r/Sherlock • u/InternationalBox9446 • 2d ago
r/Sherlock • u/BegoGlez98 • 2d ago
Discussion My personal headcanon about Mycroft Holmes (BBC Sherlock) | GB/ES | Spoilers Spoiler
🇬🇧 English version
Hi everyone! I'm new to this community, and I'd like to share my personal interpretation of the psychological profile of Mycroft Holmes, as portrayed by Mark Gatiss in BBC Sherlock.
This is just my own headcanon, based on my observations of the character throughout the series. I'd love to hear your thoughts and interpretations too!
P.S. I'm Spanish, and English isn't my first language, so I apologise if some expressions sound a little unnatural. I hope you enjoy reading my interpretation!
🎩1. Introduction: how my interest in Mycroft Holmes began
The BBC’s *Sherlock* is my comfort show and the one I’ve watched the most times, both in Spanish and with English subtitles. When I first watched it as a child – let’s say I was about 12 or 13, back in 2010 – I fell in love with the series.
At first, my favourite character was Sherlock, but every time I re-watched it and new series were added, I noticed certain behaviours in Mycroft that made me go from hating him to him becoming my favourite. He was a walking contradiction and, of course, you don’t realise it on your first few viewings, but once you know the dialogue and the episodes off by heart, you start to pay attention to the characters’ personalities. That was when, around 2020, I thought: ‘Is Mycroft like this with Sherlock because of their childhood?’ After all, he was an only child for seven years, until Sherlock was born.
👥2. The birth of my theory: jealousy towards Sherlock
So, when one of my nephews was born and I saw my niece’s reaction – she was also seven years older than her brother – I came to a conclusion.
Sherlock needed more attention because he’s exceptional, and Mycroft has always been brilliant, so the way he’s always calling Sherlock an idiot and making him feel inferior might be down to an older brother’s jealousy of his younger sibling.
In other words, he took a back seat when Sherlock was born, as his parents focused on Sherlock (and this continues even as adults, as can be seen in the final episode of series three, ‘His Last Vow’, where they call Sherlock ‘my little Sherlock’).
And Mycroft? He’s just left out. It’s only natural that Mycroft would talk back to his mother when she called him ‘Mike’ instead of using his full name. After all, he felt sidelined.
🔐3. The arrival of Eurus and family responsibilities
Let’s not even mention when Eurus was born a year later. By then, he had already become the eldest, the clever one, the one who could look after himself – in other words, the one in charge of his siblings.
This is evident in the latest episode to date, when Mycroft tells Sherlock and John about Eurus. There, he says she was extraordinarily brilliant, but that she exhibited strange behaviour: she would cut herself to look at her muscles and felt no pain.
Furthermore, she murdered Sherlock’s best friend, Victor Trevor, and set fire to the family home.
Following Victor’s death, Sherlock was so traumatised that he ended up replacing the memory of his friend with that of a dog called Redbeard. Mycroft knew the truth and, although it is not confirmed that he was the one who planted that false memory, it is possible that he helped to perpetuate it to protect his brother from the suffering that remembering what had happened would cause him.
Furthermore, Mycroft ended up becoming the keeper of another secret: Eurus was still alive and locked away at Sherrinford, whilst their parents believed she had died. Although it was his uncle Rudi who initially arranged for her to be confined, Mycroft eventually took on the responsibility of maintaining that lie in front of his family.
Goodness, Mycroft was still very young when those events took place. How can you ask someone so young to bear the weight of all that? It doesn’t matter if he’s brilliant.
🛡️4. The consequences: Mycroft as the protector of his family
He grew up having to be the one in charge, and this is evident throughout the series in the way he looks after Sherlock, protects him and even shows, in the episode ‘His Last Vow’, that he cares for him.
And then, when Mycroft reveals the truth – the secret he’s been keeping – they hold it against him, but they never ask, ‘Why did you do it?’; instead, they’re disappointed and say that Sherlock is the adult.
🧊 5. Adult personality: emotional detachment as a defence mechanism
5.1. Emotional detachment
Mycroft cannot show his feelings because he had to grow up overnight; he had to be the responsible adult for his siblings. If he never felt loved, how is he ever going to know how to show his feelings?
