r/Savate • • Aug 21 '18

Did Savate really lack any boxing, let alone punches, before the duel with Owen Swift?

0 Upvotes

I find it difficult to believe that no French boxer thought of mixing in chausson and other early kicks before the Owen Swift match. Especially since boxing was already big enough at that point that even before Michel Casseux codified the technique there were already prizefighting rings across Europe including France. Hell before Napoleon Bonaparte there was already boxing style bouts in Germany and Ireland at least (and more unsanctioned fights across Europe including France though how much it was "pure boxing" is hard for me to verify).

So its already ridiculous imo that the introduction of boxing into French fighting only came when Owen Swift defeat a Savate fighter.

Even far more idiotic and really I mean it when I say this flabbergasted me is the notion PUNCHING NEVER EXISTED in Savate before Michel Casseux blended boxing with chausson in response to Owen Swift's victory! Sure I can believe open palm strikes and spear handthrusts and other handstrikes other than punching took up the bulk of techniques. But never incorporating punching? BS! Who wrote this? Haven't they ever seen little kids brawl in the playground? You don't need to learn martial arts or even have experience in fighting to instinctively punch someone being a jerk to you!

In addition even Wing Chun and other old Kung Fu styles relying primarily on handstrikes still incorporate punches in addition to hammerfists and other hand strikes. In Wing Chun's case, straight punches (that are frequently used in boxing) are even the main method of hitting!

I find it so moronic no one in France knew anything as basic as throwing a hook before Owen Swift rocked the Savate world! Can anyone clarify what happened behind the scenes that most internet articles and books on Savate don't reveal? Especially about why even a simple straight right punch and sloppy haymaker was never in the pre-existing French fighting systems prior to Boxe Francaise?


r/Savate • • Feb 11 '19

Is it natural to feel ringing of the feet (possibly pain) when landing kicks on hard stuff like the forehead and banana trees even with hard footwear?

0 Upvotes

Two weeks ago some dumbass bodybuilding jock was harassing my sister and when I told him to leave her alone he threw a punch and I got so pissed that when he tried to follow up with a hook I immediately tackled him to the ground. I was controlling myself so I got up and tried to leave but he yelled out I'm the son of a whore and he'll fuck my sister as he was getting up. I threw a generic soccer kick that landed on his forehead because he touched a nerve he shouldn't have and he went into a coma. I was so angry it took 20 minutes to calm me down but afterwards my foot started to hurt. I wasn't wearing a typical hard steel-toed boots or working shoes however I was wearing hard leather shoes used in formal dining (the shoes Jason Statham wears in the Transporter movies). My toes weren't broken from doing straight land-on-the-tip kick associated with Savate but they were definitely hurting.

In addition just yesterday a friend of mine showed me his special imported banana tree from Thailand. We bought decided to have fun and practise techniques on it. This time I was wearing military boots with steel caps on the outsole toe area. While my feet didn't hurt from hitting it, I definitely felt a ringing like sensation after minutes of practising fouette style kicks and generic soccer kicks.

So I am curious. Since Savate is often touted as the style where you can safely do soccer kicks and other kicks landing with the toes without modifying movements because the shoes protect you, is it still natural to feel the feet to be affected-especially ringingness across the shoe and even hurting toes?

Is this something all Savate fighters expect even high level ones wearing the best protective shoes?


r/Savate • • Jan 20 '24

Why doesn't kickboxing (including Savate) attract the same genuinely tough jockish athletes the way Boxing and Wrestling does?

2 Upvotes

This is even lampshaded in Alias when Jennifer Garner fights a primarily boxing opponent (who is played by Quentin Tarantino himself) and he tells Garner (after observing her style used on mooks which uses heavy mix of punches and fancy kicking including jump attacks) and the opponent's pre-fight trash talk was "the problem with kickboxers is that they can't take a punch".

Indeed despite the fact some kickboxing styles like Muay Thai, Boxe Francaise, and other styles I can't remember are full contact and hard hitting with very heavy emphasize on hardcore general physical conditioning beyond fighting, it seems a lot of people who get into kickboxing are not really the macho but genuinely psychologically hardass jockish type who typically play soccer and other codes of football, basketball, and batting sports like cricket or baseball to extreme levels so hard it @#!$ing hurts. Hell most people who join in recent times don't even do much safer and relatively less strenuous but mainstream sports like sprinting, swimming, etc.

It seems that weekend kickboxing classes are the most many who decide to get into kickboxing do as an intense physical workout. Where as boxing and wrestling attracts real hardasses who are also often big into rugby or whatever football code and basketball and other mainstream "manly" sports.

I have to ask why is this? Especially since in Thailand many people who take MT seriously below pro level are often also jockish personalities who when they aren't doing a serious season of MT training they are doing other activities like swimming and almost all people who does Boxe Francise in Europe often came from soccer before learning any form of kickboxing or are big association football and rugby fans when they aren't practising Boxe Francaise or any other style. Pretty much the same applies to people practising other kickboxing in general in Europe. In Japan there's no rigid line between boxers and kickboxers and people who specialize in one will do drills in others for conditioning sake as well as play baseball outside of an actual team on the side. So many Sanda fans in China are in the military and South Korean kickboxers are often not typical middle class background.

So I'd have to ask why in North America, the kind of crowd kickboxing even hard hitting Muay Thai attracts tend to be very middle class and on the lower end of physical fitness? Why it seems much more people who decide to get into kickboxing tends to be comic geeks, etc outside of practising martial arts? It seems the hard athletes, the kind of folks kickboxing gyms would love to accept as student (esp soccer stars and football quarterbacks), go into wrestling and boxing instead in Canada and the USA!

Why?


r/Savate • • Feb 11 '25

Shoes for Self Defense

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

One of the things that attracted me to Savate was the use of the feet. It made sense to me that you’d kick in a way that used your shoes instead of barefoot as I’d learned in my other arts.

But I wondered if savateurs think this way? Do you wear types of shoes in regular life that make sense to use in defense? If so, what kind? Or am I misunderstanding how the art might be used in self defense?


r/Savate • • May 30 '24

Why didn't Germany develop its own equivalent to Savate without influence from France considering the country's reputation of militarism esp trouncing France in multiple wars?

