616
Jun 07 '21
People don’t train with sharp steel swords
673
77
u/BrutalPimp420 sword-type-you-like Jun 07 '21
Set plays and sparring absolutely not, but I do solo stuff with sharps.
77
Jun 07 '21
Oh absolutely, cutting tests are fun as hecc
As long as that cutting test isnt your training partners arm
→ More replies (1)15
→ More replies (8)47
u/Mage_914 Jun 07 '21
Well there was that one group from Germany a few years ago. They apparently got very friendly with the local ER staff. They were sparring with sharps and little to no armor. I think Skallagrim did a video on them at one point.
34
u/ezirb7 Jun 07 '21
I toured a fraternity house at a German university a few years back, and they brought us down to a sparring room. Apparently it was common to use sharp swords, and their stance involved holding the sword over their heads.
They said this lead to the stereotype of scarred faces on evil characters, because high ranking nazi's who were in these frats came out with scars.
Found a wiki article about it: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_fencing
→ More replies (9)11
u/Jimothy_McGowan Jun 07 '21
Holmgang Hamburg, or something like that. Not all of their stuff was with sharps, but an unsafe amount seemed to be
→ More replies (2)
527
Jun 07 '21
Axes are not just for savages. I know this about swords but the point has to be made.
137
Jun 07 '21
Heh, "the point"
91
26
Jun 07 '21
Yeah, the joke has quite an edge to it, hard to keep a grip on the topic. Might need to keep up a guard for the sake of clarity.
→ More replies (2)47
855
u/Hawkman2525 Jun 07 '21
I know this the swords reddit, but I'd say the weapon that most gets me to "wtf" and facepalm in its use in fantasy and popular media is the bow. For some reason it's always given to the woman of party, who also tends to be thin and elegant/elvish in appearance. You also see it in video games with character stats, it normally being strength for swords and dexterity for bows, which I'd argue should be the other way round, with the skeletons of professional soldiering archers being deformed by the muscle mass of their shoulders and that surely foot work and the ability to get round the opponents defence is more important that straight up raw strength when it comes to blade work.
419
u/ConstantSignal Jun 07 '21
Yeah you’re spot on here. Anyone who has attempted to fire a full weight medieval longbow will tell you it’s no small task to draw.
You really don’t need a lot of strength to do damage with a sharp spear or sword, and you really do need a lot of strength to be effective with a bow.
→ More replies (2)229
u/halfpeeled7 Jun 07 '21
Yeah, pulling back a 60lb bow and holding it long enough to actually effectively aim it is no small feat. With a recurve, even harder. A friend demonstrated hitting a target at 60 yards with his fancy compound with all the modern furniture. I handed him my 60lb recurve and laughed when he couldn't even draw it.
A well-made longsword on the other hand is lightning in trained hands, requiring more dexterity than portrayed in hack and slash fantasy.
→ More replies (10)75
Jun 07 '21
Mount and Blade Warband approach for that leveling made most sense imo.
Strength allows you to develop damage skills (separate for melee, bow, thrown javelins) higher.
Agility allows you to develop proficiency stats (separate for one handed, two handed, polearms, bows, crossbows, thrown etc.) higher - attack speed and accuracy.
51
u/Sardukar333 Jun 07 '21
The Mount and Blade games may not be perfect, but they are very well researched.
→ More replies (12)18
Jun 07 '21
This is one thing I like about Pathfinder. Dexterity helps you aim the bow but you can add strength to the damage if you have a bow with the proper draw weight.
→ More replies (5)
380
u/M-i-r-n-a Jun 07 '21
It's not that common for a sword to cut in half a solid quarterstaff.
192
u/incredibilis_invicta Jun 07 '21
To add to this, a sword can't cut a shield in two and if a sword gets stuck in wood, you can't yank it out. It's stuck there and you're often very screwed (unless you got a backup weapon).
98
u/DrakonIL Jun 07 '21
Especially when the shield user knows to just twist and yank that sword right out of your hands.
→ More replies (1)66
u/L3PALADIN Jun 08 '21
ironically, i suspect a sword appearing to cut through another sword would be far more common (due to imperfectly uniform quality of steel forming harder, more brittle areas on a swords blade that might snap when hit hard by another blade)
32
u/hydrated_raisin2189 Apr 27 '22
I agree.
Wood is increadibly fiberous and will “catch” the sword kinda like how Kevlar would catch a bullet. The wood would bend around the sword, likely even trapping it as the pressure of the cut and the geometry in the thing you are cutting would cause the wood around and be hind the sword to close with great force.