To his parents, he’s always been ‘Sherlock’, ‘Sherlock’, ‘Sherlock’, and only ‘Mike’ when he was annoying Sherlock, or ‘Mycroft’ when he told the truth.
5.2. The need for control
This need for control must stem from the fact that he saw what happened to Eurus and fears the same thing might happen to Sherlock. That’s why he keeps an eye on him, controls him and looks after him; because he’s his brother, even if he resents it and even if he teases him, he cares for him.
It’s the typical sibling row, but taken to extremes.
5.3. Irony and condescension
His irony and condescension stem from having been sidelined and, above all, from having had to grow up overnight.
5.4. Loneliness
His loneliness stems from the fact that he has never really felt appreciated by his family. Even the responsibility of keeping family secrets may have led him to prefer being alone.
Over the years, he has become so accustomed to loneliness that he no longer even knows how to connect emotionally with other people.
⚖️6. Personal sacrifice and a sense of duty
Mycroft is aware of all the sacrifices he has made, and for him, this is simply the norm. At no point in the series does he put his own needs first. If it isn’t Sherlock, it’s Britain.
6.1. Sacrifice during the Eurus trials
Mycroft knows that John is more important to Sherlock than he is. What’s more, he believes that Sherlock hates him and that he is not important to his family.
That is why, if he were to die, he thinks it would not make much difference; that his absence would go unnoticed and that Sherlock would not suffer as much as he would if John were to die, because he would lose his best friend all over again.
Mycroft believes he is not important to anyone.
6.2. Sherlock’s perception
Sherlock refuses to sacrifice Mycroft because he is his brother. What Mycroft believes is one thing; what Sherlock thinks is another.
Sherlock knows that Mycroft is always there and that he is part of his family. Furthermore, from a narrative point of view, I think the writers wanted to avoid portraying Sherlock, as the protagonist, as the villain of the story.
6.3. Mycroft’s psychological development following ‘The Final Problem’.
Not much information is provided, but, from what I can see, his feelings of inferiority and of being a hindrance may still be present.
Although something would surely have changed, it is impossible to know due to the lack of further series. That would become clear if another series or a film were to be released in the future.
💜7. Conclusion: my interpretation of Mycroft Holmes
Mycroft Holmes is portrayed as a cold and unscrupulous character, but in reality he cares deeply for his family, even though he believes they do not care for him in return.
---------------------------------------------------------------
🇪🇸 Español
¡Hola a todos! Soy nueva en esta comunidad y me gustaría compartir mi interpretación personal del perfil psicológico de Mycroft Holmes, interpretado por Mark Gatiss en Sherlock de la BBC.
Se trata de mi propio headcanon, basado en mis observaciones del personaje a lo largo de la serie. ¡Me encantaría conocer también vuestras opiniones e interpretaciones!
🎩1. Introducción: cómo empezó mi interés por Mycroft Holmes
Sherlock, de la BBC, es mi serie de confort y la que más veces he visto, tanto en español como en inglés con subtítulos. Cuando la vi por primera vez, de pequeña, digamos que tenía unos 12-13 años, allá por 2010, me enamoré de la serie.
Al principio, mi personaje favorito era Sherlock, pero cada vez que la volvía a ver y añadían temporadas, notaba comportamientos en Mycroft que hicieron que pasara de odiarlo a ser mi favorito. Era una contradicción andante y, claro, en los primeros visionados no te das cuenta, pero cuando ya te sabes los diálogos y los capítulos, empiezas a fijarte en las personalidades. Ahí fue cuando, por 2020, pensé: «¿Será así Mycroft con Sherlock por su infancia?». Después de todo, fue hijo único durante siete años, hasta que nació Sherlock.
👥2. El nacimiento de mi teoría: los celos hacia Sherlock
Entonces, cuando nació uno de mis sobrinos y vi la reacción de mi sobrina, que también se llevaba siete años con su hermano, llegué a una conclusión.
