I'm gonna tell a story, at least the bare bones of it, because it's relevant to stuff I think about here sometimes. I will either be bragging, or else tragically admitting to Beta-ness, depending on your point of view.
So I met this woman on the internets see, and she was looking for a "cuddle buddy," somebody to cuddle with, with sex an option but not primary. We had gotten together once, a month or so ago (I have very little time free of child care responsibilities where I can make visits like this happen) and had lots of wonderful cuddles and some outstanding sex.
We'd finally scheduled another visit, for today, and a few days ago we were texting about all the sex & cuddling we wanted to happen, and then the next day I got a text that said, "can we just make it nonsexual cuddles this time?" I said "yeah, if that's what you're comfortable with, of course!" In a couple subsequent texts I got that she was upset with herself about something, but no details.
So on the one hand I was OK with this but on the other it put a bunch of discomfort and doubt in my head.
Part of it was that I just didn't know why, or what was going on with her, but I knew I'd find out eventually.
I surmised that she had had sex with someone else and felt bad about it, had a bad experience, somebody was not good to her, and it had put her "off" sex for the moment.
I kind of had this weird "wait, somebody was a jerk to you, and got to have sex with you, and you know I won't be, and I don't get too..." It was kind of "friendzoney" logic territory I saw myself wandering into. The "oh, the assholes get laid and then I'm there when you don't want to have sex, because I'm safe?" kind of thing, you know the sort of horseshit that PUAs shovel. I recognized it as horseshit even as I was thinking it, but I didn't really know what was going on with her so I didn't have reality to substitute for it.
Anyway, I'm not stupid, I recognize bullshit thinking for what it is, so I tried to come to terms with exactly what was bothering me and what I needed. Answer was: I felt like my sexuality was rejected/devalued as a part of me, and I wanted it to be affirmed.
OK. Guess what, I'm a grownup, I can see about attending to my own needs. I needed affirmation, I thought of somebody who could affirm me and talked to her, talked about the situation a little, got what perspective on it she could shed (not too much, not knowing exactly what was going on, but what she said was helpful) and eventually with some trepidation I straight up asked, hey, basically I need somebody to reassure me that I'm sexy. (It was difficult to ask that then and it's difficult to type that now, cause acknowledging that kind of neediness is extremely awkward.) I also gave her this helpful GIF to illustrate my situation: http://i.imgur.com/8GL6L.gif
She briefly gave me the reassurance I needed and I felt a lot better
Aside: it's really really hard to ask people for what you need sometimes, even if you know exactly what you need and know that they can give it to you.
So today came. During the intervening time I found myself totally OK with getting together and not having sex, as it happened, cause I'm not a complete horndog in general. I wasn't sure I'd stay that OK with it when we touched, because these days nothing turns me on more than physical contact, but... whatevs. I needed the cuddles too damn it, it's been a hard few weeks.
We got together and cuddled an talked and I learned what had been going on with her.
What the deal was is that she's had a few situations lately where she had said "yes" to men that she didn't really want to say "yes" to, and felt like shit afterward. One involved a man who lied to her about a crucial fact to get with her, and she suspected he was lying but wasn't sure so she didn't say "no." She was really struggling with boundaries. We talked about it and I talked about my thoughts about the messed-upness of the commodity model of sex, and I guess that was helpful, and so on.
So basically, as I understand it, what she really badly needed was practice establishing boundaries and having them respected, and she trusted me to be someone she could do that with. Like, I was a safe zone where she could have a boundary that was meaningful, because we both really did want each other, but which she wouldn't have to fight for.
I'm down with that. In the end there was no reason for me to feel like my sexuality was rejected or devalued... it was absolutely not about me. Not even a little.
And it was absolutely nothing even vaguely like the "assholes get laid, good guys get to pick up the pieces" thing. Know what the assholes got? Sex with somebody who didn't really like it or feel good about it. They can keep that. I don't want that. They'll have to find it somewhere else, cause this girl is growing some boundaries.
We didn't keep it completely nonsexual. At a couple points, asking her first, I moved into some sexual touching situations, and she enjoyed them very much, as did I.... and let me know when she wanted to stop because it was getting to be more than she could take and not just drop everything and fuck. And I stopped. And we went back to cuddles.
Oh, we made out a bit too.
Anyways... I had a wonderful time, even if I spent a some time with very achy balls afterwards. And I was absolutely affirmed as a sexual being. Absolutely. And yes we are going to get together for some straight up wild fucking and bdsm play (we're both into that, and met on fetlife).
And the shitty way of looking at the situation that had haunted me was entirely bullshit, and the reality of the situation was, once you got all the nuances, absolutely not at all threatening to me and in fact pretty great.
So yeah. I am finding it helpful these days to actively root out shitty thinking about sex, commodity model, that kind of thing, and find out what the reality is that it is obscuring.
TL;DR:
shitty thinking: "Some alpha dude got to fuck this woman I want; I'm a nice guy so I don't get to??"
reality: "some dipshit got to have sex with a woman who didn't actually want to be fucking him or really desire him at all, but who just wasn't very good at saying 'no.' That's a shitty situation for everyone involved, and I wouldn't want to be in his shoes, cause I want my penis to be desired, not grudgingly tolerated against one's better judgment. I got to have a lot of fun touching a woman who really enjoyed it, and I'm in a happy situation of mutual trust and desire, and if we do get together to fuck in the future -- and we both want to -- all that mutual trust and desire is going to make it pretty awesome."
EDIT: I'm really grateful for people who thought this was me being awesome, but really it was just me meeting minimum standards of human decency. I didn't post it cause I thought I did anything great but because it points out how simplistic SEXTRUTHS (beep boop) may at first glance seem to describe a situation, but when you actually pay attention to what's really going on, it's way more nuanced than that, and if you believed the SEXTRUTHS you would miss out on everything important that's going on.