r/SGU • • Jul 29 '26

Destiny Loves Genocide [Professor Dave goes after Israel and Zionism]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

So, youtube channel "Professor Dave Explains", known for good science communication and debunks, has a new video that is bound to turn heads.

In light of recent developments in the SGU and the work Dave has previously done, I figured this would be interesting here as well.

The thing I'm left wondering though: why is this coming from a YouTuber who specialize in science communication? That's an odd source. How does one go about verifying this?


r/SGU • • Dec 09 '25

Steve’s Patella

Post image
0 Upvotes

Low effort jumping on the bandwagon.


r/SGU • • Aug 30 '26

I Miss Evan Doing The Quote

5 Upvotes

I know Evan had to go and do not support his views or posts on social media. But I will have to say he did a much better job than Bob at reading the ending quote. His voice was almost perfect for ending the show. Bob just seems to fumble through it and talks way too much.

Just read the quote and be done with it.


r/SGU • • Jun 27 '26

I vote they don't replace Evan

7 Upvotes

I've been listening a long time, the episode that made me a regular was Steve doing a podcast in a tent while on vacation. That showed committment, baby. Last few years I would read the shownotes and not download because it felt too bloated, like almost 2 hours. Some of the segments just went on way too long cause everyone had to have a say. Without Evan hopefully they can tighten up the show to a reasonable 75 minutes or so then I'll start listening again. That's my 2 cents on how to move forward!


r/SGU • • Sep 28 '24

Is George Hrab the Scrappy-Doo of SGU?

0 Upvotes

I’m sure George is a wonderful human being and it sounds as if he’s a close friend of the show.

But, as a long time listener, I find him an unwelcome addition to any episode and generally find myself skipping those episodes.

I find him deeply unfunny and feel he tries way too hard. I find this then cheapens the quality of the discussion as the others try to play into his forced and clunky “kookiness”.

I know that the idea here is to broaden the appeal of skepticism and science education through adding humor. I think that can definitely work but I’d love to see (hear) an alternative to George.

Is it just me and everyone else loves George?


r/SGU • • Sep 21 '26

Little ChatGPT tip.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Not flawless. But it puts up safeguards. 🤜 💥


r/SGU • • Jan 10 '26

Rank the rogues' ludicrous misunderstandings of history today

5 Upvotes

My top 3:

  1. Kara thinking that the English cultists who, after failed self-exile in the benelux, accepted a lumber contract in the New World so they could beat their children in peace under the English flag, were explorers and scientists. The Puritans were reactionary freaks, not enlightened scientists.

  2. George thinking that math and science flourished in the Islamic world until the Caliphate "got rid of" those things, when in reality some form of "caliphate" or another endured in the Islamic world from the 7th century until 1924, and the Abbasid caliphate was the primary patron of art, science, literature, poetry, and math in the Islamic world. There was never some pre-Caliphate Islamic world

  3. George thinking that distrust of government was invented during Prohibition.

The rogues are always talking about how common it is for people who are good at one thing to assume that means they're good at everything, and that speaking outside of your own expertise is risky for that reason, and then unironically spouting borderline-incoherent nonsense about history when none of them are historians. What were your favorite examples today of the rogues spreading disinformation?

Addendum: today I am learning that skeptics do not give a rat's ass about historical truth.


r/SGU • • Dec 10 '25

Stevia Novella

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Feb 01 '26

Novellas, George Hrab, Bill Nye, & James Randi in the Epstein files

0 Upvotes

On Page 6 of this file, they're all named, along with Banachek, Richard Wiseman, David Gorski, Harriet Hall, Richard Saunders and others.

https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00700415.pdf


r/SGU • • Oct 19 '18

Why I stopped listening

1 Upvotes

After several years of faithfully listening to the SGU, something changed and I stopped listening. Here's why.

A bit of background: I started listening to the podcast on my senior year of high school. It accompanied me throughout uni and grad school, and I loved it. It simultaneously kindled my desire to learn more and it quenched my anger about pseudo-science and quackery. Then, a few months ago, I stopped listening. I was not in a good place emotionally, and somehow the show didn't actually make it any better. I didn't think much of it, as I just attributed that to my own mental state.

