r/ServerSmash • • Oct 14 '14

"ServerSmash is intended to be a fight representing your entire server, not the elite of the server."

0 Upvotes

How can the SS team say this with a straight face (find it here) when the reps and people in-the-know are admitting that they have procedures for picking teams that blatantly favour the elite (here)?

Cobalt says their procedure is a "popularity contest", in which case who is going to vote for the less known more casual outfits to compete? No one?

Saying that teams will be representative implies that each outfit will have an equal opportunity to compete, a "popularity contest" goes directly against this.

Although Emerald's basic procedure sounds roughly fair (from what little is said), someone in-the-know from that server has said that they plan to bring "THE BEST team we possibly can" for the ServerSmash finals. "THE BEST". Almost a synonym for the elite, no?

If the SS team wants ServerSmash to be truly representative a better job of ensuring that procedures for picking teams are fair across servers, because they blatantly aren't now. However, you (the SS staff) have said before that you don't want to do this, hence:

Can we drop the flimsy façade of ServerSmash being an event that is representative of the entire server and not the elite? It's worn a little thin.


r/ServerSmash • • May 27 '14

shaql's silly SS match ideas

0 Upvotes

I posted a bunch of silly ideas on the SS Staff subreddit, and some of the Staff said that some ideas sound actually interesting, so I'm copying them here: (also, I am very, very good at generating random ideas, but I need other people to tell me whether they are sensible ;] )

1. 3-way matches.

Server vs Server vs Server, for even more fun, more strategy, and... well, not more size, there's only so much PTS can handle, so I guess 144 per faction would be the max.

also, the best continent for that would be Hossin - whenever it is ready. currently there's still a few uncappable bases, sadly :< as soon as every base is capturable, we can start major testing of it (though, btw, SOE, an updated map background would be very useful).

while Hossin is not ready, I guess we can still do 3-ways on other conts. no neutral territories, sadly (unless devs/admins would want to help us, that is)

2. Brood Zerg Wars

organize a big fight, with simple, completely unenforcable rules:

  1. no squads. at all. coordination only via proximity/yell chat, possibly leader/orders

  2. every single participant has to go wherever his individual Mission tells him to go

the goal of that would be testing the Mission system in sort-of-realistic conditions. though it would be much, much better in the further iterations of the Mission system, it could still be fun to see what would happen

considering how it would be hard to enforce the no-coordination, it would have to be not a competetive, but fun-focused match. possibly similar to pickups, with players assigned to teams randomly?

it would have to be pretty big, standard-sized matches. and possibly 3-ways.

3. cross-continent ServerSmash. with multi-platoon coordination across 2-3 continents.

okay, admins didn't like this one. carry on :P

4. Tower Defense

this could have many variables. with or without vehicles? are the attackers allowed to shoot defenders? and so on.

5. No-HUD combat

any kind of battle, pickup-size or Smash-size, with everyone having HUD disabled except for respawns. of course, completely unenforceable :D


I may keep editing this post with more silly ideas (both more ideas, and more silly ;] )


r/ServerSmash • • May 27 '14

A Planetside 2 Article: In the Limelight...Wrel (x-post /r/Planetside)

Thumbnail
redd.it
0 Upvotes

r/ServerSmash • • Jul 20 '14

Just to be abundantly clear...

4 Upvotes

An outfit from one server, cannot play / ring for another Server.

There has been a situation where outfits have approached other servers saying they will / can play for them. Slots for participants MUST be from that server, and not from another.

That involves, any loop-holes like individuals masqurading or ringing for certain outfits. I consider it a massive MASSIVE slap in the face to any true player from <enter server> who wants to play, but cannot because someone else from another server - who could not play for their own - took a participants slot on another server. For whatever the reason.

Not everyone can play in a Server Smash, due to many limitations - whether that be the manpower of an opponent right down to the actual physical limits of a server (I.E PTS). If you wanted to play for your server, but found out people NOT from your server - were playing for YOUR server - would you be happy? Of course not.

Reps of all servers, should - if not do so already - vet applicant outfits. Of course many people have alts, from player chars to actual alt outfits - but at the end of the day, try and be fair and allow other people to play. Don't be selfish, don't think that because you cannot play in a match - for whatever reason, does not mean you cannot play others. Do not take it to heart - or set out to try and get "even" whether that be trollings, or going to play for your servers opponents or anything else for that matter.

Many thanks.

Dotz


r/ServerSmash • • Jul 16 '14

Harv3ster has been banned for hate speech.

3 Upvotes

Harv3ster has been banned from /r/ServerSmash for unacceptable speech. His ban will last for a minimum of 6 months.

