r/SRSBooks • • Apr 04 '12

George R. R. Martin on writing women (x-post from /r/gameofthrones)

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Jul 28 '12

Jim C. Hines » Why I Cancelled my Reddit Q&A

Thumbnail
jimchines.com
38 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Jul 27 '12

[TW racism, blackface] "Save the Pearls", a YA novel that's basically saying "save the white people"

35 Upvotes

From Racebending: “Save the Pearls” is a vanity published YA novel trying to bill itself as the next “The Hunger Games.” The publisher says that “‘Save the Pearls turns the tables on racism.’” It uses blackface as a plot device. In author Victoria Foyt’s futuristic world, no one wants to mate with white people—or “pearls”—considered to be the ugliest humans oppressed by people of color. In order to survive, they must put on blackface make up to be attractive to the ruling class of “coals.” Hoyt explains: “their stunningly dark skin that carries the greatest amount of melanin…makes them the strongest, most powerful race alive.” The protagonist is a white girl who must smear her face with “midnight luster” make up in order to protect herself from radiation and in order to look beautiful to the oppressive “coals” in hopes that they will mate with her.

The rule in Eden’s post-apocalyptic world is: the darker the skin, the higher the mate-rate. Other factors calculated into one’s mate-rate include wealth or employment status. For example, Ronson Bramford, a handsome Coal titan of industry, is at the top of the heap with a mate rate of 98%. At age twenty-two, he only has two years left in which to mate—or else he’d probably have a 100% mate-rate. Tiger’s-Eyes, or Latinos, usually rate above Ambers, or Asians, in the future race wars. White-skinned Pearls offer little resistance to The Heat, and therefore, are at the bottom. Only a Cotton, or Albino, would be lower.”

IT USES BLACKFACE AS A PLOT DEVICE. HOLY GAGA I WANT TO SCREAM AND CRY AAAH


r/SRSBooks • • Apr 25 '13

Wikipedia's Sexism Toward Female Novelists

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
32 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Feb 28 '12

"there is a distinction between having the legal right to say something & having the moral right not to be held accountable for what you say. Being asked to apologise for saying something unconscionable is not the same as being stripped of the legal right to say it."

Thumbnail
chinamieville.net
31 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • May 20 '13

Just read Dracula, what a pile of poop it was! [Spoilers within]

28 Upvotes

I had to read it in a week for class, so I somewhat skimmed it, but I was absolutely STAGGERED by the amount of misogyny in that book, my god. I don't know what I was expecting, it just came as such a shock after Jane Eyre.

My lecturer said it had a very modern portrayal of women; he said Mina was a 'modern woman' who wasn't afraid to get as involved as the men were. I have to ask how exactly he saw that? Both Mina and Lucy (pre-vampire) practically fall over each other to submit to men!

So lets analyze the ladies in the book:

We have the weird sisters, caricatures of women who dare to showcase their sexuality. They're evil, eating what is implied to be a baby, just to illustrate how much they eschew motherhood and the 'proper' role of women.

Lucy, originally a 'pure' girl (though apparently less so than Mina) is forced to drink blood from Dracula's breast in another illustration of just how evil the concept of switching gender roles is. The blood transfusion from "good men" should cure her, and is treated as a sexual act, with the men unwilling to tell her husband that they saved his wife. She becomes a vampire nonetheless, and tries to seduce her husband, but they defeat and stake her (I'm not even going to get into the phallic imagery here.. Oh wait I just did).

And lastly we have Mina, who the men constantly praise as the perfect woman, who studies machines to be useful to her husband and does basically everything he says without question. She too is seduced by Dracula but pushes him away. Unlike the other women, she seems to have no sexual desires at all. She constantly serves the male characters of the novel until the end.

Dracula's sole goal is to corrupt the women into sexual beasts in order to corrupt the men and then control the country. And through this we see the true terror of the book for Stoker. It isn't vampires. He's terrified of women. More specifically, then using their seductive side to seduce men from what he would consider rational thought. This sheer terror of women manifests throughout the text, as they are all tools to the men around them, but most often used to corrupt the 'good men'.

