r/RomanceWriters • • 3d ago

I'm a Male Author Writing Dark Romance for the First time

3 Upvotes

I'm a male writer currently working on my first dark romance novel, and I'd appreciate some honest advice from more experienced writers, especially those who write or read dark romance.

My story involves organized crime, powerful characters, complicated relationships, darker themes, and a female protagonist who is strong, independent, and eventually destined to take control of her family's criminal empire.

One thing I've been thinking about is how to approach writing romance and female characters from a male perspective without making them feel unrealistic, stereotypical, or poorly developed.

I'd love some advice on a few things:

\- What are some common mistakes male authors make when writing female characters?

\- How do you write believable romantic chemistry and emotional intimacy?

\- How do you balance a dark, dangerous male character with genuine vulnerability and emotional depth?

\- What separates a well-written dark romance from a story that simply relies on shock value?

\- Are there particular things female readers look for or dislike in dark romance?

I'm not looking to write a perfect relationship. I want complicated characters who make mistakes, have flaws, experience emotional struggles, and develop throughout the story.

I'm open to constructive criticism and honest opinions. I want to improve my writing and do justice to the genre, even if I'm approaching it from a male perspective.

Thanks in advance!


r/RomanceWriters • • Sep 29 '26

Pen name stolen

0 Upvotes

So recently as I was about to finish my 2nd book (which for reference was in the romance category) I found that a new author, with books not even published yet, used/stole IMO my own name. Has anyone dealt with this before? I have a strong reader base with 0 marketing and with the launch of book 2 of my trilogy I intended to start the marketing engine.

We are both in romance but all of his books have Daddy in the title and are German. My forte is more female-led domestic romance so I’d hate to have my readers be confused when they find me in Goodreads. It’s such a conundrum that my spouse and I discovered at dinner last week.

So do I:

  1. Charge forward and hope no one gets confused?

  2. Add an initial or something to the name so there’s a visual distinction?

  3. Go back to the drawing board and craft a new name so I can own Goodreads, SEO, social handles, etc.?

I’m super pissed because I feel like someone stole my fake identity and I can’t do anything about it. Flying to Germany to have a face-to-face meeting—not in the cards.


r/RomanceWriters • • Oct 18 '26

I am writing a mlm romance as a woman

4 Upvotes

Hi. I have a passion project that is soon finished that I dream to publish one day. Though, I am actively participating in a discourse thats been discussed quite a bit recently: I am a straight woman writing a romance between men.

My story is about an male investment banker who tries to balance love and success. The novel tackles themes of queer identity, masculinity, vulnerability, and the choice of love. My main character isn’t simply ”just a gay man”. The reality of his identity is centre-stage of the novel, and I am telling a story about a minority I am not apart of.

I have lived my whole life as a straight woman (I generally identify as gender non-conforming and unlabelled, but have presented female socially and only dated men despite having an attraction to women). I cannot understand the full reality of a queer man, and never will. I have always been interested in queer identity and done a lot of research over the years, but me reading about it will never substitute for my understanding of the story if I had actively been apart of the minority that I am telling a story about. I plan on finding gay male beta readers for my book once I finish my second draft, but I will still always be a straight woman writing a gay romance.

So, what is your opinion on the matter? There has been so much discussion around this topic and the blaring problem with it; women fetishising gay relationships. I have agreed with many of these discussions, and that has also acted as an inspiration for the story for what to not do. Though, I find myself being the very thing being criticised. And I completely understrand that I am legitime for criticism for the reasons listed above.

My general question is this: should writers tell stories about minorities they are not apart of? Should you instead leave room for those actually living the stories you are trying to tell?

Curious to hear your thoughts!


r/RomanceWriters • • 29d ago

Can men be successful romance writers?

0 Upvotes

I started writing during covid, spicy romance, at the request from some women friends. They specifically asked for a male viewpoint, as they wanted something different. And I think also they wanted to get some insight to men, or me?? COVID was a weird-ass time, for sure.

The spicy level runs from 6 to 8, I guess?