As a player, you have the right to disagree. You can be a troll. You can even be an asshole. But the moment that translates into racist, sexist, or hate speech, we will drop the motherfucking hammer on you.

Falcon punch.


r/ServerSmash • • Oct 13 '14

Securing the future of ServerSmash

3 Upvotes

Miller is voting for the selection process today but the real issue is that SS as a whole needs to make up its mind what it wants to be: MLG and all about who is the "best" or low entry, getting all outfits involved into competitive play?

Different servers treating SS differently and having different selection processes as a result, simply won't work in the long run. The SS team needs to come an agreement with all servers about what SS stands for and what that means for the selection process.

Personally, with 90% of the outfits being casual and can't be bothered with hardcore competition, I foresee SS dying like MLG if it becomes more MLG. Exclude the "zergfits" & the smaller, lesser known outfits and you simply won't have 288 vs 288 any more at some point, which is exactly what SS made stand-out. CC/PAL is way better suited for serious competition, but this is all only my opinion of course. At least we need to have some clarity on this, not on a Miller level but on a worldwide SS level. Otherwise you will only see outfits getting frustrated, which is already happening atm.

Update: Miller just decided for the SS selection to be a popularity contest, meaning smaller, unknown outfits or "zergfits" will never be selected. Definitely contrary to the principles of how SS started out to be, which illustrates the point of this topic.


r/ServerSmash • • Jun 13 '14

Every participant of one server should be in the same outfit

3 Upvotes

Like the title says, every participant of one server should be in the same outfit. Next to that, an observer or admin should be in the outfit from each side also. This is to avoid the drama that happened at last Server Smash. As some of you may know, VS side (Waterson) had 7% more pop than NC (Ceres) for a large duration. I'm not saying that it was on purpose, it might have been bad communication on their part (it probably was because all their players were split across 3 platoons and not a single leader knew how many players they had exactly). It might have been 'randoms' after all, but 14 'randoms' all on VS, coincidence? On Ceres side we could see how many players of us were participating by just pressing one single button.

Of course some of you will say: 'I want to see what outfit I'm fighting.', 'I want the other server to show how good my outfit is.' But this shouldn't be the case. Fairness should always take priority over e-peen and skill showing towards other servers.

What if this suggestion is not applied? Well then it's very easy. The exact same thing might happen again. It's very easy to just bring more players than allowed, and tell everyone that they are 'randoms'. After all, the admins can't do anything about these randoms.

Even if this this suggestion is applied or not, the admins should take more action against unbalanced fights. I know this is all for fun, and a few randoms participating is not a big deal in 240vs240, but it might be in 96vs96. Especially if these randoms are actually using tactics and comms ;). So when it happens, they should pause the fight, do a headcount and see what happens. If somehow people keep fighting, then there are randoms participating (because they didn't hear the All-call on TS3).

One last thing, more fun police if possible. Even the smallest random interference (in 96vs96) can f*** up the match a lot.


r/ServerSmash • • Aug 08 '14

[Submission] Emerald USEast Logo

0 Upvotes

Noticed you guys were looking for an Emerald logo on the tweeter machine.

Thought about it, and here ya go: http://i.imgur.com/RT86kej.jpg

Edit: Typo = Fixed.


r/ServerSmash • • May 29 '14

Is there anyone that prefers the 100 vs 100 fights more than the 250 vs 250

3 Upvotes

Personally, I thought the 250 vs 250 was just a huge constant zerg fest and there was no real skill involved when trying to cap a base. All that the fights consisted of was a huge amount of grenades being thrown and very little to do with strategy, at least on a squad based level. I'm sure the force commanders and possibly platoon leads have a lot of strategy on their minds, however as a squad there isn't any, you just throw grenades until either all of them are dead or all of you are dead.

Also the lag, sweet gsus, trying to fly turns my game into a slide show and effectively ruins any chance to be a good pilot.

I enjoyed my times in the server smashes I've been in, and would love to do it a bunch more times, however I'd rather have it with smaller numbers and a lot more responsibility for the individual to preform well, rather than the platoon.

I'm just curious if anyone else feels the same way, or if I am just the only one thinking these things.


r/ServerSmash • • Sep 03 '14

Is it worth giving SOE a little nudge?

2 Upvotes

With 3 empty EU servers is it worth try to start something to get SOE to get us access just like US East Jaeger?

If SOE are still on about competitive PS2 we seriously need an EU equivalent to Jaeger, the ping difference is just too large and massively noticeable for me and others, for PS2 Pick.Up it's fine, but SS, PAL and CC it's just too much.