2 Upvotes

When I visited Germany recently in the last month of 2023, on the ride across the regions nearby the state of Hesse on the Deutsche Bahn I'd see castles everywhere. Every town significant enough to have a train station had at least 1-3 real castles (yes I know the differences between a fort fortress, palace, and other jargons). You cannot go every 10 mile without seeing a stone fort along the way on the mountains or in a forests even a few isolated on islands. And I'm not even counting individual single watch towers placed along the way.

When I visited Heidelberg palace, the place was huge and simply a sight to witness. Across multiple museums I been to esp in Frankfurt and Berlin there where entire sections full of swords, maces, guns, and suits of armor. Many of these museums I visited weren't even specifically for military and Medieval focus but simply stuff collected from local neighborhoods for centuries.

When I visited Paris, I had to specifically go to the Army museum to see this kind of stuff. The Louvre for example did not have any weapons (even though I know its not the best example since its specialized for art). There was no castles I came across within Paris. Sure I didn't explore the whole country like I did Germany but the bus I took from Germany into France went through from the North passing some of the most famous towns associated with major military events like Verdun. Yet I didn't see any castles and fortresses along the way. Contrast this to Germany whee even on a bus to the outskirts of Bavaria I saw one ruins of a castle that was destroyed centuries ago in a town near the Main river and multiple still standing impressive fortresses in the path my bus driver took.

I bring this up because I remembered from the Human Weapon TV series produced by the History Channel, on its Savate episode , they keep emphasizing about how Savate almost died out from World War 1's losses and later on a bout how the Nazis were trying to take Savate stuff to add into their own hybrid military hand to hand combat system and the featured grand master Roger LaFond told his war story of how he refused to teach German soldiers Savate because still kept his loyalties as a soldier of France unlike some other collaborators from the Savate field who had no shame getting a paycheck to teach SS and other Nazi soldiers the art. Thus LaFond was sent to a concentration camp where he did forced labor under unpleasant conditions until the liberation of France from the Americans set him free.

I still am mesmerized by the centuries old military infrastructure I seen across Germany along with the vast amount of weapons collections from knight's chainmail to Prussian rifles I seen in non-specialist museums. And from what I learned about the history of both countries, Germany gave France such a severe beatings in multiple wars. Rushing into Paris in under a month in 1870 destroying every French army blocking its path, bleeding France white at Verdun, and later on catching France so unprepared in 1940 that she surrendered without much of a scuffle despite the French military on paper being superior to the Wehrmacht in almost every way.......

I have to ask why Germany didn't create something like Savate as an original national creation that would have been exported across Europe in the light of unbelievable victories of the various German states in the 19th century? Because from what I seen the development of German hand to hand upon the unification of the country was basically based on pre-existing military training (bayonet, knives, sabers, lances) mixed in with boxing and multiple wrestling styles and even some of the early Chausson and predecessor styles before Boxe Francaise that Prussian and Austrian officers were exposed to.

Where as Savate would get exported across Europe in some way, most especially in other armed forces and self defense schools across the continent taking bits and pieces of it (as seen with Sherlock Holme's Bartitsu) , in the 19th century if not even instructors being personally hired by higher ups in military and the aristocracy outside France. Germany never became an exporter of any fighting systems, not even the hybrid styles with so much foreign influence (including Jiujitsu and Savate) created by the military upon the formantion of the 2nd Reich, forget spreading out any local mostly if not entirely local creation to the rest of Europe.

I really have to ask why was it France that created something like Savate and not Germany? In the light of the horrific defeats from wars with the Imperial German empire (where the French got beaten up hard) and France's tendency to not focus on militarism and instead on academics and the arts, its simply bizarre its France that created the first non-sports non-weapon based martial arts that experienced exportation across Europe and not Germany. Is there any reason why the historical direction went this way? In light of the widespread amount of military buildings I came across Germany it really perplexes me why Germany wasn't the origin of the most famous non-sword and non-sportified fighting style that'd be taught throughout Europe and instead its France!


r/Savate • • Jun 02 '25

Why has British fighting culture since the 19th Century been stereotyped as being"Fists Only" esp by Savateurs? Was no one in France aware of soccer hooligan riots taking place in Britain (as football was already England's most popular game by this point)? Did Savate VS Boxing reinforce stereotypes?

0 Upvotes

A stereotype so common in the martial arts world is that the Brits (and by extension her former white colonies like Australia and the USA) is that disdain using the legs in fighting is an ungentlemanly and cowardly and that real men use their fist (and maybe arms if they learn a bit of wrestling). And that English speaking fight instructors esp n London always emphasize leg techniques as something you shouldn't do because of the high risk of many dangers particularly losing balance esp kicking (but not just that but sweeps and knees and general leg movements). So the cliche is that British fighting approach as still with the arms esp fists because they are the quickest, most practical, and most of all least risky approach to fighting.

I wrote this months ago

https://old.reddit.com/r/Savate/comments/1k7hy61/is_the_ubiquity_of_football_in_europe_easily_a/

Its common to see people repeat on various websites such as Quora, Reddit, Bullshido, etc the ad nauseam argument that the Brits dismissed not just Savate but heavily leg-usage martial arts esp kicking based ones from the various Kung Fu styles of China to Capoeira and predecessors to BJJ from... historum.com historum.com

And the stuff I mentioned including references to Barton-Wright (founder of Bartitsu, the real life martial art Sherlock Holme's fighting style as based on) in the link pretty much dispel the clihe of British culture intrinsically scoffing down on kicking as a myth.

ANd I'm not counting multiple discussions other posters made before I jned rddit including one person's article mentioning that British wrestling uses traps and other leg techniques in a twisted irony of the British martial arts perception that they only strike with fists and also sending out observations of the paradox that the French Savate is basically the earliest organized form of Kckboxing while at the same type French wrestling is completely based o upper body techniques and the most popular style created in France Greco-Roman wrestling would become the dominant approach today used in international competition. And another poster pointing out evidence of Savate in ancient Gaul in another sub and so much more.

But I rally have to ask why did the UK got this stereotype of fistcuffs only? Forget the hooligan fights my Scottish Grandma witnessed as a young girl in London. Barton-Wright mentions numerous times that many British gentlemen fool themselves into thinking their weekend warrior training in Boxing is enough to handle anything on the streets and he mentions more than thrice of young British middle class guys getting cocky and talking out in the slums at night, participating in the escalation of social situations into violence, and then getting quickly taken out by soccer-loving poor British manual laborers who it several kicks on the leg quickly knck the young cocky Gentlemen down, if not outright break their legs in the process before these Gentlemen could even throw a jab jab straight combos.

