r/stobuilds • • Dec 07 '20

Guide The Baby Step Series Part 1: The First Step - Level 40 T5 Assault Cruiser Leveling Build

206 Upvotes

The Baby Step Series Part 1: The First Step - Level 40 T5 Assault Cruiser Leveling Build

Part 2: https://www.reddit.com/r/stobuilds/comments/k8ultu/the_baby_step_series_part_2_the_next_step_fresh/

Part 3: https://www.reddit.com/r/stobuilds/comments/k9jct6/the_baby_step_series_part_3_the_last_step_level/

For more comprehensive ship building information: www.stobetter.com

Build Info

"Hi, and welcome to part 1 of the Baby Step Series!

STO is terrible at teaching new players how to build their ships and unfortunately there is a lot of junk for them to sort through in order to figure it out. In this post I hope to give an example of what a good ship build looks like using the best basic gear, that can be used as a template for free/scaling T6 ships from low levels up to level 50 on normal difficulty, and allow new players to push forward on to more advanced builds.

I chose the T5 Assault Cruiser as the base since the Sovereign is a fan favorite, is performancewise one of the better options to choose from at level 40, and is arguably a better platform than the Galaxy option given at level 61. Cruisers using beam array (BA) broadside builds are also typically the best option for new/less experienced players. They have a lot more wiggle room concerning weapon firing arcs (easier to keep fire on targets), hull values (higher hull capacity and damage resistances), and access to engineering bridge officer (boff) abillities that can help with survivability.

In my opinion, escorts using dual cannons (DC)/dual heavy cannons (DHC) + turrets would be the next step after mastering cruiser play, with science vessels using exotic abilties and torpedoes (scitorp) being the next step after mastering escort play. Of course, this is just my opinion. You can start off in a science vessel or escort and master those kinds of ships first, but the learning curve would probably be a bit steeper.

Let's go to school!"

Player Information

Player Info--------------
Captain NameAll da capitans ;)
Captain FactionAll, though KDF and Rommys will be a bit different as this is focused on a FED ship and phasers.
Captain RaceAll. Captain race is unimportant outside of space barbie, though aliens are generally better because they get a 10th personal trait.
Captain ProfessionAll. Captain career has nothing to do with ship choice or build. If you want to chase DPS, go tac.
Primary SpecializationNone because noobs won't have this yet.
Secondary Specialization""
Intended RoleTo not suck while leveling.

Skill Tree

  Engineering Science Tactical 
Lieutenant Hull RestorationHull CapacityShield RestorationShield CapacityAdvanced Energy Weapon TrainingAdvanced Projectile Weapon Training
        
Lieutenant Commander Improved EPS FlowImproved Impulse ExpertiseControl ExpertiseDrain ExpertiseImproved Targeting ExpertiseImproved Defensive Manuvering
5 Points         
        
Commander Hull Plating Shield RegenerationShield HardnessAdvanced Weapon AmplificationAdvanced Weapon specialization'
15 Points       
        
        
Captain    Advanced Long Range TargetingAdvanced Hull PenetrationAdvanced Shield Penetration
25 Points      
       
        
Admiral Warp Core PotentialEngineering Readiness Scientific ReadinessCoordination ProtocolsTactical Readiness
35 Points    Defensive Coordination  
  Warp Core Efficency   Offensive Coordination  
        
Total of 46 of 46 Points Engineering Points:10Science Points:10Tactical Points:26

Skill Tree Unlocks

Points to unlockEngineering UnlocksScience UnlocksTactical Unlocks
Unlocks After 2Training Manual:Training Manual:Training Manual:
Unlocks After 5Battery ExpertiseSector Space Travel SpeedThreat Control
Unlocks After 7Training Manual:Training Manual:Training Manual:
Unlocks After 10Maximum Hull CapacityMaximum Shield CapacityProjectile Critical Chance
Unlocks After 12   
Unlocks After 15  Energy Critical Chance
Unlocks After 17  Training Manual:
Unlocks After 20  Defense
--------------------------------------------------------
Unlocks After 24 (Ultimate)  Focused Frenzy
Unlocks After 25 (Ultimate)  Frenzied Assault
Unlocks After 26 (Ultimate)  Team Frenzy
Unlocks After 27 (Ultimate)   

Skill Tree Information

"My balanced tactical ultimate for leveling. First of all, in most cases the tactical ultimate skill tree is the best option from a performance point of view. This is because taking most of the nodes in the tac part of the skill tree is a significant boost to damage, which is basically what space combat in STO is all about, and the added clicky damage ability 'Focused Frenzy' doesn't hurt either. Then, by taking 10 points each in eng and sci I'm still able to get a decent amount of added skills to enhance my non-damage catagories like hull, shields, resistances, power, mobility, as well as the hull/shield cap unlocks at 10 points spent. The 3 nodes in Coordination Protocols are also great for group content as a whole team of players using these will give nice buffs for everyone. For a leveling build I also take a point each in the readiness skills, because boff ability cooldown reduction (cdr) is super-important for high-performance, and with these points taken and used along with the science boff ability Photonic Officer (PO), abilities are often at or close to their minimal cooldowns (more on this in a bit).

When building a skill tree for directed energy weapon (DEW) builds, two things outside of the tac tree must be taken. In eng always take Improved EPS Flow as this basically helps weapon power recharge faster after a firing cycle. Next in sci, always take Advanced Long Range Targeting Scanners as this is a significant boost to damage dealt by energy weapons at range. In testing by other players over the years, it's been found that Damage Control is mostly useless, Subsystem Tuning's power increases are generally too small to matter much, and Shield Mastery is mostly a noob trap as enemy NPCs don't crit that much to make spending points in it worthwhile. Also, due to heavy diminishing returns on the Armor skill, most will not take Energized or Ablative Hull Plating. "

Build Description

"The following build is certainly FED focused and uses phasers as these are generally easy to get as a new FED player. For new KDF or Romulan players I'd recommend going with disruptors and plasma respectively as the game gives you a lot of options to use these damage types early on in the game with those factions.

Weapons in STO require focus. This means two things. One, focus on one energy type like phaser, disruptor, or plasma, don't build rainbow boats using different flavored weapons. It can work but is ultimately going to gimp you in the end. Weapon procs are mostly useless due to their low proc rate, focus on an energy type you like the look or sound of. Two, focus on the actual weapon type. All beam arrays, or all dual cannons, or all torpedos. You can mix a little but you'll need to focus on just one. Gear, especially weapons and tac consoles, should always match your level. At level 40 that means mark 9-10. At low levels gear mark is far more important than gear quality (eg. uncommon, rare, very rare, etc). At level 50+, ideally you want your gear to be as high mark and quality as possible. Mark 11 and 12 gear should start dropping at this point and should be more than capable in normal difficulty content. Crafting at low levels isn't really a great idea but if you want to try, you can. Recommend building up the Beam R&D school first using the Research Projects found at bottom of the project list (can run up to 3 a day).

Subsystem power should be set to something along the lines of: Weapons 100 / Shields 50 / Engines 25 / Auxiliary 25. The best way to do this is push the weapons subsystem power button found at the top of subsystem power UI box. When an energy weapon fires at 100 weapon power, it does 100% of its potential damage. At 125 it'll do 112.5% and at 50 it'll do only 75%. With Emergency Power to Weapons up, decently high EPS, and some power drain mitigation, one can keep weapon power above 100 with all 8 weapons firing, allowing them to do as much damage as possible.

Use your cruiser commands, namely Weapon System Efficiency. This will help your energy weapons do more damage.

Most boff ability training manuals can be purchased at boff trainer NPCs found in all the major hubs. Rank 3 abilities such as Emergency Power to Weapon 3 (ETPW) and Reverse Shield Polarity 3 (RSP) I have listed in this build are usually best purchased from the exchange, training manuals can be made from a boff candidate that already has it, or from an in-game friend who has the ability to craft it for you. Ability cooldown reduction is handled by the lieutenant rank sci bridge officer ability Photonic Officer 1 (read about it below), as well as a point each in the readiness skills to help it along, which I already mentioned. When using boff abilities it's important to figure out which ones work well together or can be used one after the other, this is called chaining. In particular for this build, Attack Pattern Beta 1 (APB) and the chosen firing mode Beam Overload (BO) or Beam Fire at Will (BFAW) should always be used at the same time. Abilities like Emergency Power to the Weapons (ETPW) and Emergency Power to the Engines (EPTE) share a cooldown and should be cycled together hitting the first one, then the other when it's off cooldown, and repeating to keep these up full time while in combat.

Personal space traits are basically the best free ones available and Reputation and Starship traits are blank as new players won't have access to these at this point.

One thing you'll see here and there in the Baby Step posts and others is the reference to Cat1/A or Cat2/B damage. Put simply, Cat1/A boosts your base damage with modifers like '25% Directed Energy Damage' and '15% Phaser Damage', whereas Cat2/B boosts your damage after those Cat1/A boosts and is generally signified in tooltips using the word 'Bonus' in the description such as '10% Bonus All Damage' and '5% Bonus Disruptor Damage'. You might hear players say things like, 'You gotta stack that Cat2!', and they're right. But the truth is you need both. In general, Cat1 boosts will come from gear and Cat2 boosts will come from traits. As the following build is pretty basic, this isn't something to concern yourself with too much. For the next two builds after this, you'll start to see Cat1/2 and 'Bonus' in more of the descriptions. As this is a pretty technical part of game mechanics (and somewhat outside my purview), you can read more about it here: https://www.reddit.com/r/stobuilds/wiki/math/damage_categories

As mentioned, this build can be adapted to lower level cruisers, scaling T6 cruisers, and somewhat to pre-level 40 escorts and science ships. However, I do not recommend adapting this build to science ships at level 40 and above as these kinds of ships require different methodology to make work well. And while escorts can use beams well enough, they shine using DCs/DHCs and turrets. Both escorts and science ships also have fairly different boff layouts compared to cruisers and would need careful adaptation to make work well. "

Basic InformationData
Ship NameUSS I Blows Stuff Up and Doesn't Die!
Ship ClassT5 Assault Cruiser
Basic InformationComponentNotes
Fore Weapons: 4Phaser Beam Array MK XComes from mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. You can buy odd mark commons from the equipment vendor for cheap, just sell your loot to the vendor. The best mod on weapons when leveling will be Crth (Critical Chance) as your low level build will have very little of it in the first place. You dont need to worry about this too much, just that when you're leveling and you get a weapon that matches your build with a Crth mod, you'll want to keep it. As you advance and begin to get more Crth from other sources, you'll want the mods on your weapons to be either all Crtd, all Dmg, or a mix of both.
 Phaser Beam Array MK X 
 Phaser Beam Array MK X 
 Photon Torpedo Launcher MK XComes from mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. You can buy odd mark commons from the equipment vendor for cheap, just sell your loot to the vendor. This is mostly here to help with weapon power drain. It can help with a little spike damage here and there. Remember that at low levels Crth (Critical Chance) will be the mod you want here. As you advance your build, Crtd (Critical Damage) is typically the best mod for torpedos.
   
------------------------------------------
Aft Weapons: 4Phaser Beam Array MK X 
 Phaser Beam Array MK X 
 Phaser Beam Array MK X 
 Phaser Beam Array MK X 
   
------------------------------------------
DeflectorPositron Deflector MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. Best for a leveling build focusing on energy weapons because they tend to give bonuses to hull and shields for survivability purposes. Other deflectors tend to give bonuses to CtrlX and DrainX which most won't need.
Impulse EnginesCombat Impulse Engines MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. You're probably going to be running your engine power fairly low which is good for these engines as they work more efficiently at lower power.
Warp CoreDeuterium-Stabilized Warp Core MK XFrom mission drops, crafting, and the exchange. Probably best to try and buy one from the exchange (remember, quality isn't as important at this point, common/uncommon will be fine). Take for the very nice -15% reduction in weapon power drain.
ShieldsResilient Shield MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. Halves shield bleedthrough damage compared to all other sheilds. Don't worry about cap or regen. This is the kind of shield you want :)
DevicesWeapons BatteryFrom equipment vendors and mission drops. Even though you may be sitting at 125 weapon power using Emergency Power to Weapons 3, there is an overcap. It's not as great as it once was but you want that overcap. With high EPS it'll refill your weapon power fast and help keep power above 100 while firing.
 Battery of your choice either Shield, Engine, or AuxiliaryFrom equipment vendors and mission drops. Chain one of these with the weapons bats. Hitting a weapons bat will put this on a 30 second cooldown. Once that cooldown is finished hit this bat and repeat. I often choose engines to keep me fast or Aux to help juice aux-scaling abilities.
 Nimbus Pirate Distress CallFrom the mission Installation 18 in the Wasteland arc. Signals for a strike team of three Nimbus Pirate vessels to assist you in combat for 45 sec. This, along with all other reinforcement beacons, can be used from inventory and doesn't need to be slotted in devices.
   
------------------------------------------
Engineering Consoles: 4Neutronium Alloy Armor MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. Gives all damage resistance. All you need is one. Stacking armor in STO is not a thing.
 RCS Accelerator MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. Cruisers turn slow. This makes turning better.
 RCS Accelerator MK X 
 EPS Flow Regulator MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. Helps weapon power recharge faster when firing, thus increases damage.
   
------------------------------------------
Science Consoles: 2Emitter Array MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. Makes shield heals better. Field Generators (to increase shield cap) are good here too but difficult to find (you could try to craft some, but probably not worth using resources on). Might as well just use the simple easy-to-get consoles here for now as these will be first to be replaced as you get better stuff.
 Emitter Array MK X 
   
   
   
------------------------------------------
Tactical Consoles: 3Phaser Relay MK XFrom mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. Always stack consoles here that increase the damage of your chosen energy flavor. Phasers = Phaser Relays / Disruptor = Disruptor Induction Coils / Plasma = Plasma Infusers / etc. These can be difficult to get early on in the game as mission rewards or drops. You can check the exchange for cheap commons or try crafting your own.
 Phaser Relay MK X 
 Phaser Relay MK X 

Officers and Crew

Bridge Officer InformationPowerNotes
Officer 1: Commander ( Engineering )Emergency Power to Engines 1Plus 40 flight speed, +2 turn rate, +20 engine power. Keeps you fast.
   Auxiliary Power to the Structural Integrity Field 1Auxiliary scaling heal and added damage resistance rating. Short cooldown and one of the better boff heals in the game.
 Emergency Power to Weapons 3Plus 40 weapon power and 16.6% all energy damage. At any rank a must for energy weapon builds. Can be purchased off the exchange, a training manual can be made for it out of a boff candidate that already has it, or it can be crafted by engineering captains.
 Reverse Shield Polarity 3Converts incoming energy damage to shields, lasts 20 seconds. Basically makes you invulernable while it's up, though things like kinetic, exotic, and physical damage will still hurt you. Works great against Vaadwaur Polaron Barrages. Can be used with a special and expensive Fabrication Engineer doff from the exchange to increase uptime. Must be purchased off the exchange or a training manual can be made for it out of a boff candidate that already has it.
Officer 2: Lt. Commander ( Engineering )Engineering Team 1Small hull heal, repairs offline subsystems and can clear some other debuffs like movement ones from the Voth and Mokai.
   Auxiliary Power to Inertial Dampeners 1Auxiliary scaling kinetic damage resistance, +50%flight speed, +100% turn rate for 15 seconds. Shares a cooldown with A2Sif above. Just a filler ability, it'll eventually be replaced.
 Directed Energy Modulation 27.5% energy weapon shield penetration and 7.5 to Armor penetration for 30 seconds. Just a filler ability, it'll eventually be replaced.
   
Officer 3: Lieutenant ( Tactical )Tactical Team 1Distributes shield strength to shields receiving damage (why its used), +18 to both Weapon and Projectile training for 10 seconds. Clear hostile boarding parties and tactical debuffs. Vets will forgo this ability for something that gives more damage but Tac Team is a must for new players. It really helps with survivability. Never have to use higher than rank 1. The butter...
   Attack Pattern Beta 1-20 all damage resistance to target. The bread...
   
   
Officer 4: Ensign ( Tactical )Beam Overload 1 or Beam Fire at Will 1Beam Overload 1 will increase damage 3x and decreases firing rate by half. Beam Fire at Will 1 hits all available targets within a beam array's arc but each beam only does 80% of its base damage and has its accuarcy skill decreased by 50. Both are viable, just your choice between being single or multi target focused. BFAW is great for clearing multiple targets at once and drawing threat as a tank. Because it draws a lot of threat, it can get you killed if you don't know how to manage a lot of incoming damage FYI. For most if not all builds, it's important to take the highest rank of these abilities. In this case, because we want to use APB1 in the LT spot, the beams' main firing mode is relegated to rank 1 for now. The meat...
     
   
   
Officer 5: Lieutenant ( Science )Hazard Emitters 1Aux scaling heal-over-time, adds all damage resistance, clears plasma fires and other hazard debuffs.
   Photonic Officer 1Super-Important Part of the Build Reduces recharge times of bridge officers by 2% each second for 20 sec. Used in conjuction with a point each in the readiness skills will keep your boff abilities cycling quicker allowing for their use more often.
Duty Officer InformationPowerNotes
No Duty Officers Needed  

Character, Reputation, and Starship Traits

Personal Space TraitsDescriptionNotes
Accurate+10% Accuracy 
Beam Training+5% Beam Weapon Damage 
Elusive+10% Defense 
Fleet Coordinator+2% All Damage per Team member (Self included), up to 10% 
Innocuous+1.5% Critical Severity -25% Threat Generation 
Operative+1% Critical Chance, +2% Critical Severity 
Projectile Training+5% Projectile Weapon Damage 
Techie+20 Hull Restoration (Improves Hull Healing) +20 Hull Regeneration (Improves Passive Hull Regeneration) 
Warp Theorist+10 Warp Core Potential (Improves Power Levels) +10 Electro-Plasma System Flow (Improves Power Transfer Rate) 
Space Reputation TraitsDescriptionObtained from
None as you won't have reps open yet.  
Starship TraitsDescriptionNotes
None as a new player won't have access to any yet.  

Concluding Remarks

" Aaannnddd... that's it! I hope this can make your leveling experience a little easier and perhaps more enjoyable. If you found this post helpful bookmark it, and don't be shy in linking it to your friends or others in need. Stay tuned tomorrow for part 2 of the Baby Step Series entitled: The Next Step - Fresh 65 T5 Assault Cruiser Free DPS, where I'll show you how to evolve this build using freely gotten gear/etc that will allow you to jump into advanced difficulty content and begin to build your max-performance ship!

Stay safe and have fun out there kiddos ;)

Did I leave anything out? Feel free to leave constructive comments on basic leveling builds below. Thanks for reading!"


r/stobuilds • • Aug 13 '20

Guide oGsMustachio's Guide to DEW Consoles in 2020

181 Upvotes

Hi all. Console choice is a major part of STO builds and some of the most common questions on here. The goal of this guide is to point people in the right direction on console choice for Directed Energy Weapon (DEW) builds for general PvE gameplay. While there will be some overlap, this guide does not apply to Science Builds, Torp Builds, or PvP builds. PvE DEW builds are probably the most common and most requested build types, so I'm focusing on that. This guide is based on my opinion and people are free to disagree, but I think you'll find that my recommendations here are pretty common for the major posters on here.

I'm first going to review consoles that should go on any build. There are a few consoles in STO that are so good that they can go on anything... or at least serve as a viable alternative for any weapon type. After that, I'll focus on console choices for specific energy types. There will be a ton of consoles I don't list, and its probably because I wouldn't consider them ever.

Consoles for Any Energy Type

S-Tier - If you have these or have access to these, you equip no matter what.

  • Dynamic Power Redistribution Module (DPRM). Generally thought of as the best console in the game. Solid passives for any ship, but the real purpose is the clicky which gives a very solid offensive boost and defensive buffs that make you nearly invulnerable. The only downside is that it is difficult for Feds to get, as they have to buy the Prototype Dreadnaught. Romulans and Klinks can buy this directly from the exchange (or get it from the infinity pack).

  • D.O.M.I.N.O. Worse passives than the DPRM, but the clicky is possibly the best offensive clicky in the game. +25% haste, +25% CatB damage, and +100% torp recharge speed is hard to beat. The clicky is so good that you equip this even if you're not phaser-based. One of the only consoles you'd consider that for. Annoying thing about these is that you have to get the Bajoran Interceptor, which was an event ship and is now in the Epic Phoenix pack.

  • Vulnerability Locators. Purchased at the Fleet Spire. With the exception of the Lorca's console, you're generally going to want to fill your tac consoles with these. Make sure to get the ones specifically for your energy type. Massive amounts of CatA combined with the substantial 2% CritH buff makes these irreplacable. These consoles are the reason that ships that can equip 5 (or 6!) tac consoles are almost always going to out-DPS ships with 3 or 4 tac console slots. Too good not to use. If you don't have access to them, you'll use your energy-specific damage tac consoles like Phaser Relays or Disruptor Induction Coils in their place. Its basically the same thing without the CritH. Vulnerability Exploiters are fine too, but you'll do better ultimately with the Locators.

  • Lorca's Custom Fire Controls. Obtained through Discovery Rep. It used to be the rule that you only equipped Locators in your tac console slots, then this console changed that. At Mk XV Epic, this gives almost as much CritH as 2 locators, a pretty substantial +7.9 WepPwr, and a colossal +157.5 Shield Pen. Shield pen isn't something you'd normally chase too much, but this gives so much you can't ignore it. Testing has shown that this performs better than having an additional locator. Also has a nice set bonus for Pha/Dis builds or if you go with the Dark Matter Torp.

A-Tier - Not quite as powerful as the S-tier consoles, but worth equipping on most builds.

  • Hull Image Refractors - Obtained through the exchange or the Infinity console pack. One of the best defensive consoles in the game. +20% CatA is a nice passive, and the clicky is a good oh shit button (basically makes you invulnerable, but you can't fire out of it), but the real purpose of this console is the defensive passive ability, which makes incoming heals (including your own) that exceed your maximum hull apply as temporary HP for 30 seconds, stacking up to 20 times. Basically makes over-healing a non-factor.

  • Altamid Swarm Processor - Obtained through the Lobi Store. I'll talk about this one again down in Plasma, but its a great console for any energy type on its own. +3.9% CritH is like having another Lorca's, plus 35 Accuracy, which will likely be converted to more CritH and CritD through Accuracy overflow. The drone it deploys is meh, but the passives are really really good. Great offensive console and IMO the best general lobi console right now for DPS.

B-Tier - Solid consoles that work for any build, but might get knocked out by energy-specific consoles.

  • Bioneural Infusion Circuits. Just a nice all-around console, giving solid amounts of HullCap, CritD, and Ctrl. Lobi console.

  • Tachyokinetic Converter. Another Lobi console. Kinda similar to Bioneural in that its an all-rounder console. Bunch of turn rate and small CritD/CritH buffs.

  • Assimilated Module. From Omega rep. This used to be a mainstay console but has been powercreeped. Yet another all-rounder giving you small amounts of CritD and CritH, some Hull Regen, some WepPwr, and some Ctrl. On its own, I'd probably prefer Bioneural or Tachyo, but on a BO build combined with the KCB, this is probably preferred.

C-Tier - Less desirable but pretty easy to get. I'd recommend these on development builds or situation dependent.

  • Zero-Point Energy Conduit. From Romulan Rep. Really similar to the AssMod and possibly worth being on the same tier. +2.4% CritH at Mk XV epic is really solid. Gives more overall power than the AssMod, but it isn't focused on weapons, making it not as good for DPS.

  • Reinforced Armaments. From Beyond the Nexus. Honestly an underrated overall console. Power transfer rate is incredibly important and this gives you a ton of it. The defensive stats from this are really solid too. Going to wind up on all phaser builds and many BO builds.

  • Priors World Elite Defense Satellite. Event/Mudd store. A pretty unique console. The clicky is fine, but it shines in its passives that give a modest CatA buff and -25 weapon power cost, which is really substantial. Primarily this is a power management console.

  • House Martok Defensive Configuration. From Brushfire. Normally winds up on disruptor beam builds, but can work for anything. Strong defensive console giving a bunch of HP and shields. Some turn rate too.

  • Trellium-D Plating. From Ragnarok. Another really strong mission reward defensive console. Damage resist, HullCap, and ShieldCap are all really good things to have.

D-Tier - If you can't think of anything else...

  • Pax/Bellum/Conductive RCS Accelerators. If you're flying something with a low turn rate, especially if you want DBBs/DHCs, a good RCS is a really nice quality of life console. Bellum for more CritH, Pax for HullCap, Conductive for a whole range of modifiers and a passive resist/turn buff.

Phasers

Phasers is in a really nice place because it has great weapons (Terran Task Force, Prolonged Engagement, Trilithium-Laced, Advanced, and Sensor-Linked) and great console flexibility. Consoles are easy (free) to get. Good for all weapon variants and all firing modes.

S-Tier - Must equip

  • Reinforced Armaments. As discussed above, a pretty good console on its own. When mixed with the Trilithium-Laced Omni/Turret, its also giving you a very very strong 5% haste buff, which is one of the best passive set bonuses in the game. This has a place on all phaser builds.

A-Tier - Solid options

  • Point Defense Bombardment Warhead/Secondary Shield Projector. PDBW comes from the NX-01 Refit (lobi/exchange) and the SSP comes from an Infinity pack/Thrai Prototype Dread. Neither of these consoles are great on their own, but when combined with the DPRM, give you a really nice +33% CatA to Pha/Dis/Pla, which, when combined with consoles own clickies/passives, makes them plenty worth it. Get the PDBW for DPS and the SSP for defense. Don't bother with either without the DPRM.

  • Quantum Phase Converter. From Sunrise. More CatA is never a bad thing and AuxPwr is nice for A2B. Solid set as well. Not a huge fan, but worth considering on all phaser builds. Very nice for development builds as its easy to get.

  • Ordinance Accelerator. From Gamma Rep. If you have to choose between this ant Trilithium Laced (beam builds), go with Trilithium, but its a solid set as well. This 2-piece set is probably worth slotting on DHC builds along with Trilithium-laced.

B-Tier - If you've got nothing better/situation specific/development builds

  • Hydrodynamics Compensator. From 8472 Rep. This is kind of an interesting console. Turn rate and Accuracy are both nice things to have, especially on slow-turners. Solid piece with the Heavy Bio Turret on a cannon build for the 7.5% CatB buff.

  • Approaching Agony. From the exchange/infinity lockbox. Solid passives and an ok clicky. Not going to wind up on many final builds, but not bad as a stand-in.

C-Tier - If you must...

  • Weaponized Helical Torsion, Magnetohydrodynamic Fusion Expulsion, Heavy Phaser Lance, Amplifying Ravager Beam. All consoles from ships. None are bad but I wouldn't go chasing them.

Disruptors

Disruptors are very strong as well for either single-target or AOE builds. The TTF Disruptor is the best overall weapon in the game and Spirals are the best non-set weapons in the game. In terms of console sets, Disruptors are very beam oriented.

S-Tier - Must equip (for beam/dbb)

  • House Martok Defensive Configuration. From Brushfire. On its own its a really nice defensive console that gives impressive hit point buffs, eng/she power buffs, shield cap, and turn. Combined with the Martok Omni, you get 2.5% CritH and some more accuracy. Might not wind up on a hyper-DPS focused build, but for normal gameplay no reason not to go for this set.

  • Nausicaan Syphon Capacitor. From Echoes of Light. You'd really only pursue this on a beam build, but its a really solid console set. The console gives solid CatA disruptor damage, solid power transfer rate, and a bunch of drain expertise. The 2-piece bonus isn't great but the 3-piece bonus with the beam and the energy torp is very solid. No reason not to go for this set on a beam boat.

A-Tier - Things to pair with the DPRM

B-Tier - Filler consoles

  • Spiral Wave Disruptor Lance/Heavy Disruptor Spiral Cannons. Both are pretty similar. Ok CatA Disruptor buffs and a special weapon clicky that isn't that great. If you happen to have either of these consoles, they aren't bad if you don't have access to some of the stronger universals, but not worth chasing.

  • Hydrodynamics Compensator. See above under phasers.

  • Zero Point Energy Conduit. Romulan rep. Discussed above but worth mentioning again here. You're going to want the Romulan Experimental Disruptor BA for any beam build, so this is worth considering too. Set bonus is miniscule.

C-tier - Early Development only

  • Harmonic Resonant Relay. Its not a great console and will be replaced immediately once you get a better normal tac console, but you might just pick this up as you're leveling and its fine in the meantime. Combine with the Preserver Resonant beam array for a small weapon power buff.

Plasma

Plasma might just be the best single-target (BO/CRF) energy type in the game right now because it combines the excellent Lukari 2-piece (technical overload is soooo good), the DPRM 2-piece, and the Altamid 3-piece. The downside to Plasma is that its expensive. No good mission rewards at all and you're really going to want the lobi 3-piece. Good for all weapon types.

S-Tier - Must haves

  • Altamid Modified Swarm Processor. As discussed above, this is an amazing console for crit. As a part of the 3-piece set, you get an absurdly powerful 100% haste for 12 seconds. Thats basically doubling your final damage. Its a short burst, but absolutely worth it.

  • Piezo Electric Focuser. From Lukari Rep. Great universal DPS console. Really nice CatA buff for a universal, some turn rate, some shieldcap, plus a bit more CatA from the set. Just a great console for piling on CatA damage, especially because you're going to want that Advanced Piezo Plasma so much as well.

A-Tier - PDBW/SSP again

B-Tier - Solid alternatives

  • Weapon Sensor Enhancer. Lobi Console. Sort of a weird choice for me here. I like this for DBB builds because it pairs with the very good Advanced Isolytic Plasma DBB. Accuracy = CritD/CritH and Ablative Hull Plating is nice as well.

  • Plasma Wave. Exchange/Infinity console. Solid passives, meh clicky. Better than the starship plasma universals and easier to get.

  • Zero Point Energy Conduit. Romulan rep. Discussed above but worth mentioning again here. You're going to want the Romulan Experimental Plasma BA for any beam build, so this is worth considering too. Set bonus is miniscule. Easy to get.

C-Tier - Hydrodynamics...

Antiproton

Used to be the best, got powercreeped, recently resurgent with the Ba'ul Lobi Set/Weapons. Very strong for AOE (BFAW/CSV) builds because of Ba'ul refraction. Lacks a strong standalone weapon like TTF or Advanced Piezos. Expensive because of the lobi set.

S-Tier Must equip if you can

  • Ba'ul Linked Sentry Coordination Matrix. Lobi console. Not as good standalone as the Altamid, but pretty good still. Solid CatA buff, modest hullcap buff, and a nice control immune passive. Where it really shines is its excellent set bonuses which adds a buffed Ba'ul Refraction effect to your AP weapons with the 2-piece and a large 50% CatB damage for 30 seconds buff and control cleanse clicky wit hthe 3-piece. Great console.

A-Tier Misc Standalones + Radiant

Polaron

Budget Plasma. Like plasma, its better for BO/CRF because of technical overload. Unlike plasma, no crazy lobi set and no DPRM 2-piece. Instead it gets the intriguing morphogenic set.

S-Tier Must equip.

  • Piezo Electric Focuser. From Lukari Rep. Same deal as it is under plasma, just a boatload of CatA that pairs up with a weapon you're going to want anyways. Great console.

  • Morphogenic Matrix Controller. From Home. Really unique console. While its unfortunately a tac console and has less CatA than a locator, you more than make up for it with the reduced weapon power cost, but most importantly the 3-piece set bonuses which result in a whopping 6% CritH and 30% CritD on a preferential targeting build (high end single-target + an off-brand low-leve AOE firing mode).

A-Tier Might as well.

  • Ordinance Accelerator. As discussed under phasers, not a bad set. Unlike phasers, you'll never have to choose between this and Trilithium-laced. Not amazing (ton of power wasted on mines...), but not terrible by any means.

Tetryon

Sigh... Tetryon. Currently the redheaded stepchild of STO and it almost always has been. This energy type has seen the least love and is really kinda meant to compliment drain builds or something. No really special weapons. Also expensive to pursue because you're going to want a lobi set for it. I can't recommend Tetryon to anyone unless you want to troll people with Sticky Web. Good chance this is the next energy type to get some love from cryptic...

S-Tier An expensive lobi set...

  • Biased Configuration Module. Lobi console. Its a solid console thats part of a more solid set. Not as special as the Ba'ul or Altamid lobi sets, but still pretty good. Also has an energy torp in the set.

  • Sticky Web. Probably doesn't deserve to be up here, but I love this console. Solid 25% CatA buff, but most importantly its clicky makes a giant wall in space that friends and foes can run into. Its like a crappy grav well but it doesn't take any auxpwr or a boff.

A-Tier Not terrible.

  • Temporal Disentanglement Suite. From Butterfly. Really better fit for a scitorp build, but could be slotted on a DEW build too along with the set omni/turret. Modest CatA set bonus. AuxPwr, SheCap, SheRes, CritH, CritD. Unfortunately the crit is based on Auxpwr, which will get crushed if you're running A2B.

  • Emitter Refocuser. From Renegade's Regret. Solid CatA, a ton of shield regen, and some drain. Not great, but its easy to get. Really meant for a tetryon/drain build.

  • Hydrodynamics Compensator. See above under phasers. Higher spot for Tetryon because there aren't many other options.

  • Sustained Radiant Field. Iconian Rep. Same deal as AP. A little CatA, but really this console and its set bonuses are all about defense. Better options out there for DPS, but pretty solid defensive 2-piece set.

Closing Thoughts

I'm sure I've forgotten something and I've definitely purposely ignored a bunch of consoles. These are the ones I usually think about when suggesting builds. Thanks for reading.

Edits: added Martok and Trellium-D under the global consoles, Sustained Radiant Field under Tetryon.


r/stobuilds • • Jun 20 '21

Guide STO Build Theory & Mechanics: How Starships Work in STO

139 Upvotes

Throughout the years, the STO community and often members of /r/stobuilds, have delved into just about every nook and cranny of this game's cryptic mechanics. Luminaries like /u/TheFallenPhoenix, /u/Mastajdog, /u/Odenknight, /u/DeadQthulhu, /u/Jayiie, /u/Talon42, /u/tilorfire27 and of course your humble author have all contributed to a greater understanding of starship mechanics in Star Trek Online. That knowledge is scattered throughout various posts as well as the STObuilds wiki.

Partnering with DeadQthulhu, Jayiie, and of course Mr. Tilor, we've been working on an aggregate resource. Much of it has been collected through years of posts and derivations from all of the individuals listed above. Some of the content is philosophical, reflecting ideas on how to focus builds and how to pilot effectively. Some of our work is raw formulas and mathematical concepts. All of it is combined to present yet another resource. Having exhausted that most ubiquitous and helpful of engineering formats, spreadsheets, we now move to one only slightly-less common: a slideshow! We'd like to present:

STO Build Theory & Mechanics: "How Starships Work in STO"

Let me be clear on what the goal of HSWIS is:

  • This is not a template guide or a how-to for basic beginning shipbuilders (though we link to several of those), including /u/neuro1g's Baby Steps guide and Prelude to Ten Forward

  • This is not a copy-and-paste set of build instructions for "optimal DPS." The DPS League website exists to serve that purpose.

  • This doesn't cover the basics. There's potentially some more work we're going to do in that space, but if you are new to level 65 gameplay, this ain't the one for you.

  • This is a mechanics guide with a dash of build theory and piloting instructions

  • If you want to learn how something works in Star Trek Online (at least on the space side of things), we hope this will be a resource to fill that purpose in a single concentrated location.

  • We hope this is both useful as a comprehensive guide to mechanics as well as a reference for specific items and concepts that will be a bit easier than trawling through the subreddit and its wiki

  • We didn't cover everything in terms of every gear or item, but we tried to cover all the relevant concepts and formulas that an experienced shipbuilder would generally want to research. If you're building in more niche areas, this probably won't help you as much (Sorry in advance, Pottsey!).

Table of Contents

Please let us know your thoughts and feedback! Likewise, if you see any errors or glaring omissions, you can assume they're my fault. Let me know and I'll see about addressing them. We've been working on this for a few months now and we're excited to be launching our 145-slide labor of love, our collection of mechanics, build theory, and crude graphics as a living resource for those who want to know "How Starships Work in STO." Again, thanks are owed to /u/Jayiie, /u/tilorfire27, and /u/DeadQthulhu for all of their contributions!

Parting Shot: As alluded to in my other post on flight speed, this is my last new major project on STObuilds. It's been a fun and wild ride over the past 5 years, but I've explored all that I care to, learned a ton about the game and Sheets, built tools for more applications than I ever thought possible, and made several good friends in the process. I will soon be moving into a stage of life with much less free time. I hope to still be around and updating existing tools, but my days of spending 100+ hours to make a new tool are finished.


r/stobuilds • • Sep 04 '21

Non-build DPS performance test of all the hangar pets I have access to, with and without Superior Area Denial (SAD).

138 Upvotes

I have very recently acquired the Superior Area Denial ship trait for myself, so I can finally answer some burning questions I have had for a very long while now.

This will be presented in a format similar to this past post on the topic, because it is pretty much the inspiration for this test (and I like tables).

Methodology:

  • Scenario: The opening space combat in the story mission "Knowledge is Power" on Elite difficulty. This was chosen for having no cooldowns, fast setup, high HP pool (roughly 1/3rd of the total enemy HP pool in an ISA) and a target rich environment with a mix of spongy battleships and light escorts.

  • Enemy targets: 3 Negh'var Warships, 7 Bird of Preys, 1 Raptor

  • Difficulty: Elite

  • Ship builds used: For most of the tests, this Aspero threat-tank carrier build with some minor modifications. For hangar pets restricted to specific ships, an approximation of that tank build is used.

Control points and variables:

  • 2-3 rounds of testing for each hangar pet with and without SAD. Though a good number of the lower performing hangar pets I only tested once because I value my sanity.

  • DPS results will be displayed as a sum of the entire hangar bay's DPS contribution, averaged from the repeat tests where applicable.

  • Parsing starts on map opening and ends when all enemy ships are wiped out. Combat time usually ends up being between 70-90 seconds.

  • Total Enemy HP pool tends to be between 14-16 mil HP (for reference, ISA has about 39-42 mil from my solo runs). Variation likely due to NPC allies that contribute in the fight.

  • Hangar pet bays fully deployed before combat starts.

  • Heavy combat participation from my ship with Threatening Stance enabled, to draw enemy fire away from hangar pets and keep them alive.

  • Gravity Wells (>250 CtrlX) employed on all tests and as soon as they are off cooldown.

  • For tests using SAD, it replaces Super Charged Weapons on my tank builds.

  • For tests using SAD, Attack Pattern Beta 1 would then be unslotted so as to not double stack on -30 DRR debuffs which might affect pet DPS results.