3 Empty servers which are still active and can be pinged

  • Woodman

  • Ceres

  • Mallory (Anyone remember the ultimate soldier showdown? Top player from each faction got a ticket to SOE Live in 2013, well this is the server it took place on ran by Pro7 over a year ago)

I would try and get people behind me but I don't have the contact with SOE if I were to get people backing me, whereas the SS team do. You ask anyone in the EU who does PAL, CC or SS and the chances are they will all agree, we need an EU equivalent which will also lead to much more even games. Take the CC World Final for example, round 1 on Jaeger, round 2 on (Insert EU server).

SS Tournaments, all servers go against each other twice at some point, one home game, one away game for an equal chance, I remember going against Mattherson, taking 3 hits from someone, get around a corner, hit my med kit and then die before the guy even emerges from the corner and then ADS' as I hit the ground.


r/ServerSmash • • Sep 28 '14

New ServerSmash layout

0 Upvotes

A lot of people complain that the fights are too big and that it's just a game of tossing as many revive grenades as possible. Not a lot of skill is involved anymore in my opinion :/

Of course you can't just say that servers can bring less people, that would not be fair because not everyone can play then.

So why not get the people on 2-3 different continents? Just have 288 divided by 3 and you have a fun amouth of people to play with. Everyone can still play, but they are not playing on the same ground.

At the end of the match you can have that who has the most territory on all the continents combined or who has the most wins on the different continents.

Tell me what you guys think and/or give some suggestions what can be changed in the idea


r/ServerSmash • • Nov 10 '14

Is There Any Way We Can Change How The Match Rules All-Call is Done?

4 Upvotes

Can we please move this to like... 15 minutes before match starts or make it shorter, or just not do it. At this point, if the people who need to know the rules don't know the rules they have no business leading.

That all call 5ish minutes before match starts is incredibly frustrating to most people I've talked to who are trying to finalize organization. At that point you want to go over final instructions, review opening with your SL's and give everyone a quick pep talk. Instead we get to AFK for a couple of minutes while rules that a decent chunk of us know by heart are gone over.

I know that this was brought up to some of the SS Admins during the last match and we were basically told to deal with it. But, I don't see why it's such a big deal. At the end of the day Server Smash is about the servers and the players and this would be a little change that would make our lives a hell of a lot easier.

Thanks.


r/ServerSmash • • Oct 14 '14

Not knowing the exact timer at the end of the match is kind of bullshit

0 Upvotes

So, During the Emerald vs Miller match, I made a tatical call to forgo defending Barrik Electrical and all-in Jagged Lance. After rewatching the cast, the casters were noting that it seemed like a bad call because Jagged Lance just would not cap in time. I had no idea where the timer was, and i'm pretty sure Miller didn't know either. I was sure that Jagged Lance would cap before the end, so I made the call to sacrifice Barrik for it. The cap was within 5 seconds of completing when the timer was called, so I was damn close to being right on that call.

It seems kinda stupid that an important decision like that could be totally bunk due to a timer that neither FC can see.

So, as a solution to that problem: if a base is within 30 seconds of capping at the end, the game doesn't end until that base is captured or the point is flipped back the other way. That way some last second caps can go through without having to prioritize bases when you have no idea which bases end first.


r/ServerSmash • • Dec 18 '14

looking to get an observe cam

0 Upvotes

need to get an observer to make an outfit trailer
can any 1 help me /give me one ?


r/ServerSmash • • Jul 01 '14

Clean Slate - May Contain Babbling. - A prologue to end of the Admin break.

4 Upvotes

Hi people.

I am sorry for the amount of crap you are about to read - however, as i usual do, enjoy the wall of text below. Hopefully people will see what i am getting at, some will see drama - some will see reason, some will see objection

Soon, a few threads on the r/serversmash will be deleted- Mainly because what i see are hotbeds for drama. Even if the threads were for a specific reason - their handling was not. Having a thread to get contact information is one thing - but making a jibe / case point which stokes fires is uncalled for.


Please note - That I have made the decision to delete 2x threads in which Lanzer has asked for contact information for it to become something else (or could be). Mainly for the fact that it is / becoming a hotbed for drama and dissent. The threads were not handled in a suitable manner, at least in my eyes. However, if people see issue with it not being done in A pm, then they should set the example and PM. Instead words / things get thrown about for people to interpret and join in. Do not get me wrong - i do not take the deletion of threads lightly, and both threads had some good points / viewpoints and i have not deleted them because i am against or with the parties involved. I also need to start moderating this a bit more - deleting threads which have either served their purpose, or causing unwanted drama or duress. In future, threads with flame / accuse will not be tolerated. We will establish, hopefully a better system to deal with that sort of thing.