My grandma may have immigrated from Scotland to London by her teens, but she tells me of stores of her other relatives who migrated to England t and were sending paycheck for her family by mail............... That generations earlier her own grand uncle (born in 1878) who was living in Liverpool at 15 got involved in a protest turned into riot at a factory in and as jailed because he kicked a policeman in the stomach and then jumped on a table and did a flying vertical kick midair at another policeman and KO'd him too before 3 more policeman sucker hit him with a bat. Add how he learned to do Kung Fu movie style strikes? He practically played Football almost all his freetime at this age.

Indeed you don't even have to search out martial arts specific literature or even read at all-even pop culture entertainment takng place in the 19th century like the recent The English Game on Netflix portray British commoners perfectly capable of using their legs for "cowardly striking".

But still I really have to ask why this stereotype of the Anglo Saxon world not just UK but former colonies is so ubiquitous n international eyes?

I mean start peekng out articles from this Website.

Australian Savate Homepage

https://savateaustralia.wordpress.com/

Which is the oldest still running collection of articles on Savate on the World Wide Web (though another Savateur from Canada told me on Discord the site creator had to move it to Wordpress from the original Web Domain because it was getting costly). Its a webste considered so much of a ell done archive on the subject that Britannica Encyclopedia even gave it an Award as seen on the front Page.

You'll immediately find the mentions of Charles Charlemont's legendary fight with British Boxer Jerry Driscoll and the proof of supremacy over regular Boxing and various contemporary statements from French professors criticizing the limitation of British fistfighting.

Even the Bartitsu Society (one of the fe websites on Sherlock Holme's styles that continually gets updated) rote an article criticizing the French of cheating in this bout as well as various diatribes criticizing not just Boxing but also Savate as being useless for general self-defense some which already mentioned in the linked Football post on this sub).

And don't get me started on Europeans VS Chinese Styles and other internatonal proto-MMA competitions where the Brits are almost always represented by a strictly boxing fighter (with the occasional crosstraining into wrestling prizfighter in the tournament).........

I really have to ask why did the UK get this stigma so attached to their fighting culture esp before Bruce Lee's international popularity? And why so many mainstream instructors who are easily accessble to Middle Class Brits seem to reinforce this cliche in the UK from the 19th century all the way post WWII?

Not only as afull well-rounded styles restricted to the British aristocarcy and military as fa as tutelage goes (which despite the vocal fighting sports journalism of Britain opposed at the time, commonly crosstrained in Savate and pick and mixed techniques from across not just Savate and the rest of the Europe but even contemporary Asian stuff)?

It got so ridiculous that I remember a website where they referenced Newspapers criticizing Bartitsu for using dirty tricks and being crudely brutal!

Yet....... As I mentioned multple times on my other post and even in this topic right now the poor working class in Brits not only had no qualms about using "sissy kicking" but a surprising number of commoners threw strikes ith genuine power and even refined tecniques because of playng England's most beloved sport at home and even at the factory during break time.

Hell forget Soccer Football..... Parts of Rural England has this sport!!!!!!!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shin-kicking

So you don't need soccer or rugby to see commoner Brits knew about kicking as a thing to be done in brawls as they had Shin Kicking and other Bizarre sports across the rural country that makes you go WTF!!!!!!

So honestly, why did Britain get the stereotypes of being the nation that only fights with your fists? Esp since the aristocracy and military trained in MMA styles and in fencing schools that made heavy use of leg techniques (in addition to taking bits of various styles from Savate and rest of Europe as contemporary Chinese and Japanese styles)? And moreso since the commoners use leg strikes all the time refined from playng games like Shin-kicking and esp Football?

And why did the existing fight clubs seek to reinforce that image for decades on the international scene? I mean noticeable the lack of British wrestlers in pre-UFC MMA cross country bouts is staggering and its as though British fight organizations were intentionally restricting their pool of warriors from the Boxing gyms!

Where as other countriessent out fighters from different styles. I already mentoned France and Savate (who managed to score some victories against Chinese and Japanese fighters) but the Germans had sent some wrestlers in these international bouts with mixed results in addition to boxers and fighters who trained in both. Russian fighters ere known to do an MMA approach even though they came from specialized backgrounds like fencing. Spain has a long history of testing different eapons against countries near the coloies in duels.

So I have to ask why British fight culture came to be this way (and in turn the stereotype also got latched onto America, Canada, and other former colonies)? Despite the fact that majority of England in the 19th and early 20th century and even all the way up until today played in a sport completely revolving around kicking a ball (which also happens to be the most popular sport in the world) while the Britis military always borrowed bits and pieces of fighting styles and even discounting crosstraining and foreign influence, British nobility practised fencing styles heavily incorporating sweeps, trips, and other leg movements and also picked up the latest cool looking fads like Barttsu?

I mean so much of the British scoff down on kicking stereotype seems to always mention Savate and the infamous bouts in the 19th century...... So I have to ask how much Savate was a major influence in why the British stereotype develop? Esp since poor British working class never took any fight training beyond maybe some barebones boxing and catch wrestling yet as the movie Green Street (a movie about Hooligan Association Footy violence in the UK) shows they effectively throw more advance kicks and effective knees in Football violence!

Why is the British aristocracy's complex fencing system and tendency to borrow the latest trend from Europe (which Savate is among the list s far as fighting goes) and esp the manual laborer Londoner in poverty already knowing damaging kick moves so ignored in this?

Why did journalists in France and England during the Savate VS Boxing Wars of the 19th century and early 1900s seem unaware of stuff like low Coup de bas style sweeps was nothing special for English commoners and done all the time in Hooligan brawls?

Or the mere simple fact that even untrained normally law-abiding English commoners (esp working class) had no qualms at kicking and stomping on opponents on the grounds during a brawl (as seen with the riots at Wembley after Italy's victory with the failed penalty shot a few years ago)? Even throwing generic vertical upwards soccer kicks against standing opponents during an exchange of fists? Why does scholarship on Savate seem to magically avoid touching upon these frequent use of leg techniques used so frequently in the UK esp during the economic and social tensions of the Industrial Revolution and the rise of association football during the same timeframe?


r/Savate • • Apr 03 '24

What do you folks here think about Savate Live?

