r/SRSDiscussion • • Jan 06 '12

[Effort] An American Perspective: Why Black People Complain So Much.

1.4k Upvotes

BEWARE. THE MOST EFFORTFUL OF EFFORTPOSTS.

Why are minorities so annoyed all the time?

When SRS rolls into town, it is a common occurrence that the discussion turns toward bigotry, the use of offensive racial language as well as stereotypes, and Caucasian-American privilege. Often well-intentioned liberals and anti-racists have been game for a scuffle and have put forth some very excellent points. I commend you. You are a credit to all of our races.

However, I find myself occasionally scrunching my nose up at what I find to be one of the weakest arguments that arises. The idea of the echo of a racist past. The belief that racism has deleterious effects passed down through generations once those policies that were in place have been removed is a substantive point. If one group was denied education, they are at a distinct disadvantage when it comes to legacies and finances. If one group was denied any representation, they have to work to move the Overton window until their very civil rights become acceptable.

Now, before I get too deep into it, I have to say that this is a very valid point and based off of the nature of civil realities as much as discourse. And since it is so valid, it is often the easy point to make. But there is one big problem. It assumes that racism and racist policies just suddenly ended. It implies that the system now works and it is simply groups trying to catch up that explains why they are so far behind.

AfAm educational attainment is about half that of C-Am and C-Am educational attainment is about half that of AsAm. As for average salaries, AfAms make 20% less than C-Ams who make 8% less than AsAms. However, the poverty rate for AfAms is 3 times that of C-Ams while AsAm poverty is currently 25% higher than poverty rates for C-Ams (AsAm poverty is relatively steady, but C-Am poverty has been increasing toward it due to the recession, so as little as 5 years ago the difference was 50%). If AsAms have twice as much schooling as C-Ams, why would they have higher rates of poverty? The simple answer seems to be in legacies of inherited wealth, which minorities lack due to how recently they achieved access to educational opportunities.

--> That, of course, in no way explains why college-educated Asian-Americans have unemployment rates 33% higher than those of Caucasian-Americans despite double the educational attainment levels.

So we hit a telling snag with the echo of a racist past point. For example, AfAm salaries are 14% higher than non-white Hispanic/non-white Latino salaries and educational attainment is up to 50% higher for AfAms but poverty levels for blacks are slightly higher than for Hispanics.

Something has to explain why education and salary are not good indicators of socioeconomic status for some groups compared to others.


Why are black people so annoyed all the time?

Since I'm black and have far more experience exploring these issues from a black perspective, that will be the point of view from which this effort post goes forth. Now, let's start at the beginning. And I don't mean with your typical little kids are raised to be racist against blacks meta-horror but with some systemic failures of the justice system.

First, children are generally not responsible for most of their stupid decisions. And yet, we have a corrective system in place to handle juveniles who break the law. That juvenile system imprisons black youths at six times the rate as white youths -- for the same crimes, with no criminal record. More importantly, despite being only about 15% of the under-18 population, black youths are 40% of all youths tried as adults and 58% of all youths sent to adult prisons. Black youths arrested for the same violent crimes as whites when comparing those with no prior record were nine times as likely to be incarcerated. Nine. Fucking. Times. NINE HUNDRED PERCENT.

Of course, if you're tried as an adult, your record isn't expunged and you can stay in prison past the age of 18. This means a non-Hispanic white can commit just as many crimes as a black person and the black person will be treated like a career criminal and the white person may not even be sentenced to probation.

But let's keep going, shall we?

You see, we were assuming that this black juvenile actually committed a crime. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. And unfortunately still, white people, who are the largest population in the United States, are the worst at making cross-racial identifications, particularly when it comes to black people -- black people have no noticeable disability with cross-racial identification toward any racial group.

But how was he even put into the system? Could it be the ridiculous number of stop-and-frisks? The 400% arrest rate of blacks over whites in places like California?The disproportionate sentencing once someone is found guilty of a drug crime? That last part could be the reason more than half of all people imprisoned for drug possession are black. It's not because black people do more drugs because they engage in that activity at the same rate. But seriously, Daloy Polizei.

Then again, what happens once that person is in prison? Well, blacks (and Hispanics) face harsher, longer sentences than non-Hispanic whites for the same crimes. And if the victim is white, the punishment is even harsher. This is even more the case when it comes to the death penalty. In fact, the very crime of being black is enough to push your punishment into death penalty territory. Yes, I said the crime of being black. There is as much predictive validity in being black for determining whether you get the death penalty as there is if you could have killed an innocent bystander. Being black is nearly the equivalent of reckless endangerment for death penalty sentencing.


But what does this have to do with black people being pissed off at white people?

Well, I didn't actually say that, but let's get comfortable. This gets really complicated.

A study of 115 white male undergrads found that the dehumanization of blacks by whites made witnessing brutality against black people acceptable. And we're not talking brainwashing, we're talking the priming of subtly held racist beliefs about the inhumanity of black people. You see, when these undergrads were primed with images and words like "ape" and "brute," they were no more likely to find the violence justifiable against the white suspect whether or not they were primed, but those who were primed by these words were more likely to consider violence against the black suspects justifiable.

And, no, I don't think that's why so many black people might be pissed off at white people. I think it has more to do with the fact that black people with college degrees have unemployment rates approaching the national average. Or that white felons are more likely to find employment than black people with equal qualifications and no criminal records.. This probably helps explain why unemployment among blacks is more than twice as high as the average for the country.

Or maybe not. Maybe, like all of the other minorities, black people are just tired of the goddamn hate crimes. Especially the ones that are unreported.

Actually, it's a little unfair to be so broad about something that is actually quite rare. Let's put a head on it. The real reasons some black people might be pissed at white people is not how society treats them but that, despite all of this, white people tend to think that they are the greatest victims of racial discrimination in this country, 46% don't think racism against blacks is widespread at all, and a full 63% of them think that the way black people are treated is completely cool.

"But wait! I voted for Obama!" No, fuck you.

But I don't believe that white people are racist. I am reluctant to believe that most white people are racist. Perhaps many of them simply don't know any better, which I, with some magnanimity will grant. It's not like someone collected all of this into one place for them to peruse or anything.

...

ಠ_ಠ

Also, who are the fuckers in the overlap between "racism is widespread" and "but whatever, black people are treated fine?" Someone answer me that.**

EDIT: Also, thanks Amrosorma. Don't want this

One more study you may want to add to your amazing effort post, OP.

Blacks and Latinos were nine times as likely as whites to be stopped by the police in New York City in 2009, but, once stopped, were no more likely to be arrested.

You'd think once they got to two or three times as many stop-and-frisks without showing an increased likelihood of criminal activity they would stop. Oh well, guess they "fit the description."

To be precise, between blacks and whites, the whites who were stopped were 40% more likely to be arrested than the blacks who were stopped (1.1 for blacks versus 1.7 for whites).

EDIT 2: And thank you, steviemcfly for this bit about pervasive racist myths on scholarships.

In America, it's, "Black people get scholarships, but white people have to pay for college!" even though minority scholarships account for a quarter of one percent of all scholarships, only 3.5% of people of color receive minority scholarships, and scholarships overwhelmingly and disproportionately go to white people.

(i.e., 0.25% of scholarships go exclusively to minorities while 76% of scholarships are given to whites)


EDIT 3: Lots more comments. Some interesting, some counterpoints, and some absolutely nonsensical. Still, I think there's merit in this.

  1. If you disagree with something, then cite a refutation/counterpoint. Just saying, "I disagree with this and refuse to acknowledge it" isn't discourse, it's whining because your feelings were hurt. You know who does that? Politicians. Do you want to be a politician? Do you want to cry because you don't like facts that disagree with you? If you can't come up with an actual, substantive, cited reason why you disagree with something then chances are your prejudices have just been challenged. There's hope! Just breathe slowly. Walk away from the computer. Think about it. Then come back and type, "Wow, I never really gave it that much thought but I suppose you're right. This explains so much about the world and has changed my view."

  2. Don't even comment on something unless you take the time to read the source. It's why it's there. If you don't think you can find a citation, it's because what you are reading is a follow-up to the previous citation in the sentence before it.