I am at my witts end - and VERY close to packing this whole thing in. I do not have the patience, the time - or the enthusiasm i once had for this. Mainly because i cannot help but feel - that we have gone from something so simplistic and self-efficient, to something constantly muffled or changed and made over-complicated because for some reason, in the eyes of people - we have some sort of obligation to provide for them, to their every demands or calls...wants and needs. Having to juggle issuses and view points whilst trying to remain neutral and transparent - to having to deal with 1000 other issues which i plainly do not have time to attend or sort out, not because i do not want to - but because i am only human And this is not mine, or others full time job (Unless, your name is Odin and have like 4 billion twitter handles)


This has gone from a case of "You bring x amount, you bring x amount - now fight" - to something i hardly recognize now.... There is so much drama FOR A TEST SEASON you would think people were playing for a world championship!. What started off as something so simple and with hardly any drama - we suddenly hit this wall of "drama" and having to have a Fun Police, because people can no longer be trusted not to be trolls! Where did it all go wrong? Has publicity really shot us in the foot? - who knows!

Ever since certain "hype" or opinions have been stated by the vocal miniority - things have spiralled out of our control. We hardly EVER had any "massive over pops" - arguments or the drama we see today. I miss the days when drama was "omg you spelt my name wrong" - not the constant bombardment of either hate messages or someones lists of demands - as if we HAVE to meet them to just appease them.


I am sick of being taken for a fool, people literally just finding any nook and cranny to make their mark - whether that be causing drama - or constantly trying to drag up drama because they want the last say and be heard.

For people to ask for action, who then lobby if that we do not do this, they will do X and Y - for people to say, on the opposite side of the fence "if you do this, we will not do X or Y - People playing us off one another. For us to have to deal with people who in question need "action" taken against them - who in turn don't like it that people are taking action - or that people who have had action taken against themselves, don't like that the people asking for action - or have not had action taken against them! My mind is literally blown at the levels of bullshit people will moan about


People cannot see past their own noses half the time, even me to boot - however, people cannot see that they are not the "angels" - Its PUBLIC test server, not our own personal playground. Yes, as a server you may have controlled your populations - but can you control the public? NO, can serversmash? NO.


Server Smash, used to be an event - where there was very little trolling - where there was NO WRITTEN gentleman agreements - it just HAPPENED. Servers turned up WITH THE CORRECT AMOUNT and PLAYED and had fun. Yes - there was the slight over pop here and there, but nobody really cared as they new they had fun - and that the other people were pubbies. There was no need for funpolice - because back then, people did not see the point of trolling an event, whereas now - the seeds of dissent have been sown, and we are suffering because said seeds have been allowed to be spread, whether that be from specific cliques, or bands of special snowflakes - or by people who think they feel wronged because they forsee us an organisation of having some sort of "obligation" to the public to be some sort of vending machine they can just take candy from and bugger off until it comes again.


People need to start being realistic, especially in concerns to what Server Smash is - in its current state. Hell, we have hardly left the stable and people are getting too far ahead of themselves.. hell.. we are still in the goddamn admin break and people are already saying that for some unknown reason - when we leave it, we are doing some sort of "proper season" - and when i say otherwise, i am muffled with "test season aint flying with anyone" - BECAUSE, people have been made to see this as something that it is NOT YET READY TO BECOME.


I have tried to take this steady, yes - it has grown with momentum and people jumping on and steering this in this way and that, however - we have gone from a crawl to a sprint.


People expect a lot from us, where it has become almost a second job. Most people, who truely know me - will know i refer to this as my baby, in the hands of friends and family, however - i cannot help but feel that people are making the baby grow up too fast, and now its become a teenager and becoming rebellious, or atleast subverted by rouge / outside influence and shaping it into something else.


I, and many others - have sacrificed their own time to make this what it is today - We still have a long LONG way to go, I will not have the time and effort - put in by so many people sullied because someone decides he wants peoples heads on a chopping block! Or that people have thrown their rattle out of the cott because they have not got their own way / we have given into their demands. That we have not done X or Y even though they are "the most love man on x server".


The amount of bullshit, drama, death-threats and general pitchforkness makes me, everyday - wonder why i have bothered - why i and others have put so much of our own time, money - and effort into this, to see it just crushed up and thrown back at us like a failed exam sheet. To see this somehow descend into a second job, because i for one - now dread refreshing my reddit inbox, my Twitter DM or any other medium, because i know for a fact - i will spend the Little spare time i have TO MYSELF, dealing with OTHER peoples drama. Whether that be some major accusation, or someone being salty because they lost / think we are to blame.


