r/SkarnerMains • u/NiceCircBro • Feb 24 '24
r/SkarnerMains • u/PunAboutBeingTrans • Mar 19 '24
RIP Skarner, the last bastion of a fun game
I fully expected to be disappointed by the rework, and somehow I'm even more depressed about it than I thought I would be.
I don't know why Riot is so determined to remove player agency from their game, but I think they've finally accomplished it.
I've been playing League since S2, and Skarner was the last of a long line of champions I loved because of the same reasons: They can build anything, and they can go fast. First it was Nidalee, where I primarily played AD bruiser splitpush top. The rework gutted that. Then it was Udyr, and the rework + post rework nerfs extremely limited his viable builds and he simply isn't fast anymore. Then it was Evelynn. My absolute favorite champ. Could build 90% of items in the game, could go ultimate bravery and still win. She was all about weird strategies and unexpected plays, knowing my champ better than you do. To say the Evelynn rework killed the champion for me would be a vast understatement. She went from being my all time favorite to a champ I am absolutely miserable trying to play, with exactly 1 build allowed, and too weak early to have any sort of strategy beyond scaling.
And then came Skarner. Finally, a champ that was historically not very good so he was unlikely to get nerfed. A champ with hybrid ratio's that made good use of nearly every possible stat in the game. And he was FUN too. He could go SO fast, his entire kit was giving a big middle finger to whoever the most annoying person on the enemy team was, and running literal circles around them. I felt actually skillful when I won with him, and not because Riot shoved so many bullshit mechanics and dashes and invisibilities into his kit so that you feel cool without actually having to practice. I was playing AP Skarner as early as Season 5, Triforce Protobelt Frozen Heart Gunblade was my old build and it was the first time I really enjoyed grinding ranked, because I was able to do it my way, and play something not many people knew about.
And now he's gone. New Skarner is visually stunning. But gameplay? He's a slow, clunky, boring as shit tank with counterplay forced into his kit. Need a shield? You have to stop moving. Want to suppress someone? They get to use their billion dashes + flash to dodge it. You have one "gap closer" that is just a barely controllable movespeed boost (because juking is just not fair I guess) and if you want to use it for movement, enjoy that 20 second cooldown buddy!
I don't care that the ratio's are "subject to change" as it's incredibly obvious that Riot is trying to force him into the pure tank role. Literally just HP ratios (omg wow they added 1 ap ratio on the ult! Amazing! It doesn't enable ANY different playstyles whatsoever!)
I genuinely don't know who is even left in the game that's not forced into a hyper specific niche. I don't give a shit if there's a million champs if I can't have 1 that can adapt to any situation. I'll probably quit league after this if I'm honest.
The creativity is gone, the cooking is over, and the kitchen is fucking closed. Thanks Riot, hope the new player engagement is worth it.
Rest in Peace Skarner, I loved you.
r/SkarnerMains • u/VG_Crimson • Jan 15 '22
If Skarner wins, he will get deleted from the game and replaced with a different scorpion champ.
Lore and kit will be demolished.
I can't say that is what I want for him. But that is what Riot envisions. Sion and Urgot are neat champs, but they resemble NOTHING like their original kits. They don't mention his name because of the negative associate with reworks, but it really would be like aatrox's deletion if you read what Skarner's VGU text said.
He only needs a different passive and rebalanced stats. Maybe an ASU.
Here is a tamer version of what they could do.
[Seeker's Scuttle]Passive: While not in combat, when standing still you channel into a stance (1.5 s channel) getting ready to pounce. You will mini leap forward and gain 50% - 70% (based on level) move speed and attack speed for 5 seconds before decaying over 2 seconds.
Rebalance:
• Base attack speed and attack speed ratio buffed to feel smoother
• Q AD and AP ratio buffed
• Slight base damage increase on Q
• Mana pool and mana regen buffed
.
.
.
