r/SWN • • Oct 26 '20

SWN using D&D 5e rules?

Hi there! I love SWN, I found it right before the revised edition came out and really got into it. I want to introduce some players to it, but I think that if there was a version that used the D&D 5e ruleset it might be a little more palatable. Has anyone adapted it already, or done a conversion guide already? Thanks for your help!

9 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

45

u/Drynwyn Oct 26 '20

I wouldn’t recommend this, I don’t think 5e would give you a good SWN experience. A certain kind of progression is top baked into 5e’s rules, as is minimal character customization. SWN’s skill point/focus system offers a lot of opportunity for customization, and opts for a quite different ‘feel’ of progression. It might be “more appealing” to them, but it won’t be a good experience- it’ll probably wind up feeling like D&D in space, in which case, just play D&D in space.

6

u/zatatmando Oct 26 '20

That is very true, thank you, and u/Captain_Hoyt for your input. It is true that it wouldn't be quite the same, I was more looking for something easier to step into, since it may be a short run for us, just a couple of nights. I think I may still try to go for it, and just see what we can do.

20

u/JoePeppy Oct 26 '20

If you're looking for something familiar to D&D that has a space feel, check out Dark Matter 5e. It's a third-party sci-fi campaign setting for D&D 5e that I found about a month ago and have fallen absolutely in love with.

The rules are straight 5e and all the normal classes/items exist and work just fine, but this expands it to include modern/futuristic technology and rules for things like space combat.

8

u/thraggon Oct 26 '20

Came here to recommend dark matter instead as well.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

Dark Matter is great. Mage Hand Press also has an amazing patreon that they use to design a lot of 5e content that's pretty incredible stuff. Their complete classes are worth paying for on the patreon.

11

u/HolyMoholyNagy Oct 26 '20

It's a pretty simple ruleset, adapting 5e would be more trouble than it's worth in my opinion. What specifically are you worried about? Is it about understanding the game or will your group reject non-5e options?

8

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20

You can roll-up a character by rolling 4-6 dice (Quick Character Creation, pg 26), all the rules players need fit on one page (System Quick Reference Sheet, pg 59), how can 5E even approach being so easy to try?

6

u/_gl_hf_ Oct 26 '20

The issue is not that it wouldn't be quite the same. It's the SWN is designed to be a ruleset that plays in a specific way. Removing that is removing essentially the whole game. The ruleset is overall easier to learn then 5e, give players some pre Gen sheets and most of it theyll have figured out in the first hour or so of session

8

u/ThatAdamKient Oct 26 '20

This. Genre doesn't define how a game plays, you have to pick the system for the type of game you want. It's totally cool to play 5e in space, as long as you're okay for the game to be the same in everything but theme.

74

u/Captain_Hoyt Oct 26 '20

Then it wouldn't really be SWN, would it?

I like SWN because it isn't 5e.

So you're looking for science fiction with 5e-ish rules? If it helps, the paid version has 'heroic' rules, where the PCs aren't as squishy, and it's a little more geared for combat.

3

u/admetes Oct 26 '20

I also recommend heroic rules, depending on what you want they can also be modified.
Heroic Character allow greater flexibility.
They take less damage. And have fray die to use against weaker opponents. (1d6 or 1d8)
Have 1 extra focus in 10 levels. (1 every even level instead of the usual progression)
Have higher attribute scores.
Nemesis NPCS are also great foes with their own fray dies.

My heroic rules modifications are as follows.
No doom damage rule(although very useful if you play with 1 or two characters only)
They do normal damage instead of hit dice damage.
They do not autostabilize.
I just half the incoming damage instead of doing math for every dice roll. (Although they can be used when not many enemies are there)

Alternatively you can just can start the players at higher level with normal character progression

19

u/anthropoll Oct 26 '20

I'm not sure I understand what you're asking for here. It seems like you don't actually want to use the rules of SWN? To my knowledge there's no conversion of SWN to 5e because that would just be 5e. SWN has guidelines in the xenobestiary section for adapting creatures from other games into it, and I believe the space magic section also outlines how to adapt spells from something like D&D into SWN.

Truthfully, SWN on a 5e rule set wouldn't be SWN. Swapping out the 2d6 system for 1d20 would result in massive changes to how every class works, and just the statistical "feel" of the game. You might be better off finding a science fiction adaptation of DND, rather than plugging the 5e rules into SWN.