Meanwhile, steel (or iron/bronze/copper/bone/stone if you are going that route) are far more brittle. While it would be less of a clean cut and more of a shattering, the force of a sword strike on another sword blade and at the right able will cause the grain structure to break apart, causing it to shatter. This is more likely with overheated swords due to an overdeveloped grain structure and far less likely with softer metal.
Source: tad over a year of Blacksmithing experience and about 9 months of bladesmithing experience.
39
u/TitansRPower Jun 07 '21
I absolutely hate when people say stuff like that about quarterstaffs and spears. "Well a sword will just chop right through it hurr hurr, it's just wood"
10
u/hydrated_raisin2189 Apr 27 '22
Quarter staffs are incredibly effective in the right hands. They are blunt force weapons which make them more effective then blades against plate armor and mail, but they also are very light, durable, and versatile.
On top of that, most of them are made from the heartwood of a hardwood tree such as Oak, Ash, or Hawthorn. From experience these are VERY blade resistant unless the blade is very thick (like an axe) or very fast (like a mill/modern saws like band saws) or a combination of dozens of tiny blades moving in tandem (like a hand saw).
623
u/Labrat0770 Jun 07 '21
Sword are not usually made by pouring molten metal into molds.
382
u/Mage_914 Jun 07 '21
As an amateur blacksmith this one pisses me off the most. Nobody in their right mind would make sword from cast iron.
→ More replies (20)22
u/Sardukar333 Jun 07 '21
Except bronze swords, but even so no one cast a sword in an open face mold. You want to limit the work you have to do. Also most castings in movies need more vent holes.
13
u/DrBunnyflipflop Jun 07 '21
Casting was standard practice for bronze swords, wasn't it?
24
u/lacerik Jun 07 '21
Absolutely but the number of popular pieces of media showing bronze weapons is practically zero.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (6)3
248
u/Yaguriel Jun 07 '21
Duels mostly don´t last longer than a few minutes at max. They are incredibly tiring and you would visibly see people get more sloppy and exhausted very quickly, especially when fighting in plate armour.
123
u/NotDoritoMan Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
Well, yes, duels generally don’t last very long, but I gotta say no to people getting sloppy and tired quickly.
Coming from fencing foil or saber (where it’s always fast-paced), adrenaline is a hell of a drug. You can easily have two decent fencers going at it for a while before either of them are showing signs of significant fatigue. If adrenaline can do that in a sport, then I can’t imagine how far it would take you when it’s for your life.
61
u/Yaguriel Jun 07 '21
Yeah, I was talking more about longsword duels in full plate with visor down there. Maybe should have clarified
→ More replies (1)18
u/Grav_Zeppelin Jun 07 '21
Same experience in hema, Larp and boxing, adrenaline helps a lot, but at some point it just wares off rather quickly and you’re close to collapsing
75
u/Mage_914 Jun 07 '21
People who think duels last very long at all have never done martial arts. Just being on the wrestling team in High School I can tell you that most relatively fit people can't last more than 2-3 minutes without getting extremely exhausted during an actual match. Longest match I ever had was 9 minutes due to multiple overtime and I almost passed out afterwards.
20
10
u/therossian Jun 07 '21
I too once went to double ovetime. At the end, I had to have someone help me stand up. Then the ref had to lift one of our hands in victory. We were both too tired to lift our hands more than a little. I was too tired to know if I won or not. Afterwards, I went and gorged before wrestling again in another hour or so. Fun times.
19
u/DenTheRedditBoi7 Jun 07 '21
This is something I really like about For Honor. Most duels are short, and mostly spent trying to read your opponent and not clashing swords together.
→ More replies (1)16
u/fuckoffcucklord Jun 07 '21
Street fistfights don't last even a minute usually. So 2-3 mins is pretty dang long.
13
u/bowtothehypnotoad Jun 07 '21
I used to fence with a lightweight foil sword. Very modern and easy to hold.
You still get tired crazy quickly though, try holding something out fully in front of your chest for a few minutes and you’ll understand.
236
u/daemons-and-dust Jun 07 '21
For the love of god stop heating blades red hot in campfires to cauterise wounds/torture/scratch your balls. You've just fucked the temper and that thing won't hold an edge again. Seen it in a few movies/books and makes me grit my teeth every time
→ More replies (1)142
u/The13thParadox Jun 07 '21
I mean if it’s my arm or my dagger...
