r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 23 '24

Question Clarification on Catholics and Christians in the show please Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So all the Japanese western-god believers have been Catholics up until Anjin’s arrival? And they mistakenly call themselves Christian even tho they’re Catholics?

Are the men on the council catholic like Mariko? Or they’re Christian Christian?

And how does Anjin’s existence threaten the council?

I’m sorry I’ve been incredibly confused by all of it 😅 thanks in advance for clarifying 🙏

EDIT: I know nothing about western religion, being sarcastic and expecting that it’s some super common knowledge that everyone on earth should know contributes nothing this post


r/ShogunTVShow • • Apr 21 '26

🗣️ Discussion Why I can't appreciate this show

0 Upvotes

Shōgun 2024 is beautifully made, that's for sure, better than the previous one. But as a portuguese, I can't digest how it flattens complex historical actors into convenient villains for an Anglo-Japanese audience.

  • The Rodrigues problem. In Clavell's novel, Captain Vasco Rodrigues is a complex, likeable Portuguese sailor who has genuine warmth toward Blackthorne and the Japanese. In the 2024 show, this character has been quietly rewritten as... spanish. This is not an adaptation choice forced by history, it's a deliberate decision that leaves the portuguese with only one nuanced character (Alvito) and a cast of villains

  • Toranaga's convenient ignorance. The show has Blackthorne reveal the existence of the portuguese settlement in Macau to a supposedly surprised Toranaga. By 1600, Portuguese-Japanese trade had been active for 50 years, with Nagasaki built partly around it. The idea that Tokugawa Ieyasu's fictional counterpart wouldn't know this strains credibility, and incidentally frames the portuguese as having deceived their Japanese partners for decades.

  • The "Christianity as soft conquest" narrative. The show implies that Jesuit missionary work in Japan was a precursor to military conquest. What is the historical basis for this ? Portuguese expansion in Asia (Goa, Malacca, etc...) was military first, with Christianization following. The Jesuits in Japan had zero military backing. The fear of conquest was real among some Japanese lords, but the show presents it as fact rather than suspicion.

  • The Iberian Union elephant in the room. The show presents the division of the world between Portuguese and Spanish spheres (treaties of Tordesillas and Zaragoza) as a live and meaningful tension in 1600. But at that point, the Portuguese and Spanish crowns had been united under Philip II since 1580. Portugal and Spain were the same monarchy ! The dramatic framing of Portuguese vs. Spanish interests as some kind of rivalry is historically muddled at best. More importantly, the show completely ignores that England and Portugal had been bound by the Treaty of Windsor since 1386 — one of the oldest alliances in history, still in force in 1600. Blackthorne and the Portuguese being portrayed as straightforward enemies erases the rather inconvenient fact that their countries were formally allied, while Portugal itself was under Spanish domination.

  • The language erasure. The part that touches me the most. Portuguese was the actual lingua franca of Asian trade in 1600. William Adams' real-life counterpart learned Portuguese to communicate in Japan. Yet the show lets us hear Japanese, English, even Spanish ("Viva España !"), while Portuguese speakers inexplicably converse with each other in English. This is a straightforward concession to Anglo and Japanese market demographics, and it quietly erases one of the most remarkable facts of the era: that a Japanese noblewoman learning Portuguese was her gateway to the wider world.

This reminds me of the story behind the movie Queimada (1969) : original script set the story on a Spanish Caribbean colony, depicting Spanish colonial brutality and a sugar plantation slave economy. Spain, still under Franco at the time, put significant pressure on the production and the island's nationality was quietly changed to Portuguese.

None of this make Shōgun a bad show. But when you can see the nationality swap, the linguistic erasure, the flattened portrayal, it's hard to just sit back and enjoy the costumes.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Jun 19 '24

Discussion Just finished the series & have a couple of criticisms Spoiler

1 Upvotes

So I just finished the series, and I kind of liked it. The cinematography was amazing, and the set design made me feel like I was in 1600s Japan, but there are a couple of questions that I still find confusing. All of them involve the man himself, Toranaga.