1 Upvotes

Their website.

https://www.savatelive.com/

As I mentioned like what a month or two (maybe three) ago, the first exposure to using Savate shoes was recently at a friends' house. He ordered his shoes from Savate Live and they were pretty interesting equipment. Made me see how neat French boxing is despite my skepticism of the whole style as it seem ineffectual. So I'm definitely exploring Boxe Francaise in the future. But really what do long-time practitioners of Savate on this message board think of the organization?


r/Savate • • Feb 06 '20

Was Savate completely ripped off from South East Asia and unoriginal to France (well Europeans)? A style completely native to Europe created without outside influence? Something in between? Or Something Sorta Universal?

2 Upvotes

I saw this rather funny post.

https://www.unrv.com/forum/topic/14268-did-gauls-use-savate-kicks-in-fighting-the-roman-legions/

OP quotes something from what I seen used to be in Wikipedia but was removed years ago because it was in source.

There are quite a few historical hints of kick fighting going back to Frankish and even Gaulish roots with the modern footwear changes and boxing amalgamation being just the most recent adjuncts in a long honorable line.

It turns into a hilarious argument about Savate's origin. If you have time read all the comments but if you are too busy just go to the last 6 or so posts. I won't spoil it but I was Laughing my fat #@! off!

With that /u/ChainSWay made several sarcastic comments to some of the silly claims that a few people have made including Human Weapon's documentary and a few other user's outta this world's post regarding Savate's origin. At one point even saying by claiming Savate existed in Renaissance fencing and Medieval swordplay you might as well say Savate originated from pankration XD.

But going on a more serious point I read some of the older posts before I started posting here and saw this post.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Savate/comments/99525s/why_do_so_many_military_systems_use_of_kicks_even/

Now I will quote a sarcastic comment on a self defense website.

The term is used to more commonly refer to individual empty handed/ archaic and/or personal weapon systems. But these are commonly presented as "ancient warrior skills/training" Tae Kwon Do is a prime example. Never mind that it is the national sport of Korea. That is not as important as the fact that it was organized by General Choi in the 1950s. He did this by bringing together multiple kwons/instructors (most of whom had been trained in karate) and then putting them under one banner -- HIS. Then came the nationalistic/political push to create a "Korean art" and history was seriously rewritten to exclude outside influence. These days you cannot pick up a book on the subject that doesn't trace Tae Kwon Do back thousands of years to the ancient Silla warriors. When in fact, the strongest influence is from karate as is immediately apparent with a comparsion of pyong /piyong/ heian/ pion forms. The current trend of calling it an ancient art arises from a marketing spin based on exactly one illustration of two individuals fighting drawn on the wall of a crypt. Let me run that by you again, because of one drawing of a guy kicking another the entire style of Tae Kwon Do is supposed to be over a 1,000 years old. The fact is we can't tell how these people moved from one drawing. For all we know they could be doing Savate.

I bring up Marc MacYoung because it brings up a bigger issue. Best explained by this post.

https://www.reddit.com/r/martialarts/comments/c0xhvs/why_did_western_fighting_systems_eliminate_leg/

As the post claims for years many people assume that kicking is entirely unique to Asian fighting. Basically as the OP claims whatever kicking techniques exist in modern systems today was primarily taken from Asian systems. Going further than that, because of that modern trend and assumptions of kicking being uniquely Asians, for decades the Western martial arts community including writers such as American Black Belt Judoka Bruce Tegnar (who wrote a small book on Savate) and other scholars who solely specialize in Asian styles (esp many historians now debunked as wrong) has claimed Savate probably originated from French sailors learning stuff from traveling in SouthEast Asia.

However now modern martial artists dispute that claim and plenty of historians and other scholars mainly specializing in European swordplay dispute these claims such as Matt Easton's school ScholaGladiatoria in Youtube. In addition we are not counting the fact that soccer and and a large number of other non-martial arts activities such as dancing, military suppress and fire tactics training in urban environments,gymnastics, acrobatics, circus performance, and so much more activities can pretty much teach people a bunch of effective kicking movements and if they have an aggressive mind and gifted talents esp in physical movements, they can easily use say dancing movements into fighting smoothly. So that does strike one against "kicking is for Asians only"

I went off a tangent but I did it to put context. Marc MacYoung, who wrote the sarcastic comment about Sila Warriors artwork could have been doing Savate instead of TKD or any other style...... Basically before he became an RBSD instructor and before he started formally taking Asian martial arts class and than expanding into HEMA, etc he was someone who got into plenty as brawl. Enough that he was around 13 years old during the first time he experienced someone pointing a gun at him.Throughout his teen and adult years he keeps on fighting and fighting to because of his temper and ghetto upbringing and he lost 4 friends by the time he graduated.

Even before he started learning Wing Chun and other martial arts (the only style he specifically practised as a full system was wrestling and he learned boxing but never mastered the fundamentals when he was young) he already learned a bunch of techniques when he was young. He claims in a blog interview now removed that when the first time he saw Savate he was pretty surprised because a good number of the bare basics techniques esp in Dans La Rue and other self-defense version was stuff he's been using as a teen in street fight such as the Chasse Bas and Coup de Pied. He says that was before he took karate and such and he just learned how to do those strikes because of fighting nonstop and learning what works and what doesn't. So whenever Western martial artists and scholars claim about Savate being stolen from Vietnam and other colonies, he disputes it almost always on the bat because he learned some of the basic stuff like chasse bas on his own from live experience as a teen.

Hell to sum it up, MacYoung always say he didn't go into martial arts to learn how to fight.He already was a fighter in the streets and could tell on first sight what is BS and what is good stuff. He took martial arts classes to become a better fighter.

I basically bring this up because in addition to Marc MacYoung's experience, the link above where the OP claims he sees Savate kicks and defensive movements (esp footwork and dodging) in the military and police version of every style across the world from TKD to Kung Fu and even Muay Thai (often seen as the complete opposite style of Savate at Sherdog and other forums). Made me wonder..............

I know various people like /u/ChainSWay already call out on claims like Savate originating from the Gladiatorial games of Ancient Rome and other nonsense by "Savate historians" such as Salem Assli as utter BS (I agree too I call it a bunch of baloney-ancient Rome my @&# hahahahahahahahahaha). But various HEMA practitioners like Matt Easton who goes under the Youtube username Scholagladiatoria say they recognize plenty of Renaissance kicks and Medieval strikes instantly when they first saw Savate, saying they are the exact same techniques in old Medieval Codex and other manuals. So this leads me to my question.........

