r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Apr 07 '21

Leaving the Cult may NOT go well if one is NOT adequately Prepared

6 Upvotes

Cultic Addiction Switching, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, Developmental Stunting & Self-Harm are Possibilities

Though some will be, MOST cult exitors will not be chased around by The True Believers trying to “save them from their big mistake.” The bigger issue effective and complete withdrawal (see not-moses’s reply to the OP on that thread) from the cultic addiction, very much including the desperate, disorganized attachment to others one has (supposedly) become close to, as well as the dire need to be a part of “something bigger.”

But “something bigger” includes more than the “sense” of community. It includes the upshots of a conditioned, in-doctrine-ated, instructed, imprinted, socialized, habituated, and normalized need to dodge the untreated psychological upshots of having been similarly conditioned etc. to a lingering state of Learned Helplessness, Dread & the Victim Identity. Left unrecognized, unacknowledged, unappreciated and unattended, that nasty combo will very often fuel a compulsion to find a new cultic involvement to provide the same addictive “fix” that kept one locked into the cultic addiction cycle in the previous cult.

The new cult may look, sound, taste, smell and feel entirely different from the old one. (Christianity-loathing former evangelicals, fundamentalists and/or charismatics may be intensely attracted to “new age,” human potential, political cause or even multi-level marketing cults. I’ve seen this a lot.) But the "hole" it fills (temporarily) is the same unless or until the exitor deals with that.

Beyond all that, there’s a particular matter one has to deal with if one has left a cult in which “moral purity” is a major coercive component. (Which would include virtually all of the fundamentalist Christian, Jewish, Islamic and other Abrahamic churches, as well as many Hindu and Buddhist cults.) Many exitors become so disgusted with the relentless “moral blackmail” heaped on them to induce Sin, Shame and Guilt that they rebound psychologically into brief, lingering or even permanent – and very costly -- moral depravity (much as I did in my 20s and 30s). The sudden release from the extreme “moral confinement” of the cult has lead many exitors into all manner of self-destructive behaviors including wanton alcoholism, hard drug abuse, hardcore ritualistic satanism, hate-fueled & revenge-bent career prostitution, sexual perversions (e.g. with pre-teen and small children; I have seen a LOT of that), risk addictions, etc.

The Abrahamic and other “social organizing” religions do serve a purpose, even if that purpose is so often contaminated and corrupted: They confer what Lawrence Kohlberg called the first of the three stages of moral development. But they tend to slow development of the second, and block access altogether the third of those stages, largely because deeply instructed belief does not allow the mind to see, hear, feel or sense what is perceived adequately to ever reach the higher stages.

In whatever event, understanding, appreciating and attending to what I have described above appears in my experience to be a requirement for successful, long-lasting, comfortable and trouble-free emergence from Religious & Cultic Trauma Syndrome.

References & Resources

How & Why People Leave One Cult — and End Up in Another

Still Stuck in the Muck of RTS? There IS a Way Out.

SIQR, the 10 StEPs & Recovery from Religious Trauma Syndrome: A How-To Guide

Dis-I-dentifying with Learned Helplessness & the Victim I-dentity (and not-moses's answers to a replier's questions there)

Do I need Exit Counseling or Deprogramming?

To find an understanding, secular therapist if you need one, see my reply to the OP on Decided to start therapy

Choiceless Awareness for Emotion Processing and pretty much everything else

CA4EP and the 10 StEPs for Emotional Blackmail

A Comprehensive -- and Free -– Online BOOK on How Cults Work and how to recover from them

A Basic Cult Library


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Jan 03 '21

Is it too late to change my sexual self-image

4 Upvotes

I have identified as an Incel since I was 14, so the past decade of my life, including all of high school and college. I really want to challenge this but I'm afraid it's too late as my entire sexual development occurred with this core belief.

To keep things short I suffered a great deal of abuse as a child that led me to this belief. I've often spent hours on end pondering how my life could have been different had I lost my virginity at 14 or 15 and never went through this decade of life with such a terrible issue in my identity.

I am still a virgin, but I will lose it in the next week. I am fairly good looking (I'd say 7-8) and I sometimes involve myself in online ERP (erotic roleplay) groups and I find myself very popular in them, as well as usually faking my orgasms during them, and as a whole I'm a generally very well liked person. From this I can say I believe I am sexually attractive but my core belief that I am an Incel and sex is inaccessible to me is something that causes me to have a terrible lack of sexual confidence, at least in any interaction that I can conceive of as leading to me losing my virginity.

I am on the autism spectrum, but I am very socially adept and confident in most things except sex. I am very driven and feel a strong sense of mission in my life, in this respect as sex is very prominent in my value system I feel I am unable to reach my true potential. I wish to become sexually confident and integrate my sexuality into the rest of my fairly successful life.

I fear that your sexual self image, and habits, and worldview develop so strongly in adolescence that they become rigid later in life and that it may be too late for me to change this. I've been trying very hard to better myself over the past few months and to get over this. I live by a motto of "don't ask if I can do something, ask how I can do something", and am generally very ambitious and determined and see nothing as impossible, but this one single area happens to be the area where my mind tells me I can't do it. I feel like even if I get everything I can possibly want sexually from this day forward, I will still see myself as an undesirable Incel that just learned to trick people, because when I was undergoing puberty and had my sexuality first emerge I developed this self perception. I feel like because I've completely missed out on ten years of learning and experience while I was developing I'll never be able to see things in the intuitive way other people can see them, and will always be playing catch up.

I'm Intelligent and a fast learner so honestly I'm probably gonna be able to catch up in knowledge, but I'll never be able to catch up in confidence i feel. I'll never be able up catch up in quantity of partners or diversity of experiences either. I just feel ten years is so much time to make up for, and if I rush it then it will warp the experiences I have into something unrecognizable. A 25 year old pua who sleeps with 30 women in a single year, after having no earlier experience will have a very different experience than a 25 year old who has been sexually active since 15, the second person might have a one night stand here or there, alongside many medium to long term relationships averaging 4 months in length. The compensating pua doesn't have any variety in their experience, they gain no wisdom, they just use a very specific tactic to increase an arbitrary number. I'd also say being sexually active at different ages gives you different qualities to your experiences that will make them more varied and qualitatively valuable too. The YouTuber Luna is someone I look to as having the ideal sex life.

I've read studies about virginity loss age that indicate people who lose theirs later tend to have increased rates of sexual dysfunction, increased income, increased relationship satisfaction, and decreased partner count. That seems like a mixed bag. I believe the mechanism on increased relationship satisfaction is that they tend not to have bad habits in relationships that they developed as a teenager, maybe as an adult I'll learn faster and avoid many pitfalls, but I fear I'll always be behind nonetheless. I'm likewise deathly afraid of sexual dysfunction and fear I will always have it, and lower partner count the same, I feel it will make my sex life much less richer than that of others.

I've thought of being poly once I am sexually active. One person (also a virgin) said that I could leverage the increased relationship satisfaction into maintaining stable polyamorous relationships that many wouldn't be able to maintain, and then have more variety in my experiences. I might be poly anyways since it sounds nice, but still I'd only be involved with other poly people so that wouldn't give a variety of experiences like others will have had.