This serves to enhance his playstyle and versatility, gaining ms and attack speed at any point he wants. Can also be used outside of ganking to cross tiny walls or speed up your first camp before it spawns.
r/SkarnerMains • u/StillRutabaga4 • Apr 05 '24
New Skarner is a massive improvement game wise
Clearly an unpopular opinion in this sub. But as someone who spammed skarner and loved his previous kit this kit is not at all bad. The new abilities have opportunity for more in depth skill expression vs just slamming Q after E and sometimes pressing W for shield or speed boost. His ult was totally broken in the last iteration almost a guaranteed kill if the cc chain was done correctly. The spires were fun but a huge pain in the ass at times.
His new abilities have nuance to them and to actually land the combo for his ult you need to plan a bit. His E is a very creative, fun mechanic. His w being a shield with damage is the only boring part of his kit. And his Q is basically two abilities in one.
You just can't play this new champ like the old champ. His old strategies just don't fit with the new kit. I'm having lot of fun. I'm biased towards tank junglers. But just give it a chance!
r/SkarnerMains • u/vvvit • Mar 27 '24
I can't find any interesting with new lore.
The old lore
revenger, hypocrisy of piltover, saving comrade, relating pink bitch and so on.
The new lore
He is just ancient kind monster,,,, I guess? He even doesn't have crystal stuff now.
how is it fair? I still really can't believe just One mobile game tier trash champ completely destroy skarne's lore. Is he deserve this? He is now one of lacking lore content champ like rammus or shaco.
r/SkarnerMains • u/Imaginary-Arm-8836 • Feb 06 '25
Skarner Main since S3 Opinion: New Skarner is just a bad champ design while the old one was versitale and original
Tbh just read the caption.
IMO its quite simple: Only benefit of the new one is - he gets played and is pretty strong. Hot take is:
Give any Champion tons of cc, health scalings and wall hack and he will forever be op. Doesn't matter if its not fun to play this clunky sh*t or how he has absolutly no identity anymore.
I know it's probably the 10.000th "i dislike the rework" hate post but - let's be honest, new Skarner is just designed without any kind of love for the original character
r/SkarnerMains • u/Federals123 • May 10 '24
The Current State of Skarner and Kit Change Suggestions
Ever since Skarner got his rework he has had only one real way to play him, and that is to just go heavy tank. A ton of people tried experimenting with Skarner, trying out different builds and playstyles, but due to his scalings it's actually quite difficult to do anything too different. You can't really build him AP as your only reliable tool for that would be your W damage. You can't really build him as a bruiser either, not because it wouldn't work, but simply because of just how much better his tank build is.
For example: in theory Spear of Shojin should be an amazing item for him as it buffs every single one of his spells and each empowered Q attack gives a stack so he can get it to the full bonus quickly. It has good damage, good health, and the ability haste feels really good on him. Another example would be Titanic Hydra. It gives high health and good damage, and the auto reset can be really good to quickly get your Q hits off, and yet people in high ranks barely do either item because that particular playstyle isn't as rewarded as just straight up rushing Sunfire or stacking up Heartsteel, or going any other tank item first and just kinda hard tanking and outdamaging the opponents due to his scalings. Bruiser items should fit Skarner well and they should have solid synergy, but that's not really the case.
Even some AP item could fit him extremely well if he had the proper scalings for it. Cosmic Drive would be an amazing item to have on Skarner. It gives health, good ability haste, AP, and speed when hitting an ability on a champion. It could be used to have a more ranged playstyle in lane to poke down your laner from afar, dodging skillshots or dipping in and out of their ability ranges, or a speedy playstyle in the jungle. Even something like Riftmaker would be amazing. It gives omnivamp so Skarner uses it even better as he does mixed damage and the health scaling passive, but again, he does not have AP the scalings to back it up.
I mostly play Skarner top lane, and I'd say that his E right now is way too strong. It stops a lot of dashes and the stun duration is way too long. It should not be a 1.5 second stun if you just use it in melee range to quickly pin down an opponent to a wall. It is probably the most frustrating part about Skarner right now. He can pin you to the wall anytime you try to engage on him and then walk it off because the stun duration is so long, not to mention the fact that the wall slam damage is actually very high as well, so his gameplay pattern in lane is to always trade when his q is up, and if you actually get on top of him when he doesn't have it there's a very good chance he will stop your engage, outdamage you in the trade, or straight up do the E+ult combo and drag you under turret.
