r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Aug 19 '25

Science journalism Prenatal Acetaminophen Linked to Higher Autism, ADHD Risk

Thumbnail
neurosciencenews.com
0 Upvotes

I posted the study itself here a few days ago, but this summary is a little friendlier for those of us without a science background.

Key takeaways from the study:

1. This is the most rigorous, in-depth study done on the topic to date:

It covers 46 studies and more than 100,000 participants worldwide.

It uses the Navigation Guide Systematic Review methodology, which is a gold-standard framework for synthesizing and evaluating environmental health data.

2. The study accounts for risks of bias, such as the confounders of maternal pain and fever:

"Studies were rated as higher risk of bias (score of 3 or 4) if they lacked adjustment for key confounders, such as [...] clinical indications for acetaminophen use (e.g., fever or infection)."

Their findings demonstrate that higher-quality studies are more likely to show the connection.

3. While this study establishes correlation and not causation, the researchers say causation is plausible:

"A causal relationship is plausible because of the consistency of the results and appropriate control for bias in the large majority of the epidemiological studies, as well as acetaminophen’s biological effects on the developing fetus in experimental studies."

4. The researchers do NOT recommend a blanket ban on acetaminophen in pregnancy, but on personalized decisions based on medical advice:

“Pregnant women should not stop taking medication without consulting their doctors,” Dr. Prada emphasized.

“Untreated pain or fever can also harm the baby. Our study highlights the importance of discussing the safest approach with health care providers and considering non-drug options whenever possible.”

5. My personal takeaway: parents should NOT feel guilty for whatever medication they took in the past.

You made the best decision you could, based on the information you had at the time.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Dec 08 '24

Question - Research required Is SIDS Real?

0 Upvotes

Left a comment on another post and already received downvotes, so might as well ask here:

What is the scientific evidence that SIDS exists as opposed to most infant deaths being suffocation (vs a tiny fraction truly unexplained)? Pinellas County, Florida seems to think this is the case (see links).

https://www.tampabay.com/special-reports/2019/12/11/did-these-parents-accidentally-suffocate-their-children-or-did-a-mysterious-ailment-cause-them-to-die/

https://stpetecatalyst.com/local-program-saves-infant-lives-expands-throughout-florida/

https://www.tampabay.com/news/health/sids-deaths-in-florida-have-plummeted-why/2216719/


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Nov 16 '23

Seeking Links To Research Where does the confidence that vaccines DON’T cause autism come from?

15 Upvotes

From what I’ve read, autism is genetic and we know, down to what genes, the mutation stems from however, we cannot detect autism via a genetic test, even though we know what genes are affected…?

These genes must mutate due to some kind of catalyst, no? I’ve read so many stories of parents being blind sided when their child turns two and suddenly get diagnosed with autism (regressive autism) when asd doesn’t run in their family, and their child was meeting milestones wonderfully up until that point. I’ve read that certain cognitive triggers occur in children at age two which is why asd becomes diagnosable at this age. Though other catalysts seem to be exposure to certain pesticides and heavy metals in utero or as an infant.

If metals are present in all vaccines, how is there so much confidence that without a doubt, vaccines do not trigger asd genetic mutations?

Edit: Not anti vax, just trying to learn. If you want to call me dumb, so be it. This awkward hostility when bringing up this topic in a science based community is lame.

Edit 2: so far I’m seeing 5 studies done which confirm no possible links between asd and vaccines, would love to learn more. Again, I’m trying to understand where the confidence comes from. Thank you!

