r/RingsofPower • • Jan 25 '24

Question Quite possibly the worst television show i've ever see Spoiler

55 Upvotes

I have almost no words for how unbelievably bad this show is. I have tried to give it the benefit of the doubt. I really wanted to like it. I have watched 7 episodes. I also have lots of questions.

  1. What the hell is this?

  2. Why is this a thing?

  3. How does this have anything to do with the 2nd age of Middle Earth, other than the characters have the same names (or anyway, some of them do)?

  4. Who thought it was a good idea to release this?

  5. Where are the Tolkien estate lawyers, and how did they allow this to get made?

I'm not even kidding... like, why does this exist?

Why does Galadriel think swimming home from the edge of the known world makes sense?

Why is Halbrand (who is actually Sauron, which makes this even more inexplicable) on a random ship trawling the open oceans?

Why is he mad at the weird elf-orc guy? (Edit: apparently the elf guy got sick of his bullshit and tried to kill him, because... reasons)

Apparently the elves just randomly discovered they're all going to die next year, and have staked their whole hopes for survival on a magical ore that may or may not exist as far as they know?

It's all just so weird. The elves feel super political and petty, and completely lacking nobility or grace. The dwarves are just jewish and Scottish stereotypes crashed into each other at high speed. Galadriel survives being hit with a nuclear volcano blast. People launch cavalry charges in urban areas. Sea monsters (?). Elrond has daddy issues. Gandalf freezes a hobbit lady (?). A random elf guy is really hot for a human single mom. Wolves are part reptile. I could go on.

The point is, what is this? Like, why is it so weird? It has none of the vibes of anything related to Tolkien's work i've ever seen. It's also just bad TV in general.

It's on in the background and some tree branches fell on some hobbit kids and all the other hobbits are mad at Gandalf (?) about it. I just found out Elrond speaks Dwarvish. The dwarves are like "why should we trust an rlf, to make a deal on behalf of other untrustworthy elves?" and he's like "well, just trust me dude, also i'm not really an elf all the way, regular elves are actually pretty shitty."

Nothing in this show makes any sense. I don't get it. Also the dialogue is bad. Just really bad. Why was Sauron on a boat again? It just has no relation to the source material. Someone just accused a dwarf king of having lice in their beard. Now they have a conversation about lice. The writers have the entire fucking second age of middle earth to plumb for source material, but instead there's a conversation about lice. Why?

I objectively hate this show.

Can someone give me a good reason why I shouldn't? In the name of Elbereth Githoniel what in the actual fuck?

<end rant>

EDIT: 73% "generally unfavorable" audience reviews on metacritic, with an average user review of 38% on rotten tomatoes. so yeah, objectively people fucking hate this show. i am not alone.


r/RingsofPower • • Jul 29 '24

Discussion Am I the only one that loves RoP and thinks haters fit a certain stereotype?

5 Upvotes

First off, yes I've read the lore. I love LOTR. I loved S1 of Rings of Power and S2 looks equally as good. I think I a must be one of a few that feels this way.

That said, I feel like its the stereotypical cliche of a person getting upset that an adaption put out on another medium, is not accurate. It's kind of tiring. Every medium means things have to be mad differently. And yes, obviously sometimes they do it well. Other times they do not.

But people really need to stop comparing things to a book, movie, game....etc and just accept new stories on a new medium, as an alternate universe. If you think about everything like that, you will find you don't hate adaptions.

Halo is also another great example of this. They even made it known it would NOT be canon lore and sort of its own thing. And yet people were still upset about changes.

Again, maybe I'm just able to flip a switch in my brain and take things as they are.

As for RoP, the trailer for S2 got me hyped again! I am actually kinda impressed that Amazon was like "Yeah, we don't care if you hated it. Here's S2" I wish more companies would do that. Especially if there is still a pretty huge group of people who love something.


r/RingsofPower • • Jun 21 '23

Discussion Amazon series, Late to the party

8 Upvotes

I thought it would be a slight disappointment, I was not however prepared for the utter, utter garbage that I witnessed. I'm not convinced it's not an elaborate, expensive joke.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 30 '24

Discussion Funny how inexperienced showrunners think adding more action and bigger battle will solve everything.

Post image
17 Upvotes

The battle scenes in S1 weren’t particularly great. The strategies felt silly and ridiculous and the fight choreography felt silly at times too.