Tabulation of DPS results (sorted by DPS w/ SAD, descending order):

RarityHangar Pet NameNon-torp?Pulse Cannon?Restrictions?Avg DPS sum w/ SADAvg DPS sum w/o SADDifference Factor
NormalTo'Duj Fighter Squadron Y 42,4337,6425.55
EliteAlliance Fighter SquadronYY 33,6287,1534.70
AdvancedAlliance Fighter SquadronYY 29,3657,2454.05
EliteStalker Fighter SquadronYYCaitian Ships27,2466,2114.39
EliteLost Souls of Gre'thorY Fek'ihri Ships26,54024,9851.06
NormalAlliance Fighter SquadronYY 26,3546,5534.02
EliteScorpion Fighter Squadron (incl. Plasma Torps)   22,8166,8533.33
NormalStalker Fighter SquadronYYCaitian Ships22,6594,3805.17
NormalJem'Hadar Fighter SquadronYY 21,7044,1705.20
NormalS'kul FightersYY 19,3064,9163.93
AdvancedJem'Hadar Fighter SquadronYY 19,0465,1433.70
NormalLost Souls of Gre'thorY Fek'ihri Ships18,70722,5890.83
EliteScorpion Fighters (incl. Plasma Torps)   17,64912,7131.39
NormalJem'Hadar FighterYY 16,6855,3083.14
EliteTerran Empire Frigate  Styx16,39513,6901.20
EliteAeon Timeships   16,07011,2031.43
EliteMirror Universe ShuttleY  15,71411,7381.34
EliteKelvin Timeline Assault Drone  Vengeance15,29412,4031.23
NormalClass F ShuttlesY  13,6535,2382.61
NormalPeregrine Fighters Y 12,7755,6712.25
NormalTo'Duj Fighters Y 12,2977,2681.69
NormalTerran Empire Frigate  Styx12,1907,9241.54
ElitePeregrine Fighters   11,7088,9711.31
NormalStalker FightersYYCaitian Ships11,0594,2602.60
NormalKelvin Timeline Assault Drone  Vengeance10,4849,0321.16
NormalJem'Hadar Support Frigate  Full Carriers10,4279,7101.07
NormalMirror Universe ShuttleY  9,8636,2791.57
NormalAeon Timeships   9,1306,4621.41
EliteTholian Widow Fighters   8,9877,1841.25
NormalRozhenko Timeships   8,4475,0191.68
NormalNing'tao Support Frigate  Full Carriers7,8085,2021.50
AdvancedDelta Flyers   7,7396,5801.18
NormalB'Rel Bird of Prey  Vo'Quv7,4066,0351.23
NormalYukawa Frigates   7,2536,0721.19
NormalOrion SlaversY  6,6963,4761.93
NormalDelta Flyers   6,5315,1081.28
NormalFer'Jai Frigates  Fek'ihri Ships6,0153,1231.93
NormalCaitian Support Frigate  Full Carriers5,4884,2231.30
NormalType 8 ShuttlesY  4,3343,1431.38
NormalDanube Runabouts   3,5373,2681.08

Table formatting brought to you by ExcelToReddit

Best Universal Pets under SAD (Difference factor >2):

  1. Normal To'Duj Fighter Squadron 42,433 DPS

  2. Elite Alliance Fighter Squadron 33,628 DPS

  3. Advanced Alliance Fighter Squadron 29,365 DPS

  4. Normal Alliance Fighter Squadron 26,354 DPS

  5. Elite Scorpion Fighter Squadron (incl. Plasma Torps) 22,816 DPS

  6. Normal Jem'Hadar Fighter Squadron 21,704 DPS

  7. Normal S'kul Fighters 19,306 DPS

  8. Advanced Jem'Hadar Fighter Squadron 19,046 DPS

Best Universal Pets without SAD:

  1. Elite Scorpion Fighters (incl. Plasma Torps) 12,713 DPS

  2. Elite Mirror Universe Shuttle 11,738 DPS

  3. Elite Aeon Timeships 11,203 DPS

  4. Elite Peregrine Fighters 8,971 DPS

  5. Normal To'Duj Fighter Squadron 7,642 DPS

  6. Normal To'Duj Fighters 7,268 DPS

  7. Advanced Alliance Fighter Squadron 7,245 DPS

  8. Elite Tholian Widow Fighters 7,184 DPS

Best Universal Non-Torp Pets under SAD (Difference factor >2):

  1. Elite Alliance Fighter Squadron 33,628 DPS

  2. Advanced Alliance Fighter Squadron 29,365 DPS

  3. Normal Alliance Fighter Squadron 26,354 DPS

  4. Normal Jem'Hadar Fighter Squadron 21,704 DPS

  5. Normal S'kul Fighters 19,306 DPS

  6. Advanced Jem'Hadar Fighter Squadron 19,046 DPS

  7. Normal Jem'Hadar Fighter 16,685 DPS

  8. Normal Class F Shuttles 13,653 DPS

Best Universal Non-Torp Pets without SAD:

  1. Elite Mirror Universe Shuttle 11,738 DPS

  2. Advanced Alliance Fighter Squadron 7,245 DPS

  3. Elite Alliance Fighter Squadron 7,153 DPS

  4. Normal Alliance Fighter Squadron 6,553 DPS

  5. Normal Mirror Universe Shuttle 6,279 DPS

  6. Normal Jem'Hadar Fighter 5,308 DPS

  7. Normal Class F Shuttles 5,238 DPS

  8. Advanced Jem'Hadar Fighter Squadron 5,143 DPS

Best Special/Restricted Pets under SAD (Difference factor >2):

  1. Elite Stalker Fighter Squadron 25,945 DPS

  2. Normal Stalker Fighter Squadron 23,904 DPS

  3. Normal Stalker Fighters 11,059 DPS

Best Special/Restricted Pets without SAD:

  1. Elite Lost Souls of Gre'thor 24,985 DPS

  2. Normal Lost Souls of Gre'thor 22,589 DPS

  3. Elite Terran Empire Frigate 13,690 DPS

  4. Elite Kelvin Timeline Assault Drone 12,403 DPS

  5. Normal Jem'Hadar Support Frigate 9,710 DPS

  6. Normal Kelvin Timeline Assault Drone 9,032 DPS

  7. Normal Terran Empire Frigate 7,924 DPS

  8. Elite Stalker Fighter Squadron 6,211 DPS

Best Frigate-class Pets:

  1. Elite Terran Empire Frigate 13,690 DPS

  2. Normal Jem'Hadar Support Frigate 9,710 DPS

  3. Normal Terran Empire Frigate 7,924 DPS

  4. Normal Yukawa Frigates 6,072 DPS

  5. Normal Ning'tao Support Frigate 5,202 DPS

  6. Normal Caitian Support Frigate 4,223 DPS

  7. Normal Fer'Jai Frigates 3,123 DPS

Misc. observations and remarks:

  • Most will know this by now, but "Non-torp" pets are a category here for those who do not wish to have their hangar pets steal Concentrate Firepower procs from themselves or teammates, which is a key BOff ability for torpedo builds.

  • Normal To'Duj Squadrons being tops while on SAD isn't surprising, but the performance gap between it and other squadrons was unexpected for me. Wonder just how much bigger these numbers were before the nerfing/fixing of SAD.

  • The results for the older hangar pets line up quite nicely with u/AboriakTheFickle's past extensive test, but there may be selection bias involved here as I based a lot of my hangar pet purchase decisions off said test.

  • These results also line up decently with u/Pottsey-X5's suggested pets in this guide. Sadly I do not own the Drone Ships to test with.

  • There can be quite a bit variation in DPS numbers between tests, but especially so for Scorpion Fighters because of their High Yield Plasma Torps, so just bear that in mind.

  • Normal Yukawa Frigates are apparently not the absolute worst.

  • My ship can end up soaking >3mil HP in damage within that 70-90 seconds of combat, inadvertently making this scenario a decent solo test for my threat-tank builds.

Changelog:

  • 19-Feb-22: New data for Alliance Fighter Squadron, Danube Runabouts, Advanced Jem'Hadar Fighter Squadron, Normal Jem'Hadar Fighter Squadron, Elite Scorpion Fighter Squadron (incl. Plasma Torps), Elite Scorpion Fighters (incl. Plasma Torps), Elite Stalker Fighter Squadron, Normal Stalker Fighter Squadron, Normal To'Duj Fighter Squadron.

  • 19-Feb-22: Pets re-ranked based on new data.


r/stobuilds • • Sep 17 '21

Contains Math The Boimler Effect: In-Depth Analysis

124 Upvotes

Howdy everyone! Thought I’d write up a post on the new trait The Boimler Effect now that Cryptic has buffed it to usable proportions. Here’s what the trait does:

  • 2.5 17.5% chance on use of any bridge officer powers: Recover the Recharge time of all other Bridge Officer Abilities up to their Shared Category Cooldowns.

Contrary to any advertisement to the contrary, this does work on specialization powers (tested in-game) and the power that activates the effect does benefit from the cooldown reduction. I’ve watched Concentrate Firepower reset itself several times now when that was only power activated.

CAUTION! There be math ahead, ye be warned! </pirate voice>

We’re going to be using two concepts that are fundamental to understanding STO mechanics at a high level and I can claim credit for very little in either field. /u/tilorfire27 put together a post and a tool to handle binomial distribution. Without going too-deep into the math, binomial distribution will tell you how often, given a set of odds (probability) and a number of rolls, how often you get a certain number of desired rolls. Excel and Sheets have a binomial distribution function and that’s what Tilor’s tool uses. He’s kind of a genius that way. The second fundamental concept is cooldown reduction, of which we owe the original research to /u/TheFallenPhoenix and /u/Jayiie. The current tool that we use for cooldown reduction would also not exist without Tilor because again he’s kind of a genius with spreadsheets and math and numerical calculus is hard. Cooldown reduction, broadly speaking, is reducing your bridge officer powers from their base cooldown to their minimum (aka “global” or “duplicate” cooldown) and is something every good build should account for. Two common methods of handling cooldown reduction are A2B (Auxiliary to Battery with Technicians) and Photonic Officer. If you want a breakdown on how the math works, check out this post by TheFallenPhoenix (Atem). I’m going to keep it fairly-surface-level for today.

Okay, back to Boimler. Boimler's effect is very strong: it resets ALL bridge officer powers to their minimum cooldown. Doesn’t matter where you were in your cycle, it gets reset to minimum cooldown. However, on release, the chance to proc was 2.5%. This is where Binomial Distribution comes in. Let’s look at a fairly-developed 15 second tactical chain on a 1-torp build (i.e. mostly energy):

  • Firing mode of choice (Beam Overload OR Cannon Power)

  • Attack Pattern Beta

  • Tactical Team

  • Kemocite

  • Engineering Team OR Aux to Structural

  • Alternate torpedo power

  • Emergency Power ability

That’s seven powers we can expect to rotate every 15 or so seconds. In that time, with 2.5% chance to proc, the Boimler Effect had an 18% chance to trigger and thus was sadder than Boimler on his escort mission in S1E2. It was, frankly, a waste of 200 Lobi/160 on 20% sale.

Okay, so Cryptic heard our collective feedback and responded to it promptly. (Make a note in the log!) Now it’s 17.5% chance to roll. Let’s redo the math for the same chain.The Boimler Effect now has a 78.5% chance to trigger in that chain and the numbers go up if we use more boff abilities. Huzzah, it’s useful!

Now that we’ve established that it’s viable, let’s talk applications and limitations. Before we begin, there is a known interaction that’s fairly abusive/possibly broken. We’re going to analyze the trait WITHOUT that interaction and address it at the end.

The Boimler Effect has 3 key limitations:

  • You’re still relying on a chance for it to trigger. 78.5% is a high chance, but it will break down sometimes and when it does, you don’t want to be screwed on cooldown reduction.

  • Not only is the chance not guaranteed, but you have no control over when it occurs in the chain. It could trigger on the last power (good). It could trigger on the first power (bad). Relying on the Boimler Effect to manage ALL cooldowns is a gamble, depending on your luck. I saw it triggering about once every 13 seconds on a rather spammy build, but where that fell in the cycle was still RNG dependent.

  • It’s still an expensive method of reducing cooldowns at 200 Lobi/160 on sale. It was 90M last night on the Exchange and that price has already gone up appreciably.

Let’s compare five different setups.

Boimler versus A2B

There are 2 DPS-related reasons to run A2B. The first is for running the trait Cold-Hearted and thus the second, that lets you run Controlled Countermeasures. Since A2B requires at least 2 engineering seats at Lt or above, this tends to be a popular setup on cruisers and other similar ships with lots of Engineering seating. With 3 purple technicians and 2 instances of A2B, the math becomes very, very easy. Let’s look at a tactical power with 30 seconds base cooldown and 15 seconds global cooldown (which is most of the good ones). A2B with 3 technicians reduces the power’s cooldown by 30% every 10 seconds:

Final cooldown = Base (30) * (1 - 0.3*2) = 30 * (1 - 0.6) = 12 seconds.

That 12 seconds ends up being 15 because you can’t reduce below global. So we can see that A2B is a fantastically effective way of reducing cooldowns, albeit at the opportunity cost of 3 doff / 2 boff slots. Given that those boff slots were Lt+ Engineering, which isn’t a fantastically valuable seat for other things, that’s not a huge deal, but it does mean we can’t take advantage of aux-scaling things like exotic powers, the Temporal Disentanglement Suite, Auxiliary to Structural, or the new Phased Space Membrane.

A2B is mostly commonly used on cruisers and battlecruisers because they have a lot of engineering seating to spare. It can be used on tanks to drive Cold-Hearted, which is a team-wide buff, but will also be at the cost of the tank’s aux (i.e. healing, hangar recharge if applicable, and any exotics). Tanks also don’t really need A2B because they are using Fire at Will (with a higher global cooldown) and have Attrition Warfare to help fill in gaps. I see A2B used more often on DPS ships using cannons or Beam Overload. To use a personal example, here’s the Over Achiever, which is a Quark Marauder build that could easily be copied to the Fleet Shepard/Gagarin.

Taking a look at that Marauder, if I replaced Cold-Hearted/Controlled Countermeasures with something like Promise of Ferocity and CrtH/CrtD energy weapon officer doffs, I end up coming out ahead on DPS by roughly 2% at greater cost. I get similar results with a FAW build running a comparable budget (using the energy calculator). Given that Cold-Hearted is a teamwide buff I think it ends being a wash DPS-wise, especially if the seats were hard-locked to Engineering. If I didn’t have Cold-Hearted to begin with or if those seats that were held for A2B were going to free up a universal seat or were going to be powerful specialization abilities like Narrow Sensor Bands, Recursive Shearing, or Override Subsystem Safeties instead, it’s better to use Photonic Officer and something else (like Boimler) instead. We’ll get to that below.

If you’re considering A2B versus Boimler, there’s no real DPS loss if you’re running Cold-hearted/Controlled Countermeasures unless you have a very high-end trait like Terran Goodbye to replace Cold-Hearted with. Remember that A2B, while limited to certain types of builds and ships, is very good at what it does (at a high opportunity cost), and it’s reliable. Boimler is somewhat unreliable and expensive. If you’re unwilling to farm the B’Tran Cluster colonization chain for Purple Technicians, on PC, a purple Technician sells for somewhere north of 20M a piece. Even if it was 30M per technician, that’s still cheaper than buying the Boimler Effect either directly via keys -> Lobi or via EC.

Boimler and Photonic Officer (Exotic)

What about for exotic builds? All of the previous analysis has been for energy weapon builds. Well, if you’re running Exotic builds and you want cheap cooldown reduction, you’re probably using Photonic Officer I and possibly Torpedo Astrometric Synergy.

Photonic Officer, when active, takes away 2%/3%/4% of the bridge officer’s base cooldown every second. So, if we fire off a Gravity Well (base 60/duplicate 40) and then trigger Photonic Officer I, over the next 20 seconds we reduce the cooldown by 2% * 20 = 40%.

Final = Base (60) * (1 - 20*0.02) = 36 seconds

Okay, that’s all well and good, but Gravity Well has a 3/2 ratio for its base-to-global cooldown. What about those pesky 2/1 powers like Torpedo Spread or Tactical Team?

Final = Base (30) * (1 - 15*0.02) = 21 seconds

Not as good, so we throw in a little tactical recharge haste (let’s say 26.4% from the rep trait and Improved Tactical Readiness) and…

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.264) * ( 1 - 15*0.02) = 16.6 seconds

Which isn’t quite global, but if you’re running an exotic build, that’s probably good enough. Most of the exotic powers have much less demanding global-to-duplicate ratios.

Photonic Officer does have a drawback though: it has a downtime. Photonic Officer has an uptime of 20 seconds and a cooldown of 30 seconds that cannot be reduced. No, the Photonic Studies duty officers do NOT affect it. On longer cooldown powers (like most exotic abilities), this is not an issue since their duplicate cooldowns are higher. On short cooldown tactical powers or things like Auxiliary to Structural, this is harder to circumvent.

However, if you’re running an exotic build and looking to spend big-time on maximizing its effectiveness, I would skip Boimler and go straight to … Improved Photonic Officer which extends the uptime of Photonic Officer by 10 seconds to eliminate the downtime AND gives you +25% Bonus Exotic Damage for basically 100% uptime. This is a top-5 trait for SciTorp builds and while it requires a Lobi ship, if you’re looking to spend big EC on something like Boimler Effect, it’s better just to go straight for this. If you’re running a bunch of tactical powers on your sci builds to power Entwined Tactical Matrices, you should run the Morphogenic Set to help reduce those cooldowns even further and get a bunch of crit:

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.414) * ( 1 - 15*0.02) = 14.85 seconds

Boom, uptime! See the LSS Pioneer for a non-Morphogenic example that uses IPO. It’s more expensive than Boimler, but it’s reliable and you’re getting 25% cat2 exotic damage out of it. On the lower-budget end, stick with Morphogenic and Torpedo Astrometric Synergy.

Boimler versus Photonic Officer (Tanks)

What if I want to use Photonic Officer on a weapon build? Improved Photonic Officer is essentially wasted if I’m running no exotics. If I have a bad spell where Photonic Officer I is down for 10 of 15 seconds, even with the rep trait Chrono-Capacitor Array and Improved Tactical Readiness, I get this on a 15-second tac power:

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.264) * ( 1 - 5*0.02) =  21.4 seconds

If I’m on a tank, I can use things like Attrition Warfare and Calm Before the Storm, plus tanks have a 20 second global chain on FAW rather than 15. So tanks, even if running Photonic Officer, probably don’t need any cooldown help. You could squeeze in a Krenim if you really wanted:

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.364) * ( 1 - 5*0.02) =  19.8 seconds and that’s in the worst case

Add in Attrition Warfare and Calm Before the Storm, possibly Tactical Initiative if running a Tactical captain and you’re completely fine on a tank without Boimler. Just use Photonic Officer I and don’t worry that Torpedo Spread isn’t at global because you’re rotating it every 20 seconds anyway.. That’s how the Stormbreaker handles cooldowns.

Boimler versus Photonic Officer (Energy DPS Builds)

Now let’s say I want to use a non-FAW weapon build on a ship WITHOUT using A2B. Improved Photonic Officer is a mostly-wasted slot and I’m on a 15 second rotation. That’s a lot of words to say “I want to run cannons, torps, or Beam Overload with PO.”

Even running Photonic Officer II will run into a few cooldown gaps if you’re in the worst case scenario for 10/15 seconds on your chain. The rep trait and Tac Readiness only help so much.

Best case with PO II:

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.264) * ( 1 - 15*0.03) = 13 seconds    

Worst case with PO II:

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.264) * ( 1 - 7*0.03) = 18.75 seconds  

I used 7 instead of 5 here because you’re going to go over and by then your PO will start ticking again. It’ll be somewhere between 17 and 18 seconds instead of 15. Adding a Krenim costs you a potential Senior Romulan Operative and will not fix the problem.

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.364) * ( 1 - 7*0.03) = 17.37 seconds  

For energy builds, Calm Before the Storm is a common answer. Even if Calm Before the Storm’s Storm buff is only up for 10 seconds of the worst case scenario, you end up with this:

Final = Base (30) /(1 + 0.484) * ( 1 - 6*0.03) = 16.6 seconds  

Not quite perfect, but close enough, especially since this is truly the worst case scenario and won’t happen all the time. If you want to fill that gap even more, this is where Boimler Effect could be used, and would let you drop down to Photonic Officer I. That said, I suspect there are more impactful traits for that slot if you have Calm Before The Storm (which I would prioritize over Boimler for the 33% energy weapon haste with 50% uptime anyway).

Boimler versus Photonic Officer (Torpedo Builds)

What about if I’m not running an energy build? The current torpedo meta, per this post by /u/Startrekker, involves wants high aux to power the Phased Space Membrane so no A2B. Since the current torpedo meta is using mines in the aft slots, there’s a good chance that there’s no Morphogenic set to help either. Even worse, THE key power for torpedoes is Concentrate Firepower III, which has a 9/4 base/global cooldown ratio (i.e. worse than 2/1). That means using Photonic Officer and 1-2 copies of a very expensive duty officer, 38 of 47, for cooldowns (chance of lowering Tac cooldowns on using Command abilities and vice versa).

Now THIS is where Boimler Effect shines. Torpedo builds, due to using Entwined Tactical Matrices, tend to be really spammy on their powers and Calm Before the Storm is a wasted slot on them. Here’s a typical 15-20 second rotation:

  • Torpedo High Yield

  • Attack Pattern Beta

  • Tactical Team

  • Engineering Team/Aux to Structural (feeds logistical support)

  • Kemocite

  • Cannon: Scatter Volley (for free torpedo spread)

  • Fire at Will (for free torpedo spread)

  • Photonic Officer

That’s 6-8 powers before adding other powers like Emergency Power to Engines/Aux or any other non-specialization powers you’ve got in your chain, which brings us back to that 78.5% or more chance of Boimler Effect triggering somewhere in there. You’re still relying on Photonic Officer with some readiness to do the heavy lifting, but to fill in the gaps when it has downtime and to help reduce Concentrate Firepower, Boimler makes the most sense. Concentrate Firepower is hard to bring to global since it’s not affected by Tac Readiness and has a high ratio, but Boimler Effect circumvents that by reducing it straight to global.

The folks selling 38 of 47 know this as well. That’s why the price of that doff has plummeted from 300M+ to 150M as of this morning. This is where the Boimler Effect has the most value, especially since he’s still cheaper than 38 of 47 as of this writing, not to mention easier to get.

Also, if you were previously mixing PO1 and 1 instance of A2B, I think Boimler Effect completely supercedes that setup if you can afford it. It has much less opportunity cost and will generally trigger sometime during your chain if unreliably so.

Boimler Alone

I took my torpedo boat out to the Doomsday Device shooting gallery and spent a little over a minute of combat activating powers then analyzed the results. In 1:20 of shooting, I had 6 triggers of Boimler Effect over 41 boff power activations. If we go back to our analysis with a tactical chain of 7, that fits the math pretty well. The longest I went without a trigger was nearly 45 seconds and 17 boff power activations, though, which illustrates relying solely on Boimler Effect for cooldown management is a bad idea. I deliberately did not use Photonic Officer just to see how good he was on his own and the answer is not very.

Channeling Boimler

There’s a rumor out there that the Boimler Effect’s chance is being rolled on every tick of channels like Tractor Beam, Distributed Targeting, and Tractor Beam Repulsors. It’s true, I’ve tested it, and if left unchanged, then Boimler’s the best way to fix CDR since pre-nerf Attrition Warfare during the Threat Tank meta. Slot TB, TBR, or Distributed Targeting and Boimler Effect and collect your global cooldowns because it's a guaranteed proc, assuming you can afford it. I also suspect that’s the sort of thing to get fixed/nerfed so I’ve done the analysis, assuming that Cryptic is going to change that behavior.

Conclusions

Boimler Effect is good now but shouldn’t be the only basis for a cooldown scheme due to its unreliability (barring any channel cheese). It’s a gap-filler that works best on kinetic torpedo builds, builds that were running PO1 and 1 instance of A2B, and to a lesser extent energy builds using Photonic Officer.

Energy builds using full A2B with Cold-Hearted/Controlled Countermeasures don’t need Boimler Effect and won’t see any DPS gains dropping A2B unless they can free up universal / specialist seating from engineering and/or have a high-end traits like Terran Goodbye alongside doffs and boff powers to replace the A2B setup with. If they do, then that's stronger. Energy builds running A2B see basically no benefits just from adding the trait and tanks don't see much either since their firing chain is longer and they have Attrition Warfare to fill gaps.

Energy builds using Photonic Officer and Calm Before The Storm would see some benefits from Boimler but only a few seconds of cooldown saved per minute. PO energy builds can probably reduce to PO1 if running Boimler as he greatly diminishes the need to use PO2 on weapon builds as long as you don’t mind a little RNG. If CBtS is not available, then his effects are relatively higher. However, Calm Before the Storm is a good enough trait for energy just based on its weapon haste alone that I don’t see Boimler Effect displacing that trait. I'd rather have CBtS and PO1 than Boimler and PO1. Having all three is small gains aside from avoiding PO2.

Improved Photonic Officer likewise is strong enough for exotics that Boimler Effect has no real place on a higher-budget build. Lastly, for torp boats, Boimler Effect seems an obvious winner, probably alongside Photonic Officer unless Cryptic leaves the channeling thing unchanged.

TL;DR

  • Boimler Effect is very good alongside PO1 on kinetic builds and energy builds (especially if the latter aren’t using Calm Before The Storm). It is better than A2B without Cold-Hearted/Controlled Countermeasures combo. He reduces the need to use Photonic Officer 2 greatly.

  • Boimler + PO 1 can be better than A2B+CH/CC but only if you have pricy-but-powerful things to replace the doffs/boffs/traits devoted to A2B.

  • Boimler Effect is not needed (nor is Photonic Officer 2) for tanks due to a longer cycle time on the main rotation.

  • Boimler Effect is also not needed for Exotic builds which would rather have Improved Photonic Officer.

The trait is currently broken with channeled powers like Tractor Beam so if Cryptic doesn’t change that, it’s all you need for cooldowns anymore on any weapon build. However, this analysis generally ignores that broken interaction; it’s still good in the situations above without it. If you buy this trait solely because of that interaction, that’s on you. I expect they will nerf or change that.


r/stobuilds • • Jun 04 '18

Quick Recap of the Current Space DPS Meta

124 Upvotes

Howdy all, with ViL less than a day out, I figured this little guide could come in handy for a few of you out there.


What is the best Faction for DPS?

Going into ViL, Romulan Tacticals are still statistically the best. However, Federation Tacticals have had a nice comeback, with the Vengeance being a beast with high end cannon setups.

But most importantly, if the Jem'Hadar Vanguard trait is comparable to the ground version (+5% Dmg for Weapons / 3% CrtH / 5% CrtD), then the Vanguard will be the new DPS Faction. This is a big if though, as Cryptic has not given us the numbers of the space trait. They're making us wait for ViL to go live so we can find out ourselves.

What is the best Class for DPS?

As for classes, this game is still heavily biased towards Tactical. Science has gotten better over the years (and is very good in Exotic boats), but Engineers have largely been left behind. Myself and a few others often consider Engineers the "noob-trap" class now. Engineers are great for new players who have no idea what they're doing, but they're extremely bad when you get to endgame and want to start doing any high level competitive content.


Is FAW still the meta?

  • FAW = Fire at Will

No. FAW was nerfed a bit with the S13 patch in the first half of 2017. On top of the nerfs, it was then given the worst duration extension trait we've seen via the Tactical MW Cruiser. This trait can give FAW up to 15/20s uptime, but it requires you to be shot once every second.

What is the energy weapon meta?

  • CSV = Cannon Scatter Volley

  • CRF = Cannon Rapid Fire

Cannons. Both CSV and CRF have gained buffs over the last 2 years that have made them extremely potent. They were nearly competitive with FAW before the FAW nerf, so the post-S13 meta gave them the opportunity they needed to fully take over.

What makes CSV so good is:

  • "Withering Barrage" Starship trait off the T6 Defiant / T'varo / Kor

  • Extends duration of CSV by 4s, giving you 14/15s uptime.

  • Was recently buffed to have a 90' Firing arc.

What makes CRF so good is:

  • "Go for the Kill" Starship trait off the T6 Jem'hadar Strike and Recon Ships

  • Once per 5s, a crit will extend duration by 3s.

  • Basically means 100% uptime on CRF.

  • "Preferential Targeting" Starship Trait from the T6 NX

  • When you use FAW or CSV, CRF & BO will get a +100% Cat 1 Dmg Buff for 30s

  • Using FAW alongside CRF will allow this to have 100% uptime.

  • "Directed Energy Flux" Starship Trait from the T6 Husnock Warship

  • When you hit Directed Energy Mod. or any Temp Ops Boff ability, CRF / BO get a 25% Cat 2 Dmg buff for 15s

  • Only worth using on ships with a Temp Ops Boff seat.

CRF is only worth using if you have at least Go For the Kill. If you don't have GftK, then you should stick with CSV.

Big issue with CRF though is that with single target focus, so you will have some issues in lower difficulty content, such as ISA. You'll often kill stuff like transformers while the gens are all still up. Also makes it hard for you to help with sphere cleanup, due to often lacking AoE DPS or most likely DPS at all from your team.

With that in mind, just know that CRF is crazy fun, and most of the hate out there for it is due to it ruining ISA DPS runs because it's simply too powerful for advanced content. Is perfectly balanced vs other options in Elite.


Is the Iconian set still the meta? Or is there something better?

The Iconian set still works, but there are better options.

Currently, the most popular option is the Fleet Colony Deflector (the one that gives a buff CrtH/ ShPen, should be 4th on the vendor list), which gives a scaling CrtH/D buff with your current HP. Up to 4% CrtH and 15% CrtD when you're at 100% HP. Can also be Re-Engineered to have mods that work better for your build.

Engine wise, the Competitive Rep engines are very good due to having a built in mini-evasive that triggers when you hit certain abilities. There's versions here that trigger off of drain/ control, weapon enhancements (like FAW/CSV/etc), and heals. I'd recommend going for the heals version, as that will give you more control of when it's active.

Core wise, do whatever you want really. Fleet Spire one works well still, Terran rep one can do ok if you're constantly in combat for a few minutes (takes 1m to build up), and the Competitive one is popular for the 3pc with the Engine/ Shield, which gives you some bonus Resistance.

Shield wise, Iconian still works, but the Competitive with the 3pc ECS is popular. Either the CrtH or MaxHP variants of the shield will work.


Antiproton is still the best damage type, right? No!!!!

Disruptors started to take over way back in early 2016. Nowadays, Phasers and Disruptors are the best choices due to various sets and consoles that buff them up.

Weapon procs were "fixed" with S13, meaning they barely proc anymore. So what matters for a dmg type now is how many things out there will stack up to buff it.

This change to weapon procs has made Sensor-Linked Phsers/ Disruptors quite popular. These weapons replace their proc with a +5 stat buff to your CrtD and Defense Skills. (2% CrtD and .75 Defense per SL weapon).

The Terran Rep Set Disruptor DHC/ Beam is still best in slot on most builds. It's unique ability is a scaling damage buff that scales as your target's HP lowers. Almost every energy weapon build should be running this. In tests I've done, it's so powerful that it can even be worth slotting on builds where no tac consoles are buffing it. (Tested it with a full phaser setup on the NX, was only 500 DPS behind the Prolonged Phaser.......)


Is CrtD still the best mod?

It depends now.

Dmg was buffed up a few years ago, and became a final damage multiplier.

It's generally recommended that Tacticals go for Dmg, and Eng/Sci go for CrtD.

What makes Dmg so good for tacs is that it goes after every last damage buff they have. It even buffs off other [Dmg] mods. A normal [Dmg] mod is a 3% final dmg buff, and the Epic level [xx/Dm] mod is 6% final. A weapon with [Dmg]x4 [CritD/Dm] would be ideal for a Tac, and would give 20 CrtD and a 19.3% Final Damage Buff (1.03x1.03x1.03x1.03x1.06). That's 19.3% multiplied after every other buff on your build.....

[Pen] still works ok, it's just that with all the sources of Debuff out there (especially if you have the Cold Hearted starship trait off the 2017-18 Winter event ship), it's not as much of a must as it once was.

Now, some Tacs still run CrtD. The difference is basically that CrtD will sometimes get lucky with RNG and give a slightly higher number. I prefer Dmg as it may have a slightly lower peak, but it will allow for me to have a consistently higher result.


How do I reduce cooldowns?

Aux2Bat has returned to the meta post-S13.

This very old method simply requires 3 Technician Doffs that reduce CDs with Auxiliary to Battery, and 2 copies of Aux2Bat.

If you spec into enough readiness and have a console/ boff for Eng Readiness, it's possible to run a single copy of Aux2Bat.

If you have the 17-18 Winter event ship, you will want to run Aux2Bat to take advantage of it. The massive debuff applied by that trait, and the CDR Aux2Bat allows for has made this the meta CDR option.


Are Leech/ Supremacy still good?

S13 brought in some changes to how power levels affected Weapons. This combined with [Amp] having been changed to not stack on itself a ton, instead being +3.3% Cat 1 All Dmg per stack, has made power levels less important.

However, leech/ supremacy are not as bad as some have made them out to be. Both are still valuable if you're not running a high end build. But I wouldn't go out and spend the 300m+ that Supremacy currently cost.

If you're on an Aux2Bat build, going without either is fine. But if you're not going with A2B, then having at least the leech on is not a bad idea.


There's likely a few others things, so ask away!


r/stobuilds • • Feb 11 '21

Contains Math Revisiting Exotics 10: The Flames of Gre’thor

116 Upvotes

While we can understand the Romulans, Klingons, and Dominion having no such qualms about using such a device at all, this latest item really makes us scratch our heads about how Starfleet justifies the usage of certain new technologies.

However, this is the same Federation in 2411 that allows subspace weapons, retrofitted assimilation devices, Section 31 technology, and various temporal BS on any-and-all ships flying the flag. If there is a Department of Ethical Technology Use, it’s manned by a single (bored) junior lieutenant Pakled who’s either a Section 31 operative or has forged an identity as a full commander. Lieutenant Pakley’s response to any-and-all reviews of new tech seems to be “Approved, suitable for use.” Even if the device uses technology from the Klingon underworld.

That’s right: this edition of Revisiting Exotics is going to cover the Fek’ihri Torment Engine. For previous iterations in this series, please check out the previous entries:

Reminder that Exotic means non-weapon offensive damage, and in this context, we're talking about ones that (generally) scale off of the Exotic Particle Generator stat. Now, back to the flames of Gre’thor.

The last couple of years have been extremely lackluster in terms of meaningful mission rewards for space builds. Arguably the last useful mission reward was the Regenerative Crystal Shield, which is still pretty niche, and that was released in 2019. Now, Cryptic has started 2021 with quite the console. The Fek’ihri Torment Engine is extremely intriguing and (unluckily for us) extremely confusing. That said, Mr. Tilor and I have been steadily working through all of the various oddities of this console. Please be kind to him in the comments for he labors tirelessly on all of our behalfs. Here’s what we found:

Fek’ihri Torment Engine

There are 3 pieces to this console:

A Cat1 boost to non-Hazard Damage Over Time A Cat1 boost to Fire, Radiation, Plasma, and Physical Damage A 10% chance to trigger shield-penetrating fire damage when dealing non-Hazard DoT damage

Now what the Gre’thor does that mean? (heh)

Part 1: Non-Hazard DOT

A Hazard is when you spawn a thing on the map that has a duration and does damage to enemies near it. The thing might follow enemies around (with Anomaly Leash), but in general, the Hazard is not fixed onto an enemy. Examples of Hazards include Tyken’s Rift, Gravity Well, Subspace Vortex, Very Cold in Space, Isolytic Tears and Chronometric Inversion Field.

A Damage Over Time is when you apply a lingering effect that deals damage to a target over multiple instances / ticks. Examples of DOTs include the Deteriorating Secondary Deflector, Aceton Beam, Channeled Deconstruction, Plasma fires from plasma torpedoes and energy weapons, and the Kentari Missile’s Radiation damage. Note that Destabilizing Resonance Beam and Delphic Tear do NOT count as Damage over Time.

This thing boosts DoTs that are NOT Hazards. Here’s our list of Non-Hazard DoTs that are in the Revisiting Exotics series/Exotic Calculator plus a few others:

  • Deteriorating Secondary Deflector

  • Tholian Web Cannon (DoT)

  • Aceton Beam

  • Kentari Missile Radiation Damage Over Time

  • Endothermic Inhibitor Beam

  • Entropic Cascade

  • Rapid Decay

  • Plasma fires procced from plasma energy weapons

  • Plasma fires procced from plasma torpedoes (including the Particle Emission Plasma Torpedo’s plasma DOT)

  • Dark Matter Torpedo DOT

  • Drain Infection

  • Fek’Ihri Torment Engine Fire procs

Part 1 of the Fek’ihri Toaster will boost all of these by 28 - 39.4% Cat1 depending on mark/rarity of the console.

Editor’s note: Objects in italics will NOT be added to Exotic Calculator

Part 2: Fire, Radiation, Plasma, and Physical Damage

This is a little more straightforward. Outside of Kinetic and Electrical, these are the other main exotic types. Here’s our non-comprehensive list of what benefits from that:

Science/Engineering powers:

  • Destabilizing Resonance Beam (physical)

  • Aceton Beam (radiation)

  • Eject Warp Plasma (plasma)

  • Endothermic Inhibitor Beam (radiation)

Temporal boff powers:

  • Chronometric Inversion Field (physical)

  • Entropic Redistribution (physical)

  • Entropic Rider (physical)

  • Entropic Cascade (physical)

  • Channeled Deconstruction (physical)

  • Rapid Decay (physical)

  • Timeline Collapse (physical)

Misc stuff

  • Particle Emission Plasma (plasma) - cloud and DOT

  • Dark Matter Torpedo DOT (physical)

  • Withering Radiation (radiation)

  • Anti-Time Entanglement Singularity aka the Rainbow bubble (physical)

  • Destabilize Warp Core (radiation)

  • Deteriorating Secondary Deflector (radiation)

  • Temporal Vortex Probe active (radiation)

  • Neutronic Eddy Generator (radiation)

  • Delphic Tear Generator (radiation)

  • Voice of the Prophets (physical)

  • Plasma Storm Module (plasma)

  • Fire proc on the Fek’ihri Torment Engine itself

  • Mycelial Rift radiation blast (radiation)

  • Isolytic Tear (physical)

  • Plasma Energy Weapons (plasma )

  • Plasma Weapon damage-over-time burn effect (plasma energy AND torpedo)

  • Blade Mines

  • Tholian Web Cannon DoT + Blast (physical)

  • Entropic Rider (physical)

Part 2 of the Fek’ihri Toaster will boost all of these by 28 - 39.4% Cat1 depending on mark/rarity of the console.

Science things that gain NO benefit from this console at all:

  • Gravity Well

  • Tyken’s Rift

  • Very Cold in Space

  • Subspace Vortex

  • Delayed Overload Cascade

  • Gravimetric Torpedo

  • Spore-Infused Anomalies

  • Mycelial Spore Burst console

  • Mycelial Rift Hazard

  • Multi-Target Tractor Arrays

  • Electrified Anomalies

  • Photonic Shockwave

  • Tyken’s Rift

Note that if something is in BOTH LISTS (ex: the Deteriorating Secondary Deflector), it gains BOTH benefits. Yes, that means nearly 80% Cat1 boost to the Deteriorating Secondary Deflector. Yes, that is an exceptionally powerful boost.

Part 3: Great Balls o’ Fire!

The third part is a 10% chance to proc extra fire damage when a non-Hazard DOT is applied (i.e. stuff in list #1).

Base damage: 60 per second, for 5 seconds. Scales with MK and rarity.

Cat1 Preload: 0.23 (though of course it scales with the console doubly as a Fire DOT). Scales with MK and rarity.

It does not scale with Aux, with +Exotic, or with +Bonus Exotic (though EPG does count). Only +All, +Fire, and of course +DoT count.

Conclusions

Now, you might think that 60 damage with questionable scaling is nothing amazing and that Cat1 damage (even 80% of it) isn’t worth giving up a console slot for but that is because you have not read and understood Revisiting Exotics 1 where we make it very clear that the Deteriorating Secondary Deflector slaps harder than a pissed off Captain Kira.

Let’s back up a little bit and do some math. (Ye were warned)

First, the proc. 60 base damage is at a hypothetical Mark 0. Cat1 gains from Mark increase drastically from MK XII to MK XV. Crank the Fek’Ihri Toaster up to Mark XV and start piling on EPG and you’ll see you can pretty easily pick up 1100 damage per second.

Mark XV Cat1 is 2.5638, then 400 EPG is 2.0 Cat1 and the console itself gives up to 0.788% Cat1 to itself. Temporal spec adds another 0.2. Also, the damage itself scales with level (we think it’s around 142 at MK XV), as does its Cat1 preload.

142 * (1 + 2.5638 + 2 + 0.23 + 0.2 + 0.788) = nearly 963 damage per second, and that’s before you add in +All damage in either Cat1/Cat2 flavors. On my high-end science ship, a blue MK XV Fek’Ihri Torment Engine is hitting for 1150 damage per second resting thanks to some +All damage consoles and traits.

As they say in the late-night infomercials, BUT WAIT, THERE’S MORE! Upgrade your Fek’Ihri Toaster during this limited-time-upgrade weekend opportunity to a Gold MK XV Fek’Ihri Toaster and you can deal 2000 damage per second just with its fire proc! Cheesy infomercials aside, the console gains 62 base damage going from blue to gold and a little more Cat1 scaling AND a bunch more Cat1 preload, and that adds up real quick. A MK XV Epic FTE with only 100 EPG and no traits boosting it had more fire damage than the full-build listed above and once I put the build back together, the damage was above 2000 per tick.

Now consider that it lasts 5 seconds per instance and can hit all over the map given how many things on an average science build can proc it. The 10% chance to proc the fire is rolled per tick of the DOT, which means you have a very high chance of proccing it every time you slap a DOT on someone. Note: repeated applications refresh the duration of the Fek’Ihri Torment proc.