→ More replies (1)116
u/daemons-and-dust Jun 07 '21
For sure, but there was one scene in django unchained where someone was tied up about to be tortured and the guy takes his belt knife and heats it red hot. There's other tools around, don't ruin your knife! (also don't torture, but that's besides the point)
→ More replies (2)
328
u/Anti-PC04 Jun 07 '21
Daggers got more kills in armoured battles
165
u/cogesmate Jun 07 '21
You reminded me of the scene in The King, where Henry is rolling around in the mud with a dagger and a war hammer. fkn gnarly.
→ More replies (3)135
u/DangerSmooch Jun 07 '21
Usually two armored opponents would end up wrestling on the ground. German fighting manuals call it "ringen" and it is the most common kind of struggle for a knight to be killed in.
→ More replies (5)
156
u/No_Clarity Jun 07 '21
You probably shouldn't spin around in circles when striking with a sword.
49
u/Sardukar333 Jun 07 '21
There are some moves that do that, but they are for specific circumstances and in nearly all of them the sword is kept close to the body while the spinning occurs.
Most of the ones I've seen go from a wide strike to pulling the blade in close to allow you to pivot faster by conservation of momentum before either engaging a different opponent or (rarely) coming back around in a sort feint.
2
u/Aerin_Soronume Jun 20 '21
Sword dont have a pasive skill to render a spear pole into a pile of splinters.
I have a friend who is writting a story i usually call this kind of bs, is a good story but it have a few anime moments, like stoping a full force axe blow with a sword like nothing, or a sword just cutting a bronce cuirass, "yes steel is harder than. Bronce but still no kevin"
3
2
138
u/MMSG Jun 07 '21
My pet peeve. If someone is not as strong as their fellow soldiers don't give them a one-handed sword. One handed swords are still heavy but you can only use one hand to wield it. Two handed swords are not much heavier but with room to use both hands so they are easier to hold.
Side note: bows require a lot of strength to properly use too.
→ More replies (1)17
u/Lupinal Jun 08 '21
%100 agree with you. My right forearm got bigger and bigger then my left one after switching from longsword to saber.
→ More replies (1)
137
u/helen790 Jun 07 '21
Swords are often heavy in TTRPGs because they carry the weight of the parties war crimes
→ More replies (1)
117
u/J-OfSpades Jun 07 '21
Swords are bad dildos.
35
u/pl233 Jun 07 '21
Is this because of the training required or the cost involved? Are spears a better option? What about the Roman gladius?
26
u/J-OfSpades Jun 07 '21
Definitely because of the training. The legendary art of Sword Masturbation is hard and complex, requiring years of training.
And not cutting yourself open.
5
4
278
Jun 07 '21
Rapiers were not weak or "light as a feather". They were as heavy as a regular sword, and were also suitable for parrying. And they were flexible. Shattering someone's rapier with your sword is fantasy.
44
u/Skirfir Jun 07 '21
Shattering someone's rapier with your sword is fantasy.
I wouldn't say it's a fantasy. It can happen but it's probably not more common than with any other two swords.
19
u/Teralyzed Jun 07 '21
It’s possible but it requires a flaw in the blade or a well used blade.
→ More replies (3)48
Jun 07 '21
In fact they were heavier than a lot of other swords since they are damn long and a swept hilt weights more than a simple guard.
They weight around the same as a longsword. I assume you knew that already, I spoke it out for the rest who might not know.
6
u/NeutralGeneric Jun 07 '21
Rapiers are one of the swords that require the most strength. They can weigh as much as a longsword, except you are only using one arm held straight out.
→ More replies (17)5
168
u/extrahammer_ Jun 07 '21
Swords were rarely used in battle. In battles, polearms and spears were most usual. Swords mostly were self defense or backup weapons (of course with exceptions).
120
u/texasscotsman Axe Master Jun 07 '21
I think it might be better to say that swords weren't the preferred weapon on battlefields. Most would be armed with a different weapon, such as you described, or axes, maces, and hammers.
I always wonder why Hollywood decided the sword was the "standard" weapon of a medieval battlefield when you'd think they'd choose spears for much the same reason as their historical counter parts. They're cheaper. Plus then you give the hero a sword because he's special and now stands out from everyone else.
