Congo(DRC), Ukraine and China. There is a free preview on Amazon and you can use the search function to see what topics are discussed in the book.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Oct 31 '25

I'm ex- trotskyite converting to Marxism-Leninism. How unmask the arguments by right and trotskyites that Stalin was an ally of the Nazis from 1939 to Invasion in 1941? There was a Decree, Resolution or Order by Stalin or Central Committe of Politburo to save the Jews from Nazis?

0 Upvotes

I'm ex- trotskyite (I was influenced by my trotskyite brother).

But I would like to debunk the lies about as "Stalin was an ally of the Nazis from 1939 to the Invasion in June 22, 1941"?

I know that the Red Army liberated the Jews from Auschwitz concetration camp in January 27, 1945. But I would like to know if there was a Decree, Resolution or Order by Stalin or Central Committe of Politburo to save the Jews from Nazis?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Mar 24 '20

Capitalists. What do you think about socialism is the only thing that will now save your business and the economy

1 Upvotes

What do you think about Government intervention and bailouts? Or are you going to stick to your Capitalist ideals and refuse this socialist help and let market forces dictate if you fail? Private profits. Public losses


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Nov 16 '21

what are socialists afraid of

0 Upvotes

I posted that i thought it was time the left arm and i was censored, how cowardly are liberals now?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Nov 29 '21

is the Taliban victory over US in Afghanistan an opportunity for Socialism?

0 Upvotes

An indigenous military revolution frees the country from capitalist imperialism but favors a more religious model of government. Can socialism catch hold and flourish here?

What Afghans need most is food and fuel for the winter, how does the socialist ideology accomplish progress here?