  1. In episode 3, when Toranaga escapes Osaka by boat, he goes to the black ship to make a deal with the Catholics. What I don't understand is why the Catholics even listen to him in the first place. I mean, they could've just sunk him right then and there. Think about it: killing Toranaga would mean that all his trusted vassals would die with him, including Blackthorne. This allows Ishido to win, but remember, there are still two Christian damiyos on the throne, and they need a replacement for Toranaga, which opens the possibility for a third. Also, if you remember, Ishido needed Blackthorne because he wanted to use his guns to combat the Christians, but now, by sinking the ship, there is no more Blackthorne(hurting Ishido and further benefiting the Christian damiyos) , and when you look back at what Toranaga offered them, it is still achievable without him. The trade will still continue with a monoply for the Portuguese, and they can have a church in Edo because even the heir of Toranaga would die too(the other one is a child in Osaka who can be influenced). The only thing that makes sinking Toranaga back then difficult to do, I guess, is because Martin likes Mariko?? But then again, his high priest doesn't seem to care that much for her.

  2. When Toranaga's army is crushed by the earthquake, why is he even allowed to march to his brother, and why is the command after he meets his brother to surrender in Osaka? I mean, wouldn't it be better to just crush him right there? This might be because I didn't understand Japanese law and customs at the time, but I still think it made no sense to make him surrender in Osaka specifically. Just get him to surrender and commit seppuku or whatever in the camp. Also, this becomes more absurd when his son tries to kill Toranaga's brother but fails and dies. Why is it that at that point he is still asked to surrender? He's obviously antagonistic and just tried to assassinate his brother. Why not just kill him right there? That's a "shamful" act, as shamful as it can get. Instead, he is asked to march to Osaka.

  3. Lastly, the Shinobi attack in the last episode: why did Mariko's death matter anyway? I mean, the seppuku ritual that was stopped by Ishido shouldn't have been stopped because isn't Mariko's lineage viewed as traitors to the Taiko? Aren't they hated in Osaka? Why would her death cause the families to revolt? Also, Ishido literally controls Osaka. I'd love to see them try to arrange any meaningful revolt because he already has everybody under surveillance. I guess that really where my problems with the show stem from is that Osaka and Ishido are just written to be incomptent, and everything they do just always fails. It doesn't feel like a back-and-forth with intriguing political maneuvers; it's just a one-man show. which is such a missed opportunity because it would have been so much more interesting if it was more balanced.

  4. One last tiny point: it feels like only Toranaga has access to spies, because I've never seen any of his opponents gain any advantage from spies, such as what he gets from them.

Please feel free to voice your opinions I really enjoy these discussions, and would love to hear what other people think.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 18 '24

Shogun related Since there probably won't be a season 2, idea for a Shogun spinoff....

0 Upvotes

John and Vasco. A buddy/road comedy.

Two pilots who hate each other are tasked with traveling across Japan together. Or even better, two pilots escape from a Japanese prison chained together and must help each other elude authorities.

While I am just kidding, the more I think about it, the more I'd want to watch it.

Edit: I want to reiterate, I am mostly kidding, though the banter between the two is one of my favorite parts of Shogun.


r/ShogunTVShow • • May 04 '24

Analysis & Theories Yabushige did nothing wrong Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Okay, so obviously he was duplicitous and boiled people alive, but he was right to never be loyal to Toranaga. He seems to be the only one who understands that Toranaga wants one things and one thing only; to be Shogun. As such, he knows that there is no safety in being loyal to a man who will sacrifice you for his plan at any time. Toranaga repeatedly sends people to their deaths just so he can come one small step closer to his goal. Even his oldest friend wasn't safe from being used as a mere pawn. Yabushige was right to not be loyal to someone who was never going to show any loyalty in return. Toranaga was the true villain all along.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Apr 18 '24

