Yoona was undoubtedly a huge part of SNSD's public image, particularly during their peak years. She was the group's visual center, had considerable public recognition, and played an important role in attracting attention to the group.
But I've always wondered: how much of SNSD's success was tied to Yoona being the visual center?
We also have to consider the era in which SNSD debuted. This was before social media became the powerful promotional tool it is today. Groups couldn't rely on every member building an individual following through Instagram, TikTok or YouTube. Marketing and public exposure had to be concentrated on one or two members to establish a recognizable face for the group.
In SNSD's case, Yoona became that face visually, while Taeyeon became arguably the most identifiable member musically.
So here's the question:
Would SNSD have been more or less successful if another member had been chosen as the visual center?
Was Yoona the ideal choice from a marketing perspective, or could someone like Jessica, Yuri, Seohyun or Tiffany have been equally effective?
Given the lack of social media at the time, was concentrating promotional efforts on Yoona and Taeyeon actually essential to SNSD's success? Would a more evenly distributed marketing strategy have worked, or would it have diluted their public identity?
I'm particularly interested in whether people think SM made the right strategic decision, rather than simply debating who was the prettiest member.
Edit - My thoughts, SM made the right call. By all accounts, SNSD is already considered a legendary girl group there is not much higher they could have climbed and Yoona is widely regarded as the center of centers, so... she more than did her job.