I also to some extent feel a 25 year old Incel can get laid despite being sexually unappealing solely based on social status, so the fact that I haven't had sex yet means I'll never be able to have sex with someone I'm sure is into me sexually vs just into my social status. Not sure about this though

Has anyone really been in a situation like this before? Does anyone have input or advice on this? I'm genuinely optimistic about my life and about getting past this, but I still have the spectre of a decade of defeatism that I need to overcome.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Sep 21 '19

A Reply to a Recovering Cult Exiter

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Jun 02 '19

Looking INTO Wim Hof

3 Upvotes

Wim Hof's "method" is mentioned often enough on r/Meditation in a particular way that it seemed worthwhile to look into it in depth. Thus...

A Google search of "Wim Hof breathing."

From Wikipedia:

"Wim Hof markets a regimen, the Wim Hof Method (WHM) that he claims will help with, among other things, sleep, willpower, sports performance, stress, creativity and immune system. Testimonials on his website claim to have improved illnesses such as rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis. The method involves three "pillars": cold therapy, breathing and meditation.[20] It has similarities to Tibetan Tummo meditation and pranayama, both of which employ breathing techniques.[21]"

"Practices such as cold bathing have been common at least as far back as Roman times, and numerous health benefits have been claimed, but long-term benefits are not yet supported by randomized controlled trials.[24]"

"Pikkers and Kox attributed the effect on the immune system to a stress-like response. In the hypothalamus, stress messages from the brain trigger a release of adrenaline, which increases the pumping of blood and releases glucose, both of which can help the body deal with an emergency. It also suppresses the immune system. In Hof and the trained subjects, the adrenaline release was higher than it would be after a person's first bungee jump.[25][26]"

"Wim Hof has been accused of overstating the benefits of his method, giving false hope to people suffering from serious diseases, and some of his claims have been uncritically reported by the media.[2] On his website he says that it has reduced symptoms of several diseases including rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis, and Parkinson's disease;[27] He has also said it might cure some forms of cancer.[2] Wouter van Marken Lichtenbelt, one of the scientists who studied Hof, stated that "[Hof's] scientific vocabulary is galimatias. With conviction, he mixes in a non-sensical way scientific terms as irrefutable evidence."[22] However, Van Marken Lichtenbelt goes on to say: "When practicing the Wim Hof Method with a good dose of common sense (for instance, not hyperventilating before submerging in water) and without excessive expectations: it doesn't hurt to try."[22] ...

"Someone who hyperventilates before submerging in water can experience a shallow water blackout, with potentially fatal consequences. Four practitioners of the WHM drowned in 2015 and 2016, and relatives suspected the breathing exercises were to blame.[28][29] The WHM website advises doing the exercises in a safe manner and location.[30]"

For someone as school-trained in the Fight / Flight / Freeze / Faint / Feign (or Fawn) Responses that can lead to Fry and then Freak functions of the autonomic nervous system as I had to come to be to understand Complex PTSD, my initial reaction to Wim Hof was one of concern. But now having looked into it for the past half hour through the lens of all this, I'd have to say that what was mere concern is now something else. Wim Hof's business has at least some of the earmarks of One More Cynical, Sociopathic, Yogic Hindu Con Job.

Caveat emptor at minimum. And take a careful look at the personality types that are attracted to such supposed "empowerment." Are at least some of them adrenaline junkies trying to compensate for an earlier conditioning, instruction, socialization, habituation and normalization to Learned Helplessness & a Victim Identity? IDK, but I've seen that kind of dot-connecting too many times now to dismiss it as a significant possibility.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Oct 05 '19

Suspicions about recovery materials with the realities of the world

4 Upvotes

I'm unable to read the most material without triggered to feeling "weak" and "bad" , specially the DBT- like eastern compassionshite material and apply them, like being perfectionist and working too much is bad and that we shouldn't push ourselves, that money is not everything and we should learn to be happy in small things, all those talks about taking baths, taking time to ourselves and not pushing ourselves too harsh because we're traumatized, that we're the "victims" and that we should play the life game according to that, that we should go slow and not compare ourselves, all /r/CPTSD mindset is that, the mindset of the retreat, accepting the survival and not wanting to thrive, when I read trauma material I feel sick to stomach, like all those talks about inner child, self-compassion, and like saying "oh this is a flashback!" which is useless as hell well, what I see in my workplace environment is that the life is no different than what I've seen in my past, the people are fucking unconscious in what they do and what is at the play is the sole BIOLOGY, people will do any kind of worse shit if they feel like they are right to do it, and if U don't get ur mental health in order people smell this weakness and they don't show any compassion or understanding, but they take it as a personal attack like u just don'T like them or u're asshole when U actually use withdrawal from social environemtn bcuz u feel triggered in reality.

Idk if there's anyone whom like me thinks that world is just a capitalistic competetive place and all those trauma work are not in line with the reality of the world, hitler killed millions of people, bosnians killed muslims and we here feel this is outrageous when people wronged their own children, I started to think the nature is cruel in its roots and this stuff is no surprise to mankind, people killed each other for small food or water reserves, there's people who are unconscious of their natural biology mechanism who will do what their emotions and thoughts tell them according to their belief structure. I think only accepting these stuff and looking into the future, how we can recuperate ourselves so we can move on is most important, not grieving about the stuff that was done in millennial year ago, or angering in your mind to ur imagined parents whom installed perfectionist drives and shame in u because that is the reality of this world.

I'm started to believe more in Aaron Beck, Albert Ellis, Viktor Frankl, Jordan Peterson. Working hard and just shifting your cognitive apparatus so U won't get triggered, so U will get strong with the Knowledge of psychology, and so U can work in the capitalist order like a true capitalist without completely analyzing ur fucked up childhood which is beyond in the ashes of the past. Ur mind constantly compares u with other people, if u feel like a small weak child in urself, then u're screwed. Earning money, being competetive and strong in workplace, being strong emotionally in relationships, all those give u the strong self image, and if u're accepting the traumatized self-image, the victim, the barely surviving, then the capitalist world won't give u its treasures, that's what I see, please comment and let's talk, but plz don't tell me that I'm crazy to think all these, say it in a civil language so we can disscuss. Thx.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Feb 24 '22

Can one expect much from trying to argue a "Rational Case" with a *True Believer*? This is what I do BEFORE I decide and either engage or move on.

6 Upvotes

I always look to see and listen to hear...

  1. how conditioned, in-doctrine-ated, instructed, groomed, imprinted, socialized, habituated, programmed and normalized is the other party by and to their particular cult's Groupthink, Social Proof, Implicit Social Contract, Confirmation Bias & Unquestioning Acceptance of Authority, and...

  2. how far the other party has moved along The Five Progressive Qualities of the Committed Cult Member.

Hopefully, the implications of those are self-evident. BUT... there's one more thing I look and listen for which may be more difficult to parse out. And that is the degree of dissociative “splitting” (see my reply to the OP on that Reddit thread) involved. Because experience has taught me that while some split off "parts" of a True Believer's mind can see and hear factual evidence, other parts cannot.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Oct 07 '21

Erase the Disc? Or Overwrite the Disc? Cybernetic Metaphors on Ethical & Effective Psychotherapy

3 Upvotes

There are several "laws" in neuropsychology, and one of them is this:

Everything that has ever been conditioned, in-doctrine-ated, instructed, imprinted, socialized, habituated, and normalized into a neural network of cognition in the human brain will be there until that brain ceases to function... even though newer -- and oppositional -- conditioning, in-doctrine-ation, instruction, imprinting, socialization, habituation and normalization has been established.

