We Shouldn't Be Here recently contacted us regarding his placement on The Black List. The conversation went south despite us attempting to work things out with him.
He recently released the following video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kL20lYf8QdI
EDIT: We Shouldn't Be Here removed the video.
Claims have been made that we threatened him and supposedly advising that we would shut his channel down - anyone who knows and understands YouTube knows that we don't have that power.
In response to his ridiculous claims, we are now releasing the following communications that took place leading up to WSBH's release of his video:
u/we-shouldnt-be-here•12 hours agoQuoteReport
Hey. It was brought to my attention the issue with me using let’s not meet stories. I just wanted to say a few things. First off, my name is Greg. Second, I’m sorry. When I started narrating, I was told you didn’t need permission to use lets not meet stories. Only nosleep stories you needed permission for. So that’s what I did. I just narrated let’s not meet stories only so that way I’d never get in trouble. But a few authors have contacted me and we have spoken about this and they basically showed me how it’s wrong to use stories without their permission. I feel bad now. I told them that I would credit them and never use stories without permission again. Which I won’t. And you can monitor my channel to keep me true to my word. And they were happy that I’ve learned my lessons. I’m more than willing to credit any author that sends me their story link and username. I never meant to offend anyone. I know what I did was wrong now. I hope to hear back from you and have a conversation about this. Again, I’m done. No more permissionless stories. Ever. And to be honest, the other night I spent 4 hours narrating 20 new let’s not meet stories for a new video. After this situation had gotten brought up, I went home and I deleted all that hard work that I did. Along with all my old stories I saved on my computer. I’m trying to do right.
u/cmd102•4 hours ago
Hi, Greg! Firstly, we're so happy to hear that you've learned the right way to do things and are willing to make necessary corrections. A lot of people who wind up on our radar do not get there under any sort of malice, but rather by misunderstanding the necessary processes.
If you're interested, there is a way for you to be removed from the Black List. We do a 90 day evaluation. In the first 30 days you would need to contact the authors of the stories you currently feature on your channel for permission, remove any videos you do not obtain permission to keep up, and properly credit those authors on the videos that you obtain permission to use. Over the remainder of the probation, you would just need to ensure that you continue only narrating stories you have permission to use and properly crediting authors. Once the evaluation ends, if everything proves to be properly handled, we'll remove you from the list!
If you're interested in doing the evaluation, let us know. We'll send you the official rundown, have you officially confirm that you want to do it, and then proceed from there!
u/we-shouldnt-be-here•3 hours ago
I’m more than willing to do a 90 day probation period and be monitored and all that Jazz. It’s kind of what I understand that I have to endure for my actions. But I’ll be completely honest. I literally do not have the time in a day to contact every author of every story I’ve ever used. To contact that many people and find those stories, is unrealistic for me. I have 2 babies and a full time job where I work overtime weekly. But what I can do, is completely correct anything I can for any author that reaches out to me. I will gladly credit them for any story I’ve used. As long as it’s brought to my attention, I can gladly correct it. I hope you know that you have my word that from this point forward, I’ll never use a story again without permission. And I hope by my sincerity, that you can take me off that list in time.
u/cmd102•2 hours agoQuoteReport
But I’ll be completely honest. I literally do not have the time in a day to contact every author of every story I’ve ever used. To contact that many people and find those stories, is unrealistic for me.
We understand you wouldn't have time in a day, that's why we give you 30 days to do it. The alternative would be to delete - not private, delete - any videos that contain stories you do not have permission to have on your channel.
But what I can do, is completely correct anything I can for any author that reaches out to me. I will gladly credit them for any story I’ve used. As long as it’s brought to my attention, I can gladly correct it.
Not to come off as shrewd, but that's not how this works. By having these stories on your channel, you are violating copyright law. The onus is on you to contact the authors, not the other way around. Many people whose story has been shared without permission will not contact you and politely ask for credit. They'll file DMCA strikes and you'll lose your channel. We're trying to help you prevent that from happening, but you have to be willing to put in the work.
I hope you know that you have my word that from this point forward, I’ll never use a story again without permission. And I hope by my sincerity, that you can take me off that list in time.
