r/SimCity • • Mar 17 '13

The state of the subreddit, and how we’re going to tackle the current status of r/SimCity

12 Upvotes

As many of you can probably tell, this subreddit has very quickly accelerated to a huge circlejerk representing only hate and disrespect towards EA, Maxis, SimCity, and even just some of the users in this subreddit – which is certainly not what a strategy game subreddit should be about. While there are many legitimate reasons for us to be angry, upset, and for some of us just plain pissed off, we need to keep in mind both Reddiquette and some general respect for not only the opinions of others, but for those who are just doing their job.

We should be focusing more on constructive feedback, general ideas, and discussion. Having the constant reposts of bashing, inappropriate and disrespectful posts and titles, and just complete disregard for any sort of respect has quickly turned this subreddit into something where not only the developers, but just general users have been pushed away from. Users who have posted legitimate questions about concerns, general fixes, or just some ideas for towns or actual discussion have quickly been buried in favor of posts which just follow the general trend of bashing. While this may be okay in other subreddits, I feel that this is not the kind of atmosphere we want in r/SimCity.

Existing posts will not be removed based on this material, but newer posts which do not provide any sort of constructive feedback or general discussion towards SimCity (including excess foul language, abuse towards others, and personal attacks aimed at the team or specific people) has the potential to be removed by me or the other moderators on the team.

  • Memes will be removed

  • Only constructive posts are allowed: Posts that clearly define the problem and give possible solutions. We're not looking for people to fix the game for EA or Maxis, we're looking for respectful reporting methods. Ex: "PSA: The population feature is broken. It's given a false read to the user which can negatively impact gameplay" is much more efficient than "Fuck this game, everything is lying to us this piece of crap" Posts that are pure bashing or don't offer any sensible advice will be deleted.

  • Only posts that are directly related to the game, thus excluding general EA bashing, Origin bashing and other things that only attract hate.

  • Absolutely NO personal Information. This is not only a rule of the subreddit, but of Reddit itself.

(These rules are holding here for the time being until we can get the subreddit back on track. These points and the general works of the subreddit will be placed up for public discussion where we can all vote and rule out things that we want/don't want to see. Until then, please follow these posting guidelines.)

We will soon be updating the sidebar with some more posting guidelines to help narrow down what we are looking to filter out. While we understand anger due to the new game and behavior that we have received from EA, Origin, and SimCity, we need to understand there are those who are just doing their job and really have no control over the outcome of your conversation with them (obviously this is not the case for all). While posting here, we are going to request some respect from you as a Subreddit. There is plenty of content offering excellent feedback and constructive criticism towards the game – which is exactly what we want.

So we’ve all had our fun, but it’s time we get SimCity back on track. Many users have been reporting abusive posts and messaging the mods about questionable content - It’s important to understand that we take every report and message and read through it thoroughly. Thanks for taking the time to read through and feel free to comment below.


r/SimCity • • Apr 03 '13

Let's talk about SimCity in a positive manner: What do you like about it?

1 Upvotes

I love the aesthetics of it, to be quite honest. Also, curved roads? Man, I would kill to have them in the previous versions!


r/SimCity • • Mar 14 '13

/r/simcity sucks the fun out of the game

5 Upvotes

Remember when a week ago most people found the game great fun if the servers were working? Good job at destroying everything that's good about SC5, don't you realize how the horrible atmosphere here poisons your opinion of the game? Which in turn results in even angrier posts, repeat ad infinitum.

My point is: how were people having fun during the beta and early release days, when most of the AI problems were already apparent? Because people left to their own devices notice a few bugs and wonky behaviour, not this massive striptease of every flaw in the game. Would you have seriously noticed that Sims are non-persistent and generated on the fly? Would you have found fake numbers-source code? No, you've read it here, now you know and of course it bugs you. Me too.

We KNOW the AI sucks. Maxis knows. EA knows. They're working on it. You don't need to make another thread about how broken you think the game is. I don't need 40 reminders of every flaw the game has every single day, stop this malicious, cynical circlejerk.

Thanks for reading.

TL;DR:

You would have way more fun with SimCity if it weren't for this hateful subreddit.


r/SimCity • • Jul 27 '24

Cities Skylines 2 Is the Biggest Dumpster Fire I’ve Ever Played

4 Upvotes

I really hope a studio rival sees this and makes something new. Damn, I wish I was Chris Sawyer or had the money to do it myself. This game makes me more mad than a Sci-fi “thriller” like Ad Astra. I would rather pull out all my teeth than pay $30 to bang my neurons against my skull with a mallet while playing this game. What sucks:

  1. Starting with an ugly, dumb, not sandbox highway to connect to. I don’t care if there are ways around it.

  2. Starting the city is irrational as all. You shouldn’t have to perfectly level terrain, figure out power on 15 layers with the terrain, perfectly calculate road angles, and spend an hour just getting ready to zone. On top of having to plan around some a-hole’s idea of having to connect to an ugly highway.

