r/Scotch • • Jun 08 '26

Glenmorangie 18 "The Infinita"

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Scotch • • Jun 16 '24

Ok, screw bourbon, I want to be a scotch man!

0 Upvotes

All my coworkers and friends are into bourbon, but I dont want to follow the crowd. I want to be my own man, and I believe scotch to be higher quality whiskey anyway.

So far, ive tried Johnnie Walker Gold Label, Black Label, and I just bought Famous Grouse today.

Can you all recommend this new guy some good ones?

Thanks, Gentlemen!


r/Scotch • • Feb 26 '25

Brands with declining quality

0 Upvotes

Who falls into this camp? Obviously Macallan. Laphroaig, Talisker, Glendronach. Would you include Ardbeg?

As someone fairly new to the scotch world, it seems these are the main culprits that aren't worth the money due to drops in quality over time and I'd like some help avoiding any others.


r/Scotch • • Feb 04 '24

Monkey Shoulder tastes like formaldehyde!

0 Upvotes

Ok, so I normally drink inexpensive bourbons and ryes such as wild turkey 101, old Granddad, bullet rye etc I'm trying to give scotch a try, but I'm not willing to pay much more than 50 (60 tops!) for a bottle of anything really.

As the title says, I've tried Monkey Shoulder, which I'm told really isn't very peat heavy and it still was too much for my tastes. I was very tempted to flush it, but I did eventually get it finished. Hated it!!

I was considering giving up on scotch, but then, at a bar, I tried a glass neat of Glenfiddich 12 year single malt and I found it actually quite nice,. Less of the formaldehyde taste and more pleasant notes. I know that many scotch officionados find glenfiddich boring, but my background iin Whiskey is more Blue collar, North American.

There has to be more scotches out there that I'd like. So ,with this background, what scotches should I try?


r/Scotch • • Oct 15 '25

Unpopular Opinion, Corryvrekan is not that good

0 Upvotes

r/Scotch • • Mar 29 '25

Thoughts on Bourbon

16 Upvotes

My affinity for scotch has led me to ascertain that bourbon is simply not at good as scotch in terms of the quality of the distillate at hand. Glenfiddich/ Balvenie still only source their water from the same spring they used in the 1800s. I’ve toured bourbon and scotch distilleries in both Kentucky and Scotland and there is no contest. The attention to detail and pride the workers carry in Scotland is bar none. I can try 5 drams from the same distillery and they all could be entirely different, any time I drink bourbon it’s the same nose, body, finish to me. IBs and the expressions you can pull from places like G&M and signatory can get you a bottle of 30 year old scotch for 400-500$ while a bottle of 15 year pappy van winkle is like 2000$.


r/Scotch • • Jun 16 '24

Guys i need help identifying

Post image
0 Upvotes

LFG help me out. Got this from my father. He had it for a long time and i wanna kno how old this thing is.


r/Scotch • • Jun 07 '24

From a time where Springbank was actually good... Springbank unicorns part 1 - Springbank Sutti import 1967 (review)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Scotch • • Jan 26 '25

3 years into scotch, mainly Islay whiskys.

4 Upvotes

Today i decided to open Jack Daniels. I gotb it as a gift from my neighbour, he doesn't know anything about whisky, but he knows i like it. So i opened it and got my sip. It tastes like a petro. Thank you.


r/Scotch • • Apr 01 '13

APRIL FOOLS POST Guis. I spent $16,000 on a bottle of Pappy. Was that a good bargain or not?

10 Upvotes

Upvotes please.


r/Scotch • • Nov 20 '24

Why do people like Bourbon? What's the difference between Scotch and Bourbon? Is there also a Whisky that is neither Scotch nor Bourbon?

13 Upvotes

Hello. This year I finally rented my own apartment so I live alone and I could finally buy alcohol since my Christian parents wouldn't like it.

I saw John Wick drinking Bourbon (Blanton's) in his movies so I went for that first. I tried Four Roses single barrel, Knob Creek 9, Wild Turkey Rare Breed, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked and Buffalo Trace. But then I saw Tom Cruise ask for Scotch in Eyes Wide Shut and I had to try a good 40 euro scotch then.

So I researched and just bought the LAPHROAIG Quarter Cask, as recommended by most people on reddit, and honestly, it tastes a lot better than any Bourbon I've tried. I was disappointed with Double Oaked and Four Roses especially. The best bourbon I've had was Knob Creek 9 and the cheap 20 euro Buffalo Trace. But to be honest after trying LAPHROAIG Quarter Cask I wonder why Bourbon exist.

Scotch just tastes more complex and has a distinct smell to it. This bourbon just tastes sharp and simple. I guess you can mix Bourbon with Coca Cola more easily but to be honest I much prefer scotch over Bourbon.

Can you tell me the difference in taste between Scotch and Bourbon? And is there a 3rd kind of whisky that is NOT scotch nor Bourbon but just a Whisky? Does that exist? Or is every Whisky either a Bourbon or a Scotch? I prefer Scotch for sure!


r/Scotch • • Dec 20 '25

What should I order?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Scotch • • Aug 04 '15

Review #57: Bowmore Dorus Mor Batch II

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Scotch • • Dec 30 '12

What brand of orange soda do you recommend mixing with a good single malt scotch?

