r/ShinobiCCTV • • Sep 23 '20

Why did I quit on Shinobi? NSFW

1 Upvotes

I installed Shinobi because in the unraid forums Spaceinvader One left me a very good impression of it, So I decided to give it a try.

As the time went by, I started experiencing issues with the software (hardware acceleration, video deletion, available videos only for the last day, etc.) So I joined Shinobi's Discord channel to seek for answers.

So I found that the admin was a guy named Moeiscool and I messaged him asking for some info and he was way inpolite.

Then a very nice guy, LAVOY, directed me gitlab to seek for solutions since Moeiscool even blocked me from messaging direclty (so I guess is not that cool anyway).

So I even oppened an account there and oppened an issue with my problem and I saw that many other people in the discord chat had the same issue to, so I told them to support my thread at gitlab.

When Moeiscool saw that I was encouraging people to support my issue, he came here and told me that it was "fixed in the latest dev".

Well I couldn't understand what he said, sorry I'm not a programmer, just an enthusiast. So I asked for more information, and he spent more time erasing my messages than pointing me to the answer. What a shame!

I can live with assholes like him, if he doesn't want to help me, I'm fine, but, he is not either helping me nor letting me get help with some others contributing to Shinobi. And if Gitlab is hurting him, he should abandon it, isn`t it?

In my goodbye post I took my time (I'm a very busy person) and left Moe this message:

"So, dear Moe, you are a perfect Ass! Good job! You made it! I quit on your lousy program, it is full of bugs and way too expensive to support, so I wish you luck in your endeavor, but I'm out!

By the way, I don't give a damn if you block me, or put me in the black list, I just DONT CARE about it! Maybe that is the only way that you can get any satisfaction in your pathetic life!

Cheers!

PS. Here are some Screenshots to show how cool is Moe! hehe."

Here is the link where I left him the above mesage:

https://gitlab.com/Shinobi-Systems/Shinobi/-/issues/210

So, In sum, Moe wants you to pay him $75.00 US Dollars per month for support, If he is willing to help like that, that is a waste of money!!! The program really sucks! and the support is not even polite, but even more, as I said, he does not even let anybody to help you!

There are other CCTV programs like blue Iris, Ok, It costs $ 60.00 US Dollars and if you need asistance you can buy the online support for $66.00 US Dollars PER YEAR!! (Moeiscool, or Moe, wants $780.00 of your hard earned money per year).

So I leave it up to you. My advice is, go look somewhere else, Shinobi is not as nice as it seems!

Cheers!

Edit September 23rd (I'm doing this for the people who is interested in Shinobi).

I was never ever going to write you back Moe, but I'll make an exception since the people here should be aware of what the can expect from Shinobi and its "support": I never used the word "demand" and I dare you to prove it! I was only asking for guidance always in a polite and respectful way. That's all.

You even closed this thread so nobody can have the freedom to write ... Congratulations on your tiny little world of yours: "Shinobi". Stay there Moe, do humanity a favor! Never go out to the real one!


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Nov 02 '21

Getting a little closer to a working system

0 Upvotes

Since installing the Reolink camera having trouble with longevity of the RPi. After a 5 hours of FTP event based recording, almost regardless of number of events, the feed from the monitor GUI drops out and I cannot SSH onto the Pi. At this point I need to unplug the Pi and Re-plug.

I notice that although I have set up a SATA drive /mnt/usbstorage and the RPi is writing to this as a secondary drive, it is also writing the same files to my SSD. I think this is could be the root cause.

This wasn't happening with my previous (cheap) camera when it was writing to the SSD only and FTP events were not available.

Error message showing when events are triggered:

  • lsM9hlOpoh : sst9AvK6818000Traditional Recording an hour ago/dev/shm/streams/lsM9hlOpoh/sst9AvK6818000/detectorStream.m3u8: No such file or directory

Additionally the web GUI seems to crash when my laptop sleeps during a connected session...

I am going to try to try recording to SSD only today and will report back. Although this is not a sustainable solution.

