My apologies in advance for the length but it’s complicated
I’m in a massive bind with Social Security and need advice from anyone who understands Title II / Title XVI rules, Trial Work Periods (TWP), Extended Medicare, the four-year rule (administrative finality), or how to force SSA to hand over my internal records.
I was approved for benefits at 17 and given Medicaid based on disability at 16. Back then, I was receiving SSI, and I did not start receiving concurrent SSDI (on the 3rd) alongside SSI (on the 1st) until my late 20s / around age 30.
2011–2013 Work Attempt & Extended Medicare: I worked from November 2011 to April 2013, and during some months my earnings went over the SGA limit. During that period, SSA reduced my SSI benefits based on my earnings. When I stopped working in 2013, I did not work at all for over a decade (2013–2024)—my SSI payments went back up to the full amount, and I kept my extended Medicare. Then, about 2–5 years later, I started receiving both SSDI and SSI. SSA is now claiming I completed my TWP back in 2011–2013, whereas I suspect my original Title II claim ended back then and later restarted/reinstated—which would mean a new Trial Work Period should apply to my recent work.
Four-Year Rule (Administrative Finality): Even if by chance I’m wrong about starting a new Title II entitlement in my late 20s, my 2011–2013 work attempt was over 13 years ago and SSA already reviewed/adjusted my benefits back then—so I’m also trying to understand if the four-year rule (administrative finality) bars SSA from reopening and retroactively redetermining my 2011–2013 work/TWP determinations over a decade later (especially when there was no fraud or similar fault).
SSA Told Me in May 2024 I Was Good to Use My TWP: Before I started working again, I specifically checked with SSA—and in May 2024, an SSA representative told me I was good to use my Trial Work Period.
Recent Work Attempt (2024–Present): Relying on that, I started working in June/July 2024 and entered the Ticket to Work program. My work history since then has been very inconsistent—I attempted to work full-time during my TWP, which failed, and my earnings have fluctuated (some months over SGA, some months below). I also had major surgery requiring formal medical leave with significant mobility impairment, and I have Impairment-Related Work Expenses (IRWE) that should be deducted from my countable earnings.
Abrupt Cutoff: Despite being told in May 2024 that I had my TWP available—and without clear accounting—SSA abruptly stopped my disability payments completely this month (November 2026) and is demanding pay stubs all the way back from 2011–2013.
The Current Roadblock—SSA Is Refusing to Give Me My Own Records:
To prove my actual entitlement history, when my Title II started/terminated/reinstated, and how they are counting my TWP months and IRWEs, I desperately need my Benefits Planning Query (BPQY), Master Beneficiary Record (MBR), and Supplemental Security Record (SSR).
Here is the wall of misinformation I’ve hit this week:
In-Person Refusal #1 (Wednesday): I went to my local SSA field office and asked for my BPQY, MBR, and SSR under the Privacy Act. The rep ("Lionel") flatly refused.
In-Person Refusal #2 (Today, Friday): I went back, got the exact same rep, and requested my BPQY, MBR, and SSR again under the Privacy Act (POMS GN 03340.001). He refused a second time, claiming SSA "does not give that information out," and the only thing he would give me was Form SSA-7050 (for paid certified IRS wage records, not benefit records). When I asked for a written explanation of the refusal (required under POMS GN 03301.045), he refused to give me that too.
After I left I called the national 800-number right after leaving, and the phone agent backed up the field office rep, claiming I have to file a **Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)**request to get my own records (even though first-party requests fall under the Privacy Act, and POMS DI 55005.005 says reps can mail a BPQY upon request).
This is on top of months of contradictory misinformation from SSA staff regarding my claims and appointments.
What I’m Doing Right Now & What I Need Help With:
I am submitting an electronic Privacy Act request through SSA's central disclosure portal for Systems 60-0090 (MBR) and 60-0103 (SSR) so I can bypass the local office.
I am updating my congressional caseworker (who is already involved in my SSA dispute) to ask their SSA liaison to pull my BPQY, MBR, and SSR directly and flag the local office's repeated Privacy Act violations.
Questions for the Community:
During 2011–2013 my SSI was reduced for earnings, then went back to the full amount when I stopped working while I believe I kept extended Medicare, and then 2–5 years later I started receiving concurrent SSDI and SSI—does that mean my prior Title II ended and later restarted/reinstated, giving me a fresh TWP for 2024 (especially since an SSA rep explicitly told me in May 2024 I was good to use my TWP)?
Even if by chance my Title II didn't restart as a new entitlement in my late 20s, does the four-year rule (administrative finality) prevent SSA from going back over 13 years to reopen and redetermine my 2011–2013 work/TWP months now?
How do I force SSA to properly apply my IRWEs, failed full-time work attempt, surgical medical leave, and their own May 2024 misinformation (or a waiver/expedited reinstatement) so I’m not left with zero income?
What is the fastest way to get my BPQY right now since my local field office and the 800-number are stonewalling me? (Would a local WIPA benefits counselor be able to pull it faster with a signed Form SSA-3288?)