63
u/ALonelyRhinoceros Jun 07 '21
I would argue a sword is the best at visibly showing skill on screen. You'd have to be skilled to use many different weapons, but the visual storytelling is a bit more obvious with swords.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (6)27
14
u/American_philosoph Jun 08 '21
I use to think this until my view was complicated a little bit. Lindybeige has a couple episodes where he dives into the battlefield physics of spear/shield/sword fighting. The general gist that you get from those is that in a line, a spear and shield is ideal, but one on one, with a spear and shield vs a sword and shield, (assuming the shields are big enough) the sword fighter wins because he can close and then gains all sorts of options while the spear user loses most of his. And when lines break down, and the mixing starts, carrying around a spear becomes less and less of a good idea. Now I of course don’t put undying faith in LBs interpretation, but it made a lot of sense to me.
20
Jun 07 '21
Especially not in Japan - the bow (used from horseback) was the gentlemanly weapon of choice on the battlefield, followed by the lance/spear.
141
Jun 07 '21
Axes and blunt weapons can often be of similar weights to swords.
→ More replies (1)79
u/floyd1550 Jun 07 '21
Weight distribution is the key to the common misconception that axes were clunkier and slower than a sword. They could be handled within a relative margin of agility as a sword and offered greater utility by providing more power and the ability to hook legs or a shield. Spiked maces and warhammers were a preferred option when faced with more heavily clad opponents due to their ability to distort, tear away, and pierce through plate materials. These too could be used with agility. Swords just push the weight closer to the hand and shorten the lever.
→ More replies (3)19
u/distressedweedle Jun 07 '21
Weight towards the handle vs towards the end of the weapon would definitely reduce agility... Adding an extra 1.5 feet to the CG of the weapon would make it feel 30-50% heavier at your shoulder and 80-100% heavier at your elbow. Meaning waaaaaay more stress on your arm.
→ More replies (1)
68
u/I_DIG_DITCHES Jun 07 '21
You can grab the blade of a sword and not necessarily have your hand turned into mince.
25
u/tyrom22 Jun 08 '21
Not only that but their are techniques that involve holding your own sword by the blade and grabbing your opponents from the bind
→ More replies (1)
172
u/DarkerPerkele Jun 07 '21
Swords werent that common among footsoldiers Instead polearms and spears saw more use in battle
67
u/ZolotoGold Jun 07 '21
Big one right here. The vast majority of melee combat was performed with spears rather than swords.
45
u/Teralyzed Jun 07 '21
And sticks…don’t forget the good ol’stick with something heavy on the end of it. Why buy a sharp pokey sword when you can just smack the dude with a sword with something that fell off a tree and take his sword.
→ More replies (6)30
u/Dallas_Delenda_Est Jun 07 '21
While I appreciate your point, I feel like this is a pretty broad generalization. For example, Roman legionaries after the Marian reforms were equipped with a gladius.
26
u/Camburglar13 Jun 07 '21
They were more the exception rather than the rule for ancient and medieval militaries. The Greeks also had swords but it was a secondary weapon as with most other armies. The roman strategy of pilum throw and basically all swords afterwards was not common. Much easier to train people to use spears than swords, and spears are much cheaper to make.
→ More replies (6)9
→ More replies (1)6
u/Foronir sword-type-you-like Jun 08 '21
Depends on the Time period and the area, think about them as pistols in more modern scenarios.
118
u/FlamingCygnet Jun 07 '21
No one in their right mind would go into melee range with a firearm.
87
u/Hawkman2525 Jun 07 '21
That's not entirely true, bayonets were a thing and bayonet charges were a standard tactic of their time.
45
u/FlamingCygnet Jun 07 '21
True, I should've word it better, but by guns I meant to specify handguns/pistols.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (1)11
u/PsychoPhilosopher Jun 07 '21
Interestingly, British manuals recommend using your pistol as a guard for your forearm by turning it around after firing. Kind of like a Tonfa.
Of course, that's on your offhand with your sword in the primary hand!
166
u/Beledagnir Longsword, Rapier, Messer, Greatsword Jun 07 '21
Katanas are neither vastly better nor vastly worse than other types of swords.
129
u/Sulfurys Jun 07 '21
i'll do you one better, it's completely pointless to compare a japanese and european sword of the same periode since they evoled completely independant from one another.
→ More replies (13)44
54
u/Sir_Daxus Jun 07 '21
Sword SHOULDN'T* go shwing when drawn, cause that suggests metal on metal contact and most likely the sword getting scratched up for no reason. It can however go shwing in the air if swung right and with enough speed!
27
u/Foronir sword-type-you-like Jun 08 '21
Comes from the standard metal sheath of sabres, 1800s onwards, Yeah, they dulled rather quick, brits and americans where awed by the "sharp blades" of the Indians and Japanese...guess what, wooden sheathes.