Currently I do not have a lot of Skarner games, around 50 or so, and the reason I don't play him more is because of how cookie cutter his builds are on top of the same playstyle every game, and I think a lot of people share the same sentiment. Every game the play pattern is the same and the builds leave very little room to change, and I expect it to be the same in the jungle. I have not seen a single Skarner on either my team or the enemy team build anything exept hard tank, and I think Skarner should have a lot of unique playstyles with different builds. If I try to do other builds, like an AP bruiser Skarner, or a mixed damage type Skarner, it just falls flat on its face because his scalings are really bad for it.
I made a list of changes that I think would greatly benefit Skarner in terms of build and playstyle diversity. The goal with these changes isn't to kill tank Skarner, just to make it less reliable and not the default take in every single situation. I'm going to explain my thought process after each ability change and why I think it would be good for him. With all that said, here are the changes I came up with:
Passive (Threads of Vibration):
Skarner's basic attacks, Shattered Earth, Upheaval, and Impale apply a stack of Quaking-> Skarner's basic attacks and abilities apply a stack of Quaking
Magic Damage: 7-10% based on level-> 3-9% (+3.5% AP) based on level
Firstly, I think it's kinda wired that not all of Skarner's abilities apply his passive, and it's even wierder considering the fact that when he uses his W he can say "Feel the threads of vibration.", but doesn't actually apply a stack of the ability literally named "Threads of Vibration". In the jungle his W and E not applying his passive doesn't really matter, but it can make the difference in lane. I heavily nerfed the % health damage early on as it becomes easier to proc the ability in lane and Skarner's jungle clear is quite fast already, not really being reliant on his passive to clear consistently. In a lot of the abilities I change the early game numbers will be nerfed and that's because I think he is way too strong early on so I would like to tone down how powerful he is in the early game and give him better scalings and spikes in the mid to late game. This is the first ability that gets an added AP scaling to it and it especially buffs AP Skarner top. In top lane if you go up against a bruiser or a tank you can keep reapplying your passive, so you can choose to go into an AP style and deal extra % health damage to them.
Q (Shattered Earth/ Upheaval):
Upheaval Damage: 10 / 20 / 30 / 40 / 50 (+ 60% bonus AD) (+ 5% bonus health) (+ 15% of the target's max health)-> 10 / 20 / 30 / 40 / 50 (+ 60% bonus AD) (+ 5% bonus health) (+ 10 / 11/ 12 / 13 / 14% of the target's max health)
This is probably the only change I would make to his Q. I do not think he should have the ability to deal 15% max health damage from level 1, so I made his Q scale up to 14% as you put points in it.
W (Seismic Bastion):
Shield: 8% max health-> 4 / 5 / 6 / 7 / 8% max health (+ 65% AP)
Mana cost: 60 / 65 / 70 / 75 / 80-> 40 / 50 / 60 / 70 / 80
Magic damage: 50 / 70 / 90 / 110 / 130 (+ 80% AP)-> 40 / 55 / 70 / 85 / 100 (+ 80% AP)
Another AP ratio added to Skarner. Now he can actually take ability power items and it would not be bad for him. Once again, a nerf to tank Skarner on the % health shield early on. If he wants to max this first he will lose out on the extra damage on Q, so there is a tradeoff to it, but AP Skarner can use the AP ratio to get a larger shield.
E (Ixtal's Impact):
Cooldown: 20 / 19 / 18 / 17 / 16-> 24 / 22 / 20 / 18 / 16
Physical Damage: 30 / 60 / 90 / 120 / 150 (+ 10% max health)-> from 30 / 60 / 90 / 120 / 150 (+ 8.5% bonus health) (+ 50% AD) up to 60 / 120 / 180 / 240 / 300 (+ 17% bonus health) (+ 100% AD) based on distance traveled before colliding with an enemy
Stun duration: 1.5 seconds-> from 0.75 up to 1.5 seconds based on distance traveled before colliding with an enemy
Cooldown refund upon successful wall hit: 35%-> 35 / 40 / 45 / 50 / 55%
This is the ability I wanted to change most. I will go through all the changes one by one.