  3. This game is not a game. It’s a bunch of ego head drafting and city planners that want to make something they think a simulator should be. It’s not a game. Go make a CAD program if that’s what you want.

  4. All the buildings and artwork are made by a robot. Uninspiring trash. Turn the colors on and turn off the commie block trash that has nothing to do with a game. Don’t make a game hoping people will mod it all. Don’t lie about having a NA and EU central theme. They both suck and look nothing like what NA or EU should be like and what about half the other world?

  5. When I first launched the game with my recently built $1500 PC, the game wouldn’t run. I had to spend an hour looking up settings and try hours more of work to make it even playable. At that, SC3K stills looms better.

I tried to get my money back after the performance issues. These great people said it was too late. Well, this is my review and I hope something new comes from the next city simulator that’s not from the group involved with this snake oil game.


r/SimCity • • Mar 08 '13

I Think You Have The Wrong Account...

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Mar 07 '13

Can these kind of posts stop now, please?

Thumbnail
quickmeme.com
42 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Mar 11 '13

SimCity UI/Server code leaked!

Thumbnail
gist.github.com
0 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Mar 13 '13

Well /r/SimCity, things have changed around here, I guess it's goodbye for the time being.

1 Upvotes

This subreddit was one of my favorite places to come for good discussions and conversations but that's definitely not possible anymore.

I understand people are frustrated by the launch of SimCity and so am I. It sucks to follow the development of a game so closely for a long time then have the launch fall flat on it's face. I know it sucks because I too paid my hard earned cash for the game but I am optimistic that with time the game will become what it was supposed to be.

Fuck me, right?

Now any positive mention of the game or even posting simple facts about the game are immediately downvoted like crazy then a flurry of insults come in. Check my history for some great examples. Now instead of intelligent discussion on the subject I'm told to "keep suckin that dick" or "get the fuck out".

So I guess I will leave, this subreddit is now depressing and shitty. Hopefully this it gets back to its roots eventually.


r/SimCity • • Apr 16 '13

Today I learnt that Maxis cannot spell 'already'!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Apr 27 '13

Angry SimCity Poster Threatens to Bomb Electronic Arts Headquarters.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Apr 17 '13

So I just got SimCity yesterday and started playing...

15 Upvotes

and I think it's pretty good! Granted, I am super glad I waited past the first few weeks after launch (I do that with all games that require an online connection and servers and whatever). Ordered it for around $30 bucks on Amazon with a decent promotion.

I guess a lot of the major bugs have been fixed. I've played about 12 hours so far, didn't have any rollbacks or lose my city at all. I have had absolutely no problems at all connecting to the servers. Traffic seemed to work fine, if there was anything that was slow, I just upgraded the streets or added another road and it worked.

The only bug I noticed was my firefighters kept driving around in circles for a few minutes while there was a fire they needed to get to, but after a while they made their way over there.

City sizes are a bit small...they're more like SimTowns...but I was expecting that already.

I guess I made this post for anyone else who was on the fence about getting it. It seems to me that it's in pretty good working order.


r/SimCity • • Mar 07 '13

Upvote if you're just refreshing the 'new' section over and over.

90 Upvotes

And having a wonderful time watching all of the fallout. :)


r/SimCity • • Mar 25 '15

SimCity13 Why all the criticism? This game seems quite good

3 Upvotes

I played Simcity2000 back in the old days, as well as Simisle, and more recently Banished. I would have tried Simcity 2013 earlier, but all of the negativity on here made me decide to forget about it, until it went on sale a month ago and I picked it up for $25 on Origin.

I have to say - this game is actually pretty good! It's way more complex than I expected it would be due to the density and wealth ideas, as well as things like freight, shopping, etc. The graphics are really great too, and I haven't experienced many bugs at all.

I know people complained about small city size compared to previous Simcity games, but it doesn't bother me too much because it requires more strategy this way, compared to just aimlessly making a bigger and bigger city - the idea being to build up after you can't build outwards, as well as re-assigning areas to other things. Plus, there's the whole region thing instead of limiting you to a single city, so you can make other cities to provide whatever yours lacks. It's just a different type of game.

I also remember reading that traffic was a big issue, and although I agree it's an important thing that you can easily mess up on, I don't think it's actually a problem - I've read a few guides on how to arrange avenues, and with some practice, I was able to make it flow pretty smoothly in most cases.

I also read that Sims don't behave as you'd expect, I.E. switching homes and jobs due to proximity, but is this really such a big deal? The time-scale is supposed to be in days representing months, and some fluidity in homes/jobs makes sense. Plus, they DO have a pretty interesting AI, with things like needing to work/shop to build up happiness, and making use of public transit. Considering the scale of the simulation, that's impressive.

I've been playing the game for a few weeks and have been having loads of fun. I've especially enjoyed the specializations concept, as they remind me of Simisle - it was really awesome finally getting my electronics and gambling cities to work perfectly. My only complaint is that there aren't enough specializations/city types to try out, since I've really only come up with 1) electronics exporting cities, 2) gambling cities, and 3) cities to provide lots of workers, with other city types being less useful.

