I'd like to share my story (so far), in case it helps others.
I moved to the foothills in northern California and brought with me a Verizon Gateway (ASK-NCQ1338FA - which I believe is the older model). I believe they still don't officially offer 5G Internet at my home address, but my account has my old one so I was able to get more devices. I don't quite remember why, but I got a second one (ARC-XCI55AX).
These devices are phenomenal. In San Francisco and Sacramento they are upwards of 600 Mbps download. Given their size, they are basically portable. I wouldn't be surprised if you can just drive around with them running (more on this later).
When I moved to this new, relatively rural address however, performance suffered. It seemed like no matter where I put the boxes, speeds were low (20-30 Mbps). At some point I even got a third box (another ARC-XCI55AX) just to ensure that I somehow didn't have a bad one. Despite the fact that Verizon says you can return them, the process is not super easy (you cannot return them to the store, you have to deal with a call center and they ship you a box and, in my case, you cross your fingers that they don't kill the wrong line).
I also tried an AT&T prepaid SIM, which somehow required autopay... the account setup was very confusing, the device was a real hunk of junk, and speeds were miserable. We have an AT&T iPhone in the house and it works sufficiently well but the "hot spot" was just bad. Suffice it to say that account management was so difficult, that I have now ended up with a "suspended account" at AT&T (whatever that means). All I wanted was a prepaid SIM to try a hotspot device I bought at their store...
Then I discovered Waveform. I got the QuadPro, followed their instructions for the ARC, and started trying to aim the thing. We have no Verizon phones and we are an iPhone house anyway, so I had no tower information. Cellmapper turned out to be...too cryptic for me at the time.
Aiming the antenna is effectively impossible. You have no hope of "scanning around". The Verizon admin panel shows signal but it does not update very quickly (more on this later). Waveform tells you to do speed tests and ignore the signal. Moving around with a ladder and an extension cord in the backyard, taking 2-3 measurements per location and orientation, is more than a few hours' work.
Then while eating dinner, with the QuadPro sitting on my desk, I suddenly get 300 Mbps. I immediately rebooted, and confirmed that it took about 45 minutes to get 300 Mbps... so there's some sort of "warm-up" time or "negotiation" with the tower. So maybe driving around with them is not quite so practical.
I found a spot up on a shelf for the QuadPro (inside the house) and for a solid 2 years was getting 300 Mbps. By this point I had the two Verizon boxes, a manual RJ45 switcher to route the house through one gateway or the other, and a dashboard running on a Raspberry Pi testing speed every 20 minutes or so (eventually increased to every hour). The two boxes with autopay from a bank cost me $100 per month; still cheaper than the local microwave option no one likes.
Fast-forward to about 3 months ago; performance had been stable for years so I was about to start the process of returning the ASK (which I considered risky since you can't get those models anymore), when performance collapsed. The ARC with the QuadPro became unusable; meanwhile, the unassisted ASK started performing well enough to switch the house to that. The dashboard started showing consistent 100+ Mbps downloads, but, more importantly, 20+ Mbps upload.
Clearly Verizon had done something at the tower. Armed with Claude, I went about trying to learn more / solve the problem. It was able to reverse-engineer the login to the gateway admin panels so that the Raspberry Pi could now log the reported cell signal once a minute. It also added a ping test once a minute. From watching this over the past few weeks, I've learned some things:
- The ARC has much better granularity than the ASK when it comes to signal. That is, the lines look squiggly over time, as you would expect. The ASK lines, on the other hand, are nearly flat until they make big jumps...except on very rare occasions when they become squiggly. I have absolutely no idea what's going on there, but will say that I think the only actually useful information from that signal panel is to find out if you're connected to 5G or LTE.
- Sending 20 pings per minute and measuring return time, which is of course much faster than a speed test, is a very reliable signal of "all hell just broke loose". Highly recommend to people that they look at this first when diagnosing things, perhaps even for antenna aiming (although that potential warm-up period could kill all hope of doing it quickly; more on this later).
- On the ARC, 5G signal was dropping significantly around 1 AM and back up around 6 AM. I saw this consistently for weeks until I reaimed the antenna (below). Not sure what that's about.
To continue my diagnosis, I got a used Samsung S23 and, to my surprise, was able to get a 30-day Verizon trial eSIM despite already having an account with them (kudos to Verizon). The cell IDs shown were not on Cellmapper, but Claude suggested a nearby tower that may be the one. Given that performance suddenly changed, it made sense that perhaps Verizon had changed equipment on the tower and IDs changed.