Is Savate really just a something some bored white Sailors saw and decided to copy when they were trading stuff at Indochina and later were sailing around Indonesia and other places for exploring? Is it a style completely native to France? So much that the Gauls used it and Gladiators all knew it (I call BS on this!!! ROFLOL!!!)? Something sorta in between where fighting styles already existed in France but explorers in Asia brought interesting stuff they saw back and added it into native local French fighting methods? Or something basically universal as the other redditor claims Thai soldiers and other military across the world start doing kicks different from their style when they put military footwear like Sabaton and boots on and as Matt Easton says they already were recorded in Renaissance fencing treatises and older texts? What do you think? Is it sorta all of the above?

I'm definitely calling BS on the Gauls practising Boxe Francaise LOL! (I do have to ask though if them and perhaps Gladiators using similar techniques is not impossible though? Just really curious on this!).

Hope this becomes a great discussion :)!


r/Savate • • Jun 15 '19

Why did Western fighting systems eliminate leg moves (esp kicks) as they became sportified? In addition why did boxing far surpass kickboxing and older forms of MMA in popularity for a long time in the West?

3 Upvotes

I published this on the martial arts subreddit.

https://www.reddit.com/r/martialarts/comments/c0xhvs/why_did_western_fighting_systems_eliminate_leg/

I'm curious if anyone can give me their intake? Particularly why kickboxing never took off until the popularity of UFC in the West and why Westerners found hands only fighting sports such as boxing far more popular than sport that use the rest of the body such as backfists and elbow thrust and esp use of legs for sweeping and kicking?

Why is it the opposite in the rest of the world? Not just Asia but even in South America fighting sports involving kicks or sweeps were extremely popular for a very long time with stuff like Vale Tudo preceeding the UFC. Even boxing crazy Mexico has forms of "street boxing" and "self defense boxing" where soccer kicks and stomp kicks along with quite surprisingly even kicks resembling those of Savate being common bare bones basic techniques!

How come despite even the heavily European influenced Latin America having kicks and sweeps as basic things in their fighting sports, the West as a whole did not see sports with leg usage become popular to the extent boxing and Greco-Roman boxing did? In particular why do many countries in the West of Europe esp. England and the Anglo-Saxon countries (USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, etc) develop a contempt for kicking as a technique for "sissies and unmanly people" and as "unfair dirty cheating"?

If we leave it strictly to France, even there Savate never got to the level of popularity as Boxing did in the country. I mean so many boxing books mentions France as having used to be one of the great powers of Western Boxing pre World War 1 and even onto the American dominance of the sports from 60s onward, they still list and record a fair number of European regional champions coming from France and even a few weight classes being dominated by a particular French champion at various times.

As much as they say Savate was really popular before World War 1 killed practitioners, all the records and stuff I read implies most French pro fighters preferred boxing and boxing was more popular of tickets sold than Savate ever was.

I am curious why boxing surpassed Savate? I don't buy the WW1 argument considering plenty of boxers were killed during the war yet boxing not only thrived in the UK but even in France boxing still maintained popularity!

As much as how in martial arts forums nationalists bring up the "British vs French" and "kicking is for sissies and punching is the real way to fight" over and over in an effort to attack France, it seems boxing was farrrrrr farrrrr farrrr more popular than Savate ever was in France!


r/Savate • • Jul 13 '22

When doing kicks, is it true that how close and hard you press your thigh against the lower parts of the legs (esp calf and ankles) will determine how high or low your kicks are? Esp with snap flip kicks, side kicks and roundhouses?

0 Upvotes

I been experimenting with different martial arts moves. I saw this technique.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FK11fS0fA8k

Emulating it, I as amazed ho practically every time my legs would always result in a low kick to around the leg area. Which is funny because I saw this instruction from another website.

Chasse Lateral. Lift the knee of the “kicking” foot towards its opposite shoulder, (left knee to right shoulder or vice versa) this motion will cause you to pivot on the supporting leg. Turn the outside edge of the striking leg towards ceiling, calf pressed against thigh. The”kicking” foot should now be pushed out towards its intended target. After hitting target pull leg back to flex before either kicking again or “placing” the foot down.

Now here's the thing. The instructions seem different from the video....... But they are basically the same kind of kick from the same style, Savate, called the Chasse Lateral which is basically Savate's own interpretation of the side kick.

What I notice is that following the quoted instruction, it seems every time I do it as described word for word, always hit around the abdominal area fro around chest to groin (most of the time it landed around stomach). IN act the quoted instructions are for the variation called Chasse Lateral Median which the site states:

Median: Front of body. (Stomach, solar plexus and sternum.)

And the version shown in the Youtube video is called Chasse Lateral Bas. Which from the Savate Website states:

Bas: Front face of legs. (Above the knee but below groin.)

(Though following the Youtuber's instructions a couple of times times I even landed the blow lower than the knee, going as lo as the ankle at least 3X unintentionally).

So I ban to wonder based on what I observed doing the different techniques.

I been trying to do a variation call Chasse Lateral Figure which is basically high kicks from aiming a the upper ribs all he way to the top of the forehead. Unfortunately the website's details are bad and it doesn't describe ho to execute variations just how to execute the most generic variation (which is the Median version). For a month I been tryng to do a Chasse Lateral at the head but fail, repeatedly losing balances and allig.

But after learning the more precise instruction of the video and comparing it to the site's instruction, I decided to do an experiment. I not only pressed my thigh against my cal as the quoted directions demand, I went as far as pressing my Achilles tendon to the point of squeezing pressure together and then launched a side kick. I as amazed that I kicked so high, literally at the forehead of my human dummy freestand bag (about 6 feet). I follow directions again and consistently hit it at the chin with a few hits at the neck and ribs. AN with complete utter ease.

I was so flabbergasted I decided to try another technique which is in the video below.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jh-7TznxTgk

And the website states.

Circular Motion Kick "THE FOUETTE" The Fouette kick is a “circular” motion kick that travels in a horizontal arc. To perform the kick you raise the striking leg with knee bent. As you do this “pivot” on your supporting leg and point the knee of striking leg, outside edge uppermost, at proposed target. Your calf muscle should at this point be touching your thigh; this position is known as “chambered” in English or “arme” in French. Finally “whip” open the striking leg to fully extended hitting your target.