Sherlock necesitaba más cuidados porque es excepcional, y Mycroft siempre ha sido brillante, así que su forma de llamar siempre idiota a Sherlock y hacerle sentir inferior a él podría deberse a los celos de un hermano mayor hacia el menor.
Es decir, pasó a un segundo plano cuando nació Sherlock, ya que sus padres se centraron en él (y sigue ocurriendo incluso de adultos, como se puede ver en el último capítulo de la tercera temporada, «Su último juramento», donde llaman a Sherlock «mi pequeño Sherlock»).
¿Y Mycroft? Ahí se queda. Es ormal que Mycroft contestara a su madre cuando esta lo llamó «Mike», en lugar de utilizar su nombre completo. Después de todo, él se sintió relegado.
🔐3. La llegada de Eurus y las responsabilidades familiares
Ya no hablemos de cuando nació Eurus un año después. Ahí ya era el mayor, el inteligente, el que puede cuidarse por sí mismo, es decir, el encargado de sus hermanos.
Se nota en el último capítulo hasta la fecha, cuando Mycroft les cuenta a Sherlock y a John lo de Eurus. Ahí ya dice que era extraordinariamente brillante, pero que tenía comportamientos extraños: se cortaba para ver sus músculos y no sentía dolor.
A su vez, asesinó al mejor amigo de Sherlock, Victor Trevor, e incendió la casa familiar.
Tras la muerte de Victor, Sherlock quedó tan traumatizado que terminó sustituyendo el recuerdo de su amigo por el de un perro llamado Barbarroja. Mycroft conocía la verdad y, aunque no se confirma que fuera él quien provocara aquel falso recuerdo, es posible que contribuyera a mantenerlo para proteger a su hermano del sufrimiento que le causaría recordar lo sucedido.
Además, Mycroft terminó convirtiéndose en el guardián de otro secreto: Eurus seguía viva y estaba encerrada en Sherrinford, mientras sus padres creían que había muerto. Aunque fue su tío Rudi quien organizó inicialmente su internamiento, Mycroft acabó asumiendo la responsabilidad de mantener aquella mentira ante su familia.
Por dios, Mycroft todavía era muy joven cuando ocurrieron aquellos acontecimientos. ¿Cómo le puedes pedir a alguien tan joven que cargue con todo eso? Da igual si es brillante.
🛡️4. Las consecuencias: Mycroft como protector de su familia
Él creció teniendo que ser el responsable, y se ve durante toda la serie en cómo cuida de Sherlock, cómo lo protege e incluso cómo muestra, en el capítulo «Su último juramento», que se preocupa por él.
Y luego, cuando Mycroft cuenta la verdad, el secreto que lleva guardando, se lo echan en cara, pero nunca le preguntan: «¿Por qué lo hiciste?», sino que se sienten decepcionados y dicen que Sherlock es el adulto.
🧊 5. La personalidad adulta: la frialdad como mecanismo de defensa
5.1. La frialdad emocional
Mycroft no puede mostrar sus sentimientos porque tuvo que madurar de golpe, tuvo que ser el adulto responsable de sus hermanos. Si él cree que no le brindan amor, ¿cómo va a saber mostrar sus sentimientos?
Para sus padres siempre ha sido «Sherlock», «Sherlock», «Sherlock», y solo «Mike» cuando molestaba a Sherlock o «Mycroft» cuando contó la verdad.
5.2. La necesidad de control
El control debe de venir de que vio lo que pasó con Eurus y teme que a Sherlock le pase lo mismo. Por eso lo vigila, lo controla y lo cuida, porque es su hermano, aunque le pese y aunque se meta con él, lo aprecia.
Es la típica pelea de hermanos, pero más extrema.
5.3. La ironía y la condescendencia
La ironía y la condescendenciavienen de haberse sentido relegado y, sobre todo, de haber tenido que madurar de golpe.
5.4. La soledad
La soledad viene de que él nunca ha llegado a sentirse apreciado en su familia. Incluso la responsabilidad de guardar los secretos familiares pudo hacer que prefiriese estar solo.