It is becoming a second job, it should not have to be. We should not be in a position where we are percieved to have to feel obligated to put on a show. To be pressured into doing things we all know we cannot do. We have had a few instances, where giddyness and opportunity has striked, and we have rolled with it - but it won't roll for ever. We will run ourselves into the ground, in which on that path i am half the way to china.


People need to take a step back, look at this for what it is. A Community run event, made and staffed by members of that community. Not some Junta which is some sort of dictatorship which imposes "stupid rules" or does not meet a players expectations / demands. Realize what PTS is, our limitations - and see that the vast majority of our problems are well out of our control. Sportsmanship and gentlemens agreement and peoples word is all we have, until we get the support we truely need.


Server Smash will not prosper, if we are at each others throats because someone thinks their idea is superior, then again - if we please some people, we upset the others and vice versa. Its a hard game to play, whilst also trying to enjoy ones self in a game that I truely love to play - sadly, when i actually get to play - and not having to deal with playground-like issues.


Everyone is entitled to their opinion, feedback is much appreciated - we are not perfect, yes - our methods may seem rash, drastic - or downright thoughtless, but we do the best we can, with what little time / resources we have at our disposal.


If everyone could start working together again, working towards the general betterment of Server Smash, setting an example for any other future Community run event -

That would be great.


With the admin break still on-going, there is going to be a lot of changes. Mainly the way our organisation is run. Yes - i want things to be better run, but its a slow walk up a steep hill. Things WILL go wrong, not because we want it to go wrong - but because things will inevitably go wrong somehow or somewhere. We will be moving to a more council-like approach, our infastructure is not efficient enough to run with this, it was a good temp-solution but the time has come to start locking down the true foundations for this event. Things will change, and people may not like the changes we are about to make - it is only natural. However, for the future of this event - and many other community events - we need to work through the growing pains and create something better.

  • Council / Structural change - Before, our strucutre was only visible to admins & staff, soon...hopefully people will know who to contact. A lot of stuff is going to the wrong people as it is - only spreading more confusion and hate.

  • Rep Codex - The do's Don'ts and general insight into what a rep should be, and how they conduct themself. More importantly - that this is not their second job, and should not feel pressured into doing the role, especially when Real Life comes first (For those lucky enough to have one)

  • Investigations / Fun Police Reports - Hopefully we can come with a way of showing what we find, without the name and shaming - Logs and data can be quite hard to interpret and shown in that regard - but we will do our best, to at least show that we are at least taking an interest. However - on that note, people must be aware of what limitations / things we are powerless in, before coming to us with any sort of drama. Hopefully - if or when we get a vid/pod cast, we can perhaps do something more.

  • Getting back on track, as a community event - and not a train driven by the select vocal minority. This will be hard, especially when people are more influential than some. It could be argued things were more efficient / civilised back in the day due to low interest / lower numbers and a tighter community, whereas now server smash is backed by more wagon-jumpers than "true believers". We Want your feedback, but as constructive critsism and not with a pinch of death-threat.

  • Myself, and other staff - becoming less transparent. Yes, it sounds like a complete turn-around, however it is becoming more and more harder for my to constantly take my own free-time to constantly reply to people. Especially when, i think its good to do - when in fact people perceive it as myself and others trying to be dictators. Not to mention the many, many occasions where i have become defensive of my baby and almost snap, coupled with the over-flow of drama i am and others are trying to sort out, all coupled together to make one giant poo to deal with. The amount of sleepless nights / talking till 4am my time in order to get things to go smooth / happen is something i and other cannot do for ever - We must all take a step back and see things for what they are, hence why we went into admin break - because it has got to the breaking point.


At the end of the day, we have hardly left the stable - never mind at the start dock. Help us, make this better - Work with us, and not against us - and we will try and do the same - Unless your lanzer, who will just sleep with you

Many thanks

A very, very Tired Dotz0r.


P.S - I appreciate all the hard work, done by members of staff - who have ALL taken their OWN FREE TIME out to help create something quite impressive in the short time span that we have had. To all players, and viewers who have played, enjoyed - and watched, and enjoyed the streams. To all the Fun Police - who have recently come into the fray to help prevent the ship from sinking before its even left port. To SOE for being that silent middle man, who appears when needed for an event they have no obligation to support.


r/ServerSmash • • Feb 04 '15

Rules Inquiry

4 Upvotes

I want to preface this discussion with a thank you. I appreciate what Server Smash is and what it has become. The SS admins work tirelessly providing a much needed event to PS2 that on some levels is what PS2 on live should be but isn't. This event itself has prevented me from quitting the game multiple times, always looking forward to the next match.

