r/ScientismToday • • Nov 01 '15

"Logic" as a dog-whistle word.

21 Upvotes

I had a very Logic teacher at my university. He was an eccentric, bubbly guy with a warm personality and much enthusiasm for the subject (which I took as an elective). He really did write the textbook we were reading, which was a weird experience. He didn't tell us that, mind you. I looked at the cover, then raised my hand and asked.

The important thing I learned from him and that class was a lesson he taught at the very beginning and re-stated after the finals. "Logic is a tool, and it is a very useful, helpful tool. Watch out when people turn it over and use its handle like a club, though."

In short, "Logic" is a nice thing, but boy is it fetishized. I lost count of the number of times in real life and online someone has pushed their opinion as "logical" and someone else's as "emotional". It gets especially twisted and unpleasant when a point is made using subjective argument both ways, but one subjectivity "feels" more logical to the one waving it like a bludgeon.

A lot of coarse, cynical, pragmatic approaches to modern problems are, I believe, partially due to this fetishization of supposedly cold calculations masking the personal biases and, yes, emotional arguments of the speaker.

How many warhawks during the Cold War, especially during the Cuban Missile Crisis, touted the logical and preferrable outcome of a pre-emptive nuclear strike? Diplomacy seemed feeble and "emotional" then, didn't it?


r/ScientismToday • • Apr 24 '17

Wikipedia and scientism

20 Upvotes

As we have seen in other posts, wikipedia appears to be led by people promoting scientism.

So let's look at some definitions:

Scientism according to wikipedia:

Scientism is a term used to describe the universal applicability of the scientific method and approach, and the view that empirical science constitutes the most authoritative worldview or the most valuable part of human learning—to the exclusion of other viewpoints

This is not correct. As someone who is against scientism, I can still use:

  1. The scientific method. I just think that it has its limitations. When you start with theories, as most do in this method, one can ignore certain observations by inventing denying theories. This is deny-ism that I often see in scientism.
    There are more limitations, but scientism simply ignores any limitations (and history).

  2. empirical science - I think that I can be even more empirical, than a follower of scientism. Since I deal with all observations. Some observations can including those of our mind.
    Scientism relies on a certain materialistic way of explaining observations.

  3. authoritative worldview or the most valuable part of human learning. A person believing in scientism is usually pushing their view onto others, and denying any other world views. It can be a form of extremism.

The most interesting point is:

Relevance to science/religion debates

No! it is not only relevant to science/religion debates, it is relevant in all debates.

I would rather describe scientism as:

Scientism is the belief that science is infallible. Often combined with the belief that that the world is purely materialistic.

Technocracy:

Technocracy is a system of governance where decision-makers are selected on the basis of technological knowledge. Scientists, engineers, technologists, or experts in any field, would compose the governing body, instead of elected representatives.

It seems nice, until you realize that scientists and engineers want to learn things or build things, and do not really want to govern. Some do not even know how to deal with common problems. Einstein was not really good in finances.
The people that do want to govern are usually the ones that think that they are better or smarter than others and are usually not the ones that you want to have in leadership. It is an ideal system for sociopaths.

As you may expect from wikipedia, this is not shown in the page.

An additional problem is that the technocracy movement pushes new unproven technologies in a society. Some of these technologies also have bad side effects, but these are rather ignored by the technocracy. Instead we get solutions like mechanical bees to replace bees that were killed by insecticides.

I personally believe that technocracy is a way that the world can destroy itself. That is because the scientists (like me) that are opposing certain technologies have a hard life against the majority of scientists that love new technologies. This push for new technologies is emphasized by corporations that can make big money out of it.

Appeal to authority

In the Western rationalistic tradition[14] and in early modern philosophy, appealing to authority was generally considered a logical fallacy.

More recently, logic textbooks have shifted to a less blanket approach to these arguments, now often referring to the fallacy as the "Argument from Unqualified Authority"[16] or the "Argument from Unreliable Authority".[17]

This is a bad move.

arguments from authority are fallacious if there is a lack of "good evidence" that the authorities appealed to possess "adequate justification for their views.