  3. There are some very uncomfortable truths you are going to uncover if you seriously engage the material instead of pulling a 63-percenter and sticking your fingers in your ears. Ignoring facts does not make them go away.

  4. Anecdotal evidence has a margin of error +/- 100%.


EDIT 4: In a study of 406 medicaid-eligible children, African-American children with autism were 2.6 times less likely to be accurately diagnosed with autism than Caucasian children.


EDIT 5: Federal data shows that children in predominantly black and hispanic schools have fewer resources, fewer class options, face harsher punishment (despite a lack of data showing they have worse behaviors), and their teachers are paid less than teachers at predominantly white schools.

Collected here


EDIT 6

In a study of 700 felony trials over 10 years in Lake and Sarasota Florida, with black populations of 5% and jury pools of 27 people, 40% of jury pools did not have a single black candidate.

The results of our study were straightforward and striking: In cases with no blacks in the jury pool, black defendants were convicted at an 81% rate and white defendants at a 66% rate. When the jury pool included at least one black member, conviction rates were almost identical: 71% for black defendants and 73% for whites. The impact of the inclusion of even a small number of blacks in the jury pool is especially remarkable given that this did not, of course, guarantee black representation on the seated jury.

Your sixth amendment rights at work.


APPENDIX

Now, this is the difference between constructive discourse and whiny bullshit:

BULLSHIT: "That's all well and good, but the real problem is [insert paraphrased anecdote from your angry, racist uncle.]" In fact, if your angry, racist uncle would say it, you should probably avoid it altogether -- no matter how clever it sounded at the time.

CONSTRUCTIVE: "Your points may be valid and well-sourced, but this study shows that [insert citation and statement here]..." That's good because then other people can refute you and then you can volley back and then some semblance of the truth can be achieved.

BULLSHIT: "Why are you even bringing this up! Do you hate white people! Are you trying to start a race war!" ...Seriously,fuckoffwiththatshit.

CONSTRUCTIVE: Anything that directs the discussion back to the salient points rather than derailing it.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Oct 03 '12

Hang ups about sex work

519 Upvotes

Sorry, this got a little long.

TL;DR: How can sex work (pornography, prostitution, stripping) be considered positive and empowering when it so often contributes to the objectification and marginalization of those it employs?

Take this quote from Derailing for Dummies as an example of an argument I typically see:

if a sex worker is making the claim that sex work can be a positive and empowering choice or the issue isn‘t the work but the stigma levelled at it, you absolutely must say they are obviously a very Privileged® sex worker because “real” sex workers are always degraded, hate their jobs and are forced into it.

This strikes me as, well, a little problematic. I get that the stigma is in large part the issue (that because a person does a certain thing for work that they are a certain thing which is obviously not true), but to me it seems as if this industry (stripping, prostitution, pornography) is largely defined by marginalization and dehumanization.

Also, relevant to a related conversation I had on this very forum recently, there is the notion that becoming a porn star, for instance, could be considered "empowering." The issue was never really resolved, but, to give you a sense of where it wound up, we ultimately were left more or less debating the merits of indentured servitude versus slavery. My argument was that embracing the demands of your oppressors and internalizing them, perhaps even to the point (as in the case of Jenna Jameson) that you become an advocate in favor of others doing the same hurts yourself and others in a real sense (by perpetuating and, in the eyes of many, providing a rationalization for your oppression) even if it serves to improve your personal immediate circumstances. This appears complacent to me, and complacency, to my mind, isn't synonymous with empowerment.

I don't want to be mistaken for blaming such persons for their situation or choices, and I don't mean to imply that a person can never simply choose sex work for themselves and be fine with it or enjoy it the same as anyone else enjoys any other job. But at the same time, isn't it true that these industries by in large are degrading and (in the case of straight porn, at least) tailored to serve the male gaze and diminish women to sex objects?

The vast majority of pornography I see seems to be almost if not entirely about the abuse of women. I would not hold it against someone for trying to make a living in that industry, but are they really empowered by contributing to it? The best answer I've heard in response to this is that it may be empowering for them even if it contributes to the broader oppression of women, but, seeing as they are also women, how can something be simultaneously empowering and oppressive?


r/SRSDiscussion • • Jun 03 '12

[TW] Do any of you remember a woman under the name 'theoculus' who was accused of faking a sexual assault claim last September? I am she.

271 Upvotes

Greetings and salutations.

For those unfamiliar with this story, I will lay it out for you. In September of 2010, I was beaten and sexually assaulted on the streets of Toronto. I posted a topic to r/reddit.com with a picture of my messed up face trying to raise awareness about rape culture. Soon after, a user posted a link to a previo us post of mine wherein I had a fake wound for a Zombie walk, using this to disprove my story. Loads of users then rallied to scour my post history drudging up any information that would prove I was a liar.

For more detailed accounts of this situation, please refer to these effortposts or this Jezebel article.

The situation then ended with me having to post a video of myself wiping my face with a wet facecloth to prove my wounds weren't faked.

I was partially vindicated I guess, and then the subject was dropped. But not everybody dropped it. While the majority of reddit stopped talking about it, I was receiving death threats. At first it was just through reddit, I contacted admins and such, and they were mostly helpful but more accounts just kept popping up to toss me some shit. Then I started receiving threats and jeers to my facebook, to my e-mail, and even my cell phone. I had to change numbers, lock up all my internet shit, and move. It was horrendous.

Above all, I was so angry. I was furious. I wanted so desperately to come back and bring light to this situation. The problem was, now, I was afraid to. I could come back, talk about how fucking unacceptable it was that I was assaulted, talk about how being injured as such caused me to be a semester behind in school, how I'm STILL going through emotional therapy and physical therapy, and how I endured all this with receiving daily death threats from some fuckheads who still believed I was lying.

What would talking about this whole fiasco accomplish? I would be labeled an 'attention whore' once again for bringing up the subject. Beyond death threats and general mockery, I received pleading messages from moderaters asking me to let the subject die. I logged in to find all my submissions deleted. I deleted my account for good, and moved on.

But now, I am ready to talk about it. I need to talk about it. There are so many people who don't believe misogyny is an issue on reddit, that everyone here are just hyper sensitive PC Nazis. As a victim of these attacks, I feel it prudent to discuss it fully and clear up any speculations.

Here is proof of identity, if anyone is so inclined to need it.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Jul 19 '13

Tired of the Racism on Reddit?

256 Upvotes

I don't know how active this subreddit is, but I guess I am writing this mostly for my own solidarity.

I've been a Redditor for about a couple of years now and these past few days, since the Zimmerman verdict, have been eerily filled with racism on Reddit or maybe I've just had my filters and blinders on too long. Most likely a equal parts of both.

What hurts the most is that I remember arriving to this country at the age of five. It was also the Fourth of July when my family landed in the airport, so my first impression of America was fireworks blasting in the sky. As a kid, you can understand how impressionable a first impression like that must be. This is the land of the free, the stars explode and rain down on you at night to let you know you are safe.

Growing up in America has allowed for many great opportunities in terms of university studies and furthering education. But it comes at a cost to some people, some more than others. As a Hispanic, who identifies as Black because of my nearer to ebony than ivory complexion, my kinky hair, and because there is never a moment in which I am not reminded of what my place in the stratum of society is, I have been subjected to the American experience of Being (with a capital 'B') Black in America. I've been unlawfully detained by police, unlawfully searched, not allowed to eat at a restaurant because I had a white girlfriend, received racial slurs from said girlfriend's family, see and understand fear and/or disgust in people's eyes when they feel my existing near them makes them uncomfortable, heard countless amounts of 'nigger's and 'spic's thrown my way. I never let it weigh me down, however abhorrent these things are, I manage to retell the stories to friends in lighthearted tones with a smile and a can-you-believe-that-happened attitude.

But something about these past few days has put me in a slump, perhaps my filters and blinders have been wearing out, perhaps it's about time that I stopped turning a blind-eye to these injustices and see them for what they are. I tend to be very dismissive of things. But not anymore. I will not allow another tongue-in-cheek racist remark or joke slip out of somebody without informing them about their bigoted views. I will not allow another woman-kitchen joke be uttered without informing the person they are sexist. I will also fight for my LGBT brothers, sisters, and any identifier that does not fall within the master's gender dichotomy.

