Q: Okay, but you catch more flies with honey than vinegar. More people would be on your side if you weren't so aggressive.
A: This is called a tone argument[2] and has been used to silence and dismiss marginalized groups for a long time. At the end of the day, these groups are allowed to express their feelings in what ever ways they see fit (so long as they don't break any laws). Telling a minority to "be less angry" about their status and treatment in order to make the majority more comfortable is, frankly, bullshit. Especially when those making the tone argument are the ones least affected.
I'm not sure about this one. I'll list my concerns one at a time.
At the end of the day, these groups are allowed to express their feelings in what ever ways they see fit
Sure. But I think most people with the viewpoint in the question (myself included) are not trying to dictate what people are and are not allowed to say. Rather, they are making a suggestion that they believe to be in the marginalised group's best interest.
Telling a minority to "be less angry" about their status and treatment in order to make the majority more comfortable is, frankly, bullshit.
I acknowledge that people who are discriminated against have absolutely every right to be angry. However, this suggestion has absolutely nothing to do with making people with discriminatory attitudes comfortable. On the contrary, the rationale behind it is to make those who are discriminated against more comfortable.
I believe that people with bigoted attitudes should be approached in the manner which is most likely to change those views. This has nothing to with their comfort, and everything to do with decreasing the net shittiness in the world for marginalised minority groups.
Now, people who are sick of being shit on by idiots absolutely have every right to circlejerk about how idiotic they are. But it's not going to decrease the world's net level of bullshit by as much as other courses of action, which I would think would be a goal for anyone who has been discriminated against.
Especially when those making the tone argument are the ones least affected.
Finally, I'm a straight, white cismale, about as privileged as it gets. I'm the guy making the tone argument who is least affected. I accept that due to this privilege, I lack important perspective, which may warp my view on these issues. However, I don't think that should automatically invalidate my views, nor my right to have and express them.
I think my arguments should be evaluated on their merit, rather than based on who is making them. If you think some part of my view might be different if I possessed the perspective of someone less privileged than I am, point it out to me, and I'll be happy to take it into consideration, and potentially change my opinion.
Please do this after actually finding something wrong with my views, rather than dismissing them out of hand simply because of who I am.
I'll be happy to discuss any part of my beliefs on this matter in the comments.