Not only that, but we’re talking about the equivalent of adding over 150 EPG to the Deteriorating Secondary Deflector, and 80 EPG to DRB, several of the most powerful Exotic clickies, and basically all the Temporal boff abilities ON TOP of the proc. My personal recommendation is to slot this on every science build out there, but since we’re fans of nuance and giving very precise advice, here’s a slightly more in-depth breakdown:

SLOT THE TORMENT ENGINE ON YOUR SPACE MAGIC BUILDS UNLESS….

  • You don’t have a secondary deflector or you don’t have at least 2 means of proccing it if you do. Not something I would ever do, but hey sci carriers exist.

  • You don’t use any Radiation/Physical/Plasma Damage active abilities from consoles (Delphic Tear, Temporal Vortex, Neutronic Eddy Generator, Plasma Storm, Tholian Web Cannon, etc.)

  • You’re not using the Particle Emission Plasma or Dark Matter Torpedo Launchers for some unfathomable reason. This also doesn’t compute to me for an exotic build as those are the second and third best torps for sci-torping.

Now, as for non-space magic builds, I don’t think that this console will be strictly-speaking meta given that it takes up a valuable tactical console slot. However, if you’re building around Plasma Torpedoes, it’s a little more interesting because the Fek’Ihri procs trigger off plasma weapon DoTs and Plasma Torpedoes have doubled Cat1 scaling on their plasma damage-over-time component from +Plasma. A Vulnerability Locator/Exploiter should yield more damage in most cases, but if you’re really DOT heavy I could see a case for this console being mixed in. Radiation builds or even plasma energy weapon builds might have some intriguing options here as well.

As one might hope, the Exotic Calculator has been updated for this console as well as a few other miscellaneous things:

  • Fixed some cells incorrectly blanked on final results.

  • Increased range for personal endeavors

  • Added Fek'Ihri Torment Engine both as a proc and a Cat1 boost

  • Reduced some more maximum targets for certain AOE abilities

  • Added Sniper starship trait

CURRENT VERSION: 6.13

Thanks for reading! Leave us a comment below and let us know of your opinion on adding Klingon hellfire to your space magic builds!


r/stobuilds • • Apr 18 '22

Contains Math Weapon Enhancement Analysis: Beams, Cannons, and Mixed Setups

100 Upvotes

Weapon Enhancement Analysis: Beams, Cannons, and Mixed Setups

Ahoy! Over the two weeks leading up to exams (so basically 3 weeks ago), we saw the introduction of the new Surgical Strikes, as well as some other intel power changes. You can see the thread I put up a few days ago discussing these powers here. However, I wanted to do a little more math involved in SS against the other various firing modes.

As always, you can see the spreadsheet here.


See part 2-Post Pilot here.


Weapon Evaluations

Before I get into the nitty gritty, in any discussion of the various weapon enhancement and effects, its best to get a good groundwork for how things function and get a good scope of what we mean when we say Weapon enhancements.

Weapon Stats

Firstly, I'd like to introduce some basic terms and numbers for the weapons themselves. While we have several, there's only a few main types. Within each archetype, of which there are beams and Cannons, a general rule is that as the arc decreases in angle, the damage increases.

Beams consist of Beam Arrays (lower damage larger arc) and Beam Banks (higher damage, smaller arc), and then Omnis, which have the same base damage of beam arrays (mostly, set Omnis will vary) with a full 360 degree range of attacks. These however are limited to one equip of a set and not-set per ship. Additionally, with the release of the Discovery Reputation an additional beam type was added, the Wide Angle Dual Heavy Beam Bank, which has the highest damage of all weapons but also the longest cycle time.

Cannons however have several variants. Dual Heavy and Dual Cannons are very similar with both having very high damage comparatively but with very small arcs; however Dual Heavy's have fewer attacks and drain more power, but have an innate +10% Critical Damage. On most builds the difference between these is negligible. Turrets are the 360 degree version of cannons, but since their not limited in equip number they have the lowest damage of all weapons. Single cannons also exist, with midlane damage between Duals and Turret, but considering the differences between Single cannons, beams, and dual cannons most players opt out of using these all together.

In addition, cannons and beams have fire different number of shots across their cycle at different rates. As such to compare them we use an Effective DPS, which is just the base damage multiplied by the number of shots in a cycle divided by the cycle duration (for all at default this is 5 seconds), and then a table can be generated:

Weapon TypeBase DamageShotsCycle TimeEffective DPS
Dual Heavy Cannon29045232
Dual Cannon19365231.6
Wide Arc Dual Beam Bank40047.5213.33
Dual Beam Bank26045208
Single Cannon16065192
Beam Array20045160
Omni (not Set)20045160
Omni (Set)18845150.4
Turret10065120

Weapon Enhancements

For both beams and cannons, various powers exist that can change how these weapons behave when firing, herein called Weapon Enhancements. These might increase the number of shots or allow for additional targets, and add an extra damage multiplier to the weapon:

Beam ModesTargetsShotsCycle TimeCycle ModifierFinal Multiplier (Rank I,II,III)Effective Multiplier (Rank I,II,III)
Fire At Will (FAW) - 1 Target1551.250.8, 0.85, 0.91, 1.0625, 1.125
Fire At Will (FAW) - 2 Targets2551.250.8, 0.85, 0.92, 2.125, 2.25
Beam Overload (BO)112.50.53, 3.5, 41.5, 1.75, 2
Cannon ModesTargetsShotsCycle TimeCycle ModifierFinal Multiplier (Rank I,II,III)Effective Multiplier (Rank I,II,III)
Cannon Scatter Volley (CSV): Dual36511, 1.05, 1.13, 3.15, 3.3
Cannon Scatter Volley (CSV): Dual Heavy34511, 1.05, 1.13, 3.15, 3.3
Cannon Rapid Fire (CRF): Dual1951.51, 1.1, 1.21.5, 1.65, 1.8
Cannon Rapid Fire (CRF): Dual Heavy1651.51, 1.1, 1.21.5, 1.65, 1.8

(Note: CRF and CSV have the same effects regardless of dual or dual heavy, and as such from hereon will be treated the same)

Given the above, I'm kinda surprised people really like CRF, I haven't really ever been too fond of it and here we can see why, it doesn't feel as powerful as the others.

Additionally, there are extra weapon enhancements from three specializations:

Specialist Firing ModesSpecializationRank IRank IIRank III
Exceed Rated LimitsMiracle WorkerLt.C: Sets Weapon Drain to 0, 60% Haste. While active suffer: 5000 Electrical Damage and &-5 all power per secondCmdr: Sets Weapon Drain to 0, 80% Haste. While active suffer: 4000 Electrical Damage and &-4 all power per secondCmdr: Sets Weapon Drain to 0, 100% Haste. While active suffer: 3000 Electrical Damage and &-3 all power per second
Reroute Reserves to WeaponsPilotLt.C: Sets Weapon Drain to 0, -10 engine power drain from energy weapon activations, and +20% HasteCmdr: Sets Weapon Drain to 0, -8 engine power drain from energy weapon activations, and +30% HasteCmdr: Sets Weapon Drain to 0, -6 engine power drain from energy weapon activations, and +40% Haste
Surgical StrikesIntelligenceLt.C: 330% Normal Damage, +30 Accuracy, +30% Critical Chance, and +40% Critical DamageCmdr: 330% Normal Damage, +30 Accuracy, +30% Critical Chance, and +60% Critical DamageCmdr: 330% Normal Damage, +30 Accuracy, +30% Critical Chance, and +80% Critical Damage

These are a bit harder to get ranges of effective improvement, and as such is our goal in this discussion: to find the effective multiplier, and the results of these various firing modes.


Methodology

As you all know, for any "experiment" we need first to look at the methods for how the data was collected and analyzed. With the help of /u/eph289, I was able to get a list of values for a few builds from around the community. From here we used a combination of some calculation methods (energy weapon calculator for effective weapon power and known damage formulas) to find the optimal number of CrtD or Dmg mods, as well as locators or exploiters (to avoid potential bias with regards to Surgical Strikes).

From here, you compare this to the un-modified damage multipliers (also accounting for the optimal CrtD/CrtH console mod spread) to find an effective increase each would have. From here, I averaged the increase across all builds to get some values.

This isn't the only not necessarily the best case to handle this either. If you have the time, /u/startrekker has published a video today outlining the tests he's done and I recommend you go watch it to see the effects it has outside of math's, it's pretty close to what I get here.

Builds

Here are a list of the builds, and core stats in each case:

BuildExpected RangeBase typeWeaponsPower Cost ReduxTac ConsolesCat1Cat2ACCCrtHBaseCrtDBaseHasteAvg Power
Baby Steps 1Very lowBO / FAW BA740.00%3290.06%31.60%39.7510.56%105.00%0.00%97.5
Baby Steps 2LowBO / FAW BA740.00%3389.98%52.77%54.7918.40%142.00%5%100.36
Baby Steps 3MediumBO / FAW BA740.00%3745.22%82.23%137.0468.06%297.00%45.67%103.44
U.S.S. RooseveltMediumFAW BA775.00%4793.48%186.80%45.6960.41%408.00%36.50%103.91
Over AchieverMediumBO DBB7110.00%4751.21%254.45%35.5059.35%402.00%36.50%109.67
U.S.S. Benjamin DavisMediumFAW BA775.00%3646.08%201.18%34.7542.40%229.00%40.50%106.14
U.S.S. ArgusMediumCSV DC660.00%5752.94%110.35%54.6957.51%328.00%40.67%113.75
U.S.S. AlamoMediumFAW BA750%4799.17%169.14%49.7551.68%313.00%36.50%103.12
U.S.S. Yi Sun-sinHighFAW BA775.00%4831.22%174.05%99.3971.71%423.00%36.50%104.9
U.S.S. DragonscaleMediumFAW BA750.00%4794.16%111.47%28.5045.42%244.00%25.50%99.05
U.S.S. BedivereMediumFAW BA7225.00%4751.00%80.35%62.0070.98%259.00%22.08%121.1
U.S.S. Von NeumannHighCSV DC660.00%5815.72%124.22%42.0063.35%299.00%36.50%107.7
Alpha's Pug JuggVery highCSV DC875.00%7713.82%250.41%142.0467.31%303.00%52.75%105.78
MB's 1M JuggVery highCSV DC7288.33%7718.82%181.93%142.0472.73%275.00%45.00%116.37
Spencer's InquiryVery highCSV DC775.00%6732.27%239.87%100.0489.87%445.00%69.83%109.83

While these builds will have likely changed from the original posting date, I believe these to be adequate representations of each and represent a wide array of builds and budgets.


Results

And now for what everyone has been waiting for, tables of results. It should be noted that for the purpose of multi-target powers, it has been assumed that the maximum number of targets were available.

Graph By Power Rank

Through all of this, I was able to develop some graphs for all 3 ranks (as the easiest method to group):

For these I have them as a logarithmic Y axis, this is because ultimately each of these ended up being a linear slope further away from the origin, and the details near the origin were blurred out. These are not as useful as I had hoped but they are nice to have none the less. SS3's trendline is interesting as it extends far above that of all the others near the axis, which means that for new starting builds SS3 aims to be the best weapon enhancement by far until you get some decent gear and get going, in which case CSV3 takes over.

Breakdown by Rank Number

Powers - Rank 1Effective MultiplierDamage Increase
CSV1x2.914+191.415%
FAW1x1.943+94.277%
ERL1x1.567+56.733%
SS1x1.501+50.096%
CRF1x1.498+49.768%
BO1x1.39+39.007%
RRtW1x1.257+25.656%
Powers - Rank 2Effective MultiplierDamage Increase
CSV2x3.067+206.69%
FAW2x2.069+106.894%
SS2x1.88+87.99%
ERL2x1.734+73.423%
CRF2x1.647+64.745%
BO2x1.622+62.175%
RRtW2x1.421+42.074%
Powers - Rank 3Effective MultiplierDamage Increase
CSV3x3.225+222.54%
SS3x2.278+127.813%
FAW3x2.199+119.914%
ERL3x1.902+90.153%
BO3x1.853+85.343%
CRF3x1.797+79.721%
RRtW3x1.585+58.492%

Breakdown by Seat Rank

Powers - EnsEffective MultiplierDamage Increase
FAW1x1.943+94.277%
BO1x1.39+39.007%
Powers - Lt.Effective MultiplierDamage Increase
CSV1x2.914+191.415%
FAW2x2.069+106.894%
BO2x1.622+62.175%
CRF1x1.498+49.768%
Powers - Lt.CEffective MultiplierDamage Increase
CSV2x3.067+206.69%
FAW3x2.199+119.914%
BO3x1.853+85.343%
CRF2x1.647+64.745%
ERL1x1.567+56.733%
SS1x1.501+50.096%
RRtW1x1.257+25.656%
Powers - CmdrEffective MultiplierDamage Increase
CSV3x3.225+222.54%
SS3x2.278+127.813%
ERL3x1.902+90.153%
SS2x1.88+87.99%
CRF3x1.797+79.721%
ERL2x1.734+73.423%
RRtW3x1.585+58.492%
RRtW2x1.421+42.074%

Evaluation

This is mostly as expected, but there are three things to note:

  1. Since CSV and FAW are multi target, and I've assumed multitarget here, we need to divide each by the amount of targets. In this case, it means that for one target FAW now becomes 0.97 at rank 1, 1.034 at rank 2, and 1.1 at rank 3. CSV similarly becomes 0.97, 1.022, and 1.075.

  2. These values are dependent on assumed power levels. A project I'm considering is creating correction factors for this but I have no idea how I'd even approach that so it remains a number. This means that the weapon power modifying powers like ERL and RRtW could come in under or over this, as all the rest could as well.

  3. these are averages across several builds, not all are created equal. Higher end builds that approach 100% CrtH see less benefit from SS3, even after using all exploiters because SS grants +30% CrtH across the board for weapons, and most builds run very high accuracy for overflow to take hold. The farther up the budget tree you are, the less of an impact SS3 will become.

/u/startrekker's Inquiry.

This is probably the most recent "pure meta" build on this list having been launched in January of 2022. This is a prime example of too much CrtH for an SS3 build, as it rests at almost 97% after accuracy is taken into effect. While his build video does include 5 locators, the math points to wanting only 3 under CSV (due to the accuracy reduction) or 2 in every other mode.

This is most likely because of how large the endeavor bonuses to CrtH and CrtD are, as well as how many newer traits add CrtH in spades, trading in either Terran Goodbye or Universal Designs (but not both) for Calm // Storm Yields higher SS3 (and only SS3) values.

Alternatively, if the text on "(Directed Energy Flux)[]" is to be believed, this is a similar SS3 beneficiary trait that can be added in place of Terran Goodbye or Universal Designs. Basically, because of the shear stat boost Surgical Strikes gives, you do not need to go all in on crit boosting traits.

While it is possible to go through and change each and every single build on here to reflect potential meta changes, I think that might be a fools errand. As I don't have many of the things needed to even test a build such as Spencer's in various ways, I have no way to fact check these changes. However, given the breadth and depth the spreadsheet goes into I think its safe to say its fairly accurate in the context of a single build.


BO3 vs SS3

This is an inevitable point of discussion, and has already happened on the subreddit a few times recently. Firstly, caveats:

  • BO3 is a Lt.C Power and not a Cmdr Spec, therefore is more easily placed on more ships

  • BO3s extension trait is now arguably more difficult to get as its a single character lockbox ship unlock, whereas SS3s is in the C-store (however expensive, if you really want to try SS3 get it while its on sale).

In the Case of Supercharged BO3 vs Non-Vanguard SS3

We can use the uptime of each to get a good idea how how they would compare if you were currently running a BO3 build and wanted to convert to SS3:

BO3 = 1.853
SS3 = 2.278

As such on the basis of already having Superweapon Ingenuity and lacking access to Vanguard Superiority, swapping to SS3 would most likely be a net loss. However, we can factor in weapons that BO3 would not be affected by:

For example, under SS3 we can run both terran weapons (which amount to approximately 1.375x a normal weapon)

BuildBO3SS3BO3 with UptimeSS3 with Uptime
3x DBB, 1xTTFBA, 1xWADHBB, 2x Omni, 1xTorp2145.9072533.1632534.9943115.877
4x DBB, 1xWADHBB, 2x Omni, 1xTorp2127.082510.9382512.7533088.54
1xTTFDHC, 1xTTFBA, 2xDHC, 1xWADHBB, 2x Omni, 1xTorp1166.8812827.6451378.4553478.1

Slight table correction by /u/noahssnark (final conclusions are the same)

(This compares a 4xDBB + WADBB with 3xDBB + WADBB + TTFBA in cases 1 and 2, showing that if you can get the TTFBA to be 1.375x that of a normal beam as it tends to parse, use the TTFBA in a BO build.)

As you can see, if you don't have Vanguard Specialists for the extra time to SS3, a pure BO3 build with Superweapon will do lots more than the accompanying SS3 build (approximately 22% more). However, once the considering of SS3s ability to mix weapon types the difference swings to SS3 by a long shot. Taking the best in case BO3 setup (2512.76) to the best in case SS3 setup (3478.1), SS3 is 37% better than the BO3 setup.

Taking the best SS3 without uptime vs best BO3 with uptime you net 11.5% Addition (SS3 > BO3)

Ignoring both uptimes, SS3 always wins over BO3.

Both Extensions but Preferential Targeting

We can use the same mixing values as before, with a 3x DBB, 1xTTFBA, 1xWADHBB, 2x Omni, 1xTorp BO3 + Preferential Targeting against a 1xTTFDHC, 1xTTFBA, 2xDHC, 1xWADHBB, 2x Omni, 1xTorp SS3 build. Here I'm going to use the median numbers as a result, and compare the 100% Cat1 from BO to an assortment of 20% additional Cat2 from some random trait:

  • Cat1 = 748.11%

  • Cat2 = 171.6%

  • CrtH = 61.88%

  • CrtD = 301%

    | BO3 Setup | SS3 Setup | BO3 Setup +5s Uptime | SS3 Setup +5S Uptime | No Uptime BO3/SS3 | Uptime BO3/SS3 :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: No additions | 154441.9961 | 250139.7986 | 182444.7814 | 307680.5022 | 0.6174 | 0.5930 With PT to BO3, and +20% cat2 to SS3 | 172652.1335 | 261066.4219 | 203956.7057 | 321120.6222 | 0.6613 | 0.6351

Using our best setups its not even close, as BO3 is doing about 60% of that of SS3. Basically even though SS3 has little support, its still a better pick. Unless you don't have a primary intel ship you like to fly...that's a bit of a challenge then


Misc Details

Some interesting things to note here is the effects of haste and high end gear, most importantly that of the Altamid 3pc. We can once again use Spencer's Inquiry build as an example, by granting it the 100% haste from the Altamid 3pc, the ranking for ERL drops sharply making it less effective than CRF3. I suspect this is as most of the benefit of ERL is its large Haste benefit rather than a raw damage increase like CRF or CSV are.

Another thing to note is that since I solved for the optimal number of consoles and CrtD mods under SS3, once you get past about 80% CrtH (including SS3s added 30%), the benefit of locators drops sharply and you see exploiters rise.

Final note I want to make is that this seems to have solved the Dmg vs CrtD debate; basically every build wants Dmg. The baby steps series builds (extreme budget) all use as many CrtD mods as you can, as do the two Oddy Tanks by myself and /u/tilorfire27. Everything else seems to want as many Dmg Mods as you can. As always be sure to check yourself by using the damage calculator but feel safe in picking all Dmg if you want a size-all option. I'll probably poke this some more in the future using this same technique.


Conclusion

We'll this has been 20000 characters presented by the now-finished-school mind of Jay on why new SS is cracked! I'd recommend if you want to give this a try you do so. Feel free to ask questions or poke some maths you're self. As always I'm human and can make mistakes so if you see something please let me know!

--Jayiie


r/stobuilds • • Nov 02 '20

Theoretical Revisiting Exotics 8: Storms, Superweapons, and Careers

99 Upvotes

This took a bit longer than we expected, but /u/tilorfire27 and I have finally derived some more of the formulas behind key new pieces for Exotics. Reminder that Exotic means non-weapon offensive damage, and in this context, we're talking about ones that (generally) scale off of the Exotic Particle Generator stat. If you're new to the series and like math, check out our previous entries:

I'm going to cut straight to the heart of the matter. We know what you're going to ask: How good is the Revolutionary set? The answer is below. There be math ahead--ye were warned.

  • The 2-piece is very, very good and should be slotted on every sci build out there.

  • The 3-piece/4-piece clicky is a little more interesting and its formula is extremely weird.

  • The radiation cylinder that it fires is tremendously finicky to aim and takes six seconds to charge. It also has the most unusual formula I've ever seen:

    9075 * (1 + 4.8612 + sum(Cat1)) * (1 + sum((Cat2) * (0.06561 * sum(Cat1+4.8612)+0.17516)) * (0.5+0.005*Aux) * (1 + resistance modifiers))

Adding the 4-piece increases the base damage to 13614. What does this mean? It means this thing is a scaling oddity. If your Cat1 is low (like 200% or lower), your Cat2 ends up only being about as half as effective as it would be. At higher ends of Cat2 (like 300% before preload), Cat2 is about 75% as effective as it is normally.

  • The rift it leaves behind has the following formula:

    1000 * ( 1 + 2.1315 + sum(Cat1 )) * (1 + sum(Cat2 )) * (0.5 + 0.005*Aux) * (1 +(resistance modifiers))

This is a very vanilla formula. The rift only lasts 8 seconds (16 with 4-piece) so it's not going to be a major source of damage, but it's worth noting that the base damage is higher than several other clickies like the Temporal Vortex Probe.

Further Analysis: 2-piece

If you'll recall from our last treatise on exotics, we defined an entry level science ship and used it as a point of comparison to analyze a bunch of different things. Here's our basic setup:

  • 250 EPG

  • 150 CtrlX

  • 130 Aux

  • The Particle Manipulator trait

  • At least 1 stack of the Fleet Coordinator trait. I'll leave it at 1 for people who like to build for solo content

  • The Particle Generator Amplifier, Precision, Advanced Targeting Systems, and Aux Config Offense reputation traits. I won't assume Tier 6 for the purposes of this.

  • We'll add 120 Starship Weapon Amplification and the House Mo'Kai 2-piece set to that as well.

Assume 10 targets for the purposes of hazards and AOEs.

Now, let's go back to the 2-piece for a second. The traditional slot for core and shields on exotic build is the Temporal set. Let's toss in a Gravity Well III, Secondary Deflector MK XV, DRB I, both the exotic torps (non-epic), Drain Infection, the Anti-Time Bubble, and Very Cold In Space I as a pretty universal/cheap setup. If I set this up with 10 targets and add the House Mo'Kai 2-piece setup with 120 Starship Weapon Amplification skill, my final, uptime-adjusted damage (DPS) increases by 18%. In comparison, the Temporal 2-piece is only a final boost of 5%.

How about for a higher-end build? I'm going to use my personal ship as an example, which is over 325% Cat1 / 195% Cat2, 92% CrtH, and 250% CrtD without either Temporal or House Mo'Kai 2-piece. It also has a larger number of exotic damage sources. On that ship, the Temporal 2-piece, as good as it is, only adds 2.7% final damage. In contrast, House Mo'Kai 2-piece is over 9% final damage.

Verdict: Hands-down, the House Mo'Kai 2-piece is best-in-slot (and probably includes the core)

Now, let's compare ColCrit from the Colony Deflector versus the Temporal 2-piece, leaving the Mo'Kai 2-piece in place.

  • Starter build: Colcrit is worth 7.6% final damage. Temporal 2-piece is a only a gain of 4.8%

  • High end build: Colcrit is worth 4.6%, Temporal 2-piece is worth 2.76%.

Mathematically, I do not believe you can re-engineer the Temporal Deflector, so it will end up with the same EPG as a colony deflector (I have 21.3 on mine). Thus, the Colony Deflector is mathematically superior and also unlocks other options like the Romulan Engines to power the House Mo'Kai 2-piece, the Competitive Engines for speed, or my personal favorite, the Regenerative Crystal Matrix Shield.

Further Analysis: 3-piece

If I am flying a low-budget or starter sci build similar to what I've outlined above, the House Mo'Kai Rift 3-piece clicky with both the radiation cone and the hazard is hitting for about 12.5K DPS in a perfect world where I nail 10 targets with the rift blast. Those who have used it know that it is much better said than done. If I'm hitting only 1 target with the cone, it's obviously only hitting for about 5K DPS and is thus not worth it. Even at 5 targets per blast, I don't see this as valuable.

Now let's talk high-end setups. At this point, remember we're talking about Improved Photonic Officer, a lot more crit and Cat2, and a somewhat higher EPG value. I'll again use my personal ship setup as the point of comparison. At that point, the 3-piece is hitting for about 30K DPS even if you only hit 1 target with the radiation cone (in fact, the 8 second hazard does more work than the radiation cone at that point).

If I drop ColCrit to pick up the 3-piece (knowing they have about the same EPG), I actually lose damage unless I hit multiple targets with the radiation cone or unless I stack more buffs right when I fire it. My potential damage is so high that even adding 30K DPS is a loss compared to a final 5% damage. At the extreme high end, if you're able to hit 100% crit without the Colony Deflector, then sure, go ahead with the House Mo'Kai 3-piece.

If you're looking at picking up the 3-piece and leaving the Colony Deflector on, at the high end, just know that the active is worth about 2% final damage depending on how many targets you hit and you'll have to weigh that against the other options.

Mind you, the actual numbers on the clicky are stupid-high. I could see someone hitting for 2 million damage on it. Unfortunately, 2 million damage divided by 180 (its recharge time) only puts it at 11K DPS overall, and that’s not even counting the 6 second charge time.

Further Analysis: Four-piece:

Low-end: Honestly, this is so close that I'd probably go for it, especially if I didn't have access to the colony deflector. Free damage is free.

High-end: Still a net DPS loss by about 1%, though if I can reliable hit more than 5 targets with the Radiation cylinder it's not.

Plasma Storm Module:

We also got our hands on a Plasma Storm Module courtesy of a fleetmate who bought one and helped us fiddle with it. Formula is pretty standard:

 498.4 * (1+2.067 + sum(Cat1)) * (1 + sum(Cat2)) * (1 +(resistance modifiers))

It does NOT Aux scale. Solid numbers, giant AOE. Passive is kinda meh, but when it hits that many targets for so long, that doesn't matter as much. The only downside is that it doesn't punch through shields and so it's better at making giant numbers than actually killing things compared to some other consoles. Unlike the Neutronic Eddy Generator, which also does very good damage, you don't have to worry about it tossing enemies all over the place if used at inopportune times.

Downsides: Expensive.

Bonus Analysis: Captain Careers

Shout-out to the uninformed folks in DPS-Bronze trying to convince people that captain career makes a big difference for sci builds. I was curious to see if that was actually true, so again I broke out the Exotic Calculator to do some analysis. Again, I used the two setups from earlier: the entry level with House Mo’kai 2-piece and my personal build. I modified the Exotic Calculator to adjust captain abilities for uptime.

A couple of simplifying assumptions:

  • We are NOT accounting for Intelligence Agent Attache. We’re dealing with less than 50% weapon crit (especially on the lower end) with maybe 5 weapons that are actually firing, of which 2-3 are torpedoes. The impact of IAA is thus comparatively lower compared to an energy build shooting 7-8 weapons

  • We are NOT going to add Tactical Fleet at all. It’s a teamwide buff, and while yes having another instance of Tac Fleet affects the uptime overall...that got really messy. We’ll fudge the Tacs up by a point for that.

  • We are NOT accounting for weapon damage increases. Since Eng (Intrusive Energy Redirection) and Tac (Vulnerability Assessment Sweep, Go Down Fighting) both have weapon damage boosts, we’ll fudge them up by a percentage point for eng, and 1-2 for tacs. Weapon damage itself tends to account for less than 10% of a high-end exotic build though.

  • We’ll give sci characters an average of 1 stack of Conservation of Energy. Each stack lasts for 15 seconds, but there’s a lot of confounding variables. Since it’s not like Sci characters get an extra bonus trait, we’ll give Tac / Eng the Operative trait in return. Operative is a good-but-not-great trait that’d be a reasonable replacement. It’s also possible that Engineers and Tactical captains would take a non-damage trait as well like Grace Under Fire. It’s an assumption.

  • We will measure all of these as a % increase from the baseline.

  • Starter build:

** Sci: 15.6% boost from baseline

** Tac: 15.5% boost from baseline

** Eng: 3.1% boost from baseline

What do we see? Tac and Sci are basically even at the starter build level. If you’re just starting out on the path of Space Magic, Tac or Sci are clearly the better choice for damage. Engineer just has too many abilities that don’t apply to science builds--but tends to be more forgiving in survivability due to Miraculous Repairs. That might in turn save you a console slot if you would otherwise slot a defensive console like Protomatter Field Projector. We did not account for those effects, and there's some merit that giving up a console for a healing console on a sci or tac captain would level the playing field some for engineers. Again, that's not a choice I'd expect to see on a typical high-end glass cannon, but we try and do these analyses for a variety of build concepts and schemes, not just the fragile high-end builds.

  • High-end:

** Tac: 7.6% boost

** Sci: 4.1% boost

** Eng: 3.1% boost

The gap narrows significantly at the high end, where Tac captains are somewhat better, and Sci falls off a little due to much higher stacking of Cat2 damage. Still, once you’re up into the DPS-chasing world, while Tac reigns supreme at the top of the leaderboards (and specifically the Tactical Romulan Alien Master Racetm), there’s a wide swathe of territory where the difference between careers is roughly 5%.

How much that matters to you personally depends on how hard you intend to chase the maximum numbers. 5% final is significant, but it’s also worth repeating until I’m blue in the face that effective piloting will matter far more than 5%. Statistically speaking, my engineer outparses all but about 200 ISE players, and a 5% gain is only going to move that number from 200 players to 175 at staggering expense.

The Tools

Feel free to do your own analysis, courtesy of a newly updated Exotic Calculator that contains the Mycelial Rift pieces and Plasma Storm, as your individual results may vary heavily. I don't have all the same gear as the highest-end players and I also tend to vary a little from whatever STO league has popularized this month.

Note that by default the tool assumes only 1 target struck with the Mycelial Rift radiation cylinder. If you want to tweak that up, you’ll need to go into a hidden sheet, but given the finicky nature of the active, I did not want to oversell its potential. I also did not leave the captain powers uptime-adjusted. If they are selected active, they're on.

Current Version: 6.11

Changelog:

Added Mycelial Rift 2-piece, 3-piece, 4-piece sets. Added Plasma Storm Module. Fixed a validation error on Lorca's Ambition 2-piece. Added Terran Goodbye. Fixed an error where DoT/Hazard boosts were not applying to some non-boff abilities.

TL;DR

  • House Mo'Kai 2-piece very good. Don't drop the Colony Deflector. Temporal 2-piece is not worth losing Colony Deflector. The 3/4-piece House Mo'Kai active is more gimmicky than amazing DPS monster.

  • Plasma Storm good but expensive.

  • Captain career: Tac = Sci > Eng at the starter build levels for exotics. Tac > Sci = Eng at the high end levels for exotics, but the difference is within 5% so it doesn't matter TOO much.

  • Tool updated, do your own homework! :D


Thanks for reading! Leave us any questions or comments below!


r/stobuilds • • Mar 12 '22

Announcement STO BETTER Season 2

97 Upvotes

We launched STO BETTER back in December with the goal of collating our builds, guides, and tools into a single repository that met our needs more than the existing Reddit suite allowed. I’ve seen links to the site pop up all over this sub as well as occasionally on /r/sto (and not just posted by me! D: ) and it’s very gratifying to see our efforts be useful to people in their shipbuilding efforts. That’s why we made the site.

Since then, we have some new and exciting things to roll out and discuss and enough that merited a separate discussion post. Nearly a month of no-cooldown-ISEs and an upgrade weekend have been very helpful for our build and testing efforts, and we also have some new tools and updates that we hope will be helpful to the wider community.

Enough with the preamble, let’s dive in!

General Site Use & Navigation

The MOST IMPORTANT part of this update is that we have a domain name that is much easier to remember and share!

www.stobetter.com redirects to our site. Note that this URL is just a redirect for the main page, so www.stobetter.com/tools will not redirect properly to https://sites.google.com/view/stobetter/tools. Our gratitude goes out to our fleetmate who purchased the URL and set this up for us.

EDIT: Tools.stobetter.com DOES now redirect to our tools page. :)

Our front page has also been updated to replace the 3-column list of builds with a searchable, sortable table for easier navigation. We’ve also added an acronym list curated by Mr. Tilor under “New & F2P”

A number of page names and structures have changed to make it a little easier to navigate. There are some things that we’re not going to do/can’t do due to Sites limitations or ease of use for our creators, but we did condense and reorganize a little bit to make the top navigation banner and dropdowns a little more intuitive and future-proofed. Where appropriate, we’ve left soft redirects where pages moved. Unfortunately, Google Sites is rather limited on what it allows us to do with hard (automatic) redirects.

For example, when we set up our tier lists, we imagined this as a resource for the community to evaluate these more expensive items. The page was named “trait-doff tier list” because that’s what we envisioned using it for. Since then, there’s been an effort to organize and rank hangar pets and it just makes sense to put this evaluation there as well. However, to avoid locking ourselves in further, we’ve genericized the page name to “tier lists” and left a soft redirect. If you open the old link, it’ll point you to the new one. Hopefully this bit of future-proofing will help us when we have more delusions of grandeur down the road.

Tools, lists, and guides

As mentioned above, we’ve also added our hangar pet aggregate ranking to our site under the aforementioned tier lists page. There’s a detailed explanation of how this algorithm works, but it essentially takes in a large volume of crowdsourced data and attempts to calibrate it using a common fighter type (Normal Peregrine Fighters) to get an anticipated average ranking in terms of DPS per bay for those fighters. We also maintain separate rankings for the four general types of hangar-pet builds, whether you’re just trying to fill in a hangar pet or if you’re looking to build around them with traits like Superior Area Denial. The list is maintained in Google Sheets like our other tier lists so you can make a copy, sort it, filter it, etc. It’ll be a living tool so as we get more data, we’re going to keep updating it with version history so you can track what changed.

We recognize that both it and the existing tier lists for traits and doffs are sort of cumbersome in their current embedded form due to not being able to sort / filter without pulling a copy of the sheet. In the future, I hope to use the same technology that we used for the overall build table to make those tools more user-friendly.

The tier lists are now at

https://sites.google.com/view/stobetter/tier-lists

We’ve taken a look at the new ships from the Mirror bundle and event and included any relevant items in the existing tier lists. The mechanics slides have also had some minor work as well to include support builds and some other small tweaks.

There have been several requests for more general guides as well, so we’ve included a basic overview for tanking in our Guides section that builds on the Energy Basics page.

We’ve also been making periodic updates to our other tools as well, including:

Builds

Eph289

  • L.S.S. Pioneer (Dranuur Exotic) - updated for new console/doff/personal trait, DPS increased from 629K to 729K on ISE

  • Stormbreaker (Chronos Tank) - substantial changes to boff layout, personal traits, hangar, and consoles. Metrics at 287K / 93% attacks in on ISE

  • U.S.S. Aldrin (Gagarin Exceed Rated Limits) - updated to reflect updated understanding of [Over] mechanics and swapped weapons to Dual Beam Banks. DPS increased from 310K to 330K on ISE.

  • U.S.S. Alamo (Presidio Support Tank) - changed Elite Class C Shuttles to Elite Alliance Fighter Squadrons to provide more team-wide support. Metrics at 254K / 94% attacks in

  • Xiphos (Legendary Scimitar Projectile) - changed Elite Class C Shuttles to Elite Alliance Fighter Squadrons. DPS changed from 545K to 668K

  • U.S.S. Doolittle (Fleet Engle/Earhart Projectile) - changed Elite Class C Shuttles to Elite Alliance Fighter Squadrons. DPS increased from 591K to 677K

  • U.S.S. Yi Sun-sin (Inquiry FAW) - moderate trait/console changes. DPS increased from 429K to 505K.

  • U.S.S. Benjamin Davis - a Fleet Malachowski-class Support DPS build geared toward supporting kinetic and EPG builds. Thus far it’s assisted in 10 new personal bests for allies. NEW

  • A.R.W. Javelin - a Legendary Scimitar Intel Dreadnought-class Support DPS build geared toward supporting energy builds. Thus far it’s assisted in 9 new personal bests for allies. NEW

Tilor

  • U.S.S. Dragonscale (Lexington tank) - this ship has changed from the Endeavour to the Lexington and has a few other changes

  • Tilor’s other builds (Iktomi exotic and Tzen-tar projectile) have significantly higher DPS with some extra piloting practice and tests - 584K and 593K respectively.

More to come

We have more we are hoping to finish in the near-ish term. That’s why we’re calling this a season rather than one big expansion. These aren’t promises but hopes of things that we would like to get to, so we’re not putting hard dates or firm commitments since this is a passion project for us.

  • Jay has a Lexington build that’s proven quite successful as well as an Equinox

  • Tilor has a pair of Tholian-themed supports that I can attest to being quite helpful.

  • We’re working on a support guide too that will be broader to help players understand how the role works (but less optimized for single-DPS ISE runs. Spencer covered that already)

  • The intel rework promises to shake things up some. Look forward to more content here and possibly on STO BETTER as we learn more and update tools.

There’s no intended timeline here, but they’re things we’d like to do as we have time, interest, and availability.

Wrapping Up

Thanks for reading our update! We’re constantly reading feedback and trying to improve both our builds and our site, so let us know what’s working and what’s in need of some polish. It’s a living site, so it’ll continue to grow and improve as we work on it. We’re just three guys (and none of us are web developers either) out building and flying in between IRL, and our focus is not chasing the meta, but rather focusing on effective fundamentals and ratings for players at endgame between level 50 and we’ll say 700K DPS. Regardless of your skill or investment in the game, we’re excited to be on our continuing mission to help people build and fly ships in STO better!


r/stobuilds • • Dec 11 '20

Contains Math Torpedo Effects and Damage 1: Photons and Quantums

97 Upvotes

Welcome to another mechanics-based post by the authors of r/STObuilds posts like Revisiting Exotics and the torpedo calculator - aka myself and the inimitably talented /u/tilorfire27.

We're back to further explore torpedo mechanics and hopefully point out the mathematical reasons why the conventional wisdom on torps is what is. Spoiler alert, it's basically all correct.

Unlike energy weapons, where the energy type (i.e Phaser, Antiproton, etc.) doesn't matter a ton*, torpedo type matters a LOT and even within torpedo type, specific torpedoes have a wide range in variance from others in performance. I've seen a lot of torpedo recommendation questions recently here and on /r/sto, and unfortunately, a lot of mathematically unsound advice too. With energy weapons, the uptime of the various “proc” effects is minimal, so energy weapon strength is more about which set bonuses benefit a given type. In contrast, torpedoes have a much higher chance (often 100%!) of applying their secondary effects so those secondary effects have much more influence on the strength of the weapon and there are fewer set bonuses that drastically swing the effects of torpedo damage. Thus, Tilor and I did more research into some of the more popular torpedoes to see how they stack up, including deriving the damage formulas for each weapon.

*Yes, we know there are exceptions like Technical Overload and Beam Overload. The point stands.

Due to their prevalence in builds , we're going to look at Photon and Quantum torpedoes first. We're NOT going to look at the rep-store knock-off brands like the regular Piezo-Photon or Thoron Infused Quantum torps as those are all basically inferior to the reputation set versions and are a waste of dilithium. Requests to research additional specific torpedoes may be considered, but not if the torpedo is either super bad or super expensive (i.e. requires spending Zen or Lobi). Now, before we get started, ye be warned: math and wonky game mechanics lie ahead!

DISCLAIMER: this post is largely written from an endgame performance-focused perspective to analyze and recommend the best torpedoes. If you like how a particular torpedo looks or ‘feels’ and we recommend not slotting it, it’s not personal.

We're also going to add some meta analysis drawing from the main use cases for torpedoes:

  • 1-torp builds are mostly energy weapon builds looking to add a torpedo for set bonuses, proc traits like Super Charged Weapons/Entwined Tactical Matrices, or just because it feels more Trek to have a torp in there.

  • Kinetic builds are torp builds where the weapon damage of the torpedo is emphasized, often with Concentrate Firepower and Torpedo Spread/High Yield slotted.

  • Scitorp builds are mostly built around scaling off of +Exotic, Auxiliary power, and the Exotic Particle Generators (EPG) skill. Torpedoes in these builds are a compliment to science powers like Gravity Well, Destabilizing Resonance Beam, and Subspace Vortex.

