r/SixFeetUnder • u/_YellowHair • Feb 06 '24
Opinion That's My Dog is trash
I'm rewatching this show again after nearly a decade. I just got to That's My Dog, an episode I hated on my first viewing, and an episode that is generally controversial.
Upon rewatch, it has firmly cemented itself to me as one of the worst episodes ever of an otherwise quality show.
I understand that Six Feet Under has a flair for the dramatic, and is not afraid to deal with difficult subjects often in a surreal manner. At times, the show even feels like a glorified soap opera with all of the terrible things that happen to the main characters. However, most of the time the subjects covered in the show are actually relatable, and serve to advance or challenge the characters in interesting ways.
Not this episode though. This episode was a creative writing exercise by writers who apparently ran out of ideas. It felt like an actual soap opera episode. It is so far-fetched, so fucking ridiculous, that I couldn't believe I was watching the same show.
Additionally, it's just fucking terribly written. David could have driven away the second the hijacker got out of the car to get rid of the corpse in the back. There is literally no reasonable explanation for him not flooring it. I do not accept that he was just in shock - that is nonsense - he was certainly lucid enough to make that extremely obvious decision. And then he fails to escape yet again after successfully running off, but for some dumb reason stops behind a car only to get caught again. Are you kidding? The writers had it right in the next episode when they have Ruth tell David "none of this makes any sense."
Lastly, and most importantly, David's character becomes insufferable for practically the entire remainder of the series. His charstcer arc, which was wonderfully constructed to that point, is completely reset back to the beginning. In fact, it's even worse. He becomes nothing but an empty, whiny husk of a character, and it's a true crime against television that this is the final chapter to his arc.
I'm not even disturbed by the content of the episode because the writing is so shit and the consequences it has on the rest of the show are disastrous. It's not an exploration of PTSD, it's an exploration for the writers trying to shock the viewers with gratuitous, grade A bullshit.
Anyway, That's My Opinion.