I can't believe my professor considered it a progressive book with regards to women. It's trite and nonsense, an exercise in colonialism and physiology, but mainly misogyny.


r/SRSBooks • • Dec 19 '13

Bilbo Baggins is a girl: Until children’s books catch up to our daughters, rewrite them (xpost /r/books)

Thumbnail
slate.com
26 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Sep 12 '12

When A Popular List Of 100 'Best-Ever' Teen Books Is The 'Whitest Ever' : NPR Ombudsman : NPR

Thumbnail
npr.org
26 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • May 05 '13

Informal SRS Book Club reading of "The Great Gatsby" this week for anyone interested!

25 Upvotes

So today I made a post in /r/SRSFeminism about The Great Gatsby, specifically about how Fitzgerald (and, by extension, Luhrmann) get the concept of flappers completely wrong.

The article itself is fun, but it included a link to a .pdf entitled "A Feminist Reading of The Great Gatsby". It's a very basic introduction to the idea of feminist literary criticism through Gatsby, and it's also a nice refresher course on Feminism 101.

During the discussion, /u/shneerp and I decided to do a lightning read of Gatsby this week before the film comes out on the 10th. We'll discuss it in a thread next weekend sometime Sunday here in /r/SRSBooks, and anyone who wants to join us is totally welcome! The discussion will focus primarily on a feminist reading of the novel, and the .pdf I linked provides a nice context and primer for anyone unfamiliar with that style of criticism.

If anyone's able to see the film or get through the slim novel (only 180 pages!) this week, feel free to head over and share your thoughts! <3

edit: shneerp has some great plans for this, so it should be a lot of fun!

edit2 It's great to see so many enthusiastic responses across the fempire! Please do let anyone else who might be interested in a feminist reading of Gatsby know that they are welcome as well; I am unfamiliar with all of the women's subreddits on reddit. Also, here is an online version of The Great Gatsby. (There are others if that format doesn't suit you!)


r/SRSBooks • • Dec 18 '12

Historically Authentic Sexism in Fantasy. Let’s Unpack That.

Thumbnail
tor.com
24 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Nov 09 '12

Books That Old White Men Love to Hate

Thumbnail
flavorwire.com
24 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Mar 13 '15

I just found out that /r/booksuggestions is run by white supremacists

22 Upvotes

It's mod list includes mods from subreddits like /r/NationalSocialism, /r/CoonTown, and /r/CuteFemaleCorpses.

It still has 47 thousand subscribers, more than triple the number in /r/suggestmeabook, the subreddit that was made to replace it.


r/SRSBooks • • May 11 '13

A feminist discussion of The Great Gatsby – come share your thoughts!

21 Upvotes

So, fellow SRSers and booklovers, here is a thread for us to discuss that 1925 classic, The Great Gatsby, through the lens of a current and progressive feminist understanding. This idea started in a thread posted a week ago in SRSFeminism by /u/lemon_meringue linking to an article about how The Great Gatsby can really be read as a critique of the “Modern Woman” that flappers embodied. This article, of course, was written in response to the then soon-to-be-released movie remake.

While keeping the popularity of this recently released movie in mind (as well as the movie’s relation to the book, for those of us who have both read the book and seen the movie), let’s get into it! Please feel free to share any thoughts on characters and their development, thoughts on specific quotations or passages, links to other criticisms of the book and the movie, and general impressions of the book (or movie).

I will now, as a structured guide, briefly delve into the arguably problematic aspects of this novel with regards to the empowerment of women through a chapter-by-chapter semi-close reading of select quotations (I will be citing the Scribner 2004 paperback edition for page numbers). I’ve excluded Chapters V, VIII, and IX for lack of relevant material (that I could find).

And here we go!

Feel free to skip down to the comments and start sharing your thoughts right away if you don’t want to read through all my babbling—I won’t be offended! :)


Chapter I

it is what preyed on Gatsby, what foul dust floated in the wake of his dreams that temporarily closed out my interest in the abortive sorrows and short-winded elations of men. [p. 2]

“What preyed on Gatsby” in this ominous prelude to our story is arguably Daisy, and her wishy-washy womanly affections. She is what consumed him, and for that she is bad.

At any rate, Miss Baker’s lips fluttered, she nodded at me almost imperceptibly, and then quickly tipped her head back again…Again a sort of apology rose to my lips. Almost any exhibition of complete self-sufficiency draws a stunned tribute from me. [p. 9]

We can see now, unsurprisingly, from the very beginning that our narrator looks down on women (or at has set expectations for them), such that he is surprised to find one who makes no effort to engage him and make him feel at ease (as women presumably usually do for him).

