r/Rings_Of_Power • u/GamingDisruptor • 6h ago
Amazon Cancels Rings of Power Episode 7 Theater Screenings In UK And Ireland - Cosmic Book News
😂😂😂😂😂🤡🔥🎉
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/BreadEggg • 3d ago
S3.E5 ∙ The Lady of Lórien
Director: Sanaa Hamri
Writers: John D. Payne, Patrick McKay
S3.E2 ∙ From Valinor
Director: Stefan Schwartz
Writers: Justin Doble, Griff Jones
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/GamingDisruptor • 6h ago
😂😂😂😂😂🤡🔥🎉
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/Spare-Difficulty-542 • 5h ago
In my humble opinion I think the production should change the showrunners to save the show on a PR front and also for the sake of the IP.
Look I get the vision of Payne and Mckay… it’s really interesting and nice but I feel like they should’ve been like assistant directors or assistant writers,simply because of their inexperience in their execution. I’ve seen some of the interviews and I can tell how passionate they are and how much they know about the lore . But sometimes when I watch the show I wonder to myself
“am I really watching the great second age show about the greatest of civilizations,good and bad….or am I just watching Galadriels and Sauron’s subplot.”
This show should’ve been GREAT!.. not good but great but it hardly maintains a good storyline with some great scenes and it’s mostly due to the actors or bears music. What they’ve done so far isn’t anything bad in its own but for an IP that has displayed nothing short of greatness,it’s bad. In the sense of scale this shows plot should’ve been 3x larger than Game of Thrones due to multiple large prospering kingdoms instead we have like 4 named elves in lindon, 5 named characters in numenor, 1 named villian in Mordor, 4 named dwarves etc …..this is such a petty ensemble for such a grand story that Tolkien has made notes of.
I do have so many praises for this show but even more worries and complaints. Although this season is the most focused and progressive season…..yet it spends 70% of the plot surrounding Galadriel and Celeborn and I feel like Sauron just got tagged along with the plot created to insert Celeborn to the show instead of giving Sauron his own story a full focus. The showrunners said that S3 will be focused on war of elves and sauron and so far nothing has been shown on screen that shows a conflict in ME other than some far off shots or some random dialogue. This is where I feel like the show is deviating from the main story. I feel like the showrunners are giving more importance and screentime to the stories they’ve made to fill the gaps all the while taking the emphasis away from the biggest events of this beautiful tale of the second age.
With two seasons left …. BOOK SPOILERS AHEAD! The fall of numenor and the war of the last alliance are the last two straws that could reinstate this show as one of the greatest shows of all time and for that I believe Amazon needs to get better and more experienced people in charge to get the script and scale right for these two biggest events from the LOTR IP.
….these two events are bigger than the pelennor fields or the destruction of the one ring that swept the Oscars. To make those two events to hit hard on a script and on a visual scale we need people of such caliber to work on the script and direction….it is season 3 and I feel like they are just learning to capture the story and scale on screen. Appreciate the improvement but worried about what is to come.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/arealkneeslapper • 6h ago
I don't know if it's just me, but I'm having a difficult time getting into the show because Sauron is so similar to Dennis from It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia. It takes me out of the show everytime he's on screen. My husband doesn't see it. Am I crazy?
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/Ambitious-Growth5387 • 9h ago
Let’s call it what it is.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/TraditionalGas1770 • 18h ago
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/Pure_Common7348 • 16h ago
My wife and I saw that Season 3 recently dropped. Since we had forgotten part of the storyline, we spent the last two weeks rewatching Seasons 1 and 2.
Having just finished the first two seasons, we were struck by how much lower the production budget for Season 3 appears in comparison. Beyond the visual quality, we also felt that the storyline in Season 3 leaves a lot to be desired.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/Meioxy • 1d ago
So this week, we finally get a look at the mighty Numenorian army on its home turf.
The worlds most powerful army that could decisively change the tide of the war against Sauron.
The one that’s so vast it’ll need 1000 ships to carry them to middle earth.
And it’s… this? About 2000 men? It’s going to be very spacious on those transport ships…
This show just cannot do scale to save its life - over 20 years on from Helms Deep and Minas Tirith, and they can’t even come close to matching it (let alone exceed it) despite the bottomless budget!
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/POE_54 • 10m ago
If we change our mindset, it's not that bad.