39
u/thatstormtrooper97 Jun 07 '21
Kings are known to put down the sword for a mace or warhammer every now and then
27
37
u/bayoubilly88 Jun 07 '21
Reforging the pieces of a broken sword is a bad idea.
32
→ More replies (2)4
u/ali94127 Jun 08 '21
Well you can fix it, but it’s not as simple as just hitting it a few times when the pieces are hot.
37
u/Tupac_Fhurri Jun 08 '21
Katanas/tachi/nodachi cant cut through armor or european swords
Samurai armor was nit made of wood.
You cant cast a sword, only forge it
Europeans also had folded steel and not just japan
6
u/A1steaksaussie Oct 23 '21
you can cast bronze swords
7
u/Tupac_Fhurri Oct 23 '21
I mean with how other movies portray it with one side open, and the steel being orange bright and melting
→ More replies (1)
36
Jun 07 '21
Question:
When would spear+ large shield be better than sword+ large shield and vice versa?
50
→ More replies (1)32
u/Yaguriel Jun 07 '21
Spear would be better for economic reasons. You can easily outfit an entire army with shields and spears on the cheap. Try that with swords and you´ll be sure to loose the war because you spent all your money on swords to equip grunts that have no idea how to use them.
The advantage of the spear is that any idiot can use them with next to no training, especially when fighting in close formation.
Swords require proper instruction by skilled combatants over an extensive amount of time.
The sword is also (contrary to most popular fiction) a weapon suited to defensive fighting due to it´s ability to easily deflect and parry which is why it was the weapon used by nobles and officers up to the the first world war. Your officers were not expected to do the actual killing in close combat but rather survive so that they can continue to order their men.
The only reason the romans managed to make large scale use of swords it was because they had a huge empire with a well oiled military machine and even then the gladius was not the main weapon and was used more like a long dagger for stabbing in between the shields of the formation instead of being used like a "traditional" western European sword.The main "problem" with the Tower/Kiteshield and sword combination is that the heavy shield means a lot of weight to balance with out while the sword has the majority of its weight concentrated towards the hilt making it a more nimble weapon.
I find this combination to be most believable on mounted noblemen, especially in the early medieval period from the 800s to the 11th century where knights were equipped mostly with chainmail, a large shield, a spear and a one handed weapon like a sword, axe or mace.
It seems plausible that a knight would have switched to his sword in case his spear got stuck, broke or he was dismounted either voluntarily or involuntarily.
dl;dr: Spears are vastly superior in formation and on regular foot troops, swords were expensive and never employed on a large scale and they were a defensively orientated weapon to keep important leaders alive rather than killing enemies.→ More replies (3)12
Jun 07 '21
So regarding the gladius
Would a shielded group with gladii beat a shielded group with spears?
→ More replies (3)
36
u/bigsisterishurtingme Jun 07 '21
swords dont make a metal clinking sound when you adjust your grip on them but in demon slayer it does and i dont understand
22
7
u/Foronir sword-type-you-like Jun 08 '21
If it does, it means your handle or handguard is loose
7
u/randybowman Jun 08 '21
He cut a boulder in half with it so it makes sense his grip would loosen up.
→ More replies (3)
33
u/NeverSeenBeforeName Jun 07 '21
Sticking your sword in the ground was a bad idea as it could dull the blade.
86
u/Vacation-Capable Jun 07 '21
I got a few:
Back scabbard was not a thing
Swords don't throw off sparks when blades hit each other
Hand is often the most venerable area in a sword fight
Fullers function is not to "channel blood"
Thrusts are more efficient in killing opponent than cuts. However, they are less disabling - unless you manage to pierce a major organ, your enemy may not even realize they were stabbed and will continue fighting some more
57
u/Skirfir Jun 07 '21
Back scabbard was not a thing
I have to disagree with you there. There is a first hand account in "Swordsmen of the British Empire" where it is described how an Indian of Afghan soldier draws a sword from his back and it is mentioned how he has to grip the blade to do so. I would write down the quote here but unfortunately I can't look it up at the moment.
But it certainly wasn't common and I don't know of any sources from Europe let alone the medieval times.
→ More replies (11)20
u/Vacation-Capable Jun 07 '21
Thanks. I am very interested in this quote. If you are able to find it, please share it here or PM me
→ More replies (3)21
Jun 07 '21
Back scabbards bugged me to no end until I saw a video of an armorer who also worked in movies. Back scabbards get used to save time and money on reshoots.
