r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Objective_Back_3563 • Mar 22 '24
Is Zeitgeist the pumpkins last good album?
Let’s all be honest with ourselves, pumpkins 2.0 is shit so when did it all go wrong? What is the pumpkins last good album?
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Objective_Back_3563 • Mar 22 '24
Let’s all be honest with ourselves, pumpkins 2.0 is shit so when did it all go wrong? What is the pumpkins last good album?
r/SmashingPumpkins
•
u/cml5526
•
Mar 23 '25
I'm very early in my transitioning phase (about 2 weeks in) so no hormones or anything for me yet, and yeah, every time I do look in the mirror, it's just a reminder of my body just feeling wrong to me, like clothes that feel too tight. That song helps me feel seen in a way, and I always appreciate it for that.
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/DJBlu-Ray • Dec 06 '23
For a band renown for their guitar sound, I was appalled when I saw them live last year up on stage using digital processors. Had no crunch, no bite, no power. The sonic assault of the Siamese Dream songs was nowhere to be heard.
There's a lot of big bands who still play arenas and big festival who mic their amps and it sounds exponentially better. Not to compare SP to Limp Bizkit, but I saw LB earlier in the year and Wes Borland's amplifier rig and guitar sound blew the Pumpkins away.
Just seems like Billy's lazy, and wants to cash in by doing what's most cost efficient live. They gotta get the amps back up on stage and do things like they used to because this new live sound just ain't it.
Who agrees and disagrees and why?
EDIT: I did a really bad of articulating myself. I found a great post with someone explaining this issue in a technical manner and in a way that I wasn't able to articulate. To understand what I was trying to express, read the post here:
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/alephnull2005 • Nov 18 '22
It's so strange to see how many people actually hang around this band's subreddit that profess to absolutely hate what SP is today.
People are literally saying things like "I couldn't get through the entire song." and "I've listened to it once and will never listen again."
Do these people think they sound cool? Do they think that this is some really hip statement to make? It sounds idiotic.
And they will continue to post here, saying the same things over and over: Billy sounds horrible, he can't write a good song anymore, the production is garbage.
They said the same exact things about Cyr, about Cotillions, Shiny, Ogilala, Monuments, Oceania, Teargarden, Zeitgeist, Future Embrace, Zwan, Machina, Adore...
When I hear a bad album or two from a band I like, I lose interest.
I couldn't tell you what the past five Nine Inch Nails or Foo Fighters albums sound like.
I couldn't tell you if bands like Third Eye Blind or Smash Mouth are still putting out records, because I do not care.
I do not care to waste my time with music that does not interest me or with artists that I do not like any more.
So what is it?
I understand some people are obsessed with the past and just plain mentality unwell.
But it got me wondering, why do so many people continue to comment on this band when they seemingly cannot stand their music for so many years?
Why do so many people spend endless hours reading about, listening to and commenting on a band that they have no interest in and find no the redeeming qualities in their music?
So maybe there are evil forces working against this band. Maybe there are evil entities trying to exert this weird negative influence about everything Billy/SP does.
Who pays you to troll the Smashing Pumpkins?
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Tranquil-Seas • Dec 23 '23
Just my opinion: Listen, I dont believe there are many songwriters that have had the kind of unique talent Kurt had. John Lennon is one. Billy Corgan is not one in my opinion (and that’s okay).
Billy: what an incredible songwriter he is. Why is he so determined to convince people that he was writing music and lyrics of Nirvana quality. Of all the things to share with the world, why does he always have to mention that Kurt was his rival.
Maybe they were when it came to Courtney, not with the music.
*Ive been a Corgan fan for over 20 years. His interviews right now make me sad.
Pro-wrestling and Greta Van Fleet. Oh and “I cried when my greatest rival died.” He’s anything but humble. Kurt’s dialogue while being interviewed was of such a humble nature (different person when not sober).
Kurt was the more unique artist without question. I thought Billy understood and respected that. As any great artist would.
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/manudublin2023 • Jul 29 '24
I was listening to MCATIS today and I still would replace 1979 with almost any of the deep cuts off TAFH compilation.
If they released the song for the first time today I wouldn't think of it as a highlight, just a nice song with a great bridge.
I prefer Perfect all the way.
Does anybody else in here feels the way I do?
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/offworldnexus • Nov 05 '25
Hey guys just a heads up, don’t post anything without “substance” or they’ll delete your post and mute you for asking for an explanation. Even though the post was a gem B side and relevant to the Pumpkins.
Hope you guys don’t have a similar experience as me
Peace and love ✌️
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/ryguybeer • Nov 14 '22
I mean seriously, the Pumpkins & Billy have been my favorite artist for decades, but this new music is trash, hot garbage, horrible.
I can't imagine if they actually all got together and recorded an album in person that it would sound like this nonsense. Do the others just let Billy bully thrm i to this shit?
As much as I am frustrated with the sound of the new stuff, I think I might be more upset with Jimmy & James for just going along and cashing the checks.