I'm always excited to find out what they've done for the next episode.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/OldShelobsTricks • 45m ago
Seems as though the show runners borrowed a few things from a 1997 classic.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/SpaceMiser • 15h ago
For the most part I enjoy the show. But IMO there are way too many scenes where it is so dark I can't make anything out on my big screen. Seems like a cop out to me. If it wasn't in the budget to create detailed imagery just leave it out. Don't hide behind a black screen.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/thewhitecampion • 15h ago
despite some of the preposterous writing decisions this season, gotta give credit where it's due and that's how well they handled celeborn's character. i was half expecting they'd make him some incompetent buffoon but he's very much not (besides that ep6 scene). he is a very skilled fighter, strategic, brave, and is not the least bit intimidated by sauron. and the way he sacrificed himself to be captured again so they wouldn't find galadriel? what an absolute chad. he always puts galadriel first and consoles her even after all the suffering he has been through. and casting jcb was one of the best decisions they've made. i always thought the elves in this show looked and acted too human, but this guy is a natural born elf. like it's actually believable that he's someone who has been alive for thousands of years. also they actually give him a personality, and quite a likeable one too. just makes it all the more disappointing with the ridiculous plot they've written when this character had so much potential.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/crustboi93 • 6h ago
The show has been pretty inconsistent with the powers of the elven rings. We've seen them be used to heal wounds and disabilities, purify corruption, warn against Nazgnagol, conceal oneself, and grant plot-relevant visions.
I want to focus on the healing bit. This season Gil-Galad only used it to return Miriel's sight. They don't seem too concerned about using this power to help their own elves during or after battle though.
Weird.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/maybe_Ancha • 16h ago
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/ILikeLiftingMachines • 1d ago
Previously, on The Rings of Power...
Galadriel, having spent another episode being the wisest person in Middle-earth by ignoring absolutely everybody's advice, has discovered that Sauron is evil. Again.
Meanwhile, Elrond is struggling with a terrible dilemma: should he save Middle-earth, or spend another forty minutes discussing his feelings?
The dwarves are arguing about a rock. The Númenóreans are arguing about an elf. The elves are arguing about some rings. And the orcs, apparently, just want to settle down, raise families, and enjoy a reasonable work-life balance.
But trouble is brewing!
Will Galadriel discover that the mysterious stranger with the glowing red eyes and the enormous black fortress might not be entirely trustworthy?
Will the Stranger finally reveal that he is Gandalf, surprising absolutely nobody except the writers?
Will the Númenóreans discover a functioning system of government?
Will anyone walk between two locations rather than magically appearing there?
And will somebody, somewhere, finally read a fucking Tolkien book?
Confused?
You will be... after this week's episode of THE RINGS OF POWER!
(PS "Soap" was an outstanding TV show)
r/Rings_Of_Power
•
u/Academic-Emu8215
•
1d ago
The biggest mistake happens right at the start of season 1. And it breaks the whole show for me. Especially since Tolkien makes it very clear that Galadriel never trusted Sauron as Annatar, but now she trusts a random human who talks in riddles and seems to possess knowledge far beyond the horizon of a mortal? It just doesn't fit for me.
I know that Sauron is a deceiver by nature. And I know that Galadriel needed some kind of arc in the show. Characters do not have to be flawless, that's not the point. But the decision to make her fall for him and his deception is a deal breaker for me. Let everyone around Galadriel trust Halbrand/Sauron. Let her get frustrated because she is the only one who sees through him, but don't let it actually be her who unknowingly helps Sauron to get back on his (evil) track.
This decision right at the start is a complete character assassination. Since Galadriel has discovered the truth and her own fault in this matter she walks around with a bad consciene for two seasons. In season 3 she has also to explain to Celeborn why she was infatuated by the Dark Lord. It's a total train wreck and I don't know how this can be brought to a satisfying conclusion.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/Unlikely_Candy_6250 • 1d ago
If you don't know Eru Iluvatar is God in LOTR. Very strongly inspired by JRR Tolkien's Catholic faith. He is otherwise known in the books as "The One" or "The Secret Fire." There's a whole account of his creation of the world in the Silmarillion.
Now, in fairness to ROP a lot of this is tied up in disputes over the rights to LOTR. For example, I doubt they could use the name "Eru" as it isn't in the appendices. So my complaint here isn't that it isn't perfectly accurate...
But rather that it's not even in the spirit of the original.
Numenor worships... the Valar.
Numenor is the one place in the books where religion is directly referenced and plays a big role in the story. The Faithful worshiped Eru and thus were wise enough to perceive that Ar-Pharazon's actions would result in divine retribution, so they were able to escape ahead of it. I'm sure they respected the Valar too but Eru is explicitly stated to be who they worshiped.