Problems solved so far:

Cheap rubbish camera
Reolink Camera - no longer hanging stream or black
FTP Events
Setting up the Pi with a SATA drive (including reformatting)
PWM Fan install


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Jan 15 '22

Prevent Shinobi from creating folders

0 Upvotes

I am running Shinobi on my Linux box where it records to its own hard drive. The problem is if the hard drive has any issue or otherwise disconnects from the mount point, Shinobi will create a folder in /mnt/mountpoint/videos and bulldoze my '/' partition until it is 100% full.

Is there a way to stop it from doing this? I tried making all the folders in /mnt read only for non-root users but looks like Shinobi is running as root as it still creates a folder and video files.


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Sep 20 '19

Object detection / Opencv etc

2 Upvotes

Lots of super cool things out there in this regard, definitely feels like Shinobi is massively lacking in this area right now ...

I had mentioned to Moe before about using ZMQ to go distributed on the processes etc..

Few links I thought interesting https://github.com/OlafenwaMoses/ImageAI

https://www.pyimagesearch.com/2015/11/09/pedestrian-detection-opencv/

https://www.pyimagesearch.com/2019/04/15/live-video-streaming-over-network-with-opencv-and-imagezmq/


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Mar 09 '22

ios app Beta expired

0 Upvotes

is it possible the app on ios is expired ?


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Dec 25 '24

Is Shinobi NVR the right choice for 40 cameras?

0 Upvotes

Hello All, A friend of mine needs 40 cameras(4k 8MP) installed for them for their business and they did some research and could only get around 32 channel NVR with a poe switch.

So I was gonna help them setup a self-hosted nvr solution such as Shinobi with better cpu or gpu. And my question is, that is Shinobi better than a chinese made NVR such as reolink or amcrest?

Here are the requirements they need.

1. 24/7 Motion detected recordings with some cameras recording audio. Optional AI detection.

2. Grid with multiple cameras in live view.

3. no downtime if possible.

4. easy remote access with ios app availability.

5. up to 50 tb storage cpacity

these are just the few requirements they asked me to solve. Let me know if this is the right solution for them or I should look elsewhere.

thank you and merry christmas.


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Jul 29 '21

Looking for example how to work with Shinobi API in any language

0 Upvotes

Hi, I want to write some test applications which use Shinobi API - just some basics - just checking videos saved. Is anybody saw any examples in any language - node/PHP/ruby


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Feb 09 '21

Platform Questions

0 Upvotes

Hello I am working in a company and we have a monitoring with the cameras on the shinobi platform but we only get audio and live video, how can I do to save these recordings on some disc or something? Thank you


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Oct 02 '20

Save Motion Events as jpeg

0 Upvotes

Apologies if this is simple and I just suck at reading docs. Is there a way to have shinobi save a jpeg to a specific directory on the host machine every time there is a motion event? I just want to have it save images so that I can process them with an external deepstack server.

Thanks!


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Jul 11 '20

This software is the biggest piece of crap I've ever used

0 Upvotes
  • randomly deletes videos instead of saving them

  • randomly fails to delete videos and fills partition resulting in complete loss of configuration -- why is it even rewriting configuration or user credentials regularly when they haven't changed?

  • motion detection basically worthless, after wasting literally days tuning it it's still immeasurably worse than the default configuration of zoneminder. I gave up and set it to always record...

  • can't remove install path from record location?

  • falls back to install path as record location, randomly fails to delete videos, fills partition, unnecessarily saves configuration to full disk resulting in complete loss of configuration??? is this real fucking life?

  • superuser control panel buttons all fail silently to do anything

  • documentation is complete trash

every time I open the dashboard it's another 2 hour frustration adventure to get it working again.


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Oct 26 '19

Sad News Folks

5 Upvotes

Today Shinobi goes toward the #WinRAR approach to get some more funding for the development. In the latest releases of Pro and CE there is a popup window upon login asking for you to support the development. To make the annoying popup go away for good you just need to add the subscription key to your conf.json like so

"subscriptionId":"sub_XXXXXXXXXXXX",

NO RESTRICTIONS HAVE BEEN ADDED TO SHINOBI

You can sign up to any of the plans offered here to get a subscription key https://licenses.shinobi.video/subscribe.

