Hi everyone, I'm /u/Fishering, a new mod of /r/Signupsforpay.
I was invited to become a moderator of this subreddit after I noticed that this subreddit has been getting bad rep on other subreddits due to a large list of scammers that roam(ed) this subreddit.
I notice that modmails have not been getting responded to at all, but I'm now trying to keep up with it. If you send in a modmail request over a week ago from today, which has not received a response and you're still in need of assistance, please bump the thread with another reply, or open a new modmail.
I'm here to try and fix this subreddit and make changes for the better, so I think now is a good time to make this town hall thread to explain changes that are already happening, as well as changes that I would like your opinions on.
So, let's get started.
Universal Scammer List
The biggest issue this subreddit has been facing recently is scammers. This subreddit has never participated in the Universal Scammer List, which is interesting because of how often it is mentioned in the sidebar. As of yesterday, /r/Signupsforpay finally will be adopting the USL, which means that many of the scammers who have been actively trading in this subreddit will now be banned.
If you're reading this and you are one of those people who have been banned as a result of this, as stated in the ban message, in order to get unbanned here, you will need to be removed from the USL by the subreddit that banned you.
New Mods?
This subreddit does not have very many mods. I'm here to help mod during this time, especially since /u/Nter is away currently. If you're someone who thinks you would be interested in helping moderate as well, feel free to send in a modmail. Right now the main qualifications are that you should be a moderator of another transaction subreddit.
New Posting Formats?
Many of you are probably familiar with other subreddits where there is typically post types of, "[Task]" as well as, "[Offer]", but /r/signupsforpay only allows "[Offer]" posts, and while most of the time people are making offers, such as, "sign up for this and you'll get $x from them and $y from me" there are also people using this tag to make offers like, "I will sign up under you for <app>, highest offer gets my sign up!"
In this case, it would make sense for there to be a [Task] tag for the first use case, and an [Offer] tag for the second case. Would this be a change that you think would be good for this sub?
Alternatively, do you think a megathread for offers like the second case would be useful? Where people could comment with what trending apps/sites they have not yet signed up with and take offers from people?
Rule 8 Adjustment?
Rule 8 states:
You are allowed to repost only every 3 days after your post (Closed included) is off the sub front page. Deleting and reposting before this is a BAN.
What I have noticed a lot of people will do is make one post about App A, and then a few hours later they'll make a post about App B... and some people make many posts every day, each with a different offer.
Would it be more useful if there was a hard limit of 1 post per day, but in this post you would include all of the sign up offers you have to offer? For example, instead of making 5 posts about WeFull, SoFi, Varo, Fetch, and Robinhood, I would make one post and include each of those in the post.
The issue with the quantity of posts some people are making is that it clutters the subreddit (almost spam like), and for people looking to sign up for things, it might make it harder to find offers.
Conclusion
Please feel free to respond with any questions or suggestions/ideas you might have for changes you'd like to see.