I wrote all that, have multiple shorts, novellas, etc. Other people (men and women) I've shared these with have been very forthcoming - great story, great characters, and good emotional roller coaster, I love this story, but "no one buys romance with a M POV".

To be clear, there's a lot of age gap (30F, 50M and similar), this is not teenaged angst. I looked around and the closest I found is something called HaremLit? But I dont have those mFFFFFF spicy scenes.

Has any writer since the beginning of time, ever been successful writing romance with a mail POV. Can anyone name a successful romance author with a male pen name?

Is it even worth it to try to publish?

EDIT:

Thanks for the constructive comments. From the comments, it's clear that MANY completely missed the first sentence - "at the request from some women friends."

None of this started as "I want to be a writer". It started during COVID. Lots of online discussions, and email chats in our rather niche friends group. One of them confessed "I had a crush on my professor, he never knew, what could have happened, how would he have felt about it." I HAD been a professor, and had been propositioned (nothing happened). So I wrote the story she asked for. But her fantasy, his viewpoint, as requested.

And then the next request "my BF and I did X, I wonder how he felt". "How do men in age gaps feel about successful, powerful, empowered younger women? What could go through their minds?"

I've since learned I was "writing to market", with my market being... orginally 5 of my *female* friends, aged 30-55. They've passed around some of my stories to their friends, and it looks like my "total addressable market" is about 20-30 women, aged 25-60. They ask, I write, we're all happy. As far as I know, no male has ever seen my writing.

Clearly this is too niche to be "successful", and that's OK. That wasn't my intent. Thanks for all the feedback.

But - after around 150K+ words for them over the past 6 years, and a lot of feedback... I'm a much better writer, and there's this techno-thriller bouncing around in my brain... Who knows?

For the person who DM'ed me and told me I would go to Hell for "promoting r*pe culture", "grooming" and that "age gaps are r*pe"... I will point you to Keturah and Deuteronomy and ask what color glass your house is made of.


r/RomanceWriters • • Apr 11 '26

The Debate On Infidelity In Dark Romance

1 Upvotes

A couple of days, I asked people about their thoughts on infidelity in dark romance and I was genuinely surprised about the feedback I got. I posted in the Dark Romance community and the responses seemed to be 70/30 in favor of it. Meanwhile, I posted in the Romance Writers community and the responses were exactly the same only flipped (70/30 against it), It's split almost exactly down the middle.

I loved hearing the different responses. I think that's part of what makes this debate great is that there is no right or wrong answer.


r/RomanceWriters • • Jun 22 '26

Craft Author Headshots

0 Upvotes

So I want to have an author picture for my social media…but I have a pen name as I could get I trouble at work. I thought of maybe doing a Bitmoji for social media…what is everyone’s thoughts on an AI generated picture? What don’t like the idea of AI for art, but I also don’t think I can keep using stock photos of inanimate objects as profile pictures.

Any suggestions would be great! Thanks in advance!


r/RomanceWriters • • Apr 27 '26

HEAs, dark romance, and my dumbass

0 Upvotes

Starting this off by saying *I* am FTM. I am a gay trans man. While the FTM love interest of my book is a deeply shitty dude, he is not meant to be representative of all trans men. There are much kinder, more normal trans men in the novel. While my FTM LI has reasons why the way he is, and his dysphoria does heavily influence his actions, its made apparent he isn't supposed to be representative of all trans men.

What is considered an HEA within the context of a dark romance?

I am writing an FTM/M dark romance. The FTM character is, for lack of a better term, completely unstable, possessive, jealous, extremely manipulative, and definitionally not a good person. You are given plenty of reasons to understand why he is this way, but the facts remain that this is who he is and he does not become a good person by the end. There is no SA but I would say there is absolutely dubcon-elements involving the aforementioned manipulation.

