r/SixFeetUnder • • Feb 06 '24

Opinion That's My Dog is trash

3 Upvotes

I'm rewatching this show again after nearly a decade. I just got to That's My Dog, an episode I hated on my first viewing, and an episode that is generally controversial.

Upon rewatch, it has firmly cemented itself to me as one of the worst episodes ever of an otherwise quality show.

I understand that Six Feet Under has a flair for the dramatic, and is not afraid to deal with difficult subjects often in a surreal manner. At times, the show even feels like a glorified soap opera with all of the terrible things that happen to the main characters. However, most of the time the subjects covered in the show are actually relatable, and serve to advance or challenge the characters in interesting ways.

Not this episode though. This episode was a creative writing exercise by writers who apparently ran out of ideas. It felt like an actual soap opera episode. It is so far-fetched, so fucking ridiculous, that I couldn't believe I was watching the same show.

Additionally, it's just fucking terribly written. David could have driven away the second the hijacker got out of the car to get rid of the corpse in the back. There is literally no reasonable explanation for him not flooring it. I do not accept that he was just in shock - that is nonsense - he was certainly lucid enough to make that extremely obvious decision. And then he fails to escape yet again after successfully running off, but for some dumb reason stops behind a car only to get caught again. Are you kidding? The writers had it right in the next episode when they have Ruth tell David "none of this makes any sense."

Lastly, and most importantly, David's character becomes insufferable for practically the entire remainder of the series. His charstcer arc, which was wonderfully constructed to that point, is completely reset back to the beginning. In fact, it's even worse. He becomes nothing but an empty, whiny husk of a character, and it's a true crime against television that this is the final chapter to his arc.

I'm not even disturbed by the content of the episode because the writing is so shit and the consequences it has on the rest of the show are disastrous. It's not an exploration of PTSD, it's an exploration for the writers trying to shock the viewers with gratuitous, grade A bullshit.

Anyway, That's My Opinion.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Apr 12 '24

Opinion Rico's my favorite character. What do you think about that?

0 Upvotes

I'll elaborate more when responding to comments


r/SixFeetUnder • • Apr 19 '24

Opinion I'm tired of this

0 Upvotes

I don't know if this classifies as a spoiler but I'm on season 5 episode 5 and I am so tired of everyone cheating on everyone all the time and lying. I'm also really tired of Claire right now


r/SixFeetUnder • • Jan 07 '24

Question Why was Lisa's anti vax opinions just shrugged off and never mentioned again?

3 Upvotes

She said to Nate at one point that she didn't want to vaccinate Maya, he didn't really have a reaction, they moved on, and it was never even mentioned again. It was treated like one of her harmless quirks, not like the child abuse with a potentially deadly outcome it actually is. That always disturbed me. I was hoping Nate would be an adult for once, divorce Lisa and go to the doctor with Maya to get her vaccinated. He still loved and cared for Maya so why would he be okay with her being unvaccinated?


r/SixFeetUnder • • Jan 06 '24

First-Timer Great show (about terrible people)

8 Upvotes

My wife and I just watched Six Feet Under for the first time. I really liked the show, but afterwards when we were talking about it I realized it's by far my favorite show in which I didn't like or root for a single character.

I mean seriously, all of these characters have the morals of hamsters. I don't think there was a single one who didn't cheat on their partner, multiple times in most cases. Almost every major character (to say nothing of the recurring characters) was narcissistic, abusive, or just unpleasant.

  • Nate? Narcissistic cheating asshole

  • David? Whiny cheating jerk

  • Rico? Entitled megacheating jerk

  • Ruth? Shrieking cheating dingbat

  • Brenda? Self-destructive cheating jerk

  • Keith? Abusive cheating asshole

  • George? Deceptive cheating dick

  • Lisa? Annoying cheating jerk

  • Billy? Just ugh.

    • redeemed somewhat when he literally bored Brenda to death

  • Olivier? Pretentious cheating prick

I think the only characters I didn't want to strangle were Vanessa (who was nastier to Rico than was strictly necessary but he TOTALLY deserved it) and Claire (who—being a teenager—was annoying but that's not REALLY her fault, plus she got dealt an awful hand being born into that family). Keith also was on an upswing toward the end but the series ended too soon to really show his growth.

And yet the show was strangely compelling and we really liked it.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Aug 12 '24

General Rewatching, why was Brenda allowed to take Maya?

0 Upvotes

I’m re-watching this for the first time in like five years, and it is pissing me off beyond belief that Brenda and her mother just waltz right in and take Maya back from Ruth. Brenda never adopted Maya, she has no legal rights to her. If I was Ruth, I would have been kicking and screaming to take her back.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Apr 18 '24

General David's chorus sucks

0 Upvotes

Holy shit these guys pick the most boring songs in the world


r/SixFeetUnder • • Aug 16 '26

Question Genuinely curious why so many here loved Brenda yet hate Maggie. Brenda actually cheated on Nate with the surfers , and lies. Maggie was not a cheater, (although was the other woman.)