Discussion Team Ishido Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I know we’re meant to hate Ishido, and his the villain and all, but everytime they bring up the fact he’s a peasant lowkey bothers me. Like why does it matter? Why can’t a peasant earn his position? Now I can see why he has this sort of animosity to Toronaga, like y’all really letting this dude gain power infront of his because his clan use to be shogun? Mariko also saying she isn’t one to be trotted on like some peasant… no one deserves to that… it just bothers me. So I guess I’m team peasant 🤷🏿‍♂️


r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 28 '24

Opinion How can I prevent myself from bursting into tears watching this?

0 Upvotes

I’m loving the show but watching Mariko being steadily fed through the wringer is starting to take a toll. I’ve started watching some of FX’s behind the scenes interviews with the cast and Anna Sawai almost started crying talking about Mariko. I was just as bad! What do I do?


r/ShogunTVShow • • Dec 10 '24

Discussion The complete absence of the Portuguese language in the show seems ever more odd considering the lengths they went through to have proper classical Japanese dialect.

20 Upvotes

I think it's such a same there is complete lack of Portuguese representation in any modern film or show, especially considering this series went through great pains to have a high degree of historical accuracy, particularly for the type of Japanese spoke in the show. To my understanding the dialect of Japanese they used is more representative of the era, and most Japanese people today would have a hard time understanding it.

It would be just like having English characters in a Shakespeare movie speak proper old English, which is unrecognizable to just about all modern English speakers, so you could say it's "more authentic". If you're going to do that you might as well make all languages be representative and not cater to a particular ethnicity of audience.

The show is wonderful regardless, I just wish for once we could have historical television that didn't cater to English viewers, we're certainly capable of reading subtitles and understanding an actors emotional/physical language!


r/ShogunTVShow • • May 17 '24

Discussion If they must make a S2 & and S3 then it should be Prequels only Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm sure many have spent time researching the real history of the many characters in the show. It definitely feels like there's a lot more that was happening leading up to Season 1 than after. Feels like most of what we would see happen after Season 1 is the battle of Sekigahara, probably some scheming to some daimyo's on Toronagar's side.

I think following the stories of Oda Nobonaga, Toyotomi Hideyoshi, Akechi Mistuhide is far more interesting. We can follow Toranaga's storyline during that part of the unifying of Japan, get a better understanding of Mariko, Lady Ochiba, Yabushige, the portuguese, the other regents, Hiromatsu, etc.

There could be some interesting Toranaga ploys that could be added to enhance the story of Season 1. Did he manipulate Mariko's dad into killing Ochiba's dad? What lead him to stop fighting the Taiko for power over Japan? What lead the Taiko to invade Korea, was Toranaga behind it?

I probably have worse imagination than the writers would be I feel like the prequel content is much more interesting... only thing that is missing is Blackthorne


r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 27 '24

Opinion Too much Mariko & Blackthorn Spoiler

1 Upvotes

When the show is about political scheming and people trying to kill each other it's awesome. It's not really about that though. It's Blackthorn and Mariko all alone talking to each other and slowly accepting their budding feelings for each other for like two thirds of each episode.


r/ShogunTVShow • • May 29 '24

Question Did [spoiler] actually die? Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Did Mariko actually die?

Honestly while I have liked this show, her and John are the only characters I had any kind of major interest in. Was hoping to see multiple seasons of them together.

I'm on the final episode now and I honestly don't know if I'll be bothering to watch any new seasons if she's actually dead, considering the only other character I really care about is John.