I would really be happy if each person who truly finds value in Shinobi, and hasn't already given back somehow, to please consider Tiny Support https://licenses.shinobi.video/subscribe?planSubscribe=plan_G42jNgIqXaWmIC

EDIT 1 :

I think there is a misconception which is mainly my fault. No part of the product will be restricted. Use it how have you been. Even If i did you could just remove that stuff from the source code. The code will always remain open for you to see and modify. The only addition is the annoying popup box that incites supporting the development of the project.

Purchase any of one of the licenses shown and you can make the silly popup go away. If you are already a supporter like bugattikid or someone on patreon. Then message me! I will generate a life time key for you right now :) It's not only about who pays, helping around matters a lot too.

Conditions for Free (Unpaid) use.

  • Use in a non commercial area

  • Used for non commercial purposes

  • When used for research or educational purposes

  • Testing Purposes

  • Usage by Educational institutions

  • Use for Emergency Services and facilties associated like Search and Rescue Services or Ambulance Services

  • Use in Health Care facility like a hospital or walk-in clinic

I understand that many people feel there is an issue with me being the only actual developer of the platform. That's partly why I want the funding. To help me build a better experience. There are many people who do contribute code or volunteer their efforts but those are their own efforts on their own time. There is no way to really focus that edge without deeper personal connection. I am part of the Shinobi Community to help build those bonds but even the people I see as "Hero Units" have their own lives. They don't always have time to spare. And since they are volunteers I can't expect anyone to answer anyone else or help me code. I can only be grateful when they do. I'm not much of a leader so I don't understand how to direct people. I just make stuff, that's my thing.

Frankly, I admit it's sad that Shinobi Systems has no real developer structure or daily plans. It's not realistic that one person actually handle all those things either. It needs to change. I am in the midst of releasing the mobile app but its quite bad at the moment. I only added the option the get the license because it can be used in Shinobi to make the lousy popup go away.

I'll be real with you, I hate having to do this. I got along just fine for a long time without doing things like this. It's just that the income sources that were once making it easy to say yes to that have now gone. I won't bore you with my drama but I was ripped off largely and I need to recuperate my losses. I suck at business. So if you have suggestions on how I can alter all of this, please feel free to let me know.

I just finished testing the object detection and can confirm it works, so I am going to quickly write an article on how to use it and then edit this post again with the link.

EDIT 2:

https://shinobi.video/articles/2019-10-26-how-to-setup-yolo-object-detection-and-use-different-weights

here is the article as promised. if you all have questions please don't hesitate to ask them here.

EDIT 3:

I've updated the popup to be hideable for 1 week before it appears again. This way its less annoying but I still get to convey the message. Thanks to all who have supported the development and continue to do so.

Also, I hear a lot of people calling it nagware. Nagware has restrictive properties, you can still use Shinobi the same way. It's just that a popup has been added to incite supporting the development.

EDIT 4:

If you choose to remove the notice window without subscribing then you forfeit your right to developer support. Please don't ask for help if you never intended to give anything in return.


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Nov 23 '20

Free Shinobi alternative and better Sw????

0 Upvotes

I tried using Shinobi, But all my efforts went waste.
I tried for 8 months., even after iVideon I tried RTSP URL. Did not work or I did not know how to make it work.
So, I saw this iVideon software and boom, It works flawless with my RTSP from Panasonic IP camera.
I didn't even know the RTSP URL, but It knows and showed me some possible URL's and one of them worked and boom it's working so flawless now and I'm very happy I found it.
Now, I have 22 days of recording for free and paid option for remote live and recorded views with 1-way audio.

Is shinobi even worth more and I missed it?


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Nov 15 '24

URGENT: Enterprise Project for 21K cameras - Want to Verify Hardware Specs

2 Upvotes

I have a large enterprise project that I am specifying, including hardware. I have done some research into the architecture differences between Shinobi and Milestone. For the same project, Milestone is specifying more than 113x servers, whereas the research I did and the configuration I build for Shinobi specifies only 24 Servers. This is made up of 8x recording servers, 6x Database Nodes, 8x Storage Nodes and 1x Quorum Node for Basic and Automated Failover. And also 1x Load Balancing Node for High Availability. The project requires streaming of the following before failover:
1080p Streams
12,751x Streams @ 1.5 Mbps per Stream
1.5Mbps * 12,751 * 86,400seconds * 30days
Total Storage = 3,960TB (3.96PB)

256x192 Streams
9,170x Streams @ 0.15 Mbps per Stream
0.15Mbps * 9,170 * 86,400seconds * 30days
Total Storage = 334TB


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Jun 07 '24

Hello and Goodbye (because of massive live lagging)

2 Upvotes

I am currently evaluating a number of OS NVRs available for Linux.