I don’t see how adding more battle will help when viewers still don’t care enough about characters and plots seem senseless and all over the place.

Does dedicating multiple episodes to a battle really make any sense..?

Is S2 going to repeat the same mistakes of giving too much time to other things while the main issues barely get addressed?


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 15 '24

Discussion Rings of Power is a great show from the perspective of a casual lore enjoyer, and who went in with all the big spoilers! Spoiler

12 Upvotes

So I just finished Rings of Power. Great show, want more. Absolutely beautiful to look at. Favorite scene is the bit with Durin and Elrond on the elevator 'YAH MISSED MY WEDDING!'. I want them to be happy together.

So I am a casual enjoyer of LoTR. I've never read the main books, and think the movies are too long, but otherwise very good. I'm not huge into the greater lore of Middle Earth but I leave the Silmarillion on to go to sleep too and have watched enough Nerd of the Rings videos to know my Valar from Ungoliants and my Manwes from my Angbands.

When RoP came out and everyone started yelling about it not following the lore properly, I, a sensible person, watched the first two episodes and was astonished at how beautiful it was. I can honestly say that the fact Isildur is 3000 years too early (or there abouts) doesn't at all spoil the experience unless you deliberately choose to let it.

Unfortunately, everyone was very busy discussing the identity of Sauron and thus, I checked out because I have very little patience for stories focused on mystery mongering and 'Ohh, who is this person actually!' It's a terrible way of telling stories and unfortunately it's becoming more and more common.

I have a very simple rule of story telling. If your story is ruined by spoilers, it wasn't worth telling. it's very freeing if you give it a try. So months later, I remember that beautiful show everyone was mad about after randomly coming across the 3 big major spoilers for who everyone is, which resparks my interest and give it another go!

I was very pleased that actually, none of the story is really about 'Who's who'. Thankfully that was just a fandom thing. I thoroughly enjoyed it, all 4 of the plot lines are very good (Although Southlanders is definitely the weakest). I assumed the half-foots would be very tedious but actually no. Very sweet. Very interesting. I like how the Stranger had been Gandalf for all of 5 minutes and decided he had to bugger off somewhere. It is easily the best looking live action show I've ever seen. Normally I'd say 5 seasons is too long but if they're all this good, then have another 5!

I haven't got a conclusion, I just wanted people to know how I watch TV wrong and still thought it was brilliant!


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 06 '24

Discussion Yeah, they "lost" the ent-wives Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I loved how the ent was pretty much completely reasonable while the entwife was just losing her goddamned mind.

Ent: We were too late
Arondir: An army? How long ago was this?
Ent-wife: OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHh
Ent: Do not ask her to speak more of it.
Ent-Wife: THEY ARE NO DIFFERENT FROM MEN!
Ent-Wife: *RAAAAAH* *Smashes the ground*

Yeah... they "lost" the Ent-wives. More like they stopped going to visit them. Bloody lunatics, they are.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 22 '24

Question New Fan. Why the backlash? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Just binged season 1 and absolutely loved the show!

Production was stunning. I thought the pace was good with each episode giving you enough as a stand alone while also moving things along for the overarching season. Acting was excellent and music was beautiful. I love this era and was always interested in this story after being referenced in LOTR. I kept wondering how they were going to reveal Sauron and I thought it was really well done.

Wondering why it is panned by fans? RT audience score an abysmal 33% yet critic score in the 80’s. Is it just because the casting is “woke”? I’ve also seen a lot of criticism of Galadriel’s depiction.

I have not read any of the books but I loved the movies growing up and felt like this was on par. I think the show format actually works better than movie as it allows more time to get into the little bits without burning out the audience.

EDIT: Thank you for the replies. I’m gathering the main gripe is that they made major changes from the source material and mainly Galadriel is quite different. As I mentioned I didn’t read the books so I don’t have that perspective to draw from. Personally I liked her as a character and felt like her temper/frustrations were justified after being gaslit by everyone and manipulated by one of the oldest and most powerful characters.