The Cis M, who is the POV character, is a nice and decent guy who is ultimately stuck in this very codependent, toxic dynamic with his best childhood friend, the FTM LI. There's stalking, manipulation, threatened suicide, attempted baby-trapping, animal death (the FTM LI kills the pet parakeet of a girl interested in the Cis M to frighten her away, with the implicit message that he is not afraid to hurt her as well if she tries to 'steal' the man he loves, it's intended to be a bit of a parallel to the Glenn Close character in Fatal Attraction, which is the movie they're watching together in the first scene of the book. No he does not boil the bird.), and more.

And I suppose this is spoilers but they do remain together. It is heavily implied (and canon, since I'm the author lol) that the Cis M will never be able to leave the other man, and will always remain enmeshed in this extremely toxic and fucked up dynamic. There is no escape for him, and he never comes to understand or know about just how badly he has been manipulated. He remains in an almost blissful ignorance, unaware every relationship he ever has with another person will be sabotaged until only FTM LI remains. People will directly tell him what kind of person the FTM LI, and his rose-tinted glasses will invariably blind him to this. It is heavily implied at one point that the FTM LI would kill both of them if he thought the Cis M was trying to leave him.

And like. That is all profoundly fucked up. But what is the standard for an HEA in dark romance? As awful as the FTM LI can be, I've read significantly worse dark romance guys. The objective HEA would be the Cis M getting away. That is not what happens. But they do both live, and for better or for worse (hint: it's for worse) they will spend the rest of their lives together.


r/RomanceWriters • • Mar 31 '26

Did you know big publishers have entire market research teams? I did not handle this information well.

45 Upvotes

So I've been working on my first romance novel. Friends-to-lovers, two AI scientists, fall in love during the AI revolution. Very niche, possibly insane, we'll see.

And like most indie authors I know, I've been writing almost entirely on vibes. Does this trope still land? Is the pacing right for what readers actually want right now? Are people tired of the slow burn or desperately starving for it? I have no idea. I am a man who quit his job in 2024, spent some time staring at the ceiling and reconsidering his life choices, and somehow ended up writing romance novels. Big tech will do that to you.

Here's the thing that broke my brain a little: I spent years working in publishing, and I knew — intellectually — that the big houses do market research. But I don't think I fully appreciated what that meant in practice until recently. We're talking dedicated teams analyzing reader reviews at scale, tracking what's gaining traction on BookTok before it becomes obvious, using sales data to make acquisition decisions. They're not acquiring books on vibes. They're acquiring books based on actual intelligence about what readers want right now.

And indie authors get... none of that. We get our gut, our beta readers if we're lucky, and whatever we can piece together from scrolling Goodreads at midnight questioning our life choices.

I've been trying to close that gap for myself — cobbling together whatever reader data I can find, digging through reviews, trying to understand what's actually resonating in my subgenre before I write myself into a corner. It's messy and time-consuming and I'm probably doing it wrong. But I can't shake the feeling that writing without any of this is like showing up to a poker game having never seen the other players' hands and just hoping your cards are good.

Maybe that's just the ex-product manager in me that can't turn off. Or maybe the gap is real and we're all just collectively pretending it isn't.

So genuinely asking: do you feel like you have any real market intelligence when you sit down to write? Or are we all just throwing darts and hoping for the best?


r/RomanceWriters • • Mar 11 '26

Is it romantic if someone leaves their fiancée for you?

28 Upvotes

I’m writing a romance story and I’m curious how readers feel about this situation. A man falls in love with someone new while he’s engaged to a woman he’s been with for seven years. Eventually he calls off the wedding because he realizes he can’t stop loving the new person. Later, during an argument, he reveals this truth to the woman he left everything for. From his perspective, he sacrificed everything — his family’s approval, a long relationship, and a planned wedding — because he loved her. But from her perspective, she just discovered that their relationship started with him cheating on someone else. So I’m curious how readers see this kind of situation:

Is this romantic… or a red flag?

Also curious — would you trust someone who left a long relationship for you?


r/RomanceWriters • • Oct 16 '26

You don't need to include slurs to show a character is a bigot

0 Upvotes

To preface, I am currently writing an LGBT+ romance story and I'm also an avid romance reader. So I'm both romance reader and romance writer. And I just want to put this out there: Writers do not need to include slurs to show a character is a bigot.