I used to not understand why activists can come off as angry. I'm never an angry person and I've dealt with many horrible things just due to the fact that I left my house. Just because I went outside. "Can you believe that?" But if you are angry because of any injustice, you are well within your person rights to be angry at this oppressive society. I will no longer feed these oppressive institutions by turning a blind eye, that is what this system thrives on, it perpetuates the proliferation of hate and bigotry when we decide to be silent. I will not be silent.

Many on Reddit can claim and upvote that Black people need to get over playing the race card if we want to progress our race relations. That we are the bigger racists. That we get benefits when we check in a box that we are black. We get facilitated acceptance into a university if we check in a box that we are black. We get accepted into a job if we check in a box that we are black. I want these people to know that to know this: You don't check a box to walk outside your house.

Where does a person of color look for inspiration in the history of this nation? It cannot be with the founding fathers, they were the ones who set this system into motion, they were the oppressors themselves. How can a person of color feel at home in a nation that does not acknowledge them if not as a bull's-eye for tossing their darts of hate? I don't know. But you know what? I still am American, no matter what any bigot out there who plays into the institution of "White" dominance may say.

Take America Back? Take America Back? How do you feel marching to that tune? Especially when America was built on the blood, sweat, and tears — but mostly blood — of enslaved Africans and the eradication of Natives. America was the rape of aborigines, its infrastructure built by blacks. And you want to take America back from whom? To what?

I leave you with a poem from Langston Hughes and would like to remind you that your American experience is not the same American experience of others. Check your privileges at the door, take a number, sit down.

I, too, sing America.

I am the darker brother.
They send me to eat in the kitchen
When company comes,
But I laugh,
And eat well,
And grow strong.

Tomorrow,
I'll be at the table
When company comes.
Nobody'll dare
Say to me,
"Eat in the kitchen,"
Then.

Besides,
They'll see how beautiful I am
And be ashamed—

I, too, am America.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Sep 02 '12

[TW?] TIL what rape culture is

255 Upvotes

I've read SRS for a while and while I agreed with a lot of it, there was always this term "rape culture" that seemed to get thrown around and I always kinda took offense to that since I could never see myself (asexual/heteroromantic make) contributing to it.
But then today it clicked in the most disgusting way.

I work at a hostel while I'm travelling abroad so I encounter a lot of people getting drunk/hooking up, etc. Tonight there was one couple and they seemed to be getting on well, but at one point the guy just invited the girl up to his room and she said "no". He continued asking until she started to relent a bit and at this point he basically lifted her up on her feet and started guiding her to his room, but you could just tell she wasn't doing it fullly willingly and was dragging her feet. I told him to fuck off and leave her alone and walker her to her bed where she thanked me profusely and said she didn't know what to do. When I got back to where the event happened, the guy and 3 other people around me said I "cockblocked" him and that she was obviously into it.

Two of these people were my coworkers and I'm not sure I really know how to look at them anymore and not feel kinda disgusted, that not only were they willing to let someone be raped, but then defended the assailant. Sorry if this is a bit incoherent, but I had to have a bit to drink after that since I just feel pretty disgusted, even at the fact that I waited so long to help. Don't really know what the point of this is, just feel pretty down about things.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Jan 17 '12

Right, I'm out. [Rant]

250 Upvotes

Right, I'm done with Reddit.

  1. You privileged fucks can't even recognise MLK Day, one of the bravest and greatest people of the 20th century, without finding some way to poison the well. Is it that important to you make sure that everyone knows that there is some controversy regarding the King Estate on MLK? Why do you do this? I mean, you chose to post that link. Why of all the things you could have said about MLK and the American Civil Rights Movement you chose that?

  2. It's not about free speech. It's about not being a dick. Is there any reason you need to use the same lame, rehashed jokes over and over, that are racist, sexist, homophobic, or transphobic? Here's a hint chucklefucks: no. You're not funny, and it's fucking painful watching how everytime you go for the same groups of people who aren't you. Humour is powerful. It's trivialising. Show some goddamn respect.

  3. Reddit has the most conservative 'liberals' I've ever seen. "Tattoos make you unemployable!" "OWS look like filthy hippies!" "Ron Paul is great, he's fantastic on all the issues except the ones that are for people not like me (i.e. not straight, white, male, cisgender) and fuck those people anyway, they're suitable only as targets from my humour! Yes, I know that you hear these kind of jokes from your racist uncle, but the difference is I do it ironically! Which is totally different!" To these people: you know how you like attacking baby boomers because they were radical in the 60s but ended up voting for Thatcher and Reagan and selling your generation out? Fuck you, that's you in 30 years. Your disregard for anyone's interests apart from your own (see how much attention SOPA/PIPA gets versus, oh, anything else) means you're well on your day to conservative douchetude.

  4. Rank hypocrisy on liberal arts. "Liberal arts are useless for jobs and won't get you money!" Perhaps. Reddit almost never talks about how a lack of social skills will scupper your career progression far more. Frankly none of you have a fucking clue about getting a job with a liberal arts degree because most of you don't have one. Nonetheless, in the best Reddit tradition, don't let this stop you have a strong opinion on something you know nothing about!

  5. This is a website on which you will in all seriousness receive more sympathy and calls for "communication and understanding" [+61] than if you're fat, a woman, or, the worst crime imaginable, a fat woman.

  6. I don't know if it's the internet or Reddit but people on this website are mean. When I spend time with friends IRL they have flaws but they're basically nice people. I go on here and people are nasty. I don't want to be a part of that anymore.

  7. Your treatment of women is appalling. It is impossible for a woman to post a picture without you either making sexual remarks, or "ironically" noting that "oh, it's a woman". FUCK OFF THANKS. Nothing more to say on this one.

  8. Your treatment of people with any kind of partners is imbecilic. "Hey, look x has a girlfriend!" is not a good response. You do realise that normal, healthy people in relationships do stuff together (stuff that isn't you being on reddit while your partner weeps for being so terribly alone, I mean) and that stuff is sometimes worth of reddit! Shocking, I know.

  9. But hey, that's not all redditors! See here. I study history. In history, we often have to infer what people believe from not necessarily very much. But in reddit, we have a very good metric for seeing what people think: upvotes! So what if it's 1000 upvotes out of a community of 300,000? When you see a poll do you assume it's bullshit because they've not asked everyone in the entire country the question? Reddit has a very strong basis on which we can say that there seem to be very prevalent attitudes. And dear God there are some so very fucked up attitudes on here.

Okay think that's pretty much everything. Thanks to SRS for making my last few months in this shithole halfway bearable. Tata folks!

-- Jormungandur


r/SRSDiscussion • • Feb 05 '12

Why Your Racist Joke Costs Me Money

246 Upvotes

This is largely an opinionated rant. I shall endeavor to explain why your "totally funny racist joke" is actually causing me real, honest to goodness harm. And not just me, but everyone that the joke could be about.

Bit of background. At my job, I do almost all of the hiring interviews. During the hiring season this takes about 50% of my time. The other 50% of the time I write code. My job is to, in a very short period of time, evaluate a candidate, and figure out if he or she (probably he) is a good cultural fit for whatever web development team we're assembling, is competent, and should be hired. We're encouraged to no-hire over hire, to be picky as hell, and to always tell someone "no" if anyone dislikes them.

So, this is a great opportunity for me to be racist. Yes, racist. I might be a minority, but behind that hiring desk I've got both power and prejudice.

This observation started after binging on youarenotsosmart.com. I began to introspect on how often I make decisions on bad or superficial data.

While testing myself I've viewed hundreds of pictures with colleges and voted "would hire / would not hire" based on the photo and nothing more. This has taught me some uncomfortable facts. If you walk in with baggy pants, I'm going to dislike you. If you're too tall or too short, I'll like you less too. Now, I'm not justifying these opinions, but I am acutely aware of them.

There's no hiring manager in the world that has these subtle biases about subjective evaluation. And thus anyone can lose a job interview just because of bad luck or, if the opinion becomes widespread, systemic bias. You think its your skill that brings you success, but no, environmental conditions matter way more than you think.