To start, I ask that a Server Smash Admin please answer these questions to the best of your ability. Your answers are important as they effect everyone who participates in Server Smash. Organizers of these events should make it one of the main priorities to ensure that rules are followed, enforced and understood for all involved in these matches. It is crucial to ensure that everyone plays under the same set of rules to ensure fair play and penalized for not doing so. I am asking these questions because Server Smash matches are coming in a few weeks and it would be really helpful to have answers to these questions, so that servers can start creating/changing their rosters with these rules in mind.

  1. Is Server Smash still an inclusive event? By inclusive I mean not allowing to discriminate against people who want to play based upon gender, race, age, religion, country, language, marital status, skill nor outfit. Inclusive being anyone who wants to play is given the opportunity to play.

  2. If Server Smash is still an inclusive event, do you still have rules/guidelines that restrict servers from stacking teams with the best outfits on their respective servers?

  3. If team stacking is still not allowed, what is your interpretation/definition of team stacking? A full platoon from a single outfit that is considered to be a top outfit on their respective server? Or possibly multiple top tier outfits on their server that are given 2 or more squads? Team stacking is a rule that is incredibly subjective and open to interpretation depending on who you ask. I want to ask the people whose opinions are essentially the most important regarding this rule, the SS admins.

  4. Assuming team stacking is against the rules, what sort of enforcement policies do you have in place to ensure that servers are following the rules? What sort of penalties are you prepared to give players, outfits or servers for breaking such rules?

I and others have had these lingering questions for many months now. To my knowledge they have not been publicly answered. I have brought up similar questions with SS admins before and they haven't been answered. I'm giving you guys an opportunity to be completely clear regarding these rules.

Thanks for reading and taking time out of your busy day to publicly set these rules straight. I wanted to go through my SS reps to get these answers, but I was given permission by one of them to come here and inquire about these rules.


r/ServerSmash • • Apr 27 '14

Waterson vs Connery - from BRIT's perspective

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/ServerSmash • • Oct 20 '14

When is the "coin" toss for Emerald vs Connery to pick warpgate/fraction?

0 Upvotes

r/ServerSmash • • May 31 '14

Cobalt too few, or Miller too many?

2 Upvotes

There was quite clearly overpopulation going on in the Miller vs Cobalt Sever Smash. 5% at game's start. Rose higher and feel back down again as game went on, ending at nearly 10% VS overpop.

That's either 20+ people who failed to turn up for Miller at the start, in which case Miller squads that were lacking numbers SHOULD have made it clear to to Commander/Admins so reserve outfits could fill in.

  • OR -

Cobalt brought too many.


Either way, this is a problem that needs to be solved. Perhaps even 100v100 ServerSmashes on lanes would be better as population overpop plays a less significant role. With these numbers, 2-3% doesn't look like much with 400 people on the continent, but that's still 8-12 people in a whole new squad.

EDIT: I'm not saying it's anybody else's responsibility beyond Miller's, all I'm requesting is that ServerSmash organisers put a simple system in place as a "cut-off" for outfit players to turn up. At this point, the server rep's are prompted to check around the squads for numbers, and if any squad is unfilled, then the reserves are put into place ready for the interviews - once again, all the work done by server rep's. No work for Smash Organisers beyond setting a point in time where they say "reps, check your numbers, get reserves into place if needed".


r/ServerSmash • • Jun 15 '14

Match Documents - Outfit Declaration.

3 Upvotes

Hi guys.


TLDR Version

  • Outfits on the Document are the only people who are supposed to be there.

  • Outfits/Servers are to Declare the amount of numbers of players an outfit etc is bringing.

  • Outfits which are reserves / subbing an outfit - need to be declared / amended on documents.

  • Reserves ARE NOT to be on PTS - PERIOD Regardless of staying in warpgate.

  • Substitution must be made aware to the admins - or more importantly the FUN POLICE.

  • Server Reps, and players are to head-count their own outfits/squads/platoons and so forth before the match

  • IF an outfit/server has a reserve pool - they are NOT to be in their outfits channel, they are to be collated in a reserve channel. To allow a headcount to be performed

  • People with no tags, particpant or not - will be treat as a non participant. Especially if their name does not match a name on Teamspeak.

  • If a server is running short of numbers, they are to INFORM an admin or their rep IMMEDIATLY. Head counts should be done WELL BEFORE match start.