A hub belt usually stretches, so shots at the end of the day will have the sword riding noticeably lower than at the start of the day. Makes editing together shots tougher. Also takes a lot of practice to wear a sword on your hip without knocking things over, sitting down awkwardly, maybe catching the end and tipping your sword out…
So I still don’t like them, but I scaled back to a quiet eye roll rather than ranting.
15
6
u/pl233 Jun 07 '21
Is the idea of back scabbards simply that it's easier to haul around a sword belt out of combat if you sling your belt over a shoulder instead of having a sword dangling from your waist?
5
u/Dlatrex All swords were made with purpose Jun 07 '21
For European context, sure the point about pop culture back scabbards is fine, and should point out there is very little evidence of use for most swords (you may have exceptions for some things like cinquedea).
Further east, there are certainly examples of back mounts for swords of various lengths.
From China
https://www.facebook.com/groups/ChineseMilitaryHistoryGroup/permalink/3553413118057148/
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1798310533530183&set=gm.1479172115481269&type=3
Japan
Thailand
Speaking of Thailand, I have attend Krabi-Krabong demonstrations where the participants used sharp blades instead of blunts: rest assured there were plenty of sparks that were flying while they went after each other with great vigor.
Not all swords/sword strikes will cause this effect, but it certainly can happen.
5
u/Flintlocke89 Jun 07 '21
Steel on steel absolutely CAN produce sparks, it's why steel hammers are a massive no-no in ATEX environments.
4
u/Sardukar333 Jun 07 '21
I'd imagine the back scabbard for larger swords was popular among people that traveled without retainers. But they wouldn't draw it from the scabbard while it was on their back, even if they did they'd have to fight with a big stick flapping around on their back. More likely they'd unsling the entire setup from their back and draw the sword, tossing the scabbard aside.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (7)3
u/fuckoffcucklord Jun 07 '21
Back scabbard is cool tho ):
Shiny spark go ⚡⚡⚡
But hitting hands is not dramatic. 4.wtf is that
The only thing that wouldn't make the swordfighting less cool.
24
u/bro_cat_82 Jun 07 '21
Tbh, every sword I’ve ever pulled out of a scabbard has gone “scheming”. It’s typically because I’m saying it... but damned if it hasn’t happened every time!
23
u/KasperBuyens Bastardsword Jun 07 '21
People don't die instantly when hit by a sword, except when you literally sever their head or smash their skull to smithereens
62
u/Occyfel2 Jun 07 '21
The locking blades with an enemy is incredibly overused
24
u/Lionfromthenorth1718 Jun 07 '21
Binding does happen when two blades notch, but any competent swordsman would retreat or advance from a bind, not just stand there pushing their swords together.
20
u/Mayo_z Jun 07 '21
Idea: have the main character break these rules so badly that the enemy is too busy laughing to fight back
18
18
u/Nova-The-Dog Jun 07 '21
Katanas are not god swords that can cut through everything and anything, think of them as super sharp knives because they’re only really good at cutting through meat. Definitely one of the cooler swords though
5
u/Hopeless-Necromantic Jun 07 '21
Katana, much like swords, are also sidearms to the yumi or naginata.
→ More replies (1)
17
17
u/JCtheWanderingCrow Jun 07 '21
If you spin in a sword fight you’re going to die. Don’t “spin away” from your opponent. Don’t twirl, don’t pirouette. Sword fighting is not ballet. 💃🏻🤺
46
14
u/Mieczyslaw_Chaladus Jun 07 '21
I will actually add my own. SWORDS DO NOT GO THROUGH ARMOUR! (Maybe gambeson if it's really sharp and pointy)
5
13
u/Kharimata Jun 07 '21
Stabbing with the pointy end seems to work much better than trying to slash.
5
u/Foronir sword-type-you-like Jun 08 '21
Depends, slashes are better at incapacitating unarmored opponents, stabs are better at killing, but take longer to take one down.
13
12
u/trumoi Armizare/Iberian Beginner Jun 07 '21
European swords are, in fact, on average heavier than swords from other cultures, however the amount that they are heavier is minimal and they are always designed to be as easy to handle as what was within the reach of the smith's materials and skills.
I'll add though: Swords are usually sidearms. They have more presence as representations of violence because they were a common part of most professional-warrior's kits regardless of their battlefield role. They were also used in civilian self-defence, which means people saw them in use far more often than a polearm or a bow.
Think of swords like pistols and polearms like rifles. Guards will sometimes hold the latter, but outside of that nobody really walks around with them and if they do its viewed as pretty militant and threatening. The former though is still considered scary and deadly, but is far more commonly seen and associated as a "weapon you'd take anywhere".
