r/SMG4 • u/Dr_Mario67 • Aug 06 '24
r/SMG4 • u/Jeff_the_Chad • Aug 14 '25
Discussion/Question This is By far my Most hated Character in Smg4.
Reasons: Has no personality, he's only used to be a Tool for the Plot. Terrible writing, He is hypocritical asf, Characters like Smg3, Bombman, or even better Morty who is already in jail, who also commited death worthy crime sentencing. (+Morty also dosent even have a Motive to Change at all, hes literally the Definition of a sociopath) gets a free pass, while Puzzles who definitly Changed By the Look of His befriendment with a Leggy 2.0 gets instantly charged By the death Cube. Better yet, Monitor Not only charged him for the deathcube, but also decided to accelerate the process Just because Puzzles Phone Ring in His cell. Not only is He an Antagonist in the series, he,s straight Up an villian who dosent have any redeemable aspects on him. I want to See him dead.
r/SMG4 • u/polishisreal • Mar 18 '23
RANT Today's movie was trash. Spoiler
Aight, i will explain why this movie sucked here.
Soo, for a few episodes, they made SMG4 go absolutely fucking nuts, they made him a madman, that is someone with that you CANNOT reason with, someone utterly insane. Only to resolve entire conflict in 30 seconds of some stereotypical "boo hoo we love u, pls don't kill us pls" speech?
For 100 hours, they have hyped Us up, for a few weeks even, for this "Epic" and the "Channel-changing" arc, and make 2 good videos, only to shit all over it and remove the castle, and make a new one? (aka. remove the the most iconic location in this entire series?).
And i would tolerate it, if it was even fucking funny, but guess what? It is not funny. Even when they have attempted, the attempts at humor were terrible, the entire movie didn't make me laugh a single time, in the span of 38 minutes, nothing made me laugh.
I also felt, that in this movie critics were metioned as haters, who only demand too much all the time. But it might be more subjective, beacuse they could just jab at those real haters, who never like anything, without giving a reason.
Overall, the Plot of the movie i rate to 2/10.Animation : 7/10.Overall : 4/10. (beacuse the plot sucked dick.)
r/SMG4 • u/Ark2202 • Nov 07 '24
Discussion/Question Mr.Puzzles deserved his Redemption Arc, not being sent to a mental hospital !
Yeah, he did a lot of bad things, to say the least, but... am I the only one who was pissed off by how the SMG4 Gang abruptly turned him over to the cops without even letting him finish his speech about realizing his mistakes??
r/SMG4 • u/Hollywill06 • Jan 31 '24
Discussion/Question POV: The Mad Cow is The Antagonist of WOTFI 2024, What Would Happen in This Saga?
r/SMG4 • u/FlowerMadison • Aug 05 '24
Episode review The Reporter has OFFICIALLY revealed her favorite SMG4 video of all time!
A Night At SMG4’s has the most BEAUTIFUL writing I’ve ever seen! Sure, all the other SMG4 videos are still good, but this one is the best SMG4 video of the year! And I really love what Mr. Puzzles said to Leggy when they’re fighting SMG4…I just can't remember what it was…hopefully, you would tell me what it was in the comments. (Probably u/Mrpuzzlevision would definitely know what I’m talking about!) That pose at the start of the episode, really makes me question: why were they posing? Though, it would be even GREATER if I was in it! (please don't downvote me!) Also, I really love how cool Mr. Puzzles is with those cool glasses! His personality, however, IS EXACTLY WHAT I’m LOOKING FOR! This LOVELY episode is all about teamwork of friendship! (And would totally fit my Paper Mario spin-off! Link in comments) Hopefully, there will be more like this in the future! And thanks for reading!
r/SMG4 • u/mauhid123qw • May 22 '23
Discussion/Question Stop it, get some help
That's it, can everyone stop criticizing smg4 like crazy? I don't care if Meggy is a mary sue (whatever that is), or Mario is a man-baby or something, all I care is if there is a video, then it's good enough to exist. You all need to know how to move on, smg4 is going to go down this lane, AND ALL OF YOU ARE GONNA LIKE IT.
