r/SetTheory • • Nov 07 '22

Bartone's Finite Primes Conjecture + Considerations

1 Upvotes

To whom is may concern,

We believed that as the value of the prime number increases, the frequency of prime number occurences decreases. We know that prime numbers grow "rarer" or appear at farther furthered intervals as their value increases. We also know that there exists an infinite amount of prime numbers. If the frequency of primes decreases as the value of the prime increases approaching infinity, then mustn't it be that the rate of prime occurrence must infinitesimally approach zero while/(for) as long as this inversely proportionate relationship persists? Therefore, unless for no apparent reason whatsoever except for perhaps this very conjecture that the frequency of primes randomly becomes either a) unexpectedly unpredictable due to a sudden increased rate of occurence as prime value still continues to increase after some point and then there-ons or b) unexpectedly predictable by way of equidistant prime occurences at regular intervals after some point and then there-ons, or has ever satisfied either of these as qualifying conditions, then it is certain that there must exist a greatest/largest "terminal" or final prime number after which another prime number does not and will not ever exist to occur.

the conjecture: if the limit of or on the rate of the generation of new primes is approaching or approaches zero as the limit of or on the value of new primes is approaching or approaches infinity, then there must exist a terminal prime and the set of all primes must therefore be a finite set.

consideration: if the limit of or on the rate of generation of new primes occuring is approaching or approaches zero as the limit of or on the value of those primes is approaching or approaches infinity, then there must exist an interval of infinite duration during which time no new prime number will occur.

conjectured corollary: consider allowing the limit of or on the rate of generation of new primes approach negative infinity as the limit of or on the value of those primes is approaching or approaches infinity. What might be thereof or therefrom be conjectured?

I also posit that |0| = ∅ = {} = -|∞|. Or, if I may be so bold to modify the notation in a creative way, 0 = }∅{= (∅ - [{ + }]) = -|∞| or ("zero is equal to an or the unbound empty set which is equal to the empty set minus parametered set limitation(s) which is equal to a(n) or the negative absolute infinity").

Thank you for your consideration.

u/PicriteOrNot conjecture: "the primes never become arbitrarily sparse"


r/SetTheory • • Dec 12 '20

set types

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 11 '20

Types -Of-Sets Empty Set

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 19 '20

Basics of Counting

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 18 '20

Types -Of-Sets Empty Set, Singleton Set, Equivalent Sets, Equal Sets, Finite Set , Infinite Set, Subsets, Super Set , Proper Set, Universal Set, Complement Set .

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 12 '20

set in mathematics

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 19 '21

My video explaining our new set chart that’s better than the Forte chart

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Mar 17 '20

how has set theory changed the way you think?what life lessons it taught u??

0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Aug 29 '20

[serious] Paradox and Anti-Paradox of Infinity in Set Theory, Part 1: The Return of Kronecker Anti-Paradox

0 Upvotes

[serious] Paradox and Anti-Paradox of Infinity in Set Theory, Part 1: The Return of Kronecker Anti-Paradox

(Apologies if I have leavened the serious mathematics with too much light-heartedness.)

Paradox of Infinity

It is now a well-known paradox of infinity that the √2 (square root of 2) is not a rational number. This discovery, by one of their number (as it were), greatly dismayed the Pythagoreans… who then felt a need to drown their sorrows.

(Sticklers: this can be considered a paradox of infinity since the Pythagoreans could construct a line segment that was obviously the √2, but was not the ratio of finite positive integers.)

But here we wish to look further, to… Anti-Paradox.

But first…

Quickie Intro

Many know that Leopold Kronecker (1923-1891), Cantor’s teacher, rejected Cantor’s Set Theory, i.e. our modern Set Theory (“… not mathematics.”).

But how many remember that Kronecker also believed that the √2 is not a number**?!**

(And moreover, that he believed that all irrationals are not in mathematical fact numbers?!)

For over a century Kronecker has been subjected to no small amount of smirking for holding this mathematical belief.

But now…

Anti-Paradox: The Revenge of Kronecker

It is strange that Kronecker overlooked a simple number theoretical demonstration that e.g. the √2 is not a number.

First some history: by the middle of the 19th Century, numbers had come to be conceived as infinite decimal place “real” numbers, where the integer portion of the number could be any finite integer (finite number of decimal places), and the fractional part would be an infinite number of decimal places that was effectively an infinite series of digits times decreasing negative powers of 10.

So by “number” Kronecker meant what everyone else meant, an infinite decimal place real number. (We’ll generally restrict ourselves here to real numbers, base 10.)

This is Bertrand Russell’s “single point” (see quote at end of article).

If we start to conceive of the √2 as a rational number, we will get a simple equation that we will shorten to:

√2 = (product of first bunch of prime numbers) / (product of second bunch of prime numbers)

Lets convert that to:

2 × (product of the squares of the second bunch of prime numbers) = (product of the squares of the first bunch of prime numbers)

From a number theoretical perspective, this equality can only hold if (necessarily but not sufficiently) the respective primes on both sides of the equation are all of even powers.

But… on the left side of our equation the integer 2 has an odd numbered power!

For equality to hold, it is a necessary (but insufficient) condition that the prime number 2 would need to have a non-trivial prime decomposition, and a perfect square one at that!

Prima facie, this seems to merely prove that the √2 cannot be a rational number…

But we will look further…

How do we know that the rational number 1 / 1 is not the √2 ?

We do not need to present an arithmetic argument; we need merely point out what we noticed just above, that it cannot be 1 / 1 because the prime number 2 does not in fact have a non-trivial prime decomposition (and a perfect square one at that).

