r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Sep 05 '26

Discussion I just realized the reason the Power of the Titans only works on Eldians isn't because they are descendant of Ymir, but because Ymir was an Eldian

Post image
0 Upvotes

I don't see any reason to assume Ymir wasn't Eldian; Germanic tribes enslaved each other long before the Romans arrived.

I think it makes the most sense that the reason Eldians are connected isn't because they are directly related to Ymir, but because they are just the same race as her.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Sep 27 '25

Discussion WHY did Levi forgive Erwin???

Post image
16 Upvotes

I am SO confused. And I NEVER see anybody talk about this. EVER. WHY IN THE HELL DID LEVI FORGIVE ERWIN FOR KILLING FARLAN AND ISABEL??????????? And not only did he forgive him, he WORSHIPPED HIM. Anddedicated the rest of his life to avenging the man who murdered his childhood friends instead of avenging his childhood friends. WTF?????


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Feb 14 '25

Cosplay Happy #eruri #eruricosplay

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Nov 23 '24

Discussion The constant Eren hate shows the naivety amongst the viewers. Eren is not an idiot. He is not a psychopath. Eren simply chose himself and his desires over the world.

29 Upvotes

A popular argument is that Eren childishly wanted an empty world like the one in Armin’s book. But it’s not that simple.

It’s not that Eren literally wanted to see the world empty, it’s that the people there were the source of the awful things that had happened to the Island for decades. So Eren wanted them gone.

The world hated them so much that they were willing to risk the Rumbling to kill everyone on the Island. Even the so called “Innocents” viewed Eldians as worst than trash. Eren said the awful treatments of Eldians in Marley paled in comparison to that of the rest of the world. Dogs were literally treated better than them.

Despite all of this and Marleys continuous genocidal attempts on the Island, Eren still tried to find a peaceful solution so they wouldn’t have to rely on the Rumbling. They were ineffective. The Scouts including Eren’s own friends became unreliable, and time was ticking. He was pushed into a corner and was by himself. He chose to act while everyone did nothing.

I hate that the ending tried to portray him as some mindless murderer when in reality, he had real genuine reasons to carry out the Rumbling.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Mar 28 '24

Discussion Hallucigenia shown on the skin of the titans! Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

The marks on the skin of both the titan and hallucigenia have those strange vein-like patterns. There may have been a better picture for the titan one, but that’s just one of many. But that really shows a part of hallucigenia in all titans from the beginning! Isayama is a mastermind istg


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Feb 25 '23

Anime Why can't MAPPA render 3D as well as ufotable or studio orange?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jun 11 '26

Discussion AOTs manga is much better then the anime overall.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Unpopular opinion, but I think the Attack on Titan manga is significantly better than the anime overall. The anime nailed a lot of the action and music, but it also missed some important details, especially Eren's facial expressions during the "that sight" scene, which completely changed the tone and emotion of the moment for me. I also feel like Mikasa's character suffered in the adaptation, with some of her development and nuances not coming across as well as they did in the manga. That said, I actually prefer the anime ending. The manga ending felt a bit rushed, even though it still delivered the message Isayama was trying to convey, while the anime had more time to flesh things out and make the conclusion feel more complete.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Feb 24 '22

Manga How the fandom is actively ruining my enjoyment of Attack on Titan Spoiler

198 Upvotes

Isayama made quite possibly the most anti-war, anti-fascist piece of media ever. Like the only thing that can compete with it is a Holocaust documentary, and yet the majority of the fandom are actual fucking fascists. The amount of leaps in logic and mental gymnastics anime-onlies and r/titanfolk types to justify what they want the Rumbling to be because "Oh Marley attacked Paradis what did they expect?" when Fritz and Eldiams of his time ACTUALLY SYSTEMICALLY CONQUERED THE FUCKING WORLD is a sight to behold.

