r/SRSQuestions • • Aug 08 '15

Why is joking about sensitive topics not okay?

1 Upvotes

When a joke is made that is racist/sexist/rapey or whatever but it's also clearly intended only for humor and has no basis in reality, why is it unacceptable? I understand that some people may have had experiences that make certain jokes very uncomfortable and I'm always willing to respect that, but why are some jokes considered inherently unacceptable by this community? And if it is forbidden to make jokes at the expense of certain people, isn't that clear evidence of inequality in favor of those people?


r/SRSQuestions • • Sep 24 '15

Why the hatred towards all men?

2 Upvotes

It seems like me just being cisgender and doing nothing immediately means I'm awful.

A la the SRSMen sidebar: "Women and anyone else who doesn't identify as a man are super duper welcome!"

And the SRSWomen sidebar: "Men = Benned."

I'm sort of neutral on your guys' stance, but if I wanted to at least get involved, it seems I might as well not even try because I'm hated for what I identify myself as(which is kind of ironic).

What's the point of an subreddit that has men in the title if it isn't even for men? And the women one is also not for men?

Please don't flame me or belittle me for my genuine curiosity. I just want to know.

Edit: I was already downvoted without anyone even posting... Not exactly inspiring.


r/SRSQuestions • • Mar 10 '14

Are agender/nonbinary identities appropriative?

0 Upvotes

I'm struggling with something and wanted some outside perspective. Bit of background, I'm male born/assigned at birth and this is the identity I've so far lived in but I'm finding myself increasingly confused. I'm not a woman and don't want to alter my body, but at the same time I am not comfortable identifying as a man. I think I intend to remain primarily 'male presenting' but I'm hoping to develop confidence to be much less gender restricted in things like appearance, clothing, etc.

However, I'm concerned that identifying in this way is appropriative of the struggles of 'real' trans* people. I am also wary of invading trans/female safe spaces but at the same time worry there is a lack of spaces for me to exist in.

Sorry if any of this is a bit confused, I've been rewriting this post in my head over the past few days. Please share any thoughts, opinions or advice you may have.


r/SRSQuestions • • May 30 '13

Question about transphobia

0 Upvotes

Greetings!

So we were having ourselves a discussion on TumblrinAction about how this one person said that if you wouldn't go out with a trans person then you are clearly transphobic and I had a question. Obviously I know my perspective on things and the general perception of TiA but I'm genuinely curious as to the SRS perspective on things. Assuming that you agree with the original assessment of transphobia that is.

So, if I wouldn't be interested in going out with a Trans woman because I want to have a child that is part me, part my partner is that transphobic?

Thanks in advance!


r/SRSQuestions • • Jan 11 '13

What's the word that describes someone who judges their own gender-ethnic group more harshly than other groups?

0 Upvotes

I will always yell at white middle class guys for being shitlords but I'm not likely to yell at a woman for her internalised misogyny or an Asian looking person for their racism against other Asian looking people. What is this called?

Edit: thanks for your answers.

I think I was asking two questions. I wanted to know a better word for internalised prejudice against people of similar identity (internalised homo oppression?) i.e. Asian people who voice that all Asian people are better at maths and science.

The other word is similar to tact i.e. why I wouldn't call out Asian persons on their internalised homo oppression as I am a white person.


r/SRSQuestions • • Apr 17 '13

"LGBT" or "GLBT" ?

0 Upvotes

r/SRSQuestions • • Jan 12 '14

My problems with one of the questions in the main FAQ

0 Upvotes

Q: Okay, but you catch more flies with honey than vinegar. More people would be on your side if you weren't so aggressive.

A: This is called a tone argument[2] and has been used to silence and dismiss marginalized groups for a long time. At the end of the day, these groups are allowed to express their feelings in what ever ways they see fit (so long as they don't break any laws). Telling a minority to "be less angry" about their status and treatment in order to make the majority more comfortable is, frankly, bullshit. Especially when those making the tone argument are the ones least affected.

I'm not sure about this one. I'll list my concerns one at a time.