Edit 3: so I found a wonderful article that compiled relevant studies and answered my question so well! https://www.cureus.com/articles/91885-does-vaccination-increase-the-risk-of-autism-spectrum-disorder#!/ this was a great read and no one in the comments helped me find it, nevertheless, some comments were helpful! To any other parents that are like me and genuinely wanted to understand where our confidence in this concern comes from, I hope you find this article helpful too.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Mar 05 '26

Question - Research required Newborn Vitamin K Shot Risk Analysis

3 Upvotes

Hi,

My wife and I are currently about to deliver our second child. They are once again asking about the Vitamin K injection. I have no doubt that the shot is likely "safe and effective" by most people's quantitative qualifications, but for me, the question is this:

"Would a child be more likely to suffer an adverse affect by receiving the vitamin K injection, or by NOT receiving the vitamin K injection?"

Again, my question is risk compared to risk. What is the rate of complications in both, and has there been sufficient testing of the vitamin K shot to prove it safer than not taking it.

I appreciate any time you put into reading and/or contemplating these questions!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Nov 13 '23

Casual Conversation Why are millennial parents so defensive about screen time?

9 Upvotes

On TikTok I recently saw a mom-content creator stitch the @gabesco video where he was complaining about iPad kids. The mom said that people in their 20s always think they have it figured out and say they’re going to give their kids crayons at the table or get frustrated when the crayons fall. She said that it’s the same thing as saying “moms who want alone time don’t love their kids” and then hiding in the pantry from your kids. I am not a mom, but I have worked in early childhood education for four years and will have a bachelors degree in ECE this spring. I have had experiences with kids throwing down because the iPad isn’t charged or I can’t find it, even when TV is an option. The AAP is extremely clear about screen time recommendations and the potential harms of extended time on screens. I’m not an advocate for no screen time; I’m actually pursuing an MLIS masters once I graduate, and I understand the incredible tool that technology is for people of all ages. What I don’t understand is why millennials parents in particular seem to really dig their heels in about screen time. It seems like a lot of parents take critiques about screen time as a whole as a personal affront on their parenting choices. I’m gen z, and I recognize the detriment that unlimited, unmonitored screen time had on my own development. Why is this such a touchy issue for people?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Aug 04 '25

Question - Research required Help. I accidentally smoked weed and I’m breastfeeding. Will it ever be safe to breastfeed again?

2 Upvotes

I made a terrible mistake and smoked weed once, and I completely blanked on looking up the breastfeeding implications before partaking. Please do not lay into me because I’m am truly devastated and feel like the worst mother on the planet. My husband, myself and our 11 week old are at a friend’s beach house for the weekend. None of us smoke. We are the squarest people on planet earth. I guess I assumed it would be like drinking and I could pump and dump until the morning - I took a few hits and definitely felt it strongly due to my complete lack of experience and immediately panic googled smoking weed and breastfeeding. What I saw was 100 times worse than I ever could have imagined and I’m wondering if I need to permanently cease breastfeeding?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Dec 31 '24

Question - Research required Does breastfeeding affect mothers mental health?

35 Upvotes

I see this statement so often all over reddit "breastfeeding tanked my mental health so I stopped". People never explain what that actually means, like what sort of symptoms they developed following which exact stressor. Someone even copy-pasted it to Wikipedia without sources.

I am sure having a baby impacts mental health, mostly in a negative way. But is there any evidence in breastfeeding being more detrimental than bottlefeeding? And if so, how and why?

Signed, a psychotherapist currently on parental leave.

Edit: Many people are sharing their negative experiences and hurt over complicated breastfeeding journeys, with some people seeming quite offended or possibly judged by the question. Please make the decisions that are right for you and your family individually.

This is however NOT research or evidence based on a broader scale (which is what this sub is about). Thank you to the commenters linking research. From what I'm seeing, there seems to be no conclusive research comparing mothers mental health when breastfeeding vs. formula feeding.

2nd Edit:

To clarify, I've seen this statement many times without explanation. People in the comments usually agree like it's obvious/common knowledge that breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health in general. That's why I was interested in research.