Funnily enough as a die hard Star Wars fan in the midst of all the Disney contention many of your complaints echo my own sentiments regarding that franchise but I kept thinking how much better TROP was compared to shows like the Acolyte which was based on one of my all time fav books and was completely butchered. Overall I thought the acting, tone, and pace were much better than the Star Wars shows and it was refreshing but I certainly understand the frustration of having beloved characters and stories changed in drastic ways and overall watered down for a broader tv audience.


r/RingsofPower • • Apr 23 '24

Discussion Netflix had to cancel witcher (one of their biggest properties) 2 seasons earlier than planned as fans hated what netflix did to the source material. And cavill (the biggest star in the show) left. RoP might end up the same way.

34 Upvotes

Netflix had planned 7 seasons of witcher. But are cancelling it after 5 seasons.

It got a lot of viewership when it premiered. But fans soon started to see that the showrunners did not care about the source material at all and wanted to tell their own stories and agendas. And by season 3 witcher fans had had enough. Even henry cavill who is a big fan decided to leave one of his dream roles as he saw the show heading in a disgusting direction.

In case of RoP :

Most Fans dislike the show in the first season itself. And have realised the showrunners don’t really care about Tolkien’s writing. And only want to use his fame to tell their own original stories (which are terrible imo).

Moreover, one of the best performances from season 1 (Adar) has already quit the show after season 1 itself. Under suspicious circumstances. (Im sure he was aware that he will have to commit for more than one season even before signing for s1, so him leaving abruptly after fan reaction is very suspicious)

All the leaks and reveals so far for s2 have pointed that showrunners are arrogant and haven’t bothered correcting things and learning from mistakes. Instead they are doing more of the same as S1.

I’m guessing we’ll see it cancelled after 3-4 seasons if fans continue to call it a shitshow and viewership continues to drop. More major actors will leave if fans continue to hate on the show and if they get no fame or awards. (Hotd and shogun cast are getting so much love from fandoms as the shows were amazing) . At the very least, we’ll see amazon slashing the budgets considerably for future seasons.


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 26 '24

Discussion Breaking the dam - Rings of power just tries too hard to be like the movie trilogy - and fails miserably.

0 Upvotes

How creatively bankrupt does one have to be to keep aping things from the movie trilogy and hiding behind “oh they’re just nostalgic callbacks” .

The whole breaking the dam to create mordor was also stolen from the idea of breaking the dam to wreck saruman’s isengard.

Only, in trilogy it was done to end evil in isengard, and RoP it was done to create evil in mordor.

In trilogy it felt believable and fairly sensible when the ents broke the simple dam that saruman had created to facilitate his evil industry. The dam was broken to restore natural order of things. Perfect.

In RoP breaking of the dam was soo complicated and used as a far fetched mechanism to drive the plot forward and felt unnecessary and forced. And ridiculous. You’d have to do mental gymnastics to accept it. Everything that followed the breaking of the dam didn’t help either. Especially the word art transition from southlands to mordor. Lmao.

Everything in every plot felt so out of place and so forced in RoP. As if it was happening just to push plot forward. It felt like characters were following a script. Nothing felt natural.

RoP plots are a lesson on how to over complicate things and still come around as dumb.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 15 '24

Discussion Female Nazgûls

Post image
37 Upvotes

Ok so that concept from the videogame where they have the two daughters of the Emperor of Shen (Eastern Middle Earth) to become Nazgûls is damn cool. What about two or three Nazgûls being former Princesses and Queens?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Discussion SUCH a satisfying ending. Wow.

3 Upvotes

Can't wait until season 2.

So much of this season was disappointing and missed the mark. But my gosh does this show have a good set is bones to work with.

Just need better writing.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 15 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers My Review: At Least It’s Over: SPOILER EDITION Spoiler

28 Upvotes

Yes, my review of the entire show, not just Season 1, because I am over it and will not be back.

The show had a lot of potential. A big budget, good casting, beautiful visuals, even some dialogue and screenwriting that were genuinely good. A lot of the Elrond and Durin IV plot line, as well as a good bit of Arondir and Bronwyn’s plot line, is enjoyable and feels like Tolkien. But all of that wasn’t enough to save what is, unfortunately, a disaster.