At the end of the day, these groups are allowed to express their feelings in what ever ways they see fit

Sure. But I think most people with the viewpoint in the question (myself included) are not trying to dictate what people are and are not allowed to say. Rather, they are making a suggestion that they believe to be in the marginalised group's best interest.

Telling a minority to "be less angry" about their status and treatment in order to make the majority more comfortable is, frankly, bullshit.

I acknowledge that people who are discriminated against have absolutely every right to be angry. However, this suggestion has absolutely nothing to do with making people with discriminatory attitudes comfortable. On the contrary, the rationale behind it is to make those who are discriminated against more comfortable.
I believe that people with bigoted attitudes should be approached in the manner which is most likely to change those views. This has nothing to with their comfort, and everything to do with decreasing the net shittiness in the world for marginalised minority groups.
Now, people who are sick of being shit on by idiots absolutely have every right to circlejerk about how idiotic they are. But it's not going to decrease the world's net level of bullshit by as much as other courses of action, which I would think would be a goal for anyone who has been discriminated against.

Especially when those making the tone argument are the ones least affected.

Finally, I'm a straight, white cismale, about as privileged as it gets. I'm the guy making the tone argument who is least affected. I accept that due to this privilege, I lack important perspective, which may warp my view on these issues. However, I don't think that should automatically invalidate my views, nor my right to have and express them.

I think my arguments should be evaluated on their merit, rather than based on who is making them. If you think some part of my view might be different if I possessed the perspective of someone less privileged than I am, point it out to me, and I'll be happy to take it into consideration, and potentially change my opinion.

Please do this after actually finding something wrong with my views, rather than dismissing them out of hand simply because of who I am.

I'll be happy to discuss any part of my beliefs on this matter in the comments.


r/SRSQuestions • • Apr 02 '14

What does your "reddit self" look like?

0 Upvotes

Who are you while you use reddit? Philosopher, artist, naysayer?

Reddit is a special place: a place of immense diversity in race, culture, location, opinions and much more. Who do you see yourself as in this shared community called reddit? I want to open discussion to how people adopt personalities while on reddit (if they do), and to see what that personality looks like.

To clarify, what I'm asking for, ideally, is a picture of something- humanoid, cartooned, meme, a black square, whatever- that you feel represents who you are while you're using reddit. For an example, look at my post in the comments.

Additionally: why do you like use reddit and what subreddits you frequent? What does reddit provide for you?

tl;dr: post a pic something that you feel like represents your "reddit personality," share why you like to use reddit and what subreddits you visit often :)

Edit: posted this in AskReddit but thought this might be an interesting place to have it, too


r/SRSQuestions • • Jun 16 '14

So a question on downvotes on SRS Prime?

0 Upvotes

Are downvotes all from reverse-brigaders? Or do SRSers ever downvote (non-troll) things on there?


r/SRSQuestions • • Aug 03 '13

Is there a term for "was woman friendly, till men came and started shitting up the place"

0 Upvotes

I've been calling it manholing but theres gotta something of an actual term for it right?


r/SRSQuestions • • Dec 10 '13

Do we really hate reddit as much as we claim, or is that just circlequeefing?

0 Upvotes

I know already that the reddit hivemind is sexist and racist, and I agree that's bad. However, I've been seeing lots of comments on prime saying that reddit is just a terrible place in general. I don't agree with this. Most of the posts and comments on reddit, barring the sexist and racist ones, are actually pretty high quality. I mean, you can pretty much count on an expert in a certain field to give a detailed and well written explanation in ELI5, or you can find some hilarious original jokes or puns in pretty much any comedic post (like this). It seems to me that reddit has far better comments and content than any other website on the internet. Also, if we all hate reddit as much as we say we do, why are we still here? Why haven't we evacuated to somewhere like thefempire.org?

I hope nobody thinks I'm a shitlord for saying this. It is often difficult to distinguish sarcasm and sincerity. I honestly don't know if we're serious or not.


r/SRSQuestions • • May 12 '14

Met a real life shitlord. What do I do? ***Possible TW***: some racist examples no slurs and tried to keep it to minimum

0 Upvotes

TL;DR or don't care to see description of racism below. Coworker at high end club is very racist. Tries to get me to be racist with her. I don't know how to respond. Don't want drama in the work place, but also want to make it clear that's not okay. The most I've come up with is saying "I don't know about that.." Awkwardly What to do?!