4 Upvotes

Hi,

I have always mixed orange soda with my scotch, and I love the flavor. Probably my favorite drink. Now generally I just go with Johnny Walker Red Label or even some bottom shelf scotch, but I want to try a good single malt scotch that costs a bit more money. I definitely want to mix it with orange soda, however I want the taste to be perfect so I am wondering if anybody knows a particular brand of orange soda that goes well with a single malt scotch?

I have always used Fanta or Sunkist orange soda. Any other recommendations, maybe a lesser known brand?

Thanks guys.


r/Scotch • • Jun 10 '24

Neck pours suck imo

2 Upvotes

I'm not sure what it is, but the first pour of any bottle is always a bit rough. Not sure why that's the case.

I've seen a post around here saying it's a "psychological" thing, but I have a hard time believing that.


r/Scotch • • Feb 02 '26

Do sherry casks mask the “true” character of a whisky?

0 Upvotes

r/Scotch • • Dec 25 '21

Tell me why I am wrong

9 Upvotes

So I've been thinking for a bit now and have spent too much money on Scotch during this pandemic and have come to a few conclusions that I really want to discuss and learn more about. I am a Canadian, so our access has always been quite limited, but now that this situation has been improving, I wanted to express these thoughts.

  1. The big brands are increasingly lacking in quality and value. Glenfiddich, Glenlivet, Macallan, Highland Park... even ignoring a couple of these are under the same ownership. Their cost efficient ranges of scotch are either lacking quality or value and their high end is extremely overpriced. Highland Park 25 may be the best Scotch I have tasted, but it's $1000 CAD a bottle here and I ain't rolling in it. FYI Glenfarclas 25 is $265 here, so how can you say Highland Park is worth almost 4x that??

  2. Age Statements are going away and it scares me. These new creatively marketed names are ridiculous. I don't know where it started, but I remember Highland park starting their viking series branding and since then it seems every brand wants to remove an age statement and call their scotch "cask of dreams" (Glenfiddich scam that got me) or something silly. Just tell us the age and barrels please! (admittedly, if the name is smart and tied to the history of the industry - like monkey shoulder - than I will keep smiling)

  3. Distilleries like Bruichladdich are making me sad. Bruichladdich makes an unpeated Islay and the most peated Islay you can buy - they freely admit the gimmick side of the business and seem to care little about the craftsmanship/art. I did their warehouse tasting and they literally give you the non-peated and then the next dram is Octamore - that's just shock value and gimmick to me (I do feel people will hate this comment, the classic Laddie seems to have a larger fanbase than I understand)

  4. The region systems needs to be improved/updated. Speyside means something, Islay means something... maybe lowland means something... Highland Scotch is a joke as it's moronic to connect Oban with Glenturret with Highland Park with Talisker with Glenmorangie (etc...)...Campbeltown is a scam under one company. Scotland has to either do away with that system or update it.

  5. If you aren't doing your own infinity cask at home, you are missing out BIG time. This probably won't get too much in the "OP is an idiot" comments, but just reminding people to take that last dram or two in a good bottle and instead of holding on to it like a gold medal, mix it into an infinity cask with others you have enjoyed. Don't throw in the disappointments and never mix heavy peat with non-peat, but it will be the best thing you do.

Otherwise, looking forward to flaming and the like. Hope everyone has a great holiday season and an awesome new years.

And lastly, to the dude posting his reviews on $1000+ bottles, I both hate you and love you - it's the worst relationship in my life.


r/Scotch • • Jun 19 '24

Best scotch with soda?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I recently unsuccessfully tried to water down my Laphroaig Select to avoid wasting it.

I know I like JW Black and soda.

What are your favorites?


r/Scotch • • Feb 27 '24

Which is the best Macallan to start with?

0 Upvotes

I've been drinking whiskey for about a year. I'd like to try Macallan, but there are so many different varieties I'm not sure where to start. What would you recommend?

Thanks!


r/Scotch • • May 06 '24

What nags me after visiting Scotland

0 Upvotes

Hello all. Recently I returned home from beautiful Scotland where of course I paid visit to various distilleries and whisky shops. Aside from many great Scottish experiences, I have seen several whisky-related things that were quite a disappointment for me and are nagging me for a while. Please let me elaborate.

Firstly, very odd whisky souvenirs. I came to Talisker Distillery visitor center and shop and I saw many visitors who made quite a journey to get there; it might even have been some kind of dream for them to see Talisker Distillery in person and get a souvenir or something.

What I saw was a shop full of what I consider tourist trap kind of like stuff. Ice makers, ice stones, whisky cocktail tools, barman stuff et cetera. I don't get it. If you make high quality whisky, why would you promote and sell stuff that, first of all, is not good for the whisky itself, and secondly, someone local would never use (I guess). I even asked one of the shop assistants if a Scotsman would ever use ice stones in his whisky, to which he said, with a grin on his face, that he never used them. That was enough for me and I left, empty handed.

