Edit: this is not an "exposing the hypocrisy" kind of essay. I am just thinking about how "non-magic" things work exactly like "magic" things and the distinction between them being entirely a social agreement.
I thought this might be helpful also for all the "I am struggling to believe" people. Everyone is is a witch doing magic all the time. Sounds weird? Consider this:
Millions of grown-up, non-religious, completely materialist and secular humans every day:
"O Great Economy, we beg you to accept our humble sacrifice, the environment that enables us to live, and bless us with electrons unto our bank accounts. For indeed, he who has no electrons is worthy of starvation and hypothermia, and justly so."
"O Great Law, I present to you the sacred texts, with the gaps filled as thou commandeth! With my stamp, I give thee life, O Stevenson & Sons Brewery Co.! Amen!"
"O Great Homeland, we beg you to accept our humble sacrifice, the life and blood of our sons and husbands, and our taxes to be spent unto bombs and tanks, so that your sacred territory may expand! For the lines of the maps, the greatness of the nation, is indeed above all."
"The planet we live on made a whole number of revolutions around its star so blow these candles and make a wish."
*
Actually everything is "magic", we just pretend that our own culturally accepted magic is some objective, scientific thing, because that is what our current mainstream ideology uses to decide if something is legit.
Every ideology is basically a religion. If you ask "why" for long enough, you arrive at some axiom which has no real explanation, you just have to accept it.
Economy is about something called "value". If you question "value", then all of economy becomes meaningless. However, it is not something measurable. Have fun determining the "value" of an hour of accountant work using scientific equipment.
Human rights is about something called "equality". It states that everyhomo sapiens sapiens specimen has something that makes them "equal", despite that in every scientifically measurable way, no two humans are equal. Yet we pretend it's true because we believe it is "right". Again, try to measure the rightness of something with the scientific method.
Technically, these are lies, but actually, this is how the human mind works. Everyone believes in magic and everyone is a witch. What makes the magic we usually talk about is that the majority of people don't play along with these specific spells and rituals.
So enjoy your magical world and have fun watching people not noticing that they are doing magic all day!