I am neurodivergent and a writer with a passion for history, mythology, comparative religions, and art....I have a penchant for deep dives into research on topics I love in particular....and ST is one of them.
Recently, I have been going through a rough patch with my mental and physical health, as well as really trying to get my act together as an adult person. I've also been on a manic, creative kick where I've been drawing again. I posted up in another sub, a drawing that I am building on, containing the many symbolic objects found in ST song lyrics as well as the entire aesthetics of the band. It's a WIP.
Every time I am working at creating art or cleaning, organizing, I need music to help drive my inspiration. Lately, I've been setting my playlist to the entirety of ST's available music and while I was in the middle of listening to Higher, I felt like I just had to post in another sub on how the lyrics blew me away. A discourse began on the interchange between the spectrum and colors Scarlet versus Ultraviolet.
My ADHD brain began to descend into the abyss, so to speak, and I landed on a theory that makes so much sense to me overall that I can't shake it. I feel like I need to discuss it with other fans who can either support or bring up their own theories....I welcome it all.
CAIN.
Yes, the Biblical Cain. I think the persona of Vessel is Cain. Here is where I build my evidence into theory:
PART I
Starting with the visual aesthetics of Vessel himself. You have a human shaped entity wearing a mask with six "eyes" of sorts, that is adorned with a progressively more elaborate filigree at the edges, "fanged" points around the mouth, and in the center, the ST logo that seems to incorporate wings, a sun setting or "sundowning," or a moon rising, along with what looks to be a halo or corona of some sort. This is a more elaborate and sleekly defined mask in contrast to the original mask that seemed more shapeless, hand formed (like clay) to carved bone with a different marking in the center as well as concealment of the mouth, that then opens and gradually becomes more accented and elaborate over time to accentuate his very expressive mouth.
Then, he wears a hooded cover-up/coat that began, like the mask, more simple and formless, progressively becoming more elaborate with each album and tour. That cover-up started out just a black linen robe in tatters but has since come with a bit of a mantle of wool/fur, now black feathers. A hooded robe meant to conceal movement, form, shape. Plus the added left shoulder pauldron that moves from included objects you might see on the floor of the ocean to jewels, leather, precious metals, filigreed armor. Chains and dangling rope like elements now.
Next, his chest, arms, and hands. He paints himself black in every visible area as another form of concealment. He also began as a thin, lean, tall figure but has since developed muscle, sinew, definition....as if preparing or honing himself for battle. At each concert, that paint, with sweat and movement as well as touches, rubs or melts off of his body. He wears various chains that tangle and entwine around his neck and over his chest with pendants and more symbols. He wears rings on his very expressive, graceful fingers.
The pants or trousers are still rather simple black....a bit baggy, allowing for plenty of his ragdoll dance movements and a simple black belt. Almost suggesting that, like his identity, his lower half is not nearly as important as what is on the upper half....or that the lower half of him is more simple, Earthly, and earthy. But there has been the addition of poleyns and greaves that are "bound" or wraps around each leg to show that however elaborate, ethereal, celestial or lofty the upper half of his body is, the lower half is still bound to the Earth and corporeal, tangible.
Moving to his feet, I noticed in some early performances, he would sometimes be barefoot. Just painted in black. Then moving to simple footwear that accented the shape of his feet to suggest that they were still bare. Now we have split toed Tabi shoes that resemble bare feet again....or cloven hooves. You can also fall down another rabbit hole regarding Tabi socks and shoes regarding origins and the benefits but in short, Tageta was straps on wood then Zori was woven straw and initially, Tabi socks were made of leather to help keep the feet warm in winter. All of this also suggesting a literal connection to the Earth and remaining grounded.
How does his appearance fit into my theory that he is Cain?