Secondly, same stuff among different distilleries. Next day I visited Blair Athol Distillery in Pitlochry, we had a nice tour including whisky tasting. The tour ended unsuprisingly in a distillery shop where I saw exactly the same whisky glasses, coasters, Christmas tree balls, whisky-flavoured chocolate or popcorn etc. - as in Talisker Distillery. They were from the same producer, it was exactly the same stuff. They were even in the same packaging and had the same price, only instead of "Talisker Distillery" they said "Blair Athol". (To give credit to Blair Athol, they don't sell any ice makers or whisky stones and I am not sure about the cocktail tools but I think I haven't seen those either.)

Thirdly, prices. How come my local shop almost 2,000 kilometres from Scotland sells the same whisky as local shops in Scotland and even distillery shops - but at a better price? I mean what is the benefit of going to the manufactory if I can't even get their own product at a lower price than in a retail shop abroad?

Fourthly, whiskies in local grocery stores. This one really won't get off my mind. I was shopping in a grocery store in Broadford, Isle of Skye and I was curious what kind of whiskies do they sell. I was shocked when I saw the same American whiskey brands as anywhere else in the world. I was in what I consider the heart of the world's beautiful whisky culture, I expected to see shelf full of local whiskies (as you can see in case of beer - I bought some Skye beer there) but I saw all this international mediocre crap.

Who would even buy the world's most common foreign whiskey in Broadford on the Isle of Skye? Locals? I can't imagine that. Tourists? Maybe some, but wouldn't they prefer local beverage? Am I naive?

Fifthly, blended whiskies phenomenon. In Blair Athol Distillery, we were told that 99.7 % of their production goes to blended whiskies, only 0.3 % is single malt and it basically cannot be purchased anywhere on the planet other than a few places like the distillery itself. I am not sure but I guess this is similar with many other Scottish distilleries. But why is that? Why would you rather sell almost all of your production to some corporation that would mix it with plenty of other whiskies and sell it as a blended one with untraceable origin - rather than selling it as single malt whisky and offer it to a wider range of customers who, even if they wanted, they simply have nowhere to buy it?

I could buy a bottle there, but since I had to go back home on a plane and didn't have check-in baggage, even if I bought a bottle to take home, I would not be able to take it through security. By the way, the smallest bottle Blair Athol offers is 2 dcl - while the smallest one you can take to the plane is 1 dcl. Why??? Once again, I left empty handed, only with a "complimentary" dram glass made who knows where (tell me not in China) that I got for paying for the tour.

And so now I am sitting in my chair, sipping my single malt Speyside whisky that I bought in a local store back home, from a dram glass with "Blair Athol" written on it, and these are the thoughts nagging me.

If you got down here, thank you for reading my rant. And if you could answer or explain me how all these things work, I would be very thankful. Also, if you can recommend me any distillery that you think I would like, please do and I will try my best to pay them a visit one day.


r/Scotch • • Apr 17 '25

Can scotch go bad once opened?

0 Upvotes

Hi r/Scotch, I really appreciate this community!

Over the last 6 months I have had a couple of opened bottles seem to develop an unpleasant sour taste after about the 1/4 bottle level. These were the Laddie 10 travel retail, victoriana (my favourite bottle the year before), and Ancnoc 12. Am I keeping open bottles too long at a low level (a month or two)? Or has something gone weird with my pallet (god forbid!)?

Thanks for any insights 🙏


r/Scotch • • Jul 22 '25

r/scotch is dying

0 Upvotes

Accounts are being asked to provide ID to participate in r/scotch. Do not play their game. Do not provide them with government ID. Do not provide them with a selfie. Do not give your biometrics to some random company. It’s all fucked. This sub is amazing but it’s been targeted. Good luck everyone.


r/Scotch • • Feb 17 '25

Old bottle from my grandpa

Post image
0 Upvotes

So I've had it for a while, but my family has this old unopened bottle of Bulloch Lade Pld Rarity (I think from 1940). I dont drink much, but I was kinda hoping to maybe save it for a special time. I have shined a light in it and there's no visible debris from the cork or anything, but I can faintly smell it through the cork. Like I said I don't drink much, and I don't know anything about whiskey, but do yall think it would still be drinkable? I don't have pictures of my bottle, but this is the same one (a picture from online)


r/Scotch • • Dec 09 '21

Lagavulin Or Macallan or glenmorangie?

0 Upvotes

finally got off that bourbon trash and actually started drinking the good stuff. Right now I have the standard 10 year glenmorangie, eh it's ok. Prior to that I bought the macallan edition no. 6 honestly I was dissapointed. I am reading about lagavulin and I have never had it but there standard is a 16 year age that has a smoky peaty flavor. Now the first time I ever tried scotch it was a 21 year aged macallan that I would say had a smoky peaty fruity(probably from sherry cask) taste. Of course the 21 year aged macallan is out of my range but do you guys think Lagavulin is a good alternative? or should I go for something like a 12/15/18 year aged Macallan or glen?


r/Scotch • • Jun 15 '22

Satire I'll say it - Octomore is overrated

11 Upvotes

Discuss. I mean... It is. Underaged brand name good tasting over priced.... Scotch