4 Upvotes

r/SixFeetUnder • • Nov 30 '23

Opinion Love the show but hate all of the characters

10 Upvotes

Am I the only one who loves the show but can't stand a single one of the characters? Each one is whiny and self indulgent. Each with annoying quirks. They spend the bulk of the entire series treating ach other terribly. By Season 4 most of them are self righteous.

But for whatever reason the show worked for me.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Sep 25 '24

General Why did Claire act like a smart ass but came up short? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

She always acted like she was the smartest person in the room and felt like the education system was holding her back. I know her friend cheated on the SAT but I was at least expecting her to get into a decent state university. Community College with all that talk? Maybe the show also wants to show us that we are all full of ourselves as teenagers lol.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Feb 05 '24

Discussion The Fisher family are angry and easily-offended

0 Upvotes

I am 10 episodes into the season 1 and just can’t understand how easily-offended and self-absorbed these Fisher siblings are. Vs Brenda and other supporting characters are way more laid-back and chilled. Nate particularly reminded me of my ex from a long time ago. What kind of families in reality raise kids like these Fisher siblings?

Edit: seems like this post is getting heated. I just want to say I empathize everything the Fisher family is going through in the show. Especially I started watching this show the next day after I lost my grandpa whom I was really closed with a month ago 🙃. My point is that, in real life, no matter how sad you are, you shouldn’t take it out on people around you or just yell at people without thinking further for whatever reasons. That’s just not how adult life works.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Jul 07 '24

First-Timer “That’s my dog” was awful Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I have absolutely loved this show so far but this episode definitely jumped the shark for me, several times over. Got to be one of the most brain-rotting horribly written episodes of television I have seen. On a level with the last season of Game of Thrones. Most of the actions taken by David felt completely nonsensical and out of character.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Sep 13 '24

Question Should Nate show up in the new Dexter? He would be a criminal that Dexter would pursue.

0 Upvotes

r/SixFeetUnder • • Dec 02 '24

Question Does anyone else find the characters insufferable? Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Now I'm not here to talk bad about the show, because I can't stop watching and have been generally loving it. But I just can't get over the fact that the characters are all terrible (maybe not all). For context I'm mid season 4 right now and I just can't get over the fact that I can keep watching and enjoying it while hating most of the characters (I generally don't "hate watch" stuff). Although Claire has become a little less insufferable (other than the whole artist thing) and I actually like David, the rest of the characters just don't seem to be likable and I feel like they maybe are meant to be disliked?

Did anyone else have this feeling of disliking basically everyone? Is that how it's kind of supposed to go? Also what is with the amount of cheating on the show? I mean I get that it happens, but everyone? The Rico and Sofia storyline doesn't even make sense, it just seemed like they wanted to make one of them a cheater after the bait with Rico's cousin.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Feb 05 '25

Discussion The Brenda character s1

2 Upvotes

I read some comments how bad Nate is but doing a rerun of the series i feel Brenda has to take a LOT of the blame how Nate develops. Especially Season 1 her behavior to a very patient Nate. Whom she shits all over, makes me feel very repulsive towards her character.

She keeps treating Nate as a fuck buddy;

Doesnt even take a second to explain why naked man #1 appears (Billy);

Then reneges on romantic dates just because Billy 'needs her';

Then doesnt seem to get bothered why Nate might be upset about naked man #2;

Then lies about naked man #2 not sleeping with her in the same bed;

Then doesnt warn about her parents;

For a developing relationship this are all BIG red flags.

Then there is the constant menage, harrasment/stalking by Billy;

Including him using an intimate made photo for an exposition;

Billy showing up in Vegas;

Billy making pictures of them sleeping in vegas hotel;

Then Brenda acting out/projecting when Nate protests about her soft approach, refusing to see Billy really did act and appears dangerous;

This is before the scene where Billy also threatens Claire, or intimidates Nate with that scene at Billys apartment. After that event, again Brenda shuts down, blames Nate. I wouldv walked right there and then, and contacted the police

Did i miss anything? Oh Billy walking in when they fuck, episode6 i think.

These are all BIG red flags for a new, developing relation.

This is before we see the end of s1 or the even worse behavior of Brenda s2. I wouldv walked away 700 times.

Evenso, the Brenda character just repulses me bigtime in s1. Whatever Nate will do, it wont ever be surpased what Brenda does to Nate. In my humble opinion.

Thoughts?


r/SixFeetUnder • • Oct 04 '23

Opinion The singing.....