Again, we are absolutely thrilled that you have decided to change your ways, but the only way to get off the list is to go through the evaluation.
Let us know what you decide!
u/we-shouldnt-be-here•2 hours agoQuoteReport
Ok. I will do my best to contact the authors
u/MTFSleeplessWatch•2 hours agoQuote
Very well, we just need you to provide your consent to the following and we can begin:
We Shouldn't Be Here,
Thank you for reaching out to us to take on the 90 Day Evaluation. For starters, please make sure you read our guide on the Do’s and Don’ts of the 90 Day Evaluation:
https://old.reddit.com/r/SleeplessWatchdogs/wiki/dosanddonts
To recap the following points:
1.) Please bear in mind that once the 90 Day Evaluation begins, we cannot stop it for any reason!
2.) During the first 30 days of the evaluation, you may set videos containing stories taken without permission to private so that you can reach out to the respective authors and ask for retro permission. Please be advised, if after 30 days you failed to obtain retro permission for any of the stories then you must do the following.: · For single videos containing single stolen stories, they must be deleted, no exceptions. · If you have any stories taken without consent that are part of a compilation video, and it’s among other stories where you did obtain permission, you will have to use the YouTube Studio Editor to cut out the sections containing the stolen story, or stories.
After the 30 day period is up, we will definitely be checking to make sure that the videos you have left were used with permission, or retro permission and you haven’t set any videos to private. 3.) After your 90 Day Evaluation period is up, we will check on all videos on your channel to ensure that permission was obtained. This does not only include videos you uploaded during the 90 Day Evaluation, any and all of your videos are subjected to review. 4.) Failure or refusal to comply or cooperate at any time during the evaluation will result in a fail, and depending on circumstances, may result in you being marked as a Legacy Entry. 5.) If you are already in the process of trying to sell your account, you do not qualify for the 90 Day Evaluation. If you’re discovered to be attempting to sell your account during your evaluation, your assessment will immediately end as a fail. By providing us with your consent, you confirm that you have read all guidelines provided for the 90 Day Evaluation. If you would like to ask questions first, now is the time. But, once you provide us with consent, you are agreeing to all of the above. We look forward to hearing back from you. r/SleeplessWatchdogs.
u/we-shouldnt-be-here•an hour agoQuoteReport
So check this out you fuckin douche bags. I went and deleted ALL MY VIDEOS that I didn’t have permission for. Now you have NOTHING on me. And no I didn’t put them in private. I deleted them. I want you to know something. I didn’t hurt ANYONE by reading those stories. But by you making this BS list, and basically forcing me to delete my videos, you actually hurt me. You took money away from my kids. Good and clothes away from them. I support my wife who has a mental condition with youtube. So I hope you’re feeling happy and satisfied.
u/we-shouldnt-be-here•36 minutes agoQuoteReport
And by the way, that picture of my channel that you posted on here, is MY FUCKING PROPERTY. I own that image and you used it without my permission. You fuckin hypocrites. Take it down IMMEDIATELY or I will report you.
(NOTE: He is referring to the fact that reddit mobile provides preview images of whatever URL is being posted)
u/cmd102•14 minutes agoQuoteReport
We told you deleting the videos was one option. You had 30 days to make the attempt to gain permission for the videos. It's not our fault that you chose the easy way out.
You will not blame us for your mistakes. You may not have hurt anyone by stealing content, but you may have. You stole stories from a support subreddit where people share traumatic events and put them on YouTube for everyone to see without the permission of the person who actually experienced the event. Btw what you did was expressly illegal, and I'm sure a lawsuit would have taken more money from your family.
You don't get to come in here blaming us and calling us names because YOU WERE WRONG*. We tried to work with you. We were 100% pleasant in our interactions, despite your attempt to skirt policy and get the easy way out from the get-go.*
Also, we're not hosting any images of yours. Reddit shows a page preview when a post contains a link.
We're done here. We do not tolerate mod abuse, so you'll be banned, and since you're so uncivil and uncooperative, your 90 day eval has been cancelled and you have been given Legacy status on the Black List.
Have a good day.