To sum up some points made here:

  • adverse experiences like pain, triple feeding, having to pump a lot and/or premature babies negatively affect individuals wellbeing

  • some people find that they get more sleep when bottlefeeding (because someone else can give bottles, because some babies sleep longer when fed formula) which can improve mood and resilience. Other people report getting more sleep when nursing so this seems highly personal. There is no high quality research on sleep depending on feeding method, but one study suggesting breastfeeding parents get more sleep

  • d-mer is a phenomenon I wasn't aware of (which sounds grueling)

  • there doesn't really seem to be a lot of high quality research on the initial question

I repeat: Please feed your babies in a way that works for you and your family. Without feeling judged - at least by me. I really don't know why so many people in the comments seem to feel judged/hurt by the question. I've personally nursed, pumped and formula fed. All of it was hard so far.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jan 10 '24

All Advice Welcome Is formula actually a net negative for babies, or just not as good as breastmilk?

9 Upvotes

I combo feed my 4 month old due to some weight gain troubles. It's about 60/40 in favor of breastmilk. I'm not overly precious about breastfeeding or anything but recently I noticed her formula can or insert (I forget which) has a notice that says something like "BY PURCHASING THIS PRODUCT YOU ARE INFORMED OF THE HEALTH RISKS THAT ARE ASSOCIATED WITH INFANT FORMULA" or something to that degree, along with a notice about breastmilk being superior. I've also seen posts on social media about how formula is full of "chemicals" and I did notice that corn syrup is one of the ingredients, which if I'm not mistaken, isn't supposed to be given to adults let alone babies.

I'm not trying to formla shame as I gladly use formula myself because my baby needs it! but I would love some unbiased scientific opinions that aren't lactivist propaganda but ALSO aren't overly concerned with "shaming" to the point of not being accurate.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 26 '24

Debate is it harmful for children to dress in the opposite gender’s clothing?

0 Upvotes

For context my 16 month old son is dressed in every colour under the rainbow and to the shock of many even has a dress that we think he enjoys wearing. However because he is so young and I live in a moderately conservative country (UK) i have received lots of comments expressing concern for the way i dress him and accusing me of damaging him, forcing him into a box and confusing him. We do give him options but he is so young and his vocabulary so limited the choice is pretty much an illusion since we pick the options.

to me i disagree with gender roles and would like him to be able to embrace all aspects of his personality. i also feel its important to express yourself through your clothes and so i dress my son in whimsical weather appropriate clothes that i think suit him… in short he is just too much of a smiley guy to dress in black and monochrome! this also extends to toys for example his favourite is the barbie fisherprice little people set at the moment.

To get to the point is it harmful for me to be making these decisions for him? have their been any studies on long term impacts of having children follow their gender roles both in clothes and toys? i try to brush off the comments but i don’t really know what to say especially as there is always an uncomfortable undertone of homophobia/transphobia in the ‘concern’ raised. i have left it open as a debate so i can hear the general thoughts but if anyone knows of a study on this matter that would be great!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Apr 13 '22

Circumcision is significantly correlated with SIDs, across 15 countries. Thoughts?

Thumbnail
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
0 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Nov 27 '22

General Discussion Is soap necessary for bathing children? Why/why not?

0 Upvotes

I have a soon to be three year old who has never been soaped. As a baby we bathed her in plain water and as she got older we just... never added any product or soap to the daily bath or shower time routine. This occurred to me recently and I've realised it definitely isn't the norm. She also has only had her hair washed with shampoo/conditioner around 5 times in her life. We wash her hands with soap or sanitiser after toileting, if we've been out somewhere public and if they look dirty from play or meals. But the rest of her just gets a water rinse.

Am I a terrible parent? My daughter is very healthy, has never had any infections of any kind, her skin and hair looks clean and well tended. Is a water rinse enough or have I just been lucky so far? Should I be using soap? Is shampoo necessary? Why/why not?

