r/Sober • u/HorseFacedDipShit • Jun 25 '23
To all the silent lurkers and active questioners who are wondering “can I drink again”? Some food for thought.
As supportive as this community can be, I’ve found the black and white mindset around permanent abstinence is incredibly unhelpful to anyone struggling. “If you have to ask if you can moderate, you can’t”. “Once you’re a pickle, you can’t go back to a cucumber”. “Alcoholism is a progressive, incurable disease”.
NONE of these statements, we’ll intentioned or not, are founded in facts or science. In fact, a full 60% of people who never receive treatment for problematic drinking are able to eventually moderate their drinking (1).
90% of people who suffer with substance misuse are able to moderate or quit on their own without any treatment. We’ve known this information for decades, yet the second this is brought up many people get incredibly upset or even aggressive.
I know this is a sobriety sub. And I would NEVER suggest to anyone to go back to drinking or using drugs. But there is just so much misinformation in the sobriety community around moderation. Around permanent abstinence, and even the disease classification of addiction. This is an individual journey, and I can’t speak for anyone else on what decision is best for them and their loved ones. There are many amazing reasons to go sober. But being a permanent addict isn’t one of them.
You’ve probably heard lots of people on this sub discuss going back out and “testing the waters” and how they were worse off than before. The thing is, you never hear from the people who went out and didn’t come back. There’s also lots of evidence to suggest that those who receive conventional (12 step) treatment or adhere to its principles are MUCH more likely to be unable to drink moderately than those who do nothing (2).
Addiction medicine is one of the most stunted areas of medicine. We’re basing outcomes and treatments mostly off a 90 year old spiritual self help group. No other area of medicine does this. As always, if it helps you please continue to do whatever it is that is helping you. But to anyone on this sub who is having thoughts about moderating one day, yes, it does happen.
“Correlates of Past-Year Status Among Treated and Untreated Persons with Former Alcohol Dependence: United States, 1992,” by Deborah A. Dawson. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research
Treatment Seeking Populations and Larger Realities,” by Robin Room, in Alcoholism Treatment in Transition,