Torpedo basics

  • Reload time: Torpedoes that aren't shooting deal no damage. On a 1-torp build, this isn't usually a big deal as the torpedo is not the main focus of the build and shooting off a torpedo spread every 10-15 seconds suffices depending on if you're using Entwined Tactical Matrices or not. A scitorp build is potentially running Ceaseless Momentum, a starship trait which reduces torpedo cooldowns every time you fire a torpedo with some weird exceptions as well as buffing all kinetic damage like Gravity Well, and a full kinetic build certainly is. On top of that, the other main reload mechanic is using Projectile Weapons Officers that have a chance to reduce torpedo reload times by 2-5 seconds on firing a torpedo.

  • Global cooldowns: Aside from some special set bonuses/passives, your ship can only launch 1 torpedo every 1.5 seconds. If using the Ferrofluid Hydraulic Assembly console, this value is reduced to 1 second (which is why this console is mandatory on kinetic torpedo boats). If you're flying a 1-torp build, this doesn't matter. If you're flying a SciTorp or Kinetic build, you want to make sure you have enough reload mechanics in place to make sure you're firing at or close to this global cooldown, but you also don't want to slot so much that your first torps are firing again before your last torp ever fires as you've essentially wasted the weapon slot at that point. The torpedo calculator was designed to help analyze this for each build.

  • Enhancements: Torpedo Spread (TS) enhances the next torpedo launched by firing multiple torpedoes at multiple targets. The number of torpedoes/targets depends on the rank of torpedo spread and the type of torpedo. Torpedo HIgh Yield (THY) fires one or more torpedoes at a single target depending on rank of THY and type of torpedo. Some torpedoes are targetable/destructible under high yield.

Preload

~~One thing that might surprise some of our readers is that most torpedoes also have a small amount of baked in Cat1 damage of varying amounts that isn't tied to gear, traits, mark, or rarity. We used the exact same setup to test the torps and the linear regression formula found slightly different amount of Cat1 preload for each torpedo. Having higher Cat1 preload means that a torpedo has higher damage, but scales slightly less well with other Cat1 boosts. If you're not familiar with these terms, please consult the wiki. ~~

EDIT: We have since determined that this preload value can vary between accounts. It is a small consideration in the grand scheme of things and so is not something we took into account since we can't seem to track down its source.

Note that if we use the term XXX that means it's a scaling value worth about 3-digits of damage/healing depending on your stats. XXXX means 4 digits (1000-9999), etc.

Photons

All Photon torpedoes have the same base damage: 1351. In general, Photon torpedoes fire extra non-destructible torpedoes on high yield and have a fast (6) second reload time. Exceptions noted below.

Photon Torpedo Launcher (Basic):

  • Base damage: 1351

  • Reload time: 6 seconds

  • Secondary effects: none

  • Meta-analysis: Don't use this at endgame. There's better.

Terran Task Force Reputation Photon Torpedo

  • Base damage: 1351

  • Reload time: 6 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 33% chance of dealing radiation damage and applying a stack of Withering Radiation (Up to 5 stacks - stacks last 60 seconds). Radiation damage is roughly XXX-XXXX times the stack number and scales with mark, +Projectile, +Radiation and +All damage but NOT the projectile weapon training skill. I sampled it at 300-400 damage per stack at MK XIII Ultra Rare and a pretty stripped down setup. On top of that, deals additional damage based on target health, scaling up to 200% against low health targets.

  • Meta-analysis: 2-piece bonus with console is a nice boost for torpedo boats. One of the better photons. Only downside is no AOE. Works nicely with TS or THY. No strong benefit to SciTorp or 1-torp.

Gravimetric Torpedo

  • Base damage: 1351

  • Reload time: 8 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 33% chance of creating a 0.5 km AOE rift that scales off of Aux and EPG/+Exotic boosts. Duration is determined by CtrlX skill. See Revisiting Exotics 4 for the exact formula.

  • Meta-analysis: SciTorping! 2-piece bonus with weapon is solid for photon boats, but the torpedo is destructible on high yield so not ideal. However, one of the two basically-essential weapons for scitorp. Unremarkable for 1-torp builds due to lack of emphasis on CtrlX or EPG/Exotic/Aux power.

Advanced Piezo-Photon

  • Base damage: 1351

  • Reload time: 6 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 15% chance of AOE shield drain in 2.5 km radius scales off of drainX, reduces shield hardness by 20% for 10 seconds. 2.5 km AOE. Sampled at around 300-400 at MK XIII Ultra Rare with DrainX values from 0-100. Guaranteed on TS; Destructible on THY.

  • Meta-analysis: The main use for this is debuffing shield hardness for energy builds with torpedo spread. Decent for photon kinetic builds. The actual drain is not that high. Since it's destructible on high yield, users of Concentrate Firepower may have reservations. Set bonus is decent for Polaron/Plasma energy builds or Photon kinetic builds.

Enhanced Bio-Molecular Photon Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1351

  • Reload time: 6 seconds

  • Secondary effects: Radiation damage applies after 8 seconds. Damage is sampled at around 1000-1500 damage at MK XIII UR on a fairly stripped-down stup. Damage scales with +Radiation and +All, not +Projectile. Radiation damage is not enhanced by THY/TS. When used with THY, this fires a single non-destructible torpedo that hits in a 2.5km AOE.

  • Meta-analysis: Top-tier photon. Non-destructible AOE damage on a high yield is rare in the photon world. The only downside is an underwhelming set bonus. The radiation damage is delayed until 8 seconds after hit (but is guaranteed) so that's not the selling point. It's all about the high yield. I don't know that I'd slot this on a build that wasn't using Torpedo: High Yield or Concentrate Firepower (which are usually kinetic builds). One odd note: this torpedo appears to not benefit from the 2% bonus damage boost from T6 reputations despite the tooltip saying it does. Cryptic!!!

Kelvin Timeline Photon Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1351

  • Reload time: 4 seconds

  • Secondary effects: None. These trade a mod that could be [Dmg] or [CrtD] for [Reload] to reduce the firing time by 2 seconds.

  • Meta-analysis: Not strong. It gets outparsed by the Terran Task Force when the HP scaling is considered and Enhanced Bio-Molecular is a better THY weapon in the photon category even before their radiation damage is considered. On a 1-torp build, there's no set bonus or other utility effect to commend this weapon and torpedo spread of any rank will be far more efficient at stacking Super Charged Weapons than waiting 12 seconds. A properly-built kinetic torpedo boat is already firing torpedoes every ~1 second or so, so the faster reload is wasted. Stacking Ceaseless Momentum on a 3-torp Scitorp setup already happens in about 5 seconds without using this. Suboptimal for optimized 1-torp or kinetic builds; completely wasted on a scitorp build.

Prolonged Engagement Photon Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1351

  • Reload time: 9 seconds

  • Secondary effects: Speeds itself up, ramping from 1%-15% haste. Has a 20% chance to grant +10 hull pen (aka 1 armor pen) for 8 seconds (100% on spread/high yield). Also has a 180 degree firing arc.

  • Meta-analysis: It's a decent leveling set weapon. The hull penetration is okay but misleading as 10 points of hull pen is 1 armor point. Furthermore, but it's hampered by a 50% longer base reload that is not compensated for by 15% haste that takes multiple minutes to fully stack. One of the lowest-parsing photons. No AOE and the weird 3-piece bonus is more in the category of "gimmick" than "effective" given that it only maximizes in eight minute combats, which are exceedingly rare and requires slotting a suboptimal console, then activating said console to get a gimmicky torpedo shot.

Quantum

Most Quantum torpedoes have the same base damage: 1502. In general, Quantum torpedoes fire extra non-destructible torpedoes on high yield and have a moderate (8) second reload time. Exceptions noted below.

Quantum Torpedo Launcher (Basic):

  • Base damage: 1502

  • Reload time: 8 seconds

  • Secondary effects: none

  • Meta-analysis: Don't use this at endgame. There's better.

Neutronic Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1802

  • Cat1 preload: 0.16

  • Reload time: 15 seconds (reduced to 12.5 with 2-piece set bonus)

  • Secondary effects: 3-km AOE XXXX radiation damage that also drains power/reduces EPS, for what very, very little that matters to NPCs. Radiation damage scales off of Mark, +Projectile, Projectile Weapon Training, and +Rad. Damage was measured at 1000-1200 at MK XIII UR at a fairly stripped down setting. The power drain scales off of DrainX, but NPCs have very high drain resist so practical utility is minimal.

  • Meta-analysis: Higher base damage than other quantums means that it's one of the hardest-hitting quantum torpedoes out there. Comes with AOE and an okay-ish set bonus that's mostly there to boost its own damage. Downside is an incredibly long reload time that's very difficult to reduce with just Ceaseless Momentum. If you're running a Quantum or mixed torpedo kinetic build, it's a strong candidate for inclusion but optimal use will require some consideration for its reload time, probably involving Projectile Weapons Officers and/or the set bonus. Scitorps can slot it, but it's probably not optimal since it doesn't help reload other torps fast enough and the set bonus is only a small Cat1 boost to radiation. A 1-torp build has intriguing possibilities here, but the problem is being overshadowed by the …

Dark Matter Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1502

  • Reload time: 8 seconds

  • Secondary effects: Adds a stacking DoT that scales with Mark and +All damage but NOT with +Projectile or the PWT skill. Adds two stacks on crit. Enemies that die with the buff active do not warp core breach. I sampled the DoT at 112-125 damage on a pretty stripped down setup at Mk XIII Ultra Rare.

  • Meta-analysis: This torp is recommended a lot for good reasons because of its 2-piece set bonus. Its own damage is better than a basic quantum but not as ridiculous as a properly-cooled Neutronic, Quantum Phase or Delphic. The set bonus gives a stacking CrtD boost up to 25% on crit. There are very few builds (even SciTorp builds) that this set bonus isn't basically amazing on when combined with the Custom Fire Controls tactical console. Since the energy weapon is a wide-angle dual beam bank in only Phaser/Disruptor, if you're running an energy build that isn't compatible with that, you can't go wrong with this on a 1-torp build. A relatively low-reload and strong set bonus means it works well with SciTorp as well though the emphasis should be on the Gravimetric and Particle Emission Plasma torps. Its DoT should benefit from Entropic Amplification, but that is a minor consideration.

Lastly, while the 2-piece is amazing for kinetic builds, the 3-piece somehow manages to be even better, as it automatically fires one of these bad boys at every target below 50% health, once per second, once per enemy in a 10 kilometer sphere. It effectively adds a 1-second 360-degree quantum torpedo launcher that bypasses the global cooldown to your ship. This set and Super Charged Weapons are the two biggest contributions to it being optimal to run 1 torp for most energy builds (specifically this torp), and the existence of the 3-piece bonus is probably the strongest argument against all-photon kinetic builds.

Quantum Phase Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1502

  • Reload time: 8 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 2km AOE shield drain that scales with Mark and DrainX. The drain is doubled with the 2-piece. On torpedo spread, the drain is multiplied by 6 (regardless of rank of torpedo spread) and the radius increased to 4 km. On high yield, the drain value stays the same but the radius is increased to 4 km and allies within the radius also receive a shield heal (doubled with 2-piece). At MK XV Epic, the drain was 962 without the 2-piece and 0 DrainX. Add in the 2-piece and it drains for 1924. Add 90 DrainX and it drains for 2790. Throw on torpedo spread and suddenly you're draining for above 16K shields guaranteed per hit without very much DrainX at all.

  • Meta-analysis: Talk about a 'read the fine print' torpedo. By itself, it's nothing special. If you're slotting the 2-piece, it gets noticeably better. Add in 100 DrainX and torpedo spreads, and it's draining for 12X the base amount. There's two cases where I'd recommend this torpedo. The first is if you want a torpedo, can fit the 2-piece and already have the Lorca's Ambition 2-piece in a 1-torp build--so basically a Phaser beam/DBB build, especially with FAW and ETM. The second place is if you're running a Quantum/mixed torpedo kinetic build. In the latter case, if Delphic is out of the budget, I'd strongly consider this as it is free from a mission. Coincidentally, I happen to have both of those kinds of builds at 340K for the Phaser 1-torp and 410K for the Quantum torp build.

Delphic Distortion Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1501

  • Reload time: 10 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 33% chance -10 DRR for 10 seconds that is applied per torpedo. Shoots one more torp than typical for quantums under Torpedo High Yield. The 3-piece bonus gives you an extra high yield once every minute (not highly recommended).

  • Meta-analysis: This is one of the few Lobi Store weapons that's truly impactful--most are mediocre to weak. The -DRR helps everything else you're doing damage-wise. Sci-torp users can get some mileage out of it for that reason, and its console has decent stats for scitorping as well as a 2-piece bonus that gives a modest boost to crit. Due to its extra torp under high yield, this is much more common on kinetic torp builds (sans other pieces of the set) that have Concentrate Firepower as you can stack the -DRR to fairly absurd levels with this torpedo. For 1-torp builds, it's somewhat superseded by the cheaper Dark Matter torpedo due to lacking an amazing set bonus, AOE, or other utility boost.

Wide Angle Quantum Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1352

  • Reload time: 8 seconds

  • Secondary effects: As implied by the name, this has a 180-degree firing arc.

  • Meta-analysis: DO NOT SLOT THIS. Repeat, DO NOT SLOT THIS. It gives up a damage mod to get that [Arc] mod but even worse, it has the base damage of a Photon combined with the reload of a Quantum aka the worst of both and no secondary effect to redeem it. It also requires the purchase of an otherwise unremarkable T6 ship. Don't buy that ship just to get this torp. If you're adamant about slotting a wide-angle torp, the Prolonged Engagement Torp is at least cheap and combos with a decent Phaser beam/cheap DPS console.

Advanced Radiant Quantum Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1352

  • Reload time: 8 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 33% chance for XXXX temp HP, stacking up to 5 times. 33% chance to apply radiation damage to 2 additional targets within 5 km. At MK XIII UR on a fairly stripped down setting, this was between 1500 and 2000 extra damage.

  • Meta-analysis: This torpedo is much better than a basic quantum, but is heavily outshone by other members in its class. The 2-piece set bonus is a small HP bonus and boost the temporary hit points. If you want AOE damage, the Neutronic or Quantum Phase will do much better than its chaining radiation proc. If you want a strong set bonus, the Dark Matter torpedo is better. So what is this thing's niche? I'd say if you're building a full Quantum kinetic build and the Delphic is out of your budget, this is probably the 5th-best quantum. Alternately, if you're doing a full-on rad boat, it's this, Terran Task Force Photon, Neutronic, and the Enhanced Bio-Molecular. That said, rad boats are more of a cheap-DPS than a peak DPS optino.

Conclusions

  • All variants of Photon Torpedo have the same base damage (1350) and similar preload values. Most reload every 6 seconds.

  • Most variants of Quantum Torpedo have the same base damage (1502) and similar preload values. Most reload every 8 seconds.

  • Since those base stats are largely the same, the distinguishing factor in gauging a torpedo's worth is what else it provides besides that base damage. Is it massive AOE? Is it a hefty stacking damage resist rating reduction? Is it a hazard that scales with EPG and Aux power? Is it an amazing set bonus? If the base stats are worse, that torpedo had better provide an amazing secondary effect or it's probably not worth slotting.

  • If a torpedo doesn't have that "something else," it's likely going to be outshone by a similar torpedo that has some other factor to it. Torpedoes that are destructible are fickle and can be hit-or-miss (Editor's note: groan.)

  • Neither of the Wide Angle torps are very good.

Tilor’s Note: If you are ever curious how we do all the math for these, let us know. I’d be happy to do a very math-y post on how we do what we do, but be warned, the cooldown calculator uses calculus (definite integrals) and the damage calculations use linear regression. We’ve got a pretty robust data collection tool at this point. And, well, I like talking about spreadsheets and lasers (STO combines both!)

I think that’s plenty for Part 1. In the next segment, we’ll cover Plasma and (briefly) Chroniton, Transphasic, and Tricobalt. Thanks for coming to our T.E.D. Talk, and yes, we really did choose the title just to fit that reference here.


r/stobuilds • • Aug 30 '20

Theoretical Revisiting Exotics 7: Anomalous Findings

95 Upvotes

Hello there! /u/tilorfire27 and I are back with another entry in this long-running series on Exotic Mechanics. Reminder that Exotic means non-weapon offensive damage, and in this context, we're talking about ones that (generally) scale off of the Exotic Particle Generator stat. If you're new to the series and like math, check out our previous entries:

Since the first 6 posts, there's been one topic that's stood out in the questions that people ask and that is: "But what about Spore-Infused Anomalies?" Since its arrival on the scene, that trait has quickly become extremely popular among science builds so if you haven't seen blue-disk explosions emanating from Gravity Wells and Subspace Vortices, you're probably in a minority.

The recent summer ship trait, "Electrified Anomalies" also occupies the same space and now that Tilor and I have had a chance to do a little research and math on these, we're ready to talk about them. (Owners of the Legendary Bundle, however, might be disappointed to find that we're not looking into Temporal Anchor and never will be barring drastic changes IRL).

So, let's talk anomalies.

Mushrooms versus Lightning

Spore-Infused Anomalies causes your anomalies (listed below) to explode in a damaging explosion with a 5 km AOE radius every time you activate a science ability. Electrified Anomalies causes your anomalies to deal electrical damage over time in a 5 km AOE radius as well as boost the power levels of allies in that same space.

We believe the following are affected anomalies:

  • Chronometric Inversion Field

  • Gravity Well

  • Ionic Turbulence

  • Subspace Vortex

  • Timeline Collapse

  • Tyken's Rift

  • Very Cold In Space

Here's the breakdown of the two traits:

Spore-Infused Anomalies (SIA)

  • Base damage: 1800.2

  • Aux scales: No

  • Damage type: Electrical

  • Targets: 5 km AOE

    Formula: Base * ( 1 + 2.1413 + sum(All Cat1 only)) * (1 + sum(All Cat2 only)) * * (1 +(resistance modifiers)) There's a few things about Spore-Infused Anomalies that are hidden within the details that need to be noted that make it slightly less amazing:

  • It does damage to shields, which is to say the damage doesn't go all straight to hull. This is better for making big numbers pile up, but worse at making enemies go boom, aka the Plasma Storm problem.

  • It does not scale off +Exotic or +Bonus Exotic damage nor does it scale off of Aux. I have double-checked this. A +All damage console like Hull Image Refractors or a +Bonus All damage trait like Aux Config Offense does boost the tooltip damage. A +Exotic console like Causal Anchor or a +Bonus Exotic trait like Particle Generator Amplifiers does not.

  • It does scale off of EPG, but with the constant of 2.1413 in the term, it's slightly-less effective to scale it up that way.

Electrified Anomalies

  • Base damage: 35 (seriously) per second over duration of anomalies

  • Aux scales: Yes, but weirdly and weakly

  • Damage type: Electrical

  • Targets: 5 km AOE

    Formula: Base * ( 1 + 3.0625 + sum(Cat1)) * (1 + sum(Cat2 only)) * (0.0012*Aux + 0.88) * (1 +(resistance modifiers))

Reminder that this is a DoT, so it will last as long as your anomalies do (10-20 seconds), which will amplify the damage considerably. It also has a fairly significant power boost to all allies within 5 km that scales with DrainX. At a very modest 100 DrainX, it's potentially a teamwide +7.5 All power, which is nice. Deriving that formula is beyond the scope of this calculator. It also scales with Aux and does scale with +Exotic and +Bonus Exotic traits/consoles. It also ignores shields. Unfortunately, its Aux scaling is very weak and the extremely high Cat1 preload (3.0625) means that it doesn't scale well at all. It has very good base damage but very poor scaling.

The Comparison

In a head-to-head comparison, the numbers just aren't there for Electrical Anomalies. Even with ignoring shields, scaling off of Aux/+Exotic, handing out power, and being multiplied by the duration of your anomalies, Electrified Anomalies is too far behind in the base damage department. SIA can be procced multiple times over 20 seconds based on setup, but it will need to be built around. Electrified Anomalies requires less build space to slot and use, but it's weaker. Trying to factor in all the variables is hard because it will depend on setup and how hard you're leaning into SIA, but I'd expect Electrified Anomalies to be less than 1/4 as effective as Spore-Infused Anomalies in raw damage output.

It's important to note that these traits are not at the same price point, where Electrified Anomalies is free for players who participated in the Summer 2020 event while Spore-Infused Anomalies requires a C-store purchase of 3000 Zen before sales/event tokens. In this case, you get what you pay for. Tilor and I discussed it and we think Electrified Anomalies is pretty good for a completely F2P or a starter sci build, but once you raise the budget from basically F2P to include C-store, there are a lot of other traits that will quickly eclipse it. Since we assume Ceaseless Momentum is likely being slotted for its kinetic damage and torpedo reload boost, we're talking about traits like Spore-Infused Anomalies, Exotic Modulation, Strike From Shadows, Improved Gravity Well, and Entwined Tactical Matrices (for extra torpedo spreads) at the C-store level and above that price point things like Improved Photonic Officer and The Ruin of Our Enemies.

A few other things

We also ran derived two other science powers that were previously missing: Very Cold In Space and Delayed Overload Cascade

Very Cold In Space

  • Base damage: 270 / 360 / 450 per second over 15 second duration

  • Aux scales: No

  • Damage type: Cold

  • Targets: 3 km AOE

    Formula: Base * ( 1 + 1.8609 + sum(Cat1)) * (1 + sum(Cat2)) * (1 +(resistance modifiers))

At the ensign level, it's going to be hard to find another AOE power that either 1) creates an anomaly to proc Spore-Infused Anomalies (as this one does), or 2) procs the Secondary Deflector (which it does not). This has a low global cooldown as well.

Delayed Overload Cascade

  • Base damage: 2600 / 3640 / 4440 to foes within 5 km of the target, plus another 50% and repel. This chain-reacts like crazy against clumped enemies.

  • Aux scales: No

  • Damage type: Kinetic

  • Targets: Technically a 5 km AOE but can be a lot bigger

    Formula: Base * ( 1 + 1.8814 + sum(Cat1)) * (1 + sum(Cat2 only)) * (1 +(resistance modifiers))

This power is ludicrously strong but hard to use well. It has higher base damage than Photonic Shockwave III (Cmdr-rank power), and is at Ensign level with a lower cooldown. Downside: it knocks your enemies apart. This is a finisher move because if you fire it and everything doesn't die from it, you just sent all your enemies flying out of your anomaly pile.

Brad Boimler

The clouds this guy leaves behind are so terrible after a couple of parsed runs that we are not going to bother with figuring out the formula. The clouds parsed at 200 DPS on a 150K ISA run. If you can demonstrate more than 5K DPS out of them on a non-radiation-theme build, I'm willing to revisit this, otherwise he can stay in the lower decks.

Further Analysis

It's worth noting that we've added Spore Infused Anomalies, Electrified Anomalies, Delayed Overload Cascade, and Very Cold in Space to the Exotic Calculator, which is now at version 6.08. We'd also like to provide a series of tables that will hopefully give more direct comparisons between the science and temporal powers competing for each rank slot. We'll use the Exotic Calculator and a base set-up to make that analysis.

In order to do that, can we agree on the following? We believe that any science ship build worth its salt, regardless of budget, is going to have at least the following:

  • 250 EPG

  • 150 CtrlX

  • 130 Aux

  • The Particle Manipulator trait

  • At least 1 stack of the Fleet Coordinator trait. I'll leave it at 1 for people who like to build for solo content

  • The Particle Generator Amplifier, Precision, Advanced Targeting Systems, and Aux Config Offense reputation traits. I won't assume Tier 6 for the purposes of this.

I won't assume starship mastery or any other set of traits--we'll be kind to any cash-strapped KDF brethren and not assume Ceaseless Momentum either.

We will assume full duration for Hazards and DoTs, and minimum cooldowns for all powers. We will also show scenarios for both single and multiple targets. Since we're assuming minimum cooldowns, we'll only show DPS, which includes the downtime of the ability. For Temporal powers, I'll assume 0 Entropy so the numbers on those could be higher with Entropy stacked. Recall for the purposes of this table that "SIA" means Spore-Infused Anomalies and "DSD" means "Deteriorating Secondary Deflector."

Ensign

PowerMinimum CooldownSingle target DPS10 target DPSNotes
Delayed Overload Cascade I15 seconds11809.7118097Warning: Pushes enemies apart. Cascading AOE not included in this. Exchange purchase. 5+ km AOE
Very Cold in Space I30 seconds9152.391523Procs SIA. 3km AOE. Winter Store.
Subspace Vortex I25 seconds8631.386313Procs SIA. Exchange purchase. Can be fickle to activate. 3km AOE
Entropic Redistribution (Temporal)15521.55215Entropy spreader from primary to secondary targets. 3km AOE
Channeled Deconstruction I (Temporal)Technically 15, but its cooldown doesn't start until after its 10 second duration281281Entropy Builder
Tractor Beam ITechnically 15, but its cooldown doesn't start until after its 10 second duration.146.7146.7The main reason for slotting this is as a low cooldown mule for Unconventional Systems. Would not slot above Ensign.
Structural Analysis I20 secondsN/AN/ADoesn't deal direct damage, but reduces enemy damage resistance AND applies the DSD in an AOE. Exchange purchase. Generally only worth slotting at Ensign.

Lieutenant

These seats tend to be heavily contested, especially since science ships will often want Photonic Officer here as well.

PowerMinimum CooldownSingle target DPS10 target DPSNotes
Delayed Overload Cascade II15 seconds16533.6165336Warning: Pushes enemies apart. Cascading AOE not included in this. Exchange purchase. 5+ km AOE
Very Cold in Space II30 seconds12203.1122031Procs SIA. 3km AOE. Winter Store.
Subspace Vortex II25 seconds11508115080Procs SIA. Exchange purchase. Can be fickle to activate. 3km AOE
Tyken's Rift I30 seconds5621.956219Procs SIA. 3 km AOE. Procs Drain Infection. Procs DSD in AOE. Conflicts with Gravity Well but can be used during the off-cycle of GW (GW has a 40 second minimum cooldown and 20 second group cooldown). Duration increases with rank of the power.
Destabilizing Resonance Beam ITechnically 30 seconds but cooldown doesn't start until after 10 second duration3672.8367283 km AOE. Reduces enemy resist and weapon damage. Procs DSD in AOE.
Entropic Cascade I (Temporal)15904.114010.8Entropy builder on primary target if no secondary targets. 3km AOE
Chronometric Inversion Field I (Temporal)30728.77287Entropy Builder. Procs SIA. Reduces enemy damage. 5km AOE
Entropic Redistribution II (Temporal)156786780Entropy spreader from primary to secondary targets. 3km AOE
Tractor Beam Repulsors I20 seconds but IIRC this also has a channel duration. Numbers assume 30 seconds.1695.35085.95km AOE, 3 targets max
Rapid Decay I (Temporal)15651.3651.3Entropy Consumer. Reduces enemy resist.
Channeled Deconstruction II (Temporal)Technically 15, but its cooldown doesn't start until after its 10 second duration365.3365.3Entropy Builder.
Tractor Beam IITechnically 15, but its cooldown doesn't start until after its 10 second duration.195.6195.6The main reason for slotting this is as a low cooldown mule for Unconventional Systems. Would not slot above Ensign.
Structural Analysis II20 secondsN/AN/ADoesn't deal direct damage, but reduces enemy damage resistance AND applies the DSD in an AOE. Exchange purchase. Generally only worth slotting at Ensign.

Lieutenant Commander

These are the most contested seats in science, with a lot of strong options here and every power represented.

PowerMinimum CooldownSingle target DPS10 target DPSNotes
Delayed Overload Cascade III15 seconds20167.4201674Warning: Pushes enemies apart. Cascading AOE not included in this. Exchange purchase. 5+ km AOE
Very Cold in Space III30 seconds15253.9152539Procs SIA. 3km AOE. Winter Store.
Subspace Vortex III25 seconds14382.7143827Procs SIA. Exchange purchase. Can be fickle to activate. 3km AOE
Timeline Collapse I (Temporal)15 seconds7302.4730243 km AOE. Entropy Consumer. Pulls enemies towards center but AOE is fixed. Procs SIA.
Gravity Well I40 seconds6324.863248Large AOE. Reduces enemy resist. Pulls enemies towards center. Procs SIA.
Tyken's Rift II30 seconds9743.397433Procs SIA. 3 km AOE. Procs Drain Infection. Procs DSD in AOE. Conflicts with Gravity Well but can be used during the off-cycle of GW (GW has a 40 second minimum cooldown and 20 second group cooldown). Duration increases with rank of the power.
Destabilizing Resonance Beam IITechnically 30 seconds but cooldown doesn't start until after 10 second duration4590.9459093 km AOE. Reduces enemy resist and weapon damage. Procs DSD in AOE.
Photonic Shockwave I30 seconds4068.4406843km PBAOE. Reduces enemy resist.
Entropic Cascade II (Temporal)151175.318214.1Entropy builder on primary target if no secondary targets. 3km AOE
Chronometric Inversion Field II (Temporal)30947.39473Entropy Builder. Procs SIA. Reduces enemy damage. 5km AOE
Entropic Redistribution III (Temporal)15834.58345Entropy spreader from primary to secondary targets. 3km AOE
Tractor Beam Repulsors II20 seconds but IIRC this also has a channel duration. Numbers assume 30 seconds.1695.35085.95km AOE, 3 targets max
Rapid Decay II (Temporal)15911.8911.8Entropy Consumer. Reduces enemy resist.
Channeled Deconstruction III (Temporal)Technically 15, but its cooldown doesn't start until after its 10 second duration449.4449.4Entropy Builder.
Tractor Beam IIITechnically 15, but its cooldown doesn't start until after its 10 second duration.244.5244.5The main reason for slotting this is as a low cooldown mule for Unconventional Systems. Would not slot above Ensign.
Structural Analysis III20 secondsN/AN/ADoesn't deal direct damage, but reduces enemy damage resistance AND applies the DSD in an AOE. Exchange purchase. Generally only worth slotting at Ensign.

Commander

The competition thins out at Commander, making this seat much less contested. There's no reason to slot Timeline Collapse II, Photonic Shockwave II, or Gravity Well II, so I am going to ignore them. Note that Gravity Well's pull increases with rank, so this seat usually goes to Gravity Well III.

PowerMinimum CooldownSingle target DPS10 target DPSNotes
Tyken's Rift III30 seconds15925.1159251Procs SIA. 3 km AOE. Procs Drain Infection. Procs DSD in AOE. Conflicts with Gravity Well but can be used during the off-cycle of GW (GW has a 40 second minimum cooldown and 20 second group cooldown). Duration increases with rank of the power.
Gravity Well III40 seconds10543.7105437Large AOE. Reduces enemy resist. Pulls enemies towards center. Procs SIA.
Timeline Collapse III (Temporal)15 seconds8590.9859093 km AOE. Entropy Consumer. Pulls enemies towards center but AOE is fixed. Procs SIA.
Photonic Shockwave III30 seconds6780.6678063km PBAOE. Reduces enemy resist.
Destabilizing Resonance Beam IIITechnically 30 seconds but cooldown doesn't start until after 10 second duration5509.1550913 km AOE. Reduces enemy resist and weapon damage. Procs DSD in AOE.
Entropic Cascade III (Temporal)151146.522417.4Entropy builder on primary target if no secondary targets. 3km AOE
Chronometric Inversion Field III (Temporal)30116611660Entropy Builder. Procs SIA. Reduces enemy damage. 5km AOE
Tractor Beam Repulsors III20 seconds but IIRC this also has a channel duration. Numbers assume 30 seconds.2814.28442.65km AOE, 3 targets max
Rapid Decay III (Temporal)151172.31172.3Entropy Consumer. Reduces enemy resist.

Torpedoes

We'll look at the hazards created by the Gravimetric and Particle Emission Plasma Torpedoes here. All weapons assumed to be MK XV. It's a little disengenuous to assume you can reliably hit 10 targets with these, but Torpedo: Spread exists and ideally you're firing into enemies pulled together by a powerful Gravity Well. Since pretty much every SciTorp build will have both, there's not much opportunity cost comparison needed, but it's useful as a point of reference:

TorpedoMinimum CooldownSingle target DPS10 target DPSNotes
Particle Emission Plasma (Epic with [Dmg])8 second base reload22618.52261850.5 km cloud on detonation for 6 seconds.
Particle Emission Plasma (Non-Epic)8 second base reload21338.22133820.5 km cloud on detonation for 6 seconds.
Gravimetric (Epic with [Dmg])6 second base reload1960819608033% chance of 1 km rift on detonation with a pull. Duration scales with CtrlX.
Gravimetric (Non-Epic)6 second base reload18498.118498133% chance of 1 km rift on detonation with a pull. Duration scales with CtrlX.

Remember, we're using rookie CtrlX numbers. Get that number up and the Gravi torp will deal more damage to any targets that survive. Upgrading these to Epic with a [Dmg] mod yields a 6% damage boost.

Everything Else.

This includes the Deteriorating Secondary Deflector MK XV, Drain Infection, Electrified Anomalies, and Spore-Infused Anomalies. We're going to have to make some assumptions here:

  • DSD will be assumed to up 75% of the time. This is something of an abstraction depending on how many procs you have going

  • SIA will be assumed to average 1 proc every 2 seconds. The rationale is that if I have a conservative 7 science powers with an average cooldown of 30 seconds and I can deploy a conservative 3 anomalies, then in 30 seconds I will proc all the explosions 21 - 6 times (the initial cast does not make the spawned anomaly explode, and the first three abilities don't have all the anomalies active, or 15 times in 30 seconds. It's possible to make that number go up, but you'll have to build around SIA more. It's a safe assumption.

  • We'll assume 100% uptime on Electrified Anomalies either through clever timing of anomaly effects or Improved Gravity Well

  • Drain Infection will only be assumed to apply to 2 targets at a time max since it has a 10 second duration and can only be applied every 5 seconds. We'll assume a generous 75% uptime.

EntityMinimum CooldownSingle target DPS10 target DPSNotes
DSD10 second duration56461.356461350% shield penetration
SIAHighly variable45215.7452157No innate shield pen
Electrified AnomaliesHighly variable2355.623556Completely ignores shields
Drain InfectionHighly variable11382276Completely ignores shields

Ranking the Damage Sources

Using the analysis above, we can look at all the entities and rank which ones have the highest potential and should be built around the most strongly. Recall that while most things scale similarly, some do not (Subspace Vortex in particular is an outlier in terms of having especially good scaling). I'll rank these generally using the AOE numbers, as most science builds heavily encourage stacking AOEs. I'm not going to consider seating or budget as much because that will depend on the individual's economy and ship.

  • S-tier: Deteriorating Secondary Deflector, Spore-Infused Anomalies

There's a reason why people build around these, even with Spore-Infused Anomalies having some weird scalings.

  • A-tier: Particle Emission Plasma Torpedo, Gravimetric Torpedo, Tyken's Rift, Delayed Overload Cascade, Very Cold in Space, Subspace Vortex, Gravity Well, Destabilizing Resonance Beam (1).

  • B-tier: Chronometric Inversion Field(2), Entropic Cascade, Structural Analysis(1), Photonic Shockwave, Timeline Collapse, Electrified Anomalies(3), Drain Infection(4)

  • C-tier: Literally everything else. If you're picking up one of these, it's likely for flavor, or as a trigger for something else, like a Temporal power for Exotic Modulation or Tractor Beam/Tractor Beam Repulsors for Unconventional Systems.

  • (1) has low innate damage but also procs the Deteriorating Secondary Deflector across multiple targets.

  • (2) has low innate damage but is also a huge AOE and is a source for SIA

  • (3) Numbers aren't great on this, but as a budget trait it's not terrible.

  • (4) Numbers are really not great on this, but it also has basically zero opportunity cost.

As a reminder, the Exotic Calculator is available for more precise fine-tuning of our specific build and questions.

The current version of the tool is 6.10 and the latest release notes are as follows:

6.08

Added Electrified Anomalies. Fixed an error where duration on DoT effects was being calculated twice in the uptime-adjusted field. Added CrtH and CrtD EWO/PWO doffs. Fixed an issue with higher ranks of Channeled Deconstruction. Adjusted uptimes on Deteriorating Secondary Deflector, Spore-Infused Anomalies, and Drain Infection.The tool assumes 1 SIA proc every 2 seconds on average.

6.09

Added Temporal Vortex Probe, Neutronic Eddy Generator, and Mycelial Spore Burst console effects. Added extra rows for non-boff powers.

6.10

Updated flanking formula to only affect powers that can flank (see below)


Thanks for reading! Leave us any questions or comments below!


r/stobuilds • • Mar 03 '20

Torpedo Mechanics: Spreading the Knowledge

93 Upvotes

As part of our torpedo explorations, /u/tilorfire27 and I have been exploring deeply into how torpedoes work. We've been doing a lot of testing to support the tool we're building and there are some surprising findings that we think the community deserves to know. Some of them are going to fly in the face of conventional wisdom, but we're trying to spread the knowledge and hopefully it'll yield high amounts of discussion. I personally am also trying to mix ceaseless amounts of torpedo-related puns into this post.

Due to the extensive ramifications of this, we believe it deserved its own topic. Moderators, please advise if you believe otherwise.

Methodology

We have tested these things repeatedly. Our preferred method is to load into the mission "Doomsday Device," disable the Targ and destroy its escort. There are 4 invulnerable Klingon ships docked at the shipyard that make for great test targets that you can shoot at for hours without worrying about timegates, movement, or getting shot at. Tilor and I welcome discussion, but between the combat logs and numerous stopwatch-assisted timed trials, we'd really prefer that any outright denials of the claims be backed up by more than memory. If necessary, we're willing to back up our findings with video capture, but seriously, do you want to watch me shoot 20 torpedo spreads in a row to validate how it interacts with Projectile Weapon Officers and Ceaseless Momentum?

Findings

Italicized are from our first post

  • Activation time: Based on over 100 torpedoes fired, we have consistently observed a delay of between 0.2 and 0.5 seconds of "activation time" on torpedoes from the time you click the weapon to the time it is ready to fire again. We are aware of Spartan's post on the matter, but our stopwatches and combatlogs do not lie. From the time you click the torpedo to the time it is ready to shoot again, there is an extra smidgen of time required. We observed no lag and my reflexes aren't that bad. For reference, we have tested this with Neutronic, Terran, Dark Matter, and regular old Quantum torpedoes.

  • Torpedo Spread and High Yield add firing delay Both of these powers also add an additional activation time that we clocked around 1 second, so effectively a torpedo with a listed cooldown of 8 seconds is actually taking about 9.25-9.5 seconds to reload on a spread shot. However, this does not slow down the time between firing OTHER torpedoes, just the torpedo that was enhanced. We did not try Transport Warhead because we believe it is terrible aside from niche uses with Tricobalts.

  • Ceaseless Momentum has downsides This trait is awesome! It boosts kinetic damage! It lowers reload times! It even bakes cookies! Unfortunately, there are some hidden drawbacks to this trait. We found that Ceaseless Momentum DOES proc on the torpedo that just fired. If I fire torpedo A, Ceaseless Momentum procs and reduces A's cooldown. If I then fire torpedo B, Ceaseless Momentum procs again and reduces A's and B's cooldown. However, Ceaseless Momentum does not self-trigger on Spread (TS) or High Yield (THY) torpedoes. We have tested this dozens of times. It does not have any effect on the torpedo that you enhance, but it does trigger for all of the other torpedoes on cooldown. If I fire torpedo A and then spread/High Yield torpedo B, Ceaseless Momentum lowers A's cooldown twice (from A firing normally and B firing a spread/high yield salvo), but does not affect torpedo B.

  • Projectile Weapons Officers and Torpedo Spread are weird. They do not self-trigger on Torpedo Spread and only roll once for other torpedoes. If I fire torpedo A and then spread torpedo B, the PWOs will roll on the spread (once) to have a chance to lower torpedo A's cooldown, but will have no effect on torpedo B.

  • Projectile Weapons Officers and High Yield behave much more favorably. PWOs on High Yield will roll per torpedo and self-affect as well. Going back to the example, if I fire torpedo A, then high yield I (Photon) torpedo B, each PWO will roll twice because torpedo B fires 2 torps, and those rolls will affect both torpedo A and B.

  • Per /u/DeadQthulhu, Over-Powered and Over-Gunned doesn't appear to affect torps. This is one we haven't been able to test ourselves.