Does she come back somehow or something? Thanks

EDIT: okay, it looks like she's actually dead lol. Sorry for the pointless post. Really disappointed tbh, I won't personally be bothering to watch anymore but I hope everyone here continues to enjoy it!! :)


r/ShogunTVShow • • May 15 '24

Question I'm confused why they can't just kill Blackthorn? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Why can't these lords just kill Blackthorn? He's a nobody and a heretic? I'm confused as to why he can't just be killed and their plans move on?


r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 23 '24

Discussion If you're a Shogun fan, you might enjoy Keanu Reeves' 47 Ronin (2013)

9 Upvotes

More than 10 years ago, I watched this movie in theater in 3d. Loved it. The movie was beautiful in every way. But it got really low score on IMDb. Most people said their acting was too stiff. But I think it captured the soul of Japanese culture, plus some fantasy elements.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1335975/

Hope you like it too.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 31 '24

Discussion Shoguns' Biggest Criticism (imo): They did my boy Blackthorn Dirty Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Shogun have some of the finest pov characters you cn find in historical fiction be it Tv or books, but one of the biggest issue that I have had with the series is is the character of blackthorn, He for lack of a better word is underwritten, there are many issue that I have with his characterization in the show they are as follow:

  • unlike other pov charactres his pov remains mostly unkown to us, one can say his talk with buntaro or his tense relationship with mariko is well written, , but in buntaro scene blackthorn felt more like a self insert than a man of his times, moreover his relationship with mariko is develops suddenly and out of nowhere in episode 4 , from there build up is gradual and steady and is at right pace, but that sudden jump in relation seems unjustified(that is why ep 4 was the worst episode so far), Moreover unlike other character his pov remains an enigma, we doesn't know what he wants (aside fm his men and ship, some sort of intimate relation with mariko), how he views his participation in the conflict , we get glimpse of culture shock , but as he is one of our main pov, his viiew is hardly explored in much detail (aside from love triangle and a possible quadrilateral).

  • He has little agency , and yet he doesn't try to gain any by learning japanese, by now (given several months have passes in the show), he should have learnt some basic japanese to gain more agency from mariko, that would allow him not only to form relationship with other characters , morover he is a commander now , toranag comes of as stupid in giving command to a non-japenese speaker the command of a regiment comprising primarily of japanese speaker(he can't rely on mariko to form relation with his unit and she would not be avaiable readily in the heat of battle).

  • He is childish, he repeatedly asks for his men and ship , and when it is clearly told to us again and again that is not going to happen, and even then he goes at it, just annoying toranag and nearly everybody around him, instead of providing a real good plan and showing their use case in the battle, like how he leveraAGED the use of his naval battle experience to train canon regiment, he could have used similar strategy instead of just asking for his men and ship and expecting toranaga to return the favour.

  • Finally it is because of the lack of his character exploration , other character in his orbit like yabushige are not given much shine, the whole character of yabu is now restricted to a conflict entreprenuer, whereas earlier the character dynamic in relation to blackthorn was beautifully established in episode one, e.g. how yabu views life and death or how him saving rodrigues despite a threat to his life, and then ready to commit suicide then top be taken by the waves earn him a measure of respect fm balckthorn. This story aspect have had a huge potential for development, now yabu character is restricted to a narrow circle and since he is outside osaka and is basically joined to toranaga camp after the death of jozen, even his political intrigue aspect is not doing him much service, maing his character mostly pointless from episode 4.

Edit (regarding learning japanese): even if we set aside unrealistic expectations from the books, learning a new language , depends on aptitude, we know blackthorn is a polyglot, with fluent understanding of multiple languages. The line “the only words we will speak will be from others” comes after several months, enough time to learn basic japanese to speak in broken verse, especially when he is surrounded by Japanese people all around him. Lack of japanese Language is giving him a perpetual L and he knows it, what especially frustrates me is that he is not even trying to learn the language.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Jan 13 '25

❓ Question Most beautiful woman in the show?

0 Upvotes

IMO it's Fumi Nikaido, but they are all beautiful.