0 Upvotes

Ugghhh... season 2....between David tra-la-la-ing and Ruth singing A Few of My Favorite Things while doing that awful dance and now Lisa is singing For Once He Was A True Love of Mine....all I can say is thank you fast forward. I can't stand it. I don't mind the silly impromptu songs like Claire's pantyhose song but the chorus stuff is awful. I hope they fired whoever thought that was a good idea....ok, rant is over.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Nov 29 '23

Opinion Can’t stand Brenda and Billy

10 Upvotes

I’m enjoying the show but Brenda and Billy are so dramatic and annoying I just feel like skipping whenever they appear.

I’m just finishing season one so no spoilers please


r/SixFeetUnder • • Dec 26 '25

General Nates Wife. Unbearable.

5 Upvotes

I’m on season 3 e10 and nates wife is just the worst. He was honestly better with brenda..


r/SixFeetUnder • • Dec 07 '25

Discussion BRENDA REMINDS ME OF KIM WEXLER

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

IMO I've never seen anyone who matches these two in terms of acting and character development


r/SixFeetUnder • • Jan 22 '24

Question Brenda🙄

0 Upvotes

I’m currently on season 2 episode 7, I can’t bring myself to like her character. I understand that she got a lot of unresolved trauma however it doesn’t give her the license to treat Nate like a crap.

Does she ever have a redemption arc or a little character development? (not expecting too much from her)..

I love David’s character, the kind of diva I’m aspiring to. Ruth is an interesting character too, I find Claire matured for her age.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Aug 23 '26

First-Timer Rico is the most realistic/relatable person on the show

12 Upvotes

Just finished the show for the first time and started reading some reviews on it and I am left surprised how many people hate Rico as I thought Rico’s character was very realistic/relatable.

Firstly, he cared very much about his job and actually decided to continue improving it for money, so his family could live a better life, and also for his genuine emotional investment towards making the passage of death easier for people (As shown by his partaking in intakes and always wanting to fulfil their wishes without any financial consideration), which was exactly what Fisher & Sons was created for. Furthermore, his connection to Nathaniel Fisher Sr. through his father’s death and working under him for many years (which made him one of the best embalmers in the area) both improved his character but also put friction between him and the Fishers. Rico was a better embalmer than David and had a very deep personal connection to Fisher Sr. but was still treated as almost irrelevant by Nate and David, especially before he was made partner. Therefore, despite his lashing outs to them being seen as narcissistic, it was due to genuine desire for being a part owner of a business which he both deeply cared about and was more useful to it than Nate and David. Even after he was made partner, he was still treated as not an equal as there is even a moment in which Nate tells him that his job is “not good enough” despite him having to deal with an emergency. He was also completely right to be angry when David told him that he called the realtors off as he had genuinely grieved for Nate, allowed David to grieve for him and only wanted to discuss their future for his family after a long period of grieving (6 weeks?). I’ve seen him being hated for being homophobic but I think people fail to realise that he is a Latino that grew up in the 80s and have always been surrounded by homophobic culture. His treatment of Ramon was also acceptable in the sense that his action of intercourse may have been seen by his family and also that Ramon cheated on his wife for years and also wasted many years of her life for not coming out. I’ve seen that he is hated for his treatment of David in the first season when he comes out but I thought that throughout the seasons, he became more and more accustomed with David’s lifestyle (as with Keith also being more prominent within the Fisher household) and only had problems with him for treating him as a lesser. He was also very concerned with his child’s behaviour as shown by him disciplining his kid for bullying another kid, showing that he genuinely was a role model for a parent.

The genuine problem with Rico was his story from the ending of Season 3 to mid Season 5 in which he cheated on his wife (unacceptable) and also started to become dishonest with her. Even though it was unacceptable, he seemed to be one of the very few people who tried to make amends after cheating (e.g. Nate cheating with Lisa and Maggie and not being remotely sorry) and actually tried to improve his marriage.

All in all, I thought Rico was a hard-working, compassionate and ambitious character whose greatest fault was his remote narcissism and his treatment of his wife for 2 seasons, even though they had a great marriage for 3 seasons and actually cared for each other at the end.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Jul 26 '22

Opinion I won’t lie the first 2 seasons are the best then the show kinda died off

9 Upvotes

I love the series, but if I’m honest with myself, the first 2 seasons were the best. It felt more natural, had more interesting plot lines and character observations. Then later on, the show just felt heavy with forced drama, and I felt it lost it’s touch. The 5th season kinda returned it back to form especially with that finale. But if I’m being honest here, I don’t think the entire run was perfect and that’s fine, but I really see the first 2 seasons were the most impressive the show ever was, after that it became repetitive and stagnant and oddly a BUNCH of sex scenes.


r/SixFeetUnder • • Jun 06 '26

Discussion One of the best queer characters on TV. Happy Pride Month.

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/SixFeetUnder • • Jul 13 '25

Finale Discussion I wish the ending would show these characters all reuniting in Heaven as their younger selves.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes