(I just posted this on /r/DebateACatholic, but figured it might garner some good discussion here, too.)
A couple of weeks ago, I got into a discussion on /r/Christianity with Fr-josh, a Catholic priest, and a couple of other people (who, IMO, weren't/aren't very uncharitable here).
In a conversation with the former, I had mentioned how elsewhere in the same thread in which we were conversing, I had made some comments pertaining to authoritative doctrinal sources which suggested even infants "being denied heaven and entering Limbo" if unbaptized.
By way of clarification, the actual comment of mine -- which I had linked to -- said
My understanding is that, among other things, Lateran IV, Lyons II and Florence formally mandated differing afterlife punishments for the non-culpable unbaptized (most obviously infants) vs. those who die in mortal sin, and that the distinction between this punishment basically (or exactly) corresponds to the punishments of Limbo vs. those of "inner" Hell.
In response, Fr-josh ridiculed this, saying simply "If you're trying to be theologically serious and bringing up Limbo then I have to stop here," after which he indeed stopped.
I tried to clarify exactly what I meant, but he never responded. In my clarification I pointed to a good article by Brian Harrison on doctrine/dogma pertaining to Limbo; and I wrote -- again, reiterating a couple of things that I had said earlier -- that
With his article (and the sources he discussed therein) in mind, the number of authoritative or in fact truly conciliar statements that suggest that "The souls of those who die . . . with original sin only . . . immediately descend to hell (yet to be punished with different punishments)," and in some instances explicitly specify infants here, can't be discarded lightly.
We can fairly call the realm/state that these enter "Limbo"; but even if we do that only as not-precisely-exact shorthand, I think it's still fair. In my mind -- as to that of Harrison and others -- the only real question of debate here is on the pleasantness or unpleasantness that those in Limbo experience. But that Limbo is the outskirts of Hell (not on the outskirts of heaven) isn't in dispute.
Now, we can dispute whether doctrine/dogma on all this has changed, or will decisively change in the future; but insofar as "[t]he teaching of Limbo flows logically from [the] infallible truth" that "[u]nbaptized babies, as cute as they are, possess souls stained by original sin, the sin inherited from Adam" (in conjunction with the principle that the non-culpable experience different afterlife punishments -- poenis disparibus -- from culpable sinning adults who have gone to the 'normal' part of Hell), I'd see no way to characterize denial of this as anything other than as "dogmatic reversal."
Finally, at the end of my comment -- though this was only somewhat tangential to the specific point about infants that I was making -- I had linked to a canon from the Council of Florence (clarified in the lines before this as delivering "true and necessary doctrine" in a "solemn session"), reading
[The holy Roman Church] firmly believes, professes and preaches that all those who are outside the Catholic Church, not only pagans but also Jews or heretics and schismatics, cannot share in eternal life and will go into the everlasting fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels, unless they are joined to the Catholic Church [translating antecedent from nisi . . . eidem fuerint aggregati] before the end of their lives; that the unity of the ecclesiastical body is of such importance that only for those who abide in it do the church's sacraments contribute to salvation and do fasts, almsgiving and other works of piety and practices of the Christian militia produce eternal rewards; and that nobody can be saved, no matter how much he has given away in alms and even if he has shed his blood in the name of Christ, unless he has persevered in the bosom and the unity of the Catholic Church
...on the basis of which I had suggested that there are good indications that at least at one time, it was authoritatively believed/decreed that non-Christian Jews (and Muslims, etc.) were thought to be destined for Hell unless they're joined to the Church before the end of their lives.
(I dispute that this canon has being a broader or more mysterious sense of being "joined" to the Church in mind. Perhaps the language isn't so exclusivistic as to deny a baptism of desire for catechumens here; but the mere fact that it even explicitly denies salvation to those who have "shed . . . blood in the name of Christ," if they haven't done it inside the "bosom and the unity of the Catholic Church," suggests a very hard line on extra Ecclesiam nulla salus here.)
Somewhat speculatively, though, I suggested that in view of some of the mitigating interpretations of this, perhaps it's Limbo -- or some place/state corresponding to the classical conception of this -- that those specified could be destined for. But again, it seems like the suggestion was plainly rejected.