I read MF and LGBT+ romance stories. And while I haven't come across this a lot, there have been some LGBT+ stories with a homophobic character who uses the f-slur and it is so jarring and unnecessary. In most of the books I've read that do have homophobia, the bigotry is demonstrated without the use of any slurs. And it is very clear. This character is a bigot. I'm guessing the intent is for it to be jarring and to show "this is a bad character." But as a Black queer woman, I promise that is unnecessary. And I think using a slur to show how a character is bigoted is harmful. In the same way that I would immediately hesitate to read another story by an author who includes a racial slur to show a character is racist, I feel the same way when an author uses the f-slur to show a character is queerphobic.

There's a queerphobic character in the story I'm writing so I understand how it can be a challenge to show that without using slurs, especially since we all know queerphobic people use slurs irl. And many times we want to write realistic, authentic characters. But I think it just means being more creative in the writing process. So, I just want to put this out there for any writers who have a bigoted character that uses slurs or you're considering it: don't. You can show bigotry without including slurs in your story.


r/RomanceWriters • • Oct 18 '26

Saved Myself from a Misogynistic Editor

52 Upvotes

I was going to hire an editor who was offering low rates (because she was new to editing) and everything was going well until she made a comment about how much she hated smut books....knowing well I write romance/romantasy. I myself have only a few scenes, but I've always been of the camp, don't yuck someone's yum. I was going to go with her but then I thought about it. Always trust your guts, ladies. If that's their best foot forward, I can only imagine the sort of harmful advice she would've written in her editing.

We have enough issues with imposter syndrome and worrying about AI, we don't need to give our money to editors who hate our genre as well while pretending they don't.

Edit: Apparently if I don't give people money who look down on people who write smut, I'm the actual misogynist, not the editor who lies that they only want to work with clean romance. If you want to work with only clean romance as an editor, say that. Don't lie then say you hate sex in novels but don't mind it in non-female literature like fantasy.


r/RomanceWriters • • Mar 20 '26

Will this age gap give readers the ick?

5 Upvotes

Fmc is 19 and mmc is 24. He has to be 24, but I can possibly push her to 20, though it makes more sense if she’s 19 for the storyline.

It meets the half your age plus 7 rule, but I think it’s the teen age that’s throwing me for a loop and slightly giving me the ick.

Will this be too much for readers or will it be okay?

It’s hella slow burn marriage of convenience where nothing really happens physically for over 6 months if that makes any difference.

Edit: physically was a poor choice of wording. I write no-spice contemporary romances so by that I mean kissing. I suppose a bit of context may help. And 6 months was a typo, I meant 9.

He has to be 24 because he just finished a 6 year military contract and is resigning. He can’t pass his GI bill free college tuition to a spouse before 6 years enlisted so his age is firm.

Her age is more loose at 19-20 because she is working to save for nursing school so she doesn’t get a loan and pays cash. She is not starting school until she has a large portion saved so it wouldn’t make sense to have her more than a year or two out of high school since (for the budgeting I did in the book) she would have enough saved to start school not long after that.

He is her brothers best friend and married her contractually so she can go to nursing school for free. He wants to take care of her like a little sister in the beginning.

I think I may push her to 20 regardless, but she is a youngest sibling of way older siblings and matured and gained life experience faster than the average girl her age because of it. She is not inexperienced and he is not a player. They start to fall over letter correspondence when he is deployed shortly after their contractual marriage.


r/RomanceWriters • • Oct 19 '26

What even is the "yearning" audiences claim to desire?

6 Upvotes

EDIT: I made this post when I was feeling really really insecure. Turns out I was more afraid of what other people would think of my work rather than me cherishing the intense yearning in my friends-to-loves romance.

I know what that deep yearning and pining for another person feels like in real life, and I get it's wish fulfillment to have the feelings be returned. But life experiences have taught me if you’re yearning over the other person liking you back, you will be disappointed and should let it go. For personal reasons, it feels unsafe and even wrong for me to write about endless pining being returned. It feels like being one of those guys who is friends with a girl just with the hope she returns his romantic feelings (aaaahhh). I could do that kind of yearning in some romances, but not the one I'm currently writing.