At least, well I hope, we are at the actual bottom. That Hooray song is the worst thing I've heard in years from any artist.
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/technoxious • Dec 07 '23
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/charlie_clifton • Nov 15 '22
If you guys want something to cry with laughter about today, then listen to the new smashing pumpkins album as it’s just utterly disappointing and terribly hilarious!
Billy corgan has pretty much promised us greatness (promising this whole project to be a true sequel to both Mellon Collie and Machina LPs) and instead made ‘songs’ out of synth fart tones, uninteresting melody structures, almost falling asleep bored vocals and has seemingly locked the rest of the band in the studios cupboard, filling up there contributions with dull drum machines and just out of place solos.
‘Horray!’ Sounds like a circus full of clowns who have been spiked with Xanax and are now trying to do the hokey pokey, it’s fucking absimal yet funnier then anything James Corden has ever said…and it definitely wasn’t intentional.
I really tried to give this thing a chance, I’m a big SP fan and have been listening to them since I was little, with my dad bringing me up on SD, MC and Adore. And to be fair, there is still snippets of greatness shrouded in tracks like ‘Goodbye’ and ‘With Ado’, but it’s being washed over by Billy’s gigantic wave of slobbish song structures, over mixed synths and his own overactive, hyperbolic ego.
Can we please either get back to what Oceania was promising for the future or start from scratch and just make an album out of songs like 99 Floors? Because right now this really is doing the exact opposite of what Billy wants and that is tainting the legacy of this amazing band to the point where they are being labelled a second rate grunge group from the 90s.
1/10, sad fan girl, someone burn down the synth room in the SP Studio.
r/SmashingPumpkins
•
u/sunshiney-daydream
•
Jun 06 '26
Phoebe Bridgers just pulled off a Madison Square Garden show with a complete no phone policy. Her upcoming tour will be as well. Tool also does it for every show that’s not a festival.
What are people’s thoughts on encouraging the band to make this happen on the MCIS 30th fall tour? I think it would make the whole atmosphere a whole lot better and improve the engagement with the experience.
It’s become a big issue the last few years especially and I hope more artists push for this.
Tl;dr: put your phones away and be in the moment
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/kbocatios • Jun 13 '24
I don't wanna sound like an insensitive asshole who has no respect for Billy or his creative mind. But man, I can't be the only one who thinks Atum fucking sucks.
Deepest respect for the band, I love them, absolute once in a lifetime talents, but my god what is this
The singing is annoying, nothing against synthesizers but man, where are the guitars?
The lyrics are dull and nothing special
Shiny And Oh So Bright had some bangers to it but that's about it. I don't like Atum and I would like to know if someone could give me any advice
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/InfiniteRespect4757 • 21d ago
I’m a huge Smashing Pumpkins fan, and I even enjoy Billy Corgan’s interviews. There’s something entertaining about watching someone apparently free of any doubt about his own historical importance. In short clips, the hubris is part of the appeal. Working with him, I suspect, would be a different experience.
But loving the music doesn’t mean accepting Billy’s assessment of its place in history. He wrote some great songs, and made some strong records. I just think there’s a distinction between making great music and fundamentally changing music.
To my ears, the Pumpkins’ greatest achievement was combining existing ideas exceptionally well: heavy metal riffs, psychedelic textures, shoegaze guitars, pop melodies and the ambition of progressive rock. The combination was distinctive, but those ingredients already had a history. Even Corgan has acknowledged My Bloody Valentine’s influence on his sound.
They certainly influenced later bands, including My Chemical Romance. But I’m less convinced by the idea that they represented some unprecedented musical revolution.
Billy’s songwriting doesn’t need that argument to stand up. He made records I still love decades later. That’s an enormous achievement without having to cast himself as the man who reinvented rock.
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/themasterofstars • Jun 28 '25
Dear Billy,
I'm the guy who ranted a bit earlier today about the price of the new Machina release. Sorry for the things I said when I was angry.
In all sincerity, this is what I wanted to communicate: I would love to see a vinyl and CD release of M1/M2 that doesn't include all the bonus tracks. Something around $100-$125 seems fair. I feel like such a price point would allow those of us who bought Machina on the day of its original release (or some other time in the last 25 years) but now have kids, mortgages, and a host of other financial priorities to continue to support a project and a piece of art that we cherish.
I believe that there is an important relationship between an artist and their audience. Some of us can get a little feisty at times, but let's be honest: So can you. Finally putting out Machina 2 as a physical release, but charging $325 for it felt like a bit of a gut punch.
I hope you understand my concern and will consider my suggestions.
Sorry again about the rant.
With every light,
A longtime fan from AZ
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/CahuengaFrank • Jan 04 '25
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Lucpip • Apr 16 '25
She just doesn't embody the SP vibe for me, sorry. She's giving Pussycat Dolls with a guitar 🤐 her look is just not it for me. I always saw the SP as misfits/weirdos and she's far from that.
