I was like 12 when Scary Movie came out, and I watched it at a sleepover with my friends. I don't think I'd even seen Scream yet. I thought it was hilarious, and even though I didn't get some of the references, a lot about Scream was just in the zeitgeist at that point.
It was probably only a year or two year later that I very passionately got into Scream. I had the Trilogy box set on DVD and loved all three films that existed at the time.
Now that I know and love Scream, I kind of hate Scary Movie. It is the lowest common denominator comedy. It's rated R, and is clearly going for the teen/grossout/sex comedy thing that was repopularized in the wake of American Pie, but I feel like it's really best enjoyed by 12 year olds. It's a dumb movie.
Doofy, in particular is a horrible character. Offensive depiction of developmental disabilities aside, it's just an insult to David Arquette's performance which is wonderful and nuanced and a huge reason why I love Scream.
Anyone else dislike Scary Movie?
UPDATE: I watched Scary Movie for the first time in 23 years.
I needed to have a little more information, and really wanted to know how I felt about the movie now, as opposed to just based off my memory.
I will say, it was a lot better than I remember, but still have some big issues with it.
I expected not to laugh at all, but that was not the case. For every joke that doesn't land, there is one that does.
I was most impressed with how faithful the recreations of Scream and I Know What You Did Last Summer were. All of them being Miramax (Dimension) films, it seemed like in many cases they were using the exact sets, locations, or reconstructing them perfectly.
Not sure what this says about me, but I laughed the hardest at the random violent moments, such as the kids getting hit with the baseball bat in the beginning, Cindy getting wailed on in general by the Ryan Phillipe proxy, or Buffy getting whacked in the head with a vase full of flowers at the pageant. Also thought the throwing Grandma down the stairs and blasting her with the piano was pretty great.
Doofy and the gym teacher were just as rough as I expected. I hate basically all those scenes.
One thing that helped my enjoyment was being very familiar (now) with all the source material.
The gay stuff was pretty funny, I thought. Being gay myself, I expected to find this part the most offensive, but in the end I felt like it was actually pretty good satire of closeted jock types, many of which I've become very familiar with since I first saw the movie 😉
So I retract my scathing opinion, and give it more of a lukewarm review. It's not as bad as I thought, it does fall flat at many points, and I probably will not watch it again for 20 more years.