I have been in the field for 34 years. Regardless of popular claims to the contrary, I've yet to see a case of "complete" de-conditioning from what was conditioned (etc.) to begin with.

That said, the relative impact of the old to the new can be modified substantially by various processes that "thin out" the old neural networks and "fatten up" the new ones.

See section seven of this earlier post in the larger package called A 21st Century Recovery Program for Someone with Untreated Childhood Trauma to see how that can be done.

Despite what most believe, there's a LOT one can do without spending a fortune on psychotherapy, as well as to speed up the process if one is in therapy or at least at the fourth of the five stages of therapeutic recovery.

References & Resources

Cayoun et al, Courtois, Dana & Porges, Fisher, Ogden et al, Shapiro and Van der Kolk in section two; Porges in section three; Linehan in section four; everyone on section five; and everyone in section six of A CPTSD Library, along with...

Agarwal, N.: fMRI Shows Trauma Affects Neural Circuitry, in Clinical Psychiatry News, Vol. 37, No. 3, March 2009.

Alladen, A.: Integrative CBT for Anxiety Disorders: An Evidence-Based Approach to Enhancing Cognitive Behavioural Therapy with Mindfulness and Hypnotherapy, Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell, 2016.

Baker, R,; Gale, L.; et al: Emotional Processing Therapy for post traumatic stress disorder, in Counselling Psychology Quarterly (UK), Vol. 26, No. 3/4, 2013.

Begley, S.: Train Your Mind, Change Your Brain: How Science Reveals our Extraordinary Potential to Transform Ourselves, New York: Ballantine Books, 2007.

Boraxbekk, C.; et al: Neuroplasticity in response to cognitive behavior therapy for social anxiety disorder, in Translational Psychiatry, February 2016. DOI:10.1038/tp.2015.218

Brown A.; Marquis, A.; et al: Mindfulness-Based Interventions in Counseling, in Journal of Counseling & Development, Vol. 91, No. 1, January 2013.

Buczynski, R.; Levine, P.; Van der Kolk, B.; Porges, S.; Ogden, P.; Siegel, D.; Fisher, S.; Rethinking Trauma: The Right Interventions Can Make Trauma Treatment Faster and More Effective, a webinar, National Institute for the Clinical Application of Behavioral Medicine, October-November, 2014.

Cozzolino, L.: The Neuroscience of Psychotherapy: Building and Rebuilding the Human Brain, New York: W. W. Norton, 2002.

Creswell, J. D.; Irwin, M.; et al: Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction Training Reduces Loneliness and Pro-Inflammatory Gene Expression in Older Adults: A Small Randomized Controlled Trial, in Brain, Behavior and Immunity, DOI: 10.1016/j.bbi.2012.07.006, July 2012.

Damasio, A.: Self Comes to Mind: Constructing the Conscious Brain, New York: Pantheon, 2010.

Dana, D.: The Polyvagal Theory in Therapy, Engaging the Rhythm of Regulation, New York: W. W. Norton, 2018.

David, A.: Basic Concepts in Neuropsychiatry, in Lishman’s Organic Psychiatry: A Textbook of Neuropsychiatry, 5th Ed., London: Blackwell, 2009.

Davidson, R.; Lutz, A.: Buddha’s Brain: Neuroplasticity and Meditation, in IEEE Signal Processing Magazine, Vol. 25, No. 1, Jan 2008.

Dimeff, L.; Koerner, K.: Dialectal Behavior Therapy in Clinical Practice: Applications Across Disorders and Settings, New York: The Guilford Press, 2007.

Dolcos, F.; Morey, R.: Cognitive PTSD Changes Are Evident on fMRI: Study of American soldiers provides early evidence of disorder's specific neuroanatomy biomarkers, in Clinical Psychiatry News, Vol. 37, No. 5, May 2009.ch

Which is only the first four letters of the alphabet.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Oct 09 '21

Choiceless Awareness for Emotion Processing in Polyvagal Resilience Therapy

7 Upvotes

Reading Dr. Deb Dana's 2018 book, The Polyvagal Theory in Therapy: Engaging the Rhythm of Regulation -- and encountering the following on page 42 after more than a decade studying the "dieseling" dysfunction of the General Adaptation Syndrome in the autonomic nervous system -- I was suddenly aware of why it is that the 10 StEPs component of Choiceless Awareness for Emotion Processing and other schemes in the general rubric of "mindfulness" are so effective in "heading that dieseling off before it gets to the pass," as well as making it possible to return to a state of comfort even if one slipped back into the muckmire for a while.

We'll get to that in a moment. First, however, Dr. Dana:

"Autonomic response is always happening. Our autonomic nervous system listens in a continual evaluation of risk and responds in service of our survival. Beneath awareness, we are swept along in the flow of [subconscious] neuroception.

"Bringing [conscious] awareness to autonomic response adds the influence of perception. With the addition of awareness, we move from a state of "being in" to "being with" and bring observer energy to interrupt ingrained response pathways. Without this interruption, the pull of old patterns keeps us moving down the autonomic hierarchy [into phylogenetically more primitive, "lizard brain" responses] and away from the neuroception of safety. As we experience the influence of awareness, we can make an intentional turn toward [self-acceptance, non-condemnation, appreciation, empathy and] self-compassion."

The afore-mentioned 10 StEPs of Emotion Processing is a mechanism for getting out of the state of "being in" and into the state of "being with" the autonomic response via Interoception rather than Introspection (see Craig) in the terminology of such modern-day, non-church, no-woo, pragmatic Buddhists as Batchelor, Epstein, Fronsdal, Kramer, Krishnamurti and Mishra. Where "neuroception" is subconscious, interoception is metaconscious or aware of awareness and whatever awareness is aware of... in the body. Including the...

a) dorsal vagal immobilized / collapsed / depressed / helpless / interpersonally disconnected, 

b) sympathetic autonomic mobilized / fight or flight or freeze / dis- or inappropriately connected, and 

c) ventral vagal safe / secure / comfortably interpersonally connected  

...states, all of which have easily identifiable sensations.  

Which is a 2,500-hundred-year-old Yogic Hindu and Buddhist skill that was evidently rediscovered by neuroscientists, psychiatrists and psychotherapists in about the late 1970s. (See Deikman, Kabat-Zinn, and Tart in the References below.) But those who stumbled upon the use of interoception to cure psychiatric ills were far from fully aware of the work of such as Selye, Benson and Wolpe back then. And people like Dana, Levine, Lupien, McEwen, Ogden, Porges, Sapolsky, Schore and Siegel had not yet emerged.