Sometimes she and Miss Baker talked at once, unobtrusively and with a bantering inconsequence that was never quite chatter, that was as cool as their white dresses and their impersonal eyes in the absence of all desire. [p. 12]

Women, eh? Truly a spectacle to be observed, with their strange ways of communication and all.

’I’m glad it’s a girl. And I hope she’ll be a fool—that’s the best thing a girl can be in this world, a beautiful little fool.’ [p. 17]

Daisy laments to Nick, and gives us a window into her thought process. She has already given up at this point in her life on being anything other than the wife of a rich but otherwise rather unendearing man.


Overall, in Chapter I Daisy and Jordan are introduced and described in terms that emphasize their languid sexuality, while on the other hand Tom is presented as hyper-masculine (our male narrator, we learn, served in The Great War and has since been “restless,” leading us to assume that he too is traditionally “masculine”), and so our story begins with gender roles firmly entrenched.

-----

**Chapter II**

>His wife was shrill, languid, handsome, and horrible. [p. 30]

Whenever Nick meets a woman, such as this party guest, he describes them similarly. As our only narrator we must rely on his descriptions. Either all the women he meets are actually terrible, or he’s a little sexist. Since this is a novel and we have no other source of information that allows to determine more objectively what the characters are like, we have little choice but to believe they are all horrible, or at least to allow ourselves to see them that way.

This chapter is the introduction to that lewd and generally unfortunate city of ashes where only debauchery occurs. We meet Myrtle, Tom’s mistress, and her friends, and they are for the most part rather unlikeable for their superficiality and airs of self-importance. Myrtle is an obviously contemptible character for how she both cheats on her well-meaning husband and uses Tom for his money. That she is female only makes things worse. Interestingly though, in this chapter Tom hits Myrtle for saying Daisy’s name. In so doing he becomes equally if not more unlikeable than Myrtle, and adds a number of entries to the list of reasons he is an unsympathetic character (he’s racist, wasteful, unabashedly unfaithful, abusive, and he thinks of Daisy as his property).


Chapter III

In his blue gardens men and girls came and went like moths among the whisperings and the champagne and the stars. [p. 39]

If we ignore for a moment both the incredible poetry and the larger metaphor of this second sentence of this chapter’s introduction and instead focus on its bare-bones implications, it sets up one of my favorite easily passed over manifestations of the patriarchy—that often, if unintentionally, used dichotomy of “men and girls.” It might as well read “men and their dependants” or “men and their inferiors” as far as I’m concerned.

The groups change more swiftly, swell with new arrivals, dissolve and form in the same breath; already there are wanderers, confident girls who weave here and there among the stouter and more stable, become for a sharp, joyous moment the centre of a group, and then, excited with triumph, glide on through the sea-change of faces and voices and color under the constantly changing light.

Suddenly one of the gypsies, in trembling opal, seizes a cocktail out of the air, dumps it down for courage and, moving her hands like Frisco, dances out alone on the canvas platform. [p. 40-41]

Girls, not women are confident. How cute of them, how endearing, how amusing, how trifling, Nick seems to say. They are gypsies, others, characters to be observed. Despite the orchestra and other party guests, these girls are the entertainment.

There was dancing now on the canvas in the garden; old men pushing young girls backward in eternal graceless circles [p.46]

Again with the men and girls, although here I believe Fitzgerald intends to evoke the meaning that I am inclined to find—that it is unacceptable that these creepy old dudes are trying (gracelessly) to cavort with these young women.

The hall was at present occupied by two deplorably sober men and their highly indignant wives. The wives were sympathizing with each other in slightly raised voices...the dispute ended in a short struggle, and both wives were lifted, kicking, into the night. [p. 51-52]

The wives are things, owned by the men. Not two men and two women, but two men and their wives that they handle like disobedient dogs.

Dishonesty in a woman is a thing you never blame deeply. [p.58]

15-year-old me wrote a bolded “what!?” in the margin, which I think says a lot. This quotation is when Nick is talking about semi-dating Jordan. Her fatal flaw is that she’s a compulsive liar, but he can’t be bothered. He has yet to learn the true extent of Jordan’s casual carelessness.


The number of times this particular chapter mentions “men” and “girls” in a comparison is almost too many to count (we see it also on p. 48 and 50), such that even anti-feminist 15-year-old me made comments in the margins about it again and again.  I don’t like this phrasing in general, but for the most part, I do believe the author’s intention was to drive home the lascivious nature of Gatsby’s parties (an intention with which I have few qualms), which paints both men and girls/women as morally bankrupt.