I took the dogs out on an extremely slow wardriving session with the Samsung, winding around private roads north and south of the suspect tower. I had Cellmapper and CellularZ recording the whole time. I came back and gave the data to Claude, who was able to approximate the tower location given that I had gone quite a bit east/west of it both north and south of it. Cellmapper, on the other hand, made a mess of things, and created a bunch of towers on the map that don't exist. This was enough to convince me that indeed the cell IDs had just changed; the tower was identified, and, best of all, an evelation profile from Google Earth between the tower and my house showed that, other than trees, I had clear line of sight.
I left the QuadPro on that shelf - still indoors - and just rotated it towards the tower, and bingo! 5G. First time ever the ARC had a 5G connection (shows no LTE signal). Mind you, this is going through at least two walls and the garage attic. Download speeds got back up to the 200+ Mbps range (which the ASK was hitting consistently with its internal antennas) but upload never broke 10 (the ASK still hitting 20+). With a lot of modern websites (and obviously video meetings), the upload speed, when it starts getting really low, is what really makes everything appear to not work. So this was disappointing.
The ARC would stay on 5G mode for about a day. Then it would switch to 5G-DC mode, after which the 5G signal reported would plummet and LTE showed something decent. Rebooting would bring back 5G standalone, only to switch back a day later. So, again, more evidence that aiming towards an antenna, without knowing where the antenna is, would be a monumental task, since it would require rebooting the router at each new aiming condition. Still, actual performance (i.e. speed tests) did not change much one way or the other, and I still could not beat the ASK.
I was considering either switching to Waveform Internet or buying the modem they use and running it myself. None of that expense seemed worthwhile at this point, with my stock ASK router kicking butt, and the ARC with a $400 antenna not doing much of anything. Bonding (which is done at some data center somewhere) seems just like another complication and worst case I could split the house between the two gateways; but honestly, with average speeds of 150/20 Mbps from the ASK, the house was running fine.
The next step was, logically, to finally put the QuadPro outside again, aimed in the general direction of the tower, and see what I could get. So far in the first spot I've put it, the only change is that the signal difference between 5G and LTE is lower; LTE has come down a bit and 5G to meet it - but the ARC is still reporting 5G-DC connection (it never goes to 5G standalone) and speeds have not dramatically improved, though it just now did manage to match the ASK's upload speed.
As you can all imagine, I'm quite tired of years of experimentation; the remaining test would be to see if an unmodified ARC could match the ASK sitting on the same shelf, but I'm probably not going to bother with that. I'll probably just put the QuadPro back on its shelf and not go through the immense trouble of climbing the roof, ordering a longer cable (20 feet has no hope of being enough) drilling massive holes, etc. etc. etc.... I think I'd have to hire someone, and here that probably means $400 minimum. Fingers crossed that the ASK continues to perform.
TLDR
- The ARC-XCi55AX and the ASK-NCQ1338FA from Verizon report signal differently. The ARC has much higher granularity.
- The most valuable part of signal monitoring is seeing the connection mode (e.g. 5G standalone) and maybe differences in antenna placement, but I think you'd need days/weeks of logged data to really glean anything. In the end, speed tests are the real answer.
- Ping RTT (round-trip delay time) is a reliable indicator of "things are really bad right now" and obviously execute much faster than a speed test.
- I have mixed feelings on the QuadPro. Although it magically worked for years aimed in a completely wrong direction, it "stopped working" once Verizon meddled with (upgraded?) their tower. I think if you have bad performance, getting one is a real crapshoot. Knowing what I do now, I'd say you'd have to a) know where the tower is, b) study any obstructions between you and the tower, c) go through all the work to permanently install the antenna wherever you have the best hope of getting a clear shot to the tower, and d) hope for the best. Because moving it around on a ladder or whatever shenanigans I tried will only leave you scratching your head with reboots, warm-up times, negotations, time-of-day changes, or whatever other black magic is going on between your gateway and the router.
I cannot imagine doing any of this without multiple devices. And I consider myself very lucky to have two different units, which is probably not even possible anymore.
Lastly, kudos to Verizon. These boxes are impressive, $100/month for two is a fantastic price. I can even take one with me when I travel. Verizon gave me a trial eSIM despite having an active account (you can get one every 12 months apparently) and I checked; getting another line added to my existing plan would only cost $20 more per month. So for $120/month I could keep two gateways and a phone. Impressive. I'm considering adding a second eSIM to my T-Mobile phone, since there's a hill between me and their tower and I can't even take the trash out without the music stopping.