My only attempt at further contribution here is to connect the dots from Dana & Porges back through all the aforementioned to such as Batchelor, Block & Block, Deikman, Epstein, Kelly, Mishra and other modern interpreters of Asian healing practices... and to offer Choiceless Awareness for Emotion (or "affect") Processing as one of several means of getting those dots to connect so that one who is temporarily stuck in the dorsal vagal or sympathetic autonomic states can -- simply by using those 10 StEPs and feeling what is there to be felt -- release the energy therein and move effortlessly back to the ventral vagal state. 

The complete list of References & Resources for this can be seen at the end of the article at this location.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Feb 22 '22

*The True Believer* can be counted upon to endorse "Magical Thinking." Because his or her mind either remains stuck in or has regressed to childlike "Fantasy Operational Processing." But don't bother trying to explain that to the Developmentally Stunted.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Oct 22 '21

Is Codependency a more "Subtle & Socially Acceptable" form of Reciprocal Reactivity? And, I guess, is Reciprocal Reactivity a more "Overt & Hostile" form of Codependency?

5 Upvotes

I guess one would have to see Reciprocal Reactivity, Ego Protection & the Cycle of Addiction: The Interpersonal Pandemic of the New Century? first just to understand what RR is. So, if interested, do that now.

I ask the title question because both are clear behavioral evidence of the Karpman Drama Triangle scheme that I have always (not sometimes, not often, not mostly, always) observed in the relationships of people in treatment who have long histories of codependent and/or reciprocally re-act-ive behavior.

Behavior driven by unobserved, unnoticed, unrecognized, unacknowledged, unaccepted, unowned and unappreciated conditioning, in-doctrine-ation, instruction, imprinting, socialization, habituation and normalization of the beliefs and emotions stored in neural networks of cognition in the human brain on a spectrum that runs from...

abject, "kick-me-sign," "I'll-put-up-with-anything-you-want," "PLEASE-don't-leave-me," masochistic, "classic" codependency to...

the sort of abuse-expecting, hair-trigger, "what-did-you-mean-by-that?" RR one sees regularly in the petulant and/or impulsive borderline-styles.

(Borderline PD now being widely understood to be something like "codependency in steroids" by many mental health professionals. See "Can't live with 'em; Can't live without 'em" – Codependency, the Drama Triangle, and the "Dark Diagnosis".)

In whatever event, they're both pretty obviously upshots of long-term conditioning in frameworks of insecure, anxious, ambivalent and/or disorganized attachment schemes people who exhibit them both seem "locked into" with one person after another in the social universes, face-to-face and online.

Enlightening and appropriate commentary is hereby solicited.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Aug 23 '21

Codependency & Contagious Cohabitative Illness (like COVID, the flu, and the common cold). Ignore at your own Risk? (Shrug.)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Oct 09 '21

Understanding Codependence as "Soft-Core" Cult Dynamics... ...and Cult Dynamics as "Hard-Core" Codependence

17 Upvotes

My two theses here are that 1) cults of personality are little other than large networks of what can range up to an extreme form of codependency, and 2) that understanding the operational dynamics of cults can be highly useful to sponsors and sponsees in Co-Dependents Anonymous, as well as to treatment professionals. One paradigm informs the other in both cases. 

(For those unfamiliar with the concept, patterns and characteristics of co-dependence, one can click on the preceding links to come up to speed very quickly. For material on co-dependence in depth, please see Anonymous, Beattie, Cermak, Evans, Mellody, Rapson & English, Schaef, Weinhold & Weinhold, and Whitfield in the Resources & References at the end of this paper. For a quick primer on the characteristics of cults, give Dan Goleman's list a look.)

For any students of sociology who stumble upon this, suffice it to say that the organizational platform here is built on Spencer's, Durkheim's and Parson's "structural functionalism," and that those who grasp that concept in depth are very easily able to see the operational similarities between codependence and cult dynamics.)

I grew up in Hollywood. It's no surprise to me that several large cults of human potential have flourished in soil pre-treated to ardent belief in (excessive) self esteem, black and white / all-or-nothing thinking, obsession with achievement and fame, and submission to dominating authority. Observed through the lens of those four concepts (aka: perfectionism, either/or dichotomism, narcissism and authoritarianism), the attachment and devotion to what some might call a self-destructive degree of co-dependence near the Soboba Indian Reservation close to San Jacinto, California (described in recent articles in the Los Angeles Times and The New Yorker magazine) may make a lot more sense.

We may never really know what all it was that the founder of Hollywood's largest cult had been exposed to that empowered his seemingly messianic (and megalomanic?) quest. Read those who deconstructed the individual, family-of-origin and group dynamics of the National Socialist, Red Chinese and North Korean "thought reform" techniques that made Hitler's, Mao's and Kim's (as well as Sun Myung Moon's) cults of personality possible. (Erich Fromm, Eric Hoffer, Robert J. Lifton, Edgar Schein, Margaret Thaler, Michael Langone, et al, are listed below). 

In so doing, it may be evident that the founder of Hollywood's Cult numero uno (who finally expired in a trailer in a tiny village in north San Luis Obispo County) had access to -- as well as a considerable grasp of -- them. And that, at least in the last half century, he was only one of several who may have gotten his or her guru chops from the folks who produced the grisly spectacles of 1933 to 1953. 

"Over time, I learned that I could escape the awful feelings of being an incompetent, shameful, guilty, submissive little fool by finding someone else in the cult to dominate, embarrass, belittle, humiliate and demoralize so that I could feel competent, capable and prideful. I learned to do whatever it took to please my dominators, including channeling their domination of me onto other little fools."

For me, anyway, the major shortcoming of many of the fine books out there on cults is that they often pay attention to all the drama but fail to connect all the dots. Nor did they look into whether the top dogs of the era following the founders' deaths are less, equally or even more schooled in the methods of mind control described by those listed above nearly as deeply as Joel Kramer, Diana Alstad, Flo Conway, Jim Siegelman, Steven Hassan, Kathleen Taylor, Mark Galanter, Arthur Deikman and the redoubtable Charles Tart (on his concept of the "consensus trance").

BUT... I'll take a shot at some dot-connecting here. Because over the more than four decades since I first either fell down the well or at least drank some of the Cool Aid in several of these organizations, I was able to see from outside the paradigm, "box," "cage," "cave," "frame," "trap" or consensus trance what was going on inside with ever greater clarity. (In fact, it was a renown psychologist in Beverly Hills for whom I worked in the late 1970s -- who himself had a relatively benign, and far less dangerous, human potential cult going there -- who kicked me in the shins just hard enough to start my own, real growth process.) (But giving credit where it's really due, it was Jiddu Krishnamurti who first put the dots close enough together for me to get some real traction with them.)

Let's look at the four characteristics I have seen again and again among cult members, leaders and escapees, as well as ardent codependents:

  1. Excessive "perfectionism" usually acquired earlier in life.

  2. Black and white / all-or-nothing thinking; aka "dichotomism."

  3. Blindly ambitious obsession with either achievement and fame or to compensate for earlier invalidation, devaluation, being ignored and/or functionally abandoned; aka "compensatory narcissism."

  4. An unusual willingness submit to dominant authority to get the rewards of attention, validation and esteem from others; aka "authoritarianism."