There has to be another way.

Maybe one or two of the MCs aren't yearning for each other, but we are for them. Or, the yearning isn't about whether one MC likes another MC back, but rather the yearning for the relationship to be the right one instead of being lopsided, that the MC loves their best friend but is scared of a relationship messing up their friendship.

For context, the romance I'm writing is a sub-plot in a larger healing + recovery story in a fantasy / sci-fi world, so a lot of the conflict is from external sources and other challenges in the characters' lives.


r/RomanceWriters • • Apr 26 '26

How to write my Dark Romance FMC who is an SA survivor as realistic as possible

2 Upvotes

Hi! Ive been writing romance and fantasy books for over 10+ years, just for me. Shared some of them with friends but never dared to publish. Currently I am writing my first dark romance novel (well it’ll probably become a series) the plot is about something else complete but my FMC has a history of traumatic SA by the father of her best friend. She met him at 13, it started at 15, happened frequently until she was about 20. In the book I write both in present day (where she’s 21, sent to prison and away from abuser for good, and then she meets MMC) and in flashbacks, jumping from year to year kinda, so the scenes where it happens are there but I don’t want to make it explicit. I do want to make her experiences in the present timeline (after abuse) explicit though.

I personally have experienced SA once but my experience is different from why she went through, thankfully, but I still want to write it because it is important for her character development. I’m deriving inspiration from books like Edge of Darkness trilogy where the FMC has similar timeline of SA history but still can enjoy sex with the MMC.

My question, to DR readers, writers, but also people in general with experience like this: how do I make her journey realistic as possible, such that she can heal from her experiences in a realistic way and timeline, and be capable of seeking out and enjoying sex with the MMC? I’ve read some books where the main character endured horrible SA but was still able to have pretty intense sexual interactions with other characters without having flashbacks or anything and I’ve always wondered if that’s realistic.

I want it to be fair to her (my character) but also to readers who might recognize themselves in her. It’s very important for me to be sensitive about this.

Anyway, i hope the question makes sense, and i would love to hear your thoughts and tips!

P.S. my account is new, I’ve been following Reddit forum for years but never dared to make an account. But here I am!

TL/DR: How do I make the recovery journey after SA (15-20 years old) as realistic as possible for my FMC and make her still able to enjoy sex with MMC?

EDIT: added specification about my own experience to diminish misunderstanding.


r/RomanceWriters • • Feb 14 '25

Werewolf romance?

0 Upvotes

I'm currently Brainstorming a YA/NA werewolf novel with a probable romance subplot as well as a possible school element to it and I'm looking for someone ideas and input. I can't say I've read a lot of werewolf books but I'd be open to recommendations.

What sort fo thing do fans of the genre like? What do you wish there was more of? What aspects draw you to this type of story? Any input is appreciated!


r/RomanceWriters • • Sep 12 '26

Need help! I am falling in love with my character…

0 Upvotes

I know her as no one ever would. I’ve seen her every single drop of tear and each imperceptible smile. Though she probably hates me for everything I made her go through…


r/RomanceWriters • • Jan 16 '25

personal opinions on happy endings

1 Upvotes

i was wondering if it would sully anyone's reading experience if two characters that were in fact in love, actually ended up not staying together due to circumstance, or death, or an outward force? i myself am a fan of the journey not necessarily the outcome, but i wanted to get some other takes


r/RomanceWriters • • Aug 29 '26

Discussion Who Was the Hardest Character in Your Romance to Figure Out?

0 Upvotes

Sometimes an entire story starts with one scene you cannot stop thinking about. What was the scene that made you realize that you needed to write a whole scene around it?


r/RomanceWriters • • Apr 12 '26

Concerns about using a pen name that could be someone's actual name?