So what does my bias have to do with your joke? Mostly because people are really bad at determining their own motives and are vulnerable to manipulation from all sorts of directions. Racism, even in a joke form, works as a very effective form of priming. All it takes is a few bad stereotypes to form the kind of subconscious thought into that will actually affect their judgement. So when you tell a joke about, say, asian people being horrible drivers, and I absorb that joke, then the next time I have to evaluate who is qualified to work offsite with rental cars on the company dime, I may very well subconsciously assume the white guy is the better driver even though I have no evidence to support this.

You do it too. And the hivemind is making you more racist every day.

Now you can try to combat subconscious bias with conscious thought, but outthinking these patterns are hard. Extremely hard! It's like we're wired to find people not like us and assign negative qualities to them.

Now for me, I can usually outthink shit about my own race and gender, because I have myself to anchor on, but after cracking a bunch of jokes about Indian telemarketers take a guess who I don't want calling the customers? That's right, our indian guy. Now for the record, I noticed this behavior and corrected it, and he's one of our most eloquent speakers. Still, how much behavior do I not notice every day? How many times has hearing a racist joke cost the most qualified candidate his job?

So here you are going "Herp Derp, what's the difference between a black guy and a pizza?" Ok, very funny. Except that every time someone hears that racist ass joke, they might actually to subconsciously assign it some measure of truth, and once they assign it some measure of truth, it's going to affect their decision making. Even if they're not consciously racist.

Even more importantly, thanks to confirmation bias and the backfire effect if a person has even a trace of racist thought, you can be sure exposure to racist jokes and the subsequent "but X aren't really like that" will both amplify the effect.

You might think yourself immune, but consider how many proverbs and meaningless aphorisms you absorb as truth every day.

Subconscious, split second decisions about which fare a taxi driver should take, about which car a cop should pull over, about which defendant is guilty, about who to hire, who to promote, who should get a raise, who should be let go, who to date -- all of these things affect people, all the time. You might think you're being rational and logical, but more often than not you make decisions and justify them afterwards. And you, like me, are making these subconscious decisions with all those racist biases you've had instilled.

So when you tell a racist joke and you don't consciously reject it, you're making my life a little bit worse. When you tell it to your non-racist friends, you're making my life a little bit worse too.

The effect is magnified on minorities. Jokes about upper class black females don't really stick with me, but how many black female hiring managers are there, especially for well paying jobs? I've met like, two, in my life. More broadly, a joke about a minority will be spread further and faster, accepted more easily, and have greater impact than a joke about a majority. That's why racist jokes about minorities, even if they're equally offensive, are worse.

Thus, I might have a hard time getting a raise because you're telling jokes about black people. That's my lifetime salary you're diminishing there. And I'm posting not just for me, because I'm doing ok, but for everyone you tell a racist joke about. Fucking stop it.

Edit: Fixed broken link

Edit 2: Consider the content of this post, and the links, to be creative commons. Feel free to repost in whatever form you like, including editing for style, adding the extra citations from the comments, and removing the pic spam. If you can improve it for a wider audience, be my guest!


r/SRSDiscussion • • Oct 12 '12

Can we talk about this now: why is investigative journalism and "doxxing" the same thing? What exactly did Gawker do wrong?

223 Upvotes

I've seen even on SRS that the official party line is "We don't support doxxing sites."

But I think it's pretty obvious now that the link on Gawker wasn't "doxxing." It was a fair profile, it talked to the subject of the profile beforehand, it was honest and forthright.

That's not doxxing, it's goddamn journalism. It's watchdog journalism, investigation. It's talking to sources and crafting a narrative.

Reddit treated it the same as if Adrian Chen had shown up and just posted VA's home address and phone number and a sign marked "Pedophile" next to it.

But those aren't the same thing.

Look, here's the deal. I've been doxxed before, by an angry ex-boyfriend using a keylogger and then spreading vicious lies mixed with just enough truth to keep people believing. It was horrible. It was among the worst things that ever happened to me. He sent messages to my family pretending to be me, he gave people my address who should never have had it.

And this isn't the same as that. It's just not. I've also been a journalist. Public figures -- people who have MADE THEMSELVES PUBLIC FIGURES THROUGH THEIR ACTIONS -- aren't being "doxxed" when someone who knows their name reveals it.

I guess I don't see what's wrong with this or why we have to pretend to be against it. This wasn't doxxing. Don't cede ground to these assholes. Adrian Chen isn't in the wrong and this is actually a point worth fighting over.

Do you really think Reddit should be a place where, so long as you break no laws, no matter how public a figure you become, everyone should work in concert to keep your identity a mystery? People played VA's identity-secret game for a long, long time. He took risks constantly. It caught up to him, as it often does with public figures and the paparazzi.

So remind me again why I'm not supposed to be cheering Gawker's methods.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Feb 01 '12

[WARNING] If you make a thread asking why there is no White History Month, we will ban you.

165 Upvotes

Why is there a Mother's day and a Father's day but no Kid's day?

Use this thread to discuss why some folks get so salty about Black History month, and why that's a silly thing to do~


JaronK provided this explanation, for anyone who was thinking of asking:

In case anyone was wondering, here's the answer: because all our history classes are taught primarily as white history. Our version of World History is pretty much just European History with a slight touch of South America and maybe China or a touch of the Middle East. But mostly, it's just European, to the point where folks actually believe that all major cultures started in Europe. And our version of US History is all white history too... mostly presidents and battles, with a touch of MLK thrown in.

So the reason we don't have a White History month is because there's already eleven of them... we just don't say it quite so explicitly.

The reason we have Black History month is to try and fill in just a little of the massive gaping hole in the history we teach. Should we need it? Absolutely not. George Washington Carver should be taught along with Thomas Edison. The Tuskegee Airmen should be taught along with Patton's tanks. Timbuktu should be taught along with Athens. And thus, we shouldn't need it. But currently we do.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Nov 11 '12

Can we please stop with this "PRIVILEGE CHECK: SAWCSM" business?

164 Upvotes

I understand the intention behind disclaimers like this and I am not trying to hurt anyone's feelings, but this is not what "privilege checking" is and, in my opinion, it just devalues the actual practice.

"Checking one's privilege" is the act of honestly and comprehensively self-evaluating one's motives and perspectives as a person of privilege on some axis. It is not simply telling everyone what your race/gender/sexuality/other statuses are before you begin a discussion about a race/gender/sexuality/other issue. It is actually something you should do on your own, before you even enter into those discussions, that involves saying to yourself, e.g.: "Is there something I'm missing here because of my relative privilege in this sphere? Is there more research I should do before I try to have a conversation like this as a person of privilege? Is my privilege allowing me to engage in this conversation in a way that others are unable to? Am I putting people who lack this privilege in an uncomfortable position in the conversation?"

I am concerned by the fact that some people here seem to believe that "checking one's privilege" is the mere acknowledgment that one is white, or a man, or cis, or whatever. Actually, posting about, for instance, a race issue and adding the "disclaimer" that you're white is quite the opposite of checking your privilege: it's asking other people to check it for you. I read it as shorthand for "I'm white, so if I mess up, that's why, and I'd like to be corrected." Don't get me wrong - I think it's important to be forthcoming about one's privilege in these conversations, and to acknowledge the shortcomings in understanding that might result, but acknowledging the fact of one's privilege is not the same thing.

At that point, it's basically just a more social justicey version of walking into a conversation about sexism and saying "Well, as a man, here's what I think..."

Again, I don't mean to call anyone out and I don't think badly of people who do this, regardless of how hostile this post may sound (the tone is a reaction to a pet peeve, not a social justice grievance). It might ultimately just be an insidious mutation of vocabulary that has taken hold in this space (and perhaps others). But I think it has deeper implications for the kinds of conversation about privilege that are welcomed/cultivated in our discussion threads, as the presence of a simplistic "privilege check" at the beginning of each post might supplant or prevent deeper, more comprehensive, sincere analyses of privilege.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Dec 15 '12

Observation: Only when a white man is the killer is there any talk of mental illness.

155 Upvotes

I decided I would turn to google for this.