  • Torpedo Spread visuals do NOT match the number of torpedoes in the combat log. Even though we were seeing Torpedo: Spread III fire up to 8 torpedoes per target, Combat Log only showed 4 impacts per target.

  • D.O.M.I.N.O., contrary to some posted opinions, does NOT lower the global torpedo cooldown. I've tested this extensively with a stopwatch firing 4 torpedo launchers. It's 4.5 seconds from start to fire torpedoes with and without DOMINO's active (I was not using Ferrofluid for this test). If you believe otherwise, please provide video evidence.

  • The Delta 2-piece set is not bugged. It does act as a recharge haste, which means that you will see a 15 second cooldown when fired, but it only takes 15/(1+0.125) = 12.5 seconds to reload.

Tool updates

The tool has been updated for all of the above findings. We are still working on a few things, namely the Romulan Hyper-Plasma torpedo launcher, some weirdness with Kentari/Rapid-Fire Missile Launcher cooldowns when enhanced, and adding the -DRR formula to the results. It is still in beta, so please continue testing it.

Other changes: Added Altamid console, Engineered soldier, Morphogenic 3-piece. Fixed cell reference in J220 for Point Defense Bombardment Warhead.

Current Version 0.02

Link to tool

EDIT: Formatting, bleh.


r/stobuilds • • Jan 29 '21

Effective Healing - There's more to the game than DPS

92 Upvotes

Full Circle

So this is it. I've come full circle. I started on STOBuilds 4+ years ago with Hull Healing math. I've made friends, made enemies (probably), earned ships, and spent countless hours pouring over ingame mechanics. I've worked on a spreadsheet for basically every mechanic in the game. Are my builds and piloting perfect? No. But I can do the math on all the game's mechanics. With the help of the illustrious u/EPH289, I've put together a comprehensive hull/resist/healing spreadsheet we're dubbing the Survivability Calculator aka SC.

Math

So first, the math. As far as simplicity goes, hull healing, capacity, and regen are pretty simple. Damage resistance isn't too bad either. Hull healing has 3 awkward categories and some apply/don't apply rather at random. In general, the biggest heals are the ones we included. There are tons of little baby heals we didn't include. If it's less than ~1k heal, don't bother. Outgoing, Incoming, and Bonus hull healing are the categories (yes, Cat1, Cat2, and Cat3). Hull Capacity is also very simple. Base hull is 45,000. Each ship has a built-in hull mod (somewhere around 1). This sets your base hitpoints. Then, hull capacity adds an amount based on that base value. So: Hull = (45,000 x Mod)*(1 + Capacity) There are no categories here, it all adds rather simply. The biggest influencing factor in your HP is your ship's hull mod. Escorts are squishy, cruisers are not. The hull mod is listed with every ship.

Damage resistance is the most complex of the bunch, but even then there's no categories. The formula for damage resistance is

Damage resist (percentage)    3*(0.25-(75/(150+(sum of all damage resist ratings)))^2)

Incoming damage is then reduced accordingly by the percentage. Note that for the purposes of survivability in PvE, Kinetic Damage Resist is far more valuable than Energy. Simply put, torpedoes hurt a lot and they hurt more when your shields are down. Most of the time, deaths in PvE are either due to damage reflect or a kinetic effect of some kind. For the purposes of this, we’re only talking about hull resistance. Shield resistance follows a similar formula, but shields and their effects are outside the scope of this project. Because of the mathematical function used for resistances, it’s inefficient to stack them. You can never have more than 75% resistance and as your resistances stack higher and higher, they have less effect (aka “diminishing returns”).

Now, how do we evaluate 1% Hull Cap vs 1% Hull Healing vs 1% Regen vs 1 DRR? There is no simple answer. Damage resistance starts to taper off the more you have. Some ships and builds will benefit more from Regen or Hull, and other builds from healing. We came up (or rather re-implemented) the concept of effective sustained HP, rather than just straight hit points. “Effective” Hit Points means that we consider your hull resistances as a percentage multiplier reducing incoming damage. “Sustained” hit points means that we consider passive regen, which can be a significant source of survivability. However, heals and regen really only count if you have time to apply them. When we combine that with hull capacity, we determine “Effective Sustained Hit Points” and that’s the real survivability statistic that matters for absorbing sustained damage. 1k hit points can effectively be 2k if you reduce all damage by 50%.

Comparisons

At certain points in missions / TFOs, we also need to consider burst heals or survivability tools. Those are when the incoming damage is particularly high and might include long-cooldown items like the Protomatter Field Generator, Reverse Shield Polarity, or Miraculous Repairs. We tried to include those as well, but you’ll want to consider those in a separate case from your ESHP number.

How much is enough? That’s harder to say and will depend on your build goals as well as your DPS. To use a personal example from Eph289, we put his Fleet Arbiter into the tool with a time duration of 10 seconds. It has an effective sustained HP of around 200,000. For burst heal scenarios, it has another 5000 HP in boff heals, Reverse Shield Polarity, and an Ablative Hazard Shielding console, plus the active reputation clickies. It can tank quite a bit in Advanced TFOs and Elite Patrols/Story missions but not enough to reliably carry threat for an entire team, certainly not in Elite TFOs. It’s a sturdy DPS build, not a tank.

In contrast, the same character also flies a Tank Chronos with an effective sustained HP of around 300,000. It also has RSP III, another small fast-cycling heal in the form of Causal Reversion, and adds a Protomatter Field Projector on top of the Ablative Hazard Shielding. That tank can handle any tanking challenge on Advanced and is fully capable of tanking ISE as well. Like we said, it depends on how much you want to be able to handle.

Using Eph289’s builds as a reasonable benchmark, we can suggest the following as guidelines that will depend on player skill, team DPS, and enemies involved:

To fly Advanced TFOs and Elite Patrols/Story Missions without worrying much about dying needs ~200K ESHP and 4 burst heals dependent on player skill and enemies involved). To tank Elite TFOs without worrying much about dying needs ~300K ESHP and 5 burst heals

Note that this won’t necessarily prevent you from getting killed by Feedback Pulse, but it’s more of a general guideline as to what’s “enough.”

Nuances for usage

There are some nuances to the sheet you should know before you dive in. There is a place to choose your ship, this pulls in the hull mod as well as the Mastery set. Right below that is a troublesome little value called “base regen”. While this isn’t going to have sweeping affects on your build, Damage Control scales off this value. Some ships have 50%, some have 60%. We surveyed every ship we had and found no discernable pattern here, and short of logging the value for all mutters-hundred ships, you’ll have to check for yourself or guess. In combat, this only gives you 2% more hull regen per minute, and damage control scales off of that poorly. We also discovered that the Leadership Bridge Officer trait and Human racial passive scale off Base Regen. Now, we're talking tiny percentages. The easiest way to discover your ship's base regen is to pick up a BOff with Leadership. Note your regen before and after equipping it (out of combat). If the difference is 5%, your base is 50%. If the difference is 6%, your base is 60%.

Going back to the concept of ESHP and burst heals, the tool accounts for both. Heals are a big burst of hit points (burst heal); regen is best applied over time. Both have their place. So, we have hit points (Base Hull + Hull Cap), Effective Hit Points ((Base Hull + Hull Cap) * Resistance), and Effective Sustained HP ((Base Hull + Hull Cap) * Resistance + Burst Heals {derated for uptime} + Regen * Time). You'll notice that if you set the time really short, resistances always win. As time goes up, heals will pick up. Add even more time, and regen will become a factor. So, you can see where you need a mix for taking a sudden burst of damage as well as sustained damage. Tanks especially need all the help they can get.

There is an entire section dedicated to deflectors. Deflectors come with some inherent values for relevant stats, and get additional based on the modifiers applied. There’s a very real possibility that some of the values I entered are incorrect. Nonetheless, choose your deflector, relevant mods and set your Mark. But what about rarity you ask? Rarity doesn’t affect Deflector/Engine/Core/Shields! Wait but why is Ultra-rare better than very rare?? With rarity-ups, you get additional mods that scale with mark, but none of the other stats are going to change. That’s why Warp Cores are pretty boring to increase in rarity since you are just hoping for mods (and there are some pretty useless ones). Also, all hull regeneration values are in combat. Some values (especially damage control) scale based on combat/non-combat. Some are 1/5th in combat vs. out of combat, some are ½, and some are unaffected. I recommend a power like Tractor Beam Repulsors strictly for testing that you can put yourself into combat at will to validate numbers.

Conclusions

So what are the clear winners/losers? Are there any surprises?

This is like a bare bones setup on my Endeavour tank, such as typical hull capacity buffs, and then this is the delta effective Hull HP in 5s by adding these powers. We'll cover a non-tank next. Aux2Sif 1: 24k Aux2Sif 3: 30.5k Attack Pattern Delta 1: 22k 60% regen from endeavour: 7.7k Protomatter Tac consoles, 1 stack: 19k Tilly 2pc: 15k Bio Link, 3 stacks: 32.5k History Will Remember, 30 stacks: 28.3k Honored Dead, 20 stacks: 68.7k

No surprise that in 5 seconds, Regen-only options aren't high. Honored Dead has a huge amount of damage resistance AND healing. Bio-link is a surprising winner, and higher ranks of Aux2Sif surprisingly ineffective. If you extend the time out to 60 seconds, Honored Dead and Tilly 2pc end up around 90k effective HP each. That’s what makes regen shine, damage over time. Why choose higher-rank Aux2Sif? Burst healing. Having a higher burst heal can help recover lost hitpoints in a flash, while regen shores up the gaps. It also offers great resistance, but that doesn't scale as much with rank.

I also want to compare the “top 5” burst heal clicky consoles. Dynamic Power Redistributor (DPRM), Protomatter Field Projector (PFP), Regenerative Integrity Field (RIF), Reiterative Structural Capacitor (RSC), and Ablative Hazard Shielding (AHS). DPRM and PFP are not very bursty heals. They provide immense regeneration, which is great but not good if you need hit points back quickly. RIF is a pretty weak burst heal (base 4,000), but on energy weapon builds, you can heal quite a bit from your energy weapons. RSC is an interesting heal, and honestly better for a team heal. It has no inherent burst, but it will distribute the damage you take to nearby allies as heals. That leaves Ablative Hazard Shielding. This is a fantastic heal (I am surprised). The base heal is 15,000 and doesn’t scale with Aux power. This also comes with a damage absorption in the form of secondary shields and such that really can be a great burst of healing as you need it. If you have Emergency Weapon Cycle, you have this console. DPRM is the hardest one to get, this has a lot of healing and damage with it’s clicky. You have to get an expensive Lockbox ship to get this console. PFP or RIF can only be acquired from an Anniversary ship, so that means Phoenix Box if you don’t already have it. RSC is a past console that you can get from Mudd’s, so that means a lot of Zen. Finally, AHS is on a T6 ship, so you can get it for a mere 3000 zen unless you spend a token. Is there an alternative? Honestly, you don’t need any of these. Auxiliary to Structural is a solid heal with a 10 second global cooldown, so you can have it up all the time.

Signing Off

There’s a lot of little nuances to the powers and skills - if something seems weird, please ask, there are too many powers to address every single one. I will say Leadership was a little surprising as it scales with your ship’s base regeneration… but it’s still a tiny amount of regeneration.

All in all, putting my Kiwavi tank into the tool shows over 400k effective hitpoints. That's a lot of hitpoints. I hope you find this tool helpful.

A note: some epic items in the game have hidden level scaling. It's rather difficult to nail down values for items I don't have, so most of the time, the wiki is correct. If you find a different value, let's talk about it.

And that's it. We have a spreadsheet for just about everything. There's... nothing left. Sure, there's shields and ground stuff, but I have no desire or intention to do anything with those. Worried about shields dropping? Slot Reverse Shield Polarity. We'll keep updating spreadsheets as neat things come out (Fekilirihiriri Torment Engine?), but at this point, I, Tilor, am done making major spreadsheets for STO. I'll probably make little ones for myself but I don't plan on posting anymore spreadsheets. It's been fun, but its time to get back to playing, theorycrafting, other things.


r/stobuilds • • Sep 05 '19

Revisiting Exotics 6: Auxcidental Mistakes

91 Upvotes

A month ago, I submitted what I thought would be my last post exploring Exotic mechanics and posting the Google Sheets Exotic calculator that Tilor and I built. I was wrong.

Over the last month, Tilor and I have discovered some errors in the formulations we provided, specifically related to auxiliary power scaling on three items: Subspace Vortex, Gravimetric Torpedo, and Delphic Tear Generator. The problem was with how I tested these items. To ensure clean test results, I tested all of these items on a character with 0 points invested into EPG and 0 mastery on his science ship. To save energy credits/marks/dil, I initially did not buy and slot the three items above. I just looked at the tooltip values on the Subspace Vortex manuals, the unequipped Delphic Tear Generator, and the Gravimetric Torpedo tooltip from the reputation project. This allowed me to sell/repurpose these items rather than binding them to a character with no interest in EPG. Unfortunately, what I realized when building an actual exotic damage build was that the tooltip values of these items in your tray when slotted did change with auxiliary power.

Mea culpa on that. We went back and retested all of the items that we initially determined did not scale off of Aux with actual slotting of all the items and found that these three DO IN FACT scale off of auxiliary power. (Delphic Tear scales, but weirdly. Thank you Tilor). Here's the list of aux scaling/non-aux scaling items, and I have updated the original posts that contain the formulas for these items.

Scales with Aux

  • Destabilizing Resonance Beam

  • Feedback Pulse

  • Gravity Well

  • Tractor Beam

  • Tyken's Rift

  • Channeled Deconstruction

  • Chronometric Inversion Field

  • Entropic Redistribution (primary and secondary)

  • Rapid Decay

  • Timeline Collapse (weirdly)

  • Delphic Tear Generator (weirdly)

  • Anti-Time Entanglement Singularity

  • Subspace Vortex

  • Gravimetric Torpedo rifts

Doesn't scale with Aux

  • Photonic Shockwave

  • Tractor Beam Repulsors

  • Aceton Beam

  • Eject Warp Plasma

  • Endothermic Inhibitor Beam

  • Structural Integrity Collapse

  • Entropic Cascade (primary and secondary)

  • PEP clouds

  • Deteriorating Secondary Deflector

  • Drain Infection

I believe we are still evaluating the Web Cannon and I will double-check Multi-Target Tractor Arrays on its aux scaling.

We have updated the Exotic Calculator (in Sheets) to fix these three scalings, as well as added a couple new things to that tool in version 6.02:

  • Temporal Disentanglement Suite

  • Multi-Target Tractor Arrays

Link to tool

We apologize for my incorrect initial analysis! Please let us know of other ways we can improve the tool, or any other corrections!


r/stobuilds • • Oct 20 '18

Guide Space Magic and You: Wey's guide to EPG in the post-AoD World

91 Upvotes

Preface

In my opinion, exotic builds are quite possibly the most fun, cheapest, and versatile class of build in STO. With the release of AoD, I think it's a good idea to go through and talk about the different parts of a standard, high-performance exotic build.

Remember that I am not fallible, some of the things discussed here may not be the most efficient or powerful, and that there's dozens of equivalent builds you can make just by playing around with your equipment, your traits, and your BOFF layout. Don't cookie cut, you should play around with your build and find what works best for you.

With that out of the way, let's get started.

Main Ideas

EPG (stands for exotic particle generator) builds are quite different from everything else in STO in that they rely on non-weapon damage to do the majority of damage. These exotic attacks are all buffed by aux power, so make sure your aux is set to 100 base. You should be in a science ship with a CMDR Sci slot and a secondary deflector. Also, if your ship has the molecular reconstruction suite (e.g., the Eternal), make sure you're using the support configuration.

They are also all buffed by the EPG skill, so one of the focuses is on maximizing this skill (to an extent, anyhow). Like everything else, they are also buffed by critH and critD (more on that later).

Your main sources of damage with an exotic build are:

Thus, to have an effective build, most of your traits, skills, consoles, etc. should be buffing these heavy hitters.

Captain Specialization

Your specialization is super critical for EPG builds, as it provides a host of buffs and useful skills. Basically, for exotic builds, there's a few different specializations you should consider:

  • Temporal Operative. This is a really really good spec. You should always have this equipped, either in your primary or your secondary slot. It provides a +50 EPG passive EPG boost simply for having it slotted. Having it as a secondary will give you +20% all DoTs, +10% exotic skill recharge, and a bit of temp hull for using exotic abilities. Having it as a primary gives you firing cycle haste (useless), temp hull for your targetable mines/torps (not super useful), but most importantly, Continuity. Continuity essentially saves you from dying once every 3 minutes

  • Miracle Worker. You should only use this as a primary spec, it's not worth it as a secondary. MW is awesome for a few reasons. First, it gives a bunch of different cleanses, resists, and buffs your healing. More importantly, when you're critically hit or critically heal (you soak up a lot of threat as an exotic build), you gain 10% all damage, stacking 3 times. Also, it has a super useful feature where power transfer happens instantly after full impulse.

  • Constable (secondary only). This is really good if you're facing heavy bosses (e.g., Korfez, DGE), as it increases the damage dealt to the target and nerfs their healing.

  • Strategist (secondary only). This is an all around good secondary as it gives quite a bit of critical severity and a few other buffs to healing. There's also a decent placate clicky.

Of these, the viable combinations are Miracle Worker (primary)/Temp op (secondary), Temp op (primary)/Constable (secondary), Temp op (Primary)/Strategist(secondary). I personally use MW/Temp, since I think MW is just so useful, but play around with them and see which you like best.

Ship Equipment

You certainly do not need anything to be upgraded to Epic (though, I think it's super useful to have your shields, engines, and torps upgraded to Mk XV, if nothing else). Here is what you generally want for an exotic build.

  • Temporal defense initiative 2-piece set bonus. This will significantly buff your DoTs, and subsequently, your DPS. Choose any two from the shields, engines, and warp core. You do not want to use the deflector, as there are much better ones for our purpose. I personally use the engines and warp core.

  • Depending on which items you are using for the temporal set, you either have a free shield, free engine, or free warp core slot. If you have a free shield slot, I recommend the Iconian shields, for the debuff cleanse. If you have a free engine slot, I would use the competitive engines for the speed boost from control abilities. If you have a free warp core slot, I would use the elite fleet isolated protomatter warp core. But as always, it's up to you. There's no right answer here.

  • Colony deflector with [EPG], [CtrlX] and [ColCrit], or the Bajoran deflector re-engineered for EPG, or the Solenae deflector. I think they are all roughly equivalent, with the colony deflector being a little bit better.

  • The Strategic deteriorating secondary deflector with [SA +Dmg] from the fleet research lab, re-engineered for as many [EPG] and [CtrlX] mods as possible. Make this MK XV.

  • If you're still working through the temporal rep, that's fine! I would instead use the quantum phase shields/engines. This set is actually quite underrated, as the engines give a +EPG boost after a full impulse and the shields regenerate when you use certain sci skills. I used the QP shields until quite recently.

  • If you have a hangar bay, fill it with Elite Hur'q Swarmers if you have them. If not, use Elite Aeon Timeships. If you don't have those either, then use either Elite Peregrine Fighters, or Elite Scorpion Fighters. The reason for this will become clear later.

  • Lastly, the exotic particle flood battery consumable is nice when you need that extra oomph.

Ship Consoles

These is less important than you may think. There is no one item here that will make-or-break your build. There are certainly a bunch of different options and various consoles, so I'd advise you to look at the full list of console that buff exotic damage on stowiki. Generally speaking, you will not be using any tac or engineering consoles unless they directly buff EPG or exotic damage. Instead, you will fill those slots up with universals. With that said, here are the easiest to obtain and best consoles for exotic builds:

  • Delphic Tear. Buy it off the exchange.

  • Constriction Anchor. Buy it off the exchange.

  • Chronometric Capacitor, from a mission. This will complete the chronometric calculations set.

  • 4 of the fleet research lab consoles with [CtrlX] and [EPG]. Either restoratives are focusers are fine, depending on how many heals you have and your timing with them. I use no heals, and therefore only use focusers.

  • 1 Exotic Particle Field Exciter. Buy an ultra-rare or epic one off the exchange with a mod you like. The best mod out there is [EPG], but those are insanely expensive. Instead, get something else you like, like [CtrlX] or [ShHP]. It's up to you.

Those are the ones that are generally easier to obtain. There are many others that are ship-specific or are harder or more costly to obtain. I will list those here.

  • 1 Conductive RCS Accelerator with [EPG]. This will likely cost you 20+ mil on the exchange. If you can't afford it, great, if not, not a big deal.

  • Bioneural infusion circuits The critD this gives results in a huge damage boost to exotics

  • Auxiliary ejection assembly. Good bonus to exotic damage, good clicky. Costly for feds.

  • Plasma storm, from the Maquis raider. Slight EPG boost but an amazing clicky. The plasma storm does ~15-20k on HSE alone, depending on how it's buffed

  • Enhanced Tipler Cylinder, from the Verne. It gives a cat1 EPG boost but the clicky is a nice "Oh shit" button and drastically reduces cooldowns when activated.

  • DPRM. 'nuff said.

  • Interphase Quantum Distributor. It gives a cat1 EPG boost, but the 2pc bonus gives +11% critD, so I'd say it's worth it.

  • Various ship specific items, like the Causal Anchor on the Eternal.

  • Probably lots of others I'm forgetting about, check the wiki

If you can't get access to those, then here are some alternatives:

  • The distruption pulse emitter isn't so bad. The clicky is pretty nice and it gives a decent EPG boost.

  • The universal console from the Nukara set boosts your EPG by a bit, and gives a few other bonuses.

  • Basically any other console to boost your critD, such as the assimilated module (borg rep) or the tachyokinetic converter (lobi). Even the dyson 3pc (along with the gravi torp and the dyson proton weapon) isn't so bad.

  • The interphasic instability console from the phoenix store isn't too bad if you have an empty console slot

Ship Weapons

Ah yes, the all important ship weapons. Here, apart from the gravimetric and PEP torps discussed earlier, you will be using your weapon slots to fill set bonuses. Your energy weapons should be doing negligiblie amounts of damage. Most of the damage is done by your torps and exotic abilities, as discussed earlier.

  • Gravimetric and PEP torps. These are super important. Make sure they are Mk XV. You may also want to consider getting the PEP torp with an [Spr] mod, as that will give you free torpedo spread 1's quite often.

  • I think it's a good idea to use the chronometric 3pc (omni + aft beam) for the clicky to increase exotic damage

  • The delta 2 pc (torp + beam) can be used to increase your radiation damage

  • If you're using the delphic console linked earlier, then having the delphic distortion torp will give +10% all critD

  • The dyson proton weapon is pretty good as well, the set bonus gives +3% critH

Play around with these until you find a combination that suits you. I use the gravi, PEP and delphic torps, with the dyson proton weapon and the chronometric 3pc.

Bridge Officers

If you're a romulan, you've lucked out. Make all your BOFFs SROs except for 1 kentari, and you'll be good. For Feds, unless you have gamma vanguard boffs, it's a bit more complicated. You should use the embassy SROs in every tac slot you have, a Kentari in an eng slot, a Weyoun (he has astrophysicist, +10 EPG) and the hierarchy sci boff in the sci slots. Any other eng or sci slots should get a krenim.

Bridge Officer Abilities

These matter a ton. Unfortunately, they are highly dependent on your ship and build. However, I will say this about it.

  • Use Gravity well 3 and subspace vortex 3. Always use them, they will be one of your most potent sources of damage.

  • Use Torpedo Spread 3 if you can fit it. If not, Spread 2 is fine (You may also want to try using both spread 2 and 3). Firing your gravimetric torp with TS results in a bunch of gravimetric rifts opening, with multiple per target. These rifts do huge damage.

  • Use multiple abilities to proc your secondary deflector on as many targets as you can. Abilities like tachyon beam, charged particle burst, structural analysis, and destabilizing resonance beam do this quite well.

  • If your ship has an Intel seat, use overload subsystem safeties. This will overcharge your exotic abilities since your aux power becomes really high. Ideally, use this in conjunction with your other buffs before you drop your grav well.

  • If your ship has a temporal seat, use channeled deconstruction and entropic redistribution (of the highest level you can). Entropic redist often crits for >400k, and also does AoE damage. It's a great ability to use.

  • If your ship has a command seat, use concentrate firepower at the highest level you can. The free Torp HYs do huge damage and let you take down huge bosses (I.E., Fez boss, tactical cubes, etc.) much faster

Other than that, it depends on your build and your playstyle.

A few other useful abilities (but by no means necessary) are:

  • Structural integrity collapse

  • Kemocite laced weaponry

  • Tractor beam repulsors (only if you have the Graga Mal doff)

Active Duty Officers

Generally speaking, the only mandatory doffs a sci-torp ship should have is 3 Projectile weapons officers (either torp recharge variant or 1-2 +crit severity variant) and 1 gravimetric scientist (either recharge or the standard gravity well aftershock variant. After that, the other 2 are up to you. I use two conn officers to keep tactical team cooled down, but it's really up to you.

Personal Space Traits

It is quite important to make sure you're not using the wrong traits, but among the good ones, it's hard to go wrong. Here are the traits you can be using. Use a subset of these, tailored to your liking. This may help you quite a bit. The traits I have bolded are super good.

  • Context is for Kings - +DMR or +DMG, depending on if you're being shot at

  • Particle Manipulator - Gain .2% critH (capping at 50%) and .1% critD for exotic abilities for every point you have in EPG. This trait is super important. You get it by leveling science R&D up to level 15. This is why your CritD is really important; it directly buffs your exotic damage.

  • Fleet Coordinator - +2% damage for every person on your team

  • Enlightened - +15% Exotic damage, +15% hull regen

  • Duelist's Fervor - +5% damage when you or a teammate kills something, stacks 3x. I highly recommend this trait, as your AoE abilities should be killing things constantly.

  • Conservation of energy - +10% bonus exotic damage when attacked, stacks 3x

  • A good day to die - GDF can be activated at any hull

  • Resonating Payload modification - -5 DMR per torp hit per target, stacks 5x. If you have any pets, be sure to slot this trait.

  • Inspirational leader - 10% chance to give +10 to all skills when using boff powers

  • Invasive control programming - Subsystem disable on use of control powers

  • Ablative shell/repair crews - Keeps you alive, basically

  • Anchored - increases your damage when not moving, up to 20% cat1, but reduces your DMR by -20 as well

Reputation Traits

There really isn't much variety here. Choose 5 of the following:

  • Aux power config-offense - (+damage for high aux)

  • Precision - +4% critH

  • Advanced Targeting systems - +16% crit severity

  • Particle generator amplifier - +5% exotic damage

  • Torpedo prefire sequence - +12.5% torpedo damage, +33% destructible torp flight speed. Use this if your ship has a command seat.

  • Chronometric capacitor - +7.5% bridge officer recharge speed

  • Aux power config - defense (+hull, shields for high aux). Use this if you need to be more tanky.

Starship Traits

I won't say much about these, mostly because I don't really have many myself, but the good ones for an exotic build, in no particular order are (go here to learn more):

  • Time to kill - All of your science bridge officer abilities will boost your damage by 10%. This effect can stack up to 3 times. - Annorax

  • Exotic modulation - While this trait is slotted, using Directed Energy Modulation or any Temporal Operative ability will provide a large boost to Exotic Damage for a short time. - Chronos temporal dread

  • Honored Dead - +DMR and +regen after taking 10k damage - Exchange

  • Highly specialized - Each time one of their abilities is activated, it will cause all other specialist bridge officer abilities to recharge more quickly, allowing them all to be used more frequently. In addition, you will gain a boost to Starship Hull Repair, Starship Weapon Specialization and Starship Particle Generators skills. This skill buff stacks up to 5 times.

  • Improved gravity well - Makes your gravity well last 20 seconds longer, reduces the CD of gravity well by 20 seconds, and adds a debuff - Science Andorian pilot escort

  • Retaliation - While this trait is slotted, and you suffer a critical hit you will gain a 10% boost to your damage and 1% to critical hit chance. This buff stacks up to 3 times.

  • Checkmate - Activating a control Bridge Officer ability will provide a 30% boost to your Exotic Damage and Projectile Weapon damage for 15 seconds.

  • All Hands on Deck - Activating a Tactical or Command Bridge Officer ability will reduce the recharge time of Science Bridge Officer abilities and Captain abilities. Science bridge officer ability recharge time reduced by 10% and captain ability recharge time reduced by 5%, this may only occur once every 5 seconds.

  • Unconventional tactics - +15% all damage when using brace for impact

  • Emitter synergy - When using Tac or Intel Bridge Office Ability: To self: +7.5% Exotic Damage for 15 sec (Stacks up to 3 times) To self: +7.5% Shield Heals for 15 sec (Stacks up to 3 times)

  • There are probably a lot more I'm missing, check the wiki or other posts

Concluding Remarks

These are the basics for making an exotic build. It's definitely not the end-all, be-all. A lot of the fun of STO (at least, for me) comes from being able to design and toy around with your build. I highly encourage you all to do that with your own builds.

Happy hunting everyone o7

-Wey@spotthecat1


r/stobuilds • • Dec 23 '20

Torpedo Effects and Damage 3: Energy Torpedoes and Final Ratings

89 Upvotes

Welcome to the third and final T.E.D. Talk on torpedoes by Eph289 and /u/tilorfire27. See part 1 and 2 here:

For our third-and-final evaluation, we’ll be looking at energy torpedoes, missile launchers, and some other . . . weird ones, as well as an overall evaluation. But first, some refreshers:

There are 3 main builds that use torpedoes and they all have different needs.

  • 1-torp builds are mostly about energy weapons and the torpedo is an add-on and/or procs certain beneficial traits. These builds would like a nice set bonus and/or some utility to benefit energy weapons. FAW-focused builds will likely be using Torpedo Spread to proc those traits, so extra effectiveness under spread is always welcome.

  • SciTorp builds are mostly using science powers and the secondary deflector to deal damage and only have limited weapon slots to deal with. These builds will want the Particle Emission Plasma Torpedo and Gravimetric Torpedo Launchers due to their EPG/Exotic scaling, but since at least a 3rd torpedo launcher would be welcome to help fill out torpedo reload times and/or bring set bonuses, extra utility or set bonuses that benefits the science portion of the build are most important. These builds will usually focus on Torpedo Spread due to the Gravimetric and PEP torps being destructible under High Yield.

  • Kinetic Torpedo builds focus on torpedo weapon damage and can be a single torpedo type (Photon/Quantum/Plasma, etc.) or mixed. These builds generally will use Concentrate Firepower and Torpedo Spread so torps that behave well and gain extra benefits under both modes are desirable.

Just Cryptic Things

We found out when we were looking into energy weapons that there was some account-wide Cat1 variance across different accounts for the same weapon, even with as much stripped down as we possibly could. Upon further investigation, we are seeing the same variance with torpedoes and since there’s no apparent rhyme or reason as to why different accounts that are all completely stripped down show different values for the same weapon, we’re going to ignore it and edit the previous posts to remove the Cat1 preload values because they will vary between different accounts. In practice, it’s 20% or less Cat1 and a very small contributor to overall performance.

Energy Torpedoes

Energy torpedoes deal energy damage (i.e. phaser, disruptor, etc.) rather than kinetic, so they do not suffer the reduced penalty to shields. They ARE affected by +Projectile boosts and the Projectile Weapon Training skill as well as by +Torpedo boosts.They ARE boosted by the appropriate energy flavor (i.e. +Phaser for the Agony Phaser torpedo) but NOT by generic +Directed Energy Weapon damage. However, items like the Ordnance Accelerator that boost a couple of energy types and projectile weapon damage (like the Protomatter Tac consoles) only count once for these and not twice. Energy torpedoes generally have between 1100 and 1300 base damage and longer reload times, which is somewhat compensated for by their lack of shield penalty.

EDIT: Amended July 2021 based on current research.

Morphogenic Polaron

  • Base damage: 1292

  • Reload time: 12 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 20% chance to reduce all power levels by 25 for 5 seconds.

  • Meta-analysis: To be honest, the Morphogenic torpedo is not that great. Even in a 1-torp setting, its bonuses tend to be outshone by certain Quantum torpedoes. However, its 3-piece set bonus is amazing if you’re running a cannon, projectile, and beam power (and ideally Entwined Tactical Matrices to get more spreads from those powers as well). 6% CrtH, 30% CrtD, and 22.5% Cat1 weapon damage is an incredibly strong boost, which is why this setup is so highly-recommended on virtually any Polaron build as well as Scitorp and even torpboat setups. The latter two stuff the torpedo in the back and don’t bother with silly ideas like actually firing it, as there are much better weapons for direct damage. This weapon is all about the 3-piece set bonus.

Advanced Diffusive Tetryon

  • Base damage: 1162

  • Reload time: 8 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 10% chance to steal 10% shield hardness from enemies, 10% chance to deal protomatter radiation.

  • Meta-analysis: Another set-bonus-focused torpedo but less awesome than the Morphogenic, kind of like how Tetryon is generally less awesome than Polaron. 25% Cat1 Projectile, 25% Tetryon, 15% Shield Resistance, and some turn rate is a solid 3-piece bonus that is mathematically very close to the Lorca’s Ambition 2-piece. However, this is a somewhat limited set bonus as it requires slotting a Dual Beam Bank or Dual Heavy Cannons, so if you’re building around Tetryon Dual Beam Bank or Cannons and feel like burning Lobi, it’s a solid choice. Otherwise, Dark Matter is just-about-as-strong Tetryon builds and there’s no reason to consider this on anything else.

Crystalline Energy (Antiproton)

  • Base damage: 1262

  • Reload time: 12 seconds

  • Secondary effects: None

  • Meta-analysis: Fairly unremarkable and hard-to-get. At the lower end, even accounting for the 2-piece, this is competitive with the Dark Matter Torpedo, but is quickly outscaled once your CritH gets up there.

Nausicaan Disruptor

  • Base damage: 1292

  • Reload time: 12 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 20% chance to hold for 5 seconds. -10 All Damage Resistance for 10 sec. Adds some minor disruptor damage with 2-piece.

  • Meta-analysis: Tied with Morphogenic for the best energy torpedo + set bonus. On top of having an awesome set bonus, it also brings a -10 DRR rating that appears to be guaranteed on hit. The downside is that the 3-piece only comes with a beam array, so if you’re running Disruptors in either Dual Beam Banks or Beam Arrays, consider this one, but cannon builds are out of luck as the 2-piece is nothing special. Dual Beam Bank builds can get the best of the two strongest sets by slotting this (and its beam in the aft) as well as the Wide Angle Disruptor Beam Bank and console from the Lorca’s Ambition set.

Agony Phaser Energy Torpedo Launcher

  • Base damage: 1033

  • Reload time: 10 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 40% chance to disable for 4 seconds (can occur every 10 seconds) and a minor Phaser DoT. The duration doesn’t scale off of ControlX.

  • Meta-analysis: Not a set, low base damage, and a weak secondary effect means this one isn’t exactly a winner. Extremely niche and not worth slotting unless you’re into disabling effects.

Missiles

I’ll be blunt: these are not good. Stats provided for posterity and most courtesy of /u/cryhavok101, so say something nice to him in the comments because if it was up to me, I’d have only looked at the Kentari Missiles and consigned the rest to the scrap heap.

Kentari Missiles

  • Base damage: 207

  • Reload time: 2.5 seconds

  • Secondary effects: Radiation damage over 3 seconds. 10% chance: -60% Flight Turn Rate for 5 sec. Spread can be fired every 3 seconds. High Yield is a destructible missile with an 8 second cooldown that deals 3.54x/8.95x/9.70 current damage kinetic but 20% less damage on radiation and puts weapon on 8 second cooldown. 10% chance to reduce flight turn rate for 5 seconds. 180 degree arc.

  • Meta-analysis: I measured the radiation damage at 2343 damage over 3 seconds (750 DPS) at MK XII Very Rare and no rad-boosting gear. That doesn’t make up for the lowest base damage of any projectile. I know there are plenty of people that are fond of them for immersion reasons, but unless you’re going for the missile look, skip these. As a point of reference, at no point were these ever even half the damage of the Particle Emission Plasma Torpedo on any of the builds we analyzed, and that was with including the radiation damage.

Rapid Fire Missiles

  • Base damage: 431.39

  • Reload time: 2 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 180 degree arc.

  • Meta-analysis: An expensive way to slot missiles. Unless you’re going for the missile look, skip these. As a point of reference, at no point were these ever even half the damage of the Particle Emission Plasma Torpedo on any of the builds we analyzed. Note that slotting more than 2 missile launchers is inefficient--due to their low cooldowns, having a third will leave 1 weapon idling.

Spatial Torpedoes

  • Base damage: 533.22

  • Reload time: 2 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 20% bonus damage against hull. 180 degree arc.

  • Meta-analysis: Still not good, and has an unremarkable set bonus. Expensive way to slot missiles that’s slightly better than the Rapid Fire Missiles but still not good. Note that slotting more than 2 missile launchers is inefficient--due to their low cooldowns, having a third will leave 1 weapon idling.

Everything else

Thermionic Torpedo

  • Base damage: Approximately 926

  • Reload time: 10 seconds.

  • Secondary effects: 15% chance to drain -15 Weapon and Engine power for 12 seconds. Destructible on high yield.

  • Meta-analysis: Very low base damage and long reload. There’s really no reason to ever slot this given how NPC drain resist is.

Temporal Disruption Device

  • Base damage: Approximately 3117

  • Reload time: 20 seconds.

  • Secondary effects: 100% chance to reduce Flight Speed and Turn Speed by 33%, 1 km AOE. Always destructible.

  • Meta-analysis: Someone mentioned this to us in the comments on Part 1 and I was initially skeptical since it sounded like a cross between a Tricobalt and a Chroniton which if you read Part 2 isn’t encouraging. That said, cryhavok101 did a lot of digging for us on this and it’s a pleasant surprise. If you want to shoot a giant warhead at something and watch giant yellow numbers go off when it hits, this is the weapon of mass destruction for you. Cooldown is lower than a Trico and it doesn’t suffer from the 15s global cooldown as well as higher base damage than Tricobalts. This is basically the king of destructible torpedoes and/or maximum 1-hit damage weapons. Weirdly, seems to benefit from +Chroniton boosts so if you’re using it, do consider its excellent console for the 2-piece. Downside: still a destructible torp, expensive, gets outparsed by the Delphic in all scenarios that involve more than 1 projectile unless you stack a bunch of enemies in the AOE.

Bio-Neural Warhead

  • Base damage: Approximately 6500

  • Reload time: 60 seconds, non-reducible.

  • Secondary effects: Shoots antiproton beams at nearby targets then explodes for kinetic damage. 2.5 to 15 km range. Always destructible.

  • Meta-analysis: We did not analyze the antiproton damage and honestly had trouble getting a consistent base damage across three different accounts that isn’t explained by the preload issue. All you really need to know is that you can’t reduce its cooldown by any means, so it will always take 60 seconds to reload. I tried Concentrate Firepower and Projectile Weapons doffs and neither had any effect. Even with its high base damage, a minute cooldown is simply too crippling.

Elachi Subspace

  • Base damage: 1132

  • Reload time: 10 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 10% chance: Disable for 2 sec. Not guaranteed on spread, but the disable does scale with ControlX. Destructible on High Yield and has a repel.

  • Meta-analysis: Not a huge difference between this and the Agony Phaser Energy Torpedo, except this is significantly more expensive. Set bonuses are nothing remarkable. Would generally steer clear as the Agony Torp is much better if you’re really about disabling due to its higher chance of triggering.

Disrupting Photon

  • Base damage: 1563 1351

  • Reload time: 6 seconds

  • Secondary effects: 5% Chance -10 All Damage Resistance for 15 sec

  • Meta-analysis: This was a pleasant surprise as well. We missed analyzing it in Part 1 because we figured it was a standard photon with a 5% chance for a proc with ignorable damage. In fact, the torp has the base damage of a Quantum with the reload of a Photon so even without the proc, this ends up being a decent weapon. If you’re running a dedicated Photon build with High Yield/Concentrate Firepower and are averse to destructible torpedoes, consider this one. It won’t beat the Enhanced Bio-Molecular or Terran torp, but it’s the 3rd-best non-destructible Photon. Unfortunately, retesting confirmed our initial suspicions: it's a standard Photon with a 5% chance for a proc with a low chance of triggering. Romulan only, probably not worth investing into.