As a side note I almost never use soap on myself either, with the exception of my hands. Just water. Not really purposefully, I just dropped the habit of using a product in the shower after leaving my family home as a teen. Also only shampoo my hair roughly fortnightly but that's since having my second child and having limited time+horrendous shower hair loss. Now I'm worried we are a family of grots!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Apr 06 '26

Question - Expert consensus required How bad is it really to use Roundup in my side gardens

0 Upvotes

We have several gardens around our backyard/play area. How bad would it be to periodically use roundup in these areas to spot treat weeds? The kids don’t play in them, it’s not like eating any food from there. There may be an occasional ball that goes into that area or a kid who hops in to get something. I was thinking if I did apply, I’d rinse those areas a few days later. Thoughts?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jan 22 '22

Medical Science Petition to FDA to remove red tape that is preventing vaccines from our youngest children

Thumbnail reddit.com
17 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Nov 07 '24

Question - Research required Is sleep training safe?

0 Upvotes

My baby was sleep trained at 6 months (currently 11 months), I was extremely happy about the results. Now my friend has a baby and she’s very hesitant about sleep training telling me it might be bad for babies, etc etc

I remember reading about it being safe but I haven’t actually read any research. Is there any trusted research around this topic?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 21 '23

All Advice Welcome 36 weeks & Breech

3 Upvotes

I’m 36 weeks today and baby is breech. I’m terrified at the thought of a c-section, really want a vaginal birth, and don’t want to mourn the birth experience I thought I was going to have. I want to know what my chances are of him turning and what I can do. I have an ECV scheduled and have been recommended spinning babies to try to get him into position. I need success stories and any literature that will give me hope he’ll turn. Please save the “You got this mama!” or “You’re doing great!” or “A healthy baby is all that matters!” BS. I really don’t want to hear it as it’s not helpful to me. Thank you in advance.

Edit: thank you so much to all who replied. I didn’t respond to everyone, but I do want you all to know that I read each one ❤️


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Dec 11 '23

All Advice Welcome Ms. Rachel “helps kids get kidnapped”?

8 Upvotes

Hello y’all, I’m a babysitter. I was encouraging my mom friend to try Ms. Rachel for her toddler, she said that it makes kids trust white ladies and more likely to get kidnapped so she won’t turn it on for her child. I tried to find if there is any info on this and I couldn’t find anything.

Has this been something anyone else has heard/has proof on? I don’t want to be disrespectful to her desires for her child, but the wee one would super benefit from some speech-heavy educational entertainment.

We are all black individuals in this situation, is there a black Ms. Rachel? Or should I find some Sesame Street reruns?

Many thanks in advance!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jul 07 '26

Question - Research required Risk of having a child with autism if my girlfriend’s brother has autism?

0 Upvotes

I’m in the early stages of a relationship and thinking about the future. My girlfriend’s brother has autism (or another developmental disability), but my girlfriend does not. As far as I know, her other siblings don’t have autism either.
Does having a sibling with autism significantly increase the chances of our future children having autism?
Has anyone been in a similar situation or spoken with a genetic counselor about this? I’d appreciate hearing about both personal experiences and any medical information.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 14 '25

Science journalism Does this article drive you crazy?

9 Upvotes

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11597163/

Has anyone read this paper on breastfeeding beyond 6 months?

The writing seems so biased I was turned off just reading it.

This claim, however, really seemed too crazy:

“If all children were breastfed within an hour of birth, exclusively fed breast milk for the first six months, and continued breastfeeding until the age of two, approximately 800,000 child lives could be saved annually. However, worldwide, less than 40% of infants under six months old are exclusively breastfed [27].”

Am I the only one who thinks this paper is… suspicious?

Edit: My baby has gotten mostly breastmilk for 7+ months now. Also, I have a PhD, have written academic papers, and still think this paper is terribly written.