As others do, I find it to be problematic that whenever there's any talk of mass shooting, mental illness is a quick topic to come up. However, in examining the races of the killers, it appears that mental illness is a hot topic . . . only when the shooter is white. Below is a list of high profile mass shootings in the past decade (post-Columbine) in the U.S. If I forgot any, let me know.

The first number is the google search for the exact search phrase on the left. The second number is that search phrase with the word "mental" attached. One shouldn't try to go by percentage comparisons, as there are way too many variables to make any meaningful inferences from it. I included the first number though for a frame of reference, as the searches reveal widely varying numbers.

Some of the names have the word "shooter" attached or a middle name removed. This was done to get the most accurate listings possible. For example, James Holmes, without the word "shooter," has over 100 million results as there are other famous people with the name. You can mess around as well and see what you come up with. However, the findings from my search:

Adam Lanza shooter (W) - 2,940,000 / 2,170,000

James Holmes shooter (W) - 2,150,000 / 1,910,000

Wage Page shooter (W) 4,630,000 / 1,840,000

Jared Loughner (W) - 2,250,000 / 615,000

Michael McLendon (W) 1,580,000 / 1,630,000

Malik Hasan - (NW) 8,000,000 / 1,310,000

Seung-hui Cho (NW) 959,000 / 243,000

Hasan (not white) and Cho are the only non-white people, and they both rank in the bottom three for number of searches with the word "mental." Hasan would be in second place were it not for Jared Lougher, a lesser-known shooter.

Because so few non-white men have committed mass shootings in the past decade in the U.S., there aren't that many data points to go on. But this search indicates that mental illness is a hot topic . . . only when the shooter is white.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Jun 08 '12

On Christian apologists/a kinda effortpost.

151 Upvotes

Hey, long time SRS user. Been here since the early days. Big fan.

I have to admit, I'm getting kind of sick of some (obviously not all, but enough that I've noticed it) of the "Hey, don't be so mean towards Christianity!" or "I don't know why people assume there's some correlation between Christianity and homophobia." I don't know if it's some circlejerky response to r/atheism where we want to be pro-Christian. I mean, I get it. r/atheism is pretty immature. Nobody is doubting that. Well besides them, maybe. But let's be honest, Christianity is, and will always be, the tool and guidebook of the oppressor. Religion is the ultimate grooming tool. Christianity isn't "used" by homophobes. It was created by homophobes. They put that stuff in to make sure that homophobia stayed alive and well.

"Oh no, The Bible is just so vague that it can be used to mean anything! These bigots are just making stuff up!" Bullshit. When it comes to alternative sexualities, The Bible is very clear. Shall we go over what The Bible says about us?

Leviticus 20:13 If a man also lie with mankind, as he lieth with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination: they shall surely be put to death; their blood shall be upon them.

So in basic terms, if a dude fucks a dude, kill them both. The favorite book for anti-gay marriage opponents to quote. More? Alright.

Deuteronomy 22:5 The woman shall not wear that which pertaineth unto a man, neither shall a man put on a woman's garment: for all that do so are abomination unto the LORD thy God.

Deuteronomy 23:18 Thou shalt not bring the hire of a whore, or the price of a dog, into the house of the LORD thy God for any vow: for even both these are abomination unto the LORD thy God.

Remember this. The Bible puts "whores" and homosexuals in the same group. This will come up later. Oh yeah, The Biblical term for homosexual is "dog." Nothing bigoted about that, right?

Samuel 20:30-20:33. Some backstory here, Saul is pissed off that his son is having a gay affair.

Then Saul's anger was kindled against Jonathan, and he said unto him, Thou son of the perverse rebellious woman, do not I know that thou hast chosen the son of Jesse to thine own confusion, and unto the confusion of thy mother's nakedness? For as long as the son of Jesse liveth upon the ground, thou shalt not be established, nor thy kingdom. Wherefore now send and fetch him unto me, for he shall surely die. And Jonathan answered Saul his father, and said unto him, Wherefore shall he be slain? what hath he done? And Saul cast a javelin at him to smite him: whereby Jonathan knew that it was determined of his father to slay David.

Stab. Your. Gay. Son. Gotcha.

Kings 14:24 And there were also sodomites in the land: and they did according to all the abominations of the nations which the LORD cast out before the children of Israel.

Kings 15:11 And Asa did that which was right in the eyes of the LORD, as did David his father. Kings 15:12 And he took away the sodomites out of the land, and removed all the idols that his fathers had made.

Make God happy, remove abominations (homosexuals) from your land.

Kings 2 23 23:7 And he brake down the houses of the sodomites, that were by the house of the LORD, where the women wove hangings for the grove.

Josiah pleases God by burning down houses of homosexuals.

Isiah 3:9 They declare their sin as Sodom, they hide it not. Woe unto their soul! Isiah 3:10 Say ye to the righteous, that it shall be well with him: for they shall eat the fruit of their doings. Isiah 3:11 Woe unto the wicked! it shall be ill with him: for the reward of his hands shall be given him.

Homosexuals hide it not in Sodom! Woe unto them!

Daniel 11:37 Neither shall he regardthe God of his fathers, nor the desire of women, nor regard any god: for he shall magnify himself above all.

This seems kinda harmless, until you realize that they are talking about the Antichrist. According to The Bible, homosexuality is literally Satanic.

Romans 1:26 For this cause God gave them up unto vile affections: for even their women did change the natural use into that which is against nature: Romans 1:27 And likewise also the men, leaving the natural use of the woman, burned in their lust one toward another; men with men working that which is unseemly, and receiving in themselves that recompence of their error which was meet.

Romans 1:28 And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient;

Romans 1:31 Without understanding, covenantbreakers, without natural affection, implacable, unmerciful.

Romans 1:32 Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them.

Corinthians 6:9 Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor abusers of themselves with mankind.

GSMs are absolutely dispised by The Bible. And the effects are clear on society. There's a lot you have to ignore if you want to say that Religion hasn't fostered a culture of hatred. Name a single anti-gay law that didn't get major funding from a Christian group. Find a common thread with all of the major anti-gay politicians. Admit the correlation between The Bible Belt and hate speech/crimes. Think of the last time gay marriage was opposed by somebody who didn't bring up some garbage about Adam and Steve. Think about all of the GSM kids across the world getting bullied by kids who say they are going to Hell. Think of the anti-bullying laws that says it's OK to bully gay youths to suicide as long as your religion says it's OK. Think of the hate crime victims who were told that they are going to Hell before they died. Think of the wildly succesful megachurches which remind it's followers that homosexuality is a sin. The most popular Christian TV show in the country is vehemently anti-gay. There are billboards across America preaching hatred against gays in the name of [God.] (http://www.thegavoice.com/images/stories/10-29-10/billboard-body-11-2-10.jpg)

Remember that part of The Bible where it equates homosexuals with whores? This is why I mentioned it.

Gee, I wonder where he got that idea?

Do you honestly want to defend that just because it might piss off a bunch of teenagers who just read Nietzsche for the first time?

I'm sure some Christians will read this and complain that I'm reminding them of the bigoted roots and effects of what they call their religion. Check your privilege. I don't have any interest in coddling people who fully embrace the culture of my oppressors. It's your religion, you deal with the culture it spawned. I know I have to.

The biggest insult to injury had to be when a SRSister claimed that Christians aren't a real majority, since they feel awkward in certain cities. That should have been laughed at, but instead it was upvoted.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Apr 11 '12

I am sick and fucking tired of reddit casually hating on mental illness [angry rant]

143 Upvotes

Okay. I'm borderline. Borderline fucking Personality Disorder. I hate it, and it's come within a single fucking hair of completely ruining my life. Drug overdoses, institutionalization, the works. I hated myself too for a very long time and I'm only just starting to get used to the idea that I can maybe, maybe be a good person if I really really try hard enough.

When you tell somebody you're depressed, they say shit like "well, just cheer up!" or bullshit like that. When you tell people you're ADD, they disbelieve you. When you tell people you're bipolar, they say you're just moody. But BPD? When my mom found out about my diagnosis (she saw a book I was reading on the subject in my apartment), she burst into tears and ran out of the room. People hate you if you're borderline. They hold it against you, personally. They say you're manipulative, evil, that you exist to drag people down, they call you a psycho if you're a guy and a psycho bitch if you're a girl. They look down on you, they persecute you, they make casual comments on major websites that make you burst into tears. I'm not pretending that other sufferers don't have it bad, and I am in no way trying to belittle your problems, it's just that this is what I see in my own personal life.