Whenever someone praises Floch as "right" I honestly wanna throw myself off a bridge. Floch is only "right" because he instigates and forces himself to be. He'd claim a completely mellow person is violent, kill their pet, attack their family, attack them, stab them, shoot them, and when that person so much as throws a single punch in return, he uses that as evidence as to how he's right, and the fascist side of this fandom completely fucking eats it up. There's not an ounce of critical thinking in these people. The manga's ending fucking proves this. The world is 80% dead, the Alliance has been working on peace negotiations for three years. What's happening during this time? The remainder of Floch's followers create an insurrectionist group, said group attacks the rest of the world, and, shocker, Paradis gets hit in return, presumably. And the dumbass fascists that agree with Floch use the fact Paradis got attacked as to how Floch is "right", completely ignoring the actual context around how that actually happens.

I used to mock publications and YouTubers that argued that AoT is breeding fascists, how could it be when the message is very clearly anti-facist? Well, shit, seems I didn't account for people clinging onto a character very clearly written to be in the wrong, ignoring all the evidence that proves their mindset to be wrong, and propping up a figure likened to fucking Hitler as "right all along".

I've honestly been wishing AoT ended with Return to Shiganshina. There was no life beyond the walls, it was just, they beat all the Titans and now have the whole world to explore. We'd lose so much of what made this series special, but apparently what made this series special didn't fucking click correctly. So many people just completely ignore important scenes from past arcs to justify their baseless criticism of how the story ended. So many people ignore what the show is actually saying to prop up actual fascist ideals, wether knowingly or unknowingly.

I made this post because, I'm honestly done. I'm done with seeing posts sucking off a fictionalized Hitler on social media. I'm done with disingenuous engagement. I'm done with people supporting indiscriminate genocide as a result of this mindsets.

I have friends that love AoT just as much as I do, very close friends. They're manga readers, so they read the series end, but I don't really know their full thoughts on it, and I'm scared to. What if their one of these fascists? What if they turn out to think fascist ideals are the way to go? I don't think so, they never expressed major criticism towards the ending (one has the same as I do, it's paced wacky. The other just hasn't mentioned it much). Both also hate Floch, so there's good signs. But, one of them has friends that are anime onlies. I'm not sure where they stand, I don't talk to them much, but if they turn out to be the fascist types and sway my friend, well, that's a problem.

I don't know, I'm just frustrated. This isn't the first time I've kept my love for something to myself because of the fandom, Star Wars, Spider-Man and Undertale to name some, but this is obviously different. This is more than just gatekeepy idiots arguing online, these are actual fascists corrupting the series fandom. If this keeps up, all AoT will be known for some odd years from now is being that one popular anime that created a bunch of fascists in the modern day. I don't want my favorite anime, my favorite piece of fiction to succumb to being known as "the fascists breeder" despite the anti-facist themes.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jul 29 '26

Discussion Either Annie or her father should've died.

0 Upvotes

Annie is in my opinion the character that's least deserving of a happy ending. She's killed a countless number of people in incredibly cruel ways, she shows no remorse for any of her actions claiming she'd do it again and all of it just to see her abusive father. At least the other warriors fought for what they believed was the greater good, that they were a part of something bigger than themselves.

By the end of it all Bertolt died and Reiner was so racked with guilt over what he'd done that he was contemplating killing himself yet Annie takes a four year nap and gets to skate by with zero consequences.

Every other character in the show had to give up something be it their lives, their humanity, their comrades sometimes all of the above and it makes sense, after all it's a cruel world isn't it? But for some reason Annie is the exception, she kills countless people and goes home to the only person she's ever cared about while no character treats her like the small, selfish and cruel person that she is. It would've been more fitting if her father died and everything she did was for nothing just like Reiner realizing that the "devils" of paradise were just regular people after all.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jul 01 '24

Discussion I feel utterly disgusted even by the mere thought of Eren

1 Upvotes

I know this probably doesn't add anything to the conversation but I've recently seen the last movies and I'm currently rewatching the show. And, oh God, I feel disgust, pain, an all-consuming rage whenever I look at Eren.