First off, the cooldown. In the jungle Skarner doesn't really get a second E off when he ganks, he only has one E usage to engage and that's about it. In lane he almost always has a guaranteed wall hit whenever he uses E, as he can just walk up close to an opponent and then pin them to the wall. This is, in my opinion, the most frustrating part about Skarner's kit as a whole when facing him. The fact that whenever you go in or try to engage on him he always has the option to just pin you to a wall, deal massive damage and then just walk off because the stun duration is so long. If you compare it to Poppy's stun, which also needs a wall to do the stun, it is so much more conditional and difficult to set up. Skarner can walk into melee range of you and instantly spin you around to hit a wall, on top of the fact that the effective range he has when carrying someone is longer. This is why I really wish these particular changes I am suggesting on Skarner's E would be implemented. If the damage and stun duration were to be based on the initial distance traveled and they started off weaker, it would mean you would be rewarded to look for longer range E hits, close to maximum range, and that his annoying stun in top lane is not as bad if they just outright do it in melee range.
I also think this makes sence thematic wise. He ramps up in speed as he charges. If he does it right in melee range of you he will always take you with 650 speed, and if he does it around the end of it he will have a maximum of 1150 speed. I feel like the ability should take into account the speed you have when you hit the enemy and should give you higher damage and a higher stun duration, a lot like how Sion's ultimate works. This gigantic scorpion is charing at you full force, he should deal more damage and stun for longer the more speed he has. Even Rammus has the Q+R combo, where the ult range increases based on his speed which is a good synergy point with his Q. On top of all of this, the reduced stun duration makes it very hard to use your melee E into R to combo get someone under turret, you actually need to have a bit more charge time beforehand so you cannot always reliably hit it.
I also shifted his health ratio into bonus health rather than maximum health, making it weaker in the early game, but if you really want to stack up health it would end up dealing more later on with a full charge. I also added an extra AD ratio on it that should really make AD bruiser Skarner stick much better and actually make an impactful shift in his build. In the jungle you will almost always hit E from max range or at least somewhat charged, as if you just walk up to the enemy they can just back off easily. The AD ratio will offset the loss of of the max health early on, but it still doesn't fully give you the same damage as Skarner's base AD is one of the worst in the game. This also means lane Skarner's point black E damage will be much lower and combined with the less stun duration it means it should fix up his most frustrating aspect by a lot.
The final change I added was the cooldown refund scaling with ability level. This can make it to where Skarner might want to max out this ability second, or perhaps even first. Support Skarner would most likely end up maxing this first for more picks around the map.
R (Impale):
Magic damage: 150 / 250 / 350 (+ 100% AP)-> 100 / 175 / 250 (+ 50% AD) (+ 70% AP)
This would be the only change I would make to his ult. Much like his old ult, I would give it a scaling with both AD and AP ratios and reduce his base damage on it.
Those would be some changes I thought could diversity Skarner's play patterns and build paths. I'm sure the numbers could use some tweaking and they are not all perfect, but I think if they just gave him more AD and AP ratios he could really take off in terms of build and playstyle diversity. If he had all these extra ratios a lot more builds could pop up. Perhaps AP bruiser Skarner would be a thing, or a mixed damage Skarner build could also be decent, or he could get Rod of Ages and not be reliant on Tear to deal with his heavy mana issues in lane, or go into a classic bruiser build with items such as Spear of Shojin and Titanic Hydra. I'm sure there's a lot of other changes they could do and I would love to see your ideas as well and to have a discussion around it all.
In case any of you were curious, this is the account I am currently playing on and my main one if you wanted to check it out:
r/SkarnerMains • u/TrainingAgency6855 • Oct 29 '24
Do you guys think the skarner rework was a nerf?