So I did the typical Median variation shown in the link and vid. Then I toyed around. I followed the Chasse Lateral Bas vid by applying the angles show but with chambering the fouette. I consistently kicked at targets around the calf and lower with incredible ease. Then again I pressed my thigh so hard against my lower legs all the way to the Achilles tendon and I as throwing round snap flip kicks to the head 100% of the time.

NOw I toed around with different kicks from different styles from the Spartan kick to the Muay Thai roundhouse to vertical snap karate kicks and my poor attempts at TKD's jump kicks as ell as Tai Chi stomping kicks and sweeps. I as freaking amazed at ho the same thing applies as hat I observed with Savate kicks!

The more I pressed the thigh against the whole lower legs (esp all the way against the Achilles Tendon), the higher my kicks were. The less I pressed the thigh against the lower legs hen chambering, the lower the kicks were thrown. If I simply only press calf against thigh and nothing else in the rest of the leg, it almost sent kicks hitting the abdomen with a few shots against the groin.

I was freaking shocked at how many Muay Thai rounhouses was sending against the dummy's cheeks as ell as ho in friendly sparring I now was able to trip my partner's so easily with Thai Chi seeps (something I kept trying to do or months but never can succeed once- I'd end up throwing the e sweeps higher than intended when I was following instructions literally which claims its supposed to make a person lose balance because his lower legs was disrupted).

So I am wondering if what I discovered is a basic principle of kicking techniques. Is what my toying around showed me accurate? Am I alone in realizing this? Or is this a long fundamental principles o executing leg strikes which most online instructions and even books do a poor job of instructing readers?

Can anyone clarify?


r/Savate • • Jul 13 '22

So is Soccer the Best non-MA way of learning fighting kicking techniques?

0 Upvotes

I was watching dramatization of Brazillian Soccer legend Pele's life and when he was growing up and playing in the amateur leagues, sometime during his ten years he gt exposed tot he Brazillian martial art Capoeira. He was told by one of his friends the team that some professional soccer players practise Capoeira to improve their game and many Capoeira professionals esp instructors also grew up playing soccer. So Pele decided to try out the style.

Pele has already been playing soccer at a competitive level since he was a kid and even young was already described as a prodigy by elementary school coaches and fellow players. When he took classes in the style, he quickly learned plenty of techniques and was rising in the style. His instructors said not only is he a prodigy who has the potential to become one of the greatest maestro of his time, they also said his prior skill in soccer is really helping him out in learning techniques quickly and rising in the beginner ranks. The Capoeira comunity he was part off seriously wished he would go full time with Capoeira but Pele openly told them after months of training he's not gonna go for a career because the whole reason he took Capoeira was to improve his football so he can imitate some of the pro players' moves.

He never practised traditional Capoiera again but a lot of his soccer drills involve kicking balls with Capoiera style and doing some exercises he learned from his time learning the basics and as history shows it, he would go on to join Brazil's national team and his participation was necessary for turning Brazil into the the status quo superpower of the soccer world along with Germany as Brazil's team won smashing victories a couple of times during his career. Brazil's reputation in football became so legendary as a result of Pele's contribution that Brazil is seen by many as the "capital of the soccer world".

So it makes me wonder. Is Soccer the best non-fighting related method for learning kicking moves? I mean as an English living in London, I can attest from seeing local riots that hooligans without any training in martial arts are capable of doing low roundhouses, kneeing,stomping and other strictly martial arts kicks to enough effectiveness, in some cases even superior execution than veteran black belt level martial artists, to be able to break someones ankles or destabilize someone's leg and cause him to fall to the ground. And thats not counting how devastatingly powerful and quick the "upward vertical kicks" that resemble your stereotypical soccer kick that these hooligans do with so much ease and perfect execution that its basically as second nature as walking for them! And all from simply playing soccer daily!

I actually witnessed a police man try to hit a rowdy drunk customer at a football bar with his bat but the drunk simply did a typical movement for passing the ball at the police and tripped him, making him fall on a table. Literally it almost ooked like a Judo move and it was done s quick before the police man's bat could hit the drunk football fan!

So it makes me assume soccer can turn someone into an effective kicker without needing to take any martial arts. How is this notion? After all country's known for styles relying primarily on kicking like Korea with TKD, France with Savate, and Thailand with Muay Thai as a few examples are the same places where soccer is hands down the most popular sport.

I mean one guy posted a on a tumblr about an article where Barton-Wright who is the creator of Bartitsu (a British hybrid style combining boxing-wrestling with various Asian and European fighting systems and is the style Sherlock Holmes uses in the original Doyle novels) warns about how young boys who only knows boxing are at a huge disadvantage in the streets esp since football hooligans often throw kicks they use from football games and there are cases reported incidents of young gentlemen getting the smollock beaten out of the because they tried to box these hooligans and the hooligans knocked them down with kicks and in some cases even broke their legs. So Barton-Wright warns people learning in self defense that while they don't need to learn how to attack with kicks in the same manner as the French do with Savate and how Asians frequently throw complex leg strikes in their styles, they must learn defensive measures from kicking like dodging, blocking, etc. Barton-Wright actually even encourages the best policy is to learn how to intercept an enemy's kicking techniques by directly counterattacking with specific savate, karate, and kung fu style kicks, preferably strike at the same time as an opponent sends leg strikes with the appropriate counters move. He really warns to be careful fighting against Holigans esp if all you know is Boxing because of how dangerous their football strikes are.

So is there any truth to this assumption of football kicks and knees? Chiming off topic a bit and going the other direction would practising martial arts esp kicking styles like K1 Kickboxing help out with soccer too?


r/Savate • • Aug 15 '16

Best Savate in US?

1 Upvotes

Who has the best Savate school in US?


r/Savate • • Aug 11 '22

How good would my Football Cleats Do as Savate Shoes?

1 Upvotes

Snce someone else keeps bringing Footy up, I might as well go ahead ask this.

https://stockx.com/adidas-speedflow4-turf-core-black-sonic-ink

How would does do for training? Evne discounting sparring at rsk of hurting others, how would this do for hitting the bag.


r/Savate • • Jul 13 '22

How skilled was Alain Delon in Savate Back in His Boxing Days?