Con el paso de los años, se ha acostumbrado tanto a la soledad que ya ni siquiera sabe cómo relacionarse emocionalmente con otras personas.
⚖️6. El sacrificio personal y el sentido del deber
Mycroft es consciente de todos sus sacrificios y, para él, es lo normal. En ningún momento de la serie antepone sus propias necesidades. Si no es Sherlock, es Gran Bretaña.
6.1. El sacrificio durante las pruebas de Eurus
Mycroft sabe que John es más importante para Sherlock que él mismo. Es más, cree que Sherlock lo odia y que no es importante para su familia.
Por eso, si él muere, piensa que no cambiará gran cosa y que Sherlock no sufrirá tanto como si muriera John, porque volvería a perder a su mejor amigo.
Mycroft cree que no es importante para nadie.
6.2. La percepción de Sherlock
Sherlock se niega a sacrificar a Mycroft porque es su hermano. Una cosa es lo que cree Mycroft y otra lo que piensa Sherlock.
Sherlock sabe que Mycroft siempre está ahí y que forma parte de su familia, aunque no sepa cómo demostrárselo.
6.3. La evolución psicológica de Mycroft tras «El problema final»
No llega a darse mucha información, pero, por lo que veo, puede que su sentimiento de inferioridad y de ser un estorbo continúe ahí.
Aunque seguramente algo habría cambiado, no se puede saber por la falta de temporadas. Eso se vería si sacaran alguna en el futuro o alguna película.
💜7. Conclusión: mi interpretación de Mycroft Holmes
Mycroft Holmes es un personaje al que presentan como alguien frío y sin escrúpulos, pero que, en verdad, aprecia a su familia, aunque él piensa que ellos no lo aprecian a él.
r/Sherlock • u/No-Location-4725 • 2d ago
Discussion I would love to see a crossover between Sherlock and Joker.
I think about this sometimes. It would be incredible to have a crossover with both characters, I love both. I especially refer here to the Joker from The Dark Knight Trilogy.
Imagine Joker spreading the chaos and Sherlock trying to stop him. Sherlock isn't rich like Batman, so it would be much more difficult for him to stop the villain. Joker is the perfect villain for Sherlock. He's a criminal genius and bold more than any villain Sherlock could have.
r/Sherlock • u/kraatze4 • 4d ago
Image Hey, it's my first post! Im 14 years old and I drew a portrait of Benedict Cumberbatch
r/Sherlock • u/Vivid_axolotyl • 5d ago
The hound episode reminds of this particular aesthetic. Anyone else feels the same?
The panels are from The Black Island.
r/Sherlock • u/Basic-Information650 • 5d ago
If there ever were a other sherlock show
Id cast either these 2 as moriarty either turkish actor Öner Erkan or i think british actor Jonathan Sayer
r/Sherlock • u/Walk_Strict • 7d ago
I thought this little detail was interesting
So to clarify I’m mostly a firm believer that Sherlock is asexual and is somewhat indifferent towards sex. I’m asexual myself and I really enjoy seeing asexuality represented in media to any degree because it’s barely shown sadly. Just wish there was more representation. People can have their own headcanons on the matter but that’s just my interpretation. But what I found interesting about this scene is how when Sherlock turns John down under the initial assumption that John is trying to ask him out, he doesn’t say “I’m not into men,” he specifically says “I’m not really looking for anything”
Now this could just further show his indifference for relationships with BOTH men and women. Or maybe he has been open to the possibility of a relationship with a man, he just doesn’t care enough to pursue it. Really it could mean a whole bunch of things but I just thought that choice of wording was very interesting. Although funny how for girlfriend without batting an eye he says “Girlfriend..? No, not really my area…” but when John asked if he had a boyfriend that actually seemed to catch his attention more and he actually looks at John. He then just says “I know it’s fine” when John clarifies that it was fine if he had one, and then says “no.” When he clarified again if he did.