So...why's everyone think this game is absolutely awful and switching over to Cities Skylines? I honestly don't see much room for improvement over Simcity.


r/SimCity • • Apr 10 '13

And So It Begins...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
34 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Aug 30 '13

Misleading Title Confirmation that the Mac port is just a wrapper

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Mar 07 '13

My first city hit 300k last night!

Thumbnail
imgur.com
45 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Mar 04 '13

"Just getting around to installing Origin so that I can play the actual shipping, release version of #SimCity." - Ocean Quigley. Not even devs like being forced to use Origin by EA.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Apr 17 '13

Cities In Motion - Patch notes 1.1.6

Thumbnail
forum.paradoxplaza.com
3 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Mar 06 '13

Trust me, I was pretty frustrated last night when I couldn't play. But..

Thumbnail
quickmeme.com
21 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Apr 19 '13

Eat My Shit!

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Sep 24 '13

Feedback Thank You SimCity Upgrade Team (Guillaume, Chris, Ross, Ryan, Patrick, Alex and so many others )

0 Upvotes

I wanted to publically say thank you for your hard work and on going support of the community and efforts through the process over the last couple months and ongoing developments.

THANK YOU


r/SimCity • • Apr 02 '13

90+ hours in and I must be playing a different game.

Thumbnail
qkme.me
0 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Mar 17 '13

This is my publicly available Sim City user data. City logs, news, etc. are protected with logintokens. My and your data is not.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
85 Upvotes

r/SimCity • • Nov 29 '13

News 11/28/2013 Off Topic Comments & More

0 Upvotes

Let it be known that hunting season on Maxis Developers and SimCity Redditors has officially come to an end.

Off topic comments will be deleted. Depending on the “severity” of the content, language, post history etc. this may result in either a warning or a lifetime ban. Here is an example of an off topic comment:

Subject: Here’s a city I made that looks cool

Off topic comment:

Man they’ve ruined this game. Look how small those maps are.

The comment has nothing to do with the topic and will be removed without question. As a gaming community, and I know many of us here play a wide spectrum of games, to insult another person’s content is uncalled for regardless of how you feel about the game. This is Reddit. Ignore the post, up vote or down vote based on the content or post a relevant comment and then move on.

Here is yet another example of an off topic comment:

Subject: SimCity Blog Article: How to make “whatever”

Off-topic comment:

I wish they’d put Maxis Headquarters in the game so the lizard can eat it.

This comment contributes nothing to the scope of the post, thus it will be deleted.

Personal attacks on any game developer or SimCity Redditor will no longer be tolerated in any medium. As we have said in the past, there is a way to convey a suggestion, your thoughts and give feedback without being insulting.

Do feel free to create a post in which you make those suggestions and feelings known. That will be a post where like minded comments can have a home. Creating a post entitled, “Maxis sucks” however will simply result in a ban and the post being removed.

Honestly folks, it’s gone on long enough. I personally removed too many posts in one day from the “Maxis Does Movember” Thread.

Without trying to sound too confrontational, I am well aware of what some members of the community here do to those who try to foster “change” to this SubReddit. I have cashed in six weeks of vacation time in which I plan to tinker around the house, play video games and relax. In general I have nothing better to do than monitor things around here.

The changes being made here are self explanatory and for a good purpose. Convey your thoughts in a way that aren't overtly insulting, stay on topic in a given thread and the world will continue on swimmingly.

The internet is a big place. There are other places for you to go and cuss, swear, insult, intimidate, threaten and be generally unhelpful and unkind. This subreddit is no longer the medium for you to act this way.

Using the "Report" feature is a way for users to bring comments and posts to our attention quickly. Please use that tool as necessary.

To those who have been able to contribute something, positive or negative, in a way that is constructive, thank you. We hope to be able to better foster an environment for you to be able to continue doing these things.

To those who are unable to adapt to change and who have had free reign around here spreading your misery, it's time for you to move on to another online venue.

Last, I am currently looking at these "refund" posts and wondering what value they add to a discussion of the game. While I am pondering this please note that the thread may very well be removed. The post offers nothing directly related to a SimCity game and is more in tune with Origin/EA sales.

Thanks.


r/SimCity • • Mar 01 '13

UPVOTE FOR VISIBILITY: AMAZON IS NO LONGER DONG PRE-LOADS ON 3/1

2 Upvotes

This really sucks. I was really excited to get the game preloaded so I could start playing at 12:01 AM on 3/5.

BUT NO TO FEAR!!! I bear good news from EA, people who preorder from origin can play on 3/4 starting at 9 PM PST. Cancel your amazon orders and preorder on origin right now!

Link for proof (and for the lazy) http://www.amazon.com/SimCity-Limited-Edition-Pc/dp/B007FTE2VW/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1362108337&sr=8-1&keywords=sim+city