0 Upvotes

As pointed out in a cinema sub its easy to find pics of him Boxing.

So I am rather curious how skilled he'd be in French Kickboxing at his young days esp since French boxing gyms often also had Savate trainers of Self Defense and Military Instructors who Taught specific techniques.

Watching many of his movies lately I recognized various Savate techniques such as the chasse kick in Le Samourai's only unarmed front scenes.

So I am curious of what level he reached in Boxe Francaise? He continued being part of regular Boxing so much that he even did a lot of behind the scenes stuff like patronage some fighters, sports betting, and promotions in his 30s.


r/Savate • • May 20 '25

Keeping Savate Honorable

9 Upvotes

Posting anonymously to raise a serious concern about how Savate rankings are being handled in the U.S.

I support qualified instructors ranking students in Savate. What I don’t support is using the legacy of the late Professor Salem Assli, and a legally suspended organization, to issue paid certifications under misleading authority.

There are certain Schools promoting students to Red Glove and Silver Glove ranks using the name of the California Association of Boxe Française-Savate (C.A.B.F.S.), founded by Assli in the early 1990s. The certificates cite affiliation with the F.F.B.F.S. (Fédération Française de Boxe Française Savate), now the F.F.S.B.F.D.A. (Fédération Française de Savate Boxe Française et Disciplines Associées).

Even more concerning:

C.A.B.F.S. has been legally suspended since July 25, 2018, and is not authorized to conduct business or issue certifications.

Source: https://www.bizapedia.com/ca/california-association-of-boxe-francaisesavate-and-associated-disciplines.html

https://ca.ltddir.com/companies/california-association-of-boxe-francaise-savate-and-associated----disciplines/

Professor Salem Assli passed away November 5, 2020 and no successor has been publicly designated to continue the C.A.B.F.S. legacy or operations.

Charging students for ranks under these expired affiliations and expanding the program through an outdated and morally wrong structure is borderline criminal, especially they same can be done using transparency such as stating that ranking is done through lineage of the teacher, networking to an authorized organization, or even go through the process of being recognized like other sanctioned bodies of Savate.

Meanwhile, the United States Savate Federation (U.S.S.F.) exists and is active. It is recognized by the proper international bodies, and instructors like Professor Nicolas Saignac continue to honor ranks awarded by Assli through official channels.

I am not posting this as a witch hunt, however violating schools should not be issuing ranks under a suspended nonprofit or defunct affiliation to lend credibility and profit. If they want to promote Savate, they should do so transparently, through their own name or a recognized federation.

Respect the art. Respect the lineage. Respect the name of Salem Assli.


r/Savate • • Aug 21 '18

Why do so many Military System's use of kicks (even those whose creators were unaware of savate) literally look like Savate kicks most of the time? To the point even blatantly different Asian styles like military Muay Thai and WW2 era Karate even Savate looking kicks?

2 Upvotes

As we know because of how so much of Western martial arts have been lost, most military hand to hand combat systems in the West end up taking most of their kicking techniques directly from eastern styles namely Karate, Muay Thai, TKD, and various Kung Fu styles. So its expected that they should use oriental style kicks........

Except a lot of what I see end up looking exactly like Savate style kicks! For example Defendu developed by Fairbairn, a practitioner of Chinese martial arts and enthusiast in Chinese culture, has fouette looking kicks! Matt Larson's Modern Army Combatives (which still heavily influences modern US Army techniques) uses the exact same principles of Savate kicks using the specific part of a shoe such as the tip and the outsoles and heels of the shoe! I seen Canadian systems with the exact same thing!

Ok I know Fairbairn and other military instructors went across the world and studied different stuff to develop their system so they might have encountered Savate or systems influenced by Savate. In addition I also know for a very long time Savate was the style European militaries was heavily influenced by as seen in how Nazi Germany had hired a few Savate fighters to help in developing their own systems and early Krav Maga creators were busy trying to add in effective techniques to defend themselves from pogroms (so it'd make sense Krav's creators would learn of Savate kicks since their initial primary influence was boxing and wrestling and they were exploring local street fights and styles to add on to their base). But AFAIK at least in Fairbairn and Matt Larson's case they crafted their system specifically around Asian techniques as far as kicking goes. Fairbairn was so heavily influenced by the Chinese even most of Defendu's handstrikes is Kung Fu and Matt Larson stated it was primarily karate (at least in the first incarnation of MAC he created in the late 80s/early 90s) he took from for kicking techniques.

However it makes it confusing that not only did some countries in Europe did not have easy access to Savate and already had their own techniques such as Russia (where peasants already had kicking techniques in local wrestling style) and Turkey (who was just recovering from the backwardness of Ottoman rule and had kicks in their traditional swordsmanship). Yet even without accessing Savateurs, their military systems already had the coup de bas and other Savate kicks. Granted mostly low kicks (which perfectly reflect their primary emphasis on wrestling) but still it was surprising.

Most shocking of it all is that if you watch modern Asian armies that USE their local systems as the official military's CQC....... They use kicks that resemble Savate! Or at least uses Savate's basic principle of using the tip of the shoe, the heel and soles, and other boots. Even styles that are blatantly different (especially Korean Tae Kwon Do), end up using more Savate-looking kicks than their styles traditional methods such as Muay Thai's kicking with shins and TKD's high attacks and jumping kicks. And its not just modern military forces- I seen WWII era Japan training and the kicking techniques use the same angles and physical placements as savate kicks. Despite the fact that when training in the dojos, they use traditional karate kicks! But in the field it seems as though they suddenly have been practising Savate for years to know about the advantages of the tip of the shoes and whatnot.

I'm not familiar with Vietnamese and Algerian martial arts but even movies and even real life documentaries I seen of riots and such such they are shown using Savate looking kicks despite the anti-French sentiment going on during the French occupation of those two countries.

Why is this? I mean despite how Savate is bashed for being "sissified French" and how many of us who respect the style think its sad its obscure, Savate techniques seem to be used by military everywhere including Asia to the point of giving the impression its as universally known as karate and Kung Fu is by the general public!