Haven't played it myself, but I believe Starfinder would have a lot in common with D&D? That might be closer to what you want.

-2

u/da_chicken Oct 26 '20

I'm not sure I understand what you're asking for here.

SWN is a rules system and a campaign setting.

2

u/Cypher1388 Oct 26 '20

Not really. The campaign setting is procedurally generated off the rule set. You can't really extract them and if you tried there really isn't much left over. Other than.... Space.

Hence everyone's comments in the thread, just play dnd in space if that's what your looking for.

5

u/da_chicken Oct 27 '20

I don't think it's remotely difficult to see the bits you can rip out whole-hog. Sector generation, adventure generation, faction generation, society tools, and most of the GM tools pull out 100% clean and can be dropped into any rules system. They might reference things the rest of the game uses, but they aren't driven by any of the systems in them so an analog in another rules set would work just as well. It would be trivial to run the rest of the game just as well with Savage Worlds Sci-Fi + The Last Parsec (which is what we played before SWN).

However, the point I'm making is that the campaign setting (to use D&D terms) is almost entirely defined by the chapter "History of Space". You could alter anything in that, and it changes the tone of the game and what you'd expect to find. You could make it during the First Wave, or the Second Wave, or during the Silence. That radically changes things, to the point that the sector generation tables would be wrong. The setting as presented exists to force the campaign setting into a post-apocalyptic setting that's, unsurprisingly, very similar narratively to Greyhawk because it's trying to emulate the same style of gameplay that OG Greyhawk had. While the game does tell you to roll randomly to generate your Village of Hommlett and there's no pre-defined worlds for you to use in the core book, that doesn't mean the setting is mute or inseparable from those tables.

Beyond that, the first 2-3 pages of virtually every chapter, or the first several paragraphs of a section, include a description for how each bit works within the setting. You can apply that lore to whatever analog you want.

Those above systems and above lore are basically independent of the other set of systems in the game: character generation and advancement system, the skills system, the combat and equipment system, the psionic system, the vehicle, mech, and starship systems, and the xeno system. Those are all loosely tied together to one degree or another (typically by the combat or skill rules), but the rules themselves do relatively little to define the settings. Yes, sure, you need starships and a combat system and the tools of a certain level of technology. But you don't need that particular flavor to play in the SWN setting and generate your campaign setting with the rules there. Indeed, you don't even need to roll to generate your setting; the GM can just pick what they want. You don't need to randomly roll everything at all. You can play SWN as an RNG sandbox, but you don't have to.

Maybe you don't want to play this way. That's fine. However, if you seriously can't see that you could do this -- not that it wouldn't be a fair bit of work to find analogs for everything but that you can do it -- then I question how many games you've run. I can't imagine a GM not seeing a game as just a set of choices and tools, any of which you can modify or replace however you wish. It's not the easiest to do that, definitely, but that's very different from "you can't they're inseparable".

That's what Crawford meant at the end of the introduction:

Above all, Stars Without Number is your game now. There is no one "correct" way to play it. There is only your way to play it, and you should feel free to make it the game you want to play.

8

u/eskatonic Oct 26 '20

Someone's already mentioned Dark Matter. There are several other Science Fiction games using the 5e rules. Check out Esper Genesis. It's essentially 5e "reskinned" for science fiction. As in, they literally just renamed the classes and spells and filed off the serial numbers. :D

https://espergenesis.alligatoralleyentertainment.com/

8

u/Dr_NANO Oct 26 '20

I think SWN is rules light enough that you should learn the system even if it only for a few sessions. The rules for space combat alone is worth learning the system for!

7

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20

The ruleset is so much easier, cleaner and well written than 5E, it’s worth reading up even for a few sessions. Honestly, it’s a breath of fresh air.

5

u/twisted7ogic Oct 26 '20

I mostly agree with others in the thread that 5e's rules dont really suit SWN's feel or mission, and probably wont be very good.

That said, while there are no explicit swn to 5e conversions that I know of, there are a few 5e based scifi systems out there. There is no reason you couldnt use those togheter with swn's excellent gm tools.

5

u/ericvulgaris Oct 26 '20

There's already lots of 5e hacks that include sci-fi elements if that's what you want. Dark Matter and Esper Genesis, for instance.