I tried to use Shinobi some years ago. The problem I had then is the same I have now - (using all different server and cameras compared to then). The live view lags massively usually up to a minute sometimes more. I did quite some reading. I tried mjpeg streams and that base64-thing. Didn't help.

I read a lot of explenations why that is. Reading about it, it seems to be god-given. But then, when I try Agent DVR, Zoneminder, Frigate NVR, the tp-link-camers own UI - with all of those I do not suffer that issue. So it seems not to be god-given after all.

All the core functionality I need (event detection, recording, alarms) might not be influenced by that, the docs I read say. Well maybe. But then also my wife will look at those live feeds, and all that core functionallity does not matter to here. When it lags for a few seconds, what I brought home is crap in her eyes.

So, I am sorry to say. It seems there are many nice features available via Shinobi and the fact that is a NodeJs project makes even more sympatic in my eyes. But then, the whole lagging thing is just a killer.

So, Hello and Goodbye


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Apr 06 '21

Really charging $5 a month just for the Android mobile app??

7 Upvotes

Was looking at moving from BlueIris, but then saw the mobile app costs $5 a month for a license for it? Kidding right?

More than the entire BlueIris yearly support license just for the mobile app?

Im hoping someone releases a good opensource mobile client to go with the opensource server perhaps, then it might be worth moving from BlueIris


r/ShinobiCCTV • • May 13 '22

I run Shinobi with docker and have some questions:

1 Upvotes

Input: Ubuntu 20.04, Docker: 20.10 RAM: 96 GB, used: 67% CPU: 64 core, Xeon Gold 6248R 100 camera H264

I run all cameras with mode mjpeg, when show all, only 6 cameras showed on chrome. I don't know the problem and how to fix. Please help me.


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Nov 27 '20

Auto Organize CCTV Recordings Using Bash

Thumbnail
blog.svarun.dev
1 Upvotes

r/ShinobiCCTV • • Nov 30 '19

Why does shinobi cost so much?

1 Upvotes

Edit: Dev not able to take critisimn, LYING (!), cant answer standard questions, not able to talk about things. instant closes discussion, PROGRAM NOT WORKING, wants STUPID amounts of money. Lets see when you delete this.

I mean, i have no problem in supporting the creators of "free software" - i know its just the popup.

But why the hell you want atleast 5€ a month? I mean xeoma costs for 2 cameras are 35usd ONE TIME (you just cant update when the year is over. Thats even possible with their docker container (you need to set version fixed).

Why not like this? Lets say 10€ for a year of updates? Or 50€ lifetime? (i dont like monthly fees)

Besides this, the support for the docker seems to be terrible (sorry). Isnt the docker created by the devs?

For it to work you need to magically know you have to add this env variables (why not put this in the readme?)

DB_USER root

DB_PASS root

DB_NAME ccio

What also isnt working is change the cron key. I can change it via webinterface, save it, "successfully saved", restart, old key is back... (?) Or i change it outside of your software, and after docker restart, it gets overwritten.... so thats very... mysterios!?

No flame or anything, just wondered why you think its worth so much. (i guess most of us dont have 89123831293912312093 cameras in a company and are actually private users?!)

I know devs dont advise to use docker, but cmon, its 2019, the world is using dockers... :?


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Feb 03 '20

Shinobi in the cloud

1 Upvotes

I've been reading a lot about shinobi but I am unsure of how to use it.
Is it possible to set up shinobi in the cloud as a nvr and then use the api to embed live streams in a website and allowing for video playback and such? And if it is where do I begin? How would I go about it doing this?

Thank you


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Jul 09 '21

Where is the AI Security ON user controlled 'NVR' hardware without a PC?

1 Upvotes

I just started looking into home security and I've come to the understanding that having multiple cameras / security solutions requires a centralized base / DVR / NVR (Network Video Recorder) and additional features may require additional software.