  • Reserves are NOT to be brought on if the population is not in your favor, there is a good chance the pop is askew due to public players, bringing a squad(s) of organized players REALLY puts the "overpop" faction at a disadvantage. If an outfit is not on the declared list > then they will be asked to leave or face future barring.

  • EVERYONE is to be on the Teamspeak, in order to be counted. People missing (i.e crashed etc) need to be accounted for so we can factor them in. This will be a Rep / nominee responsibility.

  • Server Recruitment threads are not to be made, if a servers team is already locked in. Especially if they make it out as if it is an "turn up on the day" event.

  • People are already saying the Matt / Wat game is a "turn up and play" - This needs to be squashed.

  • We MAY have to get people to logg off PTS once the map is prepared leaving only the third faction fun police to defend the map. - **Once everyone is off, we will see the % of pops (randomers) and then factor it in and do the math once everyone is brought back in <x amount of time before the match> Note : MAY HAPPEN

  • **This is not an "official" response, just a pre-lude to what is already being discussed behind the scenes during this admin break, for the sake of transparancy and to give people a look into our thoughts / feelings. Not to mention to give a semi-official response to any potential drama over anyone thinking they were underpopped / overpopped / cheated and so forth.


Long ass rabble version

This could probably have been placed better in the staff reddit, however - there is a general consensus that the public also need to understand a few things. Mainly, word of mouth and the fact that people need to educate their own server-players on a few things. Most importantly - that this event is a sign-up event. You don't contact a rep and sign up - you are not supposed to be there, as this is NOT a turn up and play event. If servers see Outfits they know, but know they are not participating then it needs to be handled in-house as their presence could influence the populations - already askew due to randomers.

There has been some fuss about servers bringing in extra squads for whatever reason which obviously will influence the overall population. Servers will say they were reserves staying behind the lines, or whatever. - It stops. ONLY participating outfits, DECLARED on the google match document are allowed to play. Any Declared RESERVES are to stay either on TS or on their own TS. They are not to go onto PTS.

With the match document - when a rep / outfit leader adds his or her outfit to the document, they - in future are to also declare the amount of player they are bringing. This will take effect immediately for any future match documents or signups. If an outfit says they are bringing 12, but ends up bringing 14 - then their 2 reserves need to seperate from their outfits mate channel - i.e sit in a reserve channel. This is so, that in future, we can see how many people are in a channel - then cross reference it with the document to see if an outfit has the amount they declared.

Head-Counts and number checks WILL HAPPEN. This is a REP Responsibility to make sure they have the correct amount of players online

Server Reps and players are to not indulge other outfits with the prospect of the chance they can "Just turn up on the day" and play. Numbers MUST be accounted for. If an outfit / squad does not turn up - then feel free to bring in a reserve last minute squad HOWEVER it needs to be declared to the admins. I.E "[ABC] is now taking over [DEF] slot". So if we see ABC, we can say "nope".

Unless people are in the same outfit, it will be hard to really see how many participants we have for each server, as people may be online on TS - but not on Live, or vice versa. A same-outfit would show us "outfit members online", which should be 240. No more, no less. However - with people wanting their own outfit tags, enforcing numbers is harder. Its a public test server - randomers happen. We cannot stop them from playing, the least we can do is TK them or ask them nicely not to interfere. What makes matters worse is people who are participants, not using either outfit tags / live name / server tag etc.

If a server sees outfits who are from their server, but not playing - then they need to do the right thing and say "sorry guys, this was a signup affair". In future, there is to be no threads of recruitment which alludes to the idea that people can just turn up, especially if the teams are already locked own

There seems to be a bit of a drama, with the Ceres / Waterson game. Ceres says Waterson brought 2 undeclared squads. Which were not on the Match document. Whether or not that was a rep decision or people just thought they could turn up, i don't know - but reps need to start either head counting or double checking they have who said they are turning up. If they are having problems with either numbers or turn ups - then they need to let it be known. (Hell, even during a woodman game - they had less than needed when they started)

I am sure other servers have had this done to them by either people turning up on the day expecting to play or by randomers just happening to be on that faction (imho, there is already people saying this weekend is "join in and play event")

We have no tools available to really enforce the populations. The only thing we have is match documents - which tell us which outfits are playing for what sever, the only improvement being - that on these lists we need to start seeing "numbers" next to it. That, or we massively enforce the Server-Outfit rule (The evidence / cases are REALLY piling up for it at the moment - who knows, maybe i will release some of these reports)

If a server has a problem with another server, whether that be number problems or questions or concerns - they need to start dialogue. In future - Both representatives from BOTH servers are to head-count participants and "Check off" outfits from the document OR AMEND where necessary.