Final Analysis

After all was said and done, we put together six notional builds, using our build definitions above, and crunched a LOT of numbers. We did a “low end” build for each of the three types, using our calculator tools to determine how much Cat1, Cat2, CrtH, etc. and then I used my personal builds as a datapoint for the higher end. You can think of a low end build as a MK XII / MK XIII build at Very Rare and Ultra Rare with few to no starship traits, whereas the high end is much more optimized, MK XV, with all the set bonuses and starship traits to hit hundreds of thousands of DPS. We tried to approximate most of the secondary effects in there and included the effects of Torpedo Spread (since all 3 builds will be running some version of it) and High Yield as well on the torpedo boat builds. Then we looked at set bonuses to see which ones had the most benefit to the build overall. That led us to a number of results that indicated some clear winners and losers.

We then did a couple of things. First, we hooked up all the base damages we derived into the Torpedo Calculator, now at 1.07. We also expanded its damage calculations further by adding in weapon mods, mark, and shield penetration as well as adding a hull-to-shield ratio setting. It now has a column that calculates final DPS, including reload times, shield pen, and basically everything that goes into DPS. If you want to do your own build analysis, this is the tool for you. It also calculates reload times which is handy for multi-torp setups.

Second, for users who just want to know what torpedo to slot for each of the builds described above, we found that a simple tier list was tricky. We kept running into lots of asterisks, gotchas and “it depends” based on which sets were slotted and which type of build was being discussed. Instead, we made a tool that walks you through a series of questions about your build and then makes recommendations based on your responses and our analysis / ratings on the torpedo. We call it Torp Finder. Note that Torp Finder is designed around the 3 types of builds we described at the start of this post, so if you’re trying to do something theme-based or just off the wall, you’re better off asking for advice on this sub. That also goes for mine-builds.

EDIT: Updated Torp Finder to 1.01 to account for re-analysis of Disrupting Photon.

This completes our exploration into torpedoes, and apologies if we missed your favorite type, but that does conclude the series. Thanks for coming to our T.E.D. Talks and leave us any questions or comments below!


r/stobuilds • • May 02 '20

Hanger Pet Testing Round 2

89 Upvotes

Okay, this was pretty exhausting...

Method of Testing: I used the Tribble space combat test map, placed my carrier over the spawn point and selected Active Combat Scenario > Basic Combat Encounter 1 to spawn 3 Borg probes and 2 Borg spheres on normal difficulty setting. Spheres being targeted first followed by probes. Pet were launched as soon as hangar was off cooldown. DPS results below are an average of 3 tests.

I used the following:-

  • High Aux + 3x Flight Deck DOffs

  • Wing Commander trait

  • Scramble Fighters starship trait

  • Dampen Energy Signature starship trait (not on T5 Jem'hadar Dreadnought Carrier)

  • Superior Area Denial (SAD) starship trait

  • Coordinated Assault (CA) starship trait

  • Improved Gravity Well starship trait

  • Swarmer Matrix console

Gravity Well (GW) does about 1k kinetic damage.

Normal buffs refers to Scramble Fighters and Dampen Energy Signature, and they are used at every available chance. The normal buffs column are probably the best results to go by for a flight deck carrier or strike escort that has pets as an afterthought.

NameTypeNormal BuffsSADCANormal Buffs + GWSAD + GWCA + GW
Elite Plesh Brek FrigatesFrigate258152566024266269243141028287
Elite Bleth Choas FightersFighter198542521025484270153112027573
Elite Mirror Universe ShuttleFighter152171777715777201642057417183
Elite Aeon TimeshipsFighter145831794113354148041845715274
Elite Class F ShuttlecraftFighter123121348511460135711748115240
Elite Delta FlyersLarge Fighter122351176311418153201706416135
Elite Obelisk SwarmersFighter121721292514081169171719214167
Elite Class C ShuttlecraftFighter114821305511481154591950216779
Elite Suliban Veil FightersFighter114721456311590145201695614025
Elite Peregrine FightersFighter11326999510551118961649412377
Elite Scorpion FightersFighter112601336410651135471623417507
Elite Jem'hadar Vanguard GunboatsFrigate1110111279112090*0*0*
Elite Jem'hadar FightersFighter110631238611814121621640813347
Elite Jem'hadar Attack ShipFrigate1089410838101900*0*0*
Normal Delta FlyersLarge Fighter1040082229693112471170014247
Elite Tholian Widow FightersFighter9629110398576115341382112735
Advanced Jem'hadar FightersFighter8285265488701120084078613509
Advanced Peregrine FightersFighter8044218347743121902613511190
Elite Tactical FlyersFighter746612668929893961266811614
Elite Callisto FrigatesFrigate744463487785114581990918516
Normal Yukawa FrigatesFrigate720790077316108421246613328
Advanced Yukawa FrigatesFrigate704585776418109681350011706
Normal Peregrine FightersFighter702318905647396062633910951
Elite Yukawa FrigatesFrigate46590**46777966769111303

*Jem'hadar Dreadnought Carrier (T5) couldn't use GW3.

**I gave up here, it was all taking far too long with everything heading off to the four corners of the map. It was obvious how useless the Elite Yukawa frigates were here.

Top 5 hangar pets - Normal buffs

  1. Elite Plesh Brek Frigates

  2. Elite Bleth Choas Fighters

  3. Elite Mirror Universe Shuttle

  4. Elite Aeon Timeships

  5. Elite Class F Shuttlecraft

Top 5 hangar pets - SAD

  1. Advanced Jem'hadar Fighters

  2. Elite Plesh Brek Frigates

  3. Elite Bleth Choas Fighters

  4. Advanced Peregrine Fighters

  5. Elite Aeon Timeships

Top 5 hangar pets - CA

  1. Elite Bleth Choas Fighters

  2. Elite Plesh Brek Frigates

  3. Elite Mirror Universe Shuttle

  4. Elite Obelisk Swarmers

  5. Elite Aeon Timeships

Top 5 hangar pets - Normal Buffs + GW

  1. Elite Bleth Choas Fighters

  2. Elite Plesh Brek Frigates

  3. Elite Mirror Universe Shuttle

  4. Elite Obelisk Swarmers

  5. Elite Class C Shuttle

Top 5 hangar pets - SAD + GW

  1. Advanced Jem'hadar Fighters

  2. Elite Plesh Brek Frigates

  3. Elite Bleth Choas Fighters

  4. Advanced Peregrine Fighters

  5. Elite Mirror Universe Shuttle

Top 5 hangar pets - CA + GW

  1. Elite Plesh Brek Frigates

  2. Elite Bleth Choas Fighters

  3. Elite Callisto Frigates

  4. Elite Scorpion Fighters

  5. Elite Mirror Universe Shuttle

Worst hangar pet (so far) - Elite Yukawa Frigates

Some notes:-

  • Results for pets that use tachyon beam should be taken with a pinch of salt. I will say though that the Breen frigates are pretty awesome.

  • That said, fighters are just better for the most part. They're more responsive, more manoeuvrable and will usually add up to more weapons than if you used a frigate.

  • Breen pets sometimes seem to do whatever they want. They will sometimes fire at their nearest target rather than shoot the one you've selected.

  • Honestly, the Advanced Jem'hadar fighters have amazing DPS with SAD. That result wasn't an anomaly, I actually tested that 6 times to make sure.

  • Most frigate pets just don't have the turnrate to deal with forward arc weapons. Just look at how the Yukawa frigate DPS is affected when each beam away is switched for a dual beam bank (Advanced gets an Omni in the aft, so it sort of regains some DPS thanks to that). It's rather hilarious how the normal ec store Yukawa frigates are much better than the elite version because of this. Cannon using frigates will sometimes spend half the time only firing their turret at the target.

  • There's very little reason to get Elite Breen frigates, all you get over the advanced ones is the energy dissipater which hardly ever fires.

  • Elite Jem'hadar gunboats have beam overload despite description.

  • Elite Obelisk Swarmers do not appear to be affected by SAD.

  • Frigates will sometimes zoom off and do nothing for a few seconds. This seems to only affect frigates that use dual cannons.

  • Unless you're doing a TFO with unshielded targets (such as ISA or KSA), abilities that do bleedthrough damage is a huge plus since most of the time pets will be attacking a shield facing. Of the top 7, 4 use transphasic torpedoes with an obelisk swarmer dealing 5-6k dmg through shields per torp (12 x 5k = 60k). Bad for players, okay for pets.

  • For most pets concentrate firepower makes little to no difference to their overall DPS.

Sometime in the future I'll try to test some of the other remaining hangar pets, especially the ones requiring lobi carriers.

Edit: Added another note regarding shield penetrating damage.

Edit 2: Added Normal Peregrine Fighters for budget Akira builds and added Normal Delta Flyers.


r/stobuilds • • Apr 17 '21 Bravo

Contains Math Agility Mechanics 1: Turn Rate

87 Upvotes

Sometimes you feel the need, the need . . . for speed. To turn and burn. To make hackneyed fighter jet movie references. You get the idea. Unfortunately, you can’t invert in this game outside of Rock and Roll. However, after what seems like an eternity, we’ve unlocked the equations for speed and turn courtesy of a 3-man team of /u/jayiie, myself /u/eph289, and /u/tilorfire27 that’s appropriately abbreviated JET.

One would think speed and turn would be comparatively easy to derive. There’s skill, power, engine type/mark, % increases, and flat increases. Well, I made that assumption and let’s just say it was seriously wrong because not all speed/turn rate boosts are created equally. Hundreds of data points sampled across multiple accounts and multiple ships later, we have finally arrived at some answers.

Borticus was asked about speed and turn on stream last week and teased us by saying there’s about 13 variables involved, but didn’t give the actual answer aside from “it works.” Well, despite the lack of transparency in STO's systems, we were still able to empirically determine the formula for turn rate. We’ve also mostly solved the speed equations but eh... they're more complicated and we're still working on it. The formula for that is very finicky but don’t underestimate three nerdy bois and a lot of spreadsheets.

Before we get started, if you’re afraid of math, skip the next couple sections. Also, if you’re here to post some shallow statement about how the Competitive Engines solve any and all speed/turn issues for any ship, go ahead and close this tab. Posting in-depth equations and reverse-engineering of this game is a major focus of /r/stobuilds and if you don’t care, that’s fine, but we’re here to understand the game beyond parroting conventional wisdom.

This post is the first of two parts and will cover turn rate.

Turn Rate

Turn ended up being the easier of the two to solve, taking us only a couple of weeks to derive the full equation. Turn is measured in degrees per second, representing how quickly your ship turns. Also worth noting is that turn drops off appreciably below 25% throttle down (linearly based on your ship’s base turn rate) to just

base turn of 3 + approximately 0.075 * (base turn rate term -3) at 0 thrusters 

This of course changes if your engine has [Aux] mods, but tbh, it has limited practical value so after hammering at it for another week, we decided that was close enough. The base turn rate term is NOT the base turn of 3 that every ship has even without an engine, it’s modified per the equation below. Before we get to that equation though, let’s define the eight inputs for the equation:

  • Base Turn Rate is the base turn rate of the ship. This is usually in the Fandom (formerly Gamepedia) wiki or the shipyard vendor.

  • Endeavor % represents your Turn Rate % from endeavors. This is NOT the same as other % turn changes. Keep note of that for the future.

  • Skill represents the Impulse Expertise skill rating

  • % turn rate includes all boosts that include +__% turn rate (but NOT endeavors or turn mods)

  • Turn decreases are fairly rare in terms of being applied to the player. The main reason we were curious about this is for the case of Defensive Configuration on full Temporal ships. This is NOT treated as a negative % turn rate boost.

  • Engine Power is the current engine power level

  • Turn mods represent the number of turn modifiers in the engine. An Epic mod of [Spd/Turn] counts as 2 turn mods and 2 speed mods.

  • Final mods present final + ___ turn rate modifiers. The most common example is Emergency Power to Engines.

The Turn Equation

The equation for turn is:

Turn Rate =Base Turn Rate*(1+[Endeavor %]*(10/6)+[Skill]*0.004+[%Turn])/(1+turn decreases)+(Base Turn Rate - 3)*(Engine [Power]/100+[#TurnMods]*0.1)/(1+turn decreases)+FinalMods

This has been proven accurate to within 0.3 degrees/second for a wide variety of ships and setups. The first term

Base Turn Rate*(1+[Endeavor %]*(10/6)+[Skill]*0.004+[%Turn])/(1+turn decreases) 

is what we’re referencing in the % throttle section.

Turn Findings

  • Turn rate endeavors are really good, as each % turn rate from endeavors is worth 1.66x a regular % turn rate increase from something like a console or set bonus. This is particularly nice as there’s no real opportunity cost for taking these (eventually). They also affect your base turn rate, which means that they modify your turn rate even (hilariously) with no engine equipped.

  • Each turn rate endeavor is worth about 4 points of skill.

  • That said, 15 skill points end up not contributing very much. On a ship with 6 or 9 base turn rate, ~50 engine power, and 123 skill from other sources and EPtE 1, 15 skill was worth less than 1 degree per second. On a 16 turn rate ship with 35 engine power and the same skill, 15 skill was worth about 1 degree per second. 35 skill points ends up having more of an influence, but for anyone considering taking Advanced Impulse Expertise, you should at least know what you’re getting into.

  • Likewise, engine power is not a strong contributor to turn rate. Adding 20 engine power on a 7.5 base turn rate cruiser with that same 123 skill, EPtE 1, and 55 power already was an increase of about 1 degree/second.

  • Thus, depending on your ship, you can think of either 20 engine power or 20 skill as roughly 1-2 degree/second turn rate.

  • Base turn rate has a huge influence on your turn rate. Doubling the base more than doubles the final turn rate of the ship.

  • Turn mods only affect the (base turn - 3) term, so they're not nearly as good.

  • Engine type (Combat, Hyper, Impulse), engine mark, and impulse modifier don’t contribute to turn rate

  • The strength of Evasive Maneuvers increases directly with skill such that each point in Impulse Expertise increases the speed and turn rate boost from Evasive Maneuvers by 1%.

Final thoughts

Stay tuned for part 2, where we’ll talk about flight speed, a much more treacherous equation and post some overall conclusions and analysis (and yes, we’ll cover the Competitive Engines). Leave us comments and questions below and we’ll do our best to answer.

If you liked this post, check out my toolbox for other topics like Exotic builds, Torpedo analysis, and build examples.


r/stobuilds • • Mar 04 '21

Guide The Not So Budget Budget Build For Cannon Pew Pew Enthusiasts

87 Upvotes

Buckle up captains, this is going to be a long one. Please excuse the wall of text the size of the Enterprise J.

I'd like to make it clear that this build is not the end goal, this is a middle-of-the-road starting point designed to get new players or players who have yet to really jump into something going. This is for people willing to grind or spend some money to get into the chase. This is not your typical budget build, it is a spenders budget build. A one-time leap to set you up for success. While this is something perfectly capable of being accomplished by grinding Dil to Zen, or for free, this is the quick way to jump into the deep end of the pool, so let's get started.

It should also be noted that you don't need to spend anything on T6's or anything using money to be successful, as long as you have the fundamentals of building down you will be fine.

Preface: This post is all about cannons, while two of the traits (Calm Before the Storm and Emergency Weapons Cycle) can be used for a basic FAW build if you grab Entwined Tactical Matrices instead of Withering Barrage, this is not going to address that. This is for those of you who want to rain fire down on the galaxy. This guide is primarily meant for PC but can be used by console players as well, though there will be no zen bonus for console. For console players, I would recommend buying during a zen discount, and the amount of EC from your leftover zen usage will vary from this. You will also have to get domino from the phoenix prize pack.

The setting: Your living room

What’s going on: You’ve just watched Star Trek: First Contact, you’ve rewound the first battle scene 27 times, you’ve heard Worf say your favorite line in all of Star Trek 27 times, and you’re contemplating watching it until your brain melts.

After some deep thought, you’ve decided that you’re tired of floundering around on Star Trek Online in your T5 without a single T6 ship. You had some IRL stuff going on as of late, so you’ve missed the KDF recruit event that gives out a T6 and you missed too much of the anniversary to get the Temer. But alas, you have a level 65 pure KDF character that has granted you faction unlock, and maybe even have some reps started, so all of your space barbie dreams can come true. You might have missed some events, but that’s okay. 

You’ve been thinking about this for a while now and you’re prepared.

You’ve saved up for a bit and you’re ready to build your own monster build and join the DPS chase you've heard so much about, but you don’t really know where to start and your wallet is about to burn through sixteen layers of neutronium if you don’t do something with the money you’ve saved up. 

That’s where this comes in. You can find moderate success in STO without spending a single dollar, and rolling around in a T5, but this is for those of you who are okay with throwing a little bit of money at the game to set yourself up for the long haul successfully. It’s also for those of you who absolutely cannot live without cannons. Cannon Enthusiasts you might say. 

So let’s begin by saying that this build is going to cost, eh, around $105-130 USD at most depending on how you do this and I'm not accounting for tax so maybe a tiny bit over, but that’s okay because it doesn’t have to be done all at once. I know, sticker shock, but it's not as bad as it sounds. You can do this in one splurge, or over time like many of your fellow captains do, or you can grind it for free, it'll just take longer.

I like to think of it as buying a couple of games, except the only game I play is STO, so that 60-65 bucks per game just goes into it instead. You’re not gonna worry about buying any lobi, lockbox, or promo ships, or lobi consoles. Not right now. You don’t need any of that to build an extremely powerful DEW build and have fun doing it. Sure, the traits and consoles for some of those are nice, and they can help when you’re really pushing some DPS, but it’s not like any of them are must-have items to complete content. And completing content is the goal for beginners. Those items are things to work towards later down the line when you know what you're doing with them and have the resources to buy them. 

Let's clear a few of the terms in this post up

  • DEW = Directed Energy Weapons 

  • DHC = Dual Heavy Cannon

  • DECS = Deflector/Impulse Engines/Warp or Singularity Core/Shield

  • CDR = Cooldown reduction

Things you’ll need

I highly recommend you do this when a charge bonus is going on if you can wait, thank me later. The extra zen will come in handy. In a perfect world you would buy zen during one, and then buy your ships when they’re discounted later in the year, but that’s a lot to ask, so it’s okay if you don’t. I know that kind of wallet would burn through my pocket faster than Data hacking into a PADD, so I won't fault you for buying immediately rather than waiting, but waiting will give you so much more room for resources.

  • Epic Games Starter Pack: Gives you a T6 token AND an epic Phoenix token to use on Domino ( This beautiful little console is good enough to go on pretty much any DEW build you can fit it on.) The haste and damage boost give us a bit more bite, and the damage boost lasts for 30 seconds. You’ll use the T6 token for one of the two ships below, either the Morrigu or the Ghemor.

SPECIAL NOTE: As of right now you can no longer link non-Epic Games accounts to STO, so you will need an existing account with them already. This problem will add another $30 to your total and will remove Domino from the equation for now. This is not the end of the world, but it is an important piece, which sucks. For now, you will utilize another fill piece from the flex list below, for now, I’ll recommend that piece be the M6 because it is the most accessible.

  • The Klingon Defense Force Elite Starter Pack - 2000 Zen (This will give you Withering Barrage, a staple trait for cannons that extends your firing mode length, and a Kor to fly around, and who doesn’t want to fly a Kor? True warriors know the power of space barbie. Plus, we want some variety in what we have available to fly.)

  • T6 Morrigu - 3000 Zen: We want this for its trait, which is a staple for DEW. Since it’s a decent enough platform to fly around in, has a cloak, and I like the seating better than the Arbiter, and the look better than the Kurak, this is what we’re going with in the build below. Its trait, Emergency Weapons Cycle, will reduce our weapon cost and also give us quite a bit of haste, which I will explain farther down. Plus, it’s the big sister of the Valdore, RIP Data. 

  • It should be noted that this can mostly be transferred to any of those ships with some creative changes to bridge seating.

  • T6 Cardassian Intel Flight-Deck Carrier - 3000 Zen: We want this for its trait as well, but it’s a nice ship to fly should you decide to. Calm Before the Storm will give us haste, and a lot of it, on top of that, it’ll give us some damage resistance, which is nice, although not the main reason we want it. We want it for the haste.

Haste is love, haste is life.

The following section on haste is brought to you by /u/AlphatheWhite

We like haste because it lets us shoot faster. When we shoot faster, we get more shots per period of time. This means we can deal the damage that we’ve stacked with bonuses (firing mode, buffs, clickies and whatnot) more often, which leads to...you guessed it, more DPS. 

So let's talk about how haste and damage get along briefly without getting into the different categories, because that’s work for another post, and you can read all about the different damage categories and the math behind it on the subreddit.

If you multiply your damage by all your added-up bonuses, you get a bunch of extra damage. Adding more of the same bonus just adds another chunk of the same. But, if you have a bonus that multiplies against everything, that means that it's not just adding chunks to your original damage, it's also adding extra from the extra damage your other bonuses already gave you!

So if your base damage is 400, and you have 100% in bonuses, you'll get 400 more damage. Add another 20% of bonuses, and you get another 20% of 400....80 more.

But with that same scenario, instead of adding 20% more bonuses, add 20% haste, which multiplies as I said above. It now gives you 80 more damage from the base 400....and 20% also of the extra 400! That's another 80! So now your total gain is 160 damage instead of just 80.

This is how builds get leveraged into stupidly high amounts of damage: by stacking the right bonuses against each other.

Okay. Breathe. The brief math adventure is over (for an in depth discussion see here).

Traits

Back to business. We’ve spent around $85-$90 and we’re pretty much set on the starship trait front and the ships we care about. The rest of our money is going to be spent on master keys or promo boxes. We have about 20-50 dollars left, and hopefully some extra zen from a charge bonus, so we have enough for about 2000 zen minimum give or take, possibly more. That’s enough to get what we need in keys (when there is a keyring pack only) or promo packs during a promo event to sell for EC. Do not open boxes with these keys, or promo boxes, as tempting as they are, the EC they are worth is the most important thing here. You’re going to want the EC to pick up the personal traits and some consoles that are listed below. If you did this during a charge bonus, you should be sitting pretty with a decent amount of extra EC on hand to pick up some extra things I will list later.

So let's get down to business with the building part of this. I have chosen a Romulan Alien Tactical officer because Tac officers are just kinda the best at whatever they want to do, and Romulan because I just really really enjoy seeing stupid high crit stats.(The crit stats are nice but any race is fine, don't let someone tell you that you HAVE to play a certain race to be successful, Romulans are ideal, but they don't rule the galaxy). (It should also be noted that you can succeed no matter what captain career you choose).

I chose a Romulan Alien for the extra trait slot granted to Alien species. That being said, this will work for any career, and any race outside of the use of the personal trait: A Good Day to Die, which is a Tac only trait.

You'll be picking up these things from the exchange with the EC you made from your extra zen to start:

There are some traits I will list at the end that you may wish to pick up if you have the EC, but are likely too expensive for the amount of EC you will have (you should have 100m give or take). (Please keep in mind this may change with the market as this post ages).

The most important of that bunch are: Self-Modulating Fire, A Good Day to Die, and Inspirational Leader.

Next up are the consoles you'll want to pick up from the exchange.

  • Approaching Agony: ( crit & phaser support, also not a terrible clicky on a boss target since it's a debuff)

  • Hostile Acquisition: (perhaps a little acc overflow with your ale captain? It's also not a terrible click on a boss target that's alive longer than 5 seconds. It also has a teeny bit of control which will buff the personal trait Fragment of AI Tech if you manage to snag it. (This may eventually be pushed out when or if you have the right lobi equipment.)

Weapons

First and foremost, erase the existence of single cannons from your mind, just pretend they don't exist or that they live in a deep dark hole that nobody visits.

We're using phaser because it has the most accessible support. Should you wish to stay canon, there are disruptor options and plasma options for this build, but the plasma option is somewhat less accessible, and the disruptor is slightly more of a pain than phaser. Should you choose to go either of those routes you will still be able to be successful. I've listed the important stuff below, just follow the template outside of this.

I have the quantum phase torpedo listed because it's free, and not the worst thing in the world, but it will immediately be pushed out by the Dark Matter Torpedo when you have access to it. Because of the bridge seating for this ship I've opted to keep a torp, and because they're fun. You could run all cannons, but that choice is up to you and whether you want to waste a bridge slot on a filler ability in place of torp spread.

The phaser quad cannons come from the T4 Sao Paulo which you can grab with dilithium, you can supplement with a regular DHC while you're grinding for it. It isn't a must-have, but the quad cannons are quite powerful.

The Prolonged Engagement DHC is there because it's a decently easy grab from the phoenix packs and it's good until you're compressing your runs too much for it to stack itself. If you get to the point where that's the case it can be replaced with a regular DHC.

Eventually you'll add the Terran Taskforce Phaser DHC to your rotation when your rep is high enough (and place it first in your firing order, so farthest left of all your cannons)

We like the Trilithium 2pc because it gives us some haste, and the console is nice for our power levels and it gives us +15 flight speed. You can get this from the mission "Beyond the Nexus".

Eventually, if you feel like it and have gathered the resources for it, you can also replace your standard wide-arc with the wide-arc phase cannons from the lobi store, but it's not a necessary grab.

I fully expect you to just run regular DHC's until you can get these things, and that is perfectly fine.

We aren't going to get into weapon modifiers any deeper than this: any mix of critD/DMG rolls on your weapons is fine. Don't pick Acc or CritH and you're golden. What specific mix is best for you is contextual and too math oriented for me to discuss without melting my brain. That's why I have other people to do that for me on the subreddit. Thank you math nerds of STOBuilds, I appreciate you.

Equipment

Now we get into the DECS

  • Deflector: Colony Deflector (Elite Fleet Intervention Protomatter Deflector), easy peasy lemon squeezy, this deflector is found on pretty much any decent build you find because simply put, it's the best for DEW, and kinetics. (Not talking about scitorp here, but still a decent slot there as well). It's cheap, and should be one of the first things you grab.

  • Engines: Braydon are free and easy to get from the mission "Of Signs and Portents", they will keep you going until you can grab your innervated comp engines. When you get your innervated engines, the zoomies can begin.

  • Core: Make sure to grab the Elite Fleet Thoron-Infused Singularity Core, weapon cost reduction makes us happy. You can replace this with the discovery core if you feel squishy and if you're already in possession of the discovery shield, the discovery 2pc is a powerful survival tool. If you're flying a ship that requires a warp core, grab the Elite Fleet Plasma Integrated Warp Core with AMP W->A

  • Shield: Crystal Regenerative Shield Matrix from Para Pacem. It's the best free shield you can get your hands on. Tilly's Review Pending Modified Shield is your endgame. It's basically the best shield in the game for its 2pc, and the debuff (extra damage to shields) and general stats. The shield you use for leveling or just grinding for marks isn't super important as long as you have one. If you don't feel like grabbing the one I've listed you could roll with the Bajor, or the Imperial Rift, it doesn't matter much. We want to focus on getting our floaties (The disco shield and core/Spire core and Singularity core I listed above) before jumping into the pool.

Consoles

  • Tac slots: Locators: if you have exploiters, it's fine, either works, but locators are preferred. Long story short, critD weapon mods exist, so taking the critH here is usually the better option, but it's not quite so simple in some cases (like if you're reaching crit cap). However, I don't have the room to explain that, and there are several other posts that already deal with the merits of that conversation.

Also, I am going to scream this from the rooftops: TAC CONSOLES ARE THE ONLY THING THAT BELONG IN TAC SLOTS ON DEW BUILDS. That space is PRECIOUS.

  • Already discussed the Tril 2pc.

  • Assimilated module: This is from Omega reputation and has some crit, some weapon power, and some control, so it's a decent slot here considering we don't have much to throw onto this. Control is nice if you have Fragment of AI Tech, which is something you can grab at a later time if you have the EC for it when you've finished this, it's a nice little damage boost basically for free (outside of the trait slot).

  • Quantum Phase Converter and Ordnance Accelerator: phaser support, from the mission "Sunrise" and Gamma reputation respectively.

  • Lorca's Custom Fire Controls: dope tac console, some critH, some shield pen, what's not to like, but would definitely move to the universal slot if you T6X, and put another locator on. Either way. The 2pc is also pretty sweet, and you'll have it with the torp slotted.

Making a new note as of 10/8/21 because apparently it was eaten by Reddit editor: the gamma turret is also an option for rear.

Bridge: Self-explanatory.

  • Hazard Emitters: for if you need a little heal (this will be replaced later on by tractor beam as an unconventional systems proc once you actually have some clicky consoles that matter or aren't feeling squishy)

  • Intel team: for some invisible fun/survivability aside from your cloak. When the NPC's have had enough of you, this might be your saving grace.

  • Emergency Power to Engines: to pair with the Emergency Conn Holo from Phoenix Prize Pack, which will cool down your evasive maneuvers.

  • Emergency Power to Weapons: to proc EWC, plus more weapon power and a nice damage boost, and you're gonna need it.

  • Attack Pattern Beta: Debuff, hooray!

  • Override Subsystem Safeties: MOOOOOOOORE POWER, the offline is negligible with a drainx node in the skill tree.

  • Aux 2 Batt: CDR

  • Beam Overload: This is an on demand comp proc, but if you get to the point where running something like the altamid 3pc makes sense, then it's also nice for the omni.

  • Cannon Rapid Fire: This is a hybrid bridge, we have rapid fire on here for some of the harder targets you may face, and because the bridge space is a little bit limiting.

  • Cannon Scatter Volley: This is your primary firing mode.

  • Torpedo Spread: You have a torp and too much tac bridge space, and torpedos are pretty.

  • Kemocite: Debuff and filler. Does a little bit of damage, but it's not a primary source.

I would also like to to link an informative post from /u/Sizer714 on general ship building for you to read, it has pretty much everything you need to know about the basics. The tone might come off a little strong, but I recommend you read it in jest and absorb the information. I highly recommend it.

Make sure to do the Spectres mission arc to gain access to the Alhana system so you can craft Deuterium Surplus. These are a nice little speed boost that will help you out when you need to scoot.

Lastly, if you find yourself with the 70+ million EC or more it may take you to get Intelligence Agent Attaché and unconventional systems, make sure to grab those, IAA will come in handy immediately, and unconventional systems will come in handy when you've got more clicks. Fragment of AI Tech is also another handy little trait that boosts damage based on the amount of control you have.


Build

Now that we've covered that, lets move on.

Let's look at Mr. Devito and his beautiful ship, just make sure you don't mention the fact that all he's wearing is a robe. He likes to lounge around in his ready room when he's not annihilating entire species or asking the questions we all need answers to.

I've also listed this as the fleet version of the Morrigu (the Mogai) because that's what you're going to want to end up in if you stay with the Morrigu.

Captain Details

Captain Name D'anny Devito  
Captain Career Tactical  
Captain Faction KDF 
Captain Race Romulan Alien  
Captain's Outfit A robe and Romulan ale  
Primary Specialization Intelligence  
Secondary Specialization Strategist  

The Skill tree I have provided is a pretty generalized skill tree that allows you to do pretty much anything you want with build types. If you wanna run torps, you can, if you wanna build a science boat, go for it. There are some points you can switch around when you know what you're doing, but you'll likely see this or a very similar version of this on most builds. Note to self: If someone tells you to use the sci ult as a skill tree, stop listening to them, the ultimate caps your critH at 50 and nobody wants that. The tac ultimate is just straight up better, it benefits both you and your team rather than just you. Helping your team helps you, make sure you take it.

Space Skill Tree

Rank Engineering  Science  Tactical  
Lieutenant  Advanced Hull Capacity   Advanced Energy Weapon Training Advanced Projectile Weapon Training 
Lt. Commander Improved Electro-Plasma System Flow Improved Impulse Expertise Improved Control Expertise Drain Expertise Advanced Targeting Expertise  
   Control Amplification    
Commander Hull Plating    Advanced Weapon Amplification Advanced Weapon Specialization 
Captain  Offensive Subsystem Tuning Improved Exotic Particle Generator Advanced Long Range Targeting Sensors Advanced Hull Penetration Advanced Shield Weakening 
Admiral Warp Core Potential    Coordination Protocols Advanced Tactical Readiness 
     Defensive Coordination  
     Offensive Coordination  
0 Points Left 10  9  27  

Space Skill Unlocks

Purchases Engineering Science Tactical 
2 Mine Dispersal Pattern Beta III Tactical Team III Cannon Rapid Fire III 
5    
7 Attack Pattern Omega III Mine Dispersal Pattern Alpha III Torpedo High Yield III 
10    
12   Cannon Scatter Volley III 
15    
17   Torpedo Spread III 
20    
24 (Ultimate)    
25 (1st Ultimate Enhancer)    
26 (2nd Ultimate Enhancer)    
27 (3rd Ultimate Enhancer)    

Ship Loadout: Fleet Mogai Heavy Warbird

Slot Item Goal Items: These are what you want to have eventually, it may take a long time to grind, but these items are worth it. These items also may be exceedingly expensive, but it's not the end of the world if you don't have them, they're just nice to have.
Fore Weapon 1 Quantum Phase Torpedo  Dark Matter Torpedo (Discovery Reputation)
Fore Weapon 2 Phaser Quad Cannons  
Fore Weapon 3 Prolonged Engagement Phaser Dual Cannons  
Fore Weapon 4 Wide Arc Phaser Dual Heavy Cannons  
Aft Weapon 1 Trilithium-Enhanced Phaser Turret 
Aft Weapon 2 Phaser Turret 
Aft Weapon 3 Phaser Turret 
  Flex Aft Weapons: Altamid Modified Kelvin Torpedo/Omni I know what you're thinking, why is he mixing energy types ? The altamid 3pc is 100% haste for 12 seconds, however, it isn't something that's going to outdo an aft full of turrets until you're reaaaally compressing your run times. When you get there, it fits, until then, stick with turrets.
Deflector Elite Fleet Intervention Protomatter Deflector 
Impulse Engines Braydon Reconnaissance Hyper-Impulse Engines  Prevailing Innervated Impulse Engines (Competitive Reputation)
Singularity Core Elite Fleet Thoron Infused Singularity CoreMycelial Harmonic Singularity Core for ships that require singularity cores / Mycelial Harmonic Antimatter Core from the Discovery reputation for ships that require warp cores. The discovery set pieces are good for when you're feeling squishy, especially with the 2pc. Elite Fleet Plasma Integrated Warp Core with AMP W->A if on a ship that requires a warp core if you want some weapons cost reduction.
Shields Regenerative Crystal Shield Matrix  Tilly's Review-Pending Modified Shield (Discovery Reputation)
  
4 Engineering Consoles Console - Engineering - Reinforced Armaments 
 Console - Universal - D.O.M.I.N.O. 
 Console - Universal - Quantum Phase Converter 
 Console - Universal - Ordnance Accelerator 
 Console - Universal - Assimilated Module Dynamic Power Redistributor Module: Simply put it's one of the best consoles in the game. Whether used for survivability or damage it's awesome. That being said, it will not make or break your build if you don't have one, it's just a nice tool to have in your toolbox. Your EC wallet will hate you for getting this.
  
2 Science Consoles Console - Universal - Approaching Agony 
 Console - Universal - Hostile Acquisition Point Defense Bombardment Warhead This makes the 2pc with the DPRM listed above and is a nice console overall. It will also hurt your EC wallet, or your actual wallet if you buy the Legendary bundle that includes the NX.
  Flex Consoles: Bioneural Infusion Circuits/Altamid modified Swarm Processor (both technically for crit, altamid likely for its 3pc, but still a good solo console.) This is the lobi stuff I said you could look at later down the line.
M6 Tactical Computer: Haste, damage bonus. Not super important to grab until you know what you're doing and your runs are relatively short.
5 Tactical Consoles Console - Tactical - Vulnerability Locator 
 Console - Tactical - Vulnerability Locator 
 Console - Tactical - Vulnerability Locator 
 Console - Tactical - Vulnerability Locator 
 Lorca's Custom Fire Controls
  Another locator here with T6X

Officer Details

Bridge Officers Power Goal Bridge Setup
Commander Tactical Beam Array: Overload I  
 Attack Pattern Beta I  
 Cannon: Rapid Fire II  
 Cannon: Scatter Volley III  
  
Lt. Commander Universal-Intelligence Intelligence Team I  If you're feeling less squishy, you can switch this to viral impulse burst for another unconventional systems proc, but I would only use that with the borg.
 Auxiliary to Battery I  Aux to batt: for your CDR, green techs will do okay for a little while you grind for blues and purples until you have all purples. On some ships with the room for it, photonic officer can be used as a CDR method as well, especially if you don't have techs, or there's not enough room for a full aux to batt setup.
 Override Subsystem Safeties III  
  
Lt. Commander Engineering Emergency Power to Engines I  
 Auxiliary to Battery I  
 Emergency Power to Weapons III  
  
Lieutenant Tactical Kemocite-Laced Weaponry I  
 Torpedo: Spread II  
  
Ensign Science Hazard Emitters I  Tractor beam when you're able to grab unconventional systems.
  

Traits & Duty Officers

Trait Name Description Goal Traits and Duty Officers
Personal Space Traits Cannon Training Increases Damage from your cannons
 Self-Modulating Fire You gain a Shield Penetration buff for your weapons when landing a critical hit on your target. May occur once every 45 seconds. 
 A Good Day to Die Wooo damage
 Inspirational Leader  Stat boosts are fun
 Fresh From R&R  reduces team abilities minimum global cooldown to 10 seconds. (this is for your intel team)Unconventional Systems: This is going to depend on you, whether you think intel team is still necessary for you as a survival tool. If you think you don't need it you can add an unconventional systems proc in the form of viral impulse burst. I don't recommend using that on non-borg unless you want them zipping around.
 Context is for Kings  damage boost
 Terran Targeting Systems +Crit Severity
 Adaptive Offense (space) crit
 Fleet Coordinator Yay more free damage
 Operative Increases Critical Chance and Critical Severity. You have it, why not use it? You can replace this later.Intelligence Agent Attaché: Extremely useful, extremely expensive. Brings captain abilities to global cooldown if you crit enough, which isn't hard.
   
Starship Traits Withering Barrage While Withering Barrage trait is equipped, the duration of your Cannon: Scatter Volley is increased. 
 Emergency Weapon Cycle - While this starship trait is active, using Emergency Power to Weapons will also reduce weapon power cost and increase your weapon fire rate moderately. 
 Calm Before the Storm Haste every 20 seconds, takes 20 seconds to charge up.
Space Reputation Traits Advanced Targeting SystemsSlightly increases critical severity in space combat. 
 Precision Increases your Critical Hit Chance in space combat. 
 Tyler's Duality +Critical Chance based on Hull Capacity 
 Energy Refrequencer Heals Hull when Dealing Damage. You're probably squishy, so this won't hurt. It can be pushed out later.
 Magnified Firepower +All Weapon Damage. Yay more damage!
   
Duty Officers Technician [SP] Recharge of bridge officer abilities reduced after Auxiliary to Battery 
 Technician [SP] Recharge of bridge officer abilities reduced after Auxiliary to Battery 
 Technician [SP] Recharge of bridge officer abilities reduced after Auxiliary to Battery 
 Conn Officer [SP] Recharges Evasive Maneuvers when Emergency Power to Engines is activated. The key to zoom zoom. This is the Emergency Conn Hologram from the Phoenix Prize Pack.
  FLEX: Borg doffs, 22 and 27 of 47 which are absurdly expensive (not kidding, it's nuts). Or crit doffs (Energy Weapon Officers). These can fill out the last two slots. Either of these are probably gonna cost some EC. 

These are flex traits, all of these are decent traits that could fit into this build and serve you well.

  • Strike from the Shadows: Crit, Placate, and a damage boost, this is a great trait and probably the first one I would recommend of this list.

  • Heart of Sol: Haste and a damage bonus, you can use this if you're a regular fed, don't bother otherwise unless you're using the assigned trait damage type since each race has a different one. Thanks, cryptic.

  • Super Charged Weapons: Not the worst pick in the world, you have a torp and the bonuses this provides are decent (damage and some crit). This is also more accessible than the rest of the list below.

  • Cold Hearted/Superior Area Denial: Either of these is a good grab if you can get your hands on them, though be prepared for Superior Area Denial to eventually get nerfed/fixed in the pet department, it will still serve as a nice debuff though.

  • Over-powered and Over-gunned: Haste and weapon cost reduction, but also a big ouch for the wallet

  • Terran Goodbye or Weapon Emitter Overdrive: Crit, Crit, and more Crit. Please help my wallet is crying. These two are mind-numbingly expensive.|||


Now let's talk about piloting. Getting used to the zoomies in your brand new Borg Yeeter 9000 with innervated engines is going to take some practice. Positioning and knowing what to activate and when is pretty important. The STOBuilds community is more than happy to help you figure this out, and there are also some great piloting reference videos that can help you figure out how to position yourself in something like ISA/E or HSE.