Some goddam brilliant armchair psychologist said in a thread about a bad breakup, "If it matters, she probably has Borderline Personality Disorder and is just being manipulative." Well fuck you too. You might as well be saying "she was probably black and that's why she robbed the convenience store" or "she was a woman and that's why she got all hysterical" or "she was probably gay and that's why she's a pedophile." No. None of those things are okay, none of those things are true, so why is it okay to treat somebody who is suffering from an illness that way? I'm not evil I'm sick.

Ah fuck I'm crying in public again. Just fuck it. Fuck this planet, fuck these people, fuck this life.

EDIT: <3 you guys


r/SRSDiscussion • • Feb 21 '13

[EFFORT] Okay, I'm Privileged - Now What?

139 Upvotes

A 102-level guide, originally written for /r/SRSRecovery.

I'm Privileged, Now What Do I Do?

Privilege isn't your fault ~ Stompy Privilege Boots ~ Privilege Blinders ~ Use Your Powers for Good, Not Evil

Recap on privilege:

(social) privilege is a set of advantages, given to members of a power majority, due to unbalanced and unfair power structures in a given society.

Privilege isn't your fault.

Even if it sounds like an insult, it really isn't. And honestly? If someone is using "privilege" as a straight-up insult on its own, they probably don't fully grasp what privilege is.

Individuals are never born asking for privilege, and nearly everyone will have some form of privilege along some set of axis: racial, gender, sexuality, class, disability and so on.

But! The point about privilege is that it gives the privileged two things: great big stompy privilege boots, that can shut down the voices of the less privileged, and privilege blinders, which means that the privileged never have to see or experience what life's like for the unprivileged.

It's these two things - the boots and the blinders - that combine to make privilege harmful. But it is perfectly possible to participate in any cause even if you are a member of the majority. Remember to be aware of those boots and those blinders!

Stompy Privilege Boots

Imagine having a crappy day - for whatever reason, nothing quite goes right. You've run out of milk, the coffee machine's broken, there's a traffic jam, the internet mysteriously refuses to work (but works for everyone else) - whatever. A million little things have happened that add up to make it a terrible day.

Naturally you might want to vent to someone or at least try to fix some of the little problems - but imagine that every time you try, you get shut down with, "But that's no big deal!" or "Why are you fussing?" and no one will listen.

Extend the day to every day of your life, extend the little things to rather big things like housing and education and job issues, and imagine that those voices are not only loud and annoying, but everywhere. That is the effect of the Stompy Privilege Boots.

The Stompy Privilege Boots shut down conversation, trivialising issues and derailing conversations. The thing is, the privileged aren't always aware that they're stepping on someone's toes, and they don't always mean to be rude or what-have-you. But having the boots on makes it hard not to step on people's toes.

The metaphorical boots are metaphorically welded to your metaphorical feet. It's not something you can take off at will. However, being aware of your privilege boots can help. By being aware of the stompyness of the boots, you can make sure you're not stepping all over the marginalised and stopping them from speaking. By learning about the ways these boots shut out their voices, and the impact of this silencing, you can help combat not only the effects of privilege, but can help by showing other boot-wearers what not to do.

Privilege Blinders

The boots also come with a complimentary set of blinders, by which I mean that privilege not only pushes others out of the way, it means that the privileged don't ever have to realise what they're doing.

The privilege blinders are what lead to well-intentioned but ultimately hurtful statements like, "If someone called me pretty on the street it'd make my day! [with regards to catcalling]" or "Hey, aren't positive stereotypes okay?". They also lead to the phenomenon of majoritysplaining: "As a straight ally, I think pride parades are too intimidating, here's how they should be run..." "As a man, this is how feminism should work..." "As a cis ally, the trans* community are scaring away potential allies, here's what they should be doing instead..."

You are well within your rights to suggest potential improvements, true, but remember the boots? The privilege blinders make the boots occasionally hard to see. And so things like telling the marginalised how to run their movement is a clear case of stomping - but it doesn't seem that way. It just sounds like good solid advice. Except... I guarantee you the movement has heard it before. Heck, they've probably tried it before, many many times, and it's not working or it simply costs far too much to keep doing. So it leads to resentment and lashing out and everyone getting upset.

It is hard to remove the privilege blinders. It may be impossible to completely remove every last trace of them. Because of the blinders, it is impossible to fully relate to the experiences of the marginalised. A straight person is never going to fully understand the gut-wrenching fear and doubt that accompanies coming out for the first time. A cis person's not going to fully understand life as a trans* person. A white American is not going to be able to completely understand the police harassing you just because you're a black American. The little things and the big things that add up to shape a marginalised person's life, are honestly too numerous and too pervasive to fully describe. But not completely understanding is okay! The important thing to remember is not to dismiss these experiences, just because you can't see them or don't think they happen.

It's these two things together that cause many of the problems between the privileged and the unprivileged. Having privilege is not inherently bad - the bad part is not understanding how it impacts your views and actions. That's the frustrating part, and if you're here, you're probably well on your way to fixing that problem.

Use Your Powers for Good, Not Evil

A tl;dr of everything up until this point:

Sit down and listen to the marginalised.

That's all there is to it, really. When you feel hurt or maybe offended by something the marginalised say, try not to get defensive immediately - sit, maybe ask them why they said that (respectfully! they deal with enough crap as it is), and listen. Listen to their grievances, listen to their experiences, and listen for their suggestions. If you do this you're on the fast track to being an Amazing Person.

Being an ally of a cause is a constant process, it's not a little medal or a title. Being an ally of a cause means constantly examining yourself, your biases, the biases of people around you, and looking at how and why they form. Let the marginalised lead the show. Allies are like bodyguards, in a sense: your job is to deflect Stompy Privilege Boots headed at the marginalised, perhaps with your own Boots of Stomping +1, and to teach others to take off their blinders.

That's where privilege can actually help you, and might even help you reach further than the marginalised can by themselves (controversial point of view). Sometimes, the only occasion a privileged poopwizard will even begin to consider an alternate point of view is when it comes from a fellow member of the privileged group. The privileged can use their advantages to create more platforms for the marginalised to spread their message. Those stompy boots can knock aside other stompy boots. Taking off your own blinders might encourage those around you to realise what's blinding them, too.

In conclusion: don't blame yourself for your privilege! You cannot control the circumstances of your birth any more than the marginalised can. But starting off with extra advantages is not something to be upset by. Help change the power structures in society, so that EVERYONE gets to start off on an equal footing. It's very tempting to succumb to privilege and look for "short cuts", but changing things is not easy. Change is difficult, it is scary, it is risky - and you should do it anyway.

Further Reading


r/SRSDiscussion • • Feb 23 '12

No cookies for fulfilling the basic requirements of being a human being - you do it so you won't be so much of an asshole - I know, because I'm one of those assholes

139 Upvotes

I was once a complete asshole. White, cis* (fuck I still hate that word - but terminology is terminology, in my day to day I stick with straight) really enjoying the everloving fuck out of that white privilege/invisibility thing.

*(Apparently I meant to write straight - though cis still applies, I can comfortably forget my unwarranted animosity to a term I only became aware of three months ago)

Then I started a relationship with a latina who is probably ten to fourteen times smarter than I am (and I think I'm pretty smart, most of the time). She laughed at my racist, misogynistic jokes. We enjoyed our problematic media. Things were going great.

Then one day she sits me down and says, in so many words, I love you, but you're completely deluded, aren't you? There is literally an entire world you have no idea about, one which makes it easy for you to say the offensive shit you say, and if anyone were to get offended, that's on them because 'you're only joking.' But you need to be aware of who you are and what you say.