I could have listed credulity, but elected not to do so because it is evident that while many co-dependents and cult members are highly credulous, many others are startlingly given to ardent skepticism; an almost knee-jerk questioning of and/or argument with those who promote propositions that they find dubious. Nevertheless, credulity and skepticism are worth understanding for those who want to comprehend the mentality of many co-dependents and cult members because it points to a particular form of dichotomism.

Neither do I see psychologic paranoia in the behaviors of all co-dependents or cult members. But I have observed it often enough to consider it a high-order correlate. Nor do I see Seligman's "learned helplessness" or Tangney & Dearing's (and Forward's) "toxic shame" in all co-dependents or cult members... but I do see them a lot.

I also see a lot of excessive internalizing (or taking too much responsibility) in both groups, but find some codependents and many cult members to be either externalizing (e.g.: blaming others) or alternatively (and excessively) internalizing and externalizing in a sort of flip-flop / ping-pong fashion. And I see a lot of Van der Kolk's "compulsion to repeat the trauma," but do not (or cannot) see it in enough people of either category to assert that it is universal in either co-dependents or cult members.

Taking those four one at a time in the frame of their relevance to both cult membership and co-dependence:

Excessive Perfectionism

Too much of a good thing may not be.

Many (most?) of the co-dependents and virtually all of the cult members or former members I have known are (often covertly and/or unconsciously) perfectionistic to the point of at least occasional (if not chronic) obsession with saying and doing what they believe to be "correct," "right," "functional" and/or "appropriate." Some came from backgrounds that predisposed them to achievement to meet parental expectations; perhaps because their parents were either high -- and proud -- (or low and shame-infected) achievers themselves. Others seem to have dots connecting their current perfectionism with early life experiences with parents who set them up to "try harder" by ignoring, invalidating, abandoning or otherwise devaluing them.

The worst cases, however, tended to have backgrounds with parents who gave paradoxical injunctions; parents who (overtly) said one thing and then (usually covertly) said or did the opposite so that the child was damned if he did and damned if didn't follow the conflicting -- often overt here and covert there -- instructions. The typical combination of paradoxical injunctions was something like, "Do your best to get rewards from us," and "Do you really expect us to pay any attention?" The child of such parents is often set up (in the fashion of the classic "double-bind") to strive for enough achievement to finally get the attention and approval that still remains out of reach. And the adult child of such parents will often work him- or herself half to death to meet the expectations and requirements of the parental dynamics that remain normalized in the so-called "superego" between his or her ears. (Wickliff's excellent rundown of family dysfunction as a precursor to cult affiliation is more than germane here.)
The manipulation of one's own, perfectionistic moral principles very easily induces (emotional) shame, guilt, remorse, regret and (cognitive) worry and morbid reflection in the minds of those already conditioned, socialized, habituated, accustomed, normalized and institutionalized to these affective and cognitive states.

Conditioned, socialized, habituated and normalized by their early life experiences to seek approval by being "perfect," such people make terrific (and "highly co-dependent") employees for bosses and employers who care little or nothing about those who backs they climb over to make their own way to the top, regardless of what they say or the minimal (and occasional) rewards they provide to those in the state of anxious attachment. In moderate burnout (before they collapse from stress), they also make fine and dandy salesmen, supporters and slaves for covertly ruthless gurus. 

Dichotomism

If there is any one technique of manipulation that stands out for its ubiquity among those who succeed at politics via the building of massive cults of personality, it is all-or-nothing, this-way-or-that, all-good-or-all-bad, black and white thinking. Our culture conditions, socializes, habituates, normalizes and even institutionalizes polarized perception to such an extent throughout childhood that most of us cannot see that we think in terms of "either / or." Researchers estimate that only about five percent of us can be counted upon to regularly see outside the box, frame or paradigm of this possibility or that. Which makes it very easy for politicians, manipulative bosses and gurus to stipulate a choice between two ("obviously") "good" or "bad" opposites. Such stipulation forces the unconscious employee, party or cult member to limit his or her choice to those offered without noticing any others. 

Most children are taught by virtually every authority they encounter to "follow the rules" and not to question those rules. The child's natural capacity to simply use his eyes, ears and other senses to tell what is from what is not with respect to anything fairly complex is dulled nearly to the point of extinction by the time he or she is six years old (see Cvencek, Greenwald & Meltzoff, and who knows how many others). From the point of view of the guru, this couldn't be any better. Because -- like any effective politician -- he will present his own explanations of and solutions for life's challenges in either / or terms that exclude all other possibilities.

Compensatory Narcissism

The very word "narcissism" has -- as the result of vernacular usage -- come to mean "too narcissistic for one's own good." The fact that a limited degree of narcissism is actually useful is obvious to those who watch infants set up a fuss to get picked up, fed and otherwise attended to when they are uncomfortable. And those frustrated, learned helpless children who were too often ignored or dismissed when they needed attention usually grow up to be fine candidates for those who understand how easily they can be manipulated by appealing to their healthy, but unmet, narcissistic needs.

I am not speaking of the "classic," entitled narcissist who was "spoiled" by overly indulgent parents (though such people do make good cult fodder, as well). I am talking about the adult child of self-absorbed parents who did not get enough attention, and who grows up having collected all manner of ways to compensate for believing him- or herself to be "unwanted," "unnecessary" and "unimportant." Listen to any card-carrying co-dependent for ten minutes, and then tell me that those three words do not describe their unconscious self-concepts. One need only listen to a cult member for a fraction of that time to grasp how obsessed they are with being wanted, necessary, important and significant.  

Authoritarianism

Raised as "victims" on Stephen Karpman's Drama Triangle (by alternate "rescuers" and "punishers"), the typical co-dependent -- and cult member -- has formed an unconsciously foreclosed identity as a victim. And he or she will spend the rest of his or her life trying to get out of the victim corner by rescuing... and if rescuing fails, by persecuting and punishing. This (non-sexual) dominance and submission schematic is glaringly obvious in the world of the cult, regardless of whether it is "religious" or not. 
(Virtually all cults -- whether they are "religious," psuedo-spiritual or "human potential" -- are set up in a tiered, top-to-bottom hierarchy of relatively more powerful dominators and less powerful submittors; each dominator being submissive to the dominators on the level above. The guru stands at the top of a functional pyramid of increasing dominance from bottom to top and increasing submission from top to bottom.) 

Because it seems germane at this point, let's take a quick left turn into Trinkner, et al's, work on Baumrind's parenting styles:

"Authoritative parents are both demanding and controlling, but they are also warm and receptive to their children's needs. They are receptive to bi-directional communication in that they explain to their children why they have established rules and also listen to their children's opinions about those rules. Children of authoritative parents tend to be self-reliant, self-controlled, and content.

"On the other hand, authoritarian parents are demanding and highly controlling, but detached and unreceptive to their children's needs. These parents support unilateral communication where they establish rules without explanation and expect them to be obeyed without complaint or question. Authoritarian parenting produces children who are discontent, withdrawn, and distrustful. 

"Finally, in contrast to authoritarian parenting, permissive parents are non-demanding and non-controlling. They tend to be warm and receptive to their children's needs, but place few boundaries on their children. If they do establish rules, they rarely enforce them to any great extent. These parents tend to produce children who are the least self-reliant, explorative and self-controlled out of all the parenting styles."