How do we know that the rational number 14 / 10 is not the √2 ?

Again, we need merely point out what we noticed just above, that it cannot be 14 / 10 because the prime number 2 does not in fact have a non-trivial prime decomposition (perfect square).

How do we know that the rational number 141 / 100 is not the √2 ?

Yet again, the prime number 2 does not in fact have a non-trivial prime decomposition (perfect square).

How do we know that the rational number 1414 / 1000 is not the √2 ?

It is all but impossible not to see where this is going…

We now ask…

The Anti-Paradoxical Question

How many decimal places do we need for the prime number 2 to have a non-trivial prime decomposition (and a perfect square one at that)?!

Intuitively Obvious To Even The Most Casual Observer:
It does not matter how many decimal places our number has, the prime number 2 will never, in standard mathematical fact, have a non-trivial prime decomposition (and a perfect square one at that)!

Further Look with Finite Induction

We can even invoke Finite Induction (to distinguish it from Transfinite Induction): we can trivially prove that the prime number 2 does not have a non-trivial prime decomposition for n = 1; we can also trivially prove that if we assume for n that the prime number 2 does not have a non-trivial prime decomposition, that we can then prove for n + 1 that the prime number 2 does not have a non-trivial prime decomposition.

It has been brought to my attention that even some professional mathematicians believe that mathematical induction – aka Finite Induction to distinguish it from Transfinite Induction – only proves the hypothesis for a “finite” (bounded above) number of the natural numbers ℕ ≡ {1,2,3…}, modernly known as the positive integers. (This assumes starting at n = 1.) This is not the case. Finite Induction always proves the hypothesis for the transfinite entirety of the transfinite set of all natural numbers. This means it would suffice for all the infinite decimal places of the √2 as well as all other irrationals.

Unsubtly relevant to the topic: I also yet again wonder why our infinity of decimal places goes by cardinals to a maximum of ℵ0 – that’s the best I can do for aleph-null – instead of much more naturally by ordinals, and so out to Cantor’s absolute infinite. We would be more likely to notice that the process for constructing the digit-decimal places must continue past ℵ0 thus showing that ℵ0 decimal places is insufficient. Just wondering…

Anyway, it can be an exercise for the reader to extend this using transfinite induction.

So, even if we had an uncountable infinity of decimal places such as we would if we had a decimal place for every ordinal, finite and transfinite, out past every transfinite cardinality to Cantor’s “absolute infinite”, we would never be able to completely represent the √2 .

This proves that √2 cannot be represented by even an infinite decimal place real number! Of any cardinality!

And a baby step further…

The Revenge of Kronecker…

Uhh… Make that…

The Return of Kronecker Anti-Paradox

The √2 is not a number!

“So quick bright things come to confusion…”

So Kronecker was right.

After a morsel of meditation and a much needed – in these days of COVID-19 – inoculation of introspection, I have become somewhat confident that something like the above might just have been percolating in Kronecker’s slipstream when he declared that the irrationals were not numbers. I am just not sure why it didn’t coalesce from his superego or id into his ego-conscious at that time. But, then again, he must have had a lot else on his plate.

“Long and Winding Road…”

“When a long established system is attacked, it usually happens that the attack begins only at a single point*, where the weakness of the doctrine is peculiarly evident. But criticism, when once invited, is apt to extend much further than the most daring, at first, would have wished.*”
Opening remarks by Bertrand Russell from his
An Essay on the Foundations of Geometry, Russell [1897].

Paradox and Anti-Paradox of Infinity in Set Theory

I intend to present a modest series of “Anti-Paradoxes of Infinity”, to challenge the Paradoxes of Infinity that have been incorporated as Cantor’s Set Theory.

I intend to resurrect the 19-20th Century question of the consistency of Set Theory.


r/SetTheory • • Dec 12 '20

set operations

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Aug 19 '21

On the Logarithm of Aleph_0

0 Upvotes

I wrote this some time ago, and didn't realize there's a subreddit for set theory, and given that the ideas are plainly not traditional, any insights would be appreciated, as I don't know the literature terribly well, and instead approached the topic wearing the hat of an information theorist.

The basic result is, the logarithm of Aleph_0 is an unusual number, that does not correspond to the cardinality of any set, but can be rigorously described as a quantity of information.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/349913208_On_the_Logarithm_of_Aleph_0


r/SetTheory • • Dec 12 '20

directed graph in discrete mathematics

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Nov 30 '20

what is Relation, reflexive relation, symmetric relation, asymmetric relation, transitive relation, equivalence relation, partial order relation

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 11 '20

set types

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 12 '20

all about relations in mathematics

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 14 '20

Basic Gates, Universal gates, other gates

Thumbnail computerscience1626.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 12 '20

venn diagram

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 12 '20

set theory

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 14 '20

Basics of Counting

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 11 '20

operations on sets

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 11 '20

Types -Of-Sets Empty Set, Singleton Set, Equivalent Sets, Equal Sets, Finite Set , Infinite Set, Subsets, Super Set , Proper Set, Universal Set, Complement Set .

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 11 '20

relations

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Jan 10 '21

Permutation

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Dec 26 '20

Multiset and operations on multisets(union, intersection, addition, difference), solved problems

Thumbnail
educationquery99.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/SetTheory • • Nov 10 '21

Can someone help me with my homework? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Let:

U={c, d, g, l, p, q, t}

X={c,g, p, t,} Y={c, d, g}

Z= {d, g, l, p, q}

Find the following set: (Z U X') 'n y

(In this Find section of the equation these are not the letter U but union and intersection)