So naturally I got defensive - really, is there a white, cis male that doesn't get defensive the first time he understands what an utter, world class shit he has been? And we argued. And argued. This went on for weeks. I would make passive aggressive statements, deliberately needling her about point of view about me. I'd remind her about all those times she almost peed herself laughing when I would do my little racist/misogynist jokes. But she held her ground and, god bless her, remained patient (she's an excellent psychologist btw) and really got me to see a few things. It's not about me, it's not about being sorry for how I was born, etc. It's that in her eyes I'm a fundamentally decent guy who is making the same mistakes over and over again because I'm completely invisible to my whiteness and inherent privilege. Nothing more, nothing less. She didn't even want me to change my sense of humor, which always geared towards the dark, and which, she said, in fairness was pretty caustic and mean-spirted to everyone, white males included. All she wanted was awareness of what I was saying. That my privilege not go unexamined simply because it's hard to admit something about yourself that you wish weren't true.

And then as the weeks went on, and I began to pay more attention, I saw her point. Let me rephrase. I felt like my eyes were opened for the first time in years. Posts on reddit that used to just irk me or strike me as needlessly sexist (seriously, is there a single non-sexist meme even indirectly related to women?) began to bother me more. There was more of a darkness. The constant references to rape and forced sex (which I never cared much for in the first place, given mine and my girlfriends history - we were both sexually abused as children) went from harmlessly offensive to 'wow, this dude must really have some unexplored issues.'

And like any newfound awareness, this was just the onion that stunk the more layers you peeled back. Did you guys know that most TV is absolutely fucking terrible? That 'How I Met Your Mother' for instance, is a show that celebrates the lives of serial rapists and their apologists? That 'Law and Order SVU' (girlfriend's favorite show) is one of the most racist pieces of shit since minstrel shows? That almost every popular website says some seriously disturbing shit almost every day? I didn't. I do now. And it makes my little white privileged brain fucking hurt. Things are awful. Why didn't anyone tell me sooner?!

I used to read Jeremy Clarkson's column in the fucking Times for Christ's sake. I mean I always thought he was just kind of a prick, but even in context... I mean, what the fuck could I have been thinking? This man is a complete asshole. Just a horrible, horrible person.

But this is it, isn't it? You can't unlearn this shit. Like the existence of rape culture, for instance. I hate rape. I hate its under-reported, under-examined nature as a crime, I hate the cultural stigma attached to victims, I hate the kneejerk reaction I STILL FEEL when I read about a person accusing someone of rape (could they have gotten it wrong? A misunderstanding? They were both drunk after all...) but then I regain my sanity and all I can think is FUCK. FUCK FUCK FUCK. This is FUCKING AWFUL AND I CAN'T STAND THAT I STILL THINK THIS WAY. Fucking apologist thoughts.

And then there's the culture. Our movies. Our TV shows. Our music. Pay attention for five fucking seconds and it really is obvious, isn't it? Women are objects. Barney Stinson is an unrepentant serial rapist, but his victims are all stupid whores, so LET'S LAUGH, EVERYBODY. And seriously, are there any DECENT roles for women that aren't being the wife to an important historical figure? Is the best argument we can make for a strong feminist role model Buffy the Fucking Vampire Slayer?

So for me, and the whole rape culture thing, the evidence keeps mounting up and very soon I'm going to have to admit, fuck, fuck fucking fuck people like me, we have a fucking awful fucking rape culture. And I hate that more than words can possibly fucking say. But that's the truth, and the anger and indignation and shame I feel is 1/1000th the amount a woman or minority has had to put up with, so really, I have no excuse for getting depressed. This is something I need to deal with instead of plaintively whining about it. There are no excuses or apologism or mitigating factors. Some things are just true.

And now to be brutally honest and reveal myself for the asshole that I am: I hate that this is true. I hate that this is a thing. I honestly thought, and I can't even believe I was this delusional once, that if we just ignored race and gender and sexuality then eventually everything in society is gonna be ok. Make no mistake: This. Is. A. Child's. Thinking.

So that's where I'm at, in a nutshell. I'm not looking for affirmation. I don't want cookies. Maybe if I actually do something worth a damn someday I might deserve a 'hey, you did something exceptional for all people today - really above the call of duty, have a biscuit' cookie, but that day is not today. I have a long road ahead.

I'm sharing my story because I do want to be better, I do want to fulfill the basic requirements of being a human being. I'm not there yet. I'm still an asshole, just maybe less of a complete asshole than I was. But I think I can get there, and I think I'm going to make it because my girlfriend loved me enough to sit me down and say 'You're full of shit.'

So if there's someone like me in your life, man or woman, who you think has the spark of something approaching a decent human being, don't give up on them. Show them that you love them, but pull no punches. I'm just glad I got exposed to this relatively early, before I got too set in my ways, before I had too many years of looking back and saying, 'Jesus Christ, what a fucking asshole I was.'

Edit: Huh. Quite a response. Wasn't expecting this much.

I just want to reiterate what may have been a little lost in my expletive-filled, sometimes incoherent post: don't give up on people you care about. It sounds cheesy, but love and respect are very powerful when it comes to changing someone's point of view. My girlfriend and I are going to be married in a few years, after that, children. I want them to be able to see that their father has the slightest vestige of decency and integrity, hopefully a 1/10 as much as their mother.

As for my anger, it grows by the day. I'm trying to balance what I am learning with my everyday life. I've had to learn to shut up when watching SVU with the girlfriend, as she is well aware of the problems with the show (someone below summed it up very eloquently - the show has gotten much, much worse than it used to be) and is comfortable with herself enough to tune them out so she can enjoy her guilty pleasure. I need to relearn that trick, so I can switch it on and off and not be such a downer sometimes.

But the anger is there, and I want to do something with it. I've been out of school for almost ten years now, and the first thing I want to do once I have some free time is revisit some of the feminist writers I too easily dismissed when I was in college. After that, who knows. I've dedicated time and energy in the past to causes I believe in (ACLU, Planned Parenthood) I should try to get some of my earlier idealism back, and offer the support that I should have been offering all along.

I'm older, I don't have the time I used to. But I have more focus than when I was younger. I also live in an area with one of the highest concentrations of academics in the world. I have no excuses. It's gonna be interesting.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Jan 25 '12

[EFFORT] Should be required reading for anyone into "jailbait"

138 Upvotes

Read this.

For every action, an equal and opposite reaction.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Jun 01 '12

PBS's "Culture of Reddit" video, where in SRS is shown in a pretty positive light

137 Upvotes

Here's the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=fXGs_7Yted8

Overall I quite enjoyed the short featurette. It highlights everything that I actually appreciate about what Reddit is capable of when shitlordery isn't involved, and SRS was given a pretty solid commendation as being a place to exist separate from the clearly observable misogynist/homophobic/racist/Generally Fucking Bigoted Crap.

What did you fine folks think of it?


r/SRSDiscussion • • May 30 '12

[Meta] Effective immediately, any threads comparing homosexuality to pedophilia will be removed and the poster put on probation

136 Upvotes

Need reasons? Read these comment trees.

1

2

If you want to talk about potential ableism as it relates to pedophilia as a psychiatric disorder, go ahead. Leave homosexuality out of it.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Mar 31 '18

Two Years of My Life I'll Never Get Back: a former anti-SJW's self-indulgent reflection on GamerGate (which still a thing somehow!)

135 Upvotes

This might sound vain and self-indulgent but I feel like I need to get this off of my chest.

I used to be a hardcore GamerGater. I helped out with the KnowYourMeme article, posted on 8chan, but I mostly hung around on Tumblr with other GGers. I was mutuals with a surprisingly large number of them (takashi0 was one of my first followers)

The thing that a lot of people don't realize about GamerGate was that at the beginning, most of us didn't consider it an anti-feminist movement or even a political movement. I thought Zoe Quinn's "crimes" (which were and still are bullshit created by an abusive ex-lover, but I fell for it nonetheless) were setting back women in the gaming industry and that Anita Sarkeesian and other feminist critics of games were sex-negative. (Side note: a lot of young men have no idea what "sex-positivity" actually means. Who would've guessed it?) I and a lot of other people tried justifying GG with feminist and social justice rhetoric, which produced such Scalding Hot Takes as "the concept of the male gaze is heteronormative and lesbophobic," "safe spaces are segregation," and my personal favorite: "intersectionality is culturally appropriating black and LGBT struggles" (that one was from a friend of mine!)