I used to like him before he decided to start killing civilians and doing a mass murder, at first I thought this development wasn't too coherent with the rest of the story. Truth was, I was looking at him the same way Mikasa did. It's always been there: his cruelty, the pleasure he took while killing other people and giants, his desire to be free while taking away other characters' freedom. He doesn't enjoy freedom, he just wants to take it away from others. That's it.

He didn't esitate, during the RtS arc, not even once, when he met again Reiner and Berthold. His comrades were all pained and suffering and couldn't really bring themselves to killing them. Eren was the only one that showed no affection. He just wanted revenge, and that's it.

Not to mention, that he put everyone through a lot of unnecessary pain for what? Everyone would have been so much better if he died in the first chapters.

And no, I don't think he really would have gone into the woods with Mikasa, had her answer be different. That was just an excuse for himself. Because he already knew her feelings. They were crystal clear and even Zeke confirms that there's no Ackerman "curse".


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jun 30 '24

Discussion Mikasa did NOT marry or have any kids. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I think this has been a topic since the manga ended, and since it started when the manga ended I’m not including any scenes added in the anime (such as the ring, which isn’t in the manga) even though stuff like that could be easily debunked as a purity ring, or maybe a promise ring toward Eren.

First I’ll start with a logic argument. It’s a simple question, why? The moving on argument doesn’t make sense, you can move on from love without getting married, and do people think Mikasa suddenly found love after Eren died? Even then that guy would be a substitution, and anyone who knows Mikasa’s character and personality knows she wouldn’t just suddenly fall in love, nor what she marry just to cope, it doesn’t make any sense.

Next I’ll go over what we see. So I think by now it’s pretty much common consensus that the child isn’t her biological child, in the manga her arm is still wrapped, meaning the crest wasn’t passed down. Also regarding the man, since the panel is so zoomed in a lot is cut out, it’s possible it was a group visit, so it very well could be Jean who as we know did have feelings for Mikasa, and Jean was just comforting her and they weren’t husband and wife. And I sincerely hope they didn’t because Jeans a great character, and doesn’t deserve to be a substitute. It would make no sense for Mikasa to suddenly fall in love with Jean, especially because most of the time she didn’t acknowledge him as anything more than a comrade. I’d also like to point out the very high possibility that Mikasa was just very involved in the community and therefore adopted. And for some theories I’m not sure if it’s explicitly mentioned, but it’s possible Armin married and that was essentially her niece or nephew that she was holding, might be a stretch but it’s possible. Now back to her “husband” if she married it would have to be with someone she liked or even loved, yet she never took off the scarf, and was even buried next to Eren, that’s not typically what a married man wants their wife doing.

All in all, not only does it not make sense but there’s a bit of evidence pointing against it. From what I’ve read from others ideas, the only strong evidence that she did marry is that the man kind of looks like Jean, and he’s touching her should and with her while visiting. Not exactly very strong evidence I mean they went through life and death, it wouldn’t be far fetched to say they are close friends visiting their other close friends grave together. I’d like to hear what y’all think.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Nov 22 '24

False What are your thoughts on this?

2 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jul 18 '24

Discussion I'm not a big fan of the revelation at the end that Eren was... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm not a big fan of the revelation at the end that Eren was in love with Mikasa. (You gotta forgive the clickbait but no ending spoilers in the title)

This is probably one of my hottest takes, but I just think it was kinda out of nowhere, with very little build up (if any), and most importantly unnecessary, the resolution of Ymir's curse consisted in Mikasa giving up on her loved one for the sake of saving as many people as possible, it didn't need Eren to reciprocate those feelings. The plot could have easily worked without it, with Eren being as attached to Mikasa as he is to Armin, not romantically but out of childhood bond, I guess the word I'm looking for is platonic(?).