Today, after nearly six months of SGU abstinence, I tried again. "I'm better, now. I can listen to it again as I used to.", I thought to myself. But I couldn't do it. I listened to the latest episode (#692) and I was annoyed by the bad audio quality, their constant bickering and colloquial speech, and their disregard of serious engaging conversations (in favour of comedy). All of those annoyed me, they contribute to my complaint.

But that is not why I stopped listening and I won't be trying again any time soon. The real reason is this: I did not hear a sliver of self-critique or self-awareness. I heard several things that I disagree with, but no debate ensued. I heard some affirmations that were outright wrong, but they were enunciated from a position of authority over the rest of the team and nobody else called it out.

If the SGU taught me anything is to be a skeptic about my own beliefs and knowledge above all else. It makes me sad to hear them fail on that account.


r/SGU • • May 20 '18

cara santa maria ..is it now her podcast?

0 Upvotes

I have been an avid listener going on 10 years now... It was my podcast I didn't want to miss one sentence of but for the last 2 years it's been a continuous battle of frustration.

I have empathy for her and respect her for her openness about her depression and think she clearly can add a ton of value to the show but it just feels like she thinks she is the main attraction and to me she is not.

Its even got to the point now where I randomly pick a spot on an episode and about 70% of the time she is talking. Even feels like she is interviewing everyone else

Does anyone else feel she should learn to take a step back or am I alone here? I've found myself skipping episodes over the last year because I feel I genuinely won't enjoy listening to her talk so much.


r/SGU • • Jan 29 '19

Am I the only one that thinks Cara may not be the best fit for SGU?

0 Upvotes

More and more I'm seeing Cara just not getting it. This weeks episode with her arguing with Steve about the complexity of identifying speech in the brain is a classic example. Instead of deffering to someone who is an expert in the field she just doubles down and ends up looking like an airhead. There have been several similar instances like this and I can just see the guys face-palming through them. Don't get me wrong, I like Cara but i think she just needs to stop talking from a point of ignorance.


r/SGU • • Mar 23 '22

Please end Who's that Noisy

1 Upvotes

The sound clips are just annoying and grating. The segment is mostly wrong guesses with a tidbit of info at the end. Please Rogues, kill that noisy!


r/SGU • • Sep 12 '26

Baby crying in ep 1105

1 Upvotes

Not complaining, I get there are limits to what you can do with sound especially when recording publicly, but boy it made it difficult to listen to this during my 1 year olds nap


r/SGU • • Sep 25 '21

An Emeritus Editor At Science-Based Medicine Just Sent This Letter To Steven Novella Criticizing The Site's Recent Turn Away From Rigorous Science

Thumbnail
jessesingal.substack.com
2 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Dec 10 '25

The Nina. The Pinta…

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Mar 23 '23

The Muddling of the American Mind – Part II

0 Upvotes

https://www.quackometer.net/blog/2023/03/the-muddling-of-the-american-mind-part-ii.html

"This is Part II of an appraisal of Steven Novella’s claim that it is “not scientifically controversial” that science is not a “binary” of male and female but a “bimodal distribution”."


r/SGU • • Dec 09 '25

Please let me know when the sub is finished posting this nonsense so I can resubscribe

17 Upvotes

It was funny the first handful of times. Now it's hackneyed.


r/SGU • • Oct 20 '24

Sorry, Jay, the segment about AI was bad

2 Upvotes

TL;DR: The topic of LLMs are/aren't a big step towards AGI had a lot of questionable statements stemming from possible misunderstanding of how LLM/AI/brain work.

I love Jay, but I think this latest episode missed the mark in this segment. I honestly don't even know what the point was. It started with a statement that some scientists think LLM is a big step towards AGI but the rest of it sounded like Jay's personal opinions on the subject. But to do that you need a pretty solid math and software background, and if you don't - the skeptics and sci-com 101 say "just cover what experts said". But there were no references or quotes of actual experts in the field..

"LLM just regurgitates" - how often can you say that whatever your opinion is is your own and is not a result from the knowledge taken from other people? Our brains regurgitate all the time. It's the most effective way to process the information and it would be weird if we didn't do that. Energy-wise.

"LLM just does statistics" - what's that supposed to convey? Our brain does that - connections become stronger the more often they are activated (among other things). That's pretty much - being driven by statistics. So why is this an argument against LLM being AGI?