In what other ways we can enforce populations, or ratio in populations i have no idea. Who knows, maybe we need to prepare the map - get EVERYONE - WHO SHOULD BE ON TS, to logg off PTS so that we can see what "percentage" is left over - take note - then allow everyone to go back onto PTS maybe 20-30 minutes or w/e before match start. Then once everyone is back on PTS - We see the difference and do the math.

In order to really start enforcing stuff - we are going to have to start being Anal about certain things. Roster - submissions are on the cards, not set-in-stone rosters, but say 1 hour before the match or <insert time> outfit leaders are to fill out a google doc of all their player names so then we can cross-reference the list when the match starts - if we see a name which is "not down as playing" we will move them to the reserve channel. We will then search for that name on PTS with what little tools we have (MK.1 Eyeball) and see if they are participating.

People caught playing whilst un-declared will be asked to desist and leave the PTS server. Unless they are subbed for someone (who does not return) and an admin is informed (This may be tedious / annoying).

If - before or during the match, an outfit who is brought in needs to be declared to the admins and the reason for them being there. Especially if they are not on the match documentation. There is to be no exscuse of "well, they have a higher population - so we brought our reserve squad(s) in" - because for all you know, their overpop might be down to randomers. Picking out outfit tags, between a sea of other outfit tags - then cross referencing them manually is tedious and inefficient. My personal opinion is that it would lesson the strain / work if servers used a server outfit - as people who did not, for example have a [WOOD] tag - would stick out like a sore thumb because its different. Now i know we cannot influence people joining the outfit who are not participant and playing anyways - but when it comes to randoms it makes it somewhat easier.

That being said, we are in the middle of an Admin break - and this is not a final say / official. This is just my feedback on on-going drama as people have already started demanding that i make an apology or that things need an official response - to things i have basically said could be sorted out behind closed doors.

A more official statement on things such as Server Outfits, Rules , Documents, Ways of doing things, protocol will come after the on-going admin break discussions.


r/ServerSmash • • Apr 24 '14

found the FNO culprit! RedolentBastard!

Thumbnail
twitter.com
3 Upvotes

r/ServerSmash • • Oct 26 '14

Twitch buffering makes for a poor live stream experience. Anything that can be done to improve this?

0 Upvotes

Talking about the Miller/Cobalt match, though the issue is not limited to that stream.

After 20 seconds of buffering I get to watch 10 seconds of incoherent video segments (probably loads 5 seconds, skips a couple of seconds, shows another 5 seconds, then back to buffering).

I've already tried the VLC media player solution which ended up with Fara talking in a loop and some obscure IP block solution, without success.

Back in spring I've watched one match that had the same issue for me, although somewhere after the 1 hour mark (and only then), finally there was the quality settings button available that let me set the quality to very low. Granted, I didn't see much due to pixels but at least I had a fluent visual and audio experience and enjoyed the show.

I've read that quality options for twitch live streams is only available for "twitch partners" or from a certain viewer count. Is this a thing? Is there a way to enable the low quality?

Help! Thank you.


r/ServerSmash • • Sep 28 '14

Suggestion/contstructive criticsm regarding the way ServerSmash teams are formed

4 Upvotes

Hi guys,

I'd like to discuss the current methods that each server is using to pick outfits/individuals to compete in ServerSmashes. The procedure seems to vary wildly from server and to server, which I think it something that might need to be looked at because:

  • It can lead to an unbalanced playing field.

  • I have heard allegations that team recruitment practices are favouring certain elite outfits, which isn't in the spirit of ServerSmash as a community-orientated event.

  • It causes lots of unnecessary drama.

  • Having the inevitable who gets to go and who doesn't argument and the which-method-are-we-using argument every ServerSmash is a waste of time.

So here is my suggestion:

Rather than having five different systems for determining who gets to play a ServerSmash, how about having a single fair procedure that is determined by the ServeSmash staff?

I believe /u/JusticiaDIGT already has a fairly good system involving randomization that could be used for this.

Regards, Ruvan


r/ServerSmash • • Sep 04 '14

Can someone better explain character creation for events on Jaeger?

0 Upvotes

Our outfit is looking for information on how the characters are created, are they ported over from another server or do you get connected sometime before? In looking at past events, I was only able to glean a little information and I could not find this information in the gutter on the right.


r/ServerSmash • • Feb 08 '15

Besides SS, what other events should PSB do? or Put more effort into?

5 Upvotes

Any ideas, suggestions - feedback etc, i would love to hear!