Fallacious arguments from authority can also be the result of citing a non-authority as an authority or citing an expert on a conversational subject

Example: Inaccurate chromosome number

In 1923, leading American zoologist Theophilus Painter declared, based on poor data and conflicting observations he had made, that humans had 24 pairs of chromosomes. From the 1920s to the 1950s, this continued to be held based on Painter's authority, despite subsequent counts totaling the correct number of 23. Even textbooks with photos showing 23 pairs incorrectly declared the number to be 24 based on the authority of the then-consensus of 24 pairs.

This important example goes into the confirmation bias. Which is mentioned nowhere at the top. Yet, I think it is very important. It is one of the main reasons not to trust an authority. "To a man with a hammer, everything looks like a nail." Confirmation bias is real, and often bigger than people want to admit. Probably there is some confirmation bias in this text, but I will formally deny that. And "you can trust me, because I know what I am doing" I am The Authority.

Not mentioned: An authority usually has an agenda, or is sponsored by people with an agenda. This will cause a bias or even a unfair false answer. We can see this bias in most science journals. Research that is sponsored by certain companies will more likely produce a positive result towards that company. Yes. Scientists are not angels nor saints.

There are also different authorities:
"Authorities in religion say that God exists"
"Authorities in astrology say that astrology works."

Or towards mainstream science:
"Authorities in Magnetic Reconnection, say that magentic reconnection is real."

"Authorities in genetic manipulation say that genetic manipulation is good for mankind"

  • You would not study genetic engineering if you would not agree with it.

A more political version would be:
"Authorities in guns say that guns don't kill"
"Authorities in women studies say that men are always bad"

This area is much broader than wikipedia shows. And I think that wikipedia is managed by people that like scientism. As I see it, scientism is appeal to authority, the belief that scientists are unbiased and infallible like the angels.
(Angels have to exist if the scientists are indeed infallible ;-)


r/ScientismToday • • Mar 15 '16

Neil deGrasse Tyson: pedantry in space

Thumbnail
samkriss.wordpress.com
19 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Sep 30 '20

Mark Passio's A.R.K (Amazing Repository of Knowledge) Available For Download

16 Upvotes

I think this is an important resource for everyone in these times of abhorrent censorship.

https://onedrive.live.com/?authkey=%21AKHe4BPWdefr6Kk&id=9D3448B2B305E35D%2143500&cid=9D3448B2B305E35D

Google Drive Link https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1p0ovK4gyzPyw4SVrY-ISFbdp7PzOj3Ky

From Mark's site: "I have been online since the days before the World Wide Web became popular. Since that time, I began collecting, studying and archiving information about our world and the events that have been occurring in it. I never left it to chance that information I came across during my search would always be available online. So, whenever I found something that I thought was worthwhile, I downloaded it and backed it up offline. As you can imagine, this much data archiving would result in an enormous amount of material. Quite frankly, it would be hard for me even to describe the amount of information I have pulled from this repository of knowledge and experience that we call the Internet.

Years ago, a friend asked me if I could place the best material that I had collected onto a hard drive for him, so that he could browse it and study it according to his interests, and at his pace and leisure. I said yes, and began the task of collecting the best data that I had gathered into a huge digital library, and copied it onto the hard drive that my friend provided. I then thought, why not share this information by making it available to anyone who wants it?

The A.R.K. drive consists of over 3,400 video files, 9,500 digital books, and 26,000 audio files. These files will always be available to you for offline browsing, playback and study, with no internet connection required to access any of the data on the drive. You may then "pass it along" by sharing any or all of this information with anyone you wish.

https://www.whatonearthishappening.com/ark

Mark's Site https://www.whatonearthishappening.com/

All Mark Passio's Video Presentations


r/ScientismToday • • Dec 09 '14

James Randi: debunking the king of the debunkers - Telegraph

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
15 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Oct 01 '14

Scientific dogmatism disguised as non dogmatism.

15 Upvotes

"Science is not a religion, not dogmatic, because it is capable of changing its stance and proving itself wrong based on new evidence" this what most materialists like to say when you call their beliefs dogmatic. This statement is true in its own sphere of influence outside of human ideology, but when you get materialism and scientism into the mix, it becomes a convenient excuse not to question ones own beliefs. In a sense its saying my beliefs are non dogmatic because i can question them if i choose to, but in my opinion in order for it to work you have to actually do it not just say you are going to do it.