Morality is as waaaaay twisted in the frame-work, paradigm, cave, cage, box or consensus trance of the cult as it was for most co-dependents and cult members in the interpersonal family system of the family in which they grew up. Twisted morality was so effectively -- and covertly -- socialized, habituated and institutionalized in such families of origin that it seems perfectly normal in the cult or severely co-dependent marriage or workplace.

The recovering co-dependent is at somewhat of an advantage here. He or she hears that long grind of "patterns and characteristics of codependence" at every CoDA meeting they attend. (For them, it's a way of working Steps Six and Seven again and again.) Those who arrived at this weblog from at least somewhat informed perspectives on cult dynamics, however, may find themselves more than a little surprised. 

"I judge what I think, say, or do harshly, as never good enough."
"I value others’ approval of my thinking, feelings, and behavior over my own."
"I constantly seek recognition that I think I deserve."
"I have difficulty admitting that I made a mistake."
"I need to appear to be right in the eyes of others and will even lie to look good."
"I look to others to provide my sense of safety."
"I am extremely loyal, remaining in harmful situations too long."
"I compromise my own values and integrity to avoid rejection or anger."
"I put aside my own interests in order to do what others want."
"I am afraid to express my beliefs, opinions, and feelings when they differ from those of others."
"I give up my truth to gain the approval of others or to avoid change."
"I believe most people are incapable of taking care of themselves."
"I attempt to convince others what to think, do, or feel."
"I freely offer advice and direction to others without being asked."
"I become resentful when others decline my help or reject my advice."
"I have to be needed in order to have a relationship with others."
"I use charm and charisma to convince others of my capacity to be caring and compassionate."
"I use blame and shame to emotionally exploit others."
"I adopt an attitude of indifference, helplessness, authority, or rage to manipulate outcomes."
"I use terms of recovery in an attempt to control the behavior of others."
"I pretend to agree with others to get what I want."

Tell me you've never seen any of this in a cult.

Codependence, Cult Participation & Complex PTSD

Like co-dependents (only generally even moreso), the devoted cult member displays high allostatic loading (especially see Bruce McEwen's, Sonya Lupien's and Robert Sapolsky's work on this very hot topic in abnormal psychology) and other behavioral presentations of complex post-traumatic stress disorder that usually began in childhood. Generally speaking, this allostatic loading was greatly densified in co-dependent, romantic and workplace relationships, as well as religious and other large group activities that were interpersonally stress-inducing, even if they seemed "normal" to the participant.
My observation is that this allostatic loading is the direct result of what Susan Forward called "emotional blackmail" (in a truly fine book of the same title) by means of the "F.O.G." manipulations of fear, obligation and guilt. 

I have observed repeatedly -- via scans of the brain with magnetic resonance imaging and three-dimensional computer-aided tomography -- that those who have been tortured psychologically have brains that function very similarly to those who have been tortured physically, as well as those exposed to violent, military combat. I have seen scans of the brains of those who have been exposed to chronic -- as well as severe acute -- stress and abuse. The histories may be as different as one can imagine... but the limbic systems look pretty much the same: amygdalae and hippocampi that are either grossly over- or under-size owing to over-growth to deal with relentless threat, or excitotoxicity from being on the receiving end. 

Over time, the severely co-dependent or cult member may find he or she needs to drink or drug, gamble, exercise, work, volunteer or otherwise distract him- or herself to excess to try to displace the conflict, anxiety, mania and/or depression typical in the traumatic stress that both causes and results from continued, chronic allostatic loading.

Are cult membership or codependence potentially "deadly?" I wish you could see those scans. As well as the statistics on both fast and slow suicide among people with anxiety-, depression- and mania-soaked, complex PTSD induced by having become "learned helpless" victims at the bottom of Karpman's Drama Triangle. 

Treatment

Once programmed and caught in the vicious cycle of trying to escape from what is causing the problem by indulging in yet more of it, is there a way out? I think so, but only for those (more or less as for anyone who has been obsessed or addicted to a substance or behavior like gambling, workaholism, excessive exercise or sex, or severely codependent relationships) who have moved through denial / pre-contemplation and contemplation / consideration into self-identification / acceptance so that they can move on to commitment / action and maintenance / relapse prevention (see Prochaska & DiClemente on the five stages of addiction recovery).

In combination with understanding the fear, obligation & guilt ("FOG") dynamics of cult mind control (e.g.: see above, see Goleman's list of cult danger signs, see Zimbardo's ten lessons from the Milgram studies)  have seen the following work for both codependents and cult exiters: Pia Mellody's approach to the 12 Steps of Co-Dependents Anonymous, Albert Ellis's Rational-Emotive Behavioral Therapy, Aaron Beck's Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Marsha Linehan's Dialectical Behavior Therapy, Stephen Hayes's Acceptance & Commitment Therapy, Stanley Block's Mind-Body Bridging Therapy, and Patricia Ogden's Sensorimotor Psychotherapy for Trauma. 
Or one can take a look at the 10 StEPs of Emotion Processing, yet another of the new wave of reality therapies that re-ground the mind in observing what is, as opposed to what the mind has been trained to believe. See also The 10 StEPs for Recovery from the Consensus Trance and The 10 StEPs to Freedom from Emotional Blackmail.) 

But one may have to employ the consciousness-raising, "howzitoworkingforyou?" techniques of motivational enhancement much as they are used in the treatments of substance abuse and behavioral addictions (including severe, unconscious, ardently denied or unseen co-dependence) to break through the first stage of denial / pre-contemplation to get the co-dependent or cult member on the road through contemplation / consideration to self-identification / acceptance of his or her causes and conditions.
Finally, those who may be looking for edification on the causes, conditions, treatment of, and recovery from both co-dependence and cultic thought reform will find an exhaustive list of published resources below. Also see the outline on CARM's website.

Links to Articles on Cult Dynamics

A FREE online Book on How Cults Work

The complete list of Resources & References for the above can be seen at the bottom of the same article at this location.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Apr 27 '21

Why can't I Decide what to Answer on those "Yes or No" / "This or That" Personality Tests?

12 Upvotes

Same thing used to happen to me when I took psychometric tests or plowed through recovery workbooks (I've done two dozen). I still have a "big yellow mental school bus" full of brats in a food fight, but ACT, DBT, MBBT and other therapies built a "driver" who can pull over and intervene.

Early life trauma may induce Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and splitting (in my reply to the OP on that Reddit thread) to try to deal with the CPTSD by protecting the abused and/or neglected / abandoned child from the overwhelming terror of realizing what the hell is going on in a world where he or she is fully dependent upon others for his or her very survival. Which may ultimately lead to a collection of Personality Disorder traits called Borderline (or Dissociative Identity) PD to "structuralize" that splitting. And those trait systems get "stored" in various default mode networks that make up an Internal Family System in the brain.

See The Abused Child's Awful Dilemma and Dissociation in Depth.

BUT, there is a way OUT. See...

The Internal Family Systems Model: The Freeway Onramp Out of CPTSD > BPD Hell?,

The 10 StEPs component of Choiceless Awareness for Emotion Processing, and the rest of...

A 21st Century Recovery Program for Someone with Untreated Childhood Trauma... because IME there's a LOT one can do without spending a fortune on psychotherapy, as well as to speed up the process if one is in therapy or at least at the fourth of the five stages of therapeutic recovery.