When you make a TV show or a movie from a written narrative, especially one as loosely sketched as the narrative of the Second Age of Middle-Earth, you have to make adaptational changes. You have to tell the story in a way that works for the screen, and for people who will be introduced to the narrative by your adaptation. Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings trilogy is full of these choices, and on balance, Jackson made GOOD choices (less so for The Hobbit trilogy). The reason that these choices are successful, even some of the ones I disagree with, is that they preserve the core of the narrative well. Characters feel “true” to their book counterparts for the most part. The sequence of the plot happens largely in the correct order and preserves the narrative sense and flow of the source. You understand that you are watching an adaptation, but that adaptation is STILL THE LORD OF THE RINGS. You can identify the original story within it.

The Rings of Power does not do this well at all. The changes made in this show undercut the core of the original narrative. Characters, particularly Galadriel, are wildly rewritten in ways that undercut their core personalities. Significant story beats are changed, both in what happens and in the order of events. Worse, core themes and concepts of Tolkien’s world are twisted, inverted, or even more stupidly, discarded in favor of new interpretations that are admitted in the show as being “apocryphal.” The end product cannot be meaningfully related to the original narrative in any way. The hallmarks of that story have been bludgeoned out in favor of ham-fisted, on-the-nose plot and character decisions that lack all subtlety, nuance, or subtext.

To be specific on a few points:

  1. Mithril, the fictional metal found in Khazad-Dum, does not have any of the mystical or supernatural powers that the show claims. It cannot prevent the Elves from fading, and the Fading of the Elves in Tolkien’s actual writing is opposite in almost every way from how the show describes it. The Elven Rings preserve and maintain not the life of the Elves, but the beauty and divine power of the Elder Days, creating sanctuaries like Rivendell and Lothlorien where time passes differently and true physical and spiritual healing and rest can occur. They derive their powers not from mithril, but from the will of the hand that made them, e.g. Celebrimbor’s will, to preserve life and beauty against the oncoming Shadow. All of this is reduced to “mithril gives off magic god radiation” by the show.

  2. The Elven Rings explicitly cannot be the first Rings of Power made in the show. It undermines what the Three are and why they were made, but also Celebrimbor’s actual character arc, which I guess we’re doing in half an episode. The Elven Rings are made by Celebrimbor alone, after Sauron has gone back to Mordor. He makes them out of a desire to preserve the beauty of the Elder Days, and Tolkien calls them the greatest of his works. They are greatest because they are last - he’s had time to practice. The order of creation also matters because the show now has no timeline for the Seven and the Nine to be made. Is Halbrand going to come back, since Galadriel didn’t tell anyone he was Sauron… for some reason? And then Celebrimbor makes the other Rings? Or is Sauron going to explicitly make the Seven and the Nine himself? That’s not a minor discrepancy, that is literally changing major plot events and the reasons for those events.

  3. Sauron… does not have feelings for Galadriel. Not even toxic ones. Unless you count a deep and abiding hatred of the beauty and goodness she represents. This way lies madness. You can’t change these characters that substantially and tell the same story at all.

  4. Without going into extraordinarily nerdy detail, the show has missed the boat (quite literally in one case, my God, I didn’t see that pun at first) on all of the metaphysics of Tolkien’s world in ways that are not merely overlooking “the lore,” but rather changing on a fundamental level the spiritual reality that Tolkien was deeply interested in conveying. The Valar, Valinor, the Unseen World, how creation and the creative act work on a spiritual level, even dumb little stuff like Gil-Galad “awarding” people passage to the Blessed Realm, are all bungled or misinterpreted. The show tinkers with these elements, or misunderstands them, so completely as to miss Tolkien’s entire worldview in the process. This from showrunners who are supposedly the biggest Tolkien superfans ever. Beware anyone who describes themselves with superlatives and titles that seem… unlikely at best. Like “Lord of Gifts,” for example. What a gift this show has been…

Look, I gave this show a lot of the benefit of the doubt. I went out of my way to assume positive intent on the part of everyone involved. As someone who is absurdly over-invested in all things Tolkien, I WANTED this show. I had truly high hopes for it. However, by even the most reasonable and generous standards, the show is a colossal disservice to the narrative it is based on, and borders on open disrespect of Tolkien himself. I have not been so deeply disappointed by something that I was looking forward to so very much in a long time.

