Let me explain.
When people think of Slenderman nowadays, they already have a pretty well-defined image of the character in mind. And for good reason. If you look back at his origins, you'll notice that many of the things associated with Slenderman are tropes that have since become popular among other monsters. And while he certainly wasn't the first to use them, he was the one who brought together enough of these elements that nowadays, whenever you see a tall, lanky humanoid silhouette, you immediately think of Slenderman. Whenever you see a figure made of roots or tentacles, falling apart while retaining a vague humanoid shape, you think of Slenderman. Or whenever you see someone wearing a suit, with no face, moving around like a mannequin, you think of Slenderman.
TV Tropes mentions under its "Trope Codifier" entry that Slenderman's mythology was what codified internet mythology. And that's not an unreasonable claim. Despite being roughly contemporary with other sites and communities such as the SCP Foundation and the Holders, neither of them spread quite as rapidly as Slenderman did. Even so, I find it difficult to give him that distinction without some reservations, because if you think about it, only the first few weeksāor I'd even say the first few daysāfollowing Slenderman's creation were truly imprinted on popular culture.
Let's go through things chronologically so I can explain what I mean.
First, we have the original posts made by Victor Surge, the person who created Slenderman and his original story. One interesting thing we can observe is that the creature manifests in a variety of different ways, to the point where, at one moment, the protagonist (if we follow the storyline Victor Surge posted on DeviantArt) wonders whether Slenderman adapts himself to people or simply adapts to whatever situation he needs to deal with.
This is where we get many famous images and ideas: Slenderman with a face, Slenderman with spider-like legs, multiple arms, the idea that he impales his victims on trees and replaces their organs with the trees themselves, placing them inside plastic bags. The idea of him being a territorial, tulpa-like creature that spreads through people's minds. And even a vague version of the idea of proxies, despite Victor Surge denying that interpretation with the first image, which implies that Slenderman forced a group of children to commit terrible acts.
Then we have all the things other users added over time. Short stories and concepts that, whether we like it or not, ended up having an impact on the internet in one way or another.
Some examples include the story of a college student whose disappearance was associated with a gigantic handprint found on her window. The images suggesting that Slenderman had appeared throughout history, including during medieval times, under different names. And even the later interpretation that connected the character to fire.
But this is where we need to stop for a moment.
Many other things associated with the character are no longer remembered as well. For example, at one point, the forums expanded to an absolutely insane degree, and I'm not even joking when I say that Slenderman was supposedly worshipped by the Aztecs. He was responsible for the Dyatlov Pass incident, the breakup of Led Zeppelin, and had even fought against a gigantic army of people equipped with tanks and all that.
While this isn't entirely disconnected from Victor Surge's original canonāhe himself mentioned, or at least hinted at, the existence of an organization attempting to hunt Slenderman, only to failāit was still quite a huge leap. To the point that if we visit the Villains Wiki and look at Slenderman's entry under his original creepypasta incarnation, we'll find that he even has quotes. Actual quotes in which Slenderman speaks, despite the original version explicitly describing him as a creature that doesn't talk and only produces noises. Now let's move on to Marble Hornets, which premiered ten days after Slenderman's creation. Although it's a little difficult to distinguish exactly what came from where, the series certainly has its own merits.
For one thing, Marble Hornets helped establish the idea of Slenderman as a stalker. This might sound strange, but the original images simply implied that someone had captured something they weren't supposed to see, or something nobody had noticed until it was too late. Marble Hornets, on the other hand, introduced the idea that this creature was actively stalking people, appearing in the background and standing perfectly still for extended periods of time.
This was different from the original images, which even suggested that the creature could move at the speed of light.
Then, of course, there were the camera glitches, something that eventually became a staple of the character. And even though they technically weren't proxies, the theory that Masky and Hoodie were proxies became so widespread within the fandom at the time that it eventually helped spawn an entire subcommunity within the creepypasta fandom, giving rise to characters such as Ticci Toby. And, of course, how could we forget the Operator Symbol? The circle with an X inside it, which many people now simply use as the proxy symbol.
Now let's make a time jump to the present.
Think about how many people lost their minds when the 2018 movie came out, claiming that it was a terrible representation of Slenderman. And, of course, it wasāat least when judged against the version of the character that had developed through all the lore the community had created over the years.
Similarly, when Slenderman was announced for Fortnite, people were more curious about whether he was actually Slenderman or the Operator, largely because of how he was presented in the trailers. The creature was portrayed almost like an Operator, without even taking center stage or showing any tentacles. It wasn't until the game was released that the tentacles were added as an extra layer to his design. All of this gives us a fairly general picture of what Slenderman is supposed to be. At least enough for people to recognize how the character is generally expected to behave.
Now let's move on to the Slenderverse. And by the Slenderverse, I'm referring to the blogs and web series that came after Marble Hornets and Just Another Fool. While it's true that the earlier series already played around with the idea of Slenderman's expanded lore from the forums, there was also this tendency for every series to do whatever it wanted with the character.
Which, well, is understandable.
Even back then, people pointed out that crossovers weren't supposed to be taken literally or seriously. They were simply cameos, and weren't actually meant to signify anything. This is something I strongly disagree with, because you can't watch TribeTwelve without understanding at least what the hell the Dark Harvest Order or Habit from EverymanHYBRID are. But beyond that, the truth is that Slenderman himself hasn't adopted many elements from those interpretations.
Not only because most of those series never went as viral as Marble Hornets did back in the day, but also because, despite the many interpretations and additions that appeared across different seriesāsome of which became popular enough to spread into other series and even outside the Slenderverse itselfānone of them really changed the character. Slenderman is still a creature that stalks people, kidnaps children, has tentacle-like appendages (depending on the author), has no face, wears a suit, spreads like a mental virus, and is territorial. At first glance, it might seem like all these series respect that basic concept, but that's not really the case.
Dark Harvest presents him as a fourth-dimensional entity that can be summoned through a cult.
TribeTwelve gives him a true form resembling a gigantic spider.
Stan Frederick incorporates plenty of concepts related to the multiverse, while its sister series, Red Red Hat, portrays him as some sort of manifestation that can be controlled if you stop being afraid of him, somewhat following Stan Frederick's interpretation.
The only time Slenderman's mythology has really changed againāand that change has remained in the public consciousnessāhas been through the video game Slender: The Arrival. And I'm not talking about the original 2014 version, but the modern remastered version, which includes things such as Charlie's story and a more prominent use of proxies. To the point that this version even replaced the TribeTwelve symbol that appeared in the original game's secret ending with the Operator Symbol. All of this got me thinking: why is that? The Slenderverse is often described as a turning point in internet culture, with many people claiming that we wouldn't have the enormous number of ARGs and web series we have today without it. And honestly, none of the explanations I've encountered have fully satisfied me.
My best guess is that it simply comes down to popularity. Some things become more well-known than others, and therefore become more visible and influential. But then I remember Morley Grove, the series created by the creator of Gemini Home Entertainment. And I honestly don't know whether that series got lucky because it was made by the creator of Gemini Home Entertainment, or because it featured Slenderman.
On the other hand, there's one small additional point I'd like to bring up, almost as a footnote.
I've noticed that certain parts of the Slenderverse community can be surprisingly protective of it, to the point that I've encountered people arguing that Slenderman isn't even a creepypasta. And that makes me wonder: how the hell do you even arrive at that conclusion? I don't know. It's just an observation based on one or two encounters that could have been coincidences, but now I've come across it four times.