My personal favorite comes from the one and only /u/MiBWH, who has so kindly allowed me to link his ISA piloting reference video. The pointing and shooting part of using cannons is the easy part, it's how you position yourself that's the hard part. This video is an excellent example of great positioning.

I know, I know, he's in a Juggernaut, there's no way I can do that. That's okay, the point of that video is to show you how to position yourself in the queue, nobody expects you to clear an ISA that fast. We're not talking about tanking in this post either, so don't worry about that either.

If you're having issues with keybinds, there are some posts in the subreddit and folks in the discord who are perfectly willing to help you out.

I hope this post has been informative, and I look forward to seeing the damage you wreak on the borg and the many other enemies you might face.


r/stobuilds • • Nov 22 '22

Guide STOBETTER has a new guide for buying things

86 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am going to keep this brief. With the Event Campaign wrapping up and Black Friday sales approaching, we're seeing a LOT of folks asking "What to buy?" specifically in the context of upgrading their existing build. In other words, they're looking for traits or consoles or gear.

STO has a lot of options and some of them are good, some of them not so much. Since it's hard to tell what's good or not, we made a guide that would point people who are in less-in-the-know in the direction of some good options for either C-store purchases or Event Campaign purchases.

Note that this guide is NOT intended to point people in the direction of their dream ship. We state up front that the first acquisition should generally be the ship you want to fly because Space Barbie is true endgame.

But if you want to upgrade your existing build, we offer a decision-tree based guide that should help individuals based on their general build type and budget options. We call it "Progression."

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1gya5DvmQYx3-egUehL3Dk8bsh9q3lmd-XtloE0mURlg/edit?usp=sharing

We were going to roll this out with our Season 2 Finale, but there's still a few (big) things we're working on for that, so in the mean time, consider this a teaser as it seems the community at large could use a resource like this right now. This will go live on the site whenever the finale is done. The best is yet to come!

Thanks for reading, leave a comment or suggestion below. If your favorite ship trait, console, or gear piece didn't make it on there, it's not necessarily because it's a bad purchase, but it might not be the most impactful compared to other choices at that price point or cheaper.


r/stobuilds • • Jun 16 '23

Contains Math Mathbusters 3: Advanced Engineering IPDM consoles

85 Upvotes

With apologies to the other thread that’s more general and devoted to the wider topic of all the Advanced Consoles as well as the new Advanced Batteries, I want to focus in on the topic of Advanced Engineering Consoles, specifically the Isomagnetic Plasma Distribution Manifolds, and the ramifications of these consoles on a variety of energy builds.

Let me say upfront that this exploration is going to be long, contain lots of math and philosophy, and that I will post short-form conclusions at the end. I will also transcribe it directly onto a STOBETTER page for easier reference (eventually).

Background

The new Isomagnetic Plasma Distribution Manifolds (aka Isomags or IPDMs) are Advanced Engineering consoles introduced in June 2023. They each contribute a standard console modifier, choosing from a pool of ~30 options, along with up to 7.25 current and stacking max weapon power. Btw, this is actually 7.25 power, but the game rounds up to 7.3 on display. This is where the power of these consoles comes into play, for a number of reasons. Just like Locators/Exploiters from the Fleet Spire are basically Energy Tactical consoles with either CrtD or CrtH tacked on, Isomags are basically energy consoles that give weapon power.

Also, since Isomags will displace Engineering Console slots, universal consoles may have to move to Tactical, or be replaced by Bellum Prefire Chambers/Directed Energy Distribution Manifolds, or else Energetic Protomatter Matrix Infusers (aka Colony consoles). I’ll discuss some of those choices below.

Now, if these just gave current weapon power, they wouldn’t be very good, because most good builds have plenty of that, and these are exclusive with Locators/Exploiters, meaning you can’t slot both. Current weapon power is the power in your system that is consumed by firing energy weapons under most firing modes. Energy damage scales off of weapon power even under modes that don’t consume weapon power while firing, like Reroute Reserves to Weapons (RRtW). If Isomags gave current and max weapon power that didn’t stack, they still wouldn’t be that good, because nobody’s trading 8% CrtH for 7.25 max weapon power. In fact, most sources of max power don’t stack, with a few exceptions like OSS and EPS Power Transfer that tend to be limited in duration. However, since these stack, this makes them more useful (and worth stacking). Thus, we need to compare 8-10% CrtH from 4-5 Locators against 29-36.25 current and max power, which is a lot harder to do mentally. This leads into a brief discussion of test methodology

How Stuff Is Tested in STO

In a variety of fields, not just STO or video games in general, there’s a spectrum of ways to test things.

The first one that everyone’s familiar with is experimental testing. Experimental Testing in our context means you go try the new thing, maybe do some comparisons between the new thing and the old thing. Most people who you’d consider influencers and guide contributors fall into this category. They’ll go try the new thing and report how it works. The advantage of experimental testing is that you can go do it “right away,” assuming you have the resources, and strictly speaking there’s a lower burden of knowledge and rigor that’s accepted by the community. “So-and-so said the thing was good” is a powerful endorsement depending on who so-and-so is. It’s easy to do and doesn’t require specialized tools. Sometimes, you just need to try how something works in the game and it doesn’t require math to go do that. For example, do I have enough Engine Power to sustain RRtW for 15 seconds? That’s a great case where it was better to go fly a map or even better yet a semi-controlled environment like Doomsday Device and see how long I could sustain the pew-pew. Many problems are best suited to this approach.

The downside is that the test methodology may be flawed:

  • Performance in STO is a combination of gear, piloting, and in non-solo content, team composition. Did the tester control for piloting by flying the same map more than once? Did they consider team comps? Is that new console really good, or were they flying ISE with a supportive composition and got good numbers with good piloting? Conversely, were they testing a new torp-thing on a channel run with 3 other torpboats and got bad numbers? For this reason, I approach claims made without context or rationale with a healthy dose of skepticism.

  • Depending on if you’re testing a stat-stick or a new damage source, it’s arguable that it’s hard to suss out just how much the new thing did, unless it shows up cleanly in a parse and doesn’t have any other funky interactions. For stuff like the new Isomags, these are stat sticks, not damage sources, so it’s a little harder to assess the direct impact of these consoles besides “number go up, big number good”

The other kind of testing is deterministic testing. In the computer world, deterministic testing means that, given a set of inputs, you get the same output every time. For STO, we’re talking about using a set of equations to directly compute the results in a repeatable, reliable fashion. This allows us to remove variables like piloting and team composition, or at least control for them somewhat. It also allows us to compute an answer without having to farm or spend resources to acquire the thing. If the deterministic test is successful, you can calculate the answer and decide accordingly before investing time/resources to acquire the new shiny.

Since STO’s damage calculations are hard to mentally compute, especially with non-intersecting systems like power and crit, it’s helpful to have a calculation tool. This is one of the things that the STOBETTER team has provided to the community for your use, and it’s called TRINITY. There are of course some problems with the deterministic approach as well:

  • The model may be wrong or incomplete. For example, TRINITY could have an error that materially impacts the outcome. Or, it could be incomplete in substantial ways. TRINITY does not simulate the game and it has limitations. For example, Kemocite’s radiation damage is not accounted for in the tool (yet) and the same with Experimental Weapons. TRINITY doesn’t know how to compute periodic power injections like dumping A2B during RRTW.

  • You’re reliant on someone else’s model and either their results or your understanding of how to use the tool, plus your willingness to crunch numbers on a spreadsheet. TRINITY is moderately complex to fill out. I helped build it and if I’m starting from scratch, it still takes me 20 minutes to fill out a full sheet. We get it, not everybody loves playing Spreadsheet Tool Online. (editor’s note: Is that not what ‘STO’ stands for???!). That’s one of the reasons why the STOBETTER team will go do the math and post results and considerations that we think are broadly applicable so that those of you who don’t love math can benefit from the mathematical answer. We also try to put considerations in there so that we’re posting a wide range of results rather than just for specific scenarios. As someone in our fleet said recently, “this is why I keep you around.” I think it was a compliment.

All that to say, for this analysis, Isomags are stat-sticks that are NOT trivial to acquire. First, you need to complete dozen or so specific Elite TFOs to get enough components for 1, then you need to craft it, roll the mod, which can take up to 30-40 re-rolls per console, then it has to be upgraded. Not cheap. So before I started down that journey, I realized that these were stat-sticks with fairly predictable performance that TRINITY can solve. So I did, because I don’t want to go farm Isomags if they’re not actually better than my existing setup.

TL;DR I used TRINITY for this. If that bothers you, the exit's that way.

Test Results

I did a total of 15 builds/versions of builds in TRINITY, most of which were mine to establish a general rubric and guidelines. Since it does take time to set these up, I hope you’ll forgive my working mostly in my self-interest since I needed to answer this question for myself, but this does cover a broad spectrum of builds. If your build is similar, the results will probably apply to you, but I’m also going to provide a link to all 11 TRINITY sheets so that you can make a copy and tweak it to match yours if the results are a little bit different.

A couple of ground rules:

  • If TRINITY’s calculated value is less than 2% different between two results, I’m going to call that basically “the same”, with a bias towards global stats like CrtH that impact things not directly modeled in TRINITY. I trust the simulation to be accurate within 2%. Less than 2% won’t move the needle for me personally. If you simply must have the most-optimal thing, I’d caution you that it’s a simulation and results aren’t guaranteed or complete.

  • All Spire/Colony/Advanced consoles are assumed to have the mod corresponding to the chosen energy flavor. I.e. a Phaser build is comparing Phaser Isomags to Phaser Locators. Matching Cat1 damage boost to your energy type is the best mod, you just have to roll into it.

  • You can Ctrl+F through the list to find the build type closest to yours. The +X by the console number indicates which consoles slots you can fit more of on this build. I also linked the TRINITY sheets so you can make your own copy and tweak it for your specific build, which should save a fair amount of time.

EDIT: This post now contains results with numbers from TRINITY 1.4

F2P Beam Overload

With apologies to /u/neuro1g I set up his Baby Steps 2 Build in TRINITY, but … frankly it wasn’t Elite capable so I gave it a little oomph, replacing the Drive Train with a more meta set-up (Colony Deflector, Romulan Engines, Fleet Core, Tilly Shield), and basically filled out his weapons and consoles with max Fleet/Rep gear at Mk XV VR / UR. I also gave him Programmable Matter Enhancements and Hull Image Refractors, which should be affordable even for an F2P player. Basically, it’s the limits of F2P on a T5 Assault Cruiser with no rarity upgrades, no C-store/Lobi/Lockbox/Promo/Legendary items. I'm calling it Baby Steps 2.5 and here it is in TRINITY 1.4

The T5 Assault Cruiser is a particularly good candidate for Isomags since it has a measly 2 Tactical console slots after leaving one for Lorca’s Custom Fire Controls.

BuildLocatorsIsomags + UniversalsIsomags + Bellum
Eng/Tac Console Layout
Eng 1Ordnance AcceleratorIsomagIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Reinforced ArmamentsIsomagIsomagIsomag
Eng 3Assimilated ModuleIsomagIsomagIsomag
Eng 4Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomagIsomag
Tac 1Lorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire Controls
Tac 2LocatorOrdnance Accelerator with 2-pieceBellum DEDMColony console
Tac 3LocatorAssimilated ModuleBellum DEDMColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS94445111113115063114012
% Difference17.65%21.83%20.72%

Table formatting brought to you by ExcelToReddit

As you can see, Locators get left in the dust pretty quickly. The difference between the other three setups is pretty minimal and plays more into what you have/care to farm rather than a mathematical difference. For example, I don’t know that the Bellum consoles are worth buying/upgrading for a less than 1% difference between those and colony consoles, especially since colony consoles also help with keeping you alive. Of course if you don’t have access to colony consoles, do you want Bellums for a 2.2% difference over the Assimilated Module and Ordnance Accelerator, which are pretty easy to acquire with dilithium vouchers from completing reputations versus buying Bellums for dil?

The bigger point worth mentioning is the 20% increase in damage from 2 Locators to 4 Isomags regardless of your other options. That said, farming Isomags in such a build is not something I would particularly enjoy doing and where STO will pressure your wallet.

Conclusion: I did not do the same analysis for the Prometheus Escort, but I would be very surprised if 2 Isomags + Lorca’s weren’t better than 3 Locators + Lorca’s. Same thing with FAW vs BO on this ship, it’s probably Isomags. You’ll see why below.

EDITOR's Note: Not much changed between 1.1 and 1.4. Isomags were 17.03-19.72% better in 1.1 and they're 17.65-21.83% in 1.4.

All of the remaining builds are in the 700K-1M DPS range parsed on ISE.

Cmdr Tac + Beam Overload, +1 Locators

Let’s keep going on the Beam Overload track. Next up is my Beam Overload World Razer, which is significantly higher-performing (and costlier!), with a few minor tweaks on consoles compared to what the site has published (i.e. I now have a Phaser Lance). It’s worth noting that ship has 6 beams, 1 torpedo, and 1 turret in the aft, so Bellum Beam consoles are less effective here. It’s also worth noting that this ship’s console layout is 5/3/3/1, so at most we’re comparing 4 Isomags against 5 Locators. TRINITY 1.4

Eng/Tac Console LayoutLocatorsIsomags + BellumIsomags + Colony
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
Eng 1Immolating Phaser LanceIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomag
Eng 3Ordnance AcceleratorIsomagIsomag
Tac 1Lorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire Controls
Tac 2LocatorImmolating Phaser LanceImmolating Phaser Lance
Tac 3LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 4LocatorOrdnance AcceleratorOrdnance Accelerator
Tac 5LocatorBellum BEDMColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS726956756834755584
% Difference4.11%3.94%

Again, the results are clear: 4 Isomags on a Commander Tac ship are beating 5 Locators, even if I keep my universal consoles largely the same for non-damage reasons like Turn Rate or Temp HP. At 3.5-3.8% difference, this is just enough to be what I would call noticeable, so even if there’s a +1 advantage to Locators on a Beam Overload ship, stacking max power is a fairly unsaturated category compared to Cat2/Crit, so Isomags come out ahead.

EDITOR's Note: Not much changed between 1.1 and 1.4. Isomags were 3.52-3.81% better in 1.1 and they're 3.94-4.11% better in 1.4. If anything the argument for Isomags is stronger with TRINITY 1.4

Cmdr Eng/MW + FAW, 1 to 1 replacement

On an offtank FAW build on an Inquiry, where I replaced Locators 1-for-1 with Isomags, the results were similar, with even a greater difference since Locators do not have a numerical advantage over Isomags. You should be able to extrapolate the results to any FAW-using heavy tank build as well since most if not all have equal or greater numbers of Engineering console slots over Tac. On a more supportive tank, I would not use Isomags as they're displacing supportive consoles that benefit the team.

At 7-8% difference this would definitely be noticeable. I did not replace any Universal consoles here since they’re here for utility rather than damage as this is an off-tank build. This particular ship is using 7 beams + 1 torpedo, so there’s no cannons in play and Bellum Directed Energy Manifolds would be good if I wanted to change consoles. That said, if I was playing for pure DPS on this ship, I would slot a turret to use MAS. I think the answer would still be basically the same and colony consoles would likely be the tac console of choice. TRINITY 1.4

Eng/Tac Console LayoutLocatorsIsomags
UniLocatorIsomag
UniLocatorIsomag
Eng 1Immolating Phaser LanceIsomag
Eng 2Ablative Hazard SheildingIsomag
Eng 3Hull Image RefractorsIsomag
Eng 4DOMINODOMINO
Eng 5Tachyon Net DronesTachyon Net Drones
Tac 1LocatorImmolating Phaser Lance
Tac 2LocatorHull Image Refractors
Tac 3LocatorAblative Hazard Shielding
Tac 4Lorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire Controls
1.4 Calculated DPS707583757392
% Difference7.04%

Editor's Note: This changed by less than 1% between 1.1 and 1.4 version of TRINITY. Conclusion the same.

Cmdr Tac + CRF, Locators +2

Okay, how about Cannons? Let’s start with a Cannon Rapid Fire build on an Edison. This one uses the Morphogenic set rather than Lorca’s (site not updated yet) but the principle is similar. With 5 Tac console slots + 1 Universal against 2 Engineering + 1 universal slots, we’re comparing 3 Isomags to 5 Locators, keeping the Morphogenic set. Due to how that set works, I basically have an Omni beam as Beam Overload overwrites CRF for the Morpho weapon, so it’s a 6 cannon, 1 beam, 1 turret ship with a 5/3 weapons layout. TRINITY 1.4

Eng/Tac Console LayoutLocatorsIsomags+BellumIsomags+ColonyIsomags+OA+Colony
UniLocatorIsomagIsomagIsomag
Eng 1Piezo-Electric FocuserIsomagIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomagIsomag
Tac 1MorphogenicMorphogenicMorphogenicMorphogenic
Tac 2LocatorPiezo-Electric FocuserPiezo-Electric FocuserPiezo-Electric Focuser
Tac 3LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 4LocatorBellum PrefireColony consoleOrdnance Accelerator
Tac 5LocatorBellum PrefireColony consoleColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS471266477817474240473199
% Difference1.39%0.63%0.41%

At the end of the day, you can see that the damage values are very, very close for Locators +2, within 2% in the simulation, and we need to acknowledge again that TRINITY does not model things like Kemocite’s damage, Experimental weapons or many damaging console actives, which would benefit from global CrtH more. Per our ground rules, we’re saying 2% or less is basically no difference, and possibly even favors Locators. If you want to go farm up Isomags for such a case, it’s your resources, but I think the math shows relatively low gain from it. The bigger gain might be swapping to colony consoles for more survivability while maintaining damage since the ship has 3 firing modes and is made of paper-thin glass.

In this case, we can speculate that our upper bound is that if # of Locators - # of Isomags = 2, then it’s not worth to run Isomags. We’ll keep exploring that with other firing modes.

EDITOR'S NOTE: Isomags gained 0.5% in 1.4. Also added an additional analysis with 1 Colony console and the Ordnance Accelerator with its 2-piece. Still would prefer Locators for raw damage given the things TRINITY doesn't account for.

Cmdr Tac + CSV, Locators + 2

Let’s stick with cannons and now let’s look at CSV on a Chimesh. This is a 6 cannon ship again, with an experimental weapon and torpedo, 5 tac, 2 eng console layout so similar to what we were seeing with the Edison. TRINITY 1.4

Eng/Tac Console Layout6 Cannons, 5 Locators6 Cannons, Isomags, Bellum6 Cannons, Isomags, Colony
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
Eng 1Assimilated ModuleIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomag
Tac 1LocatorAssimilated ModuleAssimilated Module
Tac 2LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 3LocatorBellum Prefire ChamberColony console
Tac 4Lorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire Controls
Tac 5LocatorBellum Prefire ChamberColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS756668778589767503
DPS with Exp Weapon756668771692.0595760606.0595
% Difference2.90%1.43%
% Difference with Exp Weapon1.99%0.52%

However, this time the results are different and we’re seeing that Isomags are 2.9% better if you compare the 756668 number to 778589. Why is that different between two ships with similar console and weapon layouts, on the same captain even? I believe the difference has to do with the nature of the 8th weapon. On the Edison, the 8th weapon was effectively a beam, which either lost Cat1 damage from using Bellums, meaning that Locators looked relatively good, or else globally the loss of Crit from using Colony consoles meant that all weapons suffered, keeping those closer.

Here, we have something different: the 8th weapon is an experimental weapon, which TRINITY does not model. To speculate as to the impact of a loss of approximately 8.5% CrtH on the Experimental Weapon, I need to know how much of a Cat2 loss this is. Using TRINITY, I can determine a Cat2 value from All damage and Weapon damage, resulting in a Cat2 multiplier of 2.661 without locators and 2.943 with Locators). From real-world parsing, I’ve seen 65K out of the Soliton Wave, so if I take the ratio of Cat2s and apply it to that weapon, I’m looking at an 10.6% loss in DPS, or a 6.9K DPS loss. When that’s factored in, we’re right around our 2% threshold again where there’s no advantage in using Bellums + Isomags when you consider other damage sources that benefit from global crit but NOT weapon power like an Experimental Weapon, the Dark Matter Torpedo’s passive, or Kemocite. They may even be worse. Colony consoles have a similar issue where they’re basically damage-neutral with some survivability gains. You decide whether that’s worth it to you or not.

Let’s try it again, but let’s see the results for 7 and 8 energy weapons, just to see if it’s different.

[7 weapon TRINITY 1.4] (https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1hW4ABAiej46oYZbYfwM9AT5eonGtQOTUTMzZyY29w40/edit?usp=sharing)

Eng/Tac Console Layout7 Cannons, 5 Locators7 Cannons, Isomags, Bellums7 Cannons, Isomags, Colony
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
Eng 1Assimilated ModuleIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomag
Tac 1LocatorAssimilated ModuleAssimilated Module
Tac 2LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 3LocatorBellum PrefireColony console
Tac 4LocatorBellum PrefireColony console
Tac 5LocatorBellum PrefireColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS827083846517827355
% Difference2.35%0.03%

With 7 energy weapons, I left off the torpedo and assumed an experimental weapon again, dropping Lorca’s 2-piece. At that point, it’s basically the same result as with 6 energy weapons, where Isomags + Bellums have a slight edge, which is likely around the threshold where the loss of Crit for the Experimental Weapon and other non-modeled sources comes into play. I personally wouldn’t swap over if I was flying an Escort with 5/2/1 weapons and +3 Locators over Isomags. If we accounted for the Experimental Weapon loss, we'd be under the 2% threshold again.

8 weapon TRINITY 1.4

Eng/Tac Console Layout8 Cannons, 6 Locators8 Cannons, 3 Iso+3 Bellum8 Cannons, 3 Iso+3 Col
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
Eng 1Assimilated ModuleIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomag
Tac 1LocatorAssimilated ModuleAssimilated Module
Tac 2LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 3LocatorBellum PrefireColony console
Tac 4LocatorBellum PrefireColony console
Tac 5LocatorBellum PrefireColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS889516911448891120
% Difference2.47%0.18%

With 8 energy weapons and NO experimental weapon, we’re over the 2% threshold (barely) if we don't account for the Experimental Weapon, assuming all the energy weapons are the same type, and Isomags are better for DPS. Isomags+Colony consoles are basically equal for damage for items modeled and give more survivability, but I’d expect a small DPS drop-off due to things not modeled in TRINITY losing global CritH.

EDITOR'S NOTE: Nothing significant changed between 1.1 and 1.4. All of the 1.4 results were within 0.5% of the 1.1 values.

Cmdr Eng/MW, ERL, Isomags +1

Let’s change it up and move into the specialization firing modes, starting with ERL. Now I’ll look at my ERL Gagarin, which uses 4 cannons, 1 torpedo, and 3 beams, so Bellums will not be good here. As a Battlecruiser, it’s going to get a little silly since this ship can carry far more Isomags than Locators (2 Universals + 5 Engineering versus 4 Tactical). TRINITY 1.4

Gagarin ERL5 Locators6 Isomags + Ordnance6 Isomags + Tachyo
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
Eng 1Immolating Phaser LanceIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Tachyokinetic ConverterIsomagIsomag
Eng 3Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomag
Eng 4Ordnance AcceleratorIsomagIsomag
Eng 5Tachyon Net DronesImmolating Phaser LanceTachyokinetic Converter
Tac 1LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 2LocatorOrdnance AcceleratorImmolating Phaser Lance
Tac 3LocatorTachyon Net DronesTachyon Net Drones
Tac 4Lorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire Controls
1.4 Calculated DPS849,098.13938,137.88949,233.83
% difference10.49%11.79%

Even if I don’t assume maximum Isomags, it’s a significant DPS gain to run 6 of these versus 5 Locators. This shouldn’t be surprising if you’ve read this far. For fun, I’ll also do the analysis assuming # locators > # of isomags even though very few ships can pull this off and only the Tzen-Tar has a 5 Tac / 2 Eng layout, meaning you’re comparing 6 or 7 Locators against only 4 Isomags.

TRINITY 1.4

Tac Heavy ERL6 Locators5 Isomags+1 colony4 Isomags + 1 colony
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
UniLocatorIsomagIsomag
Eng 1Immolating Phaser LanceIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Ordnance AcceleratorIsomagIsomag
Eng 3Hull Image RefractorsIsomag*Tachyokinetic in a sci slot
Tac 1LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 2LocatorTachyokineticColony console
Tac 3LocatorImmolating Phaser LanceImmolating Phaser Lance
Tac 4Lorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire Controls
Tac 5LocatorColony consoleColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS918,652.04974,723.75949,269.96
% difference6.10%3.33%

As you can see, it doesn’t matter at all even with Locators +2. You could say that Isomags > Locators for all ERL, though Locators are basically even if you have 2 more of them. I suspect that’s due to how ERL doesn’t really drain power at the same rate as standard firing modes.

EDITOR'S NOTE: This was one of the two conclusions that changed. Isomags always for ERL builds.

Cmdr Tac, RRtW, Locators +2

Now on to Reroute Reserves to Weapons, using my Deimos, which again is a mix of 3 cannons, 3 beams, a torpedo, and an experimental weapon. It’s worth noting that weapon damage still scales off of weapon power under RRtW, even though weapon power is not drained. 1.4 TRINITY

Deimos RRTW5 Locators3 Isomags+2 Colony4 Isomags+1 Colony
UniLocatorAltamid Modified Swarm ProcessorIsomag
Eng 1Computer Assisted Flight AlgorithmsIsomagIsomag
Eng 2Hull Image RefractorsIsomagIsomag
Eng 3Altamid Modified Swarm ProcessorIsomagIsomag
Eng 4Dragonsblood Flame ReactorDragonsblood Flame ReactorDragonsblood Flame Reactor
Tac 1LocatorLorca's Custom Fire ControlsLorca's Custom Fire Controls
Tac 2LocatorHull Image RefractorsHull Image Refractors
Tac 3LocatorComputer Assisted Flight AlgorithmsComputer Assisted Flight Algorithms
Tac 4LocatorColony consoleAltamid Modified Swarm Processor
Tac 5Lorca's Custom Fire ControlsColony consoleColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS961,929.45972,367.83996,398.79
% difference--1.09%3.58%

When I redid the analysis, it showed that at +2 Locators over Isomags, the Locators pulled ahead. Otherwise, Isomags were the winner. It is worth noting that TRINITY does not do a great job of modeling Engine Power fall-off on a ship where you’re injecting power back in via A2B and batteries and such, but since that’s outside of the weapon power/crit equations, it more or less factors out.

EDITOR's NOTE: This one changed a little, to favor Locators at +2 over Isomags. I also moved platforms to a different ship so that build is linked instead of the previous one.

Cmdr Tac, Surgical, Exploiters +1

Lastly, let’s discuss Surgical Strikes, where the Spire consoles of choice have been Exploiters rather than Locators. I’ll start with my Legendary Scimitar, which has more Tac Consoles than Eng Consoles. Again, since it’s Surgical, it’s a mixed build with Beams and Cannons (3 Beams, 4 Cannons, 1 Torpedo). TRINITY

Scimitar SS5 Exploiters4 Isomags+1 Colony
UniExploiterIsomag
Eng 1Altamid Modified Swarm ProcessorIsomag
Eng 2Hull Image RefractorsIsomag
Eng 3Piezo-Electric FocuserIsomag
Tac 1ExploiterFek'Ihri Torment Engine
Tac 2ExploiterAltamid Modified Swarm Processor
Tac 3ExploiterHull Image Refractors
Tac 4ExploiterPiezo-Electric Focuser
Tac 5Fek'Ihri Torment EngineColony console
1.4 Calculated DPS933821.27801521
% difference-14.17%

We can see from the results that Exploiters are handily beating Isomags here. I ran the numbers twice to make sure I didn’t make a mistake and it’s not close. Stick with Exploiters if # of Exploiters > # Isomags.

*EDITOR'S NOTE: The difference favored Exploiters even more in 1.4.

Cmdr Eng, Surgical, Isomags+1

Is that conclusion universally true for Surgical though? What about if Isomags have a numerical advantage? This time I used Jay’s Legendary Konnie for the analysis but pretended it had a 4 Eng/4 Tac/3 Science console layout ship, like the S31 Dreadnought Cruiser or the Legendary D7.

TRINITY 1.4

D7 SS5 Exploiters5 Isomags
UniExploiterIsomag
Eng 1DOMINOIsomag
Eng 2Immolating Phaser LanceIsomag
Eng 3Weaponized Helical TorsionIsomag
Eng 4Bioneural Infusion CircuitsIsomag
Tac 1ExploiterImmolating Phaser Lance
Tac 2ExploiterWeaponized Helical Torsion
Tac 3ExploiterBioneural Infusion Circuits
Tac 4ExploiterDOMINO
1.4 Calculated DPS9490891027772
% difference8.29%

And once again, we see that Isomags are coming up the winner whenever it’s a 1-to-1 replacement.

EDITOR's NOTE: I did not re-do Isomags +1, because if Isomags are winning head to head, they will win more if they have an advantage.

DEWSci

DEWsci, or mixing energy weapons with exotics, is highly variable since it's very subjective how much of each side you use. Here's my Eternal, which is about an even split of exotic and energy, just replacing Locators versus Isomags. TRINITY 1.4. TRINITY 1.4 also offers the ability to model Exotic Particle Amplifiers, so I modeled their effect for having 3 EPA [Phaser] as well in this round.

Eternal DEWSci3 Locators3 Isomags3 EPA [Phaser]
UniLocatorHull Image RefractorsShield Absorptive Frequency Generator
Eng 1Hull Image RefractorsIsomagHull Image Refractors
Eng 2Tactical System StabilizerIsomagTactical System Stabilizer
Eng 3Causal AnchorIsomagD.O.M.I.N.O.
Sci 1Shield Absorptive Frequency GeneratorShield Absorptive Frequency GeneratorExotic Particle Amplifier [EPG]
Sci 2Restorative Particle Focuser [EPG][CtrlX]Restorative Particle Focuser [EPG][CtrlX]Restorative Particle Focuser [EPG][CtrlX]
Sci 3Restorative Particle Focuser [EPG][CtrlX]Restorative Particle Focuser [EPG][CtrlX]Restorative Particle Focuser [EPG][CtrlX]
Sci 4Tachyon Net DronesTachyon Net DronesExotic Particle Amplifier [EPG]
Sci 5D.O.M.I.N.O.D.O.M.I.N.O.Exotic Particle Amplifier [EPG]
Tac 1Lorca'sLorca'sLorca's
Tac 2LocatorTactical System StabilizerTactical System Stabilizer
Tac 3LocatorCausal AnchorCausal Anchor
1.4 Calculated DPS767050784665750176
--2.30%-2.20%

This will vary, but my guess is Isomags for most firing modes, even if there's a bunch of Exotics in the build. It really depends, but they're probably close, with Isomags taking the advantage as more of the build is devoted to +Energy.

EDITOR's NOTE: Conclusions didn't change on this. Isomags slightly increased their lead with 1.4's better model. EPAs are not worth pursuing on this build, but since DEWSci is so variable, your build may favor Exotic Particle Amplifiers with more exotic investment.

Conclusions

Having done all of these scenarios, I think we can extrapolate out some general principles, to the point where I have another BO build that I didn’t bother to run through TRINITY because its # of Eng consoles > # of Tac console slots. I already know the mathematical answer is Isomags based on the rest of the analysis.

Main Firing ModeSame Type Energy Weapons (i.e. Beams or Cannons)Console WeightingVerdict
BO / FAW / CSV / CRF8Doesn't matterIsomags+Bellum
BO / FAW / CSV / CRF7Eng+, Even, or Tac+1Isomags+Bellum
BO / FAW / CSV / CRF7Tac+2Locators, but Isomags+Bellum/Colony very close
BO / FAW / CSV / CRF6Eng+, Even, or Tac+1Isomags+Bellum or Colony
BO / FAW / CSV / CRF6Tac+2Locators, but Isomags+Bellum/Colony very close
ERLShould be mixedDoesn't matterIsomags+Colony
RRTWShould be mixedTac+2Locators
RRTWShould be mixedEng+, Even, or Tac+1Isomags+Colony
SurgicalShould be mixedTac+Exploiters
SurgicalShould be mixedEven or Eng+Isomags + colony consoles

EDITOR'S NOTE: Updated and slightly condensed table.

What do you think? Did I miss something? What are your experiences with the new consoles? Discuss, rabble, etc. below and as always, check us out at www.stobetter.com!


r/stobuilds • • Dec 08 '20

Guide The Baby Step Series Part 2: The Next Step - Fresh 65 T5 Assault Cruiser Cheap DPS

85 Upvotes

The Baby Step Series Part 2: The Next Step - Fresh Level 65 T5 Assault Cruiser Free DPS

Build Info

"Hi, and welcome to part 2 of the Baby Step Series!

Before I get started I just wanted to give shout out to Eph289 for previewing and helping me edit these posts. You a STO saint, dude!

This post is the next step after the Level 40 T5 Assault Cruiser post found here: https://www.reddit.com/r/stobuilds/comments/k88fel/the_baby_step_series_part_1_the_first_step_level/

Here's Part 3: https://www.reddit.com/r/stobuilds/comments/k9jct6/the_baby_step_series_part_3_the_last_step_level/

For more comprehensive ship building information: www.stobetter.com

This ship build continues evolving the last one using generally easy-to-get mission rewards and low tier reputation gear. It is basically something that a new player wants to work up to on the way from level 40ish to 65+. It should be able to clear normal difficulty content like a boss, be able to do advanced level content without too much trouble, and allow you to start really grinding the reputation marks, fleet marks, and dilithium you'll need to begin building a max level ship for elite content. Where and how to get gear is mentioned, along with which ones should be prioritized, as well as gear they'll replace on the previous leveling build.

Let's go to school!"

Player Information

Player Info--------------
Captain NameAll da capitans ;)
Captain FactionAll, though KDF and Rommys will be a bit different as this is focused on a FED ship and phasers.
Captain RaceDoesn't matter. Alien if you want that 10th personal trait.
Captain ProfessionAll. Captain career has nothing to do with ship choice or build. Stop the lies!
Primary SpecializationNone yet as you should be leveling Strategist first from level 50-65, though this will eventually be Intelligence.
Secondary SpecializationStrategist. At level 50 this should be the first specialization you level. Read below for how and why to spend your first specialization points.
Intended RoleTo not suck between levels 40ish-65 and be able to keep up at level 65 and beyond.

Skill Tree

  Engineering Science Tactical 
Lieutenant Hull RestorationHull CapacityShield RestorationShield CapacityAdvanced Energy Weapon TrainingAdvanced Projectile Weapon Training
        
Lieutenant Commander Improved EPS FlowImproved Impulse ExpertiseControl ExpertiseDrain ExpertiseImproved Targeting ExpertiseImproved Defensive Manuvering
5 Points         
        
Commander Hull Plating Shield RegenerationShield HardnessAdvanced Weapon AmplificationAdvanced Weapon specialization'
15 Points       
        
        
Captain    Advanced Long Range TargetingAdvanced Hull PenetrationAdvanced Shield Penetration
25 Points      
       
        
Admiral Warp Core PotentialEngineering Readiness Scientific ReadinessCoordination ProtocolsTactical Readiness
35 Points    Defensive Coordination  
  Warp Core Efficency   Offensive Coordination  
        
Total of 46 of 46 Points Engineering Points:10Science Points:10Tactical Points:26

Skill Tree Unlocks

Points to unlockEngineering UnlocksScience UnlocksTactical Unlocks
Unlocks After 2Training Manual:Training Manual:Training Manual:
Unlocks After 5Battery ExpertiseSector Space Travel SpeedThreat Control
Unlocks After 7Training Manual:Training Manual:Training Manual:
Unlocks After 10Maximum Hull CapacityMaximum Shield CapacityProjectile Critical Chance
Unlocks After 12   
Unlocks After 15  Energy Critical Chance
Unlocks After 17  Training Manual:
Unlocks After 20  Defense
--------------------------------------------------------
Unlocks After 24 (Ultimate)  Focused Frenzy
Unlocks After 25 (Ultimate)  Frenzied Assault
Unlocks After 26 (Ultimate)  Team Frenzy
Unlocks After 27 (Ultimate)   

Skill Tree Information

The same skill tree from my "First Step" post. To read more about it, visit the link above.

Build Description

"This build continues to increase performance on the back of the T5 Assault Cruiser received at level 40. One thing some might notice is a focus on things like damage and crit chance/damage. This is because the best performance in STO combat comes from these things. The faster you kill your enemies, the less chance they have of hurting you. Having heals and resistances are good, just not the most important part of a build. Focusing too much on these things means becoming a turtle, all shell and no bite.

Still pretty FED focused I know, sorry klinky and rommy friends. The build can still be adapted more to your requirements, just have to replace things with disruptor and plasma stuff :)

All gear, especially weapons and tac consoles, should be mark 12+ at this point. Quality is still less of a concern though very rare and beyond should be something you're shooting for.

At level 51 you will get your first specialization point. You'll get 1 point for each level from 51-65 for a total of 15. Spend all of these points in the Strategist secondary spec for two reasons. One, Strategist is the go-to secondary because when using it while the captain ability Threatening Stance is off (which is what most players do) you get boosts to Crit Chance when using heals, damage boosts depending on how many foes you're hitting, and a utility clicky that placates enemies, reduces threat, and ups damage. Two, after spending 15 points in it you unlock the Unconventional Tactics starship trait, which gives the captain ability Brace for Impact a 15% Bonus All Damage boost.

Next, at level 65+ you'll get a spec point every time you fill the leveling bar at the top of the screen, the best ways of doing this being Fed Admiralty (for the high xp payouts and 2 spec points after every 10th tour), spec point boxes from personal/universal endeavors and events, and just playing the game. After completing Strategist spend your next 15 points in Intelligence, focusing on the space side and set it to primary. Intel is the go-to primary for energy builds mainly due to the tier 3 flanking bonuses to crits and damage. Also, after spending 15 points in it will unlock the Predictive Algorithms starship trait, which adds a debuff removal every time a firing mode is used and adds a little accuracy.

Then, spend 15 points in Command (do not not set this to primary, it's mostly useless) to unlock the starship trait Command Frequency, which allows you to use the captain ability Fleet Support at any hull value. After that, finish off Intel spec to unlock the Intelligence Fleet clicky that gives a 15% boost to armor/shield penetration for 30 seconds, and changes Predictive Algorithms to the Improved version. If you're having serious survivability issues, instead of Intel you could build up Miracle Worker in its place as it's great for that.

So, after spending your first 60 spec points as mentioned, you can then choose where you want to put them after that, such as finishing off Command (for the Improved version of the trait) or focusing on Commando for your ground game. Temporal primary is fantastic for most science ship builds, Pilot is a great primary or secondary, just overshadowed by Intel/Strat from a DPS perspective, and Constable is good for hardened targets like bosses but mostly useless for everything else.

Subsystem power will change to something like this: Weapons 100 / Shields 15-20 / Engines 15-20 / Auxiliary 60-70. This is because of two specific things found on the build: the Temporal Disentanglement Suite science console and the Nukara rep trait Auxiliary Power Configuration - Offense, that both increase their damage potential scaled off of how high your aux power is. High aux will also juice the boff abilities Hazard Emitters 1, Auxiliary to Structural Integrity 1, and Auxiliary to Inertial Dampeners 1.

To customize your subsystem power levels click the button with the 3 little boxes in it in the top right corner of the Subsystem power UI box. It will give you a 1, 2, 3, click 3 to give you a set of sliders. Weapon power should already be set to 100, click the lock above it to... lock it. Then, raise the aux slider up to 60-70. This will automatically set shields and engines to 15-20. Lock the aux slider, adjust engines/shields if you need to, then click the little 'save disk' in the top left, and to return to the numbers click the little 3 boxes button and hit 1.

The boff layout is the same as the leveling build since it's purdy gud already but is being enhanced by a couple of additions: the Emergency Conn Hologram from the Phoenix box and the Temporal reputation trait Chronocapacitor Array (read more below).

Personal traits haven't changed much since the leveling build except for three new additions: Beam Barrage from Beam R&D level 15, Point Blank Shot from mission House Pegh, and Thrill Seeker. All the reputation traits are fairly easy to get as 3 of them are found at T2, while the Nukara rep trait will take a little longer to get at T4. The starship traits are all the best free ones available, three of which are had through the specializations as mentioned above, with the fourth being a mission reward."