References & Resources:

A CPTSD Library

Section one: Basic explanations & recovery activities

Section two: More advanced

Section three: Neurobiology

Section four: BPD as an Upshot of CPTSD

Section Five: Critical Thinking

Section Six: Workbooks

Section Seven: Workbooks Specifically on Anger Processing


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Aug 25 '20

A Free online BOOK on How Cults Work

Thumbnail pairadocks.blogspot.com
6 Upvotes

r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Jul 18 '21

[Good sub] My suggestion for my fellow apostates/heretics: METTA BHAVANA / Loving Kindness Meditation

6 Upvotes

Link for Audio Book

Hello everybody. I too struggle with the hang-ups of longstanding PTSD and all the crap that being perennially pestered by a former cult entails. While I've done all kinds of things with different results I won't dare to suggest a definite fix for the issue at hand. Takes time, effort, maybe even guidance. Most here are not in a place where something of the sort can be even evaluated.

What I'll do is suggest a powerful tool to deal with with the crap in you in a soft-but-powerful way. There are many formulas for this but I've found that the most effective is as follows:

For yourself:

May I be free from hostility,

May I be free from affliction,

May I be free from anguish,

May I be happy.

For others:

May all be free from hostility,

May all be free from affliction,

May all be free from anguish,

May all be happy.

The hostility part is important, because goes a little further than just wishing well others but you aim to harmonize your relation with them.

These formulas can be repeated in a mantra-like fashion but the original idea is to make this statements and focus on the energy they create, expanding it in the process. I suggest further reading and research on the topic.

One last thing: bad religious leaders abound, they are veritable pieces of shit and so on, but for your sake don't toss the baby with the bath water. Next time just pick a good one. They are out there if you can find them.

Don't let those sons of bitches ruin you spiritually and keep you from all the good things that spiritual life entails just because you happened to cross paths with them. FUCK'M... move on.

Regards.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Apr 12 '20

Do the Boomers deserve the Blame? Or do the Elites?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ResponsibleRecovery • • May 16 '26

How do you establish healthy personal boundaries with toxic family members?

1 Upvotes

One of the hardest parts of committing to a responsible recovery process has been managing relationships with family members who do not respect my personal space or growth. I am struggling to communicate my needs clearly without causing massive arguments or feeling an overwhelming sense of guilt afterwards. If anyone has successfully set firm boundaries with difficult people while maintaining their own peace of mind please share your advice on how to handle these conversations professionally.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Jul 09 '21

Western vs. Eastern “Spirituality”

7 Upvotes

A Redditor on r/ExChristian wrote, "I'm curious how those of you who have left the faith still frame and see 'spiritual' experiences in your life. I've been experiencing many feelings that remind me of previous experiences praying or 'communing' with god. I've struggled to frame these feelings."

I answered...

One needs to know what anyone else means by "spiritual" before responding. IMOC, "spiritual" has NOTHING whatsoever to do with belief of any kind, and relates to direct comprehension of what IS vs. what is NOT. For me, all "framing" is a mental activity in accordance with previous conditioning, in-doctrine-ation, instruction, imprinting, socialization, habituation and normalization into a default mode network in the human brain.

But if spirituality is "direct comprehension of what IS vs. what is NOT" -- however brief that comprehension may be -- then there is no framing via verbalized concepts or images in memory or past experience. Comprehension is the result of looking to see, listening to hear, and feeling to sense... without resort to verbalized appraisal, analysis, evaluation, assessment, interpretation of attribution of meaning.

The real (non-church, anti-authoritarian, anti-cultic, practicing) Buddhist grasps that instantly. But the mental product of pharaonic > Osirian > Abrahamic > Mosaic > Davidic > Josiahic > Jeramiahic > Isaiahic > Paulist > Ephesian > Augustinian > Thomist > Calvinist > Wesleyan conditioning simply cannot wrap his or her head around that.

If sufficiently intrigued to want to investigate further, see Masters of Meditation.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Mar 20 '22

I tried Faith in one thing and another for a half century until I could no longer go fast enough to outrun Reality...

8 Upvotes

...even though I had given up "the high life" almost 20 years earlier. And ran head first into the wall of Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder I had tried my best to steer over, under and around to the exclusion of Just Going Through.

I've experienced vastly more meaning, comfort and competence -- and less anxiety, depression and helplessness -- since I gave up belief in what I was told in several Great Echo Chambers of Groupthink, Social Proof, Implicit Social Contract, Confirmation Bias & Unquestioning Acceptance of Authority ranging from childhood Pentecostalism and several passes through The Human Potential Movement Gone Awry in favor of looking to see, listening to hear and feeling to sense what IS vs. what is NOT.

After working through much of A 21st Century Recovery Program for Someone with Untreated Childhood Trauma, I finally stumbled into the solitary practice of Choiceless Awareness for Emotion Processing nine years ago... and have NOT looked back. BUT... I do not suggest that anyone try to follow me or anyone else who has gone that (or any similar) route unless or until one is sufficiently fed up with life on one's own terms to try on life on life's terms.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Apr 01 '22

Observing, recognizing, accepting & appreciating the role of "Participative Objective" in Withdrawal from active Cultic Affiliation.

8 Upvotes

I first ran into a concept called "participative objective" in the study of corporate employee motivation decades ago. It was evidently a "flash in the pan" that has become lost to antiquity, perhaps because it's not a part of the MBA school lexicon anymore (possibly by intention? who knows?).

This "missing the comradery & community" aspect of withdrawal has the potential to occur in all types of post-cultic situations, but I will say that I see it far and away most often in post-evangelical religious withdrawal, probably IMO because the attachments formed in that world typically began to be formed in very early life. (Though Jenna Miscavige's and Leah Remeni's books on their years in the "Church" of Scientology sound pretty similar.)

In whatever event, the concept stands up for me as something worth keeping in mind for those who leave their cults for Damned Good Reasons but say -- as so many do -- they miss the "connection with others" long afterwards.

Because, they haven't found any new participative objective elsewhere to replace the UNconscious group dynamic of feeling seen, heard, felt and sensed by peers through multiple developmental stages to which they had been conditioned, in-doctrine-ated, instructed, groomed, imprinted, socialized, habituated, programmed, normalized and accustomed? And, moreover, because so many who were raised in cults did NOT feel seen, heard, felt or sensed by our hard-headed, ultra-doctrinaire parents?

IMOC, I have been able to apply the the totally portable and instantaneously available 10 StEPs component of Choiceless Awareness for Emotion Processing to process (and re-process) a lot of the lingering affects of my own withdrawal by keeping "PO" in mind and using it to guide me to repeated moments of functional and effective exposure therapy.

Over time, the mere recognition, acceptance, ownership and appreciation of the participative objective appears to have dealt with the dysphoria. But had I been able connect the PO dots from my Pentecostal youth to my human potential cult early adulthood in early adulthood, I might have dodged several unnecessary and costly examples of "repeating the same mistake expecting different results."