I'm sorry for screaming, but I'm just tired of seeing people writing essays of criticism to the point where I just downvote it and move on. So please guys just don't criticize, I doubt any of you will be able to see this anyways, just please watch the videos and enjoy them like me. Although I only started watching smg4 around 2019 0r 2020 (and by that time I was just watching content from the youtube recommendations/homepage), I still like his videos.
Now what I want from the comments isn't what you think about my opinion, but just funny clips of Mario being stupid in the old castle, for example, this:

(p.s. Who wants for me to make a post so people can type in the comments on what game Mario should play next, for its pizza tower, mostly because I want to see Mario's reaction to the last part of the game)
(p.p.s/p.s.s [IDK what it is], moderators, I just wanted to tell you that I didn't know which flair to use for this post, so please tell me if the flair is wrong)
r/SMG4 • u/Awsum_Megario • Feb 29 '24
Meta Can you all stop yapping about the Tari VA drama?
Just kidding. I just made that the title to grab people's attention. I am actually here to be serious with the Tari VA drama, and not to stir up controversy.
Cause I'm here to ask a question: What is going on? I swear I don't go on Reddit for half a day and all of a sudden there's a drama? Can someone explain what the drama is about? Not just to me, to other people who don't know what the drama is about. That's why I'm making this post.
Thanks.
r/SMG4 • u/Some-Brief-730 • Apr 15 '25
Discussion/Question I'm leaving the fandom
Yes I decided to leave the smg4 fandom to fix up my struggles with my huge ass fictional crush on smg3 that everyone knows and yes I used the mizu 5 to give you a picture of what is happening I'm sorry guys I didn't want to leave as I got back in the fandom in 2023 but I'm sorry I enjoyed my time back in the fandom I joined in 2021 then left then came back in 2023 but I'm sorry guys I'm leaving again to fix everything in my life and the struggles in school thanks for reading I hope I can come back to the fandom when everything is solved if it isent I'm coming back in the summer untill school is back in session I HOPE YOU UNDERSTAND
r/SMG4 • u/[deleted] • Apr 20 '23
Discussion/Question can we all agree that meggy and desti kind of suck?
I mean both of them should have died, seriously desti's death is dumb can we agree on that?
and if you ask no I am not favoring old smg4 I am saying that both meggy and desti should get shish kabobed or meggy should have been an 1 time character due to her being liked we have a terrible peach.
r/SMG4 • u/pokemongoon67 • Jul 23 '26
Discussion/Question SMG4 was better without conveluted lore
SMG4 will always hold a special place in my heart however after the introduction of puzzle vision and SMG4 movies it fell off real bad..
I'm an old fan,watching since 2016-17 era and kept watching till whatever wotfi had mrpuzzle then stopped mostly because SMG4 did one thing it wasn't made for: CONVOLUTED STORIES
And I'm guessing it was Kevin's fault.. I just wish they kept the waluigi arc styled of story telling rather then whatever the hell 24 or the lawyer one was
r/SMG4 • u/disdatsteven10 • May 14 '25
Discussion/Question Is anyone else tired of SMG4 bringing back Mr Puzzles?
I get it, he’s cool, and people do like him, but he was defeated! Why even bring him back again and again AND AGAIN? He’s also why I hated the ending of Silence of the cats. He just has to be shoehorned in past his arc.
None of any other villains are. Wren was perfectly handled, Francis, and even Zero. But Puzzles is just appearing over and over without a care.
r/SMG4 • u/Phantomc05 • Dec 22 '24
Discussion/Question SMG4 (series) should have ended when GLITCH was founded
This will probably sound like an unpopular opinion but I think that SMG4 should’ve ended when GLITCH was formed. I’m pretty sure you‘ve heard of the term seasonal rot, correct? When a show goes on for too long, it’s bound to get bad overtime. This is what happens with a lot of long running shows like SpongeBob, The Simpsons, and Family Guy. You could say the same happened with SMG4. It used to be loved by back then, now it’s really controversial. Viewership has also kind of declined for the channel. You should end something while it’s still good so it doesn’t stain the series.
