Honestly, I think the most realistic possibility for a Confederate victory is one where the Union just gave up and left at which the CSA would be happy but then fall apart under economic stress and be reabsorbed anyway.
But, I thought of another interesting idea for an alternate timeline, I don't like it too much, but what do you guys think?
The South managed to capture DC and annex many parts of the North, Lincoln, and Grant were charged with crimes and executed. Sherman decided then to rally all the remaining Union soldiers out to the last remaining Union states to help quell the chaos around them. The CSA then went on to silence rebellions and kill off any Unionists they found, during this time they decided to punish the Northern States they captured.
All Northerners would be rallied around and forced to plead loyalty to the CSA or face execution, any that survived this process would then be taken to internment zones and be subjected to harassment by Southern settlers moving in and were called "Carpetbaggers". As a punishment for their "crimes against the South".
However, the CSA couldn't take over the rest of the North as their army and resources were withered by Sherman's campaign from and out of the South, so they decided instead of going onwards North, they'd move down South.
The CSA would go on to conquer various parts of the West and South America. The Mexican-Confederate War saw the annexation of Mexico and expansion out South where they would colonize many small South American Countries.
The CSA would also go out to fight the Native tribes and enslave as many of them as possible. The CSA would expand its slave population to South Americans, Mexicans, Native Americans, Irish people, Carpetbaggers, and Blacks. They also only gave full citizenship to Anglo-Saxons, so Slavs and Aryans were treated as second-class citizens. Nonslave-owning citizens also faced heavy taxation and women who didn't get married or have kids before the age of 30 were arrested.
Sherman rallied all the remaining Union states and Native American tribes to form the Free Tribes of the North, who would use guerilla warfare and traps to keep the Confederate armies at bay, they did this for over a century. The Free Tribes consisted of mostly White Americans and Native Americans, but it also had African Americans, Irish Americans, Chinese Americans, and many Mexicans and escaped slaves, the Tribes formed their own culture and identity throughout the century.
During this time, the CSA had plans to have a colonial empire, they temporarily colonized Ireland which fell apart after massive rebellions and they attempted to invade Japan but were effortlessly humiliated by the Japanese military.
The CSA would then face a financial crisis due to how unreliable an economy built on racial supremacy and slavery was, and they were nationally condemned by all other nations, especially when they tried to restart the Transatlantic Slave Trade which caused WW1 which pitted the CSA, and German Empire against multiple allied forces, and it resulted in a massive loss. Still, the CSA remained close allies with Germany especially during WW2 however, it eventually fell out when Nazi Germany allied with Japan and Italy.
Throughout this period many attempts to reform the CSA were pushed by knocked down by the military and mass executions. However, the nail in the coffin was the 2nd American Civil War.
Sherman J. Grant, descendant of General Grant, rallied the Free Tribes of the North for a full-scale invasion. The attack was quick and stealthy and the government had no idea what was happening until they were already at Richmond, at that time they had won the war, capturing Willaim Davis (descendant of Jefferson Davis). Willaim Davis and many other CSA officials and plantation owners would be executed with Sherman's final words to Davis being "This is for Lincoln!".
While the invasion did have casualties, the aftermath was even more chaotic with riots and executions all on mass, however, the USA was eventually reinstated.