But still, the descriptions of what makes each gender bad vary: the men are all intelligent, if shady, business men and/or perverts, but the “girls” are not afforded the redeeming quality of at least being successful.  They, instead, are portrayed as unintelligent pretty faces looking to mooch of the men. 

-----

**Chapter IV**

>Benny McClenahan arrived always with four girls.  They were never quite the same ones in physical person, but they were so identical with one another that it inevitably seemed they had been there before. [p.63]

This chapter begins with a long list of noteworthy people who attended Gatsby’s summer parties.  Not surprisingly, most are men.  Women are mentioned throughout, but always as someone’s “girl” or daughter or wife. The “girls” don’t truly count.

-----

**Chapter VI**

>He knew women early, and since they spoiled him he became contemptuous of them, of young virgins because they were ignorant, of the others because they were hysterical about things which in his overwhelming self-absorption he took for granted. [p.98]

Even Nick is aware that Gatsby has or had problems not just with his ego, but also with relating to the women in his life.  

>an infinite number of women tried to separate him from his money. [p. 99]

This is about Dan Cody, the yacht man. Of course those scheming women tried to get his money, *of course*.

>By God, I may be old-fashioned in my ideas, but women run around too much these days to suit me. [p. 103]

Words from Tom’s mouth, unsurprisingly. 

The men mentioned in this chapter all have their hang-ups with women, but it is not entirely problematic in light of the book’s date of publication. All in all, the final pages of this chapter are far too tragically romantic for me to have any desire to criticize Tom and Gatsby’s unfortunate categorizations of women.


Chapter VII

Wilson was so sick that he looked guilty, unforgivably guilty—as if he just got some poor girl with child. [p. 124]

Why this metaphor? Why not “as if he had just killed a kitten”?

Her expression was curiously familiar—it was an expression I had often seen on women’s faces…jealous terror [p.124-125]

This is as if to say jealousy is an emotion only for women (hint: it’s not).


In this chapter careless women do careless things, so their caretakers, the men, must get involved, and things escalate beyond repair.

-----

**Conclusion**

The book, I am afraid, *cannot* be completely divorced from its historical context; as such, it would be disingenuous to experience legitimate surprise in regard to the representation of women in the novel.  It was written soon after the passage of the 19th amendment, but just because women had gotten the right to vote and just because Fitzgerald’s wife was a “New Woman” herself does not mean we should be able to expect anything particularly enlightened.  

The movie as directed by Baz Luhrman, though I was not the biggest fan, erases almost entirely the unabashed sexism of days gone by.  By recreating the novel in the present, the problematic scenes are either cast aside completely or mocked and dismissed by eye rolls and knowing glances between our more relatable characters.

The novel, as a whole, is about the decline of civilization that Tom addresses on p. 12, “Civilization’s going to pieces,“ he laments.  To illustrate this, every single major character no matter their gender, besides perhaps our narrator with whom we must identify, is painted as morally reprehensible on a number of levels (they are all rich, or cheaters, or both). These people all get so caught up in extravagantly meaningless things that they lose themselves completely and, if they’re careless enough, they take others down with them too. 

We cannot get away from the fact that these characters, these men *and* women, *are* bad people. That’s the way they were written by Fitzgerald through Nick Carraway. We can try to argue around it based on our narrator’s bias, but there is not much ground to stand on if one chooses to argue that Daisy or Myrtle or the “girls” at the parties are “not that bad”—from what we can see, they are. 

If nothing else, the motif of the corrupt, unfeeling “modern woman” is common throughout the novel, and arguably even a guiding theme. Although they are not main characters (rather, they are merely obstacles or conquests for the men of the novel) we do see their personal stories unfold as well, but only to end in bouts of reckless abandon. Through their poetically long-winded, tragically beautiful, and borderline erotic descriptions we come to know that they are not truly women, but flighty, emotionless birds.

From the movie we can see the big picture, in 3D widescreen, that everything is spiraling downward together, *all* of these people in *all* of these places play a part in the demise of what was. But a novel forces us to read one word at a time, and to see only what is described for us—in this case we must rely on poetic metaphors masquerading as casual narrative prose. The only trouble is that these descriptions, despite their beauty, make little attempt to hide that what they rely on to illustrate civilization’s downfall is the demonization of femininity. 

r/SRSBooks • • Feb 05 '13

100 Books by Black Women

Thumbnail
forharriet.com
21 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Jul 16 '12

My big exciting plans for the evening.