Well.... in texts and various interpretations of the legend, Cain is a farmer, a cultavist who sows the land for growing crops, the fruits of the earth. Wheras Abel is a Pastoralist, herder, rancher, raising animals and more specifically sheep that play a significant symbolic role in many mythologies but in this case, Judaism. Cain murders his brother out of jealousy and fury for a few reasons but mainly because of his fruits of the earth offering disregarded by God in favor of Abel's blood and meat sacrificial offering of a first born lamb. God finds out and curses Cain to walk the Earth but never again to reap benefit from the constant blood-soaked ground he treads. Cain complains that God's punishment is too harsh and that other humans will try to kill him. So God places a mark upon his brow that shows blatantly he is cursed but whomever amongst men would seek to strike him down, would receive the sevenfold fury of God. This assures that Cain will walk the Earth untouched by man. Vessel's mask bears that mark right in the center over his third eye and is plainly visible. The earlier marking suggests something more serpentine in shape with good reason. Another legend claims that Cain is not the son of Adam and Eve but the product of Eve having lain with the Serpent from Eden or Samael or the earthly embodiment of Lucifer, the Devil, a fallen angel also cast out of Paradise/Heaven to a subterranean realm because of his arrogance, insolence, and rebellion. If this story is included in ST lore, then Cain is technically a Nephilim. Half angel, half human. Lucifer's wings burn and turn black in the Fall and his Hell is beneath the Earth's surface, in darkness and shadow, never to look upon the face of God or his Favour again. It is the same with Cain and The Land of Nod. In some more modern depictions, the Mark of Cain isn't simply his face or brow, it is that his entire body and Earthly form (shaped and molded from the clay of the Earth) is painted or covered in black. This ties in with the mask, the body paint, and the shroud he wears to keep Vessel in mystery, shrouded in shadow, concealing his movements and identity while giving high contrast to the warning signs of his cursed mark. His "shroud" or robe has black feathers on the back and shoulders. The symbol of something once celestial and heavenly....an angel pulled down, descended into earth and ash, burned. The pauldron a symbol of his preparing for war and defense on the left. Southpaws (I'm left-handed so I know how people who are dominant in their left hands are historically viewed) and the direction of Left indicating evil, unfavorable to God, demonic. Possibly alluding to Legion, warriors gathering to fight God and open up the Heavens to them again, possibly take over and rule. Also considered highly artistic and creative, intellectual, rebellious, going against standards....yet life in general is harder for the Left in a world largely created for and disciplined for the Right. Favorable to God. The chains and pendants around his neck, on his bare chest and the circlets on his fingers suggest being bound, held down, restrained, in fidelity to something....perhaps a concept, creed, another person or entity. A kind of slavery or servitude in chains. Some of it willing, possibly more unwilling but all of it in metals and stones pulled from the Earth, keeping him grounded. Then his "bare" feet. Again, the connection to the ephemeral, the ground. Reminding him always of where Vessel/Cain is forced to tread. Possibly also cloven feet, depicting something more animalistic or demonic.
After taking a look at his costumes, we can move briefly to his vocals. A voice that can move between the lowest gutural screams and primal, animal-sounding growls to soaring, ethereal octaves that seem pure, poignet and sweet, full of longing. Sometimes, technology enhances by either turning the voice into something dark, dangerous, animalistic or even demonic....to light, warm, welcoming, celestial, peaceful, pure...full of grace. All of it still commanding presence and demanding pause in the booming echoes and layers of his voices and sounds.
Next, we can take a look at instruments. Strings, percussion, woodwind, electronic. Now, I am not a musician and cannot read music, or feel I'm qualified to break down the physical structure or technological aspect of instruments....how everything is pieced together in such a way but I do know that we have all these elements combining together to create their distinctive sound. Stringed instruments harken back to instruments like harps and lyres. Percussion to drums vibrations in soundwaves. Woodwind to flutes and pipes requiring the passage of air to create sound. Electronic to the keyboard that can create synthetic elements of sound, echoes, layers or simple keys. A focus of interest would be on the music box sound used in Caramel specifically....an automated instrument that plays tuned "teeth" on carefully designed and predetermined barrel shaped steel comb. Repetitive and unchanging. Also, cyclical, never-ending until the controller seeks to end it or it winds down and runs out of inertia/energy. II has a background in Gospel music and drumming. Telling. Hinting.
These sounds, whether the voice as instrument or the rest of the physical instruments suggest everything from that cursed earth Cain is bound to and forced to tread, to him seeking absolution, forgiveness, peace, freedom in the skies and Heavens above. A combination of the earthen human animal and deity....demon, angel, god.
We have colour and shades, gradients. Moving from black and white, right and wrong, good and evil....or neutral to more visceral, earthen colours like reds for blood, warning, danger, hunger to blues for water, oceans, drowning, suffocation, mystery, erosion when water combines with air and earth, also indicating the ephemeral space on Earth that we know less about than the Heavens and space. The deepest trenches into the heart of the planet that are full of volatile elements and seemingly barren....a wasteland, yet there is life there. Seemingly monstrous, alien, terrifying. Water, capable of such violent destruction and the red if blood, is the water of life. All that makes us possible. You could also say that unoxygentated blood is blue whereas oxygenated blood is red. Then we move onto green and golds. Symbols of prosperity, wealth, abundance, life, plenty, plants, fruit, rebirth....but also a fairly high melting point. Green wood has a harder time catching fire and burning. Gold needs a higher temperature to melt from a solid into a liquid. Still, all of this rooted in the earth whether barren and the absence of life or fruitful, plentiful, full of life. Importantly noting that beneath all these changes in colours, shades, gradients, and elements, Vessel/Cain is still painted black and in shadow, concealed and removed from it all.
If there seems to be enough interest in my theory, I am more than happy to dive into the second part; ST lore, the lyrics, art, and how nearly every song (except perhaps the song covers), plays into it all. I'm certain that as fans, you can make your own connections and theories as to who Vessel really is and as I said before, I welcome discourse but for now, on this particular post, I'd ask if we could keep it narrowed down for the moment to the aesthetics like the costuming, vocals, instruments, please? (I know, this being Reddit, that it will probably not remain just about the aspects I mused over here but can't blame me for trying, right? LOL!)
If the lore and lyrical theory is wanted, I can make another post for the next part or talk in the replies about it.
Thank you, ultimately, for letting me post my diatribe speech here. 😀
And as always, remember....
Worship. You are so loved.