28
u/tomdebom01 Jun 07 '21
B-But my sword is made of magic-infused dragonsteel! Very heavy, can’t cut skin but can cleave armour in half, and always goes shwing!
8
u/AliasMcFakenames Jun 07 '21
Shardblades are in The Stormlight Archive, not Dragonsteel.
→ More replies (2)
47
u/Tommodatchi Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
Skilled duellists are no match for aggressive competent warriors.
The idea that a person can practice skills in a vaccuum in a traditional fencing school and become a competent warrior is very fanciful.
During the Napoleonic wars French officers introduced duelling proper to British culture. Brits were however allready renowned for getting drunk and killing each other. . .
When the French officers challenged the British officers to these duels tradition dictated that the person challenged could choose their weapon. French officers were nearly all skilled swordsmen with sabers etc. having been practicing at drill school and with real duels (most often to first blood)
how ever the British officers were choosing the tool most well known to them, the boarding sword; essentially a machete with some form of hand protection. The French officers whom were so used to their own cultural norms were then (usually) unceremoniously chopped up by the British officers whom were taught to be far more aggressive.
Edit: originally wrote rapier, changed to saber as it better describes contemporarily fashionable weapons.
26
u/texasscotsman Axe Master Jun 07 '21
You got a source for that. It sounds, hilarious.
→ More replies (3)5
u/AmunRa1928 Jun 07 '21
I thought rapiers went out of style long before the Napoleonic wars ?
→ More replies (1)11
8
u/YT_RandomGamer01 Jun 07 '21
Can someone explain why the bloody sword in a scabbard is a no no please
8
u/LucasDaVinci Jun 07 '21
Well the last one is wrong cause I just say shwing whenever I draw a sword cause I’m human
28
u/BrutalPimp420 sword-type-you-like Jun 07 '21
Scabbards and sheaths are two different things and not interchangeable.
13
u/SpacemanSpiff246 Jun 07 '21
Can you explain what the difference is? I’m new here
→ More replies (7)
7
u/goblinmarketeer Jun 07 '21
Worked for a jousting company eons ago. They had metal beads on the scabbards to make the shwing noise when being draw because people expected it.
Also swords ring when they hit each other... it is a distinctive sound.
7
u/izi777 Jun 07 '21
Rapiers are not super flexible they are stiff enought to pierce though thick clothes and parry other swords.
13
u/ImNotThaaatDrunk Jun 07 '21
"A sword carries more weight in its past than in the heft of its steel." Its called symbolism, just a little something that writers like to use.
18
u/Tommodatchi Jun 07 '21
My sword is not only heavy bbut it drinks the blood of its foes while resting in its scabbard. It screams "Schwing in the excited voice of both a 45 and 12 yo male when ever its swung sometimes along with a weeeeeeee! Its also a katana that can chop through anything and kills any enemies instantly just by running the blade over the belly, even when they're wearing chainmail or brigandine armour. Chops straight through plate!
60
u/Praetorian80 Jun 07 '21
But it is fiction so realities don’t need to apply. Poetic licence is fine.
One can argue that you need a basis in reality. But let’s face it. These things above do not break immersion or ruin the world they’re in.
A relatively small purist/snobs might avoid reading something due to this but they rarely affect sales.
34
Jun 07 '21
yeah but it sucks to see something ridiculous on screen. If you have a semi realistic medieval setting and the main character fell from a cliff then got up just fine youd be scratching your head. Its not about the fact that it happens its the fact that shows like GOT do it
→ More replies (14)20
u/Yaguriel Jun 07 '21
True, they don´t. I have no problem with artistic licences and such but what I do have a problem with is when a book or movie or show claims to be realistic but is really not.
Best current example: Vikings
They claim to have done a lot of research and that their outfits are historical when in fact very little about the shows props or fights is historically accurate.
The main problem with this is not that they´re making a false claim to get more people to watch it but that people who don´t know any better believe what they´re seeing at face value which then perpetuates a lot of historical myths like the Ragnar Hairstyle which in fact never existed irl.
6
u/Moosi312 Jun 07 '21
Swords ALWAYS go shwing when moving it slowly through the air
\s
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Aao12612 Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
Why the blood one though so after a battle I’m supposed to just pull out a napkin and wipe it down
3
u/Antique_Steel Forde Military Antiques Jun 07 '21
A swordsman would look after his sword diligently. Why wouldn't you clean it? A bloodied sword returned to its scabbard would not be drawable after the blood dried.