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Sep 26 '13

[X-post from r/books] 7 Breathtakingly Sexist Quotes by Famous and Respected Male Authors

Thumbnail
reddit.com
20 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Jul 29 '13

How do you feel about "manfiction"?

20 Upvotes

So some of you may recall my post the other day over in SRSWorldProblems about Watership Down and its strange lack of female bunnies. On the other hand, I may not be as renowned as I imagine and you will be asking, who the hell does this person think they are?

Either is good.

Long story short, I decided to shelve Watership Down. I don't want to read any more books that don't have female characters. I originally was going to qualify that with "for no good reason," but expunged it. It's wishy-washy. No Female Characters is a good starting point, I think. It's nonspecific. There still might not be female POVs. The female characters might be poorly drawn. Those will be decided on a case by case basis.

But you wanna write a Great Novel that's a Deep Parable told through Bunnies, and you don't feel like making any of them (until, I hear, one appears later in the book) female? Not a single bunny in the Deep Parable Bunnies' Community was female?

I call bullshit and I will not read it.

What brought us here today? Well, I was browsing Reddit and ran into another highly recommended book, and got very close to acquiring it. Post-apocalyptic? Right up my alley. Survival? Kind of horrific? Very depressing? Check, check, and check. Highly Fucking Recommended. Oh, it's a father and son story? That may run afoul of my No Wimminz, No Ready rule.

So I Googled for a feminist perspective on The Road by Cormac McCarthy. This piece came up, and it put so much of what I'd been gauzily thinking into clear words.

As reigning high priest of manfiction Cormac McCarthy noted in a relatively recent interview with the Wall Street Journal, it’s hard to write about ladies. (“I was planning on writing about a woman for 50 years. I will never be competent enough to do so, but at some point you have to try.”) It’s so hard, in fact, that Cormac eschewed the ladies altogether in his most recent, Pulitzer-Prizewinning (ladies don’t win the Pulitzer) novel The Road.

Okay, the author of the article is a little rambly. We can forgive that.

For years I read, and sometimes even loved, manfiction. I was well into my twenties before it slowly began to occur to me that the ladies who surrounded me — smart, funny, fearless, awesome; ladies who hitchhiked across the country solo, hopped trains, taught themselves homesteading, backpacked through the wilderness, played in bands, dressed sexy, dressed like boys; lades who, in short, unapologetically lived their own lives on their own terms — were nowhere to be found in the books I was reading.

This has been a kinda difficult decision. It seems puerile to refuse to read something because it lacks girls or women, and I wonder what Masterpieces of Literature I'm gonna miss because of it. Here's the list so far:

Masterpieces of Literature I might never experience due to my puerile decision to stop reading manfiction. The list so far: (Edit: more added from thread)

  1. Watership Down

  2. The Road

  3. Moby Dick

  4. The Old Man and the Sea

I've made a decision. Once I've made it through the hundreds of books on my to-read list that aren't manfiction, then I'll contemplate cracking open some manfiction again. Deal?


r/SRSBooks • • Jul 11 '13

100 great sci-fi stories by women

Thumbnail
iansales.com
20 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Aug 01 '12

Gore Vidal, Elder statesman of American Rape Apology and Transphobia

Thumbnail tigerbeatdown.com
20 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Jan 26 '16

11-year-old who got sick of reading about white boys and dogs launches a book drive to find 1000 books featuring Black female protagonists

Thumbnail
jezebel.com
19 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Oct 16 '13

[x-post from r/books] Eleanor Catton: 'Male writers get asked what they think, women what they feel.'

Thumbnail
reddit.com
19 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Sep 29 '12

Interesting take on the "Dumbledore is gay" situation

Thumbnail
ferretbrain.com
19 Upvotes

r/SRSBooks • • Mar 03 '12

Recommend me a book for raising a baby girl to be an upstanding member of the Fempire.

19 Upvotes

Can anyone help me put together a reading list? My wife will give birth to a baby girl on August 1, and I want to raise her in the glorious image of the Fempire.


r/SRSBooks • • Jul 04 '14

What Straight Boys' "Favorite Books" Say About Them | A Buzzfeed article that doesn't suck

Thumbnail
buzzfeed.com
18 Upvotes