Hi,
I want to share my story maybe it will be beneficial for new runners. Sorry if there are grammar or spelling mistakes as English is not my first language.
I started running 6 weeks ago, and I used new balance arishi v4 to run in then,I decided to get nice shoes since I got serious about running.
I went to a running shoes store, and I had my feet scanned and they analysed my gait. They told me I overpronate in my right foot and they recommended brooks adrenaline 23 or brooks glycerin 20 GTS. I chose the glycerin as it was softer.
I started running in them doing 5k around 05:30-06:00 mins/km and I started feeling some pain in my ankle. I finished my run then I started reading about the shoes and I was surprised that I shouldn't feel that pain as it has a high drop. I gave it another try at slower pace 06:45-07:00 mins/km and at this pace I could feel the shoes being heavy forcing me to heel strike which is something I don't usually do. I try to land on my mid foot most of the time.
I went back to the running shoes store. I was told I shouldn't feel the stability elements if I am a neutral runner and I need something with more motion control. This time they recommended Asics kayano 30. I liked the feel of the shoes and how soft and squishy they were.
I wore the kayano doing a slow pace run around 07:00-07:15 mins/km (zone 2 for me). After 3 km, I started to feel knee pain. Unfortunately, I did not listen to my body and I finished my run around 6km.
The following day, I had severe knee pain in my right knee and mild knee pain in my left knee. I went to my Physiotherapist with the kayano. He told me to run in them in front of him. I wore them and I ran for like 30 seconds. He noticed that my right knee collapsed inwards. He said the shoes were forcing me to land on my outer soles which put a lot of stress on my IT band and my hips that are weak and not ready for that stress. I had to rest for 2 weeks then he told to run in the shoes that makes me feel comfortable not something controlling my natural gait.
Surprisingly, I have had no pain after running yesterday wearing my new balance arishi v4 (maybe very mild niggles in my knees). I ran for 3km at slow pace then I went home and after I stretched and rested, I I had no pain at all.
Now, I am working on my leg/foot strength and stability as recommended by my physiotherapist.
I just wanted to share my story maybe it will prevent others from injuries or pain.