Editor’s note: Because I actually take days to think about things and revise them. I have changed the inaccuracies in my second observation to reflect what is actually in Tolkien’s text. After some thought, I have also removed my rating completely. No matter what number rating I give the show, people are going to use that number to ignore or minimize what I actually said in the post itself. Agree or disagree, but let’s do it on the merits. If it wasn’t clear, I think the show is bad. Very bad. The things I have heard and read from the showrunners in the last few days have not changed my opinion.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 17 '24

Discussion Taking ROP for what it is Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I’m doing a rewatch of Hobbit and Extended LOTR and the difference with ROP is so apparent. I was always a fan of the PJ movies but now I really realize all the faithful detail, the lore and nuance in the dialog and staging, the incredible imagery of battles and beauty and terror (gorgeous elves and gruesome orcs), of those 6 movies (even with the bloat of the first 3).

Actually I owe a lot of thanks to ROP. I’m getting a lot more out of the dialog in the PJ films thanks for ROP because now the name drops in the hexology make more sense in context. For ex: when Balin discusses Azog trying to end the line of Durin, or Elendil gets stomped by Sauron with GilGalad Elrond and Isildur in the melee , it makes more sense now that I’ve watched 16 hrs of ROP (they are like Cliff notes for the Silmarillion). I am even more in awe of the PJ movies and disappointed with ROP.

Having said that I still enjoy ROP. The show evokes the world and peoples of middle earth fairly well, albeit in a low budget made for tv way (ironic due to its excessive production cost). Its like how the Mandalorian relates to the 6 Star Wars movies, or the James Bond films that were made after they ran out of Ian Fleming plots. These are still entertaining shows, some more than others. I had pretty low expectations coming into ROP 2 years ago and was quite pleasantly surprised, it exceeded my expectations.

It’s disappointing that ROP isn’t honestly a worthy pre-quel to the PJ films, but they are lightening in a bottle and perhaps impossible to match.

Edit: this isn’t a diss post, to clarify, I’m really enjoying ROP, I’m just a little disappointed.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 04 '24 Polished Silver Turd

Discussion Why do y'all hate this so much?

45 Upvotes

I get it, it's not the best. There are a lot of changes, and I'm not super happy about some of them.

However,

If you think about it, some of these changes make sense. I saw so many people complain about Galadriel. Y'all, Galadriel is crazy different in this age from the Third Age. She was pretty arrogant and bloodthirsty compared to her in the movies.

Another thing I've seen complaints about is the storyline. Keep in mind a lot of these events take places over THOUSANDS of years. It makes sense for the writers to shrink it down. The source material was also an unfinished book that was never published. This is different from LotR movies, where there was a clear sequence of events that took place over like a year.

I think we should at least appreciate the fact that we have content, even if it is flawed. Idk maybe I'm wrong and the show completely sucks.

Edit: I'm not trying to hate on different opinions, nor am I really trying to change anyone's mind. I just wanted to understand why people view this show the way they do. I apologize if I offended anyone here

Edit 2: Ok, I get it. I don't know as much about the Silmarillion as I thought. I guess I wanted your opinions as to why you love or hate it. Online I see people either loving it or hating it. I just wanted to know why.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 22 '23

Discussion I'll admit it. I hate watched it. I might hate watch it again.

0 Upvotes

no, I'm not busy. yes I've read H, LoTR, and tS multiple times and I watch PJ extended editions every year.

and none of it matters because ROP sucks donkey balls. I don't give a shit about the mediocre music if it's the background to a shitshow shit show.

I don't care about the acting if they're reading shit lines and not really doing anything.

and yeah, I'll watch season 2.

will I give it a fair shot? I'll try.


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 06 '24

Discussion Why cant we enjoy stories told despite propaganda?

4 Upvotes

I have seen so many reviews on youtube that are trying to induce rage against some "hidden propaganda" in the rings of power and so many people who hate this show have not have seen the show at all.

On the other hand some of the people who are truly invested in fantasy settings actually liked the first season and gave it 6-8 out of 10. It were not critics or Amazon lovers or propagandists but pure nerds who like stories that have some true potential.

I dont want to give an impression that the first season was a masterpiece but I think it had many very strong positives.

I liked Galadriel in the first season as a character and I think her character worked well in terms of the story told. I think as well she was very well acted.

I think the background and story of Sauron was also very well prepared and made somewhat sense at least in terms of the story which was told.

I think the establishment of Mordor was very well thought out and symbolically very well created in both the story which led there and the art direction.

I also liked some of the bits and pieces of Valinor mainly in terms of the art direction.