Edit 2: Just did a little bit more research and the paper was published by MDPI, which is considered by many as a predatory publisher. I think that we have to be careful about some of the ‘scientific claims’ that are made nowadays.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Apr 28 '25

Question - Research required Zoloft Effecting Babies’ Brains

2 Upvotes

So I am currently trying to get pregnant and on 150mg Zoloft. My OB has said that it is one of the best-researched SSRIs during pregnancy. However, I have found this research article that seems to demonstrate SSRIs have a negative effect on the child’s brain development long-term. Can someone well-versed in understanding scientific studies check this out and let me know what they think?

https://www.madinamerica.com/2023/09/ssri-use-during-pregnancy-alters-the-childs-brain-development/

Edited to add: I am in no way saying Zoloft is definitively dangerous and/or should not be taken during pregnancy. In fact, I was hoping to have some responses that said it is in fact safe and this study was flawed. That seems to be the consensus and has made me feel much better. I recently had a full-term unexplained stillbirth and also have OCD so I have been struggling with not going down rabbit holes of what if’s and how I could prevent any future harm to other children. So your responses have been helpful, thank you. I’m sorry if I made anyone feel like I was condemning taking medicine while pregnant.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Apr 05 '25

Question - Research required Baby sleeping with parents

1 Upvotes

Our 10 month old baby has been sleeping in our bed with us for a while already. I know most people would put the baby to sleep in his own crib, but he would cry and not sleep if we did that. However, we really don't mind having him sleep with us since we have a big King sized bed. There isn't a risk of him falling since he is always sleeping between us or against the wall. Is there any negative aspects to doing this? Is there an age limit for having him sleep in our bed?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Are there any studies showing CIO to be harmful?

12 Upvotes

Other than the info about babies who are completely abandoned in orphanages, is there any actual evidence or studies showing that CIO or Ferber type methods harm your baby? Or is the opposition to sleep training based more on feelings/assumptions?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 08 '23

Casual Conversation Thoughts on sleep training from a therapist

468 Upvotes

Will probably get downvoted into oblivion for this, but here it goes:

While I completely understand why many parents feel the need to sleep train their babies, there are more drawbacks to sleep training than a simple google search would have you believe (when I say sleep training I’m referring to more extreme methods such as “cry it out” or long intervals with Ferber)

Babies are wired through years and years of evolution to need your comfort and support to help them sleep and coregulate. This is healthy and normal. It’s that connection that forms and the basis for their attachment system. Almost every other culture recognizes this.

Sleep training with extreme methods like “cry it out” can damage a child’s attachment system and sense of safety in the world. From birth to about 2 years, the main developmental issue for children is the question “Are you there for me? Will someone come when I call?” The answer to this determines a lot. This is one of the most critical and shaping times in a person’s life. To me personally, I wouldn’t want to mess with that, especially in a baby under a year.

People will often say “I sleep trained my baby and she still loves me/ seems very attached!” Of corse that’s the case! Damage to a child’s attachment doesn’t often look like them becoming a cold, calloused version of themself. It’s usually a subtle insecurity deep inside that manifests itself later in life. It’s hard to quantify in a something like a research study, but therapists see it all the time in the way a person relates to themselves, others, and the world around them. (But just to clarify, I’m not saying this happens with everyone who sleep trains, just that it’s a concern.)

I do recognize that sleep is important and that parents resort to extreme sleep training in moments of desperation. Of corse if you are so sleep deprived that you are a danger to your child, sleep training makes sense. This isn’t a post to stir up shame or regret. This isn’t a post to say sleep training does irreversible damage (I believe attachment styles are fluid and can be repaired) I just wish there was better information out there when a new exhasted parent googles “how to get my baby to sleep.” The internet has so much fear mongering about starting “bad sleep habits.” And the “need” to sleep train so your baby learns how to sleep.

What I wish parents knew is that there are other middle of the road options out there that don’t require you to leave a baby alone in a room to cry for long periods of time. All baby mammals will cease crying out to conserve energy when their cries are ignored for too long. This isn’t a positive thing. This isn’t your baby “learning” to sleep. It’s them learning that crying doesn’t help them.