The whole topic of "common sense". It's literally the most common answer you'd encounter in the body of knowledge of a society. That's exactly what LLMs do and do great. The whole issue on the path to AGI is to not do common sense, but to do actual logic. Maybe "common logic" is what was implied, but that's a totally different thing, and would probably result in a completely different discussion.

The examples were inadequate too, in my opinion. It takes 30 seconds to ask chat gpt why coffee gets cold and it explains it very well. You can ask to walk you through step by step what's happening and why, and it will tell you. Like Steve said multiple times before, you cannot tell if the system is AGI or not by just looking at the answers it gives you. LLMs currently WILL give you all the answers that make them seem AGI, while they are not. But your examples do not expose that. LLM totally knows what a "cheat day" is and will give you a proper answer (try it). But on the other hand, "cheat day" is not "common sense". Being from a non-US culture, I don't know what "cheat day" is and would be stumped by that question. Am I less AGI than Chat GPT?

With all that said, I do think LLMs are not AGI and will not become AGI simply by getting more training data. But the (emergent) thing they do, is converting the body of knowledge captured in written language, into mathematical/computer entities that can be operated on. And just that one thing could be a huge step to AGI. It's the ability to store and process knowledge and concepts (and not just combinations of letters) that brings a new power to these systems.


r/SGU • • Aug 01 '25

Steve and the hot dog delusion.

0 Upvotes

As smart and skeptical as he may be. Steve has really bad knowledge of the world outside the US.
He really thinks that hot dogs is somehow an American thing?

This is not the first example of when he's clueless about the world in large


r/SGU • • Jul 20 '21

What a community of skeptics.

0 Upvotes

It is a damning indictment of the SGUs reddit community that in the comments to three topics on SBM, Shrier and Singal there are so few people discussing the content of any of the arguments of any of these people! Its full of discussions about who is transphobic, who is an expert, replies and replies about how quotation marks should be used. Who counts as left, who is only interested in free speech. Anything to avoid doing the hard work of assessing the evidence and arguments for yourselves.

I have come to the conclusion that 'skeptics' are just like the non skeptical herd. You should be ashamed of yourselves. I am ashamed of you.


r/SGU • • Jul 08 '24

When the rogues go rogue they really go rogue. No, the Capulet Festival wasn't a Ponzi scheme. No, event insurance doesn't incompetence. Yes, file a dispute with your credit card company.

0 Upvotes

The rogues really should stick to science or at least bring-in an appropriate attorney or fraud expert. The Capulet Festival segment discussion went off the rails at the end.

I was really disappointed that Cara spouted Ponzi Scheme. The Ponzi Scheme allegation is especially annoying as it's often misused to attack Social Security and Medicare, so I had hoped Cara would be not feed that trope.

She then made a bizarre accusation that event organizers not paying all event costs up front is some uniquely American business scam. Of course any event organizer is going to rely on ticket sales to pay their costs. That's not a scam, but a business risk. The alleged scam aspect of the Fyre and Capulet festivals is that the organizers knew they were not going to be able to provide the services they were selling, but didn't want to cancel or refund the tickets already sold.

Then one of the guys speculated about event insurance -- which I think they would know better since they organize events. Event insurance covers unforeseeable events, disasters, and accidents -- it would not cover the organizers knowingly not providing the services they advertised. I suppose an event organize could try to get some type of Errors & Omission insurance, but that is often prohibitively expensive and probably would not be offered to an inexperienced event organizer.

And yes, ticketholders should dispute the tickets with their credit card companies. I suppose it depends on the credit card company's fraud policies whether they would consider the ticket sale to be fraudulent.

Overall this would have been an interesting segment had they brought in an expert, but instead it just turned into a low-quality podcast of people spouting unqualified opinions.


r/SGU • • Aug 25 '21

Decent summary article at "The Critic" of the SBM-Shrier controversy

Thumbnail self.blockedandreported
0 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Dec 10 '25

Cara Centi Maria

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Sep 24 '21

Covid lockdowns increasing obesity as obesity is leading comorbity for covid deaths. Worst within minority groups.

Thumbnail
thefederalist.com
0 Upvotes