Very few games grow on me as quick as Returnal did, I have been completely sucked in and having played the roguelike genre before but not loved it, this was the game that finally clicked with me.
It matched the tone and fantasy of a roguelike mechanic perfectly. The flavourtext of the story is perfect, this woman in grief and seemingly not free from blame for her woes, yet fighting to deepen her acknowledgement, atonement, or plain understanding of herself is precisely what makes a roguelike. Linking it so closesly to Greek myths is hilarious, with the characters named after Greek gods - hilarious considering Hades is the other great roguelike and is similarly suited to a genre that requires death to be a feature. Gods care not for death, it’s like breathing for them. But whereas the tone of Hades is much lighter and makes a joke of death, Selene is horrified by it, no doubt the way a mortal in Hades would feel if they experienced things the way the gods do.
It also felt like a Silent Hill game we never got. Not because it relates to Silent Hills lore, or plays like those games in any way - but consider the fog of Silent Hill engulfing everything in ominous mystery, and it’s mythos of torturing those plagued with guilt over and over again. That sits perfectly alongside Returnal in my mind. I don’t know the lore of Silent Hill, how the town came to be or the rules of it, as I think the more vague, the better - a foggy town that doesn’t really exist, only for those that cannot escape themselves, all drawn to it and become trapped as it lives off of their cycles of self-torture.
Selene and James feel like perfect candidates for that, and their forms of torture also match. Whereas James indeed felt asleep at the wheel of his life since the tragedy he went through, so too does SH2 itself feel like wandering through a dream of a town as you play. Meanwhile Selene is characterised a fighter, a driven, aggressive, and goal-oriented person, focused largely on self-preservation. Her hell on Atropos suits her as well as James’ home in Silent Hill.
Once I made that comparison I couldn’t separate them in my mind. I think it’s a masterful work that is really elevated by the AAA feel of its production, being able to render such a niche, unfriendly story and unforgiving gameplay loop at such a high quality AND having it be presented the way it was at PS5s launch always piqued my interest, and I’m so glad I finally got to play it.
I’ll be probably trying to find the last pieces of the puzzle next and then delving into the Tower of Sisyphus. It feels over too soon, but it was an absolute blast to play, and even though I’ve heard Saros is just as good in many ways, I fear we’ll never get a game quite like Returnal blending its atmosphere and gameplay and story ever again.