This series can not be compared with Peter Jackson movies, that is a plain fact, but I dont think anyone sane believed it would be able to either.

I dont care about the propaganda telling us how should we view the world around us. I just let them tell me their argument and I am the one who makes up my mind. I dont need to attack and belittle other people.

We should be able to separate a work from the artist.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '24

Constructive Criticism I feel like this portrayal of Bombadil is really, really off. Spoiler

8 Upvotes

There are a lot of things in this show that people have highlighted as being inconsistent with established canon.

Most of it I can accept as storytelling liberties given our history of the second age is mostly footnotes outside of a few essays and books published posthumously, most of which had multiple versions where Christopher quite clearly notes that he's not sure which of the manuscripts was the more final version.

But Bombadil seems like a character that you just can't adapt, as presented in the books.

The only thing we really know about him definitively is that he's supposed to represent something timeless and outside the power struggles of Middle-Earth, and that he's fully disinterested in the greater affairs of the world.

The most clarification we ever receive is in Letter #144

Tom Bombadil is not an important person – to the narrative. I suppose he has some importance as a 'comment'. I mean, I do not really write like that: he is just an invention, and he represents something that I feel important, though I would not be prepared to analyze the feeling precisely. I would not, however, have left him in, if he did not have some kind of function.

The story is cast in terms of a good side, and a bad side, beauty against ruthless ugliness, tyranny against kingship, moderated freedom with consent against compulsion that has long lost any object save mere power, and so on; but both sides in some degree, conservative or destructive, want a measure of control.

But if you have, as it were taken 'a vow of poverty', renounced control, and take your delight in things for themselves without reference to yourself, watching, observing, and to some extent knowing, then the question of the rights and wrongs of power and control might become utterly meaningless to you, and the means of power quite valueless. It is a natural pacifist view, which always arises in the mind when there is a war.

In addition to The Council of Elrond, where the following exchange happens

'He is a strange creature, but maybe I should have summoned him to our Council.'
'He would not have come,' said Gandalf.

'Could we not still send messages to him and obtain his help?' asked Erestor. 'It seems that he has a power even over the Ring.'

'No, I should not put it so,' said Gandalf. 'Say rather that the Ring has no power over him. He is his own master. But he cannot alter the Ring itself, nor break its power over others. And now he is withdrawn into a little land, within bounds that he has set, though none can see them, waiting perhaps for a change of days, and he will not step beyond them.'

'But within those bounds nothing seems to dismay him,' said Erestor. 'Would he not take the Ring and keep it there, for ever harmless?'

'No,' said Gandalf, 'not willingly. He might do so, if all the free folk of the world begged him, but he would not understand the need. And if he were given the Ring, he would soon forget it, or most likely throw it away. Such things have no hold on his mind. He would be a most unsafe guardian; and that alone is answer enough.'

In that sense I feel like this RoP depiction of Tom Bombadil is pretty.. off?

Why is he involved with anything? The literal definition of his character is to sit in a forest tending to his own lands, as a comment on symbiosis between man and nature meant to highlight renounced control and delight in things without reference to oneself.

Even if we ignore all of that, if he were in the second age remembering names he was known by "in the past back at the withywindle" (why is his future home in his past?), at that point people called him Iarwain Ben-adar, not Tom Bombadil. I mean, for God's sake, "Bombadil" is a word from the language of Bucklandish, and Buckland was founded in T.A. 2340, by Gorhendad Oldbuck. Not only does Buckland not exist yet, but the language that "Bombadil" comes from is spoken by nobody.

Idk.
I'm not trying to complain. I do love the show, but I'm struggling to understand why this character is even appearing.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 01 '24

Discussion I like that this show is expanding on Orc culture.

30 Upvotes

In the past orcs have been portrayed as vicious, bloodthirsty killers that don’t have any redeeming features. I like how the show is reshaping that by showing that they do indeed have culture and emotions.

I think it’s so much better when the villains of a show are shown to be more complex, than they are bad because they were born bad.

Also there is around 1000 years between this show and LOTR. All cultures develop over time and it’s interesting to show that orc culture is no different. They have changed to how they were in the past due to the influence of outside forces.

Finally, even Tolkien said that orcs were not irredeemable and that like all other creatures could become part of the world.