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Mar 06 '22

Brain Volumes Shrink With One Daily Drink — Even light to moderate alcohol intake shows effects

17 Upvotes

THE GOOD NEWS, based on 34 years' experience in the trenches of treatment (from CADC to Psy.D.), is that up to a point, recovery (or actually replacement) of lost neural tissue is possible and even likely if one remains abstinent for the rest of their life. (Neuroplasticity is a thing. I have seen waaaaaay too many "before & after" MRI scans to think otherwise.) But those who "pickled" parts of their brains from chronic, high-volume, "hard drinking" may never return to genetic, "factory spec" levels of function.

See the story on MedPage Today at this link if you prefer, or... read the following:

Light to moderate alcohol consumption -- as few as one or two drinks a day -- was linked with reductions in overall brain volume, a cross-sectional study showed.

Among nearly 37,000 healthy adults in the U.K. Biobank, alcohol intake was negatively associated with global brain volume measures, regional gray matter volumes, and white matter microstructure, reported Reagan Wetherill, PhD, of the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine in Philadelphia, and co-authors, in Nature Communications.

The link was stronger with greater alcohol consumption. As drinking increased from one alcohol unit (about half a beer) a day to two units (a pint of beer or a glass of wine) in 50-year-olds, for example, brain changes were equivalent to the effect of aging 2 years. An increase from two alcohol units to three showed changes equivalent to aging 3.5 years. Associations remained even when heavy drinkers were removed from the analysis.

"These findings contrast with scientific and governmental guidelines on safe drinking limits," co-author Henry Kranzler, MD, of the Penn Center for Studies of Addiction, said in a statement.

"For example, although the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism recommends that women consume an average of no more than one drink per day, recommended limits for men are twice that, an amount that exceeds the consumption level associated in the study with decreased brain volume," Kranzler observed.

The study looked at alcohol intake and brain structure of 36,678 generally healthy adults ages 40 to 69 years in the U.K. Biobank who had data available as of September 2020. Participants completed questionnaires about demographic and health information, and a nurse conducted medical history interviews.

Participants self-reported the number of weekly or monthly alcohol units consumed in the past year, including wine, champagne, beer, cider, spirits, fortified wine, and other beverages. A pint or can of beer, lager, or cider was considered two alcohol units, a 25 mL single shot of spirits was one unit, and a standard 175 mL glass of wine was two units.

The analysis controlled for age, height, handedness, sex, smoking status, socioeconomic status, genetic ancestry, and county of residence. Brain imaging data included three structural assessments, resting and task-based fMRI, and diffusion imaging. Brain volumes were normalized for head size.

Nearly 90% of all regional gray matter volumes showed significant negative correlations with alcohol intake, and lower volume was not localized to any one brain region. The most extensively affected regions included the frontal, parietal, and insular cortices, with changes also in temporal and cingulate regions. In addition, associations were noted in the brain stem, putamen, and amygdala.

Drinking also was tied to lower coherence of water diffusion, lower neurite density, and higher magnitude of water diffusion, indicating less healthy white matter microstructure with increasing alcohol intake.

"Like individuals with alcohol use disorder, alcohol intake in this healthy population sample is associated with microstructural differences in superficial white matter systems functionally related to gray matter networks, including the frontoparietal control and attention networks, and the default mode, sensorimotor, and cerebellar networks," Wetherill and co-authors noted.

Deeper white matter systems thought to be involved in cognitive functioning also were linked with alcohol intake, they added.

The research had several limitations: it was cross-sectional and based solely on middle-aged people of European ancestry. Reports of alcohol consumption were subject to reporting and recall bias, and the study did not account for people who may have had alcohol use disorder in the past. Reverse causality or potential confounding may have influenced results.

The researchers plan to use the U.K. Biobank and other large cohorts to help answer more questions about alcohol use.

"This study looked at average consumption, but we're curious whether drinking one beer a day is better than drinking none during the week and then seven on the weekend," said co-author Gideon Nave, PhD, of the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School. "There's some evidence that binge drinking is worse for the brain, but we haven't looked closely at that yet."

New longitudinal datasets that follow young people as they age may shed more light in the future, Nave added: "We may be able to look at these effects over time and, along with genetics, tease apart causal relationships."


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Aug 22 '20

Shame blog

Thumbnail self.mentalhealthsupport
2 Upvotes

r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Feb 23 '22

Putting binary black & white on The Shelf in favor of life in Living Colors

2 Upvotes

The Church conditioned, in-doctrine-ated, instructed, groomed, imprinted, socialized, habituated, programmed and normalized my mind to believe in stipulation of polarized opposites to the exclusion of seeing, hearing, feeling or sensing what just IS right now.

Once I got into Recovery from Religious Trauma Syndrome and the totally portable and instantaneously available 10 StEPs component of Choiceless Awareness for Emotion Processing what had been black & white (and "binary") began to become shades of gray. And as I continued to practice those StEPs, the shades of gray became a rainbow of colors.

And possibilities I could not see when I was blinded, deafened, dumbed down and senseless.


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • May 08 '19

Dealing with Judgmental, Abusive AUTHORITARIANS

2 Upvotes

Because so many of us grew up around such people...

Learning about the authoritarian type of parenting style was a real eye-opener for a kid who'd been raised by a pair of them. (See also: The Confusing Parent in not-moses's reply to the OP on that thread.)

Often, but not always, displaying righteously narcissistic traits, these people can be accurately expected to deal with others (not just their children) in an at least somewhat dysfunctional manner. Worse, authoritarians are rarely able to listen to anyone they do not see as an "authority" explain that to them.

My suggestion? Just...

  1. accept that his mind was conditioned, instructed, socialized, habituated, and normalizedto viewing the world as it does,

  2. set functional boundaries,

  3. stay OFF their Karpman Drama Triangles and

  4. OUT of any codependency and approval-seeking with them, and

  5. use something like this stuff process out your frustration with people like that.

Because you're going to encounter a lot of these Hurt People... Hurting Other People over the course of a lifetime. (Most of my family members are authoritarians; sigh.)


r/ResponsibleRecovery • • Mar 23 '22

Self-condemnation is usually the biggest factor in "treatment resistance" psychotherapists run into with pts who have any form of Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder including RTS. ... But, IME, no category of pt is as likely to be self-condemning as those with religious trauma...

39 Upvotes

...because RTS pts have been purposely conditioned, in-doctrine-ated, instructed, groomed, imprinted, socialized, habituated, programmed and normalized to do that.

Self-condemnation is usually the biggest factor in "treatment resistance" psychotherapists run into with pts who have any form of Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, including Religious Trauma Syndrome. Even though many of those pts will hotly deny they are the victims of self-condemnation... which is nothing more than repeating the original trauma all by oneself.

Self-condemnation is so strongly correlated to developmental stunting and treatment resistance in fundievangelicals that a therapist would have be as deafened, dumbed down, blinded and senseless as these poor people to fail to get that.

Mental health professionals (like Marlene Winell, Catherine Mann and Bonnie Zeiman) who understand and deal with such pts will tell you that therapeutic measures known to break through "self-protective" denial and uproot self-condemnation may have to be employed for weeks or months before much headway can be made in the fourth of the five stages of psychotherapeutic recovery.

If you are interested in how we accomplish that, ask, and I will summarize that for you on the basis of my own experience.