This sounds like a tiny thing, but when you download and rename files all day, it gets old really fast.
I work with MOV and MP4 videos and name them things like R2_11_V02, R2_11_V03, etc. When saving a new version, I click an existing file in the save window to grab its name, change the version number, and save.
Except Safari grabs the extension too. If I'm downloading a MOV and click an older MP4, it puts .mp4 into the filename. Click a PNG? Now my video gets a .png extension. I just wanted to reuse the name, why would I want a video named like a picture?
If I delete the extension, Safari can save the file without one altogether, so I have to keep checking and fixing it manually. I finally tried the exact same thing in Chrome on the same Mac, and it just works. Click an existing file, it takes the name and keeps the download's correct extension without showing it in the name field.
Before anyone suggests Finder settings, “Show all filename extensions” is already off. I want files to keep their correct extensions, I just don't want to deal with them every time I change a version number. I've been putting up with this in Safari for years, and honestly, this is enough to make me switch browsers.
Does this drive anyone else nuts? Has anyone found a way to make Safari handle this like Chrome does?