Also, the entire basis of Eren reciprocating those feelings is the "I don't want that" and the "I don't wanna die, I wanna be with Mikasa, with everyone else", which is kinda weak imho, but yeah AOT doesn't often spell out everything so of course it could be interpreted as Eren actually loving her, but as I said even if it seems to be the case it's so out of nowhere and unnecessary. The only moments of build up I can think of are when he asks Mikasa "what am I to you" and maybe when they blush during the sunset scene (but in that case everyone was blushing), which is very little and weak of a buildup.

Also, I would have preferred Eren to be completely freedom blinded to the point of not even being able to romantically love somebody, which is why I really can't ship him with anybody in the story (except Frieda x Path Eren for the lolz)

Anyway, even if I don't like it, I'm not particularly bothered by it, I just would have wanted more build up and and indications that Eren was romantically into her, but as I said the ending isn't entirely based on the ship like some ending haters make it out to be. It's just a further revelation of Eren's feelings, but it doesn't take away anything from the resolution of the story and its epilogue.

In fact I'm kinda baffled that back when 139 was released a lot of people completely ignored the content of the chapter and got either super happy or mad at it for "confirming EM" as if that was the entire ending and there was nothing more to it and I was like "why tf do people focus on a stupid ship". I don't like the ship either, or better yet, I don't like the revelation that Eren was also in love all along (I honestly would have preferred it to be one-sided with Mikasa finally giving up on it to make the right decision, or at least more indications and build up that Eren was also into her romantically), but the idea that people either love or hate the ending based on the canonicity of a ship amuses me.

Anyway, the best written romance in AOT is definitely Falco x Gabi and it's not even close


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Mar 03 '25

Humor/Meme Historia mentioned in Ace Combat 5!!!!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Nov 13 '23

Manga "AOT edining is PEAK" the peak in Question:

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Oct 05 '23

Anime Can anyone rationalize Ymir’s (brown haired) decision at the end? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I really did not understand why at the end of S2 Ymir went with Reiner and Berthold. I know what she said but really though?! You know you get eaten!

Edit: Keep downvoting me for having an “opinion”. Keep going with your life, I hope you will never encounter someone with a different opinion. Grow up!


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Oct 01 '23

Anime I think erens friends became plot device at the end. You r telling me none of them would side with eren? Spoiler

Post image
25 Upvotes

i think erens friend became manifestations of righteousness instead of being erens friend. This losing their individual self. They basically became plot device.

They r not perfect . It doesn’t make sense. One of them even wanted to feed a child to his mother.

I dunno how armin isnt in erens corner. Mf wouldn’t be alive if it wasn’t for eren. He shouldnt be alive too


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jan 16 '18

What if Armin is gay?

0 Upvotes

This doesn't prove anything and there's no evidence supporting that.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Sep 21 '23

Spoilerless I have nothing against Samuel Kim, but I do dislike his videos and despise what he's done to the AOT soundtrack as a whole.

8 Upvotes

For those unfamiliar, Samuel Kim is a youtuber who uploads "edits" of songs or pieces of music, usually from tv shows and particularly AOT. His edits are ok at best. I personally think they're significantly worse than their source material but it's just my opinion. Anyway, it frustrates me that someone who doesn't make any original music whatsoever gets so many more views than the creators of the music on almost all pieces without lyrics. AOT's score is nothing short of a masterpiece, but Kim's basically getting more credit than the creators of the music for putting it few a through sound filters. Earlier today I searched for the lyrics to "Dear Friend, Across the River:" from Arcane, and the only artist credited with making the song way Samuel Kim, who made his own version of it. It's probably one of his best videos as he adds much more originality to it, but he's literally getting sole credit for a very well written song across various platforms, and it scares me to think of this happening to Hiroyuki Sawano and Kohta Yamomoto.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • May 16 '25

Video Games Just tried out Attack on Titan Unbreakable (VR) and... what a wild experience!