4
u/Chewcifer-90 Jun 07 '21
Yes. Rust kills swords and blood (and other bodily fluids) will rust the blade. Put the bloody blade in its scabbard and you got a rust-maker
4
u/Hopeless-Necromantic Jun 07 '21
Do you put the knife you just made your PBJ with back in the drawer or do you clean it first?
2
u/Dovakiins Jun 07 '21
I mean it’s fiction. Maybe all those points are wrong in their fiction...
3
u/Antique_Steel Forde Military Antiques Jun 07 '21
True, but inaccuracies are rarely intended in that way.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/pcmast3r Jun 07 '21
A KATANA CAN NOT SLICE A BUILDING IN HALF IN FACT KATANAS ARE NOT THE GREATEST SWORD and depending on who makes it not the sharpest. To add to this a katana is not the most badass sword.
4
4
4
u/thisremindsmeofbacon Jun 08 '21
when you swing a sword with good edge alignment it does not make a loud rushing swish noise, it makes a quiet "swick" sound.
dual sword wielding wasn't done much in battle, but it was done outside of battle - at which point its actually a huge advantage over just one sword.
holding your sword dagger grip is terrible.
there's never long standoff's where people press swords together and glare.
swords don't have to go on the left hip only, even fairly long swords can comfortably be drawn from the right hip.
someone with a spear has a large advantage vs someone with a sword.
a well balanced sword does not always mean the balance is right back on the blade towards the handle - some of the most famously deadly swords of all time are fairly point heavy (dacian falx, dao, kukri).
the biggest benefit of two handing a sword is not how hard you hit your target - in fact thats honestly only changed a small amount. instead it makes certain types of movement much more agile (such as attack swing recovery) as well as increasing your blade stability ie. ability to block and not be parried/knocked out of the way.
4
4
7
Jun 07 '21
Swords were expensive, so they used weapon-tools and spears to minimize the expense.
6
u/Skirfir Jun 07 '21
During the early medieval period they were, during the late medieval period they were pretty cheap. Well cheap swords were cheap, there were of course very expensive swords during that time as well but a soldier form the 15th century would not likely get into financial trouble if he bought a sword.
3
3
u/-Jiras Jun 07 '21
If you try and cut a bullet with a sword and even manage that, you will have two shotwounds instead of one
3
u/incredibilis_invicta Jun 07 '21
Cutting someones head off with one swing is nearly impossible unless it's a sword made for it (executioners sword) or you have the person, without armour, right in front of you, presenting their neck.
3
u/that_gunslinger_guy Jun 08 '21
Some knights used maces, especially when fighting against other knights. They didn't all carry swords.
3
u/Metalhed69 Jun 08 '21
Carrying a sword slung on your back and drawing over your shoulder is a tv/movie trope. In real life it’s very difficult to draw one that way and it really wasn’t done. It just looks good.
3
3
3
Jun 08 '21
Actually in iaido, it is bad to make a sound when drawing the the sword because that means the draw wasn't made properly and the scabbard is being nicked. At the correct angle, it should come out pretty much silently no matter the speed of the draw. It takes skill.
3
u/ali94127 Jun 08 '21
Dual wielding is really hard and the cost almost always is not worth the benefit depending on the scenario. A shield is almost always preferred. Looks cool though.
3
3
u/TitanBrass Jun 10 '22
A sword is not ideal for cutting through heavy armor unless it's a fucking gigantic (and thus heavy) one. Seriously.
3
u/SlackJawGrunt Dec 12 '23
Swords don’t usually rattle like they’re all poorly assembled. I really only notice this in anime and Japanese period dramas.
2
2
2
2
2
2
Jun 08 '21
Most battle worn practical swords are not "Gleaming" and few people fought with swords bare handed
2
u/SontoBontoTanto Jun 08 '21
True. But a sword does get pretty heavy after you fight with it for awhile
2
2
Jun 08 '21
You cant jump and spin pointing the sword down to reduce the damage taken from a certain height
2
u/rockmodenick Jul 24 '21
Specifically, swords and bayonets drawn from a metal scabbard which uses a tongue spring to retain the blade can make a metallic shw-ting when drawn quickly. Learned to do it on my Argentine Mauser bayonet.
2
Aug 30 '21
Tangentially related: people don’t wear leather clothes or throw buckets of shit into the street.
2
u/ChrisRoadd Sep 10 '24
necro but the biggest takeaway is that sometimes, fantasy is just that, fantasy. Just like all the people pretending they were born in 1750 and actively participated in warfare
7
u/the-ancient-1 Jun 07 '21
I will make the sound effect my self than.