468 votes, Jan 20 '25
322 Anna Sawai / Toda Mariko
33 Fumi Nikaido / Ochiba No Kata
66 Moeka Hoshi / Usami Fuji
47 Yuka Kouri / Kiku

r/ShogunTVShow • • May 28 '25

📚 Book Spoilers An amazing show. Acting, production and so on. But... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I read the book first. A couple times. There were two things missing. I don't know how to point this out without seeming like a perv. Missing in the show were the sex and nudity which was so prominent in the book. The author made a point of contrasting the two cultures in many ways. He contrasted the casual nudity many times and also the different attitude towards sex. And the Pilot's relationship with Mariko went on for much longer than was portrayed in the show.

Nudity: when they went swimming and bathing. Sex: the attitudes towards sex workers and pillowing

These are stressed over and over in the book. It's a method of contrasting the two cultures. Yet that contrast is wiped out in the show. To me that actually makes the show less accurate. Too bad because the rest of the show is so well done.

One of my favorite moments: when Fuji makes her stand. Wow - that actress is amazing!


r/ShogunTVShow • • Nov 15 '24

Question Why did Blackthorne not have any European sword?

0 Upvotes

Swords are obviously an important part of being a samurai, you need to carry them or else you'll look stupid and everyone will laugh at you.

So why does blackthorne not get a sword + his pistols from his ship? They are clearly more respected in samurai culture.

We also know that Blackthorne does know how to wield some sort of saber since he's a privateer, and he holds the katana like a saber in ep 8.

So why does he not bother to get a sword he knows how to use? Would've came in handy numerous times.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 26 '24

Discussion would you want to live in this era of Japan?

4 Upvotes

I know its depends on what "level" are you there in order to say yes or no
so lets say you choose to live as a normal citizen, not something high class or something like that.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Apr 02 '24

Question Anyone else think this was Fuji? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

My heart dropped for a moment, I was terrified that this bastard was taking advantage of Fuji. But I relaxed when it wasn't lol


r/ShogunTVShow • • May 10 '24

Question Questions about Ochiba's son. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Is her son going to be a king? Will he have more power then all the people on the Council of Regents?

Once he is the right age will he be in charge of a city the size of Tokyo or a larger area?


r/ShogunTVShow • • Apr 20 '24

Question Is shogun mostly in English or is a majority of it in Japanese with subtitles?

16 Upvotes

Can someone tell me if shogun is mostly in English or if it is in Japanese with subtitles. I really want to watch it, but I have a few learning disabilities and I have a hard time following shows with subtitles.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Apr 03 '24

Opinion This Ruined The Character For Me Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Why would they end my man like that? That was the lamest end in the history of Samurai.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Mar 15 '24

Character Analysis Toranaga's son - am I the only one not satisfied with his character in episode 4? Spoiler

23 Upvotes

The first 3 episodes, Nagakado's been in Toranaga's shadow, and his character is a bit of a mystery. But there was no real tension between Toranaga and him that would indicate to me that Nagakado would act rebellious at any moment. There was no hint that Toranaga hasn't done a good job training his adult son to be a capable samurai.

Yet, episode 4, Nagakado is completely messed up. He starts out with a bang, saying the wisest line of the whole episode: "an ally with ambition is no ally". I thought alright, I like this guy! Let's go!

Then, he ends the episode being a complete moron, behaving like a spoiled brat. A joke character whose sole purpose is to push a plot. I felt let down.

In The Last Samurai, Katsumoto's son Nobutada is a mature and fearless samurai worthy of his father's respect. I prefer a movie with a good father and son duo like that. Goku and Gohan also come to mind. And at the beginning of episode 4, I thought that's what we're getting. What a major let down at the end. I feel like they could have done this differently. Or, maybe that's just how the book went and they shouldn't be blamed.


r/ShogunTVShow • • Apr 23 '24

Opinion I know it’s a limited series but it begs for a second season

12 Upvotes

The massive success this show has had, the chance to tell more story and have audience pleasing massive violent scenes… it just feels like an exception should be made and give us one more season.

Just my opinion, ready to be downvoted to hell 😂