I’m curious how other screenwriters have experienced the subjectivity of professional screenplay evaluations, particularly when different readers reach radically different conclusions about the same material.
For context, I wrote Maccabæus, a historical action feature about the Hasmonean Revolt (the story behind Hanukkah). It’s recently started gaining some industry traction, including a win at the Big Apple Film Festival, placements in several other competitions, and a growing number of industry requests to read the screenplay.
But one thing that’s surprised me throughout this process is just how wildly inconsistent professional evaluations can be.
I’m not talking about ordinary differences in taste, or one reader liking a script a little more than another. I’ve had the same draft receive glowing assessments from some professional readers and decidedly mediocre ones from others. It’s won a competitive festival category while failing to make the first cut at considerably smaller competitions.
What’s really fascinating, though, is how often the evaluations directly contradict one another on matters of craft.
The very elements one reader identifies as the screenplay’s greatest strengths are sometimes singled out by another as its most significant weaknesses. Dialogue praised as elevated and compelling by one professional is described as awkward by another. The same storytelling choices can apparently demonstrate exceptional craftsmanship or serious deficiencies, depending on who’s reading.
I recognize that my particular project has some additional complications. It’s an unapologetically Jewish story, and I’ve encountered readers who openly acknowledged difficulty engaging with the material because of their feelings about the State of Israel, despite the screenplay being set more than 2,100 years ago. 👀
It’s also a historical war epic, which inevitably raises questions about production costs. There are war elephants. That’s on me. Well, technically, that’s on history. 😆
So I understand why this particular screenplay might be polarizing. What I’m less sure about is whether that explains the extraordinary divergence in professional assessments, or whether screenplay evaluation itself is simply far more subjective than I’d appreciated.
I always assumed that, while tastes differ, experienced readers would generally recognize strong writing as strong writing, even if the material wasn’t for them. But when professionals reach diametrically opposed conclusions about the exact same aspects of a screenplay, it makes me wonder how reliable these evaluations really are as measures of craft.
Has anyone else experienced this? Not just wildly different overall reactions, but professional readers identifying the same specific elements as both exceptional strengths and serious weaknesses?
I’m genuinely interested in hearing other writers’ experiences, particularly whether you’ve noticed any patterns in the contradictory feedback you’ve received.