In psychology there is something called the bystander effect. If someone is in distress in a crowded urban area no one will help that person out because each person assumes that someone else is going to help that person. Scientific dogma is reinforced in a similar manner, no one questions mainstream science because they assume someone else more qualified will question it.

To me its a kind of mental gymnastic trick, the dogma isnt questioned because it presents itself as non dogmatic, but if it never changes or is questioned then it is a dogma. This illusion is further reinforced because skeptics claim to question beliefs, the problem is that those beliefs are of other people and ideologies not of their own. Questioning other peoples ideologies is incredibly easy, anyone can do it, questioning your own is tough. And they will say that they question their own beliefs but ask me this, when dealing with skeptical materialists, how often do you actually see them do this rather than simply say it? They may question small errors that they made, but nothing profound. Its easy to say you are objective and face the facts when the shoe isn't on the other foot.


r/ScientismToday • • Oct 30 '15

The emergence of end-point thinking.

14 Upvotes

I don't know if I'm using the right term for what I've been seeing in the most curious places, most particularly in the general chat rooms of MMOs, including Star Trek Online and even Planetside 2. Sci-fi games seem to have more of it but I don't think it's exclusively there.

By end-point thinking, I mean the whole "because heat death of universe nothing matters!" nihilism that has spin-off ideas, like "because resources exist to be consumed (thanks, Morgan Corporation faction in Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri), we should consume them first!" and even xenocidal wanks about "the only future of the human race is to go extinct, or to make everything else that's out there go extinct and plunder their resources, then at the end of time, also go extinct".

It is like the bizzaro world violent opposite of the Buddhist idea of living and embracing the present. It doesn't seem to have any useful purpose except to make edgy kids feel "logical" when congratulating each other for their brave discussions of how future humans/transhumans simply must be galactic supervillains.


r/ScientismToday • • Jul 20 '14

Why synchronicity stories wont convince materialists.

13 Upvotes

So there was a thread on /r/psychonaut talking about synchronicity and coincidences. There were mixed opinions, some believed there was more too it other people thought it was random chance/ confirmation bias. So i posed the question how frequent, specific and how immediate would a coincidence be before you say there might be more to this. Someone gave an answer along the lines of "your asking the wrong question, we have to know what the cause is we are looking for for these events in order to investigate them". Then it hit me, for the materialists it does not matter how frequent or improbable the synchronicity may be, it can always be chalked up to random chance because the materialist believes the universe is created via random chance hence everything is random and meaningless.

For example, i could be walking down my neighborhood thinking about a giraffe and when i walk down the corner i find an actual live giraffe. The skeptic would still say this is just a one in a million fluke, you didn't notice all the times you were thinking about giraffes and didn't see one. Or even if i attempted to channel a UFO and an actual UFO appeared five seconds later, the skeptic would say that was just a one in a billion chance fluke, you happened to be thinking of it coincidentally at the same time an alien visitor was traveling. Then i say i did it twice now its a one in two billion fluke, three times a one in three billion fluke, a thousand times a one in a trillion fluke. You see the skeptics can just keep adding more sides to the dice of probability to infinity. If you believed that the mind is only the brain anything can be chalked up to random chance no matter how improbable. This is why all the evidence of people like radin and sheldrake can be written off by these guys because you can always say its random chance even if it is statically significant.

edit: this exchange has proven to me that materialists are insane

me: hypothetical: so if you roll a pair of dice a trillion times without any cheating type method, you make a machine do it so theres no human tampering, intead to have it roll snake eyes and get snake eyes every single time out of the trillion, would you consider that random chance?

person: I would say there's something wrong with the dice. If it could be proven there wasn't anything wrong, then yes, random chance. Because there's no evidence to prove anything else happened.


r/ScientismToday • • Mar 05 '14

"We will lose an entire generation of scientists." ... "I loved science until I went to grad school and saw it for what it was becoming. The lying, cheating, stealing projects, and fabrication of data to get publications and funding." [x-post from /r/DarkFuturology]

Thumbnail
anothersb.blogspot.co.uk
13 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • May 17 '16

The Poverty of Scientism | The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast

Thumbnail
partiallyexaminedlife.com
12 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Sep 11 '15

When religion-bashing goes too far

Thumbnail
thestute.com
12 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Aug 14 '15

Looking for a study (loose or rigorous) testing if people will blindly believe outrageous lies when they carry the label of science.