Edit: Tolkien did have a lot of ambiguity when it came to orcs. In his original works and the first three books he did write them as being more evil and not redeemable. However, I think he found it hard to square that view with his catholic religion. Therefore, it later life in letters, and essays he softened his views in the ocrs. They were still bad but not irredeemable and could go against their worst nature. I think the ambiguity leaves a lot of room for interpretation and I like that the show has gone for this one. Yea they are still the villains and I want them to be defeated but now they are more complex.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 24 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Númenóreans in RoP are depicted completely wrong

Post image
1 Upvotes

The average Númenórean was taller than two Rangar or 6'4". Elendil was the tallest of Men who escaped the Downfall, mentioned to be almost 2.5 rangar tall, 7'11" or 2.41 m. Númenóreans were granted especially long lives when compared to that of other Men, with the average lifespan in the beginning ranging from 350 years to as much as 420. Those of the line of Elros in particular often lived 400 years or even more, while those who were outside of the royal line only rarely managed to reach 400.

Númenóreans were also those who best understood the Gift of Ilúvatar and were blessed in that they did not share the same fear of death that other men had. Often in the beginning of Númenor, Men who at last began to feel the first signs of weariness of mortal life would voluntarily give up their spirits and die of their own free will. This usually would only occur in the latter years of their lifespan, such as around year 400 for the particularly long lived.

However, as part of the decay brought on by the Shadow, many Númenóreans began to fear death rather than accept it. During the twilight of the realm, many Númenóreans would cling to life for as long as possible, becoming senile and decrepit like other Men. Additionally, lifespans began to decline as the Shadow further grew. The lifespans of those of the house of Elros began to fall to the point where many would live for less than three centuries.

— tolkiengateway.net


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Newest Episode Spoilers 3 episodes in and im shocked at how bad this season is (spoilers) Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I know some people do view the dislike to this show as being very unfair but tbh after watching three episodes of this current season im actually shocked at how bad it is, from Sauron struggling to make the one ring (fml), to galadriel wandering around with an orc and then add in Gandalfs moses moment like you can't make up how far away from the lore they're just willing to go.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 28 '24

Question What is so bad about this show?

1 Upvotes

For context I’ve not read the books, only seen the movies a couple of times. I consider myself a lighthearted fan, and enjoyed Rings of Power.

My question to die hard fans is, what was amiss? I’d love some examples as opposed to just saying “the acting is bad”. Whose acting? And when? For example.

Thank you for your time! X


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 23 '23

Discussion Why not enjoy the show for what it is?

24 Upvotes

The books will always be the definitive true source material and that will never go away. ROP like Jackson and Bakshi's movies are all but adaptations. The same with the russian ones too lol. What's irritating for me is why the Shadow of Mordor games gets a pass by fans when they break the lore constantly and ROP gets pissed on?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '24

Discussion As a new LoTR fan, RoP isn’t that much worse than the LoTR movies Spoiler

0 Upvotes

First of all, this is about comparing the films to the series, not the original source material.

I’ve just seen a lot of negativity towards the latest few episodes of this show and I don’t really understand it, especially given how much people seem to love the films.

Per background, I’m a new LoTR fan. I read the Hobbit in school as required reading but never got to the LoTR. I missed the movies when they first came out. This show has ignited my interest in Tolkien and I just binge watched the LoTR films.

I’ve seen a lot of dislike towards this show, which some is warranted especially for season 1. But there’s some that isn’t, especially since the films are held in such high regard. For example, people complaining how the elves didn’t know about the horde of orcs outside their city. It’s the same situation as how was the army of men missed all the oliphants (elephant?) when charging the orcs in RotK. This content is supposed to fantastical and fun. If you can forgive the films for their poor writing, you can forgive this series and enjoy it for what it is. Sure the show is not as engaging as the films but it’s not significantly worse and only getting better imo

On the positive side, I’ve ordered the LoTR box set and about to fully jump into this world.


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 08 '24

Discussion Hope season 2 will turn the online outrage to more neutral-positive reception

3 Upvotes

Every videos and pictures related to ROP in social media is getting bombared by negative comments. Especially in the big channels like FB, IG, Youtube and X. Some safe spaces like on lotr_prime and tumblr can have friendly fan engagement. But my hope and wish is that the next season will turn the tide and minimal reduce the hate. Similar to what happened to Wheel of Time season 2.