I work with a woman who says the most vile things about minorities. She even called a black man the n slur to his face. She straight up says racist things to me personally.

We're both dancers at a high end club. I'm not sure if the manager knows she does this kind of thing. An example of her behavior toward me

"I have a lot of trouble with the Japanese men who come in. The language barrier is really frustrating to me; I can't really understand them and they want to talk for forever" that was me. Her reply? "Yeah, if I wanted to talk to a baby, I'd talk to a fucking baby." I don't feel comfortable writing the rest. I didn't know how to respond, so I said "I don't know about that" and laughed awkwardly and busied myself with something while she continued on her rant against Asians.

We have Korean women waitressing in our club and she told them Koreans smell funny. WTF??!?

What am I supposed to say or do when she does these things? Recommend American History X? How can I do this tactfuly as I have to work closely with her for the next 2 1/2 months?


r/SRSQuestions • • May 17 '13

If SRS is about equality, then why is it a circlejerk instead of a forum for debate?

0 Upvotes

Let me explain who I am and the perspective I am coming from before I explain my questions:

First and foremost I came here to ask my question as an attempt to understand SRS, not to hate on it. Please don't take any of this personally/ban me etc.

I am a biracial cisgender man, a progressive, a feminist, a straight ally, a strong advocate of sexual consent, and most of all an advocate for equality and harmony among all humans. I am a feminist because I believe that sex and gender should play no part in determining privilege and opportunity in our society. However, I see srsprime as going against this goal. Instead of tearing down boundaries between the sexes, it puts more up by sliencing dissent and disallowing honest debate. A space dominated by women, or any other group, is just as sexist as one dominated by men in my opinion. I am concerned that this lack of conclusiveness further diminishes the legitimacy of feminism in the eyes of mainstream society by letting the ignorant dismiss "those crazy feminists" as authoritarians who silence anyone questioning their orthodoxy. I just feel really strongly, if we believe the white male orthodoxy that dominates reddit is wrong, isn't enforcing any orthodoxy as well against the principles of equality that we claim to stand for?

If this is not the goal of SRS, what is it? I am just trying to understand its purpose and justification and how it goes about promoting equality if it seemingly perpetrates some of the things it claims to be against.

Once again, no disrespect intended. I am looking forward to a robust intellectual conversation where we seek consensus (I went to a Quaker high school and consensus is something I value)


r/SRSQuestions • • Jun 25 '14

My dad's officially a neckbeard. What to do?

6 Upvotes

I was considering making a snarky checkbox style list of stereotypes he fits and examples, but that would take too long. Bottom line, he fits EVERY SINGLE stereotype he's been given a chance to fit (his opinion on pedo/ephebehebhebehbehophilia is unknown since the topic never came up): mysoginist, biotruther, redpiller (BIG time, he practically idolizes Tom Leykis), MRA, SAWCASM who thinks his view is the most valid, racist, was audibly glad when I made it clear I was cis, gun enthusiast, libertarian, conspiracy theorist, outspoken atheist, I really could go on. It all just clicked today when I was trying to have a discussion on why he didn't want me to take psychiatric medication for my depression/anxiety/general mental fuckery, and through some tangents he made it clear that, among other things, women gaining the right to vote was a bad thing because they'll only vote for the cute one or the Kardashian or w/e. He also explicitly used the words "logical" and "emotional" and "rational/irrational" in his description of gender differences, and claimed that women aren't worse than men at the same time, like the truest of the (bio)truthers (he's also the other kind of truther but w/e). Later when I tried to explain the concept of privilege against my better judgement, I gave the example of white privilege = being able to leave a store empty-handed without being suspected of shoplifting, and he basically said minorities brought that upon themselves because they're statistically responsible for more crimes since there are so many in jail. When I asked why he thinks that is he offhandedly mentioned possible socioeconomic factors, which made it all the more painful because of his steadfast refusal to get it. From past talks he also would like to live in the Middle East because women know their place there, and that Rosa Parks was a whiny bitch who refused to give her seat to a frail old man (no clue where that last detail came from, probably just to further justify his racism). Bottom line, I'm being raised by a well-meaning but currently social justice-blind (from growing up in Soviet Russia) mom, and a redditor. How do I survive the next year until I turn 18 and can finally make my own decisions?