0 Upvotes

Asking for a friend, she "asked chatGPT" but I don't trust that to give accurate info. My friend is interested in self-publishing romance/erotica short stories on the kindle store under a pen name. The pen name she had originally picked out was a normal sounding name, I googled it and found around 30 linkedin profiles, and some results on google for an illustrator (who has the URL firstnamelastname.com), a therapist, and a college athlete.

I was worried that one of these people with the actual name could sue for defamation if it hurts their brand/reputation, even if my friend isn't intentionally impersonating that specific person. What is the actual risk of this? Would it be legally safer to pick a name that sounds like a fantasy name, and do a quick google search to make sure no one is using this to represent themself under that name?

Any advice is appreciated~


r/RomanceWriters • • Apr 29 '26

How to do research for different race characters?

0 Upvotes

hey so I'm starting my book and I am mixed (black and white) and I really want to write other races and cultures but I don't want to use stereo types and or offend anyone with what I right how should I do research like where to look and get good info?


r/RomanceWriters • • May 30 '26

Craft How to bring up an ex-lover in a romance book?

0 Upvotes

I have a friend who's writing a romance novel and they asked me what I thought so far. But at the part where the MC says "I love you." to the FMC, she has a vision of the time he says it to his ex-lover. My friend says it's supposed to show the MC's tragic backstory. I told them that I felt like it kinda ruins what should probably be a very sweet moment in the book just between the two characters. I told them that I felt like it was fine to bring up that the MC loved someone before in the past but showing it to the FMC right after he says he loves her for the first time and then they're supposed to have a cute moment after, I really feel like that ruins it for anyone who reads this book.

So, I just wanted to get everyone's thoughts. If an ex-girlfriend is integral to the plot of a romance story, is there a good way to bring it up? My friend really wants to tell the tragic backstory of their MC. Or should the topic just try to be avoided altogether outside of a mention or two?


r/RomanceWriters • • May 13 '26

Is pregnancy subplot cliche?

3 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on the protagonist getting pregnant unexpectedly near the end of the novel? Is it bad? Is it the thing that kills your entire book? And is it cliche?


r/RomanceWriters • • Sep 26 '26

Discussion Writers, Does AI Worry You?

6 Upvotes

Well, it's the elephant in the room right now. I want to open the floor for us to all share our predictions, apprehensions, rants, and other thoughts on AI and it's potential impact on romance writing.


r/RomanceWriters • • Dec 01 '25

Craft Female Archetypes to Use As Inspiration in Romance Writing

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/RomanceWriters • • Mar 20 '26

Can you write a meet-cute when you've never experienced it yourself?

0 Upvotes

So technically, I've been in love but not in the healthy way in which I am trying to write. I myself have dated the 'dark, toxic' guy, the 'golden retriever who turns out to be toxic' guy, 'fake-woke feminist', etc., etc. I've never met someone and felt an instant mutual spark. I've always grown in love or sadly, been convinced and settled (before anyone comments, I am in therapy and very aware that I, too, am the problem). I've read various books in the genre but this is my first time writing a love story. It's really important to me to write this in a specific way so I would appreciate any advice or opinions.

I am writing a female character who is heartbroken and has closed herself off to love in the name of healing. She eventually meets a man in a space that is very familiar to both of them and they slowly fall in love while helping each other to heal and grow in different ways. I wanted to subvert the dark, toxic love interest archetype by creating a 'golden retriever' kind of love interest and a cynical, moody female protagonist.

From feedback I've received, I've written a meet-cute that feels kinda creepy and non-consensual because the female lead reluctantly agrees to go on the first date while the male love interest is very forward and keen. I know that I need to add a couple more beats before she agrees or perhaps they agree to be friends before falling in love but I also need something that keeps her interested despite being someone so closed off to love.

I'm trying to figure out how to create the instant spark between them (that isn't acted on until the end for the sake of the story). I've got pretty much everything else right with the female protagonist and her world. I've been told I have a very strong voice and I'm enjoying writing the story - I'm also pretty certain that once I nail this, I can write the rest.

Would people be willing to share their real-life meet-cutes? Could you describe the sensations, feelings, emotions from your experiences or perhaps, just share a cute story that would inspire me?