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/HasidicJamalGinsburg • Jul 31 '23
****EDIT**** - I appreciate all the responses. Seems like a very mixed bag. I was just curious how people felt in comparison to my own feelings. Im not bantering here anymore, my fingers are about to fall off. Be well! Long Live The Mighty SP
****2nd Edit**** - 50% upvote rate, around 60/40 positive/negative comments. Lots of conversations good and tense. Seems the fanbase is extremely divided. Thats how I feel, and wanted to verify by posting my opinion and starting a conversation. Even though this is a super small sample size of an obviously very large fan base, I think the point is clear. Well, many points are clear - not just based off of any one person's (including my) opinion or viewpoint. Cheers everyone, be well and God Bless.
Im not trying to make a negativity fest, just open and honest. The band/members don't really seem to be tackling anything new and challenging any more, Im just not feeling it.
WPC is the spokesman (per usual) and every interview regarding tours, new records, his podcast etc, always devolve into a sobfest of every thing wrong that has been done to him since 1982, and how it inspired him to write great songs to say F You to those who did wrong. The horse is beaten deader than dead. Jimmy barely chimes in but its usually just a 5 minute window into his kind view of their inner dynamic. James is a mute. Jeff is still not allowed to speak.
They sound good live, but their general disinterest in anything other than taking our money now more than ever - is so beyond apparent and constantly thrown in our face. Whether it be via email/this new social media presence/tiktok etc. Expensive ZUZU preorders, with $15 media mail shipping. Frankly, its sickening.
Atum was okay-ish, I guess.......I like 5-6 songs (and everyone seems to like a diff batch of 5-6 songs). Cyr too.
Their recent tours generally have been mostly greatest hits at big venues (15k plus) with other somewhat "big-ish" bands = draw in more ticket sales to split profits. They are now a high ticket priced, hawking expensive and weird merch, and nostalgia draw - which has this insanely weird and narcissistic and confrontational, and antagonistic "tiktok-esque" social media presence to try and "engage" new younger fans. The social media manager is basically an extension of WPC, all of the things mentioned above. Not surprised he is perfectly fine with alienating older fans, and just trying to wrangle in new blood - and their check books.
To me everything that the band represented and drew me in, has been thrown out the window, and thrown in my face. Some days it really does bum me out, and other days its just comical.
Coming from a "diehard" for several decades, I think my fandom has morphed into purely a nostalgic format, with a general disdain for the band and its current state as a whole. The downward trend, and new "presence" and cast of characters (these "superfans", social media lady, etc) have been nothing but off putting and slowly sucked the life out what goodwill I had left for the institution.
Dont even get me started on WPC
They are still "rocking" - but this seems like a cycle that has been repetitive over the past 5-6 years, and will continue until one of the core 3 dies, or they hang it up.
Thoughts?
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Pspreviewer100 • Feb 01 '23
I have no idea how Billy can be okay with the way things are right now. It sounds literally like the latest Taylor Swift album. Not even joking, create a playlist with her latest songs and Atum and you'll see exactly what I mean.
I want to enjoy their latest work but it's almost unlistenable at times... Cyr had similar production but it kinda worked, it wasn't as polished.
If I had to visualize it, SPs recent sound is the equivalent of a perfectly smooth sphere.
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/oofio65 • Dec 03 '23
One of the worst pumpkin songs imo
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Davidtheborty • Apr 22 '26
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/lucastrian11 • Oct 10 '20
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Agreeable-Ice-8367 • Oct 13 '26
Enough said. Give your thoughts on ATUM in the comments 😁
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/[deleted] • Nov 09 '21
Unlike most people here who make a whole lot of "how much did they do", Billy's humble af. We all know it's his image that is "bad", but yeah he's got so much integrity and honesty. Like he said d'arcy's strong and the moral conscious, and James is sensitive and sweet. He answered to that that he keeps those people in the band because of the dynamic. He's a mixture of honest and high integrity he is not egotistic bloody hell. He's explained why he "brags" sometimes.
. I love them all in the studio. The guy is probably the best musicians (in history).For me it's true that I love the dynamic between them and can't imagine anyone else being in the band and I do think james' "solo album" sucked, but who cares, I love how he works in their dynamic.
Billy is honest, straightforward and a very fair person. He's not judgmental about others, (apart from trying to lift others up through advice) and very caring.he just wants to lift James up, he's honest, he didn't mock James for his solo. D'Arcy, I love her but Billy gets way too much backlash. I consider Billy to be be less egotistic and more moral than D'Arcy.
r/SmashingPumpkins • u/MexicanPale • Sep 30 '25
The Machina Deluxe Boxet was supposed to ship 25 days ago. By then, they say we will get it by the end of September. Where is it? I don't even got the shipping mail most of you received. I don't care if they're a small business, they should know better.
If Madame Zuzu's cared about their customers, the world would be a better place to live. You're tearing me apart, Billy!
Jokes aside, I'm a about to say fuck it and refuse to pay customs so it goes back. Eventually. When and if it reaches my country.