But after two embarrassing years, I finally snapped. It was around the time that the alt-right were starting to gain prominence that I realized something: they came from us. We were fertile breeding ground for them. And for all our talks about "oh it's really about ethics", most of the time we were just running smear campaigns on people who disagreed with us.

And then I actually took a sociology class, followed by media studies and black history, and realized something: the "evil essjaydubayoos" weren't calling for censorship. No, they were critiquing games for political and social subtext. They were the only ones who were seriously treating gaming as an art form!

Gamer bros are funny, because they defended gaming as a form of art, then turn around and go after people for treating games like art to be critiqued.

It was incredibly disheartening, but at the same time incredibly cathartic to realize that I was part of a movement of pathetic dupes who brought into the idea of a "gamer identity". They never wanted gaming to be seen as an art form, they just wanted no one to ever say anything bad about them ever again!

In fact, the final time I ever went to r/KIA, I saw a banner that said "Gaming isn't art, it's something better!"

Oh. So that's what you're saying now?

And I look at the game industry today, full of bloated "cinematic experiences" and glorified gambling simulators, and I see gamer bros complaining about the triple a publishers not taking games seriously anymore.

And I just want to shout "THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT. YOU WANTED GAMING TO BE FREE OF ANY AND ALL SUBTEXT OF SYMBOLISM AND THEY LISTENED."

To anyone who has been harmed or harassed by GamerGate, whether it be directly or indirectly, I want to sincerely apologize for everything. I am an accomplice in this. I and a lot of other passionate people got duped into falling for a lie, and we became fertile recruitment ground for the burgeoning alt-right. I regret every moment I've spent with that toxic community.


r/SRSDiscussion • • Aug 03 '16

Is "Neckbeard" problematic?

131 Upvotes

I've never really felt comfortable with the word, but I recently came across this comic which explains my thoughts perfectly. What do you all think?


r/SRSDiscussion • • May 21 '12

[SRSIAMA] I'm 1/3rd of MemeFactory and the writer of the SRS portion of the ROFLCon presentation we gave earlier this month.

131 Upvotes

Hi everybody.

If you wanna talk about blatant ableism, the audience reaction, the show, or ROFLCon, this is the place. I'll be on and off responding to whatever y'all post.

Didn't want to interrupt the circlejerk in SRS main.

EDIT : Thanks everybody who stopped by! I had a great time. I have to feed myself and walk my dog now, so I'm stepping away from the computer for a while. I'm going to be talking about SRS in next Wednesday's episode of PBS's Off Book, an amazing series on art and culture. You can watch the series here : http://www.youtube.com/user/PBSoffbook

The latest episode is about lego art!

EDIT 2 : Whoops! Hoelt pointed out that I don't have a link to the SRS thread OR the video in here! So: Here's the SRS thread : http://www.reddit.com/r/ShitRedditSays/comments/tx7qw/meta_srs_has_infiltrated_the_media_bonus_giant/ Here's the presentation from the time we start talking about reddit: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsSiDS_z4uk&t=12m50s

SECOND PART HERE


r/SRSDiscussion • • Feb 02 '13

My love hate relationship with SRS

130 Upvotes

I was going to post this in /r/ShitRedditSays but the subreddit isn't created for personal stories. I wanted to share this story to let people know as odd as the fempire is, it taught me some very valuable lessons.

I started reading the fempire when the great violentacrez saga happened. I initially was upset with SRS for exposing another users identity. (FOR CLARITY I know SRS had nothing to do with violentacrez) But i was curious about the situation and figured out SRS had nothing to do with it.

The fempire now had my curiosity and attention. I started reading more and little but little I started to see why this subreddit existed. My final "conversion" to the SRS ideals is when SRS had a couple links to poop from /r/pics. Both of links were awesome pictures of little kids. Both threads were littered with pedophilia comments. I thought to myself why would people make comments like this in a public forum? I did some more searching and found a couple more pictures with kids in them on reddit. Almost every single one of those posts had pedophilia comments in it. It shocked and disgusted me.

After this eye opening experience I wanted to learn more. I started learn: more about feminism and why the public needs it, why gender is a sensitive issue, why a lot of jokes here aren't funny, why rape should never be joked about, how society oppresses women and most IMPORTANTLY how to respect people in a proper way.

Before the fempire I was never disrespectful in IRL or online. What I'm trying to get at that I wasn't a shitlord but not necessarily the most respectful person either. But the fempire opened my eyes on how to treat people with more respect and sensitivity.

I also learned more about myself. I'm your typical redditor I guess. I'm in my 20's, male, white and an engineering major. I learned about male privilege and how not take advantage of it. To get to the bottom of all this SRS has made me into a better person and I really enjoy the change.

I wanted to share this story because I want all you wonderful people to know your making a difference and keep working hard. You have all taught me a lot and I want to keep learning.

Thanks!


r/SRSDiscussion • • Dec 06 '16

Its not just "straight cis white men"

124 Upvotes

I don't like the way yall put it like that. No I'm not a straight cis white boy who's offended, I'm a bisexual woman of color.

I'm not trying to deny anyone's struggle but when the topic is about race, trump etc. it's wrong to make it about "white men" because white women made trump happen too. The majority of them voted trump. Most of my racist experiences have been by white women too. I just don't like this because it turns the whole thing into a joke.

No I don't hate white girls, but to include them into the same struggle as PoC and LGBTQ? No thanks. That's way too inclusive for me.

I remember this time when a racist comment was put on SRS I went through their posting history because I've seen the name before and Oh look its a white woman. One who also posted on feminist subs. The same ones I frequented.

The other parts too though. So many gay white men are extremely racist or transphobic. I thought that was a known thing, I've heard from a gay friend that the gay dating scene is so openly racist.

What do yall think?


r/SRSDiscussion • • Jan 09 '13

Hey Shitlords - it appears teaching men not to rape *does* help

123 Upvotes

Saw this one on r/sex (via SRD but that's something else):

http://freethoughtblogs.com/greta/2013/01/08/rape-prevention-aimed-at-rapists-does-work/

"The “Don’t Be That Guy” campaign is a public service rape prevention campaign launched in Edmonton in 2010, and adopted by other cities in Canada, which took the radical step of aiming its message, not at potential rape victims, but at potential rapists. It took the radical step of educating potential rapists about what rape actually is. It recognized the role that alcohol commonly plays in rape — and it educates potential rapists that having sex with someone who doesn’t consent, or who is too drunk to consent, or who is passed out and therefore unable to consent, is rape.

The campaign didn’t target the stereotypical media image of rapists, the drooling psychopaths springing on suspects in a dark alley with a knife. It targeted ordinary folks, frat boys and partiers and bar-hoppers and folks who just like to toss a few back now and then… who have been brought up in a culture that teaches that drunkenness equals consent. It was influenced by a study out of the U.K. showing that 48 percent of men ages 18 to 25 did not consider it rape if the women was too drunk to know it was happening. And it teaches them that no: drunkenness does not equal consent, being stoned does not equal consent, being passed out does not equal consent. It had slogans like, “Just because she isn’t saying no… doesn’t mean she’s saying yes.” “Just because you help her home… doesn’t mean you get to help yourself.” “Just because she’s drunk doesn’t mean she wants to f**k.” It had slogans on every poster saying, “Sex without consent = sexual assault.”

And the campaign has been so successful, the number of reported sexual assaults in Vancouver fell by 10 per cent."

Anyone else got examples of such campaigns helping?


r/SRSDiscussion • • Apr 25 '12

Blind tribal elder has KKK carved into his chest during hospital visit. Police refuse to investigate.

123 Upvotes

Here's his video

And an article

Vern Traversie is a 68 year old, totally blind Lakota tribal elder who recently underwent open heart surgery at Rapid City Regional hospital.

He woke up with KKK carved into his chest, along with multiple stab wounds. Being as he is blind, he didn't even know until a nurse finally broke down and told him.

Despite taking this to the police, FBI and state's attorney, there has been no investigation. The hospital claims the wounds were caused by excessive tape.

This needs to get out in the open. Please, spread the word. Tell people about this. All Vern wants is an investigation.