Important Benefits I'm looking for:

  • Good value / Good price

  • localized data, no cloud or company intervention

  • Streaming from home to phone with alerts

  • feature rich ( AI recognition of car/animal/person, PTZ, multiple security alarm types, etc.)

  • optional water leak/fire/gas alarm, Sound or motion alarm, door/windows open trigger alarms

  • 1 time payment, no subscriptions

  • simplicity, stability, and reliability

These are the video surveillance enhancement software that I found to like with some good/bad points that I read about (without testing any of them):

  • ZoneMinder: Has a well received 3rd party phone app (the other 2 don't), been around a long time, no windows software (why?), free, support is lacking, Overly complicated and not worth working through the issues to use.

  • Blue iris: popular, May offer a wide array of alarms (lacking details), paid (that's fine, but the hidden subscription costs isn't), 2.4/5 google app review with many issues (not fine) pretty good desktop software and features

  • Shinobi: uses low resources, seemingly simple and easy to install on raspberry pi and other tiny computers, but creates limitations due to hardware and web interface limitations, issues with the mobile, which isn't officially on the app store, but a 3rd party app called peak for Shinobi is? (from what it looks like on the site, they are different) (deal breaker), cool alternative solution, needs to grow.

There is the tradeoff with all these solutions and I've read people commonly have issues setting up and using these, but the features are quite great and they are improving over time. However after finding these features I discovered that I also have to buy and run a computer 24/7 just for those features!

Please someone tell me why no one is creating NVR hardware with this software preinstalled or able to be installed on these NVR's? It doesn't make sense for a lot of people to have a computer / server running just to run this additional software, rather than the traditional and convenient security system NVR or the modern cloud or small bases. Unless I had many cameras, like 16 4k cameras all recording that a regular NVR couldn't handle, but that's uncommon.

The home automation systems out there can do more on a small device and handle video streaming feeds. Why are open source software groups competing against each other when they could be competing against the cash cow companies making similar products?

There are open source projects that ship on hardware for phones, tablets, networking routers, TV DVR's, and so on. What are they waiting for with these? Security companies (Reolink & others) are starting to implement these awesome features (AI) from Zone minder into their own NPV's or cameras, making these alternative open software products less useful overtime and people buying the easy solution that is marketed at them instead. They are missing the ship!

This software has the potential to compete (at some level) to work on Google nest or Amazon echo or be like other all-in-one home security products that are hot sellers. So why aren't these being made into hardware alternatives like Simplisafe, Lorex Technologies, Ring, or Blink, and others with these great feature/benefits that they have? Look up those products, they are all pretty similar and making bank (They also don't require a user computer server to function).

I absolute like open source software and the project's mission. But why struggle making free/cheap software for years, scraping by with donations when you could work with a Chinese manufacture to make a complete package and those same patrons would be buying the products that fully supports the software development or more. Reach out and try to partner with Hikvision or others. This is a huge market, and has huge growth potential for the group. Don't miss this opportunity!


r/ShinobiCCTV • • May 27 '25

Shinobi gripe

5 Upvotes

I like Shinobi. It’s low resource and the UI is nice. But there’s no world where I’m paying a subscription for a software to occasionally check in on my 6 cameras. And the weekly pop up is absolutely maddening. I’d be more than happy to pay a reasonable one time fee to get rid of the pop up, but these options seem to not exist.

I really hope the developer considers adding options to remove the weekly pop up for a reasonable one time fee. I’d pay it instantly.

Until then, I keep looking into alternatives.

Anyway, that’s the end of my rant.


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Aug 31 '20

Mobile Client

2 Upvotes

$5.00/month for a mobile client? More and more I'm being pushed towards the window based Blue Iris. Sure, have the up front costs for Windows, the Blue Iris Server, and their Mobile Client. But it's a one time cost. Who in this day and time can afford another subscription. Disappointed.


r/ShinobiCCTV • • Jan 25 '18

A Story by Moe : How Shinobi Started

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/ShinobiCCTV • • Nov 09 '20

please add python Tensorflow support so that AMD GPUs can be used for Obj Det

9 Upvotes

upvote it please. just saying a new 400USD AMD GPU performs the same as a 4000 USD nvidia server grade Tesla GPU.