Well he feels weak now he cant run away like he used to be he cant cc like he used to be and yeah i think skarner rework is the worst rework that riot ever done
r/SkarnerMains • u/lp150189 • Nov 08 '23
I am so sad about skarner rework
I don’t appreciate my lobster boi enough to be honest. Now that I found out about the news they about to gut him, I am so sad. These are the final days I get to enjoy him. Maybe with him gone, I will retire from league for good
r/SkarnerMains • u/BennyBigHands • Aug 04 '24
I really hope they revert his E nerf.
I like playing him top, and I love punishing arrogant fuckhead lane bullies when they try and dive me. The problem is that when they changed the E, instead of grabbing people I'll just go through them.
I understand they wanted to make it so you couldn't just spin grab people, but when I flash behind them, then press E... only to move right through them and get killed because I was one pixel inside of their hit box already?
The character already feels a it underwhelming to play, with the only TRULY fun thing being his CC combos. If you're going to make the combos nearly impossible to pull off(when the enemy has a brain), then why should I even play him? Its like they don't want him to have any player base.
Maybe jungle feels different I dunno.
r/SkarnerMains • u/Alexfernot • May 05 '22
#dontreworkskarner >:(
It will break my hearth :( </3
r/SkarnerMains • u/RainNT_0309 • Mar 19 '24
My problem isnt the concept its the design, its clunky
From what I saw, not only does he look ugly, his gameplay and animation looks clunky and ugly. No offense to the artist but the art design is just boring and ugly to look at, dull color, strange shape, no cool aspects to the champion. And the gameplay looks so rough around the edges, cool concept though but looks terrible, could also be because the art design looks cheap. I've seen fan made concepts reworks that looked better. Like Jack Burke skarner design (shown below).

Honestly if they wanted to give him three tails they could have done that too, but they could have switched up the design to make him look cooler like this guy Jack did (which he did an amazing job btw, check out his work they are amazing). I even reworked the Jack's design to fits closer in line with Riot new Skarner. (shown below)

Isn't a design like this so much cooler????? Better than the boring shape/silhouette that Riot decided to give him. His current design has a small head, small claws, skinny tails, odd shape body which looks a bit too long for that small ass head, claws, and legs. I just think if the objective is to make him more popular and make his kit more modern than Riot current design won't hit the mark. Imo he just looks so boring and ugly no one will play him if he's not overtuned. If hes too strong everyone will play him if he isn't strong, no one will play him cause he's just boring. Its fine to make a champion look ugly, I actually encourage more ugly weird looking champs, but they have to ATLEAST look unique and ugly! Ugly but strange enough to be cool, enough spice for players to want to pick him up and play, not whatever we are about to get.
r/SkarnerMains • u/Quo210 • Apr 21 '24
People complaining about the rework being slow and clunky are missing the point of a REWORK
Reworks are meant to reimagine a character concept up to modern standards. This wasn't a gameplay update that would bring old Skarner some changes, this was a scrap old character and release new one that embodies the concept of the old kind of thing, on the level of Sion and Aatrox reworks.
Old Skarner had no set gameplay identity (Could exist as Tank, Support, Bruiser, Speedy Duelist, AP Bruiser ...) and didn't even classify as one of the 'Classes'.
This re-release sets Skarner as a dedicated Tank/Juggernaut, subset as a health stacker. New champion has more in similar with Dr. Mundo, Sion or Nautilus than he does with his old self.
He is meant to be an lumbering threat that will crush someone if he manages to land his slow abilities. He's also meant to be ungodly difficult to take down but rather easy to engage in group like a raid boss and he has no fast way to catch up someone.
He pays for that much power (Health, CC, Damage) by being unreliable, just like Sion.