SWN has a different feel from 5e mechanically and thematically for good reasons.

4

u/Never_Peel_a_Lemon Oct 26 '20

What elements exactly do you like and are looking to use from SWN like many have said it’s a completely different system but on the same set of systems so full conversion doesn’t really make sense. What do you want to keep?

4

u/DarkGuts Oct 26 '20

You can modify your 5e rule set for space (like changing skills around, reskinning classes to be more like sci-fi classes).

And you can use SWN sector building rules with any RPG system.

Straight conversion though? It wouldn't work. Don't even know what rules are so important that you couldn't do in 5e. Only thing I can think of is space rules. You'd just have to figure best way to convert target numbers for skill checks from 2d6 to d20.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20

You can port stuff like sector generation and the faction system over to any system, they stand alone.

Otherwise, if you really want 5e, you would need to come up with, or port over:

  • Skill list (and a mapping of SWN DCs to 5e DCs)

  • Classes and their abilities

  • Feats (if you want to allow them)

  • Powers (or spells, or both, depending what you want for psionics/magic)

  • Equipment (weapons and armor especially)

Not a small undertaking, but doable.

That said, I'd echo what others have said, and that trying to shoe-horn every game into 5e isn't the best approach. SWN is not a difficult system to learn, and there are so many great games out there, like SWN, that do their own thing better than 5e can ever do. I honestly think your time is better spent helping the players learn a new system.

3

u/michaelaaronblank Oct 26 '20

With what everyone else has said, it would be possible to lift elements and port them to 5E,such as Factions. But there is no official psionics system for 5E yet, so you would have to find something for that.

3

u/Munedawg53 Oct 26 '20

I have friends that went right from 5e to SWN and it wasn't that hard for them. In fact, one thing they liked a lot was that combat was nowhere near as bloated or cumbersome as it is in 5e!

3

u/kadzar Oct 27 '20

I ran SWN for for the first time for my D&D 5e group, and they were able to make characters and play a decent session in the same night.

It's really not that complicated, especially if you have some decent handouts to help them through character creation and remembering the rules in play.

For instance, u/Gwenito made this great character sheet inspired by Mothership that goes through character creation step-by-step. And u/BruceSillyWalk made a bunch of cheat sheets to help their 5e group.

Honestly, unless your group just flat out refuses to play any other system than 5e, there's not really many good reason to not just run SWN.

3

u/Morokite Oct 27 '20

Give it a go. Most of my friends only played 5e and got into SWN pretty easily. Matter fact some of us even prefer a few things(2d6 skill rolls for starters) in the swn system.
Had to clarify the occasional rule but it went smoothly overall

4

u/wampusboy Oct 26 '20

Much of what's in the SWN rulebook is system neutral. You can just use 5e's rules, but then use the setting and generators from SWN. SWN's rules are already basically 5e but stripped down. It would just be pointless work converting the rules back again.

4

u/Zyr47 Oct 26 '20

I wouldn't say SWN is at all 5e. More like 5e is SWN's root game twisted up as much or more as SWN does to the root game. (Basic/Expert D&D for SWN, AD&D2+4e remixed for 5e)

5

u/RengawRoinuj Oct 26 '20

You should look at Starfinder. I think it will suit your needs.

1

u/lobo2100 Oct 26 '20

Came here to recommend Starfinder. It’s literally D&D in space

2

u/Jonatan83 Oct 26 '20

If you strip away the stuff you'd need to strip away to make a decent sci-fi game out of 5e, you would have to remove or re-create the races, classes, spells, items & magical items, feats, world stuff, and monsters. The only thing left is a pretty bland rpg system and a huge amount of work to do. Not sure why anyone would do this to be honest.

2

u/nyktovus Oct 27 '20

there is no reason this wouldnt work

1

u/Rudette Oct 27 '20 edited Oct 27 '20

To me, SWN is the best bits of DnD and Traveller combined, packaged with amazing DMing tools.

My dude, it doesn't get much more palatable than jumping from 5e to SWN; If you know how to play 5e, you basically know how to play SWN: Revised. The transition is easy. That was a huge part of the reason I picked it over some other systems in the first place. Even my players who have only ever had experience with 5e picked it up fast and had a great time.

Have faith in yourself and your players, man. <3