Why do you guys think Germany deserved the reparations they received in the treaty of Versailles? They were defending their ally, who had a legitimate reason to go to war with Serbia, which sponsored the Black Hand. Wouldn't it be dishonorable for them to not hold up their end of the bargain and leave Austria-Hungary on their own? Even if you want to say that Austria-Hungary took too long to go to war and had done it in such a way that wasn't sympathetic anymore, did the entire German nation deserve to suffer for the sins of the Kaiser and the German high command?
I know that Imperial Germany committed war crimes against Belgium during the war and had committed a genocide against the Herero and Namquama peoples before the war. As for Belgium, what was the other option for winning a war like this quickly and relatively bloodlessly? And in regards to German genocide of Namibia, all imperial powers treated the natives in their possessions poorly. Did you forget what King Leopold II did to the Congo in the name of personal wealth? Or the Sepoy rebellion, for that matter? And yes, Germany did try to destabilize the UK by supporting Irish nationalists, but 1) isn't the UK just as much at fault for mistreating the Irish?, and 2) while this may not be a good thing, don't all countries try to influence the politics of other nations by destabilizing nationalist elements?
If Woodrow Wilson had achieved what he wanted at Versailles, wouldn't Germany not have had the economic conditions that it did that helped Nazism to rise? Wouldn't it have been a more stable republic not prone to so much public disorder, abuse of power, and weakness to extreme ideologies? The Allies didn't feel necessary to turn Germany and Austria into a pastoral state after WWII, so why were these reparations necessary?
I understand that if the Central Powers had won, the world would look a lot harsher for Armenians, Arabs, Greeks, Assyrians, Serbians, and Poles in the Danzig corridor. But the reparations didn't create the lasting peace that the Allies had thought it would, nor was it in my opinion the best or right thing to do. Germans went through the same deprivations during WWI that France and Britain had gone through, while being fooled by propaganda that Germany was winning. Does that justify the harsh economic conditions, political instability, and national humiliation (like the Ruhr Valley Crisis) of the Weimar Republic?
How does excessive punishment bring back the 20 million lives lost or bring about a lasting peace? How does economically crippling a country help them pay back their debts? That's like a landlord raising the rent dramatically and then impounding your car when you default on your payments.
EDIT: So this is what happens when you lose a bet with a history nerd.