If you dislike that type of gameplay I would advice you to move on to another champion. This was the direction they designed the character to be played as and I have no doubt it will be the direction they will push it in the future for balance.
skarner is already overpowered being this unreliable with E/R. Should he be pushed into more reliable territory (Q change made him better in that area) he will be strung with numbers nerfs to justify it
r/SkarnerMains • u/juanlacrapule • Apr 05 '24
New R
Its me or the new r is so bad ? like, the casting time is so slow so there no point on flashing and r, because you cant R flash. And even when you just do it from, if there is no setup its so easely avoidable
r/SkarnerMains • u/MonkayKing • Aug 13 '24
Unstoppable E
I feel like if you gave Skarner an unstoppable in his E. Either partly or fully his kit would work a lot better in fights.
r/SkarnerMains • u/SoulyPlays • Jan 07 '22
DONT VOTE SKARNER
The plans from last year are the same. Vote for another champion
r/SkarnerMains • u/ArmClean4321 • Dec 31 '23
skarner sup

Edit: I should say sorry or smth it was 3am morning baked potato head and when iam looking it rn it wasnt that good how it felt yes i had 0 vision and yes it was trashy but for most i had total fun yes it is troll as hell but viable troll ngl i wouldnt be surprised got baned for that and reason for hullbreaker was simple our nasus was fucked didnt push or smth i had tp and kinda ready to push as normaln laner so i took it to end faster yes my baked mind tought it was good but looking back it wasnt that best as it felt but at least i had fun and yes i will be cooking skar support cos i enjoy of meta to much so sorry to all who will meet me in futer :)

r/SkarnerMains • u/Alejandro_MG • May 21 '24
"I'll play my placement games, surely RIOT will give me reliable teams and balanced matchmaking"
r/SkarnerMains • u/[deleted] • Feb 05 '25
Riot Hates Skarner
Max Mastery Skarner here,
I believe Riot hates Skarner for the following reasons;
Remove his interesting and beautiful Lore linked to his Visuals and replace them with a generic, drab, muted colour patterned jungle monster.
Terrible VGU for skills.
Gut what made Skarner mains love him and replace it for something clunky, low damage/not as tanky.
Completely misses the mark on player reception. (Citation: Reddit, OP.GG polling, LoL discord polling, released data regarding his play, pick, ban rate)
Needlessly nerf him when he currently has a 3.98% Pick Rate / Win rate of 46.9%.
Armor Growth: 4.8 to 4.5
Stun Duration of Ixtal's Impact: 1.5 sec to 1 second.
Riot, I know that you are unlikely to revert Skarner to its previous state for us true mains. But please go the other direction with Skarner and buff, buff, buff our Brackern friend.
Edit: Taking into account the more definitive information for different win/playrates based on Emerald/Diamond, it appears it is slightly higher than all rank averages.
Win Rate for Emerald + / Diamond:
49.33 % - 50.62%
Pick Rate for Emerald + / Diamond:
4.32% - 6%
Ban Rate for Emerald + / Diamond:
13.70% - 23.3%
In terms of the highest ban rate, Skarner ranks number 4, with Wukong, Shaco and Veigo ahead of him.
If you look at this, this is an irregular spike due to his rework not coinciding with his upsurge in pick rate.
Furthermore, Wukong is ahead of him in play/win rate but this patch buffed him? I would love to know the reasoning for this, because it appears to me some semblance of bias.
Let us keep it civil, we all share the commonality of loving our Skarner, let's not be mean to each other. Happy games, Summoners
r/SkarnerMains • u/R-E-Lee • Oct 21 '23
The new model is laughably terrible
Seriously what the hell is this new model? I'm not going to complain about his abilities because it's yet to be seen how well they fare, but the visuals are cringeworthy and ridiculous.
They took almost void-like looking crystalic scorpion and reworked it into a pathetic creature with three(?????????????????) stingers that look like shit when moving. Who ever came up with that idea? The skins are underwhelming and their solution for him not fitting the lore? Change the lore ofc.
How can they proudly display this abominaton in their devblog is far beyond me. Changing the voicelines is just the last straw. I just love how each rework makes a champion less unique. End of rant.
r/SkarnerMains • u/Zaparapapa • Apr 03 '24
Sorry for you skarnermains
They pretty much removed everything that was fun about old skarner and replaced it with a shitty nunu w and a clunky kit, but hey, atleast u can throw a rock now?(after having to stop and wait)
r/SkarnerMains • u/Blueshiredsush • Jan 09 '22
Should we use they/them as skarner pronouns?
Not because skarner is not binary, but because they literally are 2 or even more people, for all the crystals that he had collected over time