5 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Oct 15 '18

Manga Spoilers [Manga Spoilers] Opinion: WIT really fucked up this time Spoiler

2 Upvotes

As I watched the 3rd season without reading the manga before, it was very tense in first half, however after the coup the temp slowed down and the atmosphere slightly changed. So when there were no casualties at the chapel and at the battle in Orwud, it was due to the growth of Eren and his friends as soldiers. That gave the comfortable feeling of peace and control and allowed to show Kenny and Keith flashbacks and other calm episodes. In the end the SC is shown as strong as ever, with Eren's success in hardening, Hange's new weapons and unprecedented support from the people.
And at that moment it was clear that Eren will get to the basement and there would be an enemy other than Titans. So the main intrigue was just the battle between SC and Titans, both intelligent and not. And here we come to the thing: WIT completely changed the attitude towards that battle. I feel sorry for Isayama, because it seems that feeling of confidence was developed intentionally.
So I think that scene with Eren, Levi and Mikasa in ED was nothing but spoiler as not just info from the future events, but something that ruins a perception of the show. The worst part is the only reason to show that is the break. Which itself has no meaning, because it would be wiser to split the season right after Historia became the Queen.
TLDR: WIT due to its own administrative problems spoiled the future arc for anime-onlies.

P.S. I want to thank all moderators for this place. Although I was anime-only for just two months, but I'm glad that I could discuss things in this sub without getting spoiled about manga development. While I read that upcoming arc would be interesting and it'd better to wait for it being animated, no one of manga readers said 'Oh, you see WHO would die' or 'Man, that part was dark'.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Apr 20 '24

Discussion HOT TAKE: Eren and Mikasa shouldn't have had a romantic relationship or feelings. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know this might get downvoted to hell, but hear me out.

Through out the whole show, I never got any romantic vibes between these 2, especially from Eren's side. I always viewed their relationship as a brother and sister one and it always felt like that, and suddenly at the end they started going hard into it and it just never clicked. It felt like it came out of nowhere to be honest, especially from Eren.

While Mikasa showed few hints here and there, there were 0 from Eren until that scene at the very end where he just confessed to Armin that he always loved Mikasa and shit. Like.....anime did it better than manga at least, because that scene sucked ass in manga, but even then, it felt like it came out of nowhere. At no point do I remember Eren expressing or hinting his feeling for Mikasa to anyone, he did what he did because he loves his friends and his land, he didn't do it just for Mikasa.

As for Mikasa, I wouldn't mind her having a crush on Eren...if done right, but bro shut her ass down basically at the end of season 2 when she tried to kiss him, bro literally went to fight a big ass titan that ate his mom and their alcoholic friend with his stumps. That is where this whole "romantic" relationship should've ended.

Just to make it clear, I am aware that Eren cares for Mikasa, he does for everyone. However, he seemed to mostly care about her as a close friend, not any different from Armin to be honest. Always thought their relationship was like one between siblings and nothing more. This whole relationship these 2 had would be fine if it was written better, there is 0 chemistry between these 2. Heck, Eren had more chemistry with Historia of all people than with Mikasa.

Also off topic now that I've mentioned Historia, Eren should've been her child's father instead of some random ass farmer who came out of nowhere, I don't like how they ended up treating her after the whole Riess storyline.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jun 05 '26

Artwork Happy Pride Month! (Monster39019096)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Dec 13 '23

Anime People who have rewatched the anime Spoiler

Post image
16 Upvotes

What are the major change of perspective which has happened while you rewatched it??for me it was

I don't see anyone as a hero or a villain now...just soldiers doing their duties

I wish Kenny would have teamed up with Levi imagine liberio raid with him being there

Someone like Erwin not knowing about marley, Ymir and the history of Titans will forever be a major flaw.

Annie was always a psychopath who enjoyed killing people.

Floch will always be the most misunderstood character in the whole fiction... he's like Snape of Anime

And every subject of Ymir was a slave to something.

And finally even in fiction United Nation is useless 😑