Basic InformationData
Ship NameUSS Isa Gud Girl ;)
Ship ClassT5 Assault Cruiser
Basic InformationComponentNotes
Fore Weapons: 4Prolonged Engagement Phaser Array MK XII+Available from the Phoenix box very rare reward, usually pretty easy to get once you have some dilithium to buy Phoenix boxes. Applies stacks of Amplified Relays. Per stack, this weapon deals 1% increased damage, deals 90% to 115% of the normal damage of a Phaser Beam Array. Every 5 stacks of Amplified Relays, gain 20% Firing Cycle Haste for this Weapon for 8 secs. Haste is one of the best things for damage as it acts like a final damage modifier. One of the best phaser beam arrays in the game. Comes at Ultra Rare. At Epic it gets the Ac/Dm mod which should be re-engineered to Crtd/Dm. Medium priority.
 Phaser Beam Array MK XII+Comes from mission drops, rewards, crafting, and the exchange. At this point it's time to start thinking about re-engineering mods to all Crtd, all Dmg, or a mix of both.
 Phaser Beam Array MK XII+ 
 Quantum Phase Torpedo Launcher MK XII+From the mission Sunrise. Upon impact drains shields from target and any other enemies within 2 km of the target. Helps to form the 2pc set bonus of the Quantum Phase Catalysts (with the console) giving 15% accuracy and making the drain proc on the torp a little better. Still just here to help with weapon power drain and add a little extra spike damage here and there, the shield drain is pretty decent too. Cannot be re-engineered. Medium-high priority.
   
------------------------------------------
Aft Weapons: 4Omni-Directional Phaser Beam Array MK XII+Crafted at Beam R&D level 15 or bought on the exchange. More time on target equals more overall damage dealt. Re-engineer mods to all Crtd, all Dmg, or a mix of both. High Priority.
 Trilithium Enhanced Omni-Directional Phaser Beam Array MK XII+From mission Beyond the Nexus. Like the crafted omni above, more time on target equals more overall damage dealt. Forms a 2pc with console Reinforced Armaments for 5% firing cycle haste. Haste is one of the best things for damage as it acts like a final damage modifier. Cannot be re-engineered. High priority.
 Phaser Beam Array MK XII+See above.
 Phaser Beam Array MK XII+ 
   
------------------------------------------
DeflectorQuantum Phase Deflector Array MK XII+From mission Stormbound. IMHO the best mission set in the game allowing one to start building up the resources for better fleet and rep gear. High priority for the whole set.
Impulse EnginesQuantum Phase Combat Impulse Engines MK XII+By themselves these set pieces are nothing special but together they're pretty good as they add some survivability, the 2pc makes the shields a little better, and the 3pc gives a little damage clicky.
Warp CoreDeuterium-Stabilized Warp Core MK XII+Core hasn't changed from the leveling build as it's pretty useful. From mission drops, crafting, and the exchange. Probably best to try and buy one from the exchange. Take for the very nice -15% reduction in weapon power drain.
ShieldsQuantum Phase Resilient Shield Array MK XII+And the shield is Resilient which is what we're usually looking for ;) Alternatives to the Quantum Phase set are the Sol Defense set from mission Midnight and the Kobali Regenerative Circuitry set from mission Dust to Dust. Both provide decent stats for survivability as well as in their 2-3pc bonuses. There is also the Bajor Defense set from mission Scylla and Charybdis which has a 2pc bonus of 17.8% Cat1 Phaser/Disruptor/Plasma damage. You could use the deflector/eng plus the deuterium core and a resilient shield.
DevicesSubspace Field ModulatorFrom mission Skirmish in the Devidian story arc found in the "Available" missions tab. Taken for the added damage resistance and defense. A decent free 'Oh Shit!' button. Don't worry, nothing really uses proton damage so don't worry about the -400 proton damage resistance thing, it's moot. Low priority.
 Energy AmpliferCrafted in Beam R&D at level 10. Gives 20% bonus energy damage for up to 20 seconds if the Battery Expertise unlock is taken in the skill tree. High priority.
 Deuterium SurplusPlay the Alhena system daily mission in the beta quad and get it at the end, then craft in Eng R&D. Consuamble mini-Evasive Maneuvers that helps to keep you fast. Low-medium priority.
 Reactive Armor CatalystPlay mission Broken Circle and choose the reward, then Craft in Eng R&D. Increases hull cap and gives a sizable heal-over-time when Battery Expertise is taken. Low-medium priority.
 Reinforcement BeaconsThere are two more free reinforcement beacons like the Nimbus Pirate Distress Call mentioned in the leveling build. These are the Delta Alliance Reinforcements Beacon from mission Broken Circle and the Phased-Waveform Beacon from the mission Home. Like the Nimbus beacon they do not need to be slotted in your devices and can be used from your inventory.
------------------------------------------
Engineering Consoles: 4Reinforced Armaments MK XII+From mission Beyond the Nexus. 53.3% EPS power transfer rate, +20 to hull restoration and cap skills at mark 12 VR. Forms 2pc with omni phaser BA (or turret) for extra 5% weapon haste. Remember haste is big when it comes to damage. High priority. Will replace the EPS Flow Regulator.
 Ordnance Accelerator MK XII+From Gamma rep T2. Gives 20% phaser and 20% projectile damage at mark 12 VR. Med-high priority. Will replace a RCS Accelerator.
 Assimilated Module MK XII+From Omega rep T1. 0.92% Critical Chance, 9.2% Critical Severity, +5 Weapon Power Setting, +5.1 Starship Hull Regeneration, +22.9 Starship Control Expertise at mark 12 VR. The original DPS console. Taken mostly for the added crit chance and crit damage. High priority. Will replace a RCS Accelerator.
 Zero Point Energy Conduit MK XII+From Romulan rep T1. 1.8% Critical Chance, 19.7 DrainX, +1.8 power to all subsystems at mark 12 VR. Taken for the crit chance. Medium priority. Will replace the Neutronium Alloy Armor. If having survivability issues the Trellium-D Armor from mission Ragnarok and/or the House Martok Defensive Configuration from mission Brushfire could also go here.
   
------------------------------------------
Science Consoles: 2Temporal Disentanglement Suite MK XII+From mission Butterfly. +4 aux power, 20% maximum shield cap, +3% shield resistance, aux scaling 0-2.5% crit chance and 0-10% crit damage at mark 12 VR. Taken for the crits. High priority.
 Quantum Phase Converter MK XII+From mission Sunrise. 20% phaser damage, +3 aux power, +30 DrainX at mark 12 VR. Forms 2pc with the torpedo. Taken for the increase to phaser damage. High priority.
   
   
   
------------------------------------------
Tactical Consoles: 3Phaser Relay MK XII+These haven't changed from the leveling build. Always stack consoles here that increase the damage of your chosen energy flavor. Phasers = Phaser Relays / Disruptor = Disruptor Induction Coils / Plasma = Plasma Infusers / etc. These can be difficult to get early on in the game as mission rewards or drops. You can check the exchange for cheap commons or try crafting your own.
 Phaser Relay MK XII+ 
 Phaser Relay MK XII+ 

Officers and Crew

Bridge Officer InformationPowerNotes
Officer 1: Commander ( Engineering )Emergency Power to Engines 1Plus 40 flight speed, +2 turn rate, +20 engine power. Procs the Conn Officer doff that effectively resets Evasive Maneuvers. Keeps you fast.
   Auxiliary Power to the Structural Integrity Field 1Auxiliary scaling heal and added damage resistance rating. Short cooldown and one of the better boff heals in the game.
 Emergency Power to Weapons 3Plus 40 weapon power and 16.6% all energy damage. At any rank a must for energy weapon builds. Can be purchased off the exchange, a training manual can be made for it out of a boff candidate that already has it, or it can be crafted by engineering captains.
 Reverse Shield Polarity 3Converts incoming energy damage to shields, lasts 20 seconds. Basically makes you invulernable while it's up, though things like kinetic and physical damage will still hurt you. Works great against Vaadwaur Polaron Barrages. Can be used with a special and expensive Fabrication Engineer doff from the exchange to increase uptime. Must be purchased off the exchange or a training manual can be made for it out of a boff candidate that already has it.
Officer 2: Lt. Commander ( Engineering )Engineering Team 1Small hull heal, repairs offline subsystems and can clear some other debuffs like movement ones from the Voth and Mokai.
   Auxiliary Power to Inertial Dampeners 1Auxiliary scaling kinetic damage resistance, +50%flight speed, +100% turn rate for 15 seconds. Shares a cooldown with A2Sif above. Mostly a filler ability.
 Directed Energy Modulation 27.5% energy weapon shield penetration and 7.5 to Armor penetration for 30 seconds. Not super-great but decent filler ability.
   
Officer 3: Lieutenant ( Tactical )Tactical Team 1Distributes shield strength to shields receiving damage (why its used), +18 to both Weapon and Projectile training for 10 seconds. Clear hostile boarding parties and tactical debuffs. Vets will forgo this ability for something that gives more damage but Tac Team is a must for new players. It really helps with survivability. Never have to use higher than rank 1. The butter...
   Attack Pattern Beta 1-20 all damage resistance to target. The bread...
   
   
Officer 4: Ensign ( Tactical )Beam Overload or Beam Fire at Will 1Beam Overload 1 will increase damage 3x and decreases firing rate by half. Beam Fire at Will 1 hits all available targets within a beam array's arc but each beam only does 80% of its base damage and has its accuarcy skill decreased by 50. Both are viable, just your choice between being single or multi target focused. BFAW is great for clearing multiple targets at once and drawing threat as a tank. Because it draws a lot of threat, it can get you killed if you don't know how to manage a lot of incoming damage FYI. For most if not all builds, it's important to take the highest rank of these abilities. In this case, because we want to use APB1 in the LT spot, the beams' main firing mode is relegated to rank 1 for now. The meat...
     
   
   
Officer 5: Lieutenant ( Science )Hazard Emitters 1Aux scaling heal-over-time, adds all damage resistance, clears plasma fires and other hazard debuffs.
   Photonic Officer 1Super-Important Part of the Build Reduces recharge times of bridge officers by 2% each second for 20 sec. Used in conjuction with a point each in the readiness skills, as well as the Temporal reputation's Chronocapacitor Array trait, will keep your boff abilities' cooldowns at or close to their minimums, resulting in their use more often.
   
Duty Officer InformationPowerNotes
Emergency Conn HologramUsing Emergency Power to Engines effectively resets Evasive Maneuvers' cooldown.From the Phoenix box rare rewards. Relatively easy to get once you have some dilithium to spend. Keeps you fast. Low-med priority.
Projectile Weapons OfficerChance to reduce the time for torpedos to recharge after use. 20% chance: Improve recharge time by 5 secLaw from the mission A Fistful of Gorn. You can stack up to three PWOs to increase your chance at reducing the torp's cooldown. Cheap filler doff to help the Quantum Phase torp firing a little more often. Low priority.

Character, Reputation, and Starship Traits

Personal Space TraitsDescriptionNotes
Accurate+10% Accuracy 
Beam BarrageOn activation of Beam ability to self: +2% All Beam Damage Bonus for 30 sec (Stacks up to 3 times)From Beam R&D Level 15. Replacing Innocuous. Medium priority.
Beam Training+5% Beam Weapon Damage 
Elusive+10% Defense 
Fleet Coordinator+2% All Damage per Team member (Self included), up to 10% 
Operative+1% Critical Chance, +2% Critical Severity 
Point Blank Shotto self: +0-10% Bonus Energy Weapon Damage, based on Distance to Target. Maximum bonus when less than 2km, no effect beyond 6kmFrom mission House Pegh. Replacing Projectile Training. Med-high priority.
Techie+20 Hull Restoration (Improves Hull Healing) +20 Hull Regeneration (Improves Passive Hull Regeneration) 
Thrill-seeker+15% Flight and Full Impulse SpeedReplacing Warp Theorist.
Space Reputation TraitsDescriptionObtained from
Advanced Targeting Systems+16% Critical SeverityT2 Dyson, high priority.
Auxiliary Power Configuration - Offense+5% (at 100 Aux) Bonus All Damage, +5 Accuracy (at 100 Aux)T4 Nukara, med-high priority.
Precision+4% Critical Hit ChanceT2 Romulan, high priority.
Chrono-Capacitor Array+7.5% Bridge Officer Ability Recharge SpeedT2 Temporal, medium priority.
Starship TraitsDescriptionNotes
Unconventional TacticsBrace for Impact grants 15% Bonus All Damage BuffFrom completing Strategist spec. The best free starship trait.
The Best DefenseAttack Patterns grant Hull Healing Buff to SelfFrom mission House Pegh. APB will be up most of the time in combat making this a nice ultility.
Command FrequencyAble to use captain ability Fleet Support at any hull percentage.From spending 15 points in Command spec. Nice support, even better with the improved version.
Predictive AlgorithmsActivating any Weapon Enhancement Ability removes 1 Debuff effect and grants +2.5 Accuracy Rating for 30 sec from weapon enhancing abilities (stacks up to 4 times)From spending 15 points in Intelligence spec. Getting rid of debuffs is nice and the added accuracy doesn't hurt either (especially when using BFAW).

Concluding Remarks

"Just like the leveling build, this one can be adapted to a number of other cruisers and escorts. This is not for science ships. If adapting this for an escort it's possible to swap out the weapons for DCs/DHCs and turrets, take a cannon firing mode like Cannon: Scatter Volley (CSV) or Cannon: Rapid Fire (CRF), and change the boff layout to something with more tac abilities. You can even adapt this build to a different energy type by swapping the weapons and phaser boosting consoles, with ones that boost your chosen energy type using a console guide like this one: https://www.reddit.com/r/stobuilds/comments/i8v5iw/ogsmustachios_guide_to_dew_consoles_in_2020/

Aaannnddd... that's it! I hope this build can make your life in STO a little easier without too much trouble. If you found this post helpful, bookmark it and link it to your friends or those in need. Stay tuned tomorrow for part 3 of the Baby Step Series entitled: The Last Step - Level 65 High-End Fleet T6X Archon Intel Assault Cruiser, where I'll show you how to evolve this build using the T6X fleet Sovereign with the most expensive, sought-after gear/traits, in order to build a max-performance ship!

Stay safe and have fun out there kiddos ;)

Did I leave anything out? Feel free to leave constructive comments on free/cheap DPS builds below. Thanks for reading!"


r/stobuilds • • May 27 '19

Hangar Pet Update - 23rd May 2019

85 Upvotes

For those that aren't aware, Thursdays Patch (23rd May 2019) introduced several fixes and buffs to almost all hangar pets in some manner. I originally planned on only outlining some of the worst pets in the game, but as I continued testing and sharing results my desire to keep testing different pets continued to grow and this turned from what was going to be a simple project detailing before and afters of worst offenders into a full-blown breakdown of nearly all the Pets I have access to.

Patch Notes

The Relevant excerpt of Hangar Pet changes


  • Hangar Pet Updates:

    • Resolved an issue that would cause many hangar pets to get stuck in "Escort" mode, if this mode was ever selected.

      • This would then prevent them from properly docking, or following at full impulse.

    • Resolved an issue that would prevent some hangar pets from using Full Impulse in certain situations, where they should have been using it to catch up with their owner.

    • Added some missing AI conditions to Jem'Hadar Attack Ships, Jem'Hadar Gunboats, and Kelvin Timeline Assault Drones, which could cause them to become non-responsive to further commands, and stop using proper following behavior.

    • Resolved an issue on the Breen Plesh Brek and Vorgon Echentis hangar pets which could cause them to occasionally attempt to ram enemies, even though they were not equipped with a ramming ability.

    • Removed the limitation of needing targets to be within 15km in order to allow Hangar Pets to launch.

      • Launching Hangar Pets no longer evaluates your current target.

    • Hangar Pets in the "Attack" state should more reliably know when to follow their owner, based on distance from relevant foes.

      • This should also improve their "Full Impulse" behavior by extension, making them more frequently able to follow their owner.

    • Hangar Pets are now capable of increasing their speed momentarily if told to attack a distant target.

      • This should increase their time-on-target during the initial engagement period of combat scenarios.


Elite - Cardassian Yukawa Frigates

Fore Weapons

WeaponNotes
Spiral Wave Disruptor Beam Bank
Spiral Wave Disruptor Beam Bank
Spiral Wave Disruptor Beam Bank
Photon Torpedo Launcher

Aft Weapons

WeaponNotes
Spiral Wave Disruptor 360 Beam Array

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Torpedo Spread: IIITorpedo Weapon Enhancement, attacks up to five targets
Subnucleonic Carrier Wave IRemoves the 2 longest-duration buffs25% chance: +4 sec to recharge time to one of the following systems: Energy Weapons, Projectiles, Tactical, Engineering of Science abilities-21.5% Power Recharge Speed for 15 sec
Suppressive ArmamentsModualte weapons for 15 seconds, reducing Accuracy of any foe attacked

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2CombinedParse Image
ISA #13,456.162372.645,919.79Parse 1
ISA #23,496.603,206.106,702.70Parse 2
ISA #33,855.051,997.765,852.80Parse 3
ISA #43,762.471,451.155,213.62Parse 4
ISA #53,241.652,107.325,348.97Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs, this nets them an average of 5,807.576 DPS. I don't have parses on record from the testing I did when Victory is Life launched, but they have improved vastly over the 1k to 1.2k they were doing then. Sadly this improvement isn't enough to make them worth it IMO. Overall they are still underperforming, especially given the cost of 100k Fleet Credits and 38k Dil. Given that cost and their performance, I would recommend the Elite Peregrines if fed, or Elite Nausicaan Stingers if KDF over these.

So what do I think are the Yukawa's downfall? Well for starters, they lack an Energy Weapon Enhancement like FAW or BO. Pets aren't smart enough to know when to fire their Torpedo Spreads, so often times they will just spam them whenever, often hitting the shield and doing next to no damage, evidenced by the fact that in pretty much every parse, their Spiral Wave DBBs with no weapon enhancement did more damage than their torpedo spread and torp combined.

A further demerit, though at the time of writing this I haven't gotten to testing the other pets, so this may affect all of them, they still aren't Full Impulsing correctly. They are doing it some so, that's a vast improvement over pre-patch where they wouldn't full impulse at all. But they're sporadic and tend to wander off. I had one fly 38k away for no reason in one queue. They also seem to drop out of full impulse sometimes, causing them to go back and forth between full and normal speed, and depending on the area you have to traverse in some queues, causes them to despawn quite frequently. Their full impulse burst to bring them into combat, on the other hand, seems to work excellently. I've seen them trailing 8k~ behind me as I drop out of full impulse approaching my target, and as I buff and close into combat range I've seen them speed into combat distance and start attacking.

Overall these Frigate pets are still pretty disappointing. They're far improved over where they were just a few hours ago, and if this improvement is enough for you then by all means. They have beastly hull, rivaling a player escort and don't die a whole lot, but as stated before, you'd find better options than this.


Elite - Tzenkethi Shuk-Din

Weapons

WeaponNote
Diffusive Tetryon Dual Cannon
Diffusive Tetryon Dual Heavy Cannon
Diffusive Tetryon Turret
Tetryon Energy Torpedos(?)Tool tip list torpedos plural, not sure how many torpedo launchers they actually have

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Lock TrajectoryIncreases their flight speed while locking their path
Cannon: Rapid Fire IIICannon Weapon Enhancement Mode, Causes cannons to fire 50% more shots per second for 10 seconds while dealing 120% more damage during this duration
Tactical Team IIISelf Explanatory again. Slight buff and distributes shield strength

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2CombinedParse Image
ISA #13,016.772,472.225,488.98Parse 1
ISA #23,474.182,426.905,901.08Parse 2
ISA #33,886.643,163.267,068.16Parse 3
ISA #42,139.901,660.525,528.67Another pug, another death
ISA #54,099.223,155.837,255.05Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs a single hangar of Elite - Tzenkethi Shuk-Dins averaged 6,848.388 DPS. Before the patch, 2 hangars of Shuk-Dins were averaging around 10-12k DPS so it appears that these are largely unchanged. Maybe 1-2k higher than before patch. Sadly again, for the cost of these pets, their performance simply isn't worth it.

So their downfalls? Honestly, I'm not 100% sure on this one. If I had to guess, their AI is reused from the Callisto Pets which are horribly stupid pets and notorious for being terrible, along with the fact that both the Callistos and Shuk-Dins have Lock Trajectory, which can cause them to lock onto a target and overshoot targets and just behave poorly.


Elite - Xindi-Primate Nusuti Heavy Fighters

Weapons

WeaponsNotes
Plasmatic Biomatter Beam Array
Plasmatic Biomatter Beam Array
Quantum Torpedo

Abilities

AbilitiesDescription
Fire at Will IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beams:_Fire_at_Will
Jam Sensors IIIPlacate, should last 20 seconds
Torpedo Spread IIITorpedo Weapon Enhancement, attacks up to five targets

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2Pet 3Pet 4CombinedParse Image
ISA #13,657.273,024.442,913.112,886.5012,499.33Parse 1
ISA #22,297.352,109.571,680.081,515.787,602.78Parse 2
ISA #31,920.931,839.181,338.39828.448,239.19I died in this parse so there are more pets
ISA #42,987.392,950.372,738.352,694.2811,370.39Parse 4
ISA #54,435.723,250.952,685.68613.3711,039.28Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs 1 hangar of Elite - Xindi Nusutis Averaged 10,150.194 DPS. I hadn't tested the Nusutis in close to a year, but the last time I did 1 hangar barely managed 2-3k dps. This patch has vastly improved them for one reason or another. This one is actually a huge surprise to me. I was very curious going into this on how they would play out compared to the last time I did testing with them.

Downfalls? None. Depending on how the Castrois play out which were the superior Xindi Pet before this patch would affect which pet I would choose overall, but on the whole, these are definitely noteworthy now.

So what changed? Honestly, I have zero ideas but I welcome the change regardless. I can't say for sure that they had problems keeping up at full impulse as it was just too long ago for me to truly remember. So perhaps that combined with other changes? Or maybe Cryptic tweaked their AI some. They've received several direct fixes and buffs throughout the years and none of them have made a huge impact so it's hard to say for sure. I'm going to chalk this one up as a mystery and just be glad and surprised at how much they improved.


Elite - Xindi-Insectoid Castroi Fighters

Weapons

WeaponsNotes
Plasmatic Biomatter Beam Array
Quantum Torpedo
Plasmatic Biomatter Turret

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Emergency Power to Shields IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Emergency_Power_to_Shields
Beam: Fire at Will IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beams:_Fire_at_Will

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunsPet 1Pet 2Pet 3Pet 4Pet 5Pet 6CombinedParse Image
ISA #12,707.172,379.012,316.272,000.301,941.751,201.0613,383.97Parse 1 some died
ISA #23,725.443,584.922,973.552,908.022,652.342,449.0318,293.30Parse 2
ISA #33,676.423,507.333,415.743,280.943,080.852,487.8219,714.91Parse 3, 2 died right at the beginning :(
ISA #42,207.891,845.361,625.641,612.351,494.011,413.7613,610.98Parse 4, many deaths for the brave little Castrois
ISA #53,713.503,227.813,023.923,022.672,501.002,409.9518,279.24Parse 5 Deaths part 3, Electric Boogaloo

Summary

Across 5 runs 1 hangar of Elite - Xindi Castrois averaged 16,656.48 DPS. Much like the Nusutis, I hadn't tested the Castrois in a year plus. Previous testing of my own put a single hangar in the 12k~ dps range, equivalent to the Elite - Nausicaan Stingers at the time period. This puts the pets anywhere from 3-7k higher dps than they were before. Their highest parse of 19.7k, almost 20k was a complete shock. Nearly 20k from a single hangar of fighters is quite impressive.

So.. Downfalls. Honestly, they have only two that I've observed in my testing. They are very very fragile. More so than most fighters it seems. Parses where some of them died parsed considerably lower(the 2 13k parses). The other being the fact that they are locked to the Xindi Ships. If you use one of those ships and have access to these(You need to own the Ateleth or the Olaen to unlock the Castrois and Nusutis) they are absolutely worth using. I'd even go so far to say they are among some of the best fighter pets in the game.


Elite - Jem'Hadar Attack Ship

Weapons

WeaponNote
Polaron Dual Cannon
Polaron Beam Array
Polaron Turret
Quantum TorpedosAnother pet listed as Torpedos. Not sure how many this actually includes

Abilities

AbilitiesDescription
Cannon Rapid Fire IIICannon Weapon Enhancement Mode, Causes cannons to fire 50% more shots per second for 10 seconds while dealing 120% more damage during this duration
Antiproton SweepAntiproton Sweep temporarily disables the cloaking devices of nearby hostile ships and damages their shields. Shield damage increases based on currently available auxiliary power level and skill. Can't hide from me Donatra!
Beam Array Overload IIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beams:_Overload
Ramming SpeedWhen JHAS pets drop below 50% hull, they have a chance to initiate ramming speed. Can crit for a monstrous amount. Have seen a 400k Max-One hit from one of them ramming before.

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2CombinedParse Image
ISA #18,328.587,992.3716,320.95Parse 1
ISA #26,532.022,795.2712,092.44Parse 2 one died :(
ISA #37,314.896,711.6314,026.51Parse 3
ISA #46,682.006,261.7712,943.77Parse 4
ISA #55,700.824,291.4610,838.36Parse 5, one died again :(

Summary

Ahh, my old friends. Across 5 runs 1 hangar of Elite - JHAS pets averaged 13,244.406 DPS. These pets are still some of the best frigates in the game, as they very well should be considering the premium price you have to pay for them. As many know I'm a huge fan of the Jem'Hadar Dreadnought Carrier, and it's been my flagship for years now. Likewise, I've been running 2 hangars of Elite JHAS just as long. In previous parses before the Hangar Pet Patch, 2 hangars averaged somewhere between 25-28k, with 30k being the outlier. Overall I believe these pets are performing about 2-5k higher than before the patch, possibly more with further testing.

Downfalls? The JHAS Pets have pretty much everything going for them, so what downfall could they have? They aren't consistent. Now you could say that about a lot of things in the DPS game. You can run ISA 100 times and each time it'll be different and this is very true. RNG elements affect some things too and the nature of pets being an AI Controlled NPC removes a lot of variables from our control. Even looking at some of the other tables that I've completed so far, other pets have inconsistency as well, so why single these out? Well perhaps it's just bias or my imagination, but having played with these hangar pets for years now, they have the tendency to swing wildly one way or the other, even if none of them die and in similar team compositions. One queue they may do 30k+ across 2 hangars, next maybe they only do 20k even if your DPS is fantastic. This is all very subjective and all just personal observation that I've perhaps missed by not having spent the same amount of time with the other pets tested. I would love to hear from other JHDC pilots and see your feedback and results.

Overall these pets are still beastly. If you have a JHDC and you have the Strike Ship/Recon Ship or an Ultra-Rare Phoenix Token for the JHAS, use these. They perform better than the Gunboats for the most part and are more resilient overall, and are just fantastic. Among the top hangar pet in the game. If you don't have access to them, the Gunboats are still competitive and nearly as good and are useable on more Dominion ships than the JHAS pets, so if you're a person on a budget who likes to swap between the Dominion ships, go Gunboats.


Elite - Jem'Hadar Vanguard Gunboats

Weapons

WeaponNotes
Polaron Dual Beam Bank
Polaron Beam Array
Polaron Beam Array
Quantum TorpedoesYet another that says torpedoes plural. Curious just how many this entails

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Fire at Will IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beams:_Fire_at_Will
Attack Pattern Lambda IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Attack_Pattern_Lambda
Evasive Burst IIIBrief increase to Flight Speed, Turn Rate, and Defense
Ramming SpeedSame as the Attack Ships, when health below 50%, chance to initiate ramming speed

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2CombinedParse Image
ISA #17,887.377,374.3015,261.66Parse 1
ISA #25,091.983,775.9812,069.23Parse 2, some died
ISA #37,890.407,652.2615,542.66Parse 3
ISA #43,924.123,803.2010,236.48Parse 4, both died at gate/tac cube F
ISA #58,035.243,107.6413,934.01Parse 5, moar deaths :(

Summary

Across 5 runs, 1 hangar of Elite - Jem'Hadar Vanguard Gunboats averaged 13,408.808 DPS. This like most of the pets brings them up anywhere from 2-5k dps overall compared to before the patch where 2 hangars averaged anywhere from 20-25k with the highest I've ever seen was 32k.

Downfalls? They aren't as good as the JHAS Pets. They are certainly comparable and as mentioned before, if you don't have access to one of the 3 required ships to unlock JHAS Pets, these will certainly fill that role quite well and perform. Overall they seem to be squishier than the JHAS pets which is unfortunate and odd as, in my time running 2 hangars of them, I rarely saw them die.

Overall these are very solid performers. If you don't have access to the JHAS Pets, or you are on a budget and switch between the different Dominion Ships frequently, or you just prefer the looks of these, they are all around pretty solid pets and should serve you well.


Elite - Romulan Drone Ship

Weapons

WeaponNotes
Disruptor Beam Array
Disruptor Beam Array
Disruptor Beam Array
Plasma TorpedoesAgain with the Plural. The greatest mystery of our age?!

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Multi-Spectral EmittersAllows Drone Ships to disguise themselves as other ships
Tri-Phasic EmittersWorks in tandem with the Multi-Spectral Emitters to change the Drones weapons to match the ship it is disguised as
Beam Array Overload IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beams:_Overload
Fire at Will IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beams:_Fire_at_Will
Emergency Power to Shields IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Emergency_Power_to_Shields
Multi-Spectral Emitter - Sensor Distortion IIA confuse and placate the Drones use to blind enemies

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2CombinedParse Image
ISA #17,952.216,829.6214,781.83Parse 1
ISA #29,936.589,617.2219,553.80Parse 2
ISA #311,356.598,535.7519,892.34Parse 3
ISA #410,570.846,294.4020,842.34Parse 4, 1 died at right transformer :(
ISA #511,567.088,357.8919,924.97Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs, 1 hangar of Elite - Romulan Drones averaged 18,999.056 DPS. Honestly, I don't have a whole lot to say about the Drone pets. They are still top tier and some of the best pets in the game hands down. In the previous testing before the patch, Drones performed somewhere in the 15k range, with results as high as 18-20k. All in all, it seems there wasn't a lot to be improved on something that was already pretty much perfect.

Downfalls? They're only useable on the T5 and T6 Scimitar Variants, and the Kelvin Timeline T'laru Carrier. That's it. That's their only real downfall. They are strong, resilient, all around beastly pets.


Elite - Nausicaan Stinger Fighters

Weapons

WeaponNotes
Disruptor Beam Array
Disruptor Pulse Cannon
Photon TorpedoesIs plural, but then says times(x1) one, well which is it o.O

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Torpedo: High Yieldhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Torpedo:_High_Yield
Emergency Power to Weapons Ihttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Emergency_Power_to_Weapons
Emergency Power to Weapons IINot sure why these little guys have two copies of EPtW but oh well

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2Pet 3Pet 4Pet 5Pet 6CombinedParse Image
ISA #14,468.673,815.293,794.763,153.823,089.643,006.6521,328.84Parse 1
ISA #22,031.891,907.251,874.691,679.131,438.291,409.2816,845.51Parse 2, Many Nausicaans died for this intel
ISA #34,126.723,972.083,965.883,868.903,160.883,059.6823,054.36Parse 3, few deaths this time
ISA #43,763.793,610.943,136.152,645.352,529.741,862.5622,292.71Parse 4, several sacrifices made for the good of the many or something
ISA #53,832.853,753.823,321.143,213.013,029.382,939.7220,089.92Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs, 1 hangar of Elite - Nausicaan Stingers averaged 20,722.268 DPS. These pets were always good, they've been the best fighter option KDF side for years now and I'd say they damn well hold that title still. It has been a good year or two since I myself have parsed the Stingers but previously they averaged around 12k, nearly an 8k performance increase when talking about the pure average.

Downfalls? Well, they like the Castrois are pretty fragile, though unlike the Castrois even if they die it seems they can continue to perform instead of having damage drop off. Other than that the only other con you could even begin to attach to them is having to buy the Kolasi Siege Destroyer to unlock them, but that's a small thing in comparison to other ships on this list that require lockbox or promotion ships to unlock. Plus, once you own the Kolasi, they are unlocked and useable on any ship on your KDF. A Dreadnought Carrier with 2 hangars of these would see great results and is something I look forward to the day all ships have a t6 mastery or some way to unlock account wide.

Overall these are incredible. For how inexpensive it is to get these fighters, how versatile they are, being able to be used on any ship with a hangar. They are an absolute must in my opinion. And with the changes to Romulan's and the introduction of Jem'hadars, KDF aligned Roms and JHs can make use of these as well. Their only real fault as mentioned above, is how fragile they are, though that's a trait that is associated with almost all fighter hangars, and they seem able to cope with it far better than other hangars.


Elite - Aeon Timeships

Weapons

WeaponsNotes
Antiproton Beam Array
Antiproton Beam Array
Chroniton Torpedo LaunchersWho even knows anymore o.O

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Subatomic Disruptorhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Subatomic_Disruptor
Torpedo High Yield IIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Torpedo:_High_Yield

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunsPet 1Pet 2Pet 3Pet 4Pet 5Pet 6CombinedParse Image
ISA #13,201.562,965.152,918.202,909.502,285.312,146.6317,759.81Parse 1, botched this one by forgetting to slot them before queueing, so I had to wait for the timer before launching any, still performed well though a few died
ISA #24,291.833,627.813,525.653,492.652,813.631,928.3020,239.08Parse 2
ISA #33,143.612,839.632,685.012,451.842,24.011,096.5616,548.61Parse 3
ISA #43,294.712,975.182,810.182,809.292,630.632,060.4717,186.38Parse 4
ISA #53,354.143,240.043,081.272,990.582,847.261,670.6618,521.14Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs, 1 hangar of Elite - Aeon Timeships averaged 18,051.004 DPS. These may be the biggest surprise yet. They are extremely fragile, with every run suffering some casualties, but overall they exceeded my expectations in performance. Pre-patch, 1 hangar of these averaged 8-12k. They've gained 6k DPS post patch, making them very potent and viable pets.

Downfalls? Same as the rest of the fighters, very squishy, possibly the weakest of the fighters tested as both the Stingers and Castrois had at least 1 run where none died. But much like the Stingers even if some die, they can continue to perform with the difference between their best and lowest performing runs being only 3,690.47 DPS.

Overall these are excellent pets that really shine post patch. They perform well and aren't set back by deaths like a lot of pets that need to build momentum. Their Subatomic Disruptor spreading -DRR around is also quite nice for debuffing. They're all around very solid pets and if you have a Paradox, I can wholeheartedly endorse these. Would I buy a Paradox just for these pets? That's a tough question. The Paradox in its own right is a very solid Sci Dreadnought, and these are overall very solid pets. Ultimately I can't make any decision for you. There are always going to be more affordable options out there that perform just as well or equivalent. These pets being useable on any ship so long as you own a Paradox is a big boon in their favor.


Elite - Kelvin Timeline Assault Drone

Weapons

WeaponNotes
Phaser Emitter Arrays
Kelvin Photon Torpedo Launcher x1Heyyyy the one that is singular for a change

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Ramhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Ramming_Speed
Torpedo Spread Ihttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Torpedo:_Spread
Beam Fire at Will Ihttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beam_Array:_Fire_at_Will

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunsPet 1Pet 2Pet 3Pet 4Pet 5Pet 6CombinedParse Image
ISA #15,327.794,682.484,677.823,960.472,760.382,639.3324,770.70Parse 1
ISA #24,861.034,549.104,239.214,165.394,029.903,705.5126,028.19Parse 2
ISA #33,600.943,210.002,956.112,897.812,306.411,923.6518,474.03Parse 3
ISA #45,057.144,627.454,056.863,958.813,852.162,823.1325,740.05Parse 4
ISA #53,792.613,704.943,452.172,774.642,700.791,753.6521,738.07Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs, 1 hangar of Elite - Kelvin Timeline Assault Drones averaged 23,350.208 DPS. These drones have always been incredible pets that only further boost the Vengeance's status as one of the best Fed ships in the game. Pre Patch, they would average around 16-18k. So like a lot of other pets they've seen roughly a 5k increase in DPS.

Downfalls? Extremely squishy. Every single parse had at least one Drone die, and most had multiple. Luckily they seem to hold on pretty well like the Aeons and Stingers. Their only other real downfall is their long launch time. It can make it troublesome to get more back out on the field especially if you have launch pets in your spam bar or Macro'd.

Overall these pets are absolutely fantastic. If you have a Vengeance these are the pets you should be using on it, period. I wish they were ship unlocked so they could be useable on everything with a hangar, but then they probably wouldn't be this awesome so.


Elite - Elachi Qulash Frigate

Fore Weapons

WeaponNotes
Elachi Dual Cannon
Elachi Dual Heavy Cannon
Elachi Torpedo Launcher

Aft Weapons

WeaponNotes
Elachi Turret

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Elusive TargetAllows the Qulash Frigate to quickly outmaneuver foes that get too close.
Torpedo Spread IIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Torpedo:_Spread
Cannon Rapid Fire IIICannon Weapon Enhancement Mode, Causes cannons to fire 50% more shots per second for 10 seconds while dealing 120% more damage during this duration
Sub-Space JumpAllows the Qulash Frigate to teleport 5km behind their current target.
Evade Target Lock Ihttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Evade_Target_Lock

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2CombinedParse Image
ISA #15,406.755,235.2010,641.95Parse 1
ISA #26,656.453,034.289,690.73Parse 2
ISA #35,414.615,063.7810,478.39Parse 3
ISA #48,265.813,518.1811,783.99Parse 4
ISA #58,694.994,013.8712,708.86Parse 5

Summary

Across 5 runs, 1 hangar of Elite - Elachi Qualash Frigates averaged 11,060.784 DPS. For pets that can only be used on the Sheshar, and having such a high price tag, I hoped these would be better, but overall they are pretty disappointing. When the Sheshar first released they were absolutely horrendous, only parsing around 2-3k from what I can recall. In patches since then, they've received some targeted attention.

Downfalls? Many. They have the longest launch time of any of the pets I tested, and possibly one of the longest launch times period meaning your second pet is almost always going to perform less than the first. They're slow and bulky, they don't seem to be in much of a hurry to do anything or go anywhere. They do full impulse without any issues so they do have that going for them. Part of the problem that ties into the previous point, is the Elusive Target and Sub-Space Jump. Like previously mentioned, pet AI isn't the smartest(neither is most NPC AI but that's a whole other thread of its own) they aren't smart enough to know when to use these abilities to their maximum effect, often times causing them to lose time on target because they activated either of them and lost target lock.

Overall these Frigates are pretty disappointing. They aren't Yukawa or Shuk-Din level of disappointment, but if I was going to run the Sheshar full time I'd choose an alternative and not spend valuable resources on these. I do plan on testing the Elachi Fighters in the next phase of testing so stay tuned for that.


Elite - Tholian Mesh Weavers

Weapons

WeaponNotes
Tetryon Dual Beam Bank
Tetryon Dual Beam Bank
Tetryon Beam Array
Tholian Thermionic Torpedo

Abilities

AbilityDescription
Beam Fire at Will IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Beam_Array:_Fire_at_Will
Attack Pattern Beta IIIhttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Attack_Pattern_Beta
Evasive Maneuvers Ihttps://sto.gamepedia.com/Ability:_Evasive_Maneuvers

Parse Breakdown

ISA RunPet 1Pet 2CombinedParse Image
ISA #14,287.352,491.629,210.39Parse 1, both died after right transformer mysteriously
ISA #26,254.924,362.1613,133.09Parse 2, more deaths
ISA #34,029.252,362.629,358.91Parse 3 so many deaths
ISA #47,722.077,419.0715,141.14Parse 4, none died this time wooo
ISA #57,792.515,657.4015,137.08Parse 5 died :(

Summary

Across 5 runs, 1 hangar of Elite - Tholian Meshweaves averaged 12,396.122 DPS. Meshweavers aren't known for being high DPSing pets themselves, more so for their Attack Pattern Beta III but overall I'd say these pets can perform while also debuffing and helping the team at the same time.

Downfalls? Out of the frigate pets I tested, these are easily the weakest. Only 1 run had zero casualties where the rest either lost one or both pets. Their AI also doesn't seem to be the smartest as they'll linger behind and it doesn't look like they are Impulse Bursting into combat as they should.

Overall the standout feature of these pets is still APB3. If they can survive they can put up some decent numbers, but overall they are best used for what we already knew, APB3 DRR debuff spam.