The other thing I wish people would recognize is that baby sleep is developmental, not “trained.” All babies will eventually learn how to fall asleep and stay asleep, whether you sleep train them or not. The IG account @heysleepybaby is great for understanding what biologically normal sleep habits for babies look like.

For anyone interested, Here are a couple articles on the subject I found compelling. To be clear, there isn’t great research for OR against sleep training. It’s an extremely under researched topic. Studies struggle with small sample sizes, short timelines, over reliance on what parents “report” rather than what’s really going on in the baby. Nonetheless I personally found these articles compelling. Im not saying this is the best/ most rigorous research out there, this is just what I’ve been reading lately.

Australian Association for Infant Mental Health https://www.aaimh.org.au/media/website_pages/resources/position-statements-and-guidelines/sleep-position-statement-AAIMH_final-March-2022.pdf (Good discussion of research with citations starting on page 3)

6 experts weigh in on cry it out https://www.bellybelly.com.au/baby-sleep/cry-it-out/

Psychology today on sleep training

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/moral-landscapes/201112/dangers-crying-it-out?fbclid=IwAR0e3zgrPZJ1hKVQe9A7g2lKDI0P7AOeABPVx-IKuEoByNTb8GH92om21KA

Edit to add: I didn’t do a very good job in the original post of clarifying that I see the core of this issue as US culture devaluing parenthood by not allowing mothers the maternity leave they need. - Not a moral failing of individual parents. I get that for many, there is no option. It’s just a world I wish we didn’t live in, and it kills me when everywhere from Google to Instagram normalizes it. Sleep training isn’t good for babies, it’s a necessary evil in a capitalistic society that gives new mothers 6 weeks of unpaid leave before they have to return to work.

ETA 2: I’m not presenting this post as a scientific conclusion. (For goodness sake, the tag is “casual conversation”) Its obviously dripping in my personal opinion. I’ve already stated that this is an extremely under-researched area and people are mad that I’m not providing air tight evidence that sleep training is damaging? Social science in general is the poster child for bad data and testing methodology. My main point (which was stated above) is that sleep training isn’t proven to be safe, and it’s not as innocuous as US culture would have you think. There’s the potential for damage and I think that’s worth discussing. The topic is difficult to research, much of this is speculation, and still, it’s worth discussing. The vitriol and attempts to silence this conversation are disappointing.

ETA: Man, this blew up, and obviously I hit a nerve with many. What seems to be upsetting folks the most is the mistaken notion that I believe sleep training is more damaging to a baby than a mentally ill or dangerously sleep deprived parent. I already stated above that if that’s the case, sleep training is a reasonable option. Do I still think it has risks? Yes. Is there really no room for nuance on this sub?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 23 '26

Question - Research required Sleep training - harms or benefits baby?

1 Upvotes

Looking for a peer reviewed research on sleep training for infants. Specifically, the "wave" method outlined in The Happy Sleeper book - checking in every 5 minutes.

There's a lot of conflicting information - I know it's a controversial topic.

Does sleep training stunt proper emotional and cognitive development, and harm the parent-child attachment? Or does it create healthy sleep habits which promote independence?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Dec 31 '23

All Advice Welcome Friend's kids aren't vaccinated against Covid-19, but are for everything else

0 Upvotes

Could use some advice! My friend's kids aren't vaccinated against Covid-19, but they are for everything else. I have a 3.5 month old who's vaccinated according to the vaccine schedule, so she won't get the Covid-19 vaccine until she's 6 months old. We'll be visiting my hometown for the next month. Should my baby be around my friend and her kids? Should we only stay outdoors and I wear my carrier? Should I wait until my baby is vaccinated?

Other context - I've gotten my Covid-19 booster and flu shot, among all the other vaccines. I'm breastfeeding so baby should have some immunity.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Aug 16 '25

Question - Research required Are there studies done on the benefits of cosleeping?

22 Upvotes

What are they? And until what age is it beneficial to cosleep.

I'm aware of safe sleep and AAP recommendations. Please no comments on safety of cosleeping