Can anyone explain if I'm just hallucinating or if they also observed this phenomenon too? I seeing Muay Thai military training use more Savate kicks (hit with the toes) than kicking the shin especially when they're sparring while in uniform is so unbelievable its like seeing a woman pull up her shirt and flash her naked body at me! Or even witnessing a demon run in town and slaughter people!


r/Savate • • Mar 11 '26

Punching bag

131 Upvotes

r/Savate • • Apr 25 '25

Is the Ubiquity of Football in Europe easily a Prime Reason Eastern Martial Arts didn't Take Europe By Storm the way it did with the rest of the world esp North America? In particular the UK? Esp with exporting Savate into British culture specifically in the 19th century?

0 Upvotes

Already I seen people repeat on various martial arts sub esp r/WMA repeat the ad nauseam argument that the Brits dismissed not just Savate but heavily leg-usage martial arts esp kicking based ones from the various Kung Fu styles of China to Capoeira and predecessors to BJJ from Brazil because because they saw kicking as ungentlemanly and that real men fight only with their fists..........

Discounting British wrestling which as someone pointed out has sweeps and trips with knee pins and locks as well as chokes both using the legs......... Another argument I see at Quora and other places online is that while they are now mostly dormant, a big reason why Eastern martial arts did not dominate Europe as it did during the Bruce Lee Craze of North America is that traditional local styles in Europe like Savate and Zipota and Italian Fencing still existed in towns and old neighborhoods across Europe (which Catch and Freestyle Wrestling are arguably British examples). Sure they are unknown to the majority of the populace esp Middle Class in the generic thriving Metropolis, but the simple fact in neighborhoods in Rome boxing styles with some of kicks similar to Savate in are taught in local gyms and fight clubs among some isolated ghettos that largely remain the same as before the unification of Italy (with the addition of modern appliances like electricity and plumbing) is often another theory why Europe did not have the mass martial arts fad that USA experienced in the 70s and still is suffering the effects from..............

As well as the dominance of Boxing in Europe (which another poster brings up) esp the British Isles.

But I have a theory that is often overlooked esp since so many martial artists don't tend to be into mainstream sports and are the intellectual white collar types........

The sport of Football.

I have a grandma born in Scotland and lived in London for her young adult life before immigrating to America. She grew up watching violence by local Footballer Hooligan. She still tells me stories and among them is that some hooligans she knew personally trained in boxing clubs and underground fight clubs when they weren't spending the rest of their freetime kicking footballs outdoor along with drinking at pubs and brawling across many places.

In plenty of fights she'd always notice hooligans wouldn't just box, they'd be doing toe kicks using their heavy worker's footwear , instep kicks with locked ankles similar to what she seen among karate practitioners in the 60s but almost entirely vertical, round circular kicks resembling ballet dancers and the effeminate dancing of the pansy Frenchies with their feet boxing (probably referring to Savateurs in London)-her words not mine-, hitting someone with knees, sliding leg tackles (I mean the move to steal the ball in football, not a MMA style sprawl and takedowns), and well a bunch of other Association Football moves she'd often used herself when playing Footy with her brother on the sidewalks of London.

Now a few Bartitsu and Savate websites mention about Football Hooligans and their use of kicks so it makes me wonder.......

Is Association Football easily one of the most essential reasons if not the prime reason why Europe didn't develop as big a fetish for Oriental styles esp Karate and Kung Fu the way Americans and Canadians as well as the rest of the world did after WWII's end?

I mean just go watch news about the riots in England after Italy's victory at Wembley back in 2021. Footage shows plenty of Football fans (some who aren't even into Hooligan culture but just everyday normal law abiding citizens) throwing a lot of leg strikes despite never taking a single martial arts class (I doubt a lot of them ever even learned wrestling or even Boxing).

And if you watch old videos you see a lot of incidents not just in the UK but across Europe like a German fan knocking down a lady down the stairs Leonidas Well Scene Style in 300 and Russian gangs doing sweeps and locking legs after a game in France.

And nevermind that we are forgetting Football's universal mainstream popularity across the whole wide European continent which takes away people from being interested in not just Asian martial arts but actively hampers the continuing growth of other mainstream popular sports like Basketball and Rugby........

So is it fair to say the Association Code is among the prominent reasons why America took the Oriental martial arts craze far wider than Europe ever did and even today is an obstacle to MMA's growth in the Continent esp in the United Kingdom? In particular is it a gigantic reason why Savate couldn't find a foothold to attain popularity in British society esp during the 19th century, most specifically in the Victorian era when Savate was being formulated?


r/Savate • • Oct 09 '23

Savate 101 Chasse Bas a Quick Comprehensive Guide

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Savate • • Jan 31 '20

How effective are savate kicks with optional external shoe protection (such as soccer cleats) and internal toe protections worn before putting shoes on (such as Suede Toes)?

3 Upvotes

Savate shoes are practically nonexistent in many parts of the world and right now I'm pretty broke so I can't buy manual labor shoes and construction or military style boots.

So I am curious how effective would it be if I add a hard attachment removable anytime to the shoes toe box region? Or buy wearable hard protection that I put on my toes before putting my shoes on in which it is meant to protect the foot internally of the shoes? What I mean by this is for example soccer has many optional attachment to your daily rubber shoes like specialize cleats designed to protect your toes as you kick the ball and suede toe caps dancers wear to avoid injuries from stepping accidents as well as plastic toe inserts that construction workers use as a quickfix protection when something happens tot heir boots and they have to use their daily sneakers.

Are these substitutes enough to practise Savate kicks to full effect without hurting your toes? Or do I need to buy specific internal wearable toe guards and optional outer shoe protection that are on the same level as the steel toed parts of a military boots and other similar footwear to Savate shoes?

Or can the kicks only really work with hard shoes made in the vein of Savate shoes and steel toed military and manual labor boots?

Because I tell you my attachable soccer cleats not only adds protection to my foot not just from soccer ball but even when I do fouettes on the heavy bag but its even feels as hard and sturdy as the typical tips of military boots! So I assume this is OK? Or No?


r/Savate • • Aug 24 '15

Chasse Lateral

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/Savate • • Dec 03 '22

SAVATE - Incredibly underrated - FIND OUT WHY!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Savate • • May 17 '23

Looking for Savate in DFW

3 Upvotes

Hello, I'm looking for Savate in the DFW area. I found a gym on Google, but idk if it is considered a legit gym by Savate standards.

The website is lefthooksavate.com

Basically is this a real French Savate affiliated gym or just a McDojo by another name?