Another thing worth mentioning is that ever since GLITCH started doing well, SMG4 became a side project and money maker. This would probably explain why the series now has inconsistent quality.
Now I know what you’re all gonna ask me, “well if the series ended, how are they gonna get funds for glitch?“, GLITCH sells so much merch so they can just rely on that.
r/SMG4 • u/Odhran_7 • Oct 19 '24
Discussion/Question Was it just me, or was that the BEST WOTFI EVER!?!
In my opinion, that was the greatest WOTFI I’ve ever seen. And I’ve rewatched them all countless times. Just teh way Mr Puzzles (sort of) shifted, and the cliffhanger of him laughing, and the tone about Meggy‘s arc from Meggy-Leggy-Meggy-Leggy-Leggy/Meggy Hybrid-Meggy. The only thing I’m asking for is for Mr Puzzles to become a main character. He isn’t bad, or good, he’s neutral, and he is best friends with Meggy.
Maybe next year…
r/SMG4 • u/[deleted] • Nov 04 '23
Discussion/Question Mario is so getting redesigned lmao
Why else would they call this week’s episode Super SMG4 Wonder instead of Stupid Mario Wonder? Why else would the Mario Does Things series get rebranded into the SMG4 Crew? Why else would Marty exist? Why else would Peach’s castle get booted of the show in favor for an original castle. Why else would SMG4, SMG3, Boopkins, and Bob get redesigned? At this point, if still think that this isn’t a possibility, it’s just cope. It’s gonna happen. It’s not a matter of if it will happen. It’s a matter of when it will happen. Which will probably be by the end of the year of early next year in some fancy big movie or something. If you have an actual argument for why Mario, Luigi, and probably other Nintendo characters won’t get redesigned or killed off, please let me know because there is no way I’m wrong.
Edit: Me and everyone else is forgetting the whole point of this post. Whether or not SMG4 will succeed without Mario is a different conversation. The point was that Mario will get redesigned.
Edit 2: Okay this is getting nowhere. Look I’m gonna be real, I kinda have a life to live and I don’t really feel like arguing with you guys anymore. Especially when you all have the same exact argument even after I present evidence. You guys probably think I’m delusional but are you guys any better? It’s literally an echo chamber in here. Let me just say one last thing. Marty was first introduced in Mario is Fine. He was created because Mario was stressed out or whatever. Literally the most out of nowhere ending ever. It literally makes no sense. Lui, Luigi’s OC that Mario also created was also introduced which makes even less sense. Think about it. All I’m asking for you guys is to put the puzzle pieces together and just think. Don’t worry about the business side of it or SMG4 saying that he wouldn’t, just think. If you still don’t believe me, then whatever. I am 100% sure that Mario is getting redesigned and none of you can tell me otherwise.
r/SMG4 • u/Fair_Strawberry_5775 • Aug 24 '24
Episode review This sucks so much
Who else hates this
r/SMG4 • u/megabuster21 • Jul 12 '24
Discussion/Question cant wait for mid story and abysmal writing tomorrow!!
r/SMG4 • u/[deleted] • Sep 08 '23
Discussion/Question Do y’all remember when SMG4 was actually good?
After the anime art SMG4 really fell off hard. remember when it actually had a good rating and good jokes and not just Cocomelon for 12 year olds. I’m so disappointed just because he was funny at one point in even had good emotional he’s.(also I’m not a super Mario Logan fan)
r/SMG4 • u/UncannySkeleton • Jun 14 '24
Discussion/Question My SMG4 Character Tier List (Based on my Opinion, no hate)
r/SMG4 • u/VGRProductions • Feb 10 '23
Theory Karen the Cat is Uzi Doorman
Is Karen the Cat actually Uzi Doorman? Both Karen and Uzi are portrayed by Elsie Loveluck since Meggy Spletzer. What will see that Serial Designation N from Murder Drones who appears in the SMG4 Universe to meet Karen the Cat?
I'll call her Karen Doorman because she looks similar to Karen the Cat and Uzi Doorman.