Not trying to read too deeply into it, but I just thought the behavior and choices of words really stood out.
r/Sherlock • u/Just-here-for-old • 7d ago
Discussion I just finished series 4, the second time I have ever watched it since it was released
Great performances and it annoyed me less but my feeling is still that the ending montage of Sherlock and John solving cases is all I ever wanted from the show. Not the over the top schemes within schemes mess it became.
r/Sherlock • u/SallyStJohn • 8d ago
Discussion Watson tv series
What do people think about Watson applying Sherlock’s techniques to a medical condition mysteries?
r/Sherlock
•
u/thevanishingnote
•
10d ago
I hand-painted a hidden scene on the page edges of a copy of Sherlock Holmes using watercolors.
Thought fellow fans might appreciate it.
r/Sherlock • u/scaredofdaddylongleg • 9d ago
Discussion DVD commentary links (his last vow specifically)
I have the DVDs, but I like listening to commentaries as if they were podcasts on my phone
There are some on YouTube and daily motion, and there used to be his last vow 3x3 but now I can’t find it
Does anyone have a link to his last vow (or just all of the commentaries in one place)
r/Sherlock • u/Walk_Strict • 11d ago
Image The scene at the end of the wedding where Sherlock wanted to find someone to dance with but couldn’t breaks my heart so bad
It’s so sad because he said he loved dancing too, but it broke my heart that he left because he couldn’t find anyone to dance with… someone dance with that man!!
r/Sherlock • u/crazycat7778 • 11d ago
Discussion I think Martin Freeman is hot as Watson
Like at first hes just the doctor. But then he kinda grows on you. And then...tee hee
r/Sherlock
•
u/Calm-Bat1092
•
14d ago
Discussion Autumn/winter & rewatching
For some reason every November I start feeling the need to rewatch bbc Sherlock
r/Sherlock • u/Impressive_Drink1808 • 15d ago
Discussion Who do you think was the closest real-life equivalent to Sherlock Holmes, past or present?
reddit.comr/Sherlock • u/Walk_Strict • 17d ago
Image I finally got a chance to draw Sherlock
Idk how much I like the way it turned out but I guess I’m happy enough with the result that I feel somewhat comfortable posting it lol. Also I am going into surgery tomorrow for my elbow (I have a congenital dislocation in my elbows that limits arm and wrist mobility, and it’s been causing me severe nerve pain, so they’re going to fix the bone and move the nerve so it doesn’t keep hurting), kind of nervous, as I’m unsure how much pain I’ll be in after, since I’m already in so much pain as it is, so I wanted to draw a character I find comfort in to help me calm down.
r/Sherlock • u/Critical-Situation78 • 17d ago
Found two very meta Sherlock Holmes books (sex & military)
galleryr/Sherlock • u/An_Innocent_Bunny • 18d ago
Discussion Sherlock's Ability to "Delete" Information Is Completely Ridiculous
I'm rewatching the series for the first time in years, and I find myself asking the same question now that I did the first time around: How in the world can Sherlock forget things on demand? I know that it's a TV show, and that it's make-believe, but when he talks about "deleting" information on his "hard drive" (his brain), it's like... What? Are you telling me, Sherlock, that you could instantly forget your parents' names if you wanted to? Plus—and again I realize that this is a TV show, but I can't help but think these thoughts—the human brain is not at all analogous to a hard drive. When you learn a new skill, do you first forget an old one?
Am I the only one to have this reaction?
r/Sherlock • u/VariousBuilding4906 • 18d ago
Discussion Denton Halloween Mystery of the Mad scientist (Sherlock Jones is on the ...
In a world of madness and monsters, one paranormal detective seeks to rid a tenacle creature from the destroying a small building in Denton Halloween. Follow Detective Sherlock Jones as he attempt to unravel the mystery of the Mad Scientist and the tenacle monster. It is a battle between genius vs madness, man vs monster to save the citizens of Denton Halloween. Who will win? The mad scientist and the tenacle monster or Detective Sherlock Jones. Tune in and watch the video on the Run Joe Run YouTube Channel and see the epic battle. If you have enjoyed this video, please hit that like button and subscribe to my channel. Remember to share the channel and video with others and leave your comments. We appreciate our viewers and subscribers. Thank you for watching our videos. Have a Happy Halloween!