12 Upvotes

Thanks.


r/ScientismToday • • Feb 24 '21

MC Hammer Is More Informed About Philosophy of Science Than 99% of Scientists

Thumbnail
uproxx.com
11 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Apr 19 '16

Scientific Regress

Thumbnail
firstthings.com
11 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Jan 31 '14

A good example of scientism on Colbert.

Thumbnail
colbertnation.com
11 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Jan 16 '14

Philosophers must oppose arrogance of scientism

Thumbnail
irishtimes.com
11 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Jan 06 '14

The Closing of the Scientific Mind

Thumbnail
commentarymagazine.com
11 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Jan 01 '14

Scientism as a Metaphysical Claim

11 Upvotes

Happy New Year everyone! I'm a new mod here, so I wanted to introduce myself and explain some of my views on scientism. I'm not planning any changes to this sub, but if you guys have suggestions for the sidebar or otherwise feel free to send them my way. I really like the concept of this sub, so thanks /u/UlyssesOntusado for making me a mod here.

By day I am a Biologist working in the biomedical device industry. More importantly, I am a contemplative/psychonaut who views the world very differently than most of my peers in industry or otherwise. I know a good deal about science, as well as a little bit of philosophy.

Going through any scientific training, regardless of ones field, means learning the Scientific Method. That is what Science is, a method. Today however, many scientists go far beyond using science as a method and create a worldview out of it. All sorts of unsubstantiated philosophical claims are made in the name of 'science', and belief gets represented as fact. This is a very dangerous practice because it threatens to undermine true scientific progress by limiting what kinds of questions can be asked and which interpretations of data are allowed.

The vast majority of perpetrators of scientism claim that material reductionism is the correct way to view reality because it is proven by science. This is a strong metaphysical claim, yet perpetrators of scientism fail to recognize that scientific models cannot 'prove' any metaphysic. However, they seem heavily invested in rebelling against religious dogma and thus have invented a dogma of their own.

I will give a thought experiment showing how scientism can look... Let's say that every time I utter the word 'ghost' my EMF detector activates. A strong correlation is shown with high statistical significance. What kind of causal mechanism exists?

A real scientist would pursue this line of inquiry, yet is not committed to any metaphysical system. His metaphysical models are dynamic and dependent on what he finds. The 'mechanism' may not match current paradigms, and the true scientist's understanding of reality would change. On the other hand, a perpetrator of scientism would assume some material cause a priori. When no material cause can be found, he would deny the existence of the phenomenon or say it is an illusion.

They say "Science goes where the money flows," making scientism as much of a sociopolitical issue as it is a scientific issue. Now I realize that many people are heavily invested in material reductionism, and that is ok IMO. My intention is not to change people's worldviews, it is to get people to recognize where science ends and philosophy begins. Without the ability to discern science from belief, people risk falling victim to dogma and religiosity.


r/ScientismToday • • Dec 02 '21

I started a sub on the reproducibility crisis. it is r/reproducibilitycrisis. Please check it out.

10 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • May 04 '15

Skeptical About Skeptics.

Thumbnail
skepticalaboutskeptics.org
10 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Dec 03 '14

Circular logic that is used by the skeptics

10 Upvotes

Heres how it goes, im sure all of you are familiar with this idea, but i found a way to lay it out very simply.

  1. a skeptic claims the mind is the brain because there is no evidence for psi phenomenon.

  2. convincing evidence for psi is presented.

  3. the skeptic thinks there has to be a flaw in the experiment because the mind must equal the brain. cycle repeats

Now this is definitely an over simplification and their are probably more nuanced aspects of this, but i think if you are convinced that the works of Rupert Sheldrake or Dean Radin have any shred of validity at all you can take point number 2 seriously as skeptics will probably most highly criticize point number 2. They say there is no evidence, but have they actually tried to find it, or do they just hear someone like james randi say that and not think anymore about it?


r/ScientismToday • • May 08 '14

A cartoon I came across today. I figure the readers of the sub might relate, even if the things discussed aren't necessarily as fantastic as dragons.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Oct 09 '13

The Wikipedia Battle for Rupert Sheldrake's Biography

Thumbnail
realitysandwich.com
10 Upvotes

r/ScientismToday • • Jun 27 '13

When Scientists Get Honest (a light x-post from r/funny)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
10 Upvotes