In ROP, the Numenorians worship the Valar and them only. Furthermore as they're only referred to as a collective it's hard to really get a read on what they're even meant to stand for in this show or what Pharazon is eroding.
Death is the gift of... the Valar.
That said the real crime to me is that they describe death as the "Gift of the Valar" in this show.
If you don't know, Eru personally created Man and Elves, and bestowed death upon the former as a gift rather than a curse. There's a lot of rumination about that in LOTR, with Man having come to fear death despite it being a divine gift Eru bestowed upon them. Even the Elves can't perceive the why of it fully, with there being a lengthy written debate between an elf and human woman about it in one of the histories.
In ROP, it's apparently the Valar who actually bestowed it. Which is especially weird because death actually is referred to as "the One's gift" in the appendices so they presumably had the rights to this but still chose to change it for unknown reasons.
Beyond that, the Gift of Man (Death) is treated rather simplistically in ROP. The way they talk about it you'd think they didn't just accept death as a divine mandate and believe in a better life after it... but actually WANT to die. With Earien hopping off a ledge being viewed as embracing the Gift, which feels a little tone deaf.
Gandalf fell to Arda so hard he forget who God is.
Then hilariously when it comes to things that should concern the Valar they change THAT to be Eru instead. Gandalf was sent by the Valar, he IS a servant of Eru as he is still essentially an angel. However, his mission was originally bestowed upon him the Valar who sent him by boat to Middle Earth.
In ROP, he's either shot out of a cannon or hurled down from the Heavens so hard he forgets who he is, what his mission is, who God is, and how to speak...
Great job, guys!
Eru appears... to deliver exposition.
Then of course you have the scene where the Secret Fire actually appears to speak to Gandalf in ROP. Except that all he does is give exposition on all of the things that Gandalf forgot.
They needed to use the all-powerful God of the universe to write themselves out of a boring amnesia plotline because they kept dragging it out for so long. If Eru appears it should be a huge event not a simple dump of information.
In short, Eru seldom appears in LOTR and they still managed to screw it up at every turn.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/AffectionatePush8165 • 1d ago
Galadriel is crying, saying "he was all i had left... i'll tell you his name if you want". The way she says it makes it sound like something happened (sexually speaking) between her and this being, and it's clearly Sauron in his Halbrand version... except we never saw anything like that, or anything that implied something had happened in seasons 1 or 2—just that tension between them... Sauron talks like something happened to Celeborn, which you'd expect from him... So I'm left wondering because of Galadriel's line in this scene. Did I miss something in the earlier seasons? Sure, something might show up in upcoming episodes, but I don't think they'll go much further with this dynamic—to me it feels more like clickbait to pull in another crowd that's into tropes and stuff, though this scene... I don't know, maybe I'm just being slow lol
Ps.: To me, it's kind of like when someone cheats on their partner and decides to come clean, and the other person usually asks, "Who was it? Who was it with?" In Galadriel's case, she jumps ahead and already says she'll tell his name if Celeborn wants to know.. you know what I mean?
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 • 1d ago
This is not meant to offend the people who like this show, I do as well, even if only as a satirical parody, in that regard it’s bloody hilarious. I just wanted to share a great find on Threads, this app is so utterly ridiculous, absolutely brilliant. You won’t find takes like this anywhere else, genuinely love these.
Oh what masterful dialogue we’ve been getting.
r/Rings_Of_Power • u/LescobeRanden • 1d ago
The show treats this as some massive secret that Sauron cunningly worms out of Celeborn, but how on Earth is it possible that he didn't already know this? He forged the Seven and the Nine together with Celebrimbor, at a point that Celebrimbor trusted him fully, and the other elven smiths Sauron worked with (and even led for a while) knew this too, and none had any reason to hide this from him.
Am I to believe this somehow never came up during the many months Sauron and Celebrimbor spent together forging Rings based on the model of the Three, even though this was a crucial ingredient for the Three? Really?
Back in season 2 I considered it a plot hole that they never explained where they got the gold and silver from Valinor from to forge the new Rings, as season 1 had established this was a crucial element without which the Rings could not be made.
But now they apparently retconned that, the other Rings could be made without this ingredient, and this was just some special thing Celebrimbor did for the Three and not for the others for no reason that is ever explained. And he never discussed with Sauron that he left this crucial ingredient out for the other Rings even though, again, he fully trusted Sauron at that point.
It makes no sense whatsoever, just a massive plot hole. I just didn't realize it at first because I was distracted by the barrage of other stupid things this last episode fired at me.