Edit: I'm also gay and he doesn't know AFAIK, but given reddit's stance and how close his is to theirs in other respects coming out would be really, really, dumb


r/SRSQuestions • • Dec 31 '12

Is preferring your own gender homophobic?

0 Upvotes

Anyway, I read this other thread with interest, and I completely agree that it is shitlordy as hell to decide beforehand that you aren't attracted to an entire race. But that got me thinking, does this apply to straight people? Are they homophobic for thinking that they could never be attracted to another person of the same gender? I am asexual, so I guess this applies to me as well.


r/SRSQuestions • • Dec 28 '15

Question about a specific joke many SRS'rs find offensive.

2 Upvotes

The whole attack helicopter thing, to me at least has always been about people who are tumblr-style otherkin, NEVER trans individuals. I'm trying to figure out where the idea that the phrase is inherently transphobic.

In addition I guess I'll throw in why does* SRS seems so vehemently against dark humor. I can laugh about jokes targeted at my race, kinks, sexuality etc.., but it seems like many in this/that sub take them as inherently ill-meant when in reality I feel its just jabbing fun at something.

Note, I am 'white' but look Puerto Rican and male, but probably what you'd call gender queer or on the gender spectrum.

*edit a word.


r/SRSQuestions • • Jan 02 '13

Why does /r/feminism link to /r/antiSRS in the sidebar?

14 Upvotes

http://www.reddit.com/r/feminism

What the fuck? Surely they have more in common with us than the rape apologists and brave defenders of bigotry over on AntiSRS, but if they have a problem with SRS, why would they link to AntiSRS, and just not link to SRS? it's as if they are condoning the defense of all the hateful shit that gets posted on Reddit...

I can see why people might not like the fempire, but surely it's better to just ignore the issue all together than say you are fully against the calling out of misogynistic shit on Reddit by putting a link to that crap in the sidebar? The people who are actively against SRS are almost always ignorant rape apologists and disrespectful assholes, I don't understand why you would rather side with them than SRS, or neither... It's so strange to me, can someone explain this?


r/SRSQuestions • • May 01 '13

I don't know if this is quite the right place to ask, but it's been bugging me lately. What's with the whole SRS is racist jerk going on everywhere?

7 Upvotes

Seriously, I don't get it, is it just people trying to dredge up anything they can for shit to fling at us? Is it something to do with the whole reverse racismtm jerk? It genuinely baffles me that they pick something so utterly out of the blue, so completely fractally wrong to throw around. So yeah, just, why?

Edit: It seems I've struck a nerve with this one, it's getting bridged all to hell, not sure whether I should delete it or not.


r/SRSQuestions • • Mar 27 '14

Looking for youtube videos on sex and gender theory!

0 Upvotes

Hey guys! I'm presenting some videos in my Sociology of Sexuality class and would like to know if anybody has some recommendations on videos that can be shown and properly linked to classic gender and sexuality theorists such as Judith Butler and Adrienne Rich.

Please, no "Sex: 101" videos = we all have a pretty good idea of what constitutes sexuality, but I'd like to display media which breaks it down using social theory and criticism.

Thanks!


r/SRSQuestions • • Feb 28 '15

Anyone else feel that Reddit discussions have gone down hill?

0 Upvotes

The top comment on a picture of a delicious looking stop is a dick pic? We finally make a big victory on Net Neutrality and the top comments are all negative and conspiratorial? Stuff like that. It feels like it has become 'Ventland.' I guess it always kind of was, but it feels like it is getting worse. There are still some amazing things being posted and making it to the front page, but the conversation has gone downhill imo.


r/SRSQuestions • • Oct 18 '13

Do you identify as a "social justice (warrior/____/xyz)" as part of your identity?

0 Upvotes

I personally don't. I'm an anarchist communist. I am against all heirarchies, which includes patriarchy/racism/etc, but I don't call myself a social justice warrior or whatevz. I have personal beliefs that lead me to certain beliefs. But those are from a certain base, no a priori


r/SRSQuestions • • Mar 07 '18

Are some SJWs guilty of hypocrisy on this point?

0 Upvotes

Alice: Am I allowed to say <word>?

Bob: No you may not.

Alice: Why is that?

Bob: Because if you say <word> then you are evil.

Alice: But Charles says <word> all the time and you don't judge him as evil.

Bob: It is okay for Charles to say <word> because he belongs in <Category X> while you belong in <Category Y>.

Alice: But you just said that it is evil to say <word>!

Bob: It's only evil for people in <Category X> to say <word>.

However, I believe that Bob is being a hypocrite, because he is advocating a standard ("saying <word> is evil") that he does not really believe ("...but it is only evil for people in <category Y> to say the word.")


r/SRSQuestions • • Apr 06 '13

SAWCSM looking for advice on calling people out

2 Upvotes

Hi, as mentioned in the title, I'm a SAWCSM who in the past few months has woken up to my privilege and all the horrible, oppressive shit that goes on after being called out on some pretty terrible stuff I said. I've since been working a lot on looking inwards on my own internalized oppressive beliefs, but I've also been working on trying to be a good ally. The hardest part for me has been in actually calling people out on bullshit.

I've recently started trying this out, and I've found it really... uncomfortable, which I suppose I should have expected. I think to myself "Oh maybe you're overreacting", "its not your business to tell them off", or "are you sure that that's oppressive?" when I do try to call people on oppressive/derogatory statements etc.

I'll give you an example: My university held its annual Drag Show last night, which is really popular. One of my facebook friends posted that he was going. One of his friends commented

"Better bring some Chlorox wipes and not touch anything."

I thought this sounded pretty shitty and trans-phobic so I commented with the following:

I'm sorry ______, but what are you trying to insinuate? That those participating are unclean in some way? That they are "dirty" because they're transgender, genderqueer, or men dressing in women's clothes? That people should take some kind of precaution due to the assumed uncleanliness of the assumedly promiscuous performers because they're transgender? Michael, maybe you think you're just making a joke, but what you're really doing is dehumanizing the people involved in that event. So go fuck yourself.

And this was the response:

i was just making a joke - i love the queens, and think what they do is pretty impressive, even though i would never do it myself. im sorry if my comment offended you, (i've deleted it) i was not trying to make sweeping negative stereotypes against drag. i am a performer and gay myself so i like to poke harmless fun sometimes - idk what i'd do without a good hour of rupaul's drag race...

So I guess my question is: Was I overreacting? Was I right to call them out? Am I fucking up in some way that I'm not even realizing? How do I respond to something like that? I'm feeling pretty conflicted right now and could use some advice.

Thanks.


r/SRSQuestions • • Mar 10 '14

Is there anything problematic with my idea for a subreddit?

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm thinking of creating a subreddit that I have been wanting but have not found in existence already, and I thought I'd run the idea past you guys first to make sure nothing about it is problematic. Basically, I'm a woman who finds men that crossdress extremely attractive. While there are a few subs out there specifically for crossdressers themselves to get tips and share personal photos, I want to create a collection of beautiful photos of crossdressers specifically geared towards those that admire them. Basically, the men I most often see in /r/ladyboners just don't do it for me, so this would be my version of that concept.

However, I want to make sure this won't come off as me ogling these men in a creepy way like SRS calls out male redditors for doing to women. I definitely won't allow any photos clearly taken without the subject's consent or ones that feature underage subjects. I also won't tolerate anyone mocking the men featured for displaying femininity because that is not my intended purpose at all; I want to celebrate these men. Because of that, I additionally won't allow any photos of men crossdressing as a form of mockery against the act of crossdressing itself or against trans* people.

With that said, would this subreddit still